Skip to main content

Full text of "Vasari on technique; being the introduction to the three arts of design, architecture, sculpture and painting, prefixed to the Lives of the most excellent painters, sculptors and architects"

See other formats


CORNELL 

UNIVERSITY 

LIBRARY 


GIFT  OF 
Mr.  Eugene  Montillon 

FINE  ARTS 


Cornell  University  Library 
N  7420.V44 


Vasari  on  technique;  being  the  Introducti 


3  1924  020  624  742 


The  original  of  this  book  is  in 
the  Cornell  University  Library. 

There  are  no  known  copyright  restrictions  in 
the  United  States  on  the  use  of  the  text. 


http://www.archive.org/details/cu31924020624742 


VASARI   ON   TECHNIQUE 


All  rights  reserved 


< 
CO 

< 
> 

CO 

Q 

w 

o 

H 
Z 
W 


W 

z 
o 

H 

CO 

0- 
O 

C/3 

Q 
5 

M 
< 

U 
I 
H 


^  ^   5  = 


1 

1 

1 

t; 

Tl 

3 

U  ; 

u 

^ 

ri 

i" 

h] 

0 

u 

IL 

H 

•" 

uT 

d 

0 

V 

s 

0 

c 

u 

n! 

1 

a 

1 

.2 
a. 

o 

u 

o 

p- 

3 

iH 

■4-1 

o 

R 

a 

,0 

& 

:_ 

c 

To 

.u 

d 

£i 

'i 

"3 

0 

(u 

a 

fo 

CQ 

CQ 

t: 

Ji 

^' 

(1) 

■2 

i 

s 

0 

S 

j: 

U 

J 

uT 

TS 

■& 

< 

3 

u 

0 

n 

P 

£ 

1, 

TS 

S 

1 

5 

1 

E 

rt 

S 

0 

p 

a 

cd 

J= 

•a 

rt 

N 

c 

0) 

j:: 

O 

p 

1 

> 

CS 

s 

1 

g 

U     (ii     R    « 
Soma) 

M       L,     ■  -      4J 

u  zi  P^  :a 
■5  <*-  I- 1> 


H  ~ 


e'O  s  I 

^  =.  a  -S 

s  S  S  3 

a  s  g  o 

<  :'  o  -- 


VASARI  ON  TECHNIQUE 

BEING  THE  INTRODUCTION  TO  THE  THREE 
ARTS  OF  DESIGN,  ARCHITECTURE,  SCULPTURE 
AND  PAINTING,  PREFIXED  TO  THE  LIVES  OF 
THE  MOST  EXCELLENT  PAINTERS,  SCULPTORS 
AND   ARCHITECTS 


By  GIORGIO  VASARI 

PAINTER    &-    ARCHITECT    OF    AREZZO 


NOW    FOR    THE    FIRST    TIME 
TRANSLATED    INTO    ENGLISH    BY 

LOUISA   S.   MACLEHOSE 


EDITED    WITH    INTRODUCTION    &'    NOTES    BY 

PROFESSOR   G.   BALDWIN   BROWN 


AND    PUBLISHED     BY 

J.    M.    DENT    &   COMPANY 

29   &   30   BEDFORD    STREET,   LONDON 

1907 


a.ii 


Glasgow:  printed  at  the  university  press 
by  robert  maclehose  and  co.  ltd. 


TO  THE  MEMORY  OF 
A   BROTHER   AND   DEAR   FRIEND 

RQBERT    MACLEHOSE,   M.A. 

OBIIT   APRIL    1 8,    1907 


PREFATORY   NOTE 

The  title  page  indicates  the  general  responsibility  for  the 
different  parts  of  the  work  now  offered  to  the  reader.  It 
should  be  said  however  that  the  editor  has  revised  the 
translation  especially  in  those  portions  which  deal  with 
technical  matters,  while  the  translator  has  contributed  to 
the  matter  incorporated  in  the  Notes.  The  translation  was 
in  great  part  written  during  a  sojourn  near  Florence,  and 
opportunity  was  taken  to  elucidate  some  of  the  author's 
expressions  by  conversation  with  Italian  artificers  and 
with  scholars  conversant  with  the  Tuscan  idiom. 

The  text  has  been  translated  without  omissions,  and 
the  rendering  has  been  made  as  literal  as  is  consistent 
with  clearness  and  with  a  reasonable  regard  for  the  English 
tongue.  In  the  two  editions  issued  in  Vasari's  lifetime 
the  chapters  are  numbered  continuously  from  one  to  thirty- 
five  through  the  three  divisions  of  the  work,  but  in  more 
modern  editions  each  division  has  its  chapters  separately 
numbered.  The  latter  arrangement  has  been  followed, 
but  the  continuous  numbers  of  the  chapters  have  been 
added  in  brackets.  With  the  view  of  assisting  the  reader 
the  text  has  also  been  broken  up  into  numbered  sections, 
each  with  its  heading,  though  there  is  no  arrangement  of 
the  kind  in  the  original. 

The  shorter  notes  at  the  foot  of  the  pages  are  intended 
to  explain  the  author's  meaning,  which  is  not  always  very 
clear,  and  to  help  to  identify  and  localize  buildings  and 
objects  mentioned  in  the  text.  A  certain  number  of  the 
notes,  the  longer  of  which  have  been  placed  at  the  ends 


viii  PREFATORY   NOTE 

of  the  three  divisions,  afford  an  opportunity  for  discussing 
more  general  questions  of  historical  or  aesthetic  interest 
raised  by  Vasari. 

A  number  of  plates  and  figures  in  the  text  have  been 
added,  some  of  which  are  illustrative  of  Vasari 's  descrip- 
tions, while  others  give  representations  of  unpublished 
objects,  and  examples  of  the  different  kinds  of  artistic 
work  included  in  the  scope  of  the  treatise.  Our  acknow- 
ledgements for  permission  to  reproduce  are  due  to  the 
authorities  of  the  Print  Room,  British  Museum,  and 
the  National  Art  Library;  to  Signor  Giacomo  Brogi  at 
Florence;  and  to  others  to  whom  we  have  expressed  our 
thanks  in  the  text. 

Vasari's  unit  of  measurement  is  the  'braccio,'  and  this 
term  has  been  retained  in  place  of  the  more  familiar 
English  equivalent  '  cubit.'  Vasari's  braccio  seems  to  be 
equal  to  about  twenty-three  inches  or  fifty-eight  centi- 
metres. This  equation  is  given  by  Aurelio  Gotti,  and 
agrees  with  various  dimensions  Vasari  ascribes  to  monu- 
ments that  can  now  be  measured.  A  smaller  unit  is  the 
'  palmo,'  and  this  is  not,  as  might  be  supposed,  the  breadth 
of  a  hand,  but  what  we  should  rather  call  a  'span,'  that 
is  the  space  that  can  be  covered  by  a  hand  trying  to  stretch 
an  octave,  and  may  be  reckoned  at  about  nine  inches. 

In  the  matter  of  proper  names,  Vasari's  own  forms 
have  in  most  cases  been  followed  in  the  text,  but  not 
necessarily  in  the  commentary. 

There  are  some  passages  in  which  we  suspect  that  the 
printed  text  does  not  exactly  correspond  with  what  Vasari 
originally  wrote  (see  Index  s.v.  '  Text '),  but  no  help  is  to 
be  obtained  here  from  any  known  MS.  sources.  Vasari 
gives  us  to  understand  that  the  original  edition  of  the  Lives 
was  printed,  not  from  his  own  autograph,  but  from  a 
transcript  made  for  him  by  a  monastic  calligraphist,  placed 
at  his  disposal  by  a  friendly  abbot  who  also  corrected  to 
some  extent  the  text.  Neither  this  transcript,  nor  any 
MS.  of  the  additions  made  for  the  second  edition  of  the 
work,  is  known  to  exist,  and  textual  criticism  has  to  be 


PREFATORY   NOTE  ix 

confined  to  a  comparison  of  the  printed  texts  of  the  two 
editions  published  in  Vasari's  own  lifetime. 

The  character  of  the  subject  matter  and  the  multiplicity 
of  the  processes  and  materials  passed  in  review  have 
rendered  it  needful  to  invoke  the  aid  of  many  Italian 
scholars  and  experts  in  historical  and  technical  matters, 
who  have  met  our  applications  with  a  courteous  readiness 
to  help  for  which  we  desire  to  express  our  sincere  grati- 
tude. Our  obligations  to  each  of  these  are  expressed  in 
the  notes,  but  we  cannot  close  this  preface  without  a  special 
word  of  thanks  to  Signor  Agnoletti,  of  the  University 
of  Glasgow,  and  to  the  Rev.  Don  Vittorio  Rossi,  Priore 
of  Settignano.  Our  acknowledgements  are  also  due  to 
Mr  G.  K.  Fortescue,  Keeper  of  Printed  Books  at  the 
British  Museum;  Mr  G.  H.  Palmer,  of  the  National 
Art  Library;  Comm.  Conte  D.  Gnoli,  Biblioteca 
Vittorio  Emanuele,  Rome;  Comm.  Dottore  Guido  Biagi, 
Biblioteca  Medicea  Laurenziana,  Florence;  Dr  Thomas 
Ashby,  Director  of  the  British  School  at  Rome;  and  Mr 
John  Kinross,  R.S.A.  To  many  artists  and  connoisseurs 
in  this  country  whom  we  have  consulted  on  technical 
points  we  are  indebted  for  information  not  easily  to  be 
found  in  books,  and  to  Mr  W.  Brindley  a  special  tribute 
is  due  for  the  kindness  with  which  he  has  opened  to  us 
his  unique  stores  of  practical  knowledge  of  stones  and 
quarries. 


TABLE    OF  CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Prefatory  Note,     -  vii 

Table  of  Contents,        -  xi 

List  of  Illustrations,  -  xxi 

Introductory  Essay,  i 

OF  ARCHITECTURE,  -  23 

Chapter  I. 

Of  the  different  kinds  of  Stone  which  are  used  by  Architects 
for  ornamental  details,  and  in  Sculpture  for  Statues  ;  that  is, 
Of  Porphyry,  Serpentine,  Cipollaccio,  Breccia,  Granites,  Paragon 
or  Test-stone,  Transparent  Marbles,  White  Marbles  and 
Veined  Marbles,  CipoUini,  Saligni,  Campanini,  Travertine,  Slate, 
Peperigno,  Ischia  Stone,  Pietra  Serena  and  Pietra  Forte,  25 

§  I.  The  Author's  object  in  the  Discussion  of  Architecture  (25). 
%2.  Of  the  working  of  hard  stones,  and  first  of  Porphyry  (26). 
%l.  Of  Serpentine  (35).  §  4.  Of  Cipollaccio  (36).  §  5.  Of 
Breccia  {'■  Mischio,'  Conglomerate)  (37).  §6.  Of  Granite  (39). 
§7.  Of  Paragon  [Touchstone)  {i,'2).  §8.  Of  Transparent  Marbles 
for  filling  window  openings  iji^'^.  §9.  Of  Statuary  Marbles  {i^'^. 
§  ID.  OfCipollino  Marble  (49).  §11.  Of  White  Pisan  Marble  (50). 
§  12.  Of  Travertine  (51).  §  13.  Of  Slates  (54).  §  14.  Of 
Peperino  (55).  §  15.  Of  the  Stone  from  Istria  (56).  §  16.  Of 
Pietra  Serena  (57).  %\'].  Of  Pietra  Forte  (60).  §  18.  Con- 
clusion of  Chapter  (61). 

b 


xii  CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Chapter  II. 

The  Description  of  squared  Ashlar-work  (lavoro  di  quadro)  and 

of  carved  Ashlar-work  (lavoro  di  quadro  intagliato),  63 

§  19.  The  work  of  the  Mason  (63). 

Chapter  III. 

Concerning  the  five  Orders  of  Architecture,  Rustic,  Doric, 
Ionic,  Corinthian,  Composite,  and  also  German  Work,  65 

<^  20.  Rusticated  masonry  and  ihe  Tuscan  Order  {6^).  §21.  The 
Doric  Order  (68).  §  22.  A  constructive  device  to  avoid  charging 
architraves  (72).  §  23.  The  proportions  and  parts  of  the  Doric 
Order  (75).  §  34.  The  Ionic  Order  (78).  §  25.  The  Corinthian 
Order  (79).  §  26.  The  Composite  Order  (80).  §  27.  Of  Terminal 
figures  (82).     §  28.  German  Work  {the  Gothic  Style)  (83). 

Chapter  IV. 

On  forming  Vaults  in  Concrete,  to  be  impressed  with  Enrich- 
ment :  when  the  Centerings  are  to  be  removed,  and  how  to  mix 
the  Plaster,  85 

§  29.     The    Construction    of   enriched    Stucco    Vaults    (85). 
§  30.  Stucco  made  with  Marble  Dust  (86). 

Chapter  V. 

How  Rustic  Fountains  are  made  with  Stalactites  and  Incrusta- 
tions from  water,  and  how  Cockle  Shells  and  Conglomerations 
of  vitrified  stone  are  built  into  the  Stucco,  87 

§  31.  Grottoes  and  Fountains  of  ^  Rocaille'  work  (87). 

Chapter  VI. 

On  the  manner  of  making  Pavements  of  Tesselated  Work,  91 

§  32.    Mosaic  pavements  (91).      §  33.   Pictorial  Mosaics  for 
Walls,  etc.  (93). 

Chapter  VII. 

How  one  is  to  recognize  if  a  Building  have  good  Proportions, 

and  of  what  Members  it  should  generally  be  composed,      -  95 

§  34.  The  Principles  of  Planning  and  Design  (95).     §  35.  An 
Ideal  Palace  (96). 


CONTENTS  xiii 


PAGE 


Notes  on  'Introduction'  to  Architecture,  99 

Porphyry  and  Porphyry  Quarries,  -  loi 

The  Sassi,  della  Valle,  and   other   Collections  of 

Antiques  of  the  Early  Part  of  the  Sixteenth  Century,  102 

The   Porphyry   Tazza  of  the  Sala  Rotonda  of  the 

Vatican,                                                                       -  108 

Francesco  Del  Tadda,  and  the  Revival  of  Sculpture 

IN  Porphyry,  no 

The  Cortile  of  the  Belvedere  in  the  Vatican,  in  the 

Sixteenth  Century,  115 

Paragon  (Touchstone)  and  other   Stones  associated 

with  it  by  Vasari,  117 

Tuscan  Marble  Quarries,  119 

The  Round  Temple  on  the  Piazza  S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi, 

AND  'Maestro  Gian,'  128 

Rusticated  Masonry,  132 

Vasari's  Opinion  on  Mediaeval  Architecture,  133 

Egg-shell  Mosaic,  -  136 

Ideal  Architecture  ;  an  Ideal  Palace,  138 


OF  SCULPTURE,  141 

Chapter  I.    (VIII.) 

What  Sculpture  is  ;  how  good  works  of  Sculpture  are  made,  and 
what  qualities  they  must  possess  to  be  esteemed  perfect,  143 

§36.  The  Nature  of  Sculpture  {li^l).  §37.  Qualities  necessary 
for  Work  in  the  Round  (143).  §  38.  Works  of  Sculpture  should 
be  treated  with  a  view  to  their  destined  position  (145).  §  39-  The 
Proportions  of  the  Human  Figure  (146).  §40.  Artists  must 
depend  on  their  fudgement  rather  than  07i  the  Measuring 
Rule  (146). 

Chapter  II.    (IX.) 

Of  the  manner  of  making  Models  in  Wax  and  in  Clay ;  how 
they  are  draped,  and  how  they  are   afterwards  enlarged  in 


xiv  CONTENTS 


PAGE 


proportion  in  the  Marble  ;  how  Marbles  are  worked  with  the 
point  and  the  toothed  tool,  and  are  rubbed  with  pumice  stone 
and  polished  till  they  are  perfect,  148 

§41.  The  small  Sketch-ModelinWax  or  Clay  (iii,%).  §42-  The 
Preparation  of  Wax  (148).  §  43.  Polychrome  Wax  Effigies  (149). 
§  44.  The  Manipulation  of  Wax  over  an  Armature  (149)- 
§45.  The  Small  Model  in  Clay  (149).  §46.  The  Full-sized 
Model  in  Clay  (150).  §  47.  Drapery  on  the  Clay  Model  (150). 
§  48.  Transference  of  the  Full-sized  Model  to  the  Marble 
Block  (151).  §49.  Danger  of  dispensing  with  the  Full-sized 
Model  (151).  §  50.  The  Tools  and  Materials  used  in  Marble 
Carving  {ic,2). 

Chapter  III.    (X.) 

Of  Low  and  Half  Reliefs,  the  difificulty  of  making  them  and  how 

to  bring  them  to  perfection,  1 54 

§  51.  The  Origin  of  Reliefs  (154).  §  52.  Pictorial  or  Per- 
spective Reliefs  (154).  §  53.  Low  Reliefs  {Bassi  Rilievi)  (156). 
§  54.  Flat  Reliefs  {Stiacciati  Rilievi)  (156). 


Chapter  IV.    (XI.) 

How  Models  for  large  and  small  Bronze  Figures  are  made,  with 
the  Moulds  for  casting  them  and  their  Armatures  of  iron  ;  and 
how  they  are  cast  in  metal  and  in  three  sorts  of  Bronze  ;  and 
how  after  they  are  cast  they  are  chased  and  refined  ;  and  how, 
if  they  lack  pieces  that  did  not  come  out  in  the  cast,  these  are 
grafted  and  joined  in  the  same  bronze,  158 

§55.  The  Full-sized  Model  for  Bronze  {is'S).  §56.  The  Piece- 
Mould  in  Plaster  (158).  §  5  7.  The  Construction  of  the  Core  (159). 
§58.  The  Piece- Mould  lined  with  a  Skin  of  Wax  {ido).  §59.  This 
Skin  of  Wax  applied  over  the  Core  (160).  §  60.  The  fire- 
resisting  Envelope  applied  over  the  Wax  (161).  §61.  The 
External  Armature  (162).  §  62.  The  Vents  (162).  §  63.  The 
Wax  melted  out  {162).  §  64.  The  Mould  in  the  Casting-pit  ( 1 63). 
§  65.  The  Composition  of  the  Bronze  (163).  §  66.  Making  up 
Imperfections  (164).  §  67.  A  simpler  Method  of  Casting  small 
Figures  and  Reliefs  {16^).  §68.  Chasing  the  Cast  and  Colouring 
the  Bronze  (165).  §  69.  Modern  Tours  de  Force  in  small 
Castings  (i65). 


CONTENTS  XV 

^  PAGE 

Chapter  V.    (XII.) 

Concerning  Steel  Dies  for  making  Medals  of  bronze  or  other 
metals  and  how  the  latter  are  formed  from  these  metals  and 
from  Oriental  Stones  and  Cameos,  167 

§70.  The  Fabrication  of  Matrices  for  Medals  {lb"]).     §71.  The 
Cutting  of  Intaglios  and  Cameos  (168). 

Chapter  VI.  (XIII.) 

How  works  in  White  Stucco  are  executed,  and  of  the  manner 
of  preparing  the  Wall  underneath  for  them,  and  how  the  work 
is  carried  out,  -  1 70 

§72.  Modelled  and  stamped  Plaster  IVork  {lyo). 

Chapter  VII.    (XIV.) 

How  Figures  in  Wood  are  executed  and  of  what  sort  of  Wood 

is  best  for  the  purpose,  -  173 

§  73.   Wood  Carding  (i  73). 

Notes  on  'Introduction'  to  Sculpture,  177 

The  Nature  of  Sculpture,  179 

Sculpture  Treated  for  Position,  180 

Waxen  Effigies  and  Medallions,  188 

Proportionate  Enlargement,  190 

The  Use  of  Full-sized  Models,  192 

Italian  and  Greek  Reliefs,  196 

The  Processes  of  the  Bronze  Founder,  -  199 


OF  PAINTING,  -  203 

Chapter  I.    (XV.) 

What  Design  is,  and  how  good  Pictures  are  made  and  known, 

and  concerning  the  invention  of  Compositions,  205 

§  74.  The  Nature  and  Materials  of  Design  or  Drawing  (205). 
§  75.  Use  of  Design  {or  Drawing)  in  the  various  Arts  (206). 
§  76.  On  the  Nature  of  Painting  (208). 


xvi  CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Chapter  II.    (XVI.) 
Of  Sketches,  Drawings,  Cartoons,  and  Schemes  of  Perspective ; 
how  they  are   made,   and   to   what  use  they  are   put  by  the 
Painters,     -  212 

§  ^^.  Sketches,  Drawings,  and  Cartoons  of  different  kinds  (;2\-2). 
§  78.  The  Use  of  Cartoons  in  Mural  and  Panel  Painting  (215). 

Chapter  III.    (XVII.) 

Of  the  Foreshortening  of  Figures  looked  at  from  beneath,  and 

of  those  on  the  Level,  -  -        -      216 

§79,  Foreshortenings  {21b). 

Chapter  IV.    (XVIII.) 

How  Colours  in  oil  painting,  in  fresco,  or  in  tempera  should 
be  blended :  and  how  the  Flesh,  the  Draperies  and  all  that  is 
depicted  come  to  be  harmonized  in  the  work  in  such  a  manner 
that  the  figures  do  not  appear  cut  up,  and  stand  out  well  and 
forcibly  and  show  the  work  to  be  clear  and  comprehensible,  218 

§80.  On  Colouring {2 iS). 

Chapter  V.    (XIX.) 

Of  Painting  on  the  Wall,  how  it  is  done,  and  why  it  is  called 
Working  in  Fresco,     -        -  221 

§81.  The  Fresco  process  {22\). 

Chapter  VI.    (XX.) 

Of  Painting  in  Tempera,  or  with  ^%'g,  on  Panel  or  Canvas,  and 

how  it  is  employed  on  the  wall  which  is  dry,  223 

§  82.  Painting  in  Tempera  (223). 

Chapter  VII.    (XXI.) 
Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  Panel  or  on  Canvas,  -  226 

§  83.  Oil  Painting,  its  Discovery  and  Early  History  (226). 
§  84.  How  to  Prime  the  Panel  or  Canvas  (230).  §  85.  Drawing, 
by  transfer  or  directly  (231). 


CONTENTS  xvii 

„  PAGE 

Chapter  VIII.    (XXII.) 

Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  a  Wall  which  is  dry,  -  -        -      232 

§  86.    Mural  Painting   in    Oil  (232).      §  87.    Vasaris  own 
Method  {21-^. 

Chapter  IX.    (XXIII.) 
Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  Canvas,  236 

§  88.  Painting  on  Canvas  (236). 

Chapter  X.    (XXIV.) 

Of  painting  in  Oil  on  Stone,  and  what  stones  are  good  for  the 
purpose,  -  238 

§  89.  Oil  painting  on  Stone  (238). 

Chapter  XI.    (XXV.) 

Of  Painting  on  the  wall  in  Monochrome  with  various  earths  : 
how  objects  in  bronze  are  imitated  :  and  of  groups  for  Triumphal 
Arches  or  festal  structures,  done  with  powdered  earths  mixed 
with  size,  which  process  is  called  Gouache  and  Tempera,  240 

§  go.  Imitative  Paintings  for  Decorations  (240). 

Chapter  XII.    (XXVI.) 

Of  the  Sgraffiti  for  house  decoration  which  withstand  water  ; 
that  which  is  used  in  their  production  ;  and  how  Grotesques 
are  worked  on  the  wall,  243 

§  91.    S^affito-work    (243).      §  92.    Grotesques,    or   Fanciful 
Devices,  painted  or  modelled  on  Walls  (244). 

Chapter  XIII.    (XXVII.) 
How  Grotesques  are  worked  on  the  Stucco,        -  246 

Chapter  XIV.    (XXVIII.) 

Of  the  manner  of  applying  Gold  on  a  Bolus,  or  with  a  Mordant, 

and  other  methods,  248 

§  93.  Methods  of  Gilding  (248). 


xviii  CONTENTS 

PAGE 

Chapter  XV.     (XXIX.) 

Of  Glass  Mosaic  and  how  it  is  recognized  as  good  and  praise- 
worthy, 251 

§  94.  Glass  Mosaics  (251).  §  95.  The  Preparation  of  the 
Mosaic  Cubes  (253).     §  96.   The  Fixing  of  the  Mosaic  Cubes  (255). 

Chapter  XVI.    (XXX.) 

Concerning  the  Compositions  and  Figures  made  in  Inlaid  Work 

on  Pavements  in  imitation  of  objects  in  Monochrome,  258 

§  97.  Pavements  in  Marble  Mosaic  and  Monochrome  (258). 
§  98.  Pavements  in  Variegated  Tiles  (260).  §  99.  Pavements  iti 
Breccia  Marble  (261). 

Chapter  XVII.    (XXXI.) 

Of  Mosaic  in  Wood,  that  is,  of  Tarsia  ;  and  of  the  Compositions 
that  are  made  in  Tinted  Woods,  fitted  together  after  the  manner 
of  a  picture,  -  -        -  -  262 

§  100.  Inlays  in  Wood  (262). 

Chapter  XVIII.    (XXXII.) 

On  Painting  Glass  Windows  and  how  they  are  put  together  with 
Leads  and  supported  with  Irons  so  as  not  to  interfere  with  the 
view  of  the  figures,  -        -  -      265 

§  loi.  Stained  Glass  IVindows,  their  Origin  and  History  (265). 
§  102.   The  Technique  of  the  Stained  Glass  Window  (268). 

Chapter  XIX.    (XXXIII.) 

Of  Niello,  and  how  by  this  process  we  have  Copper  Prints  ;  and 
how  Silver  is  engraved  to  make  Enamels  over  Bas-relief,  and 
in  like  manner  how  Gold  and  Silver  Plate  is  chased,  -  -      273 

§  103.  Niello  Work  (273).  §  104.  The  Origin  of  Engrav- 
ing (274).     §  105.  Enamels  over  Reliefs  (276). 

IChapter  XX.     (XXXIV.) 
Of  Tausia,  that  is,  work  called  Damascening,      -         -  .      279 

§  106.  Metal  Inlays  (279). 


CONTENTS  xix 

PAGE 

Chapter  XXI.    (XXXV.) 

Of  Wood  Engraving  and  the  method  of  executing  it  and  con 
cerning  its  first  Inventor :  how  Sheets  which  appear  to  be  drawn 
by  hand  and  exhibit  Lights  and  Half-tones  and  Shades,  are 

produced  with  three  Blocks  of  Wood,                            -        -  281 

§  107.  Chiaroscuro  Wood  Engravings  (281).     §  108.  Depend- 
ence on  Design  of  the  Decorative  Arts  (284). 

Notes  on  'Introduction'  to  Painting,  285 

Fresco  Painting,    -                              -  287 

Tempera  Painting,  291 

Oil  Painting,  -  294 

Enriched  Fa9ades,  298 

Stucco  'Grotesques,'                           -  299 

Tarsia  Work,  or  Wood  Inlays,  -  303 

The  Stained  Glass  Window,               -  308 

Vasari's  Description  of  Enamel  Work,                  -  311 


LIST   OF    ILLUSTRATIONS 


INSERTED   PLATES 

Specimens  of  Stones  mentioned  by  Vasari.    (Reproduction  in 

colour  of  a  drawing  by  the  Editor.)  Frontispiece. 

Portrait  of  Vasari,  from  the  Edition  of  1568.  Probably 
by  a  German  artist  called  in  Italy  '  Cristoforo  Coriolano.' 

Tail-piece  to  List  of  Illustrations. 

Plate  I.  Leo  X  with  his  Cardinals.  Mural  Painting  by  Vasari 
in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio,  Florence.  (From  a  photograph  by 
Alinari.)  To  face  p.  17 

Plate  II.  Principal  Doorway  at  S.  Maria  Novella,  Florence, 
showing  the  position  of  the  inscribed  porphyry  tablet  on  the 
riser  of  the  step.     (From  a  photograph  by  Alinari.)     To  face  p.  32 

Plate  III.  Portrait  in  Porphyry  of  Cosimo  'Pater  Patriae,' 
BY  Francesco  del  Tadda,  in  the  Magazines  of  the  National 
Museum,  Florence.  (From  a  photograph  by  the  Editor.) 
Unpublished.  To  face  p.  34 

Plate  IV.  Interior  of  Grotto  in  Boboli  Gardens,  Florence, 
showing  an  unfinished  statue  ascribed  to  Michelangelo.  (From 
a  photograph  by  the  Editor.)  To  face  p.  90 

Plate  V.  Portrait  in  Porphyry  of  Leo  X,  by  Francesco 
del  Tadda,  in  the  Magazines  of  the  National  Museum, 
Florence.     (From  a  photograph  by  the  Editor.)    Unpubhshed. 

To  face  p.  114 


xxii  LIST   OF   ILLUSTRATIONS 

Plate  VI.  Salamander  Carved  in  Travertine,  on  the  Fagade 
of  S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi,  Rome.  The  work  of  a  French  artist 
'  Maestro  Gian.'  (From  a  photograph  by  the  Editor.)  Un- 
published. To  face  p.  132 

Plate  VII.  Illustration  showing  Process  of  Piece-Moulding 

IN  Plaster.    (From  the  French  EncydopMie.)        To  face  p.  160 

Plate  VIII.  Engravings  illustrating  the  Process  of  Casting 

IN  Bronze.     (From  the  French  EncydopMie^  To  face  p.  164 

Plate  IX.  Statue  of  S.  Rocco  carved  in  Lime-wood,  by  a  French 
artist  '  Maestro  Janni,'  in  the  Church  of  the  Annunziata, 
Florence.    (From  a  drawing  by  Robert  J.  Rose.)    Unpublished. 

To  face  p.  176 

Plate  X.  A.    Interior    of    a    Sculptor's    Studio    in    the 

F.IGHTEENTH  CENTURY,  with  illustrations  of  the  methods  of 

measurement  then  in  vogue.    (From  the  French  EncydopMie.) 

B.   Diagram  to  illustrate  Leon  Battista  Alberti's 

method  of  measurement.  To  face  p.  192 

Plate  XI.  Specimen  of  so-called  'Sgraffito'  Decoration,  on 
the  exterior  of  the  Palazzo  Montalvo,  Florence.  (From  a 
photograph  by  Alinari.)  To  face  p.  244 

Plate  XII.  Portion  of  the  Decoration  of  the  Loggie  of 
THE  Vatican,  by  Raphael  and  his  assistants.  (Reproduced 
in  colour  from  a  hand-painted  example  of  the  engravings  of 
about  1770-80  by  Ottaviani  and  Volpato,  in  the  National 
Art  Library.)  To  face  p.  248 

Plate  XIII.  Specimen  of  Niello  Work.  A  'Pax,'  formerly  in 
the  Baptistry,  and  now  in  the  National  Museum,  Florence. 
(From  a  photograph  by  Alinari.)  To  face  p.  274 

Plate  XIV.  Chiaroscuro  Wood-Engraving  by  Ugo  da  Carpi, 
in  the  Print-Room,  British  Museum.  Subject:  'Jacob's 
Dream,'  after  Raphael.  To  face  p.  282 

Plate  XV.  Head  of  Mary,  from  Luini's  Fresco  of  the 
'Marriage  of  the  Virgin'  at  Saronno.  (From  a 
photograph  by  Giacomo  Brogi.)  To  illustrate  the  fresco 
technique.  To  face  p.  290 


LIST   OF   ILLUSTRATIONS  xxiii 

Plate  XVI.  Example  of  Tarsia  Work.  S.  Zenobi,  by  Giuliano 
da  Majano,  in  Opera  del  Duomo,  Florence.  (From  a 
photograph  by  Alinari.)  To  face  p.  306 

Plate  XVII.  Painted  Glass  Window  in  the  Laurentian 
Library,  Florence.    (From  a  photograph  by  Alinari.) 

To  face  p.  310 


FIGURES    IN   THE   TEXT 

Fig.  I.  Inscribed  Porphyry  Tablet  at  S.  Maria  Novella,  Florence. 

(Drawn  from  a  photograph  by  the  Editor.)  P-  31 

P'ig.  2.  Tools  mentioned  by  Vasari,  etc.     (From  drawings  by  the 

Translator  and  Editor.)  p.  48 

Fig.  3.  Fortezza  da  Basso  at  Florence.     (Drawn  from  a  photograph 

by  the  Editor.)  p.  67 

Fig.  4.  Rusticated  masonry  on  the  exterior  of  the  Fortezza  da  Basso 

at  Florence.     (Measured  drawing  by  the  Editor.)  p.  69 

Fig.  5.  Construction  of  the  Portico  of  the  Uffizi  at  Florence,  from 

Vasari's  description.     (Drawn  by  the  Editor.)  p.  71 

Fig.  6.  Drawing  of  the  remains  of  the  Basilica  Aemilia  in  the 
Forum  at  Rome,  that  survived  to  the  time  of  Vasari.  (After 
Giuliano  da  San  Gallo,  in  Monumenti  del  Istituto,  XII, 
T.  II,  12.)  p.  77 

Fig.  7.  Roman  Doric  Cap,  with  Stucco  Finish,  at  S.  Nicola  in 
Carcere,  Rome.  (From  Mitteilungen  d.  k.  deutschen  archeo- 
logischen  Insiituts,  xxi.)  p.  78 

Fig.  8.  Portion  of  a  Plan  of  Rome,  before  recent  alterations,  from 

Nolli,  Nuova  Pianta  di  Roma,  1748.  p.  105 

Fig.  9.  Sketch  of  shape  of  the  large  porphyry  Tazza  in  the  Sala 

Rotonda  of  the  Vatican.  p.  109 


xxiv  LIST   OF   ILLUSTRATIONS 

Fig.  10.  Sketch    map    of    the    marble-producing    districts    of    the 

Apiian  Alps.  p.  121 

Fig.  II.  Two  views  of  unfinished  Greek  marble  statue  blocked 
out  on  the  ancient  system.  In  quarries  on  Mount  Pentelicus, 
Athens.  (From  a  photograph  kindly  furnished  by  M.  Georges 
Nicole.)  p.  193 


rORTRAIT  OF  VASARI,  FROM  THE  EDITION  OF  1568, 
probably  by  a  German  artist,   called  in  Italy  '  Cristoforo  Coriolano ' 


INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 


INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

When  Vasari  published  in  1550  his  famous  Lives  of  the 
Artists,  he  prefixed  to  the  work  an  Introduction,  divided  into 
three  parts  headed  respectively  Architecture,  Sculpture,  and 
Painting.  In  the  text  of  the  Lives  he  refers  more  than  once 
to  this  preliminary  matter  under  the  terms  '  parte  teorica  ' 
and  '  capitoli  delle  teoriche, '  but  as  a  fact  it  only  consists 
to  a  small  extent  in  '  theory,'  that  is  in  aesthetic  discussions 
on  the  general  character  of  the  arts  and  the  principles  that 
underlie  them.  The  chief  interest  of  the  chapters  is  technical. 
They  contain  practical  directions  about  materials  and  processes, 
intended  in  the  first  place  to  enlighten  the  general  reader  on 
subjects  about  which  he  is  usually  but  little  informed ;  and 
in  the  second,  to  assist  those  actually  engaged  in  the  operations 
of  the  arts. 

To  some  of  the  readers  of  the  original  issue  of  Vasari's 
work  these  technical  chapters  proved  of  special  interest,  for 
we  find  a  Flemish  correspondent  writing  to  him  to  say  that 
on  the  strength  of  the  information  therein  contained  he  had 
made  practical  essays  in  art,  not  wholly  without  success.  This 
same  correspondent,  as  Vasari  tells  us  in  the  chapter  on 
Flemish  artists  at  the  end  of  the  Lives,  hearing  that  the  work 
was  to  be  reprinted,  wrote  in  the  name  of  many  of  his  com- 
patriots to  urge  Vasari  to  prefix  to  the  new  edition  a  more 
extended  disquisition  on  sculpture,  painting,  and  architecture, 
with  illustrative  designs,  so  as  to  enforce  the  rules  of  art 
after  the  fashion  of  Alberti,  Albrecht  Diirer,  and  other  artists. 
This  seemed  however  to  Vasari  to  involve  too  great  an 
alteration  in  the  scheme  of  his  work,  and  in  the  edition  of 
1568  he  preserved  the  original  form  of  the  Introduction,  though 
he  incorporated   with   it   considerable   additions.     It  is   worth 

A 


2  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

noting  that  the  increase  is  chiefly  in  the  earlier  part,  as  if 
Vasari  began  his  revision  with  the  intention  of  carrying  out 
the  suggestion  of  his  correspondents,  but  gave  up  the  idea 
of  substantial  enlargement  as  he  went  on.  For  example  the 
first  chapter  in  the  'Introduction'  to  Architecture  is  half  as 
long  again  in  the  second  as  in  the  first  edition,  and  Architecture 
generally  is  increased  by  a  third  part,  while  in  Sculpture  the 
additions  are  trifling.  The  total  additions  amount  to  nearly 
one  seventh  of  the  whole.  The  matter  thus  added  is  in  general 
illustrative  of  the  previous  text,  and  adduces  further  examples 
of  work  under  review.  It  is  this  extended  Introduction  of 
the  second,  or  1568,  edition,  which  is  now  completely  trans- 
ited and  issued  with  the  needful  commentary. 

The  reputation  of  the  writer  and  the  value  of  his  world- 
renowned  biographies  naturally  give  importance  to  matter 
which  he  has  deliberately  prefixed  to  these,  and  it  is  somewhat 
surprising  that  though  the  text  has  been  constantly  printed 
it  has  not  been  annotated,  and  that  it  has  never  yet  been 
rendered  as  a  whole  into  English,  nor,  as  far  as  can  be 
ascertained,  into  any  other  European  language. 

Ernst  Berger,  in  his  learned  and  valuable  Beitrage_zur_Erit- 
wickltmgs-Geschichte  der  Maltechmkj^y}exi§JFo\ge^ 
i9oi,"3oes  justice  to  Vasari 's  Treatise,  of  which,  as  he  says, 
'  the  thirty-five  chapters  contain  a  complete  survey  of  the  manual 
activities  of  the  time,  in  connection  with  which  Vasari  gives 
us  very  important  information  on  the  condition  of  technique 
in  the  sixteenth  century, '  and  he  translates  the  chapters  relating 
to  painting  with  one  or  two  useful  notes.  There  was 
apparently  an  intention  of  editing  Vasari 's  Introduction  in 
the  Vienna  series  of  Technical  Treatises  (Quellenschriften) 
but  the  project  was  not  carried  out.  Anglo-Saxon  readers  will 
note  that  the  chapters  do  not  appear  in  the  classic  English 
translation  by  Mrs  Jonathan  Foster,  nor  in  the  American 
reprint  of  selected  Lives  lately  edited  with  annotations  by 
Blashfield  and  Hopkins ;  they  are  omitted  also  from  the  French 
translation  by  Leclanch6,  and  from  that  into  German  by 
Ludwig-  Schorn.  Mrs  Foster  explains  that  she  only  meant  to 
translate  the  Lives  and  not  Vasari 's  '  other  works  ' ;  while 
the  German  editor,  though  he  admits  the  value  of  the  technical 


NEGLECT  OF  VASARI'S  INTRODUCTION   3 

chapters  to  the  artist,  thinks  that  the  latter  '  would  have  in 
any  case  to  go  to  the  original  because  many  of  the  technical 
terms  would  not  be  intelligible  in  translation.' 

On  this  it  may  be  remarked  that  the  chapters  in  question 
are  not  '  other  works  '  in  the  sense  in  which  we  should  use 
the  term  in  connection  with  Vasari's  Letters,  and  the 
'  Ragionamenti,'  or  description  of  his  own  performances  in 
the  Palazzo  Vecchio  at  Florence,  that  are_  all_  printed  by 
Milanesi  in  the  Sansoni  edition  oT~  Vasari's  works.  The 
chapters  are  distinctly  a  part,  and  a  valuable  part,  of  the 
main  work  of  the  author,  and  it  is  difficult  to  see  any  valid 
reason  why  they  should  ever  have  been  dissociated  from  it. 
With  regard  to  the  reason  for  omission  given  by  the  German 
editor,  surely  the  resources  of  the  translator's  art  are  not  so 
limited  as  he  supposed  !  It  may  be  claimed,  at  any  rate,  that 
in  what  follows  a  conscientious  effort  has  been  made  to  find 
techpical  terms  in  English  equivalent  to  Vasari's,  and  yet 
intelligible  to  the  reader.  Where  such  terms  do  not  seem 
to  be  clear,  a  footnote  has  been  added  in  explanation. 

It  is  probable  that  the  real  reason  of  the  neglect  of  Vasari's 
Introduction  by  his  translators  has  been  the  fact  that  when 
these  translations  were  made,  more  than  half-a-century  ago, 
not  much  interest  was  taken  by  the  reading  public  in  the 
technical  processes  of  the  arts,  and  this  part  of  Vasari's  work 
was  passed  over  in  order  not  to  delay  the  reader  anxious  for 
the  biographical  details  the  author  presents  in  so  lively  a 
fashion.  At  the  present  time,  largely  as  a  result  of  the  inspiring 
influence  of  William  Morris  alike  upon  the  craftsmen  and  the 
artistic  public,  people  have  been  generally  awakened  to  the 
interest  and  importance  of  these  questions  of  technique,  and 
a  new  translator  of  Vasari  would  certainly  not  be  betrayed 
into  this  omission.  The  present  translation  and  commentary 
may  therefore  claim  to  fill  a  gap  that  ought  never  to  have 
been  suffered  to  exist,  and  on  this  ground  to  need  no  explana- 
tion nor  apology.  Some  English  writers  on  the  technique  of 
the  arts,  such  as  Mrs  Merrifield  and  the  late  G.  T.  Robinson, 
have  made  considerable  use  of  the  material  that  Vasari  has 
placed  before  students  in  these  Introductory  Chapters,  and 
the    practical    service    that    they    have    thus    rendered    is    an 


4  INTRODUCTORY  ESSAY 

additional  reason  why  they  should  be  brought  as  a  whole  in 
convenient  form  before  English  readers. 

Readers  familiar  with  Vasari's  Lives  will  miss  in  the 
technical  Introduction  much  of  the  charm  and  liveliness  of 
style  in  which  they  have  been  wont  to  delight.  Vasari  indeed 
had  a  natural  gift  for  biographical  writing.  He  had  a  sense 
of  light  and  shade  and  of  contrast  in  colouring  that  animates 
his  literary  pictures,  and  is  the  secret  of  the  fascination  of 
his  work,  while  it  explains  at  the  same  time  some  of  its 
acknowledged  defects.  Above  all  things  he  will  have  variety. 
If  one  artist  have  been  presented  to  the  reader  of  the  Lives 
as  a  man  of  the  world  in  constant  touch  with  his  fellows,  the 
next  artist  who  comes  forward  on  the  stage  is  a  recluse.  If 
one  be  open  and  free,  another  is  secretive  and  brooding;  the 
artist  jealous  of  his  brother's  fame  and  envious  of  his  secrets 
is  contrasted  with  the  genial  companion  ready  to  impart  all 
he  knows  to  his  less  fortunate  compeer.  In  bringing  out  these 
picturesque  comparisons,  the  writer  sometimes  forces  the  note, 
and  is  a  little  more  regardful  of  effect  than  of  strict  bio- 
graphical accuracy,  J^  and  this  accounts  for  some  of  the  censure 
which  in  the  modern  critical  age  has  fallen  to  the  lot  of  the 
Aretine. 

The  technical  disquisitions  in  the  Introduction  afford  little 
opportunity  for  picturesque  writing  of  this  kind,  and  they 
must  be  judged  from  another  standpoint.  They  have  certain 
obvious  defects  that  are  however  counterbalanced  by  qualities 
of  much  value.  Vasari's  treatment  in  many  parts  lacks 
system  and  completeness,  his  statement  is  wanting  in  clearness, 
his  aesthetic  comments  are  often  banal.  On  the  other  hand 
there  are  sections  or  chapters  of  great,  even  enthralling, 
interest,  as  when  he  discourses  with  all  a  Florentine's 
enthusiasm  on  the  virile  and  decided  handling  of  a  master  in 
fresco  painting;  or  lets  us  follow  step  by  step  from  the  small 
sketch  to  the  finished  casting  the  whole  process  of  making  a 
great  bronze  statue.     Throughout  the  treatise  moreover,   we 

1  Berenson,  Tie  Drawings  of  the  Florentine  Painters,  London,  1903,  I,  p.  18, 
says  that  Vasari  '  was  an  indifferent  connoisseur  and  a  poor  historian  ;  but  he  was 
a  great  appreciator  -  .  .  and  a  passionate  anecdote-monger.  Now  the  Anecdote 
must  have  sharp  contrasts  .  .  .  . ' 


VASARI'S  INTENTION  IN  THE  INTRODUCTION  c 
/ 
have  the  advantage  of  hearing  a  practical  craftsman  speaking 
about  the  processes  and  materials  with  which  he  is  himself 
familiar,  for  Vasari,  though  he  did  not  put  his  own  hand  to 
nearly  all  the  kinds  of  work  he  describes,  yet  was  all  his  Ufe 
a  professional,  in  intimate  touch  with  craftsmen  in  every 
branch  of  artistic  production.  If  he  did  not  make  painted 
glass  windows,  he  at  any  rate  designed  for  them.  His  mural 
work  involved  modelled  and  stamped  plaster  enrichment  and 
wood  carving,  while  his  sections  on  different  processes  of 
decoration  for  temporary  purposes  derive  a  personal  interest 
from  the  fact  that  the  writer  was  a  famous  expert  in  the 
construction  and  adornment  of  showy  fabrics  for  pageants  and 
state  entries,  of  which  his  own  letters  give  tis  many  details. 
If  he  be  unavoidably  tedious  in  his  description  of  the  Orders 
of  Architecture,  he  enlivens  this  by  a  digression  on  his  own 
devices  in  the  masonry  of  the  Uffizi  palace.  The  august  figure 
of  Michelangelo  sometimes  crosses  the  page,  and  in  the  midst 
of  the  rather  copious  eulogies  of  which  Vasari  is  lavish,  we 
find  here  and  there  some  record  of  a  word  or  work  of 
Buonarroti  which  reminds  us  of  the  author's  intimate  personal 
relation  to  the  master  whom  he  calls  in  a  letter  '  il  mio  rarissimo 
e  divinissimo  Vecchio. ' 

Vasari 's  general  intention  in  this  Introduction  he  explains  at 
the  close  of  the  '  Proemio  '  to  the  whole  work  that  precedes  the 
technical  chapters.  The  Introduction  is  primarily  to  instruct 
'  every  gracious  spirit  in  the  most  noble  matters  that  appertain 
to  the  artistic  professions  ' ;  and  next  in  order,  '  for  his  delight 
and  service,  to  give  him  to  know  in  what  qualities  the  various 
masters  differed  among  themselves,  and  how  they  adorned 
and  how  they  benefitted  each  in  his  own  way  their  country  ' ; 
and  finally  to  enable  any  one  that  wills  to  gain  advantage 
from  the  labour  and  cunning  of  those  who  in  times  past  have 
excelled  in  the  arts.  Architecture  will  be  shown  to  be  the 
most  universal,  the  most  necessary,  and  the  most  useful  of 
human  arts,  for  whose  service  and  adornment  the  other  two 
arts  exist ;  the  different  qualities  of  stones  will  be  demonstrated, 
with  the  styles  of  building  and  their  proper  proportions,  and 
the  characteristics  of  good  designs  and  good  construction. 
Next  in  order  comes  Sculpture,  and  here  will  be  shown  the 


6  INTRODUCTORY  ESSAY 

manner  of  working  statues,  in  their  correct  forms  and  pro- 
portions, and  the  qualities  that  make  sculpture  good,  '  with 
all  the  directions  for  work  that  are  most  secret  and  most 
precious.'  Lastly,  the  treatment  of  Painting  will  include 
design;  the  methods  of  colouring  and  of  carrying  out  a 
picture;  the  characteristics  of  painting  and  its  subordinate 
branches,  with  ifcosaics  of  every  sort,  niello  work,  enamels, 
damascening,  and  finally  engravings  after  pictures. 

Vasari's  treatise  does  not  stand  alone  but  is  only  one  among 
many  technical  and  theoretical  essays  which  have  come  down 
to  us  from  various  epochs  both  of  the  middle  ages  and  of  the 
Renaissance.  The  nature  and  the  value  of  it  will  be  best 
understood  if  we  compare  it  with  one  or  two  representative 
publications  of  a  similar  kind,  contemporary  with  it  or  of 
earlier  date.  The  comparison  will  serve  to  show  the  spirit 
in  which  Vasari  writes,  and  to  exhibit  the  strong  and  the 
weak  points  in  his  work. 

About  the  middle  of  the  last  century,  a  number  of  technical 
treatises_and_TOU£crions_^_re^^^^  from  MSS.  of  the  twelfth 

^o  the  eighteenth  centuries^  were  edited  and  published  by 
Mrs  Merrifield ,  and  the  acumen  and  accuracy  with  which  she 
fulfilled  her  laborious  task  are  warmly  eulogized  by  Dr  Albert 
Ilg,  the  learned  editor  of  Theophilus  and  Cennini  in  the  Vienna 
Quellenschriften.  The  most  important  of  existing  treatises 
o^_tihe  kind  are  howw^  not  i^luded^  in  Mrs  Merri%jy's 
work^  though  they  have_  l3e_en.  translated  and.,  edited  separately 
both  by  her_  and  by  _Qth£r— scholars.  The  recenjt^gi^lication 
-» by  Ernst  Berger  noticed  above  givegj^ja  mpst-Comg jete  account 
of_ail^Jhis_Jte(^tiiii£aJ^Ete^  Those  of  the  early  treatises 

or  tracts  that  consist  in  little  more  than  collections  of  recipes 
need  not  detain  us,  and  the  only  works  of  which  we  need 
here  take  account  are  the  following:  (i)  The  Schedula 
Diversarum  Artium  of  Theophilus,  a  compendium  of  the 
decorative  arts  as  they  were  practised  in  the  mediaeval 
inonastery,  drawn  up  by  a  German  monk  of  the  eleventh  or 
twelfth  century;  (2)  II  Libra  dell'  Arte,  o  Trattato  della  Pittura 
of  the  Florentine  painter  Cennino  Cennini,  written  in  the  early 
part  of  the  fifteenth  century;  (3)  The  De  Re  Aedificatoria  and 
the  tracts  Delia  Pittura  and  Della  Scultura,  written  rather  later 


COMPARISON  WITH  EARLIER  TREATISES      7 

and  in  quite  a  different  vein,  by  the  famous  Florentine  humanist 
and  artist  Leon  Battista  Alberti;  (4)  Benvenuto  Cellini's 
treatises,  Sopra  V  Oreficeria  e  la  Scultura,  that  belong 
to  the  same  period  as  Vasari's  own  Introduction,  and  partly 
cover  the  same  ground.  There  are  later  treatises,  such  as 
Borghini's  II  Riposo,  1584;  Armenini's  Dei  veri  Precetti  della 
Piffwrn,  1587;  Pacheco's  Arte  de  la  Pintura,  iG^g;  Palomino's 
El  Museo  Pictorico,  etc.,  1715-24,  which  all  contain  matter  of 
interest,  but  need  not  be  specially  noticed  in  this  place.  Some 
of  these  later  writers  depend  very  largely  on  Vasari. 

The  fact  just  stated  about  the  treatises  of  Cellini  and  Vasari 
suggests  the  question  whether  the  two  are  independent,  or, 
if  borrowing  existed,  which  treatise  owes  most  to  this  adven- 
titious aid.  The  dates  of  Vasari's  two  editions  have  already 
been  given.  Cellini's  two  Trattati  first  appeared  in  1568  the 
same  year  as  Vasari's  second  edition,  and  there  exists  a 
second  recension  of  his  text  which  formed  the  basis  of 
Milanesi's  edition  of  1857,  republished  in  1893.  It  is  worth 
noting  that  Vasari's  account  of  bronze  casting,  in  which  we 
should  expect  reliance  on  Cellini,  appears  in  full  in  the  first 
edition  of  1550,  and  the  same  applies  to  the  account  of  die- 
sinking.  On  the  other  hand  Celini's  notice  of  the  Tuscan 
building  stones,  pietra  serena,  etc.,  seems  like  a  clearer 
statement  of  what  we  find  in  Vasari's  edition  of  1550.  On 
the  whole  it  was  Cellini  who  used  Vasari  rather  than  Vasari 
Cellini,  though  the  tracts  can  be  regarded  as  practically 
independent.  The  Tyatfafi^pf  Cellini,  are  really  complementary 
to.  Vasari's  '  Introductions. ' 

Vasari,  as  he  says  of  himself,  was_painter  and_  architect, 
while  Celliniwas  sculptor  and  worker  in  metal.  In  matters 
like  die-sinking,  niello  work,  enamelling,  and  the  making  of 
medals,  Cellini  gives  the  fuller  and  more  practical  information, 
for  these  were  not  exactly  in  the  province  of  the  Aretine,  while 
Vasari  on  his  side  gives  us  much  information,  especially  on 
the  processes  of  painting  and  on  architectural  subjects,  for 
which  we  look  in  vain  to  Cellini. 

Allowing  for  these  differences,  the  two  treatises  agree  in 
the  general  picture  that  they  give  of  the  artistic  activity  of 
their  times,  and  thev_faithfully  reflect  the  spirit  of  tjiejjjgh 


8  INTRODUCTORY  ESSAY 

Renaissance,  when  the  arts  were  made  the  instruments  of 
a  dazzling,  even  ostentatious,  parade,  jn_wHch_,decadence  was 
unmistakeably  prefigured.  From  this  point  of  view,  the  point 
of  view,  that  is,  of  the  general  artistic  tone  of  an  age,  it  is 
interesting  to  draw  a  comparison  between  the  spirit  of  the 
treatises  of  Vasari  and  Cellini  on  the  one  side,  and  on  the 
other  the  spirit  of  the  earlier  writings  already  referred  to.  If 
the  former  bring  us  into  contact  with  the  Renaissance  in  the 
heyday  of  its  pride,  the  artistic  tractates  of  Alberti,  of  a 
century  before,  show  us  the  Renaissance  movement  in  its 
strenuous  youth,  already  self-conscious,  but  militant  and  dis- 
posed to  work  rather  than  to  enjoy.  Cennini's  Book  of  Art, 
though  certainly  written  in  the  lifetime  of  Alberti,  belongs 
in  spirit  to  the  previous,  that  is  to  the  fourteenth,  century.  It 
reflects  the  life  of  the  mediaeval  guilds,  when  artist  and  crafts-' 
man  were  still  one,  and  the  practice  of  the  arts  proceeded 
on  traditional  lines  in  urban  workshops  where  master  and 
apprentices  worked  side  by  side  on  any  commissions  that  their 
fellow  citizens  chose  to  bring.  Lastly  the  Schedula  of  the 
monkJTheoghilus  introduces  us  into  quite  a  different  atmosphere 
of  art.  Carrying  us  back  for  two  hundred  years,  it  shows 
us  art  cultivated  in  an  ascetic  community  in  independence  of 
patrons  or  guilds  or  civic  surroundings ;  on  purely  religious 
lines  for  the  glory  of  the  Almighty  and  the  fitting  adornment 
of  His  house. 

This  treatise  by  Theophilus  is  by  far  the  most  interesting 
and  valuable  of  all  those  that  have  been  named.  No  literary 
product  of  the  middle  ages  is  more  precious,  for  it  reflects, 
a  side  of  mediaeval  life  of  which  we  should  otherwise  be 
imperfectly  informed.  Can  it  be  possible,  we  ask  ourselves, 
that  men  vowed  to  religion  in  its  most  ascetic  form,  who 
had  turned  their  backs  on  the  world's  vain  shows  and  whose 
inward  eye  was  to  see  only  the  mystic  light  of  vision,  could 
devote  time  and  care  to  the  minutiae  of  the  craftsman's 
technique?  Such  however  was  the  fact.  We  cannot  read  the 
first  few  pages  of  Theophilus  without  recognizing  that  the 
religion  of  the  writer  was  both  sincere  and  fervent,  and  that 
such  religion  seemed  to  him  to  find  a  natural  outcome  in  art. 
Art  moreover  with  the  German  monk  was  essentially  a  matter 


THE  'SCHEDULA'  OF  THEOPHILUS  9 

W  technique.  From  end  to  end  of  the  treatise  there  is  com- 
oaratively  little  about  art  as  representative.  Sculpture  and 
pointing  indeed  in  the  monastic  period  were  not  capable  of 
embodying  the  ideal,  so  as  to  produce  on  the  spectator  the 
religious  impression  of  a  Madonna  by  Angelico  or  Raphael. 
The  art  of  the  eleventh  and  twelfth  centuries  was  decorative, 
and  aimed  at  an  effect  of  beauty  with  an  under  suggestion 
of  symbolism.  Theophilus  troubles  himself  little  about  sym- 
bolism but  bases  everything  on  a  knowledge  of  materials  and 
processes ;  and  in  the  workshop,  whose  homely  construction 
and  fittings  he  describes,  we  are  invited  to  see  the  gold  and 
silver  and  bronze,  the  coloured  earths,  the  glass  stained  with 
metallic  oxides,  all  taking  shape  in  dainty  and  beautiful  forms, 
and  coming  together  in  discreet  but  opulent  display,  till,  as 
he  phrases  it,  the  Abbey  Church  which  they  bedeck  and  furnish 
'  shall  shine  like  the  garden  of  Paradise. '  For  to  the  mind 
of  the  pious  craftsman  this  church  is  a  microcosm.  Creative 
skill  has  made  it  all  beautiful  within,  and  this  is  the  skill  of 
man,  but  it  is  only  his  in  so  far  as  man  shares  the  nature  of 
the  Divine  Artist  that  fashioned  the  vast  macrocosm  of  the 
universe.  Artistic  knowledge  and  craftsmanship  are  a  part 
of  the  original  heritage  of  man  as  he  was  made  in  the  image 
of  God  the  creator,  and  to  win  back  this  heritage  by  patient 
labour  and  contriving  is  a  religious  duty,  in  the  fulfilment  of 
which  the  Holy  Spirit  will  Himself  give  constant  aid. 
Theophilus  enumerates  from  St  Paul  the  seven  gifts  of  the 
Spirit,  and  shows  how  the  knowledge,  the  wisdom,  the  counsel, 
and  the  might,  thus  imparted  to  men,  all  find  a  field  of  exercise 
in  the  monastic  workshop. 

Cennino  Cennini  da  CoUe  di  Val  d'  Elsa  was  not  a  devotee 
nor  a  man  of  religion,  but  a  city  tradesman  and  employer  of 
labour.  Art  in  his  time  had  taken  up  its  abode  in  the  towns 
that  were  the  seat  of  the  artistic  activity  of  the  Gothic  period 
in  France  and  the  neighbouring  countries.  It  was  there 
practised  by  laymen  in  secular  surroundings,  but  as  the  French 
Cathedrals  and  the  work  of  Giotto  and  Simone  Martini  testify, 
on  religious  subjects  and  in  a  spirit  of  piety.  Some  gleams 
of  the  visionary  light  that  irradiates  the  workshop  of  Theophilus 
fall  across  the  panels  which  Cennini  and  his  apprentices  smooth 


10  INTRODUCTORY  ESSAY 

and  clamp,  and  prime  with  gesso,  and  paint  with  forms  of 
the  Madonna  or  the  Crucified.  In  one  of  his  chapters  he 
demands  for  the  artist. a,  chaste  and  almost  ascetic  life,  as  of 
one  who  studies  thp.nlngy  nr  philosophy,  and  again  he  bids 
him  clothe  himself  for  his  art  with  love  and  obedience,  .with 
patience  and  g."dly  fea-c.  When  beginning  a  delicate  piece 
of  manipulation  Cennini  bids  the  worker  '  Invoke  the  name 
of  God,'  and  it  is  characteristic  too  that  he  tells  him  that 
such  work  must  not  be  executed  in  haste,  but  '  with  great 
affection  and  care.'  In  the  main  however,  Cennini 's  treatise 
is  occupied  with  a  description  of  the  processes  of  painting 
traditional  in  the  school  of  Florence,  that  was  dominated 
throughout  the  fourteenth  century  by  the  commanding  figure 
of  Giotto.  We  learn  from  the  Trattato  how  walls  were 
plastered  and  prepared  for  the  mural  painter,  and  can  measure 
how  far  the  technical  practice  of  fresco  had  at  the  time  been 
carried.  Fresco  painting,  on  which  the  reader  will  find  a  Note 
at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction  '  to  Painting,  was  only  the 
revival  of  an  art  familiar  to  the  ancients,  but  the  best  form 
of  the  technique,  called  by  the  Itahans  '  buon  fresco,'  was 
only  completely  recovered  in  the  course  of  the  fifteenth  century. 
In  the  school  of  Giotto,  represented  by  Cennini,  the  practice 
was  as  yet  imperfect,  but  his  account  of  it  is  full  of  interest. 
Painting  on  panels  and  on  the  vellum  of  books  he  thoroughly 
understands,  and  his  notices  of  pigments  and  media  convey 
much  valuable  information.  Amongst  other  things  he  seems 
quite  au  fait  in  the  practice  of  oil-painting,  which  Vasari  has 
made  many  generations  believe  was  an  invention  of  the  Flemish 
van  Eyck. 

The  chief  importance  however  of  Cennini  for  the  present 
purpose  is  to  be  found  in  his  implicit  reliance  on  authority  and 
tradition,  in  which  he  contrasts  most  markedly,  as  we  shall 
see,  with  his  fellow-countryman  and  successor,  Leon  Battista 
Alberti.  Cennini  had  himself  worked  for  twelve  years  with 
Agnolo  Gaddi  the  son  of  Taddeo  Gaddi,  for  twenty-four  years 
the  pupil  and  assistant  of  Giotto,  and  he  warns  the  student 
against  changing  his  teacher,  and  so  becoming,  as  he  calls  it, 
a  '  phantasist. '  To  quote  his  own  words,  '  do  thou  direct 
thy  course  by  this  rule  according  to  which  I  will  instruct  thee 


CENNINI   AND   ALBERTI  ii 

in  the  painter's  art,  for  Giotto  the  great  master  himself 
followed  it.  Four  and  twenty  years  was  Taddeo  Gaddi,  the 
Florentine,  his  scholar;  Taddeo's  son  was  Agnolo;  Agnolo 
kept  me  by  him  twelve  years,  during  which  he  taught  me  to 
paint  in  this  manner,'  and  he  points  the  moral  from  his  own 
experience,  '  At  the  earliest  moment  you  can,  put  yourself  under 
the  best  master  you  can  find,  and  stay  with  him  as  long  as 
you  are  able.' 

Cennini.  who  seems  to  have  been  born  about  tt/2.  probably 
wrote  his  Trattato Acmards  the  close  pf  his  1ifp,j  and  there  is 
MS.    authority    for   dating    the    tract   Delia   Pittura   of    Leon 
Battista  Alberti  about  1435,  so  that  the  two  works  may  have 
been    composed   within    the    same    generation.      The    contrast 
between  them  is  however  most  striking.     Cennini's  id^as  are 
wholly  those  of  the  fourteenth  century,  when  guild  traditions 
were  supreme  over  artistic  ttcagtice ;  whereas  Alberti  is  possessed 
by  the  spirit  of  thp  F.arly  Rpngissnnrp.,  of  which  he  is  indeed 
one  of  the  most  representative  figures.     In  his  view  the  artist 
should   base   his    life   and   his   work   on   the   new   humanistic 
culture  of  the  age,   and  build  up  his  art  on  science  and  the 
study  of  nature  anc}  Qn_.tli£-.exsmple  of  the  masters  of  antiouitK. 
With  regard  to  the  last,  the  reader,  who  hears  Alberti  invoking 
the  legendary  shades  of  Pheidias  and  Zeuxis  and  Apelles,  may 
suspect  that  a  new  authority  is  being  set  up  in  place  of  the 
old  and  that  the  promised  freedom  for  the  arts  is  to  be  only 
in  the  name.     It  is  of  course  true  that  the  reliance  on  classical 
models,  which  came  into  fashion  with  the  Revival  of  Learning, 
was  destined  in  future  times  to  lie  like  an  incubus  on  the  arts, 
and  to  give  an  occasion  for  many  famous  revolts ;    but  these 
times  were  not  yet,  and  with  Alberti  the  appeal  to  antiquity 
i&Jittle  more  Jiian..a„iasliion_of-s,peech..    At  other  epochs,  when 
men   have   suddenly   broken   loose   from    some   old-established 
authoritative  system,  they  have  turned  to  the  classical  world 
for  the  support  which  its  sane  and  rationally  based  intellectual 
and  political  systems  seemed  to  offer.     It  was  so  at  the  time 
of  the  French  Revolution,  and  so  it  was  earlier  when  the  men 
of  the  fifteenth  century  were  passing  out  from  under  the  shadow 
of  mediaeval  authority.     Alberti  seems  to  find  satisfaction  in 
the  thought  of  the  existence  of  unquestionable  models  of  pev- 


12  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

fection  in  those  classical  masters  whose  names  were  current 
in  humanistic  circles,  but  he  makes  but  little  practical  use 
of  them.  It  is  remarkable  indeed  how  little  direct  influence 
in  the  essentials  of  art  was  exercised  over  the  Italian  painting 
and  sculpture  of  the  fifteenth  century  by  the  models  of  the 
past.  Classical  subjects  come  in  by  the  side  of  the  more 
familiar  religious  themes,  and  accessories  in  pictures  are  drawn 
largely  from  antique  remains,  but  the  influence  does  not  pene- 
trate very  deep.  How  little  there  is  that  is  classical  in  the 
spirit  and  even  the  form  of  the  art  of  Donatello  !  How  closely 
we  have  to  scan  the  work  or  the  utterances  of  Leonardo  to 
find  a  trace  of  the  study  of  Roman  or  Hellenic  antiquity  ! 

With  Alberti,  as  with  the  humanists  in  art  in  general,  the 
watchword  was  '  Nature. '  As  if  with  direct  reference  to  what 
Cennini  had  said  about  adhering  to  a  chosen  master,  Alberti 
in  the  third  book  of  his  Delia  Pittura,  derides  those  who  follow 
their  predecessors  so  closely  as  to  copy  all  their  errors. 
Equally  at  fault  are  those  who  work  out  of  their  own  head 
without  proper  models  before  them.  The  real  mistress  is 
nature.  Now  ever  since  the  beginning  of  the  Italian  revival 
the  study  of  nature  had  been  set  before  the  artist,  and  Cennini 
bids  the  craftsman  never  to  pass  a  day  without  making  some 
drawing  from  a  natural  object.  The  study  of  nature  however, 
with  Alberti  and  the  masters  of  the  Early  Renaissance,  meant 
something  more.  The  outward  aspect  of  things  was  to  be 
narrowly  observed,  and  he  instances  the  effect  of  wind  on  the 
drapery  of  figures,  but  underneath  this  outward  aspect  the 
artist  was  to  explore  the  inner  structure  upon  which  the 
external  appearance  depends.  The  nude  figure  must  be  under- 
stood under  the  drapery,  the  skeleton  and  muscular  system 
beneath  the  integument.  Then  nature  as  a  whole,  that  is  to 
say,  figures  and  objects  in  their  mutual  relations,  must  be 
investigated,  and  this  on  a  basis  of  mathematical  science. 
Alberti  has  a  passion  for  geometry,  and  begins  his  treatise 
with  a  study  from  this  point.  oX  view  of  visible  surfaces^  The 
relation  of  the  eye  to  visual  objects,  and  especially  the  changes 
which  .these  are  seen  to  undergo  in  their  sizes  and  relations 
according  as  the  eye  is  moved,  lead  on  to  the  study  of  per- 
spective,  on   which   science,    as   is   well   known,    depended   so 


THE   IDEALS   OF   HUMANISM  13 

much  of  the  advance  in  painting  in  the  fifteenth  century. 
Everything  in  a  picture  is  to  be  studied  from  actual  persons 
or  objects.  It  will  add  life  and  actuality  to  a  historical  com- 
position if  some  of  the  heads  are  copied  from  living  people 
who  are  generally  known,  but  at  the  same  time  a  common 
sort  of  realism  is  to  be  avoided,  for  the  aim  of  the  artist 
should  not  be  mere  truth  to  nature  but  beauty  and  dignity. 

It  is  in  his  conception  of  the  artist's  character  and  life  that 
Alberti  is  least  mediaeval.     Here,  in  the  third  book  of  Delia 
Pittura,  we  see  emerging  for  the  first  time  the  familiar  modern 
figure  of  the  artist,  who,  as  scholar  and  gentleman,  holds  a  place 
apart  from  and  above  the  artizan.    The  same  conception  inspires 
the  interesting  chapter,  the  tenth  in  the  ninth  book,  of  Alberti 's 
more  important  treatise  De  Re  Aedijicatoria,  where  he  draws 
out   the   character   of  the   ideal  architect,   who   should  be   '  a. 
man  of  fine  genius,  of  a  great.aBPlication,  of  the  best  education, 
of  thorough  exp^r^enqe  and  especially  of_spund  sense  and  firm 
judgement. '     The  Renaissance  artist  was  indeed  to  fulfil  the 
idea  of  a  perfectible  human  nature,   the  conception  of  which  * 
is  the  best  gift  of  humanism  to  the  modern  world.     As  sketched  • 
in  Delia  Pittura,  he  was  to  be  learned  in  all  the  liberal  arts,  / 
familiar  with  the  creations  of  the  p>oets,  accustomed  to  converses 
with   rhetoricians,    '  a_man_  an_d__a_..g;ood_jnaji   and__yersed.„_in  1 
all  good   pursuits.'     He  was   to  attract  the  admiring  regard! 
of  his  fellows  by  his  character  and  bearing,  and  to  be  marked! 
among  all  for  grace  and  courtesy,  for  '  it  is  the  aim  and  end  I 
of  the  painter  to  seek  to  win  for  himself  through  his  works  \ 
praise  and  favour  and  good-will,   rather  than   riches.'     Such  "^ 
a   one,    labouring  with   all   diligence   and   penetration   on   the 
study  of  nature   and   of   science,   would   win  his  way   to  the 
mastery  possessed  by  the  ancient  painters,  and  would  secure 
to  himself  that  fame  so  dear  to  the  Italian  heart ! 

Tn  t>iP  hiinHrpH  ypgrc  that  ;n|f i-^rf.peH  hp.twpp.n  the.  ILfe.cniirsfS 

of-Alberti-aiid  of  Vasari.  the  Renaissance  artist,  whom  Jhe 
former,^scribes  m  the  making;^,  had  become  a  finished  product, 
and  the  practice  of  the   arts  was   a  matter  of  easy  routine. 

Tfee-<wJis±k„paiMaas.at.ssdu£h4Ji&.men  .0 

hjad-Jabgured  so  earnestly  were  solved ;  the  materials__  had 
become  plastic  to  the  crattsfnarT's"  will*:   TBejForms  df  nature 


14  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

were  known  so  well  that  they  ceased  to  excite  the  curiosity 
which  had  set  Leonardo's  keenly  sensitive  nature  on  edge: 
At  the  time  Vasari  wrote,,  witl^  the..ejLcepiMaamaL^th£',  JiZenql^ans 
aad^jaLMohdaagslD^-AlLjtilg,  men  of  genius  who  had  created 
the   art   Q,f, fj^. ^(^ij,a.issajtae^had,,.pa.<tspri.  .aHaay^^jjirl. .  the,  hqay 

'  workers  whose,  multitudinous  operations  he  watched  and 
chronicled  were,  like  himself,  only  epigoni — successors  of  the 
great.  We  have  only  to  read  Vasari 's  eulogy  of  Michel- 
angelo^s  frescoes  on  the  vault  of  the  Sistine,  in  his  Life  of 
that  master,  to  see  how  far  the  tone  of  the  age  in  regard  to  ■ 
art  had  changed  from  the  time  when  Alberti  was  exhorting 
the  student  to  work  out  his  own  artistic  salvation  with  fear 
and  trembling.     '  No  one,'  exclaims  Vasari.  '  who  is  a  painter 

_cares.  now  any  more  to  look  out  for  novelty  in  invpntmng  nr 
attitudes  or  drapery,,,  for  aew-  piQdes -of.«.fi«ipcessi0a^aBd»4or 
sublimity  in  „§^ajfe£..  varied  ^fiet§.jlt-a«t;  seeing  that  all  the 
per^qption  which  it  is  possible  to  give  in  work  done  in  this 
fashion  has  been  imparted  to  these  figures  by  Michelang-elo. ' 
The  cultivation  of  the  MJcJlsIiaog^lss«[ue,  instead  of  the  severe 
and  patient  study  of  nature,  that  Lfeonardo  had  called  '  the 
mistress  of  all  masters,'  marks  the  spirit  of  the  Florentine  and 
Roman  schools  after  the  middle  of  the  sixteenth  century,  and 
Vasari 's  own  works  in  fresco  and  oil,  hastily  executed  and 
on  a  vast  scale,  but  devoid  alike  of  originality  and  of  charm, 
are  the  most  effective  exponents  of  the  ideas  of  his  time  and 
school.  At  this  epoch  the-.actis.t,..bimself  was.,  no.  lanQ.ikr.^\if 
domjaanit^figure-  in  ~the^.worId  of  arj,,  nor  was  his  struggle  for 
self-perfection  in  the  forefront  of  interest  for  the  spectator. 
The,  stap-e  was  rathpr  TOmr"a"'le.d--b-y-thp  patrnn,  thp  pnpp 
Leo,  thff  nuke  Cosimo  or  the_.Cajdi.nal  Fftrrifsp  nf  ttip  ^a^, 
at  whoS£-hLdding-  the„.axtIst-mus4-.i:un_j3JJjajai:-anr|  tytfhi-r^  anrf 
leave  one  task  for  another,  till  a  delicate  nature  like  Raphael's 
or  Perino  del  Vaga's  fails  under  the  strain,  and  the  sublime 
genius  of  Michelangelo  is  thwarted  in  its  free  expression. 
With  the  exception  of  the  Venetians,  most  of  the  more 
accomplished  Italian  masters  of  the  period  were  at  work  on 
commissions  set  them  by  these  wealthy  patrons,  who  lorded 
it  over  their  kind  and  made  the  arts  subservient  to  their 
temporal   glory.     For   such   Vasari   himself   was   always   con- 


VASARIi  AS  ARTIST  15 

tentedly  busy  on  buildings  or  frescoes  or  pageants,  and  for 
work  of  the  kind  demanded  nature  had  exactly  equipped  him. 
He  was  evidently  embarrassed  neither  by  ideals  nor  by  nerves, 
but  was  essentially  business-like.  Galluzzi  in  his  History  of  the 
Grand  Dukes  says  of  him  that  '  to  the  qualities  of  his  profession 
he  united  a  certain  sagacity  and  alertness  of  spirit  which 
gave  to  Duke  Cosimo  considerable  pleasure  from  his  company. ' 
He  was  distinguished  above  his  fellows  for  the  characteristic, 
not  too  common  among  artists,  of  always  working  to  time. 
He  might  scamp  his  work,  but  he  would  by  one  method  or 
another  get  it  finished  in  accordance  with  his  contract.  His 
powers  of  application  must  have  been  of  a  high  order,  for  we 
should  remember  that  his  literary  output  was  by  no  means 
inconsiderable,  and  with  his  busy  life  the  wonder  is  not  that 
he  wrote  rather  carelessly  but  that  he  was  able  to  do  any 
serious  literary  work  at  all. 

A  favourable  specimen  of  Vasari's  decorative  painting  is 
the  fresco  in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio  at  Florence,  given  on 
Plate  I.  It  represents  Leo  X  surrounded  by  his  Cardinals,  and 
introduces  portraits  of  famous  men  of  the  day.  For  instance, 
on  the  left  above  the  balustrade  in  the  upper  part  of  the  fresco 
against  the  opening,  will  be  observed  four  heads  of  personages 
outside  the  conclave.  That  on  the  right  is  of  Leonardo  da 
Vinci  and  the  one  on  the  left  Michelangelo's,  while  the  two 
men  with  covered  heads  who  intervene  are  Giuliano  de'  Medici, 
Due  de  Nemours,  and  his  nephew  Lorenzo  de'  Medici,  Duca 
d'  Urbino,  the  originals  of  Michelangelo's  world-famous  statues 
on  the  Medici  tombs,  that  are  of  course  treated  in  a  wholly 
ideal  fashion.  It  will  be  observed  that  among  the  foreground 
figures  the  heads  of  the  second  from  the  left  and  the  second 
from  the  right  are  rendered  with  much  more  force  and  character 
than  the  rest.  They  are  of  Cardinal  Giulio  de'  Medici  after- 
wards Clement  VII,  and  Cardinal  de'  Rossi,  and  Vasari  has 
saved  himself  trouble  by  boldly  annexing  them,  and  with  them 
the  bust  of  the  Pope,  from  Raphael's  Portrait  of  Leo  X,  of 
which,  as  he  tells  us  elsewhere,  he  had  at  one  time  made  a 
copy. 

It  has  been  well  said  of  him  by  the  continuators  of  his 
autobiography  that  '  to  our  Giorgio  nature  was  very  bountiful 


i6  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

in  her  gifts;  study  and  good  will  had  largely  improved  his 
natural  disposition,  hntjjip  taste  nf  the  times,  and  the  artistic 
education  he  received,  corrupted  the  gifts  of  nature^  anid  the 
^r,"iL.£Lilig_B"^^^'"kA.  .gtudJiSS. '  Vasari  was  not  an  inspired 
artist,  and  he  had  neither  the  informing  mind  of  a  master 
nor  the  judgement  of  a  discriminating  critic,  but  he  was,  as 
we  have  already  pointed  out,  above  all  things  a  thoroughly 
practical  craftsman  in  intimate  touch  with  all  the  manifold 
artistic  life  of  the  Italy  of  his  time.  He  possessed  moreover 
q^nnBt  gpnial  pprSQnfiMty,  .wJtb.  W.hichL.ltJg-  a  pleasureL-to  come 
into  contact,  and  his  good  temper  (which  only  fails  him  when 
he  talks  about  Gothic  art),  though  it  may  at  times  slightly 
provoke  us,  accounts  for  not  a  little  of  the  deserved  popularity 
of  his  writings.  1 

Vasari  has  nn  dni^ht  a|  jjill  al;)out  the  arts  being  in  the  most 
healtbj^-XQnditiQJL-ln  -the  best  of  all  possible  artistic  worlds, 
but  it  is"  easy  for  us  to  see  that  this  art  of  the  High  RenaTs- 
sance  was  not  of  the  ysxy.  M§LkJihsLlla&.im!^hM..^ii^t 
oCiJLaiia2§L-ia^.5Paa«a5,,«li)fi,»i^^  outward 

P^rffiCtrCTin.i.rr-iy^'^  cannot  share  the  facile  optimism  oF"^7asari 
who  will  admire  any  work,  or  any  at  least  in  his  own  school 
and  style,  in  which  there  is  initiative  and  force  and  technical 
mastery,  and  in  whose  eyes  to  paint  feigned  architecture  on 
a  stucco  fafade,  provided  it  be  deftly  done,  is  as  miich  a 
'  cosa  bellissima  '  as  to  carve  the  Marsuppini  sarcophagus  in 
S.  Croce.  We  cannot  however  withhold  our  admiration  when 
we  consider  the  copious  artistic  output  of  the  age,  the  manifold 
forms  of  aesthetic  expression,  the  easy  surrender  of  the  most 
intractable  materials  to  the  artist's  will.  As  we  read  Vasari's 
descriptions  and  recipes  the  air  all  about  us  seems  full  of  the 
noise  of  the  mason's  hammer,  the  splash  of  plaster  on  the  wall, 
the  tinkle  of  the  carver's  chisel  against  the  marble,  the  grating 
of  the  chaser's  rasp  upon  the  bronze.  We  feel  ourselves 
spectators   of   an   organized   activity   on   a   vast   scale,    where 

^  The  materials  for  our  knowledge  of  Vasari  and  his  works  are  derived  from 
his  own  Autobiography  and  his  notes  on  himself  in  the  Lives  of  other  artists, 
as  well  as  from  the  Ragionamenti  and  from  the  Letters,  printed  by  Milanesi  in 
the  eighth  volume  of  the  Sansoni  edition  of  Vasari's  writings,  or  previously 
printed  by  Gaye  in  the  third  volume  of  the  Carteggio. 


a 
E- 


So 

aft 
>o 


.S  o 
Is, 


S5 


en 

g 

3 
< 


I— I 

0 


RESUME  OF  VASARI'S  'INTRODUCTIONS'    17 

processes  are  so  well  understood  that  they  go  on  almost  of 
themselves.  In  the  present  day,  in  so  much  that  is  written 
about  art,  the  personal  or  biographical  interest  is  uppermost, 
and  the  lives  of  Italian  artists,  with  their  troubles  and  triumphs, 
absorb  so  much  attention  that  one  wonders  whether  any  is 
left  for  Italian  art.  Hence  one  of  the  chief  values  of  Vasari's 
Technical  Introduction  is  its  insistence  on  artistic  practice  in 
general,  as  distinct  from  the  doings  of  individual  artists,  and 
in  this  it  may  serve  as  a  useful  supplement  or  corrective  to  the 
biographical  writing  now  in  vogue.  In  Va^ari, .  oq  ..JfiQi^-ffTiq^^ 
there  jax^,  np^^^ttractiye  personal  legends,  like  that  of  Giotto's 
shepherding  or  Donatello's  adventure  with  the  eggs,  l^nt  -are 
learn  in  exchange  to  follow  step  by  step  the  building  and 
plastering  ..and  painting  of  Giotto's  chapel  at  Padua,  and  can 
watch  Donatello's  helpers  as  they  anxiously  adjust;  the  mould 
and  core__for^ casting  riie  statue jofjGgJJam^i^i- 


It  may  assist  the  reader  if  there  be  here  subjoined  a  succinct 
resum6  of  the  subjects  treated  by  Vasari  in  the  three  '  Intro- 
ductions. ' 

The  first  of  these,  on  Architecture,  opens  with  a  long  chapter 
on  stones  used  in  building  and  decoration,  which  is  important 
as  the  fullest  notice  of  the  subject  that  has  come  down  to  us 
from  the  Renaissance  period.  Into  his  somewhat  loose  dis- 
quisitions on  porphyry,  marbles,  travertine,  and  other  materials, 
Vasari  introduces  so  many  incidental  notices  of  monuments 
and  personages  of  interest,  that  a  somewhat  extended  com- 
mentary has  in  this  part  been  necessary.  Next  follows  the 
inevitable  chapter  on  the  five  Orders,  at  the  close  of  which 
comes  the  notable  passage  in  which  Vasari  adopts  for  late 
mediaeval  architecture  the  term  '  Gothic  '  that  has  ever  since 
adhered  to  it.  With  Vasari  the  word  '  Gothic  '  means  '  bar- 
barian,' and  he  holds  that  the  style  was  invented  by  the  Goths, 
after  they  had  conquered  the  Romans  and  destroyed  all  the 
good  antique  structures.  His  description  of  what  he  terms 
the  '  abominations  '  of  slender  shafts  and  niches  and  corbels 
and  finials  and  doors  that  touch  the  roof  is  quite  spirited,  and 
might  be  learned  by  heart  as  a  lesson  in  humility  by  some  of 
our  mediaeval  enthusiasts.     On  the  question  whether  Vasari 

B 


i8  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

was  the  first  to  use  the  term  '  Gothic  '  in  this  sense  a  word 
will  be  said  in  the  Note  on  the  passage  in  Vasari's  text. 

Next  come  chapters  on  the  architectural  use  of  enriched 
plaster;  on  the  rustic  fountains  and  grottoes,  the  taste  for 
which  was  coming  in  in  Vasari's  time,  and  which  at  a  later 
period  generated  the  so-called  '  rocaille  '  or  '  rococo  '  style  in 
ornamentation  ;  and  on  mosaic  pavements.  This  '  Introduction  ' 
ends  with  a  chapter  on  an  interesting  subject  to  which  it 
does  not  quite  do  justice,  the  subject  of  ideal  architecture, 
on  which  in  that  and  the  succeeding  age  a  good  deal  was 
written. 

Though  Sculpture  was  not  Vasari's  mitier  his  account  of 
the  processes  of  that  art  is  full  and  practical,  though  we  miss 
the  personal  note  that  runs  through  the  descriptions  of  the 
same  procedure  in  the  Trattato  of  Cellini.  After  an  intro- 
ductory chapter  we  have  one  on  the  technique  of  sculpture 
in  marble,  with  an  account  first  of  the  small,  and  then  of  the 
full-sized,  model  in  clay  or  wax,  the  mechanical  transfer  of 
the  general  form  of  this  to  the  marble  block,  and  the  com- 
pletion of  the  statue  by  the  use  of  tools  and  processes  which 
he  describes.  Chapter  three  introduces  the  subject  of  reliefs, 
and  there  is  here  of  course  a  good  deal  about  the  picturesque 
reliefs  in  which  perspective  effects  are  sought,  that  Ghiberti 
and  Donatello  had  brought  into  vogue.  The  account  of  bronze 
casting  in  chapter  four  is  one  of  the  most  interesting  in  the 
whole  treatise,  and  the  descriptions  are  in  the  main  clear  and 
consistent.  Illustrations  have  been  introduced  here  from  the 
article  on  the  subject  in  the  French  Encyclopddie  of  the 
eighteenth  century,  where  is  an  account  of  the  processes  used 
in  1699  for  casting  in  one  piece  Girardon's  colossal  equestrian 
statue  of  Louis  XIV  for  the  Place  Vendome  in  Paris.  A 
chapter  on  die-sinking  for  medals  is  followed  by  one  on 
modelled  plaster  work,  for  this  material  is  dealt  with  in  all 
the  three  sections  of  the  Introduction;  while  sculpture  in  wood 
forms  the  subject  of  the  concluding  chapter,  in  which  there 
is  a  curious  notice  of  an  otherwise  unknown-  French  artist, 
who  executed  at  Florence  a  statue  of  S.  Rocco  which  may 
still  be  seen  in  the  church  of  the  Annunziata.  In  various 
places  of  this  '  Introduction  '  to  Sculpture  questions  of  general 


THE  'INTRODUCTION'  TO  PAINTING         19 

aesthetic  interest  are  brought  forward,  and  some  of  these  are 
discussed  in  the  commentary  at  its  close. 

Of  the  three  '  Introductions  '  that  on  Painting  is  the  longest 
and  deals  with  the  greatest  variety  of  topics.  After  a  pre- 
liminary chapter  in  which  Vasari  shows  that  he  regards  the 
art  with  the  eyes  of  a  Florentine  frescoist,  he  gives  a  practical 
account  of  different  methods  of  executing  drawings  and 
cartoons,  and  of  transferring  the  lines  of  the  cartoon  to  the 
fresh  plaster  of  the  wall,  on  which  the  fresco  painter  is  to 
work.  A  chapter  on  colouring  in  mural  pictures  leads  on  to 
the  account  of  the  fresco  process.  As  Vasari  was  in  this  an 
expert,  his  description  and  appreciation  of  the  process  form 
one  of  the  most  valuable  parts  of  the  treatise.  He  is 
enthusiastic  in  his  praise  of  the  method,  which  he  calls  the 
most  masterly  and  most  beautiful  of  all,  on  account  of  its 
directness  and  rapidity.  Tempera  painting  on  panel  or  on 
dry  plaster  is  next  discussed,  and  then  follows  a  notice  of 
oil  painting  on  panel  or  canvas.  The  statement  here  made 
by  Vasari  that  oil  painting  was  invented  by  van  Eyck  is  the 
earliest  enunciation  of  a  dogma  that  has  given  rise  in  recent 
times  to  a  large  amount  of  controversial  writing.  He  goes 
on  next  to  treat  of  the  right  method  of  mural  painting  in  the 
oil  medium,  and  in  this  last  connection  Vasari  gives  us  the 
recipe  he  had  finally  adopted  after  years  of  experiment,  and 
employed  for  preparing  walls  for  the  application  of  oil  paint 
in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio  at  Florence.  The  use  of  oil  paint  on 
a  ground  of  slate  or  other  kinds  of  stone  furnishes  matter  for 
another  chapter. 

With  chapter  eleven  begins  what  we  may  regard  as  a  second 
division  of  this  '  Introduction,'  in  which  various  processes  of 
the  decorative  arts  are  grouped  together  under  the  head  of 
Painting,  on  the  ground  of  the  pictorial  eifects  produced  by 
their  means.  Decorative  painting,  in  the  usual  sense,  is  first 
described  as  executed  in  monochrome  for  permanence  on  the 
fa9ades  of  buildings,  or  for  temporary  purposes  on  triumphal 
arches  and  similar  structures ;  and  then  follows  a  chapter  on 
what  is  known  as  '  Sgraffito  '  work,  or  decoration  in  plaster 
of  two  colours,  especially  valuable  as  the  first  statement  of 
the  method  and  aim  of  this  process,  which  had  been  evolved 


20  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

from  p&te-sur-pdte  pottery  not  long  before  Vasari's  time. 
•  Grotesques  '  in  modelled  and  stamped  plaster  are  next 
described,  and  the  uses  of  colour  in  various  ways  in  connection 
with  them  are  noticed,  though  with  tantalizing  brevity. 
Recipes  for  gilding  follow,  and  then  with  a  treatment  of  glass 
mosaic  we  pass  on  to  a  discussion  of  eight  different  kinds  of 
decorative  work,  which  interest  Vasari  chiefly  because  of 
their  pictorial  possibilities.  Of  glass  mosaic,  while  he  gives 
very  good  advice  about  the  sort  of  design  suitable  for  it,  he 
says  that  it  must  be  so  executed  as  to  look  like  painting  and 
not  like  inlaid  work.  Some,  he  says,  are  so  clever  that  they 
make  it  resemble  fresco.  Floor  mosaics  in  coloured  marbles 
are  to  appear  exactly  like  a  flat  picture;  works  in  tarsia,  or 
wood  inlays,  are  dismissed  because  they  cannot  do  more  than 
counterfeit  painting  without  equalling  it;  stained  glass 
windows,  on  the  other  hand,  are  lauded  because  they  can  be 
carried  to  the  same  perfection  as  fine  pictures  on  panel. 
Enamel  is  noticed  because  it  is  of  the  nature  of  picture-work, 
and  even  damascening  on  metal  '  partakes  of  the  nature  both 
of  sculpture  and  of  painting.'  Lastly  wood-engraving  is  only 
described  under  the  form  of  the  Chiaroscuri,  or  shaded  prints, 
introduced  early  in  the  sixteenth  century,  though  W.  J.  Linton 
in  his  work  The  Masters  of  Wood  Engraving  regards  these  as 
merely  aping  drawings,  and  hardly  coming  under  the  engraver's 
art  at  all ! 
\  To  return  for  a  moment  in  concluding  to  a  comparison  already 
drawn,  the  contrast  is  very  significant  between  Vasari's  attitude 
towards  these  decorative  processes  and  that  of  the  mediaeval 
writer  Theophilus.  Throughout  his  treatise  Theophilus  hardly 
says  anything  about  design,  or  what  is  to  be  represented 
in  the  various  materials.  It  is  the  materials  themselves  that 
are  his  concern,  and  the  end  before  his  eyes  is  the  effect  of 
beauty  and  sumptuousness  in  colour  and  texture  that  their 
skilful  manipulation  will  secure,  '^o  Vasari  these  materials 
are  chiefly  of  importance  as  producing  something  of  the  effect 
of  painting,  and  though  he  deals  with  them  and  their  manipu- 
lation from  the  technical  point  of  view,  the  vision  of  the 
completed  result  as  a  picture  hovers  always  before  his  eyes. 
In  this  Vasari  was  only  following  in  his  theoretical  treatment 


THE  DECORATIVE  ARTS  IN  MODERN  TIMES    21 

the  actual  facts  of  artistic  development  in  his  times.  Since 
the  heginnTng-  nf  the  Rpn"^issanrp  period  all  the"  forms  nf 
inriiistrial  art  whir.h  he  Hpsr.rihes  had  been  g-radually  losing- 
the  purely  decorative  character  which  belong-ed  to  them  in 
the  mediaeval  epoch,  and  were  beinpr  hurried  along-  at  tjie 
chariot  wheels  of  the  triumphant  art  of  painting:.  This  is  one 
nf  the  two  Hanfrprs  to  which  these  forms  of  art  are  always 
subject.  The  naturalism  in  designj  which  is  encouraged  by 
the  popularity  of  the  painter's  art  on  its  representative  side, 
is  as  much  opposed  to  their  true  genius  as  is  the  modern 
svst£m.„of  mechanical  production^  .which_depriyes_them_of  the 
charm  thev  owe  to  the  touch  of  the  craftsman's  personality. 
History  brought  it  about  that  in  the  century  after  Vasari  these 
arts  were  in  a  measure  rescued  from  the  too  great  predominance 
of  the  pictorial  element,  though  they  were  subjected  at  the 
same  time  to  the  other  unfavourable  influence  just  hinted  at. 
Italy,  from  which  the  artistic  Renaissance  had  spread  to  other 
lands,  ceased  in  the  seventeenth  century  to  be  the  main  centre 
of  production  or  of  inspiration  for  the  decorative  arts,  which 
rather  found  their  home  in  Paris,  where  they  were  organized 
and  encouraged  as  part  of  the  state  system.  The  Manufacture 
des  Meuhles  de  la  Couronne,  a  creation  of  Louis  XIV 's 
minister  Colbert,  which  had  its  headquarters  at  the  Hotel 
des  Gobelins  and  the  Savonnerie,  was  a  manufactory  of 
decorative  work  of  almost  every  kind  and  in  the  most 
varied  materials.  That  this  work,  judged  on  an  aesthetic 
standard,  was  cold  and  formal,  and  wanting  in  the  breath 
of  life  which  plays  about  all  the  productions  of  the  mediaeval 
workshop,  was  an  inevitable  consequence  of  its  systema- 
tized official  character  and  of  its  environment.  The  lover 
of  art  will  take  more  real  pleasure  in  the  output  of  the 
old-fashioned  and  more  personal  English  craftsmanship  of  the 
seventeenth  and  eighteenth  centuries,  than  in  the  artistic  glories 
of  the  French  state  factories  under  the  Ancien  Rdgime.  This 
native  British  craftsmanship  was  however  struck  into  inanition 
a  century  ago  by  the  apparition  of  machinery;  and  the  result 
of   half-a-century   of   the   new   industrial   era   was    the    Great 

the  greatest  collection  qf__artistic  failures  that  the  vrorld_  has 


22  INTRODUCTORY   ESSAY 

gvf-r  hRhpjH.  In  consequence  agencies  were  then  set  on  foot, 
and  engineered  by  the  Science  and  Art  Department,  to  improve 
the  artistic  quality  of  industrial  products,  but  unfortunately 
these  were  based  on  principles  not  wholly  sound.  The 
shibboleths  '  Historic  Ornament  '  and  '  Applied  Ornament  ' 
covered  the  desponding  view  that  the  decorative  arts  were 
dead,  and  that  enrichment  must  henceforth  not  be  a  living 
thing,  the  concomitant  and  even  the  product  of  the  work  itself, 
but  a  dead  or  '  historic  '  thing,  that  might  be  procured  from 
books  or  museums  and  then  '  applied  '  as  an  afterthought  to 
whatever  was  to  be  made  a  '  work  of  art. '  The  results  of 
this  system  were  not  encouraging,  and  led  to  the  revival  of 
mediaeval  ideas,  which,  embodied  in  the  magnetic  personality 
of  William  Morris,  have  done  .much  to  effect  a  real,  though 
as  yet  not  far-reaching  artistic  revival. 

Thf    firgt    prinriplp    lifrp    is    tn    rUsrm'ragp    nnrlnp    naturalispl 

in  ornamental  desiffn-Jav-wi.thdra.win|J-  the  riernrativp,  arts  from 
the,  inflijpnf'p  nf  pfilpting,,  g|pd  attaching  them  rather  to  the  arts 
of  constructioa._under  the  beneficent  control  of  which  they  did 
so  well  in  the  middle  ages.  The  next  principle,  which  is  equally 
important,  is  to  foster  the  personal  element  in  decorative  work, 
but  at  the  same  time  to  prevent  individuality  from  becoming 
self-assertive  and  running  into  vagaries,  by  insisting  on  the 
vital  connection  of  ornament  with  material  and  technique.  For 
the  worker  to  ornament  a  thing  properly  he  must  either  have 
made  it  or  at  any  rate  be  in  intimate  touch  with  the  processes 
of  fabrication,  out  of  which  the  decorative  treatment  should 
grow.  The  fact  that  the  more  advanced  Schools  of  Art  in  our 
own  country,  such  as  that  at  Birmingham,  regard  as  essential 
parts  of  their  equipment  the  range  of  workshops  where 
technical  processes  are  explained  and  studied,  is  an  encouraging 
sign,  and  this  return  from  the  drawing-board  and  the  book 
to  the  bench  and  the  tool  gives  an  additional  practical  value 
to  the  older  treatises  on  the  technique  of  the  arts,  of  which 
^  Vasari's  Introduction  is  one. 


OF   ARCHITECTURE 


OF   ARCHITECTURE 


CHAPTER   I. 

Of  the  diflferent  kinds  of  Stone  which  are  used  by  Architects  for 
ornamental  details,  and  in  Sculpture  for  Statues ;  that  is,  Of  Porphyry, 
Serpentine,  CipoUaccio,  Breccia,  Granites,  Paragon  or  Test-stone, 
Transparent  Marbles,  White  Marbles  and  Veined  Marbles,  CipoUini, 
Saligni,  Campanini,  Travertine,  Slate,  Peperigno,  Ischia  Stone, 
Pietra  Serena  and  Pietra  Forte. 

§  I.  The  author's  object  in  the  Discussion  of 
Architecture. 

How  great  is  the  utility  of  Arciiitecture  it  does  not  fall 
to  me  to  tell,  since  the  subject  has  been  treated  at  length 
and  most  carefully  by  many  writers.  For  this  reason, 
leaving  on  one  side  the  limes,  sands,  wood,  iron  armatures, 
mode  of  preparing  the  foundations,  as  well  as  everything 
else  that  is  used  in  a  building;  disregarding  also  the 
questions  of  water  and  localities  and  sites,  already  enlarged 
on  by  Vitruvius  ^  and  by  our  own  Leon  Battista  Alberti,^ 

^Before  Vasari  published  his  Lives,  at  least  eight  editions  of  Vitruvius  had 
appeared.  The  Editio  Princeps,  '  curante  Jo.  Sulpitio  Verulano,'  is  believed  to 
have  been  issued  at  Rome  about  i486,  and  in  1496  and  1497  reprints  were  pub- 
lished at  Florence  and  at  Venice.  In  151 1  appeared  the  important  edition,  with 
emendations  and  illustrations,  by  the  famous  architect  Fra  Giocondo  of  Verona, 
and  this  was  reprinted  in  the  Giunta  edition  at  Florence  in  1513.  Other  editions 
saw  the  light  in  1522,  1523,  1543,  and  1550.  An  Italian  translation  was  published 
in  1521,  a  French  one  in  1547,  and  in  1548  one  in  German.  The  reverence  of  the 
architects  of  the  Renaissance  for  Vitruvius  was  unbounded,  and  Michelangelo  is 
said  to  have  remarked  that  if  a  man  could  draw  he  would  be  able  by  the  help  of 
Vitruvius  to  become  a  good  architect. 

"  Leon  Battista  Albert!  shares  with  Brunelleschi  the  distinction  of  representing  in 
its  highest  form  the  artistic  culture  of  the  early  age  of  Humanism.     His  principal 


26  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

I  shall  only  discuss,  for  the  use  of  our  artificers  and  for 
whoever  likes  to  know,  the  essential  qualities  of  buildings, 
and  in  what  proportions  they  should  be  put  together  and 
of  what  parts  composed  in  order  to  obtain  that  graceful 
beauty  that  is  desired.  In  short,  I  shall  collect  all  that 
seems  to  me  necessary  for  the  purpose  in  view. 

§2.  Of  the  working  of  hard  stones,  and  first  of  Porphyry. 

In  order  that  the  great  difficulty  of  working  very  hard 
and  compact  stones  may  be  clearly  understood,  we  shall 
treat  distinctly  but  briefly  of  every  variety  which  our 
workmen  handle,  and  first  of  porphyry.^  This  is  a  red 
stone,  with  minute  white  specks,  brought  into  Italy  from 
Egypt,  where  it  is  generally  believed  that  the  stone  when 
quarried  is  softer  than  it  is  after  it  has  been  exposed  to 
rain,  frost  and  sunshine;  because  all  these  influences  make 
it  harder  and  more  difficult  to  work.*  Of  this  stone 
numberless  works  are  to  be  seen,  some  of  them  shaped 
with  the  chisel,  some  sawn  into  shape,  and  some  again 

work  Di  Re  Aedificatoria,  or,  as  it  is  also  called,  De  Architedura,  was  published 
after  his  death,  in  1485.  It  is  divided,  like  the  work  of  Vitruvius,  into  ten  books, 
and  is  an  exceedingly  comprehensive  treatise  on  the  architectural  art  both  in  theory 
and  practice,  and  on  the  position  of  architecture  in  relation  to  civilization  and  to 
society  at  large.  It  is  written  in  a  noble  and  elevated  style,  and,  as  the  title 
implies,  in  I^atin.  It  was  translated  into  Italian  by  Bartoli  and  into  English  by 
J.  Leoni  (three  volumes,  folio,  1726).  Alberti  also  wrote  shorter  tracts  on 
Sculpture  and  Painting,  as  well  as  other  works  of  a  less  specially  artistic  order. 

'  See  Note  on  '  Porphyry  and  Porphyry  Quarries '  at  the  close  of  the  '  Intro- 
duction' to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  loi,  and  A  on  the  Frontispiece,  which  gives 
representations  in  colour  of  the  stones  Vasari  mentions  in  these  sections, 
omitting  those  familiarly  known. 

*  If  a  stone  be  comparatively  soft  when  quarried  and  become  harder  after 
exposure  to  the  air,  this  is  due  to  the  elimination  in  the  air  of  moisture  that  it 
held  when  in  the  earth.  In  a  dry  climate  like  that  of  Egypt  there  is  little  or  no 
moisture  for  stones  to  hold,  and  the  Egyptian  porphyry,  Mr.  W.  Brindley  reports, 
is  quite  as  hard  when  freshly  quarried  as  after  exposure.  Vasari  repeats  this 
remark  when  he  is  dealing  with  granite  in  §6,  postea,  p.  41.  He  has  derived 
it  from  Alberti,  who  in  De  Architedura,  bk.  11,  ch.  vii,  notices  perfectly 
correctly  that  the  question  is  one  of  the  comparative  amount  of  moisture  in  the 
stone. 


PORPHYRY  27 

gradually  worked  up  by  means  of  wheels  and  emery. 
There  are  many  different  examples  in  divers  places;  for 
instance,  square,  round,  and  other  pieces  smoothed  for 
pavements,  statues  for  edifices,  a  great  number  of  columns 
large  and  small,  and  fountains  with  various  masks,  all 
carved  with  the  greatest  care.  There  are  also  sarcophagi 
still  extant,  with  figures  in  low  and  half  relief,  laboriously 
wrought,  as  at  the  temple  of  Bacchus,^  outside  Rome,  by 
Sant'  Agnese,  where  is  said  to  be  the  sarcophagus  of  Santa 
Costanza,  daughter  of  the  Emperor  Constantine,  on  which 
are  carved  many  figures  of  children  with  grapes  and  vine- 
leaves,  that  testify  how  great  was  his  labour  who  worked 
them  in  a  stone  so  hard.  There  is  another  example  in 
an  urn,  near  to  the  door  known  as  the  Porta  Santa  in 
San  Giovanni  in  Laterano,  which  is  decorated  with  scenes 
containing  a  great  number  of  figures.^  There  is  also  in 
the  piazza  della  Ritonda  a  very  beautiful  urn  made  for 
sepulchral  purposes  ^  that  is  worked  with  great  care  and 

^ '  Temple  of  Bacchus '  was  the  name  given  at  the  Renaissance  to  the  memorial 
chapel  containing  the  tomb  of  Constantia,  daughter  of  Constantine  the  Great, 
on  the  Via  Nomentana  close  to  S.  Agnese,  and  now  known  as  S.  Costanza. 
The  name  was  suggested  by  the  mosaics  with  vintage  scenes  on  the  barrel  vault 
of  the  aisle,  which  are  of  great  interest  and  beauty.  In  Vasari's  time  this  still 
contained  the  porphyry  sarcophagus  where  Constantia  was  laid,  and  of  this  he 
goes  on  to  speak.  In  1 788  Pius  VI  transferred  it  to  his  new  Sala  a  Croce  Greca 
in  the  Vatican,  where  it  now  stands. 

'This  is  the  second  of  the  two  vast  cubical  porphyry  sarcophagi  in  the  Croce 
Greca,  and  it  is  believed  that  it  served  once  to  contain  the  mortal  remains 
of  Helena,  mother  of  Constantine.  It  is  much  finer  in  execution  than  the 
other,  and  exhibits  a  large  number  of  figures  in  high  relief,  though  incoherently 
composed.  The  subject  may  be  the  victories  of  Constantine.  It  was  originally  in 
the  monument  called  'Torre  Pignattara,'  the  supposed  mausoleum  of  Helena 
on  the  Via  Labicana,  and  was  transported  in  the  twelfth  century  by 
Anastatius  IV  to  the  Lateran,  whence  Pius  VI  had  it  transferred  to  the  Vatican. 
The  restoration  of  these  huge  sarcophagi  cost  an  immense  amount  in  money  and 
time.  Massi  (Museo  Pio-Clementino,  Roma,  1846,  p.  157)  states  that  the  second 
one  absorbed  the  labour  of  twenty-five  artificers,  who  worked  at  it  day  and  night 
for  the  space  of  nine  years.  Strzygowski,  Orient  oder  Rom,  igoi,  notices  the 
sarcophagi. 

'  Urns,  or,  as  the  Italians  called  them,  '  conche,'  of  porphyry,  basalt,  granite 
and  marble  existed  in  great  abundance  in  the  Roman  Thermae  where  they  were 


28  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

diligence.  It  is  of  extremely  graceful  and  beautiful  form, 
and  is  very  different  from  the  others.  In  the  house  of 
Egizio  and  of  Fabio  Sasso  ^  there  used  to  be  a  seated 
figure,  measuring  three  and  a  half  braccia,  preserved  to 
our  days  with  the  remains  of  the  other  statues  in.  the 
Casa  Farnese.^  In  the  courtyard  also  of  the  Casa  la 
Valle,^"  over  a  window,  is  a  she- wolf  most  excellently 
sculptured, ^1  and,  in  the  garden  of  the  same  house,  the 

used  for  bathing  purposes.  From  the  seventh  century  onwards  the  Christians 
adopted  these  for  sepulchral  use  and  placed  them  in  the  churches,  where  many 
of  them  are  still  to  be  seen  (Lanciani,  Storia  degli  Scavi,  Roma,  1902, 
I,  3,  and  Marangoni,  Delle  Cose  Gentilesche,  etc.,  Roma,  1744).  Hence  Vasari 
speaks  of  the  porphyry  urn  of  the  Piazza  della  Rotonda  (the  Pantheon)  as  of 
sepulchral  origin,  and  it  was  indeed  rumoured  to  have  held  the  ashes  of  Agrippa, 
and  to  have  stood  once  on  the  apex  of  the  pediment  of  the  Pantheon  portico.  It 
was  however  an  ancient  bath  vessel,  and  was  found  when  Eugenius  IV,  1431-39, 
first  excavated  and  paved  the  piazza  in  front  of  the  Pantheon.  It  was  placed  with 
two  Egyptian  lions  in  front  of  the  portico,  where  it  may  be  seen  in  the  view  of  the 
Pjazza  della  Rotonda  in  G.  F.  Falda's  Vedute  delle  Fabbriche,  etc.,  of  1665. 
Clement  XII,  1730-40,  who  was  a  Corsini,  had  it  transported  for  his  own 
sepulchre  to  the  Corsini  chapel  in  the  Lateran,  where  it  now  stands,  with  a 
modern  cover.  Vasari  evidently  admired  this  urn,  and  he  mentions  it  again  in  the 
life  of  Antonio  Rossellino,  where  he  says  of  the  sarcophagus  of  the  monument  of 
the  Cardinal  of  Portugal  in  S.  Miniato,  '  La  cassa  tiene  il  garbo  di  quella  di 
porfido  che  e  in  Roma  sulla  piazza  della  Ritonda.'  (Opere,  ed.  Milanesi, 
HI,  95.)  See  Lanciani,  //  Pantheon,  etc.,  Prima  Relazione,  Roma,  1882, 
p.  15,  where  the  older  authorities  are  quoted.  Of  all  the  bath  vases 
of  this  kind  now  visible  in  Rome,  tjie  finest  known  to  the  writers  is  the 
urn  of  green  porphyry,  a  rare  and  beautiful  stone,  behind  the  high  altar  of 
S.  Nicola  in  Carcere.  It  is  nearly  six  ft.  long,  and  on  each  side  has  two  Medusa 
heads  in  relief  worked  in  the  same  piece,  with  the  usual  lion's  head  on  one  side 
at  the  bottom  for  egress  of  water.  The  workmanship  is  superb.  It  may  be 
noted  that  the  existing  baptismal  font  in  St.  Peter's,  in  the  first  chapel  on  the 
left  on  entering,  is  the  cover  of  the  porphyry  sarcophagus  of  Hadrian  turned 
upside  down.     It  measures  13  ft.  in  length  by  6  ft.  in  width. 

*  In  chapter  vi  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  93,  Vasari  writes 
of  the  'casadi  Messer  Egidio  et  Fabio  Sasso'  as  being  'in  Parione.'  See  Note 
at  the  end  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Architecture  on  '  The  Sassi,  della  Valle,  and 
other  Collections  of  Antiques  of  the  early  part  of  the  sixteenth  century,'  postea, 
p.  102  f. 

"  This  is  the  '  Apollo '  at  Naples,  No.  6281.     See  Note  as  above. 

'"^  See  Note  above  mentioned. 

"  Now  lost. 


PORPHYRY  29 

two  prisoners  bound,  each  four  braccia  in  lieight,^^ 
executed  in  this  same  porphyry  by  the  ancients  with 
extraordinary  skill.  These  works  are  lavishly  praised 
to-day  by  all  skilled  persons,  knowing,  as  they  do,  the 
difficulty  the  workers  had  in  executing  them  owing  to 
the  hardness  of  the  stone. 

In  our  day  stone  of  this  sort  is  never  wrought  to  perfec- 
tion,^^  because  our  artificers  have  lost  the  art  of  tempering 
the  chisels  and  other  instruments  for  working  them.  It  is 
true  that  they  can  still,  with  the  help  of  emery,  saw  drums 
of  columns  into  slices,  and  cut  other  pieces  to  be  arranged 
in  patterns  for  floors,  and  make  various  other  ornaments 
for  buildings.  The  porphyry  is  reduced  little  by  little  by 
means  of  a  copper  saw,  without  teeth,  drawn  backwards 
and  forwards  between  two  men,  which,  with  the  aid  of 
emery  reduced  to  powder,  and  kept  constantly  wet  with 
water,  finally  cuts  its  way  through  the  stone. 1*  Although 
at  different  times  many  ingenious  attempts  have  been  made 
to  find  out  the  method  of  working  porphyry  used  by  the 
ancients,^^   all    have    been    in    vain,    and    Leon    Battista 

'^  Now  in  the  Boboli  Gardens  at  Florence.  See  Note  on  the  Sassi,  etc. ,  Collections. 

'^  See  Note  on  '  The  Revival  of  Sculpture  in  Porphyry,'  postea,  p.  1 10  f. 

^*  Reciprocating  saws  of  the  kind  Vasari  mentions,  mostly  of  soft  steel  or  iron, 
and  also  circular  saws,  are  in  use  at  the  present  day,  the  abiasives  being  emery,  or 
a  new  material  called  '  carborundum. '  This  consists  in  minute  crystals  of  intense 
hardness  gained  by  fusing  by  an  electric  current  a  mixture  of  clay  and  similar 
substances.     See  The  Times,  Engineering  Supplement,  Oct.  31,  1906. 

^'  It  needs  hardly  to  be  said  that  the  ancients  had  no  '  secrets '  such  as  Vasari 
hints  at.  Mr.  W.  Brindley  believes  that  the  antique  methods  of  quarrying  and 
working  hard  stones  were  '  precisely  the  same  as  our  own  were  until  a  few  years 
ago,'  that  is  to  say  that  the  blocks  were  detached  from  the  quarry  and  split  with 
metal  wedges,  dressed  roughly  to  shape  with  large  and  small  picks,  and  '  rubbed 
down  with  flat  stone  rubbers  and  sand,  then  polished  with  bronze  or  copper 
rubbers  with  emery  powder'  [Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  1888,  p.  25).  At  a  very 
early  date  in  Egyptian  history,  even  before  the  dynastic  period,  the  hardest  stones 
(not  excepting  porphyry)  were  successfully  manipulated,  and  vases  and  bowls  of 
these  materials  cut  with  exquisite  precision.  Professor  Flinders  Petrie  found 
evidence  that  at  the  epoch  of  the  great  pyramids  tubular  drills  and  bronze  saws 
set  with  gem-stones  (corundum)  were  employed  by  the  Egyptians  in  hollowing 
basalt  sarcophagi  and  cutting  the  harder  stones  [The  Pyramids  and  Temples  of 
Ghizeh,  London,  1883,  p.  173  f.).    There  is  however  no  evidence  of  the  use  of  these 


30  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

Alberti,  the  first  to  make  experiments  therein  not  how- 
ever in  things  of  great-  moment,  did  not  find,  among  the 
many  tempering-baths  that  he  put  to  the  test,  any  that 
answered  better  than  goats'  blood;  because,  though  in 
the  working  it  removed  but  little  of  that  hardest  of  stones 
and  was  always  striking  sparks  of  fire,  it  served  him 
nevertheless  so  far  as  to  enable  him  to  have  carved,  in 
the  threshold  of  the  principal  door  of  Santa  Maria  Novella 
in  Florence,  the  eighteen  antique  letters,  very  large  and 
well  proportioned,  which  are  seen  on  the  front  of  the  step, 
in  a  piece  of  porphyry.  These  letters  form  the  words 
Bernardo  Oricellario.^''  And  because  the  edge  of  the 
chisel  did   not  suit  for  squaring  the  corners,   or  giving 

advanced  appliances  by  the  Greeks  or  Romans.  It  must  not  be  forgotten  that 
even  before  the  age  of  metals  the  neolithic  artificers  of  western  Europe  could  not 
only  cut  and  bore,  but  also  ornament  with  patterns,  stone  hammer-heads  of  the 
most  intractable  materials,  with  the  aid  only  of  pieces  of  wood  twirled  or  rubbed 
on  the  place  and  plentifully  fed  with  sand  and  water.  The  stone  axe-  and  hammer- 
heads so  common  in  pre-historic  collections  were  bored  with  tubular  drills,  made 
probably  from  reeds,  which  cut  out  a  solid  core.  Such  cores  can  still  be  seen  in 
partly-pierced  hammer-heads  in  the  Museum  at  Stockholm,  and  elsewhere. 

'^  Fig.  I  shows  the  inscription  of  which  Vasari  writes  and  the  situation  of  it  on 
the  riser  of  the  step  is  seen  on  Plate  II.  The  porphyry  slab  is  3  ft.  5  in.  long  and 
5j  in.  high.  The  tongues  at  the  ends  are  in  separate  pieces.  The  letters, 
nineteen  not  eighteen  in  number,  are  close  upon  2  in.  in  height  and  are  cleanly 
cut  with  V-shaped  incisions.  The  illustration  shows  the  form  of  the  letters  which 
Vasari  justly  praises.  The  name  '  Oricellario '  or  -us  was  derived  by  the  dis- 
tinguished Florentine  family  that  bore  it  from  the  plant  Oricello,  orchil,  which 
was  employed  for  making  a  beautiful  purple  dye,  from  the  importation  of  which 
from  the  Levant  the  family  gained  wealth  and  importance.  The  shortened 
popular  form  of  the  name  '  Rucellai '  is  that  by  which  the  family  is  familiarly 
known.  Giovanni  Rucellai  gave  a  commission  to  Alberti  to  complete  the  fafade 
of  S.  Maria  Novella,  which  was  carried  out  by  1470.  The  Bernardo  Rucellai  of 
the  inscription,  the  son  of  Giovanni,  was  known  as  a  historian,  and  owned  the 
gardens  where  the  Platonic  Academy  had  at  one  time  its  place  of  meeting. 
Fineschi,  in  his  Forestiero  htruito  in  S.  Maria  Novella,  Firenze,  1790,  says  that 
Bernardo  desired  to  be  buried  in  front  of  the  church  and  had  the  inscription  cut 
for  sepulchral  purposes.  The  existence  of  sepulchral  '  aj^ '  of  distinguished 
Florentine  families  at  the  front  of  the  church  makes  this  seem  likely,  and  in  this 
case  the  lettering  would  be  after  Alberti's  time,  though  as  Fineschi  believes,  the 
earliest  existing  work  of  the  kind  in  hard  stone  at  Florence.  See  Rev.  J.  Wood 
Brown,  6'.  Maria  Novella,  Edinburgh,  1902,  p.  114. 


PORPHYRY  31 

the  necessary  polish  and  finish,  he  had  a  little  revolving 
drill  made,  with  a  handle  like  a  spit,  which  was  easily 
worked  by  placing  the  said  handle  against  the  chest,  and 
putting  the  hands  into  the  crank  in  order  to  turn  it.^^  At 
the  working  end,  instead  of  a  chisel  or  bit,  he  fixed  copper 
discs,  larger  or  smaller  according  to  need,  and  these,  well 
sprinkled  with  emery,  gradually  reduced  and  smoothed 
the  stone,  producing  a  fine  surface  and  finishing  the 
corners,  the  drill  all  the  while  being  dexterously  twirled 
by  the  hand.  But  all  this  effort  cost  so  much  time,  that 
Leon  Battista  lost  heart,  and  did  not  put  his  hand  to 
anything  else,  either  in  the  way  of  statues,  or  vases,  or 
other  delicate  work.  Others,  afterwards,  who  set  them- 
selves to  smoothing  stones  and  restoring  columns  by  the 


same  special  process,  have  done  it  in  this  way.  They 
make  for  the  purpose  large  and  heavy  hammers,  with  the 
points  of  steel,  keenly  tempered  with  goats'  blood,  and 
worked  in  the  manner  of  diamond  points ;  with  these  they 
carefully  tap  on  the  porphyry,  and  '  scabbling '  it,  or 
working  it  down,  little  by  little  the  best  way  they  can, 
finally  reduce  it,  with  much  time  and  trouble,  to  the  round 
or  the  flat,  as  the  workman  chooses, — not  however  to 
the  form  of  statues,  because  of  this  we  have  lost  the 
art — and  they  polish  it  with  emery  and  leather,  scouring 
it  till  there  comes  a  lustre  very  clear  and  well  finished. 

Now  although  every  day  refinements  are  being  made 
on  human  inventions,  and  new  things  enquired  into,  yet 
even  the  moderns,  who  from  time  to  time  have  tried 
fresh  methods  of  carving  porphyry,  various  tempering- 
baths,  and  very  carefully  refined  steels,  have,  as  was  said 
above,   up  till   recent  years  laboured  in   vain.     Thus  in 

"After  the  fashion  of  an  ordinary  carpenter's  '  brace.' 


32  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

the  year  1553  Pope  Julius  III,  having  been  presented  by 
Signer  Ascanio  Colonna  ^^  with  a  very  handsome  antique 
porphyry  basin,  measuring  seven  braccia  across,  ordered 
it  to  be  restored,  for  some  pieces  were  missing,  that  it 
might  adorn  his  vineyard :  the  work  was  undertaken, 
and  many  things  tried  by  the  advice  of  Michelagnolo 
Buonarroti  and  of  other  excellent  masters,  but  after  a 
great  length  of  time  the  enterprise  was  despaired  of,  chiefly 
because  it  was  found  impossible  to  preserve  some  of  the 
arrises,  a  matter  essential  to  the  undertaking :  Michel- 
agnolo, moreover,  even  though  accustomed  to  the  hardness 
of  stones,  gave  up  the  attempt,  as  did  all  the  others,  and 
nothing  more  was  done. 

At  last,  since  no  other  thing  in  our  days  was  lacking 
to  the  perfection  of  our  arts,  except  the  method  of 
satisfactorily  working  porphyry,  that  not  even  this  should 
still  be  to  seek,  it  was  rediscovered  in  the  following 
manner.  In  the  year  1555,  Duke  Cosimo,  wishing 
to  erect  a  fountain  of  remarkable  beauty  in  the  court 
of  his  principal  palace  in  Florence,  had  excellent 
water  led  there  from  the  Pitti  Palace  and  Garden,  and 
ordered  a  basin  with  its  pedestal  to  be  made  for  the  said 
fountain  from  some  large  pieces  of  porphyry  found  among 
broken  fragments.  To  make  the  working  of  it  more  easy 
to  the  master,  he  caused  an  extract  to  be  distilled,  from 
an  herb,  the  name  of  which  is  unknown  to  me,  and  this 
extract  had  such  virtue,  that  red-hot  tools  when  plunged 
into  it  acquired  the  hardest  possible  temper.  With  the 
aid  of  this  process  then,  Francesco  del  Tadda,  the  carver 
of  Fiesole,^^  executed  after  my  design  the  basin  of  the 
said  fountain,  which  is  two  and  a  half  braccia  in 
diameter,^"  together  with  its  pedestal,  just  as  it  may  be 

''See  Note  on  'The  Porphyry  Tazza  of  the  Sala  Rotonda  of  the  Vatican,'  at  the 
close  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  io8. 

"See  Note  at  the  end  of  the  '  Introduction'  to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  liof., 
on  '  Francesco  del  Tadda  and,  the  Revival  of  Sculpture  in  Porphyry.' 

^^  About  4  ft.  9  in.  In  a  letter  of  May  1557  in  Gaye,  Carteggio,  11,  419,  Vasari 
mentions  the  work  as  nearly  finished. 


Tlatf,  II 


PRINCIPAL  DOORWAY  AT  S.   MARIA  NOVELLA,   FLORENCE 
Showing  the  position  of  the  inscribed  porphj-ry  tablet  on  the  riser  oi  the  step 


PORPHYRY  33 

seen  to-day  in  the  above-named  palace.^^  Tadda,  judging 
that  the  secret  imparted  to  him  by  the  duke  was  very 
precious,  set  himself  to  put  it  to  the  test  by  carving  some- 
thing, and  he  has  succeeded  so  well  that  in  a  short  time 
he  has  made,  in  three  ovals,  life-size  portraits  in  half-relief 
of  Duke  Cosimo  and  of  the  duchess  Leonora,  and  a  head 
of  Christ,  executed  so  perfectly  that  the  hair  and  beard, 
most  difficult  to  reproduce  in  carving,  are  finished  in  a 
manner  equal  to  that  of  the  ancients.  The  Duke  was 
talking  one  day  of  these  works  with  Michelagnolo-^^  when 
his  Excellency  was  in  Rome,  and  Buonarroti  would  not 
believe  in  them ;  therefore,  by  the  Duke's  order,  I  sent 
the  head  of  Christ  to  Rome  where  it  was  seen  by 
Michelagnolo  with  great  wonder,  who  praised  it  highly 
and  rejoiced  greatly  to  see  the  sculpture  of  our  time 
enriched  by  this  rare  gift,  which  until  our  day  had  been 
searched  for  in  vain.  Tadda  has  rece^ntly  finished  the 
head  of  the  elder  Cosimo  de'  Medici  ^3  in  an  oval,  like 
those  mentioned  above,  and  he  has  executed  and  continues 
to  execute  many  other  similar  works.  " 

All  that  remains  to  be  said  of  porphyry  is  that,  because 
the  quarries  are  now  lost  to  knowledge,^*  it  is  necessary 
to  make  use  of  what  is  left  of  it  in  the  form  of  ancient 
fragments,  drums  of  columns  and  other  pieces;   and  that 

"^  The  palace  in  question  is  the  well-known  Palazzo  Vecchio  at  Florence,  which 
was  adapted  for  the  Grand-ducal  residence  largely  by  Vasari  himself  under  the 
Grand  Dukes  Cosimo  and  his  successor  Francesco.  The  fountain  is  the  one  at 
present  in  the  courtyard  of  the  palace,  carrying  the  beautiful  bronze  figure  of  a  boy 
with  a.  dolphin,  by  Verrocchio.  This  'putto'  was  brought  in  from  the  famous 
Medicean  Villa  at  Careggi,  the  seat  of  the  Platonic  Academy,  for  the  purpose  of 
completing  the  fountain  of  which  Vasari  here  gives  an  account.  The  porphyry 
work,  both  in  design  and  execution,  is  worthy  of  the  beautiful  bronze  that  surmounts 
it.  The  basin  rests  on  a  well-turned  dwarf  pillar  of  porphyry  and  this  on  a  square 
base  of  the  same  material.  The  surfaces  are  true  and  the  arrises  sharp,  and  the 
whole  is  carried  out  in  a  workmanlike  manner,  and  by  no  means  betrays  a 
'  prentice  hand.' 

^  See  Vasari's  Life  of  Michelangelo,  Qpere,  ed.  Milanesi,  vii,  260. 

^That  is  Cosimo  'Pater  Patriae,'  who  died  at  Careggi  in  1464.  The  portrait 
in  question  is  shown  on  Plate  III.  For  what  is  known  about  this  and  other 
works  by  Francesco  del  Tadda,  see  postea,  p.  113  f. 

"See  Note  on  '  Porphyry  and  Porphyry  Quarries,'  postea,  p.   loi. 

C 


34  .  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

in  consequence  he  who  works  in  porphyry  must  ascertain 
whether  or  not  it  has  been  subjected  to  the  action  of  fire, 
because  if  it  have,  although  it  does  not  completely  lose 
its  colour,  nor  crumble  away,  it  lacks  much  of  its  natural 
vividness  and  never  takes  so  good  a  polish  as  when  it 
has  not  been  so  subjected;  and,  what  is  worse,  it  easily 
fractures  in  the  working.  It  is  also  worth  knowing,  as 
regards  the  nature  of  porphyry,  that,  if  put  into  the 
furnace,  it  does  not  burn  away  (non  si  cuoce),^^  nor  allow 
other  stones  round  it  to  be  thoroughly  burnt;  indeed,  as 
to  itself,  it  grows  raw  (incrudelisce)  as  is  shown  in  the 
two  columns  the  men  of  Pisa  gave  to  the  Florentines 
in  the  year  1117  after  the  acquisition  of  Majorca.  These 
columns  now  stand  at  the  principal  door  of  the  church 
of  San  Giovanni ;  they  are  colourless  and  not  very  well 
polished  in  consequence  of  having  passed  through  fire, 
as  Giovanni  Villani  relates  in  his  history .^^ 

^^  This  remark  is  evidently  derived  by  Vasari  from  Leon  Battista  Albert!,  who 
writes  as  follows  in  De  Re  Aedificatoria,  Lib.  11,  'At  nos  de  porphirite  lapide 
compertum  habemus  non  modo  flammis  non  excoqui,  verum  et  contigua  quaeque 
circumhereant  saxa  intra  fornacem  reddere  ut  ignibus  ne  quidquam  satis  exquo- 
quantiir.'  The  sense  of  'excoqui'  in  this  passage,  and  of  Vasari's  'cuocer,'  is 
somewhat  obscure,  but  can  be  interpreted  by  reference  to  old  writings  on  stones, 
in  which  great  importance  is  given  to  their  comparative  power  of  resistance  to 
fire.  See  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xxxvi,  22,  etc.,  etc.  Theophrastus,  Ilepi  AWui',  §4, 
has  the  following :  '  Stones  have  many  special  properties  ...  for  some  are  con- 
sumed by  fire  and  others  resist  it  .  .  .  and  in  respect  of  the  action  of  the 
fire  and  the  burning  they  show  many  differences  ..."  The  '  excoqui '  of  Alberti 
probably  refers  to  the  resistance  of  porphyry  to  the  fire  as  compared  with  the 
submission  to  it  of  stones  like  limestone,  which  are  '  burnt  out '  or  calcined  by  the 
heat.  Vasari's  '  non  si  cuoce '  is  net  an  adequate  translation  of  Alberti's  word 
'excoqui.'  With  a  blast  heat  porphyry  fuses  to  a  sort  of  obsidian  or  slag,  but 
a  moderate  heat  only  causes  it  to  lose  its  fine  purple  hue  and  become  grey.  This 
is  the  '  rawness '  implied  in  Vasari's  word  '  incrudelisce.'  To  us  rawness  suggests 
raw  meat  which  is  redder  in  colour  than  cooked,  but  the  Italians,  who  are  not 
great  meat  eaters,  would  have  in  their  minds  the  action  of  fire  on  cakes  and 
similar  comestibles  that  darken  when  baked,  and  an  Italian  artist  would  think  too 
of  the  action  of  fire  on  clay,  '  che  viene  rossa  quando  ella  ^  cotta '  as  he  says 
in  chapter  xxv  of  the  'Introduction'  to  Painting.  See  Frontispiece,  where  Al, 
compared  with  A,  shows  the  e6fect  of  fire  on  the  stone . 

^The  two  porphyry  columns,  that  stand  one  on  each  side  of  Ghiberti's  Old 
Testament  gates  at  the  eastern  door  of  the  Baptistry  of  Florence,  serve  to  point 


Plate  III 


PORTRAIT  IN  PORPHYRY  OF  COS  I  MO  'PATER  PATRIAE' 
BY  FRANCESCO  DEL  TADDA 


SERPENTINE  35 

§   3.  0/  Serpentine. 

After  porphyry  we  come  to  serpentine, ^^  which  is  a 
green  stone,  rather  dark,  with  little  crosses  long  and 
yellowish  all  through  its  texture.  The  artificers  busy 
themselves  with  making  columns  and  slabs  for  pavements 
in  edifices  from  it,  in  the  same  way  as  from  porphyry. 
It  is  never  seen  carved  into  figures,  although  it  is  very 

a  moral  about  the  untrustworthiness  of  popular  sayings.  When  these  apply  to 
monuments  it  usually  happens  that  the  monument  itself  hopelessly  discredits  the 
saying.  The  porphyry  columns  in  question  are  perfectly  normal  in  colour  and 
show  no  recognizable  trace  of  the  action  of  fire.  Villani  (Chronicle,  bk.  IV,  ch.  31) 
says  of  these  columns  '  The  Pisani  sent  them  to  Florence  covered  with  scarlet 
cloth,  and  some  said  that  before  they  sent  them  they  put  them  in  the  fire  for  envy.' 
If  we  rationalize  a  little  we  can  imagine  that  the  scarlet  cloth,  the  use  of  which  by 
the  Pisans  in  connection  with  porphyry  shows  a  most  lamentable  absence  of  taste 
in  colour,  would  at  first  sight  seem  to  take  the  colour  out  of  the  porphyry  and 
make  it  look  grey  through  contrast.  Hence  may  have  arisen  the  impression  which 
gave  rise  to  the  saying.  Boccaccio,  in  his  commentary  on  the  passage  in  Dante 
(Inferno,  xv,  67),  in  which  the  '  blindness '  of  the  Florentines  is  referred  to, 
notices  this  aflfair  of  the  columns  as  one  explanation  of  this  accusation  against 
his  countrymen. 

"On  the  subject  of  serpentine  some  misapprehension  exists.  Mineralogists 
apply  the  term  to  a  soft  stone  of  a  green  hue  with  long  curling  markings  through 
it,  which  in  their  form  suggest  lacertine  creatures  and  account  for  the  name  of  the 
stone.  It  derives  its  colour  from  the  presence  of  a  large  percentage  of  manganese 
in  union  with  silica,  and  contains  twelve  or  so  per  cent,  of  water.  A  penknife 
scores  it  easily.  The  '  Verde  di  Prato,'  a  dark  stone  used  in  bands  on  Tuscan 
buildings,  of  which  there  is  question  in  a  subsequent  section,  postea,  p.  43,  is  a 
species  of  true  serpentine. 

On  the  other  hand  the  word  '  serpentine '  is  in  common  use  for  a  dark  green 
stone  of  quite  a  different  kind,  that  occurs  very  commonly  in  ancient  Roman 
tesselated  pavements,  and  it  is  this  false  serpentine  that  Vasari  has  in  view.  It  is 
very  hard  indeed,  and  a  penknife  does  not  mark  it.  Professor  Bonney  describes  it 
as  '  a  somewhat  altered  porphyritic  basalt,'  and  it  is  full  of  scattered  crystals  of  a 
paler  green  composed  of  plagioclasic  felspar.  These  crystals  average  about  the 
size  of  grains  of  maize  and  they  sometimes  cross  each  other,  thus  justifying  Vasari's 
description  of  them.  A  specimen  is  B,  on  the  Frontispiece.  This  stone  was  found 
in  Egypt,  and  it  is  probably  the  '  Augustan '  and  '  Tiberian '  stone  mentioned  by 
Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xxxvi,  7.  See  Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  1888,  p.  9.  The 
chief  quarry  of  it  however  was  in  the  Peloponnesus  to  the  south  of  Sparta, 
and  the  produce  of  this  is  called  by  Pliny,  loc.  cit.,  '  Lacedaemonium  viride.'  It 
should  be  noted  that  'Verde  Antico,'  a  green  marble  of  which  the  chief  quarries 
are  in  Thessaly,  is  distinct  from  both  the  true  and  the  false  '  serpentine.' 


36  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

often  used  for  the  bases  of  columns,  the  pedestals  ot 
tables,  and  other  works  of  a  ruder  kind.  Though  this 
sort  of  stone  is  liable  to  fracture,  and  is  harder  than 
porphyry,  it  is  sweeter  to  work  and  involves  less  labour. 
Serpentine  is  quarried  in  Egypt  and  Greece  and  the  sound 
pieces  are  not  very  large ;  consequently  no  work  of  greater 
dimensions  than  three  braccia  in  any  direction  is  ever 
seen  of  serpentine,  and  such  works  as  exist  are  slabs 
and  pieces  of  pavement,  A  few  columns  are  found  also 
but  not  very  massive  nor  thick,  as  well  as  some  masks  and 
sculptured  brackets,  but  figures  never.  This  stone  is 
worked  in  the  same  manner  as  porphyry. 

§  4.  Of  Cipollaccio. 
Softer  than  serpentine  is  cipollaccio,^^  a  stone  quarried 
in  various  places;  it  is  of  a  crude  yellowish  green  colour 
and  has  within  it  some  square  black  marks,  large  and 
small,  and  also  biggish  white  marks.  Of  this  material 
one  may  see  in  various  places  columns  both  massive  and 
slender,  as  well  as  doors  and  other  ornaments,  but  not 
figures.  There  is  a  fountain  of  this  stone  in  Rome  in  the 
Belvedere,  that  is  to  say  a  niche  in  a  corner  of  the  garden 
where  are  the  statues  of  the  Nile  and  of  the  Tiber ;  ^9  Pope 
Clement  VII  had  this  niche  made,  after  a  design  by 
Michelagnolo,^°  to  adorn  the  statue  of  a  river  god  that 

^  Cipollaccio.  It  is  not  clear  what  is  the  difference,  if  any  exist,  between  the 
stone  thus  called  and  the  '  CipoUino '  which  Vasari  discusses  in  a  later  section, 
postea,  p.  49.  The  latter  is  a  name  in  universal  employment,  but  the  term 
'Cipollaccio'  is  not  known  to  Cavaliere  Marchionni,  the  courteous  Director  of  the 
Florentine  State  Manufactory  of  Mosaics,  nor  is  it  recognized  at  Carrara.  On  the 
other  hand  it  is  given  as  the  name  of  a  marble  in  Tomaseo's  Dhionario  (though 
probably  only  on  the  strength  of  this  mention  in  Vasari)  and  a  stone  worker  at 
Settignano  claimed  to  know  and  use  the  word.  On  the  material  see  the  Note  on 
'  Cipollino,'  postea,  p.  49.  The  terminations  '-accio'  and  '-ino'  are  dear  to 
the  Florentines — Masflcno  and  tAasolino  will  occur  to  everyone. 

^  This  is  the  '  Cortile  di  Belvedere '  where  the  Laocoon  and  Apollo  Belvedere 
are  located.     See  Note  30. 

^^  On  Michelangelo's  niche  and  fountain  see  the  Note  on  '  The  Cortile  of  the 
Belvedere  in  the  Vatican  in  the  sixteenth  century,' at  the  end  of  the  'Introduction' 
to  Architecture,  postea,  p.   115.     The  '  river  god '  is  the  '  Tigris '  of  the  Vatican. 


CIPOLLACCIO;  BRECCIA  37 

it  might  look  very  beautiful  in  this  setting  made  in 
imitation  of  natural  rocks,  as  indeed  it  actually  does. 
Cipollaccio  is  also  sawn  into  panels,  round  and  oval,  and 
into  similar  pieces  which,  when  arranged  with  other  stones 
in  pavements  and  other  flat  surfaces,  make  lovely  com- 
positions. It  takes  a  polish  like  porphyry  and  serpentine 
and  is  sawn  in  the  same  manner.  Numberless  pieces  of 
it  are  found  in  Rome,  buried  under  the  ruins;  these  come 
to  light  daily  and  thus  of  ancient  things  modern  works 
are  made,  such  as  doors  and  other  ornamental  details, 
which,  wherever  placed,  are  decorative  and  very  beautiful. 

§  5.  0/  Breccia  ('  Mischio,'  Conglomerate). 
Here  is  now  another  stone,  called  '  mischio '  (breccia), ^^ 
from  the  mixture  of  various  stones  coagulated  together  and 
made  one  by  time  and  by  the  mordant  action  of  water.  It  is 
found  in  abundance  in  several  places,  as  in  the  mountains 
of  Verona,  in  those  of  Carrara,  and  of  Prato  in  Tuscany, 
and  in  the  hills  of  the  Impruneta  in  the  neighbourhood 
of  Florence.'^^  But  the  best  and  choicest  breccias  have 
been  found,  not  long  ago,  at  San  Giusto  at  Monte  Rantoli, 
five  miles  distant  from  Florence.^^  In  this  material  Duke 
^psimo  Jias_,  commissioned  me  to  decorate  all  the  new 
rooms  of  the  palace  with  doors  and  chimney  pieces,  and 

'^  Vasari's  description  of  the  variegated  stones  called  breccias  is  clear  and  good. 
Corsi,  Z)elk  Pieire  Antiche,  Roma,  1845,  p.  139,  defines  breccias  as  'marbles 
formed  of  numerous  fragments  of  other  marbles  either  of  one  colour  or  of  different 
colours,  embedded  in  a  calcareous  cement.'  The  mineralogist  distinguishes 
breccias  from  conglomerates  by  the  fact  that  in  the  former  the  fragments  embedded 
are  angular,  in  the  latter  round  like  pebbles.  The  fragments  need  not  be  of 
marble.  These  breccias  were  greatly  used  at  the  Renaissance,  as  Vasari  indicates, 
for  the  framing  of  doorways  and  for  chimney  pieces,  but  it  may  be  questioned 
whether  they  are  really  suitable  for  such  architectural  use.  For  door  jambs 
and  similar  constructive  members  a  self-coloured  stone,  with  its  greater  severity 
of  effect,  would  be  preferable.  On  the  other  hand,  for  panels  and  inlays  and 
decorative  uses  generally,  the  variegated  stones  are  quite  in  place.  See  C,  D  on 
the  Frontispiece. 

'^See  Note  on  'Tuscan  Marble  Quarries '  postea,  p.  119  f. 

'^S.  Giusto,  commonly  called  S.  Giusto  a  Monte  Martiri,  lies  by  Monte 
Rantoli,  between  the  valleys  of  the  Ema  and  Greve,  to  the  south  of  Florence. 


38  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

the  effect  is  most  beautiful.  Also  for  the  garden  of  the 
Pitti,  very  fine  columns  seven  braccia  high  have  been 
quarried  from  the  same  place,  and  I  am  astonished  that 
in  this  stone  such  large  pieces  should  be  found  free  from 
flaws.^*  Being  of  the  nature  of  limestone,  it  takes  a 
beautiful  polish  and  in  colour  inclines  to  a  reddish  purple 
streaked  with  white  and  yellowish  veins.  But  the  finest 
examples  of  all  are  in  Greece  and  Egypt,^^  where  the 
stone  is  much  harder  than  ours  in  Italy,  and  it  is  found 
in  as  many  different  colours  as  mother  nature  has  delighted 
and  still  delights  to  produce  in  all  perfection.  In  the 
breccias  formed  in  this  way  one  sees  at  Rome  at  the  present 
day  both  ancient  and  modern  works,  such  as  columns, 
vases,  fountains,  door  ornaments,  and  various  inlays  on 
buildings,  as  well  as  many  pieces  in  the  pavements. 
There  are  various  sorts,  of  many  colours;  some  draw  to 
yellow  and  red,  others  to  white  and  black,  others  again 
to  grey  and  white  speckled  with  red  and  veined  with 
numerous  colours;  then  there  are  certain  reds,  greens, 
blacks  and  whites  which  are  oriental :  and  of  this  sort 
of  stone  the  Duke  has  an^ntic[ue  urn,  four  and  a  half 
braccia  across,  in  his  garden  at  the  Pitti,  a  thing  most 
precious,  being  as  I  said  of  oriental  breccia  very  beautiful 
and  extremely  hard  to  work.^^  Such  stones  are  all  very 
hard,  and  exquisite  in  colour  and  quality,  as  is  shown  by 

^^  Breccia  columns  answering  to  this  description  are  to  be  seen  in  the  lower 
part  of  the  Boboli  Gardens  to  the  west  of  the  'island  basin'  with  John  of 
Bologna's  '  Oceanus.' 

^  The  Egyptian  breccia  is  found  at  Hamamat  to  the  east  of  Luxor.  It  consists, 
Mr.  Brindley  writes,  in  rich-coloured  silicious  fragments  cemented  together,  and 
is  very  difficult  to  work  and  to  polish,  'owing  to  the  cementing  matrix  being 
frequently  harder  than  the  boulders.'  Its  general  colour  is  greenish  and  it  is 
called  sometimes  '  Breccia  Verde. '  The  most  important  known  work  executed 
in  this  breccia  is  the  grand  sarcophagus  of  Nectanebes  I,  about  378  B.C.,  now  in 
the  British  Museum.  It  is  on  the  left  in  the  large  Hall  a  little  beyond  the 
Rosetta  stone.      Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  1888,  p.  24  ff. 

'^  Signor  Cornish,  the  courteous  castellan  of  the  Royal  Palace,  believes  this  to 
be  the  urn  that  now  serves  as  the  basin  of  the  fountain  surmounted  with  a  figure 
of  the  Arno,  near  the  Annalessa  gate  of  the  Boboli  Gardens.  It  has  two  masks 
carved  on  the  front,  as  is  common  in  antique  conche  of  the  kind. 


BRECCIA;   GRANITE  39 

the  two  columns,  twelve  braccia  high  at  the  entrance  of 
St.  Peter's  in  Rome,  which  support  the  first  arcades  of 
the  aisles,  one  on  each  side.^''  Of  this  stone,  the  kind 
which  is  found  in  the  hills  of  Verona,  is  very  much 
softer  than  the  oriental;  and  in  that  place  is  quarried  a 
sort  which  is  reddish,  and  inclines  towards  a  vetch 
colour.3^  All  these  kinds  are  worked  easily  in  our  days 
with  the  tempering-baths  and  the  tools  used  for  our  own 
local  stones,  Windows,  columns,  fountains,  pavements, 
door  posts  and  mouldings  are  made  of  them,  as  is  seen 
in  Lombardy  and  indeed  throughout  Italy. 

§  6.  0/  Granite. 

There  is  another  sort  of  extremely  hard  stone,  much 
coarser  and  speckled  with  black  and  white  and  sometimes 
with  red,  which,  on  account  of  its  grain  and  consistency, 
is  commonly  called  granite.^^  In  Egypt  it  exists  in  solid 
masses  of  immense  size  that  can  be  quarried  in  pieces 
incredibly  long,  such  as  are  seen  nowadays  in  Rome  in 
obelisks,  needles,  pyramids,  columns,  and  in  those  enor- 
mous vessels  for  baths  which  we  have  at  San  Pietro  in 
Vincola,  at  San  Salvadore  del  Lauro  and  at  San  Marco.*" 

''  On  entering  the  porch  or  narthex  of  St.  Peter's  by  the  central  archway, 
the  visitor  may  note  on  each  side  of  the  external  opening  a  column  of  breccia, 
or  strictly  speaking  of  '  pavonazzetto  brecciato,'  over  twenty-five  feet  in  height. 
They  are  worn,  patched,  and  discoloured,  and  evidently  come  from  some  earlier 
building.  It  can  be  reasonably  conjectured  that  these  are  the  two  columns  to 
which  Vasari  refers,  and  that  they  were  originally  in  the  old  basilica  which  was 
being  replaced  in  Vasari's  time  by  the  existing  structure.  Vasari  would  see  them 
in  their  original  position  forming  part  of  the  colonnade  between  nave  and  aisles, 
for  the  entrance  part  of  the  old  Constantinian  basilica  was  still  standing  in  the 
sixteenth  century,  and  the  columns  were  only  removed  to  their  present  position 
when  Paul  V  constructed  the  existing  fa9ade  at  the  beginning  of  the  century 
following. 

^  The  familiar  red  Verona  marble  is  not  a  true  breccia,  but  a  fossil  marble. 

'' '  Granite '  is  from  the  Italian  '  granito,'  which  means  the  '  grained '  stone. 

^'The  'grandissimi  vasi  de'  bagni,'  to  which  Vasari  here  refers,  are  those  vast 
granite  bath-shaped  urns,  some  twenty  feet  long,  of  which  the  best  known  is 
probably  the  specimen  that  stands  by  the  obelisk  in  the  centre  of  the  amphi- 
theatre of  the  Boboli  Gardens  at  Florence.     This,  with  a  fellow  urn,  that  stands 


40  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

It  is  also  seen  in  columns  without  number,  which  for 
hardness  and  compactness  have  had  nothing  to  fear  from 
fire  or  sword,  so  that  time  itself,  that  drives  everything 
to  ruin,  not  only  has  not  destroyed  them  but  has  not  even 
altered  their  colour.  It  was  for  this  reason  that  the 
Egyptians  made  use  of  granite  in  the  service  of  their  dead, 
writing  on  these  obelisks  in  their  strange  characters  the 
lives  of  the  great,  to  preserve  the  memory  of  their  prowess 
and  nobility. 

From  Egypt  there  used  also  to  come  another  variety 
of  grey  granite,  where  the  black  and  white  specks  draw 
rather  towards  green.  It  is  certainly  very  hard,  not  so 
hard  however,  but  that  our  stonecutters,  in  the  building 
of  St.  Peter's,  have  made  use  of  the  fragments  they  have 
found,  in  such  a  manner  that  by  means  of  the  temper  of 
the  tools  at  present  adopted,  they  have  reduced  the  columns 
and  other  pieces  to  the  desired  slenderness  and  have  given 
them  a  polish  equal  to  that  of  porphyry. 

Many  parts  of  Italy  are  enriched  with  this  grey  granite, 
but  the  largest  blocks  found  are  in  the  island  of  Elba, 
where  the  Romans  kept  men  continually  employed  in 
quarrying  countless  pieces  of  this  rock.*^     Some  of  the 

not  far  off  in  the  Piazzale  della  Meridiana,  came  from  the  Villa  Medici  at  Rome, 
and  they  may  have  been  seen  in  Rome  by  Vasari  before  they  were  placed  in  that 
collection.  No  such  urns  are  now  to  be  found  in  or  about  any  of  the  three  churches 
at  Rome  here  mentioned  by  Vasari.  Documents  however,  recently  publislied  in  the 
first  volume  of  Lanciani's  Storia  degli  Scavi,  pp.  3-5,  show  that  there  stood 
formerly  in  the  Piazza  S.  Salvatore  in  Lauro,  north  west  from  the  Piazza  Navona, 
a  '  conca  maximae  capacitatis,'  to  which  Vasari  no  doubt  refers.  Two  other  such 
conchae  were  found  in  the  Thermae  of  Agrippa,  and  one  was  placed  by  Paul  II, 
1464-71,  in  the  Piazza  di  S.  Marco,  which  was  then  called  'Piazza  della  Conca  di 
S.  Marco,'  while  the  other  was  located  by  Paul  III  (Farnese),  1534-49,  in  front 
of  his  palace.  Cardinal  Odoardo  Farnese  afterwards  united  the  two  and  formed 
with  them  the  two  fountains  now  in  the  Piazza  Farnese.  Lanciani  also  mentions 
■^  '  conca  di  bigio  in  S.  Pietro  in  Vinculis. '  There  is  a  fine  specimen,  which  may 
be  one  of  those  Vasari  has  mentioned,  in  front  of  the  little  church  of  S.  Stefano  at 
the  back  of  St.  Peter's.  We  wish  cordially  to  thank  Signor  Cornish,  of  the 
Royal  Palace,  Florence,  for  information  kindly  given  about  the  Boboli 
monuments. 

••i  The  quarries  opened  by  the  Romans  in  Elba  are  now  practically  abandoned. 


GRANITE  41 

columns  of  the  portico  of  the  Ritonda  are  made  of  it, 
and  they  are  very  beautiful  and  of  extraordinary  size.*^ 
It  is  noticed  that  the  stone  when  in  the  quarry  is  far 
softer  and  more  easy  to  work  than  after  it  has  lain 
exposed,*^  It  is  true  that  for  the  most  part  it  must  be 
worked  with  picks  that  have  a  point,  like  those  used  for 
porphyry,  and  at  the  other  end  a  sharp  edge  like  a  toothed 
chisel.**  From  a  piece  of  this  granite  which  was  detached 
from  the  mass,  Duke  Cosimo  has  hollowed  out  a  round 
basin  twelve  braccia  broad  in  every  direction  and  a  table 

The  Catalogue  to  the  Italian  Section  of  the  London  International  Exhibition  of 
1862  speaks  of  the  granites  of  Elba  as  'but  little  used,  although  blocks  and 
columns  of  almost  any  size  may  be  had.'  In  the  late  mediaeval  and  Renaissance 
period  however,  the  quarries  of  Elba  were  worked,  and  the  granite  columns  of 
the  Baptistry  of  Pisa  were  cut  there  in  the  twelfth  century,  while  Cosimo  I 
extracted  thence  the  granite  block  out  of  which  he  cut  the  tazza  of  the  Boboli 
Gardens  mentioned  by  Vasari  a  few  sentences  further  on.  Jervis,  I  Tesori 
Soiterranei  dell'  Italia,  Torino,  1889,  p.  315,  speaks  of  the  remains  of  Roman 
quarrying  works  to  be  seen  on  the  Island.  He  believes  that  the  grey  columns  of 
the  Pantheon  (see  Note  infra)  are  Elban,  and  Cellini  {Scultura,  ch.  vi)  claims 
an  Elban  origin  for  the  granite  column  of  S.  Trinita,  Florence,  which  is  certainly 
antique  and  of  Roman  provenance,  see  postea,  p.  1 10  f. 

^  The  portico  of  the  Pantheon  is  now  supported  by  sixteen  monoliths  of  granite 
nearly  40  ft.  high.  Seven  of  these  in  the  foremost  row  are  of  grey  granite,  the 
eighth  (that  at  the  north-east  angle)  and  all  those  behind  are  of  red  granite.  The 
present  portico  is  a  reconstruction  by  Hadrian  in  octostyle  form  of  the  original 
decastyle  portico  built  by  Agrippa.  Agrippa's  portico  had  columns  of  a  grey 
granite  called  'granito  del  foro,'  because  it  is  the  same  kind  that  is  used  for  the 
columns  of  the  Forum  of  Trajan  (Basilica  Ulpia).  This  according  to  Corsi, 
Delle  Pietre  Antiche,  Roma,  1845,  is  Egyptian  from  Syene,  the  Lapis  Psaronius 
of  Pliny,  and  Professor  Lanciani,  who  has  kindly  written  in  reply  to  our  question 
on  the  subject,  endorses  this  opinion,  though  Jervis,  see  above,  thinks  the  grey 
Pantheon  columns  are  Elban.  When  Hadrian  reconstructed  the  portico,  he  added 
columns  of  red  granite,  which  are  admitted  by  all  to  be  Egyptian.  The  two 
columns  at  the  east  of  the  present  portico  were  brought  in  in  the  year  1666 
to  fill  gaps  caused  by  the  fall  of  the  two  Hadrianic  ones.  They  came 
from  the  Baths  of  Nero  and  were  found  near  S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi.  See 
postea,  p.  I28f. 

*'See  Note  4,  ante,  p.  26. 

"The  form  of  the  pick  Vasari  seems  to  have  in  his  mind  is  given  in  the 
sketch,  C,  Fig.  2,  postea,  p.  48.  Among  other  tools  figured  in  the  illustration, 
A  and  B  are  some  that  are  employed  at  this  day  in  Egypt  for  the  working 
of  hard  stones. 


42  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

of  the   same   length   for   the  palace   and   garden   of   the 
Pitti.45 

§  7.  0/  Paragon  (Touchstone) A^ 

A  kind  of  black  stone,  called  paragon,  is  likewise 
quarried  in  Egypt  and  also  in  some  parts  of  Greece.  It 
is  so  named  because  it  forms  a  test  for  trying  gold;  the 
workman  rubs  the  gold  on  this  stone  and  discerns  its 
colour,  and  on  this  account,  used  as  it  is  for  comparing 
or  testing,  it  comes  to  be  named  paragon,  or  index- 
stone  (a).  Of  this  there  is  another  variety,  with  a  different 
grain  and  colour,  for  it  has,  almost  but  not  quite,  the 
tint  of  the  mulberry,  and  does  not  lend  itself  readily 
to  the  tool.  It  was  used  by  the  ancients  for  some  of  those 
sphinxes  and  other  animals  seen  in  various  places  in 
Rome,  and  for  a  figure  of  greater  size,  a  hermaphrodite 
in  Parione,*'^  alongside  of  another  most  beautiful  statue 
of  porphyry.*^  This  stone  is  hard  to  carve,  but  is  extra- 
ordinarily beautiful  and  takes  a  wonderful  polish  (b). 
The  same  sort  is  also  to  be  found  in  Tuscany,  in  the 
hills  of  Prato,  ten  miles  distant  from  Florence  (c),  and 
in  the  mountains  of  Carrara.  On  modern  tombs  many 
sarcophagi  and  repositories  for  the  dead  are  to  be  seen 
of  it ;  for  example,  in  the  principal  chapel  in  the  Carmine 
at  Florence,  where  is  the  tomb  of  Piero  Soderini  (although 

^^This  tazza  is  still  in  evidence  and  serves  as  the  basin  of  the  great  fountain 
in  the  '  island '  lake  in  the  western  part  of  the|  Boboli  Gardens.  It  is  said  that 
Duke  Cosimo  extracted  a  second  tazza  larger  than  this  one  from  the  Elban 
quarry  but  it  was  unfortunately  broken.  Signor  Cornish  says  the  fragments  are 
still  to  be  seen.  The  sculptor  Tribolo  was  sent  to  Elba  to  obtain  the  basins.  Of 
the  '  tavola '  or  table  nothing  is  known. 

^*In  this  apparently  innocent  section  Vasari  has  mixed  up  notices  of  some 
half-dozen  different  kinds  of  stone,  on  most  of  which  his  ideas  are  somewhat 
vague.  Hence  a  separate  Note  is  required,  and  this  will  be  found  at  the  end  of 
the  'Introduction'  to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  117  ('Paragon  and  other  Stones 
associated  with  it  by  Vasari').  The  letters  (a),  (b),  etc.,  are  referred  to  in  the 
Note. 

*'The  'Apollo'  at  Naples,  in  basalt,  no.  6262.     See  Note,  postea,  p.  104. 

^^  The  porphyry  '  Apollo  '  at  Naples,  no.  6281.     See  Note,  as  above. 


PARAGON;   TRANSPARENT  MARBLES       43 

he  is  not  within  it)  made  of  this  stone,  and  a  canopy  too 
of  this  same  Prato  touchstone,  so  well  finished  and  so 
lustrous  that  it  looks  like  a  piece  of  satin  rather  than  a 
cut  and  polished  stone  (d).  Thus  again,  in  the  facing 
which  covers  the  outside  of  the  church  of  Santa  Maria 
del  Fiore  in  Florence,  all  over  the  building,  there  is  a 
different  kind  of  black  marble  (e)  and  red  marble  (f),  but 
all  worked  in  the  same  manner. 

§  8.  Of  Transparent  Marbles  for  filling  window  openings. 

Some  sorts  of  marble  are  found  in  Greece  and  in  all 
parts  of  the  East,  which  are  white  and  yellowish,  and 
very  transparent.  These  were  used  by  the  ancients  for 
baths  and  hot-air  chambers  and  for  all  those  places  which 
need  protection  against  wind,  and  in  our  own  days  there 
are  still  to  be  seen  in  the  tribune  of  San  Miniato  a  Monte, 
the  abode  of  the  monks  of  Monte  Oliveto,  above  the  gates 
of  Florence,  some  windows  of  this  marble,  which  admit 
light  but  not  air.*^  By  means  of  this  invention  people 
gave  light  to  their  dwellings  and  kept  out  the  cold. 

§  9.  Of  Statuary  Marbles. 
From   the   same   quarries  ^°  were   taken   other   marbles 
free  from  veins,   but  of  the  same  colour,   out  of  which 
were  carved  the  noblest  statues.     These  marbles  were  of  a 

■"  The  five  eastern  window-openings  of  S.  Miniato  are  filled  with  slabs  of  antique 
pavonazzetto  with  red-purple  markings,  nearly  two  inches  thick  and  measur- 
ing in  surface  about  9  ft.  by  3  ft.  The  windows  are  square  headed.  The  slabs 
transmit  the  light  unequally  according  to  the  darker  or  lighter  patches  in  their 
markings,  but  the  effect  is  pleasing.  Similar  window-fillings  are  to  be  seen  at 
Orvieto.  '  Almost  any  marble,'  it  has  been  said,  'with  crystalline  statuary  ground, 
an  inch  thick,  placed  on  the  sunny  side  of  a  church  in  Italy  would  admit  sufficient 
light  for  worship,  but  it  would  not  do  in  our  variable  climate.'  The  so-called 
Onyx  marbles  of  Algeria  and  Mexico,  as  well  as  Oriental  alabasters,  are 
specially  suitable  for  the  purpose  here  in  view.  The  '  white  and  yellowish ' 
eastern  marbles  that  Vasari  writes  of  were  probably  of  this  kind. 

*"  By  '  the  same  quarries '  Vasari  means,  no  doubt,  those  of  Egypt  and  Greece, 
of  Carrara,  of  Prato,  etc. ,  mentioned  in  §  7  in  connection  with  '  paragon. '  On 
the  subject  see  the  Note  on  'Tuscan  Marble  Quarries,'  postea,  p.  iigf. 


44  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

very  fine  grain  and  consistency,  and  they  were  continually 
being  made  use  of  by  all  who  carved  capitals  and  other 
architectural  ornaments.  The  blocks  available  for  sculp- 
ture were  of  great  size  as  appears  in  the  Colossi  of 
Montecavallo  at  Rome,?i  in  the  Nile  ^^  of  the  Belvedere 
and  in  all  the  most  famous  and  noble  statues.  Apart 
from  the  question  of  the  marble,  one  can  recognize  these 
to  be  Greek  from  the  fashion  of  the  head,  the  arrangement 
of  the  hair,  and  from  the  nose,  which  from  its  juncture 

^'  The  reference  is  to  the  two  so-called  '  Horse-Tamers '  opposite  the  Quirinal 
Palace  at  Rome,  that  probably  once  stood  in  front  of  the  Thermae  of  Constantine, 
which  occupied  the  slope  of  the  Quirinal.  The  figures  of  the  youths,  perhaps 
representing  the  Dioscuri,  are  eighteen  feet  high,  and  the  material  was  long  ago 
pronounced  Thasian  marble  (see  Matz-Duhn,  Antike  Bildwerke  in  Rom,  Leipzig, 
1881,  I,  268).  The  works  are  Roman  copies  of  Greek  originals.  They  have 
recently  been  overhauled,  with  very  good  result  as  regards  their  appearance.  The 
sculptor,  Professor  Ettore  Ferrari,  who  superintended  this  work,  reports  that  the 
material  is  '  marmo  greco,'  which  may  be  held  to  settle  the  question  in  favour  of 
Greek  as  against  Luna  marble. 

^  The  '  Nile '  is  now  in  the  Braccio  Nuovo  of  the  Vatican,  the  fellow-statue, 
the  '  Tiber, '  see  ante,  p.  36,  in  the  Louvre  at  Paris.  They  are  said  to 
have  been  discovered  at  Rome  early  in  the  sixteenth  century,  near  S.  Maria 
Sopra  Minerva  where  was  the  Temple  of  Isis  and  Serapis,  and  Pope  Leo  X 
had  them  placed  in  the  Cortile  di  Belvedere  of  the  Vatican.  They  were 
removed  to  Paris  in  'the  year  X'  by  Napoleon,  and  in  1815  the  'Nile' 
was  sent  back  to  Rome,  the  '  Tiber '  remaining  in  the  Louvre.  The 
'  Nile '  is  much  the  better  work  of  art  and  is  a  copy  or  a  study  from  an 
Alexandrian  original,  perhaps  the  'Nilus'  in  basalt,  which,  according  to  Pliny, 
Hist.  Nat.,  XXXVI,  7,  Augustus  dedicated  in  the  Temple  of  Peace.  Amelung,  in 
his  Sculpturen  des  Vaticanischen  Museums,  only  states  that  the  '  Nile '  is  in 
'  grobkornigem  Marmor.'  The  material  of  the  statue  certainly  differs  from  that  of 
the  restored  parts,  and  we  should  guess  it  as  Pentelic  marble  repaired  with  Carrara. 
About  the  '  Tiber,'  Froener,  in  the  Louvre  Catalogue,  states  that  it  is  of  Pentelic 
marble,  and  it  is  so  labelled.  Our  measurements  show  that  both  statues  required 
blocks  of  the  dimensions  10  ft.  by  5  ft.  by  5  ft.  in  height.  It  may  be  noted  that 
the  finest  statuary  marble  known,  that  of  the  island  of  Paros,  is  not  to  be  obtained 
in  very  large  blocks.  That  out  of  which  the  Hermes  of  Praxiteles  has  been  carved 
must  have  measured  about  8  ft.  by  5  ft.  by  3  ft.  6  in.  and  is  considered  an 
exceptionally  fine  block.  Pentelic  and  Carrara  marble  can  be  obtained  in  much 
larger  pieces.  We  saw  not  long  ago  in  the  modern  quarries  behind  Mount 
Pentelicus  a  block  nearly  20  ft.  in  cube.  One  seventeen  feet  long  has  recently 
been  cut  in  the  Monte  Altissimo  quarries  in  the  Carrara  mountains  for  a  copy  of 
the  '  David '  of  Michelangelo.  A  piece  of  Monte  Altissimo  marble  of  the  best 
quality  is  shown  as  J  on  the  Frontispiece. 


STATUARY  MARBLES  45 

with  the  eyebrows  down  to  the  nostril  is  somewhat 
square.^3  jhis  marble  is  worked  with  ordinary  tools  and 
with  drills,  and  is  polished  with  pumice-stone,  with  chalk 
from  Tripoli,  and  with  leather  and  wisps  of  straw. 

In  the  mountains  of  Carrara  in  the  Carfagnana,^*  near 
to  the  heights  of  Luni,  there  are  many  varieties  of  marble, 
some  black, ^^  some  verging  towards  grey,  some  mingled 
with  red  and  others  again  with  grey  veins.^^  These  form 
an  outer  crust  over  the  white  marbles,  and  they  take  those 
colours,  because  they  are  not  refined,  but  rather  are  smitten 
by  time,  water  and  the  soil.  Again,  there  are  other  sorts 
of  marble,  called  '  cipollini,'^^  '  saligni,'  '  campanini  '  and 
'  mischiati.'^^  The  most  abundant  kind  is  pure  white  and 
milky  in  tone;  it  is  easy  to  work  and  quite  perfect  for 
carving  into  figures.  Enormous  blocks  lie  there  ready 
to  be  quarried,  and  in  our  own  days,  pieces  measuring 
nine  braccia  have  been  hewn  out  for  colossal  statues. 
Two  of  these  colossi  have  recently  been  sculptured,  each 
from  a  single  block.  The  one  is  Michelagnolo's  '  David,' 
which  is  at  the  entrance  of  the  Ducal  Palace  in  Florence ;  "^ 

^'  This  remark  shows  a  just  observation  on  the  part  of  Vasari.  The  Greek  nose 
is  markedly  different  from  the  Florentine.  The  latter,  as  may  be  seen  in  the  '  St. 
George '  of  Donatello,  or  the  '  David '  of  Michelangelo,  has  more  shape  than 
the  classical  nose.  There  is  more  difference  marked  betvv'een  the  nasal  bone  and 
the  cartilaginous  prolongation  towards  the  tip,  and  there  is  more  modelling  about 
the  nostril,  which  the  Italian  sculptors  make  thinner  and  more  sensitive. 

"  The  Carfagnana,  or  more  properly  Garfagnana,  is  the  name  applied  to  the  upper 
part  of  the  valley  of  the  Serchio,  between  the  Apennines  and  the  Apuan  Alps,  on 
the  western  slopes  of  which  the  marble  quarries  are  situated.  See  Note  on  '  Tuscan 
Marble  Quarries,'  postea,  p.  iigf.,  for  the  different  marbles  and  their  provenance. 

°*  Benvenuto  Cellini,  Scultura,  ch.  iv,  mentions  this  black  marble  from  Carrara, 
which  he  says  is  very  hard  and  brittle  and  difficult  to  work.  Black  marble  is  still 
quarried  in  the  Carrara  district,  but  only  to  a  small  extent. 

°^The  grey  marble  is  that  known  now  as  'Bardiglio';  the  grey-veined 
'  Marmo-'  or  'Bardiglio-'  'fiorito';  the  red,  'Breccia.' 

^'  For  '  Cipollino '  see  footnote  70  on  p.  49,  postea. 

°'The  'Mischiati'  are  the  variegated  stones  we  know  as  'Breccias,'  already 
noticed  in  §  5.  Vasari  explains  the  names  '  Saligni '  and  '  Campanini '  in  §  10. 
The  terms  are  not  now  in  use. 

™  The  '  David '  stood  formerly  on  the  left  hand  side  as  one  entered  the  gateway 
of  the  Ducal  Palace,  or  Palazzo  Vecchio.     It  is  15  feet  high.     In  1873  it  was 


46  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

the  other  is  the  '  Hercules  and  Cacus  '  from  the  hand  of 
Bandinello  standing  at  the  other  side  of  the  same  entrance. 
Another  block  of  nine  braccia  in  length  was  taken  out 
of  the  quarry  a  few  years  ago,  in  order  that  the  same 
Baccio  Bandinello  should  carve  a  figure  of  Neptune  for 
the  fountain  which  the  Duke  is  having  erected  on  the 
piazza.  But,  Bandinello  being  dead,  it  has  since  been 
given  to  Ammannato,  an  excellent  sculptor,  for  him  like- 
wise to  carve  a  Neptune  out  of  it.^°  But  of^all  these 
marbles,  that  of  the  quarry  named  Polvaccio,^^  in  the 
place  of  that  name,  has  the  fewest  blemishes  and  veins 
and  is  free  from  those  knots  and  nuts  which  very  often 
occur  in  an  extended  surface  of  marble — occasioning  no 
little  difficulty  to  the  worker,  and  spoiling  the  statues 
even  when  they  are  finished.  From  the  quarries  of 
Seravezza,  near  to  Pietrasanta,  there  have  been  taken  out 
a  set  of  columns,  all  of  the  same  height,  destined  for  the 
fagade  of  San  Lorenzo  at  Florence,  which  is  now  sketched 
out  in  front  of  the  door  of  that  church ;  '^^    one  of  these 

removed,  and  is  now  in  the  Academy,  but  Bandinello's  group  still  holds  its 
original  position  to  the  right  of  the  entrance,  on  the  side  towards  the  Uffizi. 

^  The  existing  figure  of  Neptune  is  the  work  of  Ammanati,  to  whom  Florence 
owes  the  stately  Ponte  S.  Trinita.  The  subsidiary  figures  of  sea-deities  on  the 
fountain  are  by  other  hands. 

^^See  Note,  postea,  p.  iigf. 

'^On  the  subject  of  the  Seravezza  quarries  and  their  exploitation  by  Michel- 
angelo see  Note,  as  above.  With  regard  to  the  Fayade  of  S.  Lorenzo  much  might 
be  said,  as  the  project  for  its  completion  has  now  again  come  forward  into 
prominence.  See  articles  by  Sig.  B.  Supino  in  VArte,  Anno  IV,  fasc.  7,  and  M. 
Marcel  Reymond  in  the  /ievue  Archiologique  for  1906.  It  is  well  known  that 
Brunelleschi,  who  reconstructed  the  basilica  in  the  fifteenth  century,  left  the 
fa9ade  incomplete  and  with  no  indication  of  his  design  for  it.  As  it  was  the 
church  of  the  Medici,  the  popes  of  this  family,  Leo  X  and  Clement  VII,  furthered 
by  means  of  a  competition  a  grand  project  for  its  completion ;  and  in  this  work 
Michelangelo  was  for  many  years  involved.  Drawings  of  his  for  the  proposed 
fa9ade  are  to  be  seen  in  the  Casa  Buonarroti,  and  he  prepared  marbles,  as  noticed 
in  the  Note,  postea,  p.  iigf.,  but  the  preparations  proved  abortive. 

What  Vasari  says  about  Michelangelo's  fajade  that  it  '  e  oggi  abbozzata  fuor 
della  porta  di  detta  chiesa,'  and  that  there  is  one  column  on  the  spot,  is  interesting 
but  not  very  easy  to  understand.  Milanesi,  in  a  note  on  this  passage  in  his  edition 
of  Vasari,  I,  119,  going  one  better  than  the  Lemonnier  editors,  gives  a  circum- 


STATUARY   MARBLES  47 

columns  is  to  be  seen  there,  the  rest  remain,  some  in  the 
quarry,  some  at  the  seashore. 

But  returning  to  the— quarries  of  Pietrasanta,^^  I  say 
that  they  were  the  quarries  in  which  all  the  ancients 
worked,  and  no  other  marbles  but  these  were  used  for 
their  statues  by  those  masters,  who  were  so  excellent. 
While  the  masses  were  being  hewn  out,  they  were  always 
at  work,  blocking  out  figures  in  the  rough  on  the  stones 
while  they  were  still  in  the  quarry.  The  remains  of  many 
of  these  can  be  seen  even  yet  in  that  place.®*  This  same 
marble,  then,  the  moderns  of  to-day  use  for  their  statues, 
not  only  in  Italy,  but  in  France,  England,  Spain  and 
Portugal,  as  can  be  seen  to-day  in  the  tomb  executed  in 
Naples  by  Giovan  da  Nola,  the  excellent  sculptor,  for 
Don  Pietro  di  Toledo,  viceroy  of  that  kingdom,  to  whom 
all  the  marbles  were  presented,  and  sent  to  Naples  by 
Duke  Cosimo  de'  Medici.®^  This  kind  of  marble  has  in 
itself  larger  available  pieces  and  is  more  yielding  and 
softer  to  work  and  receives  a  finer  polish  than  any  other 
marble.  It  is  true  that  occasionally  the  workman  meets 
with  flaws  called  by  the  sculptors  '  smerigli  '  (emery  veins) 

stantial  account  to  the  effect  that  '  The  preliminary  worlc  (abbozzata)  which  was 
outside  the  church  in  the  days  of  Vasari,  was  buried  in  the  first  years  of  the 
seventeenth  century,  along  with  other  architectural  fragments,  in  a  trench  excavated 
on  the  piazza  along  the  left  side  of  the  church.'  Unfortunately  among  the 
authorities  at  S.  Lorenzo  this  statement  is  smiled  at  as  a  mere  popular  legend, 
but  it  is  hoped  that  in  connection  with  the  long-delayed  completion,  which  is 
now  again  on  the  tapis,  the  truth  on  this  matter  will  come  to  light. 

"'.Milanesi  remarks,  ad  loc,  that  for  '  Pietrasanta '  Vasari  should  have  written 
'Carrara,'  as  the  quarries  at  the  latter  place  were  actually  exploited  by  the 
ancients,  whereas  the  Pietrasanta  workings  were  only  opened  up  in  the  time  of 
Michelangelo.  See  postea,  p.  122.  The  Pietrasanta  people  however  do  claim 
that  the  Romans  were  at  work  among  their  hills. 

"There  are  abundant  instances  both  from  Greek  and  from  Roman  times  of 
statues,  heads,  architectural  members,  columns,  and  the  like,  blocked  out  in  the 
quarries,  and  still  lying  unfinished  as  they  were  left  many  hundreds  of  years  ago. 

"'Vasari  gives  a  notice  of  Giovanni  da  Nola,  whose  surname  was  Merliano, 
in  the  Lives  of  Alfonso  Lombardi  and  other  sculptors.  See  Opere,  ed.  Milanesi, 
V,  94  f.  He  there  describes  the  tomb  mentioned  above,  which  was  to  have  been 
transported  to  Spain,  but  owing  to  the  death  of  the  viceroy,  Don  Pietro,  Marquis 
of  Villafranca,  it  has  remained  in  8.  Giacomo  at  Naples. 


48 


OF  ARCHITECTURE 


which  usually  cause  the  tools  to  break.  The  blocks  are 
first  roughed  into  shape,  by  a  tool  called  '  subbia ' 
(point)  6^  which  is  pointed  like  a  stake  in  facets,  and  is 
heavier  or  lighter  as  the  case  may  be.  At  the  next  stage 
are  used  chisels,   named  '  calcagnuoli  '  (toothed  chisels), 


7"~■'^J^^l,lll|.^■l^.^^^.^V|^\,\w^■rt'^^^v^.^s^>v^^■^^>'^|l^lVlW■>^^>.^^,^',>'^'■|^■.'|'''^■■^H';,^/j;^^      ./,  r 


Fig.  2. — Tools  mentioned  by  Vasari,  etc. 
Aj  B,  Models  of  Tools  used  in  Egypt  at  the  present  day  for  working  hard  stones. 

C,  The  pick  referred  to  by  Vasari,  p.  41. 

D,  A  burin  or  graver. 

E-J.  Tools  in  actual  use  in  a  stone-cutter's  yard  at  Settignano : 

E,  Subbia,  a  point.  H,  Scarpello,  a  chisel. 

F,  Calcagnuolo,  a  toothed  chisel.^  J,  Trapano,  a  drill. 

G,  Gradina,  a  broader  toothed  chisel. 

which  have  a  notch  in  the  middle  of  the  edge  of  the  blade; 
after  that  finer  and  finer  tools  with  more  teeth  are  used 
to  score  the  marble,  after  which  it  is  smoothed  with  another 
chisel  called  *  gradina,'  (broader  toothed  chisel)  used  to 
reduce  and  refine  the  figures.  The  tooth-marks  left  in  the 
marble  are  removed  with  iron  rasps  straight  and  curved, 

^^  Some  of  the  tools  of  sculptors  and  masons  referred  to  by  Vasari  are  shown 
in  Fig.  2,  E — ^J,  above. 


STATUARY   MARBLES;    CIPOLLINO  49 

and  thus  at  last,  by  polishing  gradually  with  pumice-stone 
the  surface  aimed  at  is  attained.  Iiji  order  not  to  fracture  the 
marble,  all  the  drill-holes  are  made  with  drills  of  different 
sizes  weighing  from  twelve  pounds  each  even  to  twenty, 
according  to  the  size  of  the  hole  needed,®^  and  they  serve 
to  finish  every  sort  of  work  and  to  bring  it  to  perfection. 
Of  certain  white  marbles,  streaked  with  grey,®^  sculptors 
and  architects  make  ornaments  for  doors  and  columns 
for  houses  and  the  same  are  used  also  for  pavements  and 
for  facings  of  large  buildings,  and  for  all  sorts  of  things. 
All  the  marbles  called  '  mischiati  '  ®^  are  used  for  the  same 
purposes. 

§   ID.  Of  Cipollino  Marble.'"^ 

The   cipoUini    marbles   are   another   kind,    different    in 

grain    and    colour,    and    found    in    other    places    besides 

Carrara.     Most  of  them  are  greenish,  and  full  of  veins; 

they  are  useful  for  various  things,   but  not  for  figures. 

"A  worker  in  stones  at  Settignano  knew  of  drills  of  the  weight  of  about 
twelve  pounds  each,  and  thought  twenty  pounds  conceivable,  for  very  large  work. 

""  Vasari  seems  to  refer  to  the  common  greyish  marble  popularly  called  'Sicilian.' 
There  are  finer  kinds  of  veined  marble  called  'fioriti,'  'flowered,'  including 
'  marmi  fioriti '  and  '  bardigli  fioriti,'  the  last  in  two  shades  of  grey. 

''i.e.,  the  breccias  noticed  in  §  5. 

™  '  Cipollino '  marble,  a  very  familiar  material,  receives  its  name  from  '  cipolla ' 
an  onion,  but  there  is  a  curious  divergence  of  opinion  as  to  the  reason  of  the 
appellation,  (i)  The  onion  colour  the  marble  shows  in  many  specimens;  (2) 
the  onion-like  shape  of  the  large  bossy  markings  which  occur  in  the  marble ; 
(3)  the  fact  that  it  is  disposed  to  scale  away  under  the  influence  of  the  weather 
like  the  coats  of  an  onion ;  and  (4)  the  concentric  curves  in  which  the  edges  of 
these  coats  are  seen  to  lie  in  a  section  across  the  grain,  have  all  been  adduced 
as  explanatory  of  the  name.  Herrmann  in  his  Steinbruchindustrie,  Berlin,  1899, 
p.  68,  pronounces  for  the  third,  and  this  is  also  the  opinion  of  Corsi,  who  says, 
Pietre  Antiche,  p.  97,  '  gli  scarpellini  lo  conoscono  sotto  il  nome  di  cipollino, 
per  la  ragione  che,  trovandosi  fra  la  sostanza  calcare  di  tel  marmo  lunghi  e  spessi 
strati  di  mica,  facilmente  su  tali  strati  si  divide  a  somiglianza  della  cipolla.'  Zirkel 
however,  in  his  Lehrbuch  der  Petrographie,  Leipzig,  1894,  III,  452,  pronounces 
for  the  fourth,  which  seems  on  the  whole  the  one  to  be  preferred.  There  are  two 
cipollino  columns  standing  in  the  Roman  Forum  a  little  to  the  east  of  the  temple 
of  Antoninus  and  Faustina,  famous  for  its  monoliths  of  this  same  marble,  that  in 
the  concentric  wavy  lines  marking  the  alternate  layers  in  the  stone  remind  us 
curiously  of  an  onion  cut  in  half.     See  for  a  specimen  H  on  the  Frontispiece. 

D 


so  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

Those  which  the  sculptors  call  '  saligni,' ''^  because  they 
are  partly  transparent,  and  have  that  lustrous  appearance 
seen  in  salt,  have  something  of  the  nature  of  stalagmite, 
and  are  troublesome  enough  to  make  figures  of;  because 
the  grain  of  the  stone  is  rough  and  coarse,  or  because 
in  damp  weather  water  drops  from  it  continually  or  else 
it  sweats.  The  '  campanini '  marbles  are  so  named 
because  they  sound  like  a  bell  under  the  hammer  and 
give  out  a  sharper  note  than  other  marbles  .^^  These  are 
hard  and  crack  more  easily  than  the  kinds  above  men- 
tioned. They  are  quarried  at  Pietrasanta.^^  Again  at 
Seravezza  ''*  in  many  places  and  at  Campiglia  ''^  there 
are  marbles  excavated,  which  are  for  the  most  part 
excellent  for  ashlar  work  and  even  fairly  good  sometimes 
for  statues. 

§    II.  Of  White  Pisan  Marble. 

A  kind  of  white  marble,  akin  to  limestone,  is  found 
likewise  at  Monte  San  Giuliano  near  Pisa.''^  It  has  been 
used  for  covering  the  outside  walls  of  the  Duomo  and 
the  Camposanto  of  Pisa,  as  well  as  for  many  other  orna- 
ments to  be  seen  in  that  city.  Formerly  the  said  marbles 
were  brought  to  Pisa  from  the  hill  at  San  Giuliano  with 
trouble  and  expense,  but  now  it  is  different,  because  Duke 
Cosimo,  in  order  to  make  the  district  more  healthy  and 
also  to  facilitate  the  carriage  of  the  marbles  and  other 
stones  taken  from  those  mountains,  has  turned  into  a 
straight  canal  the  river  Osoli  and  many  other  streams, 
which  used  to  rise  in  those  plains  and  do  damage  to  the 

'^  Vasari  explains  the  name  '  saligno '  as  '  salt-like.'  The  term  is  not  recognized 
3.t  Carrara,  nor  in  the  Florentine  manufactory  of  Mosaics. 

'"  The  term  '  campanino '  for  a  kind  of  marble  is  not  known  now  in  the  Carrara 
district. 

''  About  10  miles  south  east  of  Carrara. 
'*  Near  Pietrasanta  in  the  Apuan  Alps. 
"  On  the  promontory  of  Piombino,  opposite  Elba. 

"  In  the  so-called  Pisan  Mountains  between  Pisa  and  Lucca.  For  these  places 
and  their  quarries  see  Note  on  'Tuscan  Marble  Quarries,'  postea,  p.  iigf. 


PISAN   MARBLE;   TRAVERTINE  51 

country.  By  means  of  this  canal,  the  marbles,  either 
worked  or  rough,  can  be  easily  conveyed,  at  a  trifling 
cost,  and  with  the  greatest  advantage  to  the  city  which 
is  now  almost  restored  to  its  former  magnificence,  thanks 
to  the  said  Duke,  who  has  no  object  more  dear  to  him 
than  that  of  improving  and  restoring  the  city,  which  was 
falling  into  ruins,  before  His  Excellency  became  its  lord.'^^ 

§    12.  Of   Travertine. 

There  is  another  sort  of  stone  called  travertine,  which 
is  much  used  for  building  and  also  for  carvings  of  various 
sorts.  It  is  always  being  quarried  in  many  places 
throughout  Italy,  as  in  the  neighbourhood  of  Lucca,  at 
Pisa,  and  round  about  Siena;  but  the  largest  blocks  and 
the  best,  that  is,  those  which  are  most  easily  worked,  are 
taken  from  above  the  river  Teverone  at  Tivoli.'^^  The 
stone  is  all  a  kind  of  coagulation  of  earth  and  of  water, 
which  by  its  hardness  and  coldness  congeals  and  petrifies 
not  only  earth,  but  stumps  and  branches  and  leaves  of 
trees.  On  account  of  the  water  that  remains  within  the 
stones — which  never  can  be  dry  so  long  as  they  lie  under 
water — they  are  full  of  pores  which  give  them  a  spongy 
and  perforated  appearance,  both  within"  and  without. 

Of  travertine  the  ancients  constructed  their  most  won- 
derful buildings,   for  example,   the   Colosseum,   and   the 

"  See  Note,  as  above,  especially  p.  126. 

"There  are  great  quarries  of  this  stone  below  Tivoli  near  the  course  of  the 
ancient  Anio,  now  Teverone.  The  station  Bagni  on  the  Roma-Tivoli  railway  is 
close  to  them.  Those  near  the  place  called  Barco  were  exploited  by  the  ancient 
Romans,  while  Bernini  derived  the  stone  for  the  colonnades  in  front  of  St. 
Peter's  from  the  quarries  called  '  Le  Fosse,'  a  little  to  the  north  of  the  former. 
Vitruvius,  De  Arch.,  11,  vii,  2,  writes  of  the  '  Tiburtina  saxa '  as  resisting  all 
destructive  agencies  save  that  of  fire,  and  the  remark  is  repeated  by  Pliny, 
Hist.  Nat.,  XXXVI,  22.  Vasari's  account  of  its  origin  is  correct.  It  is  a  deposit 
of  lime  in  water,  and  the  cavities  in  it  are  partly  caused  by  plants,  moss,  etc., 
round  which  the  deposit  has  formed  itself  and  which  of  course  have  long  ago 
decayed  away.  See  O  on  the  Frontispiece.  The  stone  did  not  come  into 
use  at  Rome  until  about  the  last  century  of  the  Republic,  and  it  was  not,  like 
peperino,  one  of  the  old  traditional  building  materials. 


52  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

Treasury  by  the  church  of  Ss.  Cosimo  e  Damiano^^  and 
many  other  edifices.  They  used  it  without  stint  for  the 
foundations  of  their  public  buildings,  and  in  working 
these  basements,  they  were  not  too  fastidious  in  finishing 
them  carefully,  but  left  them  rough,  as  in  rustic  work; 
and  this  they  did  perhaps  because  so  treated  they  possess 
a  certain  grandeur  and  nobility  of  their  own.^"  But  in  our 
days  there  has  been  found  one  who  has  worked  travertine 
most  skilfully,  as  was  formerly  seen  in  that  round  temple, 
begun  but  never  finished,  save  only  the  basement,  on  the 
piazza  of  San  Luigi  de'  Francesi  in  Rome.^^  It  was  under- 
taken by  a  Frenchman  named  Maestro  Gian,  who  studied 
the  art  of  carving  in  Rome  and  became  so  proficient,  that 
his  work  in  the  beginning  of  this  temple  ^ould  stand 
comparison  with  the  best  things,  either  ancient  or  modern, 
ever  seen  carved  in  travertine.  He  carved  Astrological 
globes,  salamanders  in  the  fire,  royal  emblems,  devices 
of  open  books  showing  the  leaves,  and  carefully  finished 
trophies  and  masks.  These,  in  their  own  place,  bear 
witness  to  the  excellence  and  quality  of  the  stone  which, 
although  it  is  coarse,  can  be  worked  as  freely  as  marble. 
It  possesses  a  charm  of  its  own,  owing  to  the  spongy 
appearance  produced  by  the  little  cavities  which  cover 
the  surface  and  look  so  well.  This  unfinished  temple 
being  left  imperfect,  was  razed  by  the  French,  and  the 
said  stones  and  other  pieces  that  formed  part  of  its  con- 
struction were  placed  in  the  fafade  of  the  church  of  San 
Luigi  ^2  and  in  some  of  its  chapels,  where  they  are  well 
arranged,  and  produce  a  beautiful  effect. 

''Vasari  evidently  refers  to  the  remains  of  the  Templum  Sacrae  Urbis  behind 
the  present  church  of  Ss.  Cosma  e  Damiano,  to  which  was  affixed  the  ancient 
'  Capitoline '  plan  of  Rome. 

*"  See  the  remarks  on  Rusticated  masonry  in  §  20,  and  Notes,  postea,  pp.  65 
and  132. 

8^ On  the  'round  temple,'  and  its  designer,  'Maestro  Gian,'  see  Note  on  the 
subject,  postea,  p.   128  f. 

^S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi  is  the  national  church  of  the  French,  and  is  situated 
close  to  the  Palazzo  Madama,  the  meeting  place  of  the  Italian  Senate,  near  the 
Piazza  Navona.  The  present  edifice  was  built  by  Giacomo  della  Porta  and  con- 
secrated in  1589.     See  Note,  postea,  p.  128  f. 


TRAVERTINE  S3 

Travertine  is  excellent  for  walls,  because  after  it  is  built 
up  in  squared  courses  and  worked  into  mouldings,  it  can 
be  entirely  covered  with  stucco  ^^  and  thereafter  be 
impressed  with  any  designs  in  relief  that  are  desired,  just 
as  the  ancients  did  in  the  public  entrances  to  the  Colos- 
seum ^*  and  in  many  other  places ;  and  as  Antonio  da 
San  Gallo  has  done  in  the  present  day  in  the  hall  of  the 
Pope's  palace,  in  front  of  the  chapel,^^  where  he  has  faced 
the  travertine  with  stucco  bearing  many  excellent  devices. 
More  than  any  other  master  however  has  Michelagnolo 
Buonarroti  ennobled  this  stone  in  the  decoration  of  the 
court  of  the  Casa  Farnese,^^     With  marvellous  judgement 

^  For  which  it  offers  in  the  cavities  above  spoken  of  an  excellent  key. 

"  Traces  of  these  stucco  decorations  are  still  to  be  seen  in  the  public  entrance 
to  the  Colosseum  next  the  Esquiline.  They  are  said  to  have  been  taken  as 
models  by  some  of  the  plaster-workers  of  the  Renaissance.  See  Vasari's  Life 
of  Giovanni  da  Udine,  Opere,  vi,  553. 

"  This  is  the  so-called  '  Sala  Regia '  which  serves  as  a.  vestibule  to  the  Sistine 
Chapel.  Sixtus  IV  planned  it  and  San  Gallo  enlarged  it  and  began  the  adorn- 
ment of  the  vault  with  plaster  work,  which  was  carried  on  afterwards  by  Perino 
del  Vaga  and  Daniele  da  Volterra  (Pistolesi,  II  Vaticano  Descritto,  VIII,  89).  It 
is  the  most  richly  decorated  of  all  the  Vatican  apartments,  but  is  florid  and  over- 
laden. The  stucco  enrichment  of  the  roof  is  heavy,  and  the  figures  in  the  same 
material  by  Daniele  da  Volterra  that  are  sprawling  on  the  tops  of  the  doorways 
and  on  the  cornices  are  of  the  extravagant  later  Renaissance  type.  The  contrast 
between  this  showy  hall  and  the  exquisitely  treated  Appartamento  Borgia  of 
earlier  date  is  very  marked. 

*°The  Farnese  Palace  is  in  the  main  the  work  of  Antonio  da  San  Gallo,  the 
younger,  who  at  his  death  in  1546  had  carried  up  the  fa9ade  nearly  to  the  cornice 
and  completed  the  ground  story  and  half  the  second  story  of  the  cortile. 
Michelangelo  finished  the  second  or  middle  story  of  the  cortile,  as  far  as  the 
architecture  went, '  according  to  San  Gallo's  design,  and  added  the  third  story 
from  his  own.  His  are  also  the  enrichments  of  the  frieze  of  the  second  order  in 
the  cortile,  and  he  has  the  chief  credit  for  the  noble  external  cornice,  of  which 
Vasari  writes  in  this  section.  It  is  now  rather  the  fashion  to  criticize  severely 
Michelangelo's  architectural  forms,  and  G.  Clausse,  Les  San  Gallo,  Paris,  1901, 
condemns  his  third  story  of  the  cortile  and  says  of  his  frieze  (p.  85),  '  Michelange 
fit  ajouter  dans  la  frise  ces  guirlandes  et  ces  mascarons  en  stuc  qui  enlevent  i  ce 
beau  portique  le  caractere  de  grandeur  simple  et  d'harmonieuse  majesty  dfl  a  ses 
proportions  mSmes.'  It  will  not  escape  notice  that  Vasari  regards  these  orna- 
ments as  not  in  stucco  but  in  the  travertine  itself.  On  the  question  thus  raised 
Monseigneur  Duchesne,  the  distinguished  Director  of  the  French  School  at  Rome 


54  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

he  has  used  it  for  windows,  masks,  brackets,  and  many 
other  such  fancies;  all  these  are  worked  as  marble  is 
worked  and  no  other  similar  ornament  can  be  seen  to 
excel  this  in  beauty.  And  if  these  things  are  rare,  more 
wonderful  than  all  is  the  great  cornice  on  the  front  facade 
of  the  same  palace,  than  which  nothing  more  magnificent 
or  more  beautiful  can  be  sought  for.  Michelagnolo  has 
also  employed  travertine  for  certain  large  cHapels  on  the 
outside  of  the  building  of  St.  Peter's,  and  in  the  interior, 
for  the  cornice  that  runs  all  round  the  tribune ;  so  finished 
is  this  ■  cornice  that  not  one  of  the  joints  can  be  per- 
ceived, everyone  therefore  can  well  understand  with  what 
advantage  to  the  work  we  employ  this  kind  of  5tone. 
But  that  which  surpasses  every  other  marvel  is  the  con- 
struction in  this  stone  of  the  vault  of  one  of  the  three 
tribunes  in  St.  Peter's;  the  pieces  composing  it  are  joined 
in  such  a  manner  that  not  only  is  the  building  well  tied 
together  with  various  sorts  of  bonds,  but  looked  at  from 
the  ground  it  appears  made  out  of  a  single  piece. ^^ 

§   13.  Of  Slates. 

We  now  come  to  a  different  order  of  stones,  blackish 
in  colour  and  used  by  the  architects  only  for  laying  on 
roofs.  These  are  thin  flags  produced  by  nature  and  time 
near  the  surface  of  the  earth  for  the  service  of  man.     Some 

which  is  housed  in  the  Farnese,  has  had  the  kindness  in  reply  to  our  inquiry 
to  say  that  so  far  as  can  be  ascertained  without  the  use  of  scaffolding  the 
ornaments  of  the  frieze  are  in  stucco,  with  the  exception  of  the  Fleur-de-lys  which 
occur  in  the  position  of  key-stones  above  the  centre  of  each  window  arch.  These 
are  in  travertine,  as  are  the  ornaments  (trophies  of  arms  etc.)  carved  on  the 
metopes  of  the  frieze  of  the  order  of  the  ground  story  in  the  cortile.  The  point 
has  some  interest  in  connection  with  the  travertine  carvings  by  the  French  artist 
at  S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi  (see  postea,  p.  131),  and  the  suggestion  of  M.  Marcel 
Reymond  (loc.  cit.)  that  the  Italians  of  the  first  half  of  the  fifteenth  century  were 
not  accustomed,  as  the  French  were,  to  execute  decorative  carvings  in  soft  stone. 

8'  The  exterior  of  St  Peter's  is  built  of  travertine,  and  a  walk  round  it  gives  an 
opportunity  for  a  study  of  the  fine  effect  of  the  stone  when  used  on  a  vast  scale. 
The  details  of  construction  in  the  interior,  which  are  lauded  by  Vasari,  are  now 
concealed  under  the  decoration  that  covers  all  the  interior  surfaces. 


SLATES;  PEPERINO  55 

of  these  are  made  into  receptacles,  built  up  together  in 
such  a  manner  that  the  pieces  dovetail  one  into  the  other. 
The  vessels  are  filled  with  oil  according  to  their  holding 
capacity  and  they  preserve  it  most  thoroughly.  These 
slates  are  a  product  of  the  sea  coast  of  Genoa,  in  a  place 
called  Lavagna ;  ^^  th^ey  are  excavated  in  pieces  ten  braccia 
long  and  are  made  use  of  by  artists  for  their  oil  paihtings, 
because  pictures  painted  on  slate  last  much  longer  than 
on  any  other  material,  as  we  shall  discuss  more  appropri- 
ately in  the  chapters  on  painting. 


§   14.  Of  Peferinofi^ 

We  shall  also  refer  in  a  future  chapter  to  a  stone  named 
piperno  or  more  commonly  peperigno,  a  blackish  and 
spongy  stone,  resembling  travertine,  which  is  excavated 
in  the  Roman  Campagna.  It  is  used  for  the  posts  of 
windows  and  doors  in  various  places,  notably  at  Naples 
and  in  Rome;  and  it  also  serves  artists  for  painting  on 
in  oil,  as  we  shall  relate  in  the  proper  place.  This  is  a 
very  thirsty  stone  and  indeed  more  like  cinder  than 
anything  else. 

'^  Lav^na  is  on  the  coast  about  half  way  between  Genoa  and  Spezzia.  The 
slate  of  the  district  is  pronounced  by  Mr.  Brindley  to  be  of  poor  quality  and 
liable  to  bleach  to  a  dirty  ochre  colour  like  that  of  brown  paper.  In  the  Official 
Catalogue  of  the  Italian  section  of  the  International  Exhibition  of  1862  it  is 
stated  that  in  modern  times  also  '  large  jars  or  reservoirs  for  containing  oil, 
made  of  this  slate,  are  employed  in  Liguria,  as  well  as  in  the  principal  maritime 
■dep6ts  of  the  oil  trade.' 

''Peperino  is  a  volcanic  product  in  origin  quite  distinct  from  travertine.  It 
consists  of  ashes  and  fragments  of  different  materials  compacted  together  and 
is  called  '  pepper  stone '  from  the  black  grains  that  occur  in  it.  /It  was  one 
of  the  two  old  traditional  building  stones  at  Rome  before  the  introduction  of 
travertine  from  the  quarries  by  Tibur,  the  other  being  the  coarser  and  commoner 
tufa  of  which  the  wall  of  Servius  TuUius  was  built.  The  most  interesting 
monument  in  the  material  is  the  sarcophagus  of  Lucius  Cornelius  Scipio  Barbatus 
in  the  Vatican,  dating  from  the  third  century  B.C.  A  characteristic  piece,  with 
the, black  '  pepper '  marks,  is  shown  as  Q  on  the  Frontispiece. 


56  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

§   15.  Of  the  Stone  from  Istria.^° 

There  is  moreover  quarried  in  Istria  a  stone  of  a  livid 
white,  which  very  easily  splits,  and  this  is  more  frequently 
used  than  any  other,  not  by  the  city  of  Venice  alone,  but  by 
all  the  province  of  Romagna,  for  all  works  both  of  masonry 
and  carving.  It  is  worked  with  tools  and  instruments 
longer  than  those  usually  employed,  and  chiefly  with 
certain  little  hammers  that  follow  the  cleavage  of  the  stone, 
where  it  readily  parts.  A  great  quantity  of  this  kind  of 
stone  was  used  by  Messer  Jacopo  Sansovino,  who  built 
the  Doric  edifice  of  the  Panattiera  ^^  in  Venice,  and  also 
that  in  the  Tuscan  style  for  the  Zecca  (mint)  on  the  Piazza 
of  San   Marco.^2    Thus  they  go  on  executing  all  their 

'"  Istrian  stone  is  a  fine-grained  limestone  of  a  warm  yellowish  grey  tint ; 
it  is  capable  of  taking  a  polish,  and  is  obtainable  in  large  pieces.  It  is  broken 
at  various  points  of  the  coast  from  Merlera  near  Pola  to  the  island  of  Lesina 
off  the  coast  by  Spalato,  and  was  largely  used  in  the  buildings  of  Venice,  and 
generally  in  north-eastern  Italy.  A  considerable  amount  has  been  recently 
employed  in  the  monumental  buildings  of  the  Ring  at  Vienna.  See  L  on 
the  Frontispiece. 

'^ '  The  Doric  edifice  of  the  Panattiera '  sounds  a  very  curious  description  of 
Sansovino's  famous  and  magnificent  Library  of  S.  IJarco,  the  finest  late  Renais- 
sance building  in  Italy,  but  this  seems  to  be  what  Vasari  had  in  his  mind. 
Dr.  Robertson  of  Venice  has  been  kind  enough  to  explain  in  a  letter  the 
history  of  the  site  which  he  has  ascertained  from  the  archives.  The  ground 
where  the  Library  now  stands  was  occupied  up  to  1537  by  a  government 
grain  and  bread  store,  the  '  Panattiera '  (or  more  properly  '  Panatteria ').  The 
shops  for  the  sale  of  bread  were  then  removed  and  grouped  round  the  base 
of  the  Campanile,  where  they  were  replaced  a  little  later  by  Sansovino's  Loggetta. 
Vasari  visited  Venice  in  1542,  and  at  that  time  if  the  shops  and  store  had 
themselves  been  removed  their  name  would  still  cling  to  the  place  and  explain 
'  his  words.  We  should  hardly  call  the  Library  a  'Doric  edifice,'  as  only  the 
lower  Order  is  '  Doric,'  but  we  must  remember  that  it  was  only  this  lower 
Order  that  would  be  completed  at  the  date  of  Vasari's  visit. 

8^  The  Tuscan  Zecca.  The  original  Zecca  or  mint  was  at  the  Rialto, 
and  it  was  afterwards  transferred  to  the  Piazzetta,  where  Sansovino  in  1535 
erected  for  it  the  present  edifice,  in  the  rusticated  or  Tuscan  style.  The  situation 
of  it  is  between  the  Library  and  the  quay.  The  fa9ade  shows  an  arcaded  lowest 
story  in  rusticated  masonry,  with  two  stories  above,  one  in  the  Doric  the 
other  in  the  Ionic  Order,  and  the  columns  in  both  cases  are  themselves  rusticated ; 
that  is  to  say  they  have  projecting  horizontal  courses  of  stone  that  appear  to 
mark  them  with  a  series  of  bands  or  bars. 


ISTRIAN   STONE;    PIETRA   SERENA  57 

works  for  that  city,  doors,  windows,  chapels,  and  any 
other  decorations  that  they  find  convenient  to  make,  not- 
withstanding the  fact  that  breccias  and  other  kinds  of 
stone  could  easily  be  conveyed  from  Verona,  by  means 
of  the  river  Adige.  Very  few  works  made  of  these  letter 
materials  are  to  be  seen,  because  of  the  general  use  of 
the  Istrian  stone,  into  which  porphyry,  serpentine  and 
other  sorts  of  breccias  are  often  inlaid,  resulting  in  com- 
positions which  are  very  ornamental.  This  stone  is  of 
the  nature  of  the  limestone  called  'alberese,'  not  unlike 
that  of  our  own  districts,  and  as  has  been  said  it  splits 
easily. 

§  1 6.  0/  Pietra  Serena. 
There  only  remains  now  the  pietra  serena  and  the 
grey  stone  called  '  macigno  '  ^^  and  the  pietra  forte  which 
is  much  used  in  the  mountainous  parts  of  Italy,  especially 
in  Tuscany,  and  most  of  all  in  Florence  and  her  territory. 
The  stone  that  they  call  pietra  serena^*  draws  towards 

^' '  Macigno '  is  a  green  grey  sandstone  of  the  lower  tertiary  formation  in  Italy. 

**  Pietra  Serena  is  a  very  fine  sedimentary  sandstone,  and  Vasari  does  not 
say  too  much  in  its  praise.  Baldinucci  in  his  Vocabolario  repeats  much  of 
what  Vasari  has  said,  but  mentions  also  a  'pietra  bigia'  or  grey  stone,  which 
lies  outside  the  'serena,'  and  is  inferior  to  it. 

The  quarries  of  pietra  serena  are  abundant  along  the  southern  slopes  of  Monte 
Ceceri,  to  the  south  east  of  Fiesole,  overhanging  Majano.  The  blue  colour 
Vasari  ascribes  to  it  is  the  cause  of  its  name,  the  epithet  '  sereno '  being  specially 
applicable  to  the  clear  blue  sky.  See  G  on  the  Frontispiece.  Vasari's  account  of 
the  stones  dealt  with  in  §§  i6,  17,  is  not  very  clear,  as  he  returns  to  the  epithet 
'serena'  at  the  close  of  §  16  for  a  stone  that  he  makes  to  differ  essentially 
from  the  '  serena '  of  the  beginning  of  the  section  in  that  it  is  weather-resisting. 
Cellini  in  his  second  Treatise,  Delia  Scultura,  ed.  Milanesi,  1893,  p.  201, 
is  clearer.  He  distinguishes"  three  kinds,  (i)  'pietra  serena,'  azure  in  hue 
and  only  good  for  work  in  interiors ;  (2)  a  stone  of  a  brownish  hue  (tane)  that 
he  calls  'pietra  morta.'  The  lexicographers  fight  shy  of  this  term,  but  it 
seems  to  mean  a  stone  without  any  lime  in  it  and  therefore  unchangeable  by 
the  action  of  fire,  while  a  limestone  would  be  '  pietra  viva.'  See  Cellini,  loc.  cit., 
p.  187.  This  is  suitable  for  figure  carving,  and  it  resists  'wind  and  rain  and 
all  violence  of  the  weather.'  It  is  evidently  the  stone  Vasari  writes  of  as  the 
material  of  Donatello's  'Dovizia.'  (3)  The  third  kind  is  the  pietra  forte,  also 
brownish  in  hue,  and  usefiil  for  decorative  carvings  on  exteriors.  Cellini  notes 
as  Vasari  does  that  it  is  only  found  in  small  pieces. 


S8  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

blue  or  rather  towards  a  greyish  tint.  There  are  quarries 
of  it  in  many  places  near  Arezzo,  at  Cortona,  at  Volterra, 
and  throughout  the  Apennines.  The  finest  is  in  tjie  hills 
of  Fiesole,  and  it  is  obtained  there  in  blocks  of  very  great 
size,  as  we  see  in  all  the  edifices  constructed  in  Florence 
by  Filippo  di  Ser  Brunellesco,  who  had  all  the  stones 
needed  for  the  churches  of  San  Lorenzo  and  of  Santo 
Spirito  quarried  there,  and  also  an  unlimited  quantity 
which  are  in  every  building  throughout  the  city.  It  is 
a  very  beautiful  stone  to  look  at,  but  it  wastes  away  and 
exfoliates  where  it  is  subjected  to  damp,  rain,  or  frost. 
'  Under  cover  however  it  will  last  for  ever.  Much  more 
durable  than  this  and  of  finer  colour  is  a  sort  of  bluish 
stone,  in  our  day  called  '  pietra_^dgl_iQSsato.'  ^^  When 
quarried,  the  first  layer  is  gravelly  and  coarse,  the  second 
is  never  free  from  knots  and  fissures,  the-third  is  admirable 
being  much  finer  in  grain.  Michelagnolo  used  this, 
because  of  its  yielding  grain,  in  building  the  Library  and 
Sacristy  of  San  Lorenzo  for  Pope  Clement,  and  he  has 
had  the  mouldings,  columns,  and  every  part  of  the  work 
executed  with  such  great  care  that  even  if  it  were  of  silver 
it  would  not  look  so  well.®^  The  stone  takes  on  a  very 
fine  polish,  so  much  so  that  nothing  better  in  this  kind 
of  material  could  be  wished  for.  On  this  account  it  was 
forbidden  by  law  that  the  stone  be  used  in  Florence  for 
other  than  public  buildings,  unless  permission  had  been 
obtained    from    the    governing    authorities.^'^     The    Duke 

'^  Pietra  del  fossato.  Signer  Cellerini,  of  the  Opera  del  Duomo,  Florence, 
says  that  the  name  '  pietra  del  fossataccio '  is  still  used  among  practical  stone 
workers.     It  is  stone  gained  by  excavation. 

°'The  colour  of  the  stone  in  the  Libr?,ry  and  New  Sacristy  of  S.  Lorenzo 
is  a  brownish  grey  rather  than  'bluish.'  It  tells  as  warm  in  hue  against  the 
white  walls,  which  are  of  marble  in  the  Sacristy  and  in  the  Library  of  plaster. 

''Dr.  A.  Gherardi,  Director  of  the  State  Archives  at  Florence,  has  been 
so  kind  as  to  make  researches  in  the  documents  under  his  charge  for  the  purpose  of 
discovering  Vasari's  authority  for  this  statement.  These  investigations  have  so  far 
however  proved  without  result.  Among  the  '  Leggi  e  Bandi '  of  the  sixteenth 
century  in  Tuscany  collected  by  Cantini  in  the  first  volume  of  his  Legislazione 
Tascana  there  are  various  regulations  about  trades,  prohibitions  against  cutting 


PIETRA   SERENA  59 

Cosimo  has  had  a  great  quantity  of  this  stone  put  into  ^ 
use,  as  for  example,  in  the  columns  and  ornaments  of  the 
loggia  of  the  Mercato  Nuovo,  and  for  the  work  begun 
by  Bandinello  in  the  great  audience  chamber  of  the  palace 
and  also  in  the  other  hall  which  is  opposite  to  it ;  but  the 
greatest  amount,  more  than  ever  used  elsewhere,  has  been 
taken  by  his  Excellency  for  the  Strada  de'  Magistrati,^^ 
now  in  construction,  after  the  design  and  under  the  direc- 
tion of  Giorgio  Vasari  of  Arezzo.  This  stone  demands 
as  much  time  for  working  it  as  marble.  It  is  so  hard 
that  water  does  not  affect  it  and  it  withstands  all  other  a 
attacks  of  time.  __,./ 

Besides  this  there  is  another  sort  called  pietra  serena, 
found  all  over  the  hill,  which  is  coarser,  harder,  and  not 
so  much  coloured,  and  contains  certain  knots  in  the 
stone.  It  resists  the  influence  of  water  and  frost,  and  is 
useful  for  figures  and  carved  ornaments.  Of  this  is  carved 
La  Dovizia  (Abundance),  a  figure  from  the  hand  of 
Donatello  on  the  column  of  the  Mercato  Vecchio  in 
Florence ;  ^^    and   it   serves   also  for   many  other   statues 

timber  on  the  hills,  measures  facilitating  the  import  of  building  materials  into 
certain  ocalities,  and  the  like,  which  show  that  an  edict  such  as  Vasari  refers 
to  was  quite  possible  in  the  early  days  of  the  Grand  Ducal  regime.  The  nearest 
approach  to  it  that  we  have  been  able  to  discover  are  certain  edicts  of  the  end 
of  the  sixteenth  century,  published  by  Mariotti,  La  1  egislazione  delle  Belle  Arii, 
Roma,  1892,  p.  246  f.,  that  prohibit  the  exportation  from  the  state  of  'pietre 
mischie  dure '  (agates,  jaspers,  and  the  like)  of  which  the  Grand  Duke  had 
need  for  a  certain  chapel  he  was  building,  evidently  the  'Cappella  dei 
Principi'  at  S.  Lorenzo. 

''This  is  of  course  the  well  known  '  Uffizi,'  erected  by  Vasari  between  1560 
and  1574  for  the  accommodation  of  various  state  departments.  The  expression 
'  strada '  or  '  street '  has  reference  to  the  scheme  of  the  building,  which  is  erected 
along  the  two  sides  and  one  end  of  a  very  elongated,  and  indeed  street-like, 
court,  from  which  the  various  entrances  into  the  building  open.  In  documents 
relating  to  its  construction  it  is  sometimes  referred  to  as  'Via  dei  Magistrate' 
A  little  later  Vasari  gives  an  interesting  note  on  the  scheme  of  construction 
he  employed  in  the  lower  order  of  the  edifice.     See  postea,  p.  72  f. 

'"The  Mercato  Vecchio  at  Florence  was  an  open  square  that  occupied  the 
northern  portion  of  the  site  now  covered  by  the  new  Piazza  Vittorio  Emmanuele. 
On  the  side  next  the  Via  Calimara  a  granite  column  was  erected  in  1431,  and  on 
this  column  was  set  up  the   statue    by   Donatello  representing   '  Abundance ' 


6o  OF    ARCHITECTURE 

executed  by  excellent  sculptors,  not  only  in  this  city,  but 
throughout  the  territory. 

§  17.  Of  Pietra  Forte. ^°° 
The  pietra  forte  is  quarried  in  many  places;  it  resists 
rain,  sun,  frost,  and  every  trial,  and  demands  time  to  work 
it,  but  it  behaves  very  well ;  it  does  not  exist  in  very  large 
blocks. 1°^  Both  by  the  Goths  ^°^  and  by  the  moderns 
have  been  constructed  of  this  stone  the  most  beautiful 
buildings  to  be  found  in  Tuscany,  as  can  be  seen  in 
Florence  in  the  filling  of  the  two  arches,  which  form 
the  principal  doors  of  the  oratory  of  Orsanmichele,i°^  for 

{'Dovizia').  This  stood  till  October  20,  1721,  when  in  consequence  of  damage 
due  to  time  and  exposure  it  fell  to  the  ground  and  was  dashed  into  pieces. 
In  the  following  year,  1722,  Giov.  Batt.  Foggini  carved  another  figure 
representing  the  same  allegorical  personage,  and  this  remained  till  our  own 
time  ;  and  may  be  seen  in  situ  in  one  of  Alinari's  photographs.  It  is  now 
in  the  museum  of  S.  Marco  with  other  fragments  from  the  demolitions  in  the 
'Centro.'     See  Guido  Carocci,  //  Mercato  Vecchio  di  Firenze,  Firenze,  1884. 

™'  On  '  Pietra  Forte,'  the  Official  Catalogue  of  the  Italian  Section  of  the 
International  Exhibition  of  1862  reports,  p.  62,  as  follows.  'The  rock  called 
Pietraforte  ...  is  very  largely  used  in  Florence ;  it  is  veiy  durable,  as  may  be 
seen  in  the  older  palaces  of  the  city.  In  composition  it  is  an  arenaceous  lime- 
stone, which  is  very  hard  and  unalterable,  as  its  name  implies.'  It  has  been 
extensively  quarried  by  Fiesole  and  to  the  north  of  Majano,  and  Monte  Ripaldi, 
above  the  valley  of  the  Ema  to  the  south  of  Florence,  furnishes  large  supplies 
of  it.     See  M,  N,  on  the  Frontispiece. 

'"1  The  JDlocks  used  for  the  facade  of  the  Pitti  have  been  remarked  on  for  their 
great  si2;e,  one  of  them,  an  exceptional  one  it  is  true,  measures  28  ft.  in  length. 

^"^On  this  use  of  the  word  'Goth'  or  'Gothic'  in  the  sense  of  'mediaeval,' 
see  Note  on  'Vasari's  Opinion  on  Mediaeval  Architecture,'  postea,  p.  133  f. 

I'S  Or  San  Michele,  as  every  visitor  to  Florence  knows,  is  the  church  occupying 
the  lower  story  of  a  lofty  building  in  the  Via  Calzaiuoli.  Constructively  speaking 
the  upper  part  is  supported  on  the  ground  story  by  piers  between  which  are 
round  headed  arches,  three  on  the  north  and  south  sides  and  two  on  the  east  and 
west.  The  heads  of  these  are  in  every  case  filled  with  florid  late  Gothic  tracery 
with  intersecting  arches  and  rich  cusping,  and  on  all  sides  but  the  west  the 
openings  below  the  heads  are  walled  in.  On  the  west  the  arches  contain  the 
doorways  of  entrance,  and  the  tracery  above  the  doors,  about  which  Vasari  is 
writing,  is  richer  than  on  the  other  sides  of  the  building.  It  is  curious 
to  find  Vasari  calling  this  work  '  truly  admirable,'  whereas  a  page  or  two  later 
we  shall  find  him  inveighing  against  the  '  Goths '  (the  mediaeval  builders)  and 
all  their  works  and  ways. 


PIETRA   FORTE  6i 

these  are  truly  admirable  things  and  worked  with  the 
utmost  care.  Of  this  same  stone  there  are  throughout, 
the  city,  as  , has  been -said,  many  statues  and  coats  of 
arms,^°*  as  for  instance  in  the  Fortress  and  various  oth^r 
places.  It  is  yellowish  in  colour  with  fine  white  veins 
that  add  greatly  to  its  attractiveness,  and  it  is  sometimes 
employed  for  statues  where  there  are  to  be  fountains, 
because  it  is  not  injured  by  water.  The  walls  of  the 
palace  of  the  Signori,  the  Loggia,  and  Orsanmichele  are 
built  of  it,  also  the  whole  interior  of  the  fabric  of  Santa 
Maria  del  Fiore,  as  well  as  all  the  bridges  of  our  city, 
the  Palace  of  the  Pitti  and  that  of  the  Strozzi  families. 
It  has  to  be  worked  with  picks  because  it  is  very  compact. 
Similarly,  the  other  stones  mentioned  above  must  be 
treated  in  the  manner  already  explained  for  the  working 
of  marble  and  other  sorts  of  stones. 

§    i8.  Conclusion  of  Chapter. 
After  all  however,  good  stones  and  well  tempered  tools 
apart,  the  one  thing  essential  is  the  art,  the  intelligence, 
andThe  judgement  of  those  who  use  them,  for  there  is  the 

'"*  Coats  of  arms.  These  '  stemmi,'  as  they  are  often  called,  are  very  familiar 
objects  on  the  exterior  of  Tuscan  palaces,  and  the  arms  of  the  Medici,  six  round 
balls  or  pellets,  are  constantly  in  evidence.  In  the  view  of  the  Fortress  in  Fig.  3 
a  '  stemma '  of  the  Medici  is  to  be  seen  displayed  on  the  face  of  the  wall.  It  is 
referred  to  by  Vasari,  Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  IV,  544.  Mariotti,  La  Legislaaione 
delle  Belle  Arti,  Roma,  1892,  p.  245,  has  printed  an  interesting  edict  of  the  year 
1571,  in  Tuscany,  designed  to  protect  these  memorials  of  the  ancient  Florentine 
families.  The  memory  of  those  who  built  the  houses,  it  says,  '  is  preserved  and 
perpetuated  by  their  Arms,  Insignia,  Titles,  Inscriptions,  which  are  affixed  or 
painted  or  carved  or  suspended  over  the  doors,  arches,  windows,  projecting  angles 
or  other  places  where  they  are  conspicuously  to  be  seen,'  and  the  edict,  re-enacting 
older  regulations,  reminds  the  citizens  that  no  one  who  purchases  or  becomes 
possessed  of  an  old  house  on  which  there  are  insignia  of  the  kind  is  allowed  to 
remove  or  in  any  way  deface  them.  No  new  owner  is  to  presume  to  add  his  own 
arms  or  other  memorial  by  the  side  of  the  old  ones  of  the  founder  and  constructor 
of  the  house.  Only  in  cases  where  these  are  absent  may  the  new  owner  put  up  his 
own  insignia.  This  regulation  shows  a  historical  sense  and  a  care  for  the  tangible 
memorials  of  =>  city's  past  which  have  been  too  often  lacking  in  more  modern 
times.  No  doubt  it  is  due  to  its  enforcement  that  so  many  of  these  '  stemmi '  are 
left  to  add  interest  to  the  somewhat  modernized  streets  of  the  Florence  of  to-day. 


62  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

greatest jlifference_between  artists,  although  they  may  all 
use  the  same  method,  as  to  the  measure  of  grace  and 
beauty  they  impart  to  the  wgrksjwhich  they  execute.  This 
enaBles  us  to  discern  and  to  recognize  the  perfection  of 
the  work  done  by  those  who  really  understand,  as  opposed 
to  that  of  others  who  know  less.  As,  therefore,  all  the 
excellence  and  beauty  of  the  things  most  highly  praised 
consist  in  that  supreme  perfection  given  to  them  by  those 
who  understand  and  can  judge,  it  is  necessary  to  strive 
with  all  diligence  always  to  make  things  beautiful  and 
perfect — nay  rather,  most  beautiful  and  most  perfect. 


CHAPTER   II. 

The   Description   of  squared   Ashlar-work    (lavoro   di   quadro)  and   of 
carved  Ashlar-work  (lavoro  di  quadro  intagliato). 

§   19.  The  work  of  the  Mason. 

Having  thus  considered  all  the  varieties  of  stone,  which 
our  artificers  use  either  for  ornament  or  for  sculpture, 
let  us  now  go  on  to  say,  that  when  stone  is  used  for 
actual  building,  all  that  is  worked  with  square  and  com- 
passes and  that  has  corners  is  called  squared  ashlar  work 
(lavoro  di  quadro).  The  term  (quadro)  is  given,  because 
of  the  squared  faces  and  corners,  for  every  order  of 
moulding  or  anything  which  is  straight,  projecting,  or 
rectangular  is  work  which  takes  the  name  of  'squared,' 
and  so  is  it  commonly  known  among  the  artificers. 
But  when  the  stone  does  not  remain  plain  dressed, 
but  is  chiselled  into  mouldings,  friezes,  foliage, 
eggs,  spindles,  dentels  and  other  sorts  of  carving,  the 
work  on  the  members  chosen  to  be  so  treated  is  called 
by  the  mason  carved  ashlar  work  (opera  di  quadro 
intagliato  or  lavoro  di  intaglio).  Of  this  sort  of  plain 
and  carved  ashlar  are  constructed  all  the  different  Orders, 
Rustic,  Doric,  Ionic,  Corinthian,  and  Composite,  and  so 
too,  in  the  times  of  the  Goths,  the  German  work  ^  (lavoro 
tedesco) :  and  no  kind  of  ornament  can  be  made  that 
is  not  founded  on  both  sorts  of  the  work  above  described. 
It  is  the  same  with  breccias  and  marbles  and  every  sort 
of  stone,  and  also  with  bricks,  used  as  a  foundation  for 

^ '  In  the  times  of  the  Goths ; '  '  German  work. '    See  Note  on  '  Vasari's  Opinion 
on  Mediaeval  Architecture,'  postea,  p.  133  f. 


64  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

moulded  stucco  work.  The  same  applies  to  walnut, 
poplar,  and  every  kind  of  wood.  B(Ut,  because  many  do 
not  recognize  the  difference  between  one  Order  and 
another,  let  us  discuss  distinctly  and  as  briefly  as  possible 
in  the  chapter  which  follows,  every  mode  and  manner 
of  these. 


CHAPTER   III. 

Concerning    the    five    Orders    of   Architecture,    Rustic,    Doric,    Ionic, 
Corinthian,  Composite,  and  also  German  Work. 

§   20.  Rusticated  masonry  and  the   Tuscan  Order. 

The  work  called  Rustic  ^  is  more  stunted,  and  more  mas- 
sive than  that  of  any  other  Order,  it  being  the  beginning 
and  foundation  of  all.  The  profiles  of  the  mouldings  are 
simpler  and  in  consequence  more  beautiful,  as  are  the 
capitals  and  bases  as  well  as  every  other  member. 
The  Rustic  socles  or  pedestals,  as  we  call  them,  on  which 
rest  the  columns,  are  square  in  proportion,  with  a  solid 
moulding  at  the  foot  and  another  above  which  binds  it 
like  a  cornice.  The  height  of  the  column  measures  six 
heads,2  in  imitation  of  people  who  are  dwarfed  and  adapted 

'  It  will  be  seen  that  in  this  section  Vasari  combines  two  quite  distinct  things,  the 
so-called  '  Tuscan,'  or  as  he  calls  it,  the  '  Rustic '  Order,  and  rusticated  masonryi 
which  has  nothing  to  do  with  the  Orders  of  Architecture,  but  is  a  method  of  treating 
wall-surfaces.  On  this  see  the  Note  on  '  Rusticated  Masonry,'  postea,  p.  132. 
The  reason  why  the  '  Tuscan '  is  called  the  '  Rustic '  Order,  is  that,  being  the 
simplest  and,  so  to  say,  rudest  of  the  Orders,  it  is  most  suitably  employed  in 
connection  with  walling  of  a  rough  and  bossy  appearance.  The  shafts  of  columns 
are  sometimes  rusticated  to  correspond  with  the  walling,  as  at  the  Venetian 
'  Zecca,'  mentioned  ante,  p.  56,  but  the  expedient  is  of  doubtful  advantage,  as 
the  clear  upright  appearance  of  the  column  is  thereby  sacrificed. 

^  Vasari  says  here  that  the  '  Rustic '  or  Tuscan  column  is  six  '  heads '  high. 
What  does  he  mean  by  this?  There  is  evidently  in  his  mind  the  familiar  com- 
parison of  different  columns  to  human  figures  of  different  proportions,  a  conceit 
found  in  Vitruvius  (iv,  i,  6f.)  and  in  writers  of  the  Renaissance  {see  Alberti, 
£>e  Re  Aedificatoria,  Lib.  IX,  c.  7),  and  so  he  measures  by  '  heads,'  which  would 
apply  to  a  figure  but  not  to  a  column.  '  Testa,'  '  head,'  cannot,  as  the  context 
shows,  mean  the  height  of  the  capital  of  the  column.     It  really  means  here  the 

E 


66  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

to  sustain  weights.  Of  tliis  Order  there  are  to  be  seen 
in  Tuscany  many  colonnades  both  plain  and  rusticated, 
with  and  also  without  bosses  and  niches  between  the 
columns  :  and  many  porticoes  which  the  ancients  were 
accustomed  to  construct  in  their  villas ;  and  in  the  country 
one  still  sees  many  tombs  of  the  kind  as  at  Tivoli  and 
at  Pozzuolo,  This  Order  served  the  ancients  for  doors, 
windows,  bridges,  aqueducts,  treasuries,  castles,  towers, 
and  strongholds  for  storing  ammunition  and  artillery; 
also  for  harbours,  prisons  and  fortresses;  in  these  the 
stones  project  in  an  effective  manner  in  points  like  a 
diamond,  or  with  many  facets.  The  projections  are  treated 
in  various  ways,  either  in  bosses,  flattened,  so  as  not  to 
act  as  a  ladder  on  the  walls — for  it  would  be  easy  to  climb 
up  if  the  bosses  jutted  out  too  much — or  in  other  ways, 
as  one  sees  in  many  places,  and  above  all  in  Florence, 
in  the  principal  fa9ade  of  the  chief  citadel,  built  by 
Alexander,  first  duke  of  Florence.^    This  fa9ade,  out  of 

lower  diameter  of  the  column.  It  is  this  lower  diameter  (or  sometimes  half  the 
lower  diameter)  that  is  the  normal  unit  of  measurement  for  the  proportions  of  a 
column.  Thus  the  height  of  the  Tuscan  column  is  given  by  Vitruvius  and  by 
Palladio  and  other  moderns  as  six  times  the  lower  diameter.  Though  'head' 
may  seem  a  very  curious  word  with  which  to  describe  this,  there  is  no  doubt  that 
such  is  the  meaning  of  it.  Alberti,  in  his  tract  on  the  Orders  and  their  pro- 
portions, uses  the  lower  diameter  as  his  measure  but  applies  to  it  this  very  term 
'testa.'  There  is  a  certain  letter  from  Vasari  to  Duke  Cosimo  that  deals  with 
the  measurements  of  a  column  of  granite  presented  to  him  by  the  Pope  and 
afterwards  conveyed  from  Rome  and  set  up  in  the  Piazza  di  S.  Trinita,  where  it 
carries  the  porphyry  statue  by  Francesco  del  Tadda  (postea,  p.  iii).  Vasari  gives 
the  diameter  of  the  '  head '  of  this  column,  but  notes  afterwards  that  the  shaft 
diminishes  from  the  'head'  upwards  towards  the  necking  (coUarino).  Hence 
there  is  no  doubt  about  the  interpretation  of  the  word  in  question.  See  the  letter 
in  Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  viii,  352. 

'  The  Citadel  of  Florence.  This  is  not  the  '  Belvedere '  fortress  on  the  hill 
behind  the  Palazzo  Pitti,  but  the  so-called  '  Fortezza  da  Basso '  to  the  north  of 
the  town,  now  used  as  barracks,  which  the  railway  skirts  just  before  entering 
the  station  near  S.  Maria  Novella.  It  dates  from  1534,  and  was  built  by 
Alessandro  dei  Medici  with  the  intention  of  overawing  the  citizens.  It  occupied 
the  site  of  the  Faenza  gate,  and  was  partly  within  and  partly  outside  the 
enceinte  of  the  city.  The  '  principal  fa9ade '  of  which  Vasari  writes,  is  still  well 
preserved  in  the  middle  of  the  southern  face,  opposite  the  town,  and  a  sketch 


RUSTICATED   MASONRY 


67 


respect  to  the  Medici  emblems,  is  made  with  ornaments 
of  diamond  points  and  flattened  pellets,  but  both  in  low 
relief.  The  wall  composed  of  pellets  and  diamonds  side 
by  side  is  very  rich  and  varied  and  most  beautiful  to 
look  at.  There  is  abundance  of  this  work  at  the  villas 
of  the  Florentines,  the  gates  and  entrances,  and  at  the 
houses  and  palaces  where  they  pass  the  summer,  which 


Fig.  3. — Fortezza  da  Basso  at  Florence. 

not  only  beautify  and  adorn  that  neighbourhood,  but  are 
also  of  the  greatest  use  and  convenience  to  the  citizens. 
But  much  more  is  the  city  itself  enriched  with  magnificent 
buildings,    decorated    with    rusticated    masonry,    as    for 

of  it  is  shown  in  Fig.  3,  but  nothing  else  of  interest  is  said  to  remain  from  the 
Renaissance  period. 

The  masonry  of  the  fayade  is  an  excellent  example  of  elaborate  rustication,  and 
is  very  carefully  executed  in  pietra  forte.  The  illustration,  Fig.  4,  bears  out 
Vasari's  description,  and  exhibits  in  alternation  round  bosses  18  in.  in  diameter 
and  4  in.  in  salience,  and  oblong  diamonds  about  3  ft.  by  z  ft.  6  in.  There  are 
worked  borders  about  i  in.  in  width  round  all  the  lines  of  juncture,  and  the 
scheme  is  worth  noticing. 


68  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

example  the  Casa  Medici,  the  fa9ade  of  the  Pitti  Palace, 
the  palace  of  the  Strozzi  family  and  innumerable  others. 
When  well  designed,  the  more  solid  and  simple  the 
building,  the  more  skill  and  beauty  do  we  perceive  in  it, 
and  this  kind  of  work  is  necessarily  more  lasting  and 
durable  than  all  others,  seeing  that  the  pieces  of  stone 
are  bigger  and  the  assemblage  much  better,  all  the  build- 
ing being  in  bond,  one  stone  with  another.  Moreover, 
because  the  members  are  smooth  and  massive,  the  chances 
of  fortune  and  of  weather  cannot  injure  them  so  severely 
as  the  stones  that  are  carved  and  undercut,  or,  as  we  say 
here,  '  suspended  in  the  air  '  by  the  cleverness  of  the 
sculptors. 

§   21.  The  Doric  Order. 

The  Doric  Order  was  the  most  massive  known  to  the 
Greeks,  more  robust  both  as  to  strength  and  mass,  and 
much  less  open  than  their  other  Orders.  And  not  only 
the  Greeks  but  the  Romans  also  dedicated  this  sort  of 
building  to  those  who  were  warriors,  such  as  generals 
of  armies,  consuls,  praetors — and  much  more  often  to  their 
gods,  as  Jove,  Mars,  Hercules  and  others.  According 
to  the  rank  and  character  of  these  the  buildings  were 
carefully  distinguished — made  plain  or  carved,  simple  or 
rich— so  that  all  could  recognize  the  grade  and  the  position 
of  the  different  dignitaries  to  whom  they  were  dedicated,* 
or  of  him  who  ordered  them  to  be  built.  Consequently 
one  sees  that  the  ancients  applied  much  art  in  the  com- 
position of  their  buildings,  that  the  profiles  of  the  Doric 

''Vitruvius  in  his  first  boolj  (i,  ii,  5)  gives  directions  as  to  the  Orders  suitable  for 
temples  to  different  deities.  Thus  Minerva,  Mars,  and  Hercules  are  to  have 
temples  in  the  Doric  style,  etc. ;  while  in  the  eighteenth  century  Sir  William 
^  Chambers,  transferring  the  same  idea  to  modern  times,  says  that  Doric  '  may  be 
employed  in  the  houses  of  generals,  or  other  martial  men,  in  mausoleums  erected 
to  their  memory,  or  in  triumphal  bridges  and  arches  built  to  celebrate  their 
victories.'  The  modern  architect  is  disposed  to  smile  at  these  restrictions,  but 
there  underlies  them  a  sound  appreciation  of  the  aesthetic  significance  pf  architec- 
tural forms. 


RUSTICATED    MASONRY 


69 


70  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

mouldings  are  very  graceful,  and  the  features  harmonious 
and  of  a  high  degree  of  beauty ;  and  also  that  the  propor- 
tion of  the  shafts  of  the  columns  is  very  well  understood, 
as  they  are  neither  too  thick  nor  too  thin.  The  form 
of  the  columns,  as  is  commonly  said,  resembles  that  of 
Hercules ;  it  shows  a  certain  solidity  capable  of  sustaining 
the  weight  of  the  architraves,  friezes,  cornices  and  the  rest 
of  the  upper  parts  of  the  building.  Because  this  Order, 
as  more  secure  and  stable  than  the  others,  has  always 
'  much  pleasedDute^Sosimo,  he  desires  that  the  building, 
which  he  has  charged  me  to  construct  for  thirteen  civil 
magistrates  of  his  city  and  dominion,  should  be  of  the 
Doric  Order.  This  building  is  to  have  splendid  decoration 
in  stone,  and  is  to  be  placed  between  his  own  palace  and 
the  river  Arno.^  Therefore,  in  order  to  bring  back  into 
use  the  true  mode  of  construction,  which  requires  the 
architraves  to  lie  level  over  the  columns,  and  avoid  the 
falsity  of  turning  the  arches  of  the  arcades  above  the 
capital,  I  have  followed  in  the  principal  fa9ade  the  actual 
method  of  the  ancients,  as  can  be  seen  in  the  edifice.  This 
fashion  of  building  has  been  avoided  by  architects  of  the 
recent  past,  because  stone  architraves  of  every  sort  both 
ancient  and  modern  are  all,  or  the  greater  part  of  them, 
seen  to  be  broken  in  the  middle,  notwithstanding  that 
above  the  solid  of  the  columns  and  of  the  architraves, 
frieze,  and  cornice,  there  are  flat  arches  of  brick  that  are 
not  in  contact  with  and  do  not  load  the  work  below.  Now, 
after  much  consideration  on  the  whole  question,  I  have 
finally  found  an  excellent  way  of  putting  into  use  the  true 
mode  of  proceeding  so  as  to  give  security  to  the  said 
architraves,  by  which  they  are  prevented  from  suffering 
in  any  part  and  everything  remains  as  sound  and  safe  as 
can  be  desired,  as  the  result  has  proved.  This  then,  is 
the  method,  that  is  stated  here  below  for  the  benefit  of 
the  world  at  large  and  of  the  artificers. 

'The  building  referred  to  is  the  well-known  Uffizi  palace  at  Florence.     See 
ante,  p.  S9- 


A  CONSTRUCTIVE  DEVICE 


71 


o 


o 


-~w 


CD 


n 


zA 


C^J 


CQ 


TZ" 


CQ 


.>o 


^ 


.^^ 


°      ^ 


^ 


.-1/ 


ntr 


n 

CQ 

^ 

< 

e 
& 


u 

I 


72  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

§  22.  A  constructive  device  to  avoid  charging 
architraves.^ 
Having  set  up  the  columns,  and  above  the  capitals  the 
architraves,  which  are  brought  into  contact  the  one  with 
the  other  above  the  middle  axis  of  the  column,  the  builder 
proceeds  to  make  a  square  block  or  die  (D,  D,  Fig.  5). 
For  example,  if  the  column  be  a  braccio  thick  and  the 
architraves  the  same  in  width  ^  and  height,  let  the  die  in 
the  frieze  be  made  equal  to  them ;  but  in  front  let  there 
remain  an  eighth  in  the  face  for  the  vertical  joint,  and 
let  another  eighth  or  more  have  a  sinking  into  the  die  on 
each  side,  bevelled  to  an  angle  of  45°,  Fig.  5  (i).  Then 
since  the  frieze  in  each  intercolumniation  is  in  three  pieces 
(B,  A,  B),  let  the  two  at  the  sides  (B,  B)  have  bevelled  pro- 
jections in  the  opposite  sense  to  the  sinkings,  increasing 
from  within  outwards.  Fig.  5  (2),  so  that  each  may  be 
mortised  in  the  die  and  be  keyed  after  the  manner  of  an 
arch,  and  in  the  front  the  amount  of  the  eighth  must 
bond  vertically;    while  the  part  on  the  other  side  must 

^  The  construction  described  by  Vasari  is  evidently  of  the  kind  indicated  in  the 
accompanying  drawing,  Fig.  5.  The  pieces  of  the  frieze  are  joggled  one  into 
the  other  so  as  to  form  a  flat  arch,  but  the  construction  is  kept  to  the  inner  part 
and  the  face  shows  vertical  joints  between  the  pieces.  As  this  passage  in  Vasari 
seems  to  have  escaped  the  notice  of  those  interested  in  Renaissance  construction, 
the  existence  of  the  device  he  describes  has  remained  unsuspected  and  nothing  is 
known  about  it  at  the  Uffizi  itself.  The  fact  is  that  Vasari's  system  has  succeeded 
in  one  way  too  perfectly  for  his  purpose.  Everything  has  remained  '  safe  and 
sound,'  and  no  one  of  the  architrave  beams  shows  signs  of  failure,  so  that  no 
technical  examination  of  the  fabric  has  been  called  for.  On  the  other  hand, 
neither  the  artificers  nor  the  world  at  large  seem  to  have  benefitted  by  Vasari's 
kindness,  for  the  books  do  not  notice  his  device.  There  is  no  mention  of  it  even 
in  the  huge  work  on  Tuscan  Renaissance  architecture  now  just  completed  under 
the  editorship  of  Baron  Henri  de  Geymuller,  nor  in  Raschdorff 's  Palast-Architectur, 
nor  Durm's  Baukunst  der  Renaissance,  though  references  to  it  may  possibly  occur 
in  older  books  that  have  escaped  our  notice.  Joggled  lintels  forming  flat  arches 
are  of  course  common  enough.  The  new  Parhament  Building  at  Stockholm  shows 
them  conspicuously  with  the  actual  joints  appearing  on  the  face  of  the  building. 
Mediaeval  and  Renaissance  fireplaces  often  have  lintels  of  the  kind,  as  in  Conings- 
burgh  Castle,  Yorks,  and  Linlithgow  Palace. 

'i.e.  width  on  the  soffit,  or,  as  it  might  be  expressed,  in  depth  from  the  outer 
face  inwards. 


A   CONSTRUCTIVE   DEVICE  73 

do  the  same  to  the  other  die.  And  so  above  the  column  ^ 
one  must  arrange  that  the  piece  in  the  middle  of  the  said 
frieze  closes  within  and  is  recessed  in  quarter-round  form 
up  to  the  middle,  while  the  other  half  must  be  squared 
and  straight  and  set  with  an  empty  space  below,  in  order 
that  it  may  hold  as  does  an  arch,  the  wall  on  the  external 
face  appearing  worked  with  vertical  joints.^  Do  not  let 
the  stones  of  the  said  frieze  rest  on  the  architrave,  but  let 
a  finger's  breadth  be  between  them ;  in  this  way,  making 
an  arch,  the  frieze  comes  to  support  itself  and  does  not 
burden  the  architrave.  Afterwards  make  on  the  inside, 
for  filling  up  the  said  frieze,  a  flat  arch  of  bricks  as  high 
as  the  frieze,  that  .stretches  from  die  to  die  above  the 
columns.  Then  make  a  piece  of  cornice  as  wide  as  the 
die  ^°  above  the  columns,  which  has  the  joints  in  front  like 
those  of  the  frieze,  and  within  let  the  said  cornice  be 
keyed  like  the  blocks  of  the  frieze,  care  being  taken  to 
make  the  cornice,  as  the  frieze,  in  three  pieces,  of  which 
the  two  at  the  sides  hold  from  within  the  middle  piece  of 
the  cornice  above  the  die  of  the  frieze, ^^  and  mind  that 

'  'Sopra  la  colonna.'  This  does  not  mean  strictly  the  piece  vertically  above  the 
column,  which  is  the  die  (dado  quadro)  already  mentioned.  It  is  equivalent  to 
the  expression  just  below  'sopra  le  colonne,'  and  means  simply  'in  the  upper 
part.'  The  piece  referred  to  is  A,  A,  in  Fig.  5,  the  '  pezzo  del  mezzo '  of  the  text 
as  quoted  below. 

° '  Cosl  si  faccia  sopra  la  colonna,  che  il  pezzo  del  mezzo  di  detto  fregio  stringa 
di  dentro,  e  sia  intaccato  a  quartabuono  infino  a  mezzo ;  I'altra  mezza  sia  squadrata 
e  diritta  e  messa  a  cassetta,  perchfe  stringa  a  uso  d'arco  mostrando  di  fuori  essere 
murata  diritta.'  The  sense  of  this  sentence  seems  to  be  indicated  by  the  drawing 
Fig.  5.  The  centre  pieces  A,  A,  will  slip  down  into  their  places  and  in  a  fashion 
key  the  flat  arch.     There  is  the  same  construction  in  the  cornice,  see  below. 

■"'  The  dimension  here  implied  is  not  the  width  on  the  face  from  right  to  left,  but 
the  soffit-width,  or  depth  from  the  outer  face  inwards.  The  dies  and  the  cornice- 
pieces  are  of  the  same  soffit-width  as  the  architrave,  but  the  frieze  pieces  are  so 
much  narrower  as  to  allow  space  behind  them  for  =>  flat  arch  of  brick  abutting  at 
each  end  on  that  part  of  the  die  that  exceeds  in  soffit-width  the  frieze.  See  plan, 
Fig.  5  (4),  and  section,  Fig.  5  (5).     The  plan  is  at  the  level  x,  y. 

"  'Sopra  il  dado  del  fregio'  see  note  on  '  Sopra  la  colonna.'  The  middle  piece 
which  goes  'a  cassetta,'  i.e.  spanning  a  void,  is  at  the  centre  of  the  inter- 
columniation,  not  vertically  over  the  die  above  the  column. 


74  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

the  middle  piece  of  the  cornice,  C,  C,  slips  down  into 
the  sinkings  so  as  to  span  the  void,  and  unites  the  two 
pieces  at  the  sides  so  as  to  lock  them  in  the  form  of  an 
arch.  In  this  fashion  everyone  can  see  that  the  frieze 
sustains  itself,  as  does  the  cornice,  which  rests  almost 
entirely  on  the  arch  of  bricks. ^^  Thus  one  thing  helping 
another,  it  comes  about  that  the  architrave  does  not  sustain 
any  but  its  own  weight,  nor  is  there  danger  of  its  ever 
being  broken  by  too  heavy  a  load.  Because  experience 
shows  this  method  to  be  the  most  sure,  I  have  wished  to 
make  particular  mention  of  it,  for  the  convenience  and 
benefit  of  all;  especially  as  I  know  that  when  the  frieze 
and  the  cornice  were  put  above  the  architrave  as  was 
the  practice  of  the  ancients,  the  latter  broke  in  course  of 
time,  possibly  on  account  of  an  earthquake  or  other 
accident,  the  arch  of  discharge  which  was  introduced  above 
the  cornice  not  being  sufficient  to  preserve  it.  But  throw- 
ing the  arches  above  the  cornices  made  in  this  form,  and 
linking  them  together  with  iron,  as  usual, ^^  secures  the 
whole  from  every  danger  and  makes  the  building  endure 
eternally. 

Returning  to  .the  matter  in  hand,  let  us  explain  then 
that  this  fashion  of  work  may  be  used  by  itself  alone, 
or  can  be  employed  in  the  second  floor  from  the  ground 
level,  above  the  Rustic  Order,  or  it  can  be  put  higher  up 
above  another  variety  of  Order  such  as  Ionic,  Corinthian 
or  Composite,  in  the  manner  shown  by  the  ancients  in 
the  Colosseum  in  Rome,  in  which  arrangement  they  used 
skill  and  judgement.  The  Romans,  having  triumphed  not 
only  over  the  Greeks  but  over  the  whole  world,  put  the 
Composite  Order  at  the  top,  of  which  Order  the  Tuscans 
have  composed  many  varieties.     They  placed  it  above  all, 

^^P'ig.  5  (4)  and  (5)  show  the  nature  of  the  construction  across  from  the 
fa9ade  inwards.  The  corridor  is  spanned  with  a  barrel  vault  that  conceals  the 
back  of  the  entablature.     It  starts  from  the  top  of  the  architrave. 

"  For  this  use  of  iron  ties,  which  Vasari  regards  here  as  normal,  see  the  illustra- 
tion on  p.  25  of  Professor  Durm's  Baukunst  der  Renaissance  in  Italien,  in  the 
Handbuch  der  Architectur,  Stuttgart,  1903. 


PROPORTIONS  AND  PARTS  OF  DORIC  ORDER    75 

as  superior  in  force,  grace,  and  beauty,  and  as  more  strik- 
ing than  the  others,  to  be  a  crown  to  the  building;  for  to 
be  adorned  with  beautiful  members  gives  to  the  work  an 
honourable  completion  and  leaves  nothing  more  to  be 
desired. 

§  23.  The  proportions  and  parts  of  the  Doric  Order. 

To  return  to  the  Doric  Order,  I  may  state  that  the 
column  is  made  seven  heads  in  height.  Its  pedestal  must 
be  a  little  less  than  a  square  and  a  half  in  height  and  a 
square  in  width, ^*  then  above  are  placed  its  mouldings 
and  beneath  its  base  with  torus  and  two  fillets,  as  Vitruvius 
directs.  The  base  and  capital  are  of  equal  height,  reckon- 
ing the  capital  from  the  astragal  upwards.  The  cornice 
with  the  frieze  and  architrave  attached  projects  over  every 
column,  with  those  grooved  features,  usually  called 
triglyphs,  which  have  square  spaces  ^^  interposed  between 
the  projections,  within  which  are  the  skulls  of  oxen,  or 
trophies,  or  masks,  or  shields,  or  other  fancies.  The 
architrave,  jutting  out,  binds  these  projections  with  a  fillet, 

"The  expression  is  a  little  awkward,  but  the  meaning  evidently  is  that  the 
pedestal  is  half  as  high  again  as  it  is  wide.  There  is  some  doubt  whether  the 
•clause  '  then  above  are  placed  'to  "as  Vitruvius  directs '  refers  to  the  pedestal  or 
the  column  itself.  In  the  case  of  all  the  other  Orders  Vasari  mentions  the  upper 
and  lower  mouldings  of  the  pedestal,  and  it  would  be  most  natural  to  imagine  him 
doing  so  here,  but  the  '  torus  and  two  fillets  (bastone  e  due  piani)  as  Vitruvius 
directs'  sounds  more  like  the  'Attic'  base  of  the  column,  and  the  reference  to 
Vitruvius  should  be  conclusive  that  it  is  not  the  pedestal  of  which  there  is  question, 
for  the  good  reason  that  Vitruvius  knows  nothing  of  the  pedestal  under  the  single 
column  of  any  of  the  Orders.  Such  a.  feature  does  occur  in  classical  work,  as  in 
the  temple  at  Assisi,  but  it  is  not  a  normal  classical  form,  and  architectural 
purists  in  modern  times  reject  it.  Vitruvius  is  however  again  referred  to  by  Vasari 
in  this  connection,  in  §25,  and  Giorgio  may  have  in  his  mind  the  sentence  in 
Vitruvius,  in,  iv,  5,  in  which  there  is  a  reference  to  the  mouldings  on  the 
■continuous  podium  that  serves  as  the  substructure  of  the  Roman  temple,  and 
forms  one  difference  between  it  and  the  Greek  temple.  The  single  pedestal  was 
often  used  in  Renaissance  work,  and  Vasari  regards  it  as  a  matter  of  course. 

^'  The  metopes ;  these  are  always  set  back  a  little  behind  the  face  of  the 
triglyphs,  which  are  here  termed  the  projections.  The  metope  offers  a  suitable 
field  for  carved  ornaments. 


^6  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

and  under  the  fillet  are  little  strips  square  in  section,  at 
the  foot  of  each  of  which  are  six  drops,  called  by  the 
ancients  '  guttae '  (goccie).  If  the  column  in  the  Doric  order 
is  to  be  seen  fluted,  there  must  be  twenty  hollow  facets 
instead  of  flutes, ^^  and  nothing  between  the  flutes  but  the 
sharp  arris.  Of  this  sort  of  work  there  is  an  example 
in  Rome  at  the  Forum  Boarium  which  is  most  rich;^'^ 
and  of  another  sort  are  the  mouldings  and  other  members 
in  the  theatre  of  Marcellus,  where  to-day  is  the  Piazza 
Montanara,  in  which  work  there  are  no  bases  (to  the 
Doric  columns)  and  those  bases  which  are  visible  are 
Corinthian.  It  is  thought  that  the  ancients  did  not  make 
bases,  but  instead  placed  there  a  pedestal  of  the  same 
size  as  the  base  would  have  been.  This  is  to  be  met  with 
in  Rome  by  the  prison  of  the  Tullianum  where  also  are 
capitals  richer  in  members  than  others  which  appear  in 
the  Doric  Order. ^^     Of  this  same  order  Antonio  da  San 

^'Vasari  merely  has  in  mind  the  familiar  difference  in  form  between  the  Doric 
and  Ionic  flutes,  the  former  being  much  shallower  than  the  latter,  and  not  showing 
the  plain  strip  or  fillet  which  in  the  Ionic  column  comes  between  every  two  of  the 
flutes. 

^'  The  reference  probably  is  to  the  portion  of  the  ancient  Basilica  Aemilia,  which 
in  Vasari's  time  still  stood  erect  where  recent  excavations  have  revealed  the  plan 
and  part  of  the  architectural  members  of  this  famous  structure.  We  must  bear  in 
mind  that  what  Vasari  and  his  contemporaries  called  the  '  Forum  Boarium '  was 
not  the  part  between  the  Capitol  and  the  Palatine,  near  the  '  Bocca  della  Verita ' 
which  was  the  ancient  Cattle  Market  and  now  has  resumed  its  antique  name,  but 
the  Forum  proper,  which  used  even  in  the  memory  of  those  now  living  to  be 
called  'Campo  Vaccino.'  It  seems  to  have  derived  the  name  'Forum  Boarium' 
from  this  very  fragment  of  the  Basilica  Aemilia  which  Vasari  has  in  his  mind  in 
this  passage.  The  fragment  was  figured  by  Giuliano  da  San  Gallo  in  a  drawing 
in  the  Barberini  Library,  which  is  reproduced  in  Monumenti  dell'  Istituto, 
XII,  T.  II,  12,  and  from  this,  by  the  kind  permission  of  the  Imperial  German 
Archaeological  Institute,  has  been  taken  Fig.  6.  The  destruction  of  this  most 
interesting  fragment,  which  stood  over  against  the  arch  of  Septimius  Severus, 
is  one  of  the  many  almost  inconceivable  acts  of  vandalism  of  which  the  men 
of  the  later  Renaissance  period  were  guilty.  The  richness  of  which  Vasari 
speaks  can  be  seen  in  the  illustration. 

18  Here  again  Renaissance  and  modern  topographical  nomenclature  do  not 
agree.  What  Vasari  knew  as  the  '  Tullianum '  was  not  the  familiar  '  Career 
Mamertinus'  above  the  Forum  on  the  way  up  to  S.  Maria  in  Araceli,  but  certain 


PROPORTIONS  AND  PARTS  OF  DORIC  ORDER    y7 


^^1 


Fig.  6. — Drawing  by  Giuliano  da  San  Gallo  of  a  portion  of  the  Basilica  Aemilia  in  the 
Roman  Forum,  that  survived  to  the  time  of  Va,sari. 


78 


OF   ARCHITECTURE 


Gallo  has  made  the  inner  court  of  the  Casa  Farnese  in 
the  Campo  di  Fiore  at  Rome,  which  is  highly  decorated 
and  beautiful;  thus  one  sees  continually  ancient  and 
modern  temples  and  palaces  in  this  style,  which  for 
stability  and  assemblage  of  the  stones  have  held  together 
better  and  lasted  longer  than  all  other  edifices. 


§  24.  The  Ionic  Order. 

The  Ionic  Order,  more  slender  than  the  Doric,  was 
made  by  the  ancients  in  imitation  of  persons  who  stand 
mid-way  between  the  fragile  and  the  robust;  a  proof  of 
this  is  its  adoption  in  works  dedicated  to  Apollo,  Diana, 
and  Bacchus,  and  sometimes  to  Venus.  The  pedestal 
which  sustains  the  column  is  one  and  a  half  squares  high 
and  one  wide,  and  the  mouldings,  above  and  below,  are 
in  accordance  with  this  Order,  Its  column  measures  in 
height  eight  times  the  head,  and  its  base  is  double  with 

antique    structures    under   the    church    of    S.    Nicola    in    Carcere,    near    the 

Piazza  Montanara.  These  were  the  'favissae' 
or  cells  within  the  structure  of  the  podium 
or  platform  of  one  of  several  ancient  Roman 
temples  on  this  site,  which  was  formerly 
the  '  Forum  Olitorium.'  These  substructures 
are  now  accessible,  and  the  worthy  sacristan  of 
the  church  who  shows  them  is  still  of  opinion 
that  he  has  in  charge  the  prison  of  the  Tul- 
lianum.  One  of  the  travertine  columns  of  one 
of  these  temples  is  to  be  seen  within  the 
church,  and  this  though  Doric  is  extremely 
simple,  even  rude,  in  its  outline.  Dr.  Huelsen 
has  however  in  a.  recent  paper  (Mitteilungen 
d.  k.  deutschen  Archaeologischen  Instiiuts,  XXI, 
169  f.)  shown  that  this  column  was  originally 
finished  with  stucco,  in  which  somewhat  elaborate 
mouldings  were  worked.  It  was  drawn  by 
several  of  the  Renaissance  architects,  and  Per- 
uzzi  notes  it  as  being  'in  carcere  Tulliano.' 
Huelsen  has  drawn  out  a  scheme  of  the 
mouldings  in  profile  and  this  is  reproduced  by 
permission    in    Fig.    7.     It    will    be    seen   that 


Fig.  7.— Roman  Doric  cap,  with 
scucco  finish,  at  S.  Nicola  in 
Carcere,  Rome. 


Vasari's  remark  about  its  richness  in  membering  is  quite  justified. 


IONIC   ORDER;    CORINTHIAN   ORDER        79 

two  tori,  as  described  by  Vitruvius  in  tiie  third  cliapter 
of  liis  third  book.  Its  capital  with  its  volutes  or  scrolls 
or  spirals,  as  anyone  may  call  them,  should  be  well 
turned,  as  one  sees  in  the  theatre  of  Marcellus  in  Rome, 
above  the  Doric  Order;  and  its  cornice  adorned  with 
modillions  and  with  dentils,  and  its  frieze  slightly  convex 
(pulvinated).  Should  it  be  desired  to  flute  the  columns, 
there  must  be  twenty-four  flutes,  but  divided  in  such  a 
manner  as  to  leave  between  each  two  of  them  a  flat  piece 
that  measures  the  fourth  part  of  the  flute.  This  order 
has  in  itself  the. most  beautiful  lightness  and  grace  and 
is  consequently  a'dopted  by  modern  architects. 

§  25.  The  Corinthian  Order. 

The  Corinthian  style  was  invariably  a  favourite  among 
the  Romans,  who  delighted  in  it  so  greatly  that  they 
chose  this  Order  for  their  most  elaborate  and  most  prized 
buildings  to  remain  as  a  memorial  of  themselves;  as  is 
seen  in  the  Temple  at  Tivoli  above  the  Teverone,  in  the 
remains  of  the  temple  of  Peace,^^  in  the  arch  of  Pola, 
and  in  that  of  the  harbour  of  Ancona;  but  much  more 
beautiful  is  the  Pantheon,  that  is  the  Ritonda  of  Rome. 
This  Order  is  the  richest  and  most  decorated  of  all  the 
Orders  spoken  of  above.  The  pedestal  that  supports  the 
column  is  measured  in  the  following  way;  a  square  and 
two  thirds  wide  (high)  ^°  and  the  mouldings  above  and 
below  in  proportion,  according  to  Vitruvius  21  :  the  height 
of  the  column  nine  heads  with  base  and  capital,  which  last 
shall  be  in  height  the  diameter  of  the  column  at  the  foot, 
and  its  base  half  of  the  said  thickness.  This  base  the 
ancients  used  to  carve  in  various  ways.     Let  the  ornament 

"  Vasari  probably  refers  to  the  great  Corinthian  column  which  was  still  to  be 
seen  in  his  time  in  the  interior  of  the  Basilica  of  Constantine  (formerly  called  the 
Temple  of  Peace).  The  column  was  placed  early  in  the  seventeenth  century  in 
the  Piazza  in  front  of  S.  Maria  Maggiore,  where  it  is  still  in  evidence. 

" '  Largo '  is  the  word  in  the  text,  but  it  must  be  merely  a  clerical  error  for 
•alto.' 

''See  Note  14,  ante,  p.  75. 


8o  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

of  the  capital  be  fashioned  with  its  tendrils  and  its  leaves, 
as  Vitruvius  directs  in  the  fourth  book,  where  he  records 
that  this  capital  has  been  taken  from  the  tomb  of  a 
Corinthian  girl.  Then  follow  its  proper  architrave,  frieze 
and  cornice  measured  as  he  describes,  all  carved  with  the 
modillions  and  ovolos  and  other  sorts  of  carving  under 
the  drip.  The  friezes  of  this  Order  may  be  carved  with 
leafage,  or  again  they  may  be  plain,  or  adorned  with 
letters  of  bronze  let  into  marble,  as  those  on  the  portico 
of  the  Ritonda.  There  are  twenty-six  flutes  in  the 
Corinthian  columns,  although  sometimes  also  there  are 
fewer,  and  the  fourth  part  of  the  width  of  each  flute  remains 
flat  between  every  two,  as  is  evident  in  many  ancient 
works  and  in  modern  works  copied  from  the  ancients. 

§   26.  The  Composite  Order. 

The  Composite  Order,  although  Vitruvius  has  not  made 
mention  of  it — having  taken  account  of  none  others  than 
the  Doric,  Ionic,  Corinthian,  and  Tuscan,  and  holding 
those  artists  lawless,  who,  taking  from  all  four  Orders, 
constructed  out  of  them  bodies  that  represented  to  him 
monsters  rather  than  men- — the  Composite  Order  has 
nevertheless  been  much  used  by  the  Romans  and  in 
imitation  of  them  by  the  moderns.  I  shall  therefore  pro- 
ceed, to  the  end  that  all  may  have  notice  of  it,  to  explain 
and  give  the  proportions  of  buildings  in  this  Order  also, 
for  I  am  convinced  of  this,  that  if  the  Greeks  and  Romans 
created  these  first  four  Orders  and  reduced  them  to  a 
general  rule  and  measure,  there  may  have  been  those  who 
I  have  done  the  same  for  the  Composite  Order,  forming 
'  of  it  things  much  more  graceful  than  ever  did  the  ancients. 
As  an  example  of  the  truth  of  this  I  quote  the  works 
of  Michelagnolo  Buonarroti  in  the  Sacristy  and  Library 
of  Sarr^Eorenzo  in  Florence,  where  the  doors,  niches, 
bases,  columns,  capitals,  mouldings,  consoles  and  indeed 
all  the  details,  have  received  from  him  something  of  the 
new  and  of  the  Composite  Order,   and  nevertheless  are 


THE  COMPOSITE  ORDER  8i 

wonderful,  not  to  say  beautiful.  The  same  merit  in  even 
greater  measure  is  exhibited  by  the  said  Michelagnolo  in 
the  second  story  of  the  Court  of  the  Casa  Farnese22  and 
again  in  the  cornice  which  supports  on  the  exterior  the 
roof  of  that  palace.  He  who  wishes  to  see  in  this  manner 
of  work  the  proof  of  this  man's  excellence — of  truly  celestial 
origin — in  art  and  design  of  various  kinds,  let  him  consider 
that  which  he  has  accomplished  in  the  fabric  of  St.  Peter's 
in  compacting  together  the  body  of  that  edifice  and  in  mak- 
ing so  many  sorts  of  various  and  novel  ornaments,  such 
beautiful  profiles  of  mouldings,  so  many  different  niches 
and  numerous  other  things,  all  invented  by  him  and 
treated  differently  from  the  custom  of  the  ancients.  There- 
fore no  one  can  deny  that  this  new  Composite  Order, 
which  through  Michelagnolo  has  attained  to  such  perfec- 
tion, may  be  worthily  compared  with  the  others.  In 
truth,  the  worth  and  capacity  of  this  truly  excellent 
sculptor,  painter,  and  architect  have  worked  miracles 
wherever  he  has  put  forth  his  hand.  Besides  all  the  other 
things  that  are  clear  as  daylight,  he  has  rectified  sites 
which  were  out  of  the  straight  and  reduced  to  perfection 
many  buildings  and  other  objects  of  the  worst  form, 
covering  with  lovely  and  fanciful  decoration  Jhe  defects 
^fjiature  and  ait.^^    In  our  days  certain  vulgar  architects, 

2=  See  Note  86,  ante,  p.  53. 

''''On  Michelangelo's  use  of  architectural  details  M.  Garnier  had  some  rather 
severe  remarks  in  the  Gazette  des  Beaux  Arts  for  Jan.  I,  1876.  He  denied  to 
him  an  understanding  of  the  grammar  of  the  use  of  such  forms.  It  is  generally 
admitted  that  for  the  details  of  the  JTarnese  cornice,  the  fittings  and  decoration 
of  the  Library  of  S.  Lorenzo,  and  other  such  works  to  which  his  name  attaches, 
he  was  indebted  to  professional  architects,  such  as  Vignola,  whom  he  employed. 
We  must  never  forget  however  that  we  owe  to  Michelangelo  the  dome  of  St 
Peter's,  one  of  the  greatest  architectural  creations  of  its  kind  in  the  world.  In 
mentioning  the  'siti  storti'  (sites  that  were  irregular  or  out  of  the  straight), 
Vasari  probably  had  in  view  the  design  for  laying  out  the  Capitol,"  which  is 
another  of  Michelangelo's  acknowledged  successes.  Here  the  existing  Palazzo 
dei  Conservatori  stood  somewhat  askew  and  the  site  was  regularized  to  corre- 
spond with  the  line  of  its  fagade.  All  this  about  Michelangelo  was  added  for  the 
second  edition,  after  Vasari  had  himself  worked  at  his  master's  staircase  at 
S.  Lorenzo. 

F 


82  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

not  considering  these  tilings  judiciously  and  not  imitating 
them,  have  worked  presumptuously  and  without  design 
almost  as  if  by  chance,  without  observing  ornament,  art, 
or  any  order.  All  their  things  are  monstrous  and  worse 
than  the  German. 

Returning  now  to  our  subject,  it  has  become  usual  for 
this  manner  of  work  to  be  called  by  some  the  *  Composite,' 
by  others  the  'Latin,'  and  by  others  again  the  'Italic' 
Order.  The  measure  of  the  height  of  this  column  must 
be  ten  heads,  the  base  the  half  of  the  diameter  of  the 
column,  measured  in  the  same  way  as  the  Corinthian 
column,  as  we  see  in  the  arch  of  Titus  Vespasianus  in 
Rome.  And  he  who  wishes  to  make  flutes  in  this  column 
can  do  so,  following  the  plan  of  the  Ionian  or  Corinthian 
column — or  in  any  way  that  pleases  him  who  adopts 
this  style  of  architecture,  which  is  a  mixture  of  all  the 
Orders.  The  capitals  may  be  made  like  those  of  the 
Corinthian  except  that  the  echinus  moulding  of  the  capital 
must  be  larger  and  the  volutes  or  tendrils  somewhat  larger, 
as  we  see  in  the  above  mentioned  arch.  The  architrave 
must  be  three  quarters  of  the  thickness  of  the  column 
and  the  rest  of  the  frieze  supplied  with  modillions,  and 
the  cornice  equal  to  the  architrave,  because  the  projection 
gives  the  cornice  an  increase  of  size,  as  one  sees  in  the 
uppermost  story  of  the  Roman  Colosseum ;  and  in  the 
said  modillions  grooves  can  be  cut  after  the  manner  of 
triglyphs,  and  there  can  be  other  carving  according  to  the 
taste  of  the  architect;  the  pedestal  on  which  the  column 
rests  must  be  two  squares  high,  with  the  mouldings  just 
as  he  pleases. 


§  27.  Of  Terminal  Figures. 

The  ancients_  were  accustomed  to  use  for  doors  or 
sepulchres  or  other  kinds  of  enrichment,  various  sorts  of 
terminal  figures  instead  of  columns,  here  a  figure  which 
has  a  basket  on  the  head  for  capital,  there  a  figure  down 


TERMINAL  FIGURES;    GOTHIC   ART         83 

to  the  waist,  the  rest,  towards  the  base,  a  cone  or  a  tree 
trunk ;  in  the  same  way  they  made  virgins,  chubby  infants, 
satyrs,  and  other  sorts  of  monsters  or  grotesque  objects, 
just  as  it  suited  them,  and  according  as  the  ideas  occurred 
to  them  so  the  works  were  put  into  operation. 


§  28.  German  Work  (the  Gothic  Style). 

We  come  at  last  to  another  sort  of  work  called  German, 
which  both  in  ornament  and  in  proportion  is  very  different 
from  the  ancient  and  the  modern.  Nor  is  it  adopted 
now  by  the  best  architects  but  is  avoided  by  them  as 
monstrous  and  barbarous,  and  lacking  everything  that 
can  be  called  order.  Nay  it  should  rather  be  called  con- 
fusion and  disorder.  In  their  buildings,  which  are  so 
numerous  that  they  sickened  the  world,  doorways  are 
ornamented  with  columns  which  are  slender  and  twisted 
like  a  screw,  and  cannot  have  the  strength  to  sustain  a 
weight,  however  light  it  may  be.  Also  on  all  the  fagades, 
and  wherever  else'  there  is  enrichment,  they  built  a  male- 
diction of  little  niches  one  above  the  other,  with  no  end 
of  pinnacles  and  points  and  leaves,  so  that,  not  to  speak 
of  the  whole  erection  seeming  insecure,  it  appears  impos- 
sible that  the  parts  should  not  topple  over  at  any  moment. 
Indeed  they  have  more  the  appearance  of  being  made 
of  paper  than  of  stone  or  marble.  In  these  works  they 
made  endless  projections  and  breaks  and  corbellings  and 
flourishes  that  throw  their  works  all  out  of  proportion ; 
and  often,  with  one  thing  being  put  above  another,  they 
reach  such  a  height  that  the  top  of  a  door  touches  the 
roof.  This  manner  was  the  invention  of  the  Goths,  for,\ 
after  they  had  ruined  the  ancient  buildings,  and  killed  1 
the  architects  in  the  wars,  those  who  were  left  constructed) 
the  buildings  in  this  style.^*    They  turned  the  arches  with 

"  See  Note  on  '  Vasari's  Opinion  on  Mediaeval  Architecture '  at  the  close  of  the 
'Introduction'  to  Architecture,  postea,  p.  133  f.     The  phrase  'this  manner  was  ^ 
the  invention  of  the  Goths,'  etc.,  is  historically  important  as  the  firsHntiodllCtioai 
into  literature  of  the  familiar  architectural  term  'Gothic' 


84  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

pointed  segments,  and  filled  all  Italy  with  these  abomina- 
tions of  buildings,  so  in  order  not  to  have  any  more  of 
them  their  style  has  been  totally  abandoned. 

May  God  protect  every  country  from  such  ideas  and 
style  of  buildings !  They  are  such  deformities  in  com- 
parison with  the  beauty  of  our  buildings  that  they  are 
not  worthy  that  I  should  talk  more  about  them,  and 
therefore  let  us  pass  on  to  speak  of  the  vaults. 


CHAPTER   IV. 

On  forming  Vaults  in  Concrete,  to  be  impressed  with  Enrichment :  when 
the  Centerings  are  to  be  removed,  and  how  to  mix  the  Plaster. 

§  29.  The  Construction  of  enriched  Stucco  Vaults. 

When  walls  have  reached  the  point  where  the  arches  of 
brick  or  light  stone  or  tufa  have  to  spring,  it  is  necessary 
to  turn  a  centering  with  planks  in  a  close  circle,  over  the 
framework  of  struts  or  boarding.  The  planks  are  fitted 
together  according  to  the  form  of  the  vault,  or  in  the 
shape  of  a  boat,  and  this  centering  for  the  vaults  must 
be  fixed  with  strong  props  in  whatever  mode  you  wish, 
so  that  the  material  above  does  not  strain  it  by  its  weight ; 
and  afterwards  every  crevice,  in  the  middle,  in  the  corners, 
and  everywhere,  must  be  firmly  stopped  up  with  clay  so 
that  when  the  concrete  is  spread  the  mixture  shall  not 
filter  through.  This  finished,  above  that  surface  of 
boards  they  make  caissons  of  wood,  which  are  to  be 
worked  contrariwise,  with  projections  where  a  hollow  is 
wanted;  in  the  same  way  let  the  mouldings  and  details 
that  we  wish  to  make  be  worked  by  opposites,  so  that 
when  the  material  is  cast,  it  may  come,  where  (the  mould 
is)  hollow,  in  relief;  where  in  relief,  hollow,  and  thus 
similarly  must  all  the  members  of  the  mouldings  be 
arranged.  Whether  the  vault  is  to  be  smooth  or  enriched, 
it  is  equally  necessary  to  have  shapes  of  wood,  which 
mould  the  desired  forms  in  clay;  with  this  clay  also  are 
made  the  square  panels  for  such  decoration,  and  these  are 
joined  the  one  to  the  other  on  the  flat  or  by  mouldings 
or  enriched  bands,  which  can  be  made  to  follow  the  line 
of  this  centering.  Having  finished  covering  it  all  with 
enrichments  of  clay,  formed  in  intaglio  and  fitted  together. 


86  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

as  was  said  above,  one  must  then  take  lime,  with  pozzolana 
earth  or  sand  riddled  finely,  mixed  liquid  and  mostly 
lime,  and  of  that  lay  evenly  a  coating  over  all,  till  every 
mould  is  full.  Afterwards,  above  this  coating  make  the 
vault  with  bricks,  raising  or  lowering  them  according  as 
the  vault  turns,  and  continually  adding  till  the  arch  be 
closed.  This  done,  it  must  all  be  left  to  set  and  get  firm, 
till  the  work  be  dry  and  solid. ^  Then  when  the  props  are 
removed  and  the  vault  is  left  free,  the  clay  is  easily  taken 
away  and  all  the  worJj  remains  modelled  and  worked  as 
if  done  in  stucco,  and  those  parts  that  have  not  come  out 
well  are  gone  over  with  stucco  till  they  are  complete.  In 
this  manner  have  been  executed  all  the  works  in  the  ancient 
edifices,  which  had  afterwards  stucco  enrichment  upon 
them.  This  the  moderns  have  done  to-day  in  the  vaults 
of  St.  Peter's,  and  many  other  masters  throughout  Italy 
have  done  the  same. 

§  30.  Stucco  made  with  Marble  Dust. 
Now  let  us  show  how  the  stucco  is  mixed  .^  Chips  of 
marble  are  pounded  in  a  stone  mortar ;  no  other  lime  is 
used  for  this  stucco  save  white  lime  made  either  of  marble 
chips  or  of  travertine ;  instead  of  sand  the  pounded  marble 
is  taken  and  is  sifted  finely  and  kneaded  with  the  lime, 
in  the  proportion  of  two  thirds  lime  to  one  third  pounded 
marble.  The  stucco  is  made  coarser  or  finer,  according 
as  one  wishes  to  work  coarsely  or  finely.  Enough  now 
of  stuccoes  because  the  rest  will  be  said  later,  when  I  shall 
treat  of  them  in  connection  with  Sculpture.  Before 
passing  to  this  subject,  we  shall  speak  briefly  of  fountains 
which  are  made  for  walls  and  of  their  various  ornaments. 

'Vasari  makes  no  provision  for  Tainding  together  the  vault  in  stucco  and 
that  in  brick.  Each  is  apparently  independent  of  the  other,  though  they  are 
in  contact,  and  no  keys  are  formed  in  the  upper  surface  of  the  stucEO  for  the 
purpose  of  tieing  it  to  the  brickwork  above. 

"  This  same  subject  is  treated  in  the  sixth  jchapter  of  the  '  Introduction '  to 
Sculpture  and  the  thirteenth  of  that  to  Painting.  In  connection  with  it  see 
Note  on  'Stucco  Grotesques'  at  the  close  of  the  'Introduction'  to  Painting, 
postea,  p.  sgg. 


CHAPTER  V. 

How  Rustic  Fountains  are  made  with  Stalactites  and  Incrustations  from 
water,  and  how  Cockle  shells  and  Conglomerations  of  vitrified  stone 
are  built  into  the  Stucco. 

§  31.  Grottoes  and  Fountains  of  '  Rocaille  '  work. 

The  fountains  which  the  ancients  made  for  their  palaces, 
gardens,  and  other  places,  were  of  different  kinds;  some 
stood  alone,  with  basins  and  vases  of  different  sorts,  others 
were  attached  to  the  walls,  and  bore  niches  with  masks, 
figures,  or  ornaments  suggesting  the  sea;  others  again 
for  use  in  hot  baths,  were  simpler  and  plainer,  and  finally 
others  resembled  woodland  springs  that  rise  naturally  in 
the  groves;  while  those  which  the  moderns  have  made 
and  continue  to  make  are  also  of  different  kinds.  The 
moderns,  always  varying  them,  have  added  to  the  inven- 
tions of  the  ancients,  compositions  of  Tuscan  work,^ 
covered  with  stalactites  from  petrified  waters,  which  hang 
down  resembling  roots,  formed  in  the  lapse  of  time  of  con- 
gelations of  such  waters  as  are  hard  and  are  charged  with 
sediment.  These  exist  not  only  at  Tivoli,  where  the  river 
Teverone  petrifies  the  branches  of  trees,  and  all  objects 
that  come  in  contact  with  it,  turning  them  into  gum-like 
exudations  and  stalactites;    but  also  at  the  lake  Pih  di 

^  The  '  Tuscan  work '  referred  to  here  is  the  same  thing  as  the  '  lavoro 
chiamato  rustico'  of  which  Vasari  writes  at  the  beginning  of  the  third  chapter 
(§  20).  The  so-called  Tuscan  Order  was  the  simplest  and  heaviest  of  all,  and 
so  most  suited  for  work  that  partook  of  the  rough  and  unpolished  character  of 
natural  rock.  For  the  same  reason,  as  was  seen  above,  ante,  p.  65,  the 
Tuscan  Order  lends  itself  best  to  association  with  bossy  or  'rusticated' 
masonry. 


88  OF   ARCHITECTURE 

Lupo,2  where  the  stalactites  are  very  large;  and  in 
Tuscany  at  the  river  Elsa,^  whose  water  makes  them  clear 
so  that  they  look  like  marble,  glass,  or  artificial  crystals. 
But  the  most  beautiful  and  curious  of  all  are  found  behind 
Monte  Morello*  also  in  Tuscany,  eight  miles  from 
Florence.  Of  this  sort  Duke  Cosimo  has  had  made  in 
his  garden  at  Olmo  near  Castello^  the  rustic  ornaments 
of  the  fountains  executed  by  the  s(^ulptor  Tribolo.  These 
stalactites  removed  from  where  nature  has  produced  them 
are  introduced  into  work  done  by  the  artificer  and  fixed 
with  iron  bars,  with  branches  soldered  with  lead  or  in 
some  other  way,  or  they  are  grafted  into  the  stones  so 
as  to  hang  suspended.  They  are  fixed  on  to  the  Tuscan 
work  in  such  a  way  as  to  leave  it  here  and  there  exposed 
to  view.  Then  by  adjusting  leaden  tubes  hidden  between 
these  stalactites,  and  distributing  holes  among  them,  jets 
of  water  are  made  to  pour  out,  when  a  key  at  the  entrance 
of  the  conduit  is  turned;  and  thus  are  arranged  pipes 
for  water  and  various  jets  through  which  the  water  rains 
I  down  among  the  incrustations  of  these  stalactites,  and  in 
falling  sounds  sweet  to  the  ear  and  is  beautiful  to  the  eye. 
There  is  also  another  kind  of  grotto,  of  a  more  rustic 
fashion,  imitating  sylvan  fountains  in  the  following  way. 
Some  take  sponge-like  stones  and  joining  them  together 

^  Fife  di  Lupo.  This  is  clearly  a  mistake  for  Fife  di  Lugo,  for  at  the  lake  of 
that  name  above  the  great  Cascade  of  Terni,  there  are  appearances  corre' 
sponding  exactly  with  what  Vasari  says.  It  is  remarked  in  Hare's  Days  near 
Rome,  II,  p.  141,  that  the  waters  of  the  Vellino,  which  makes  the  fall,  are 
'so  strongly  impregnated  with  carbonate  of  lime,  that  they  constantly  tend  to 
form  a  deposit  of  travertine,  and  so  to  block  up  their  own  channel.' 

'The  Elsa  flows  from  the  Apennines  by  CoUe  and  Castelfiorentino  to  join 
the  Arno  by  S.  Miniato,  halfway  between  Florence  and  Pisa.  The  valley  was 
the  birthplace  of  Cennino  Cennini,  the  author  of  the  Trattato. 

*  Monte    Morello,    3065    ft.,    is    the    conspicuous    height    to    the    north    of 
Florence,  which  serves  the  populace  for  a  weather-glass. 
'  Quando  Monte  Morello 
Ha  il  cappello 
Frendi  I'ombrello.' 

"  A  few  miles  to  the  north  west  of  Florence. 


GROTTOES   AND   FOUNTAINS  89 

sow  grass  over  them,  thus,  with  an  order  which  appears 
disorder  and  wild,  the  grottoes  are  rendered  very  natural 
and  real.  Others  make  smoother  and  more  polished 
grottoes  of  stucco,  in  which  are  mingled  both  stones  and 
stucco,  and  while  the  stucco  is  fresh  they  insert,  in  bands 
and  compartments,  knobs  •  or  bosses,  cockle  shells,  sea 
snails,  tortoise  shells,  shells  large  and  small,  some  showing 
the  outside  and  some  the  reverse :  and  of  these  they  make 
flower  vases  and  festoons,  in  which  the  cockle  shells 
represent  the  leaves,  and  other  varieties  of  shells  the 
fruit ;  ^  and  to  these  they  add  shells  of  turtles,  as  is  seen 
in  the  vineyard  at  the  foot  of  Monte  Mario  that  Pope 
Clement  VII,  when  still  Cardinal,  had  made  by  the  advice 
of  Giovanni  da  Udine.'' 

Again  a  rustic  and  very  beautiful  mosaic  in  many 
colours  is  made  by  using  little  bits  of  old  bricks  that  have 
been  too  much  baked,  and  pieces  of  glass  which  has  run 
owing  to  the  pans  of  glass  bursting  in  an  overheated 
furnace.  The  work  is  done  by  sticking  these  bits  into 
the  stucco  on  the  wall  as  was  said  above,  and  arranging 
between  them  corals  and  other  spoils  from  the  sea,  things 
in  themselves  full  of  grace  and  beauty.  Thus  are  made 
animals  and  figures,  covered  with  the  shells  already 
mentioned  as  well  as  with  coloured  pastes  in  various  pieces 
arranged  in  rustic  fashion,  very  quaint  to  look  upon. 
There  have  been  many  fountains  of  this  kind  recently 
set  up  at  Rome,  which  by  their  charm  have  incited  the 

*  These  fanciful  conceits  have  a  significance  for  the  history  of  ornament  which 
they  hardly  seem  to  deserve.  Artificial  grottoes  of  the  kind  Vasari  describes 
were  very  popular  in  the  France  of  the  eighteenth  century,  and  pleased  the 
taste  of  the  sophisticated  society  of  the  time  with  an  artificial  'nature,'  that 
corresponded  to  the  affected  pastoral  style  in  literature.  From  the  shell  and 
stalactite  decoration  of  these  grottoes  was  evolved  the  ornamental  style 
characteristic  of  the  age  of  Louis  XV,  the  shell-like  forms  of  which  betray  its 
origin.  The  name  commonly  given  to  this  ornament,  that  consists  in  little  but 
a  graceful  play  of  curved  forms,  is  '  rococo,'  and  this  word  is  connected  with 
'  rocaille,'  a  regular  French  term  for  fantastic  grotto-work  of  the  kind  here 
under  notice. 

'The  well-known  'Villa  Madama.' 


90  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

minds  of  countless  persons  to  be  lovers  of  such  work. 
Another  kind  of  ornament  entirely  rustic  is  also  used 
now-a-days  for  fountains,  and  is  applied  in  the  following 
manner.  First  the  skeleton  of  the  figure  or  any  other 
object  desired  is  made  and  plastered  over  with  mortar  or 
stucco,  then  the  exterior  is  covered  in  the  fashion  of 
mosaic,  with  pieces  of  white  or  coloured  marble,  according 
to  the  object  designed,  or  else  with  certain  little  many 
coloured  pebbles  :  and  these  when  carefully  worked  have 
a  long  life.  The  stucco  with  which  they  build  up  and 
work  these  things  is  the  same  that  we  have  before 
described,  and  when  once  set  it  holds  them  securely  on 
the  walls.  To  such  fountains  pavements  are  made  of 
sling-stones,  that  is,  round  and  flat  river  pebbles,  set  on 
edge  and  in  ripples  as  water  goes,  with  excellent  effect. 
Others,  for  the  finer  fountains,  make  pavements  with  little 
tiles  of  terra  cotta  in  various  divisions  and  glazed  in  the 
fire,  as  in  clay  vases  painted  in  various  colours  and  with 
painted  ornaments  and  leafage ;  but  this  sort  of  pavement 
is  more  suitable  for  hot-air  chambers  and  baths  than  for 
fountains.^ 

8  One  of  the  best  existing  examples  of  these  '  rustic '  grottoes  and  fountains  is 
that  constructed  by  Buontalenti  in  the  Boboli  Gardens  near  the  eastern  entrance. 
As  part  of  its  decoration  there  are  Wit  in  four  marble  figures,  supposed  to  have 
been  sketched  out  by  Michelangelo  for  the  tomb  of  Julius.  A  view  of  the 
interior  of  this  grotto  is  given  on  Plate  IV.  The  statue  in  the  corner  is  one  of 
the  four  noticed  above,  while  a  little  above  it  and  to  the  left  is  one  of  the 
grotesque  figures  incrusted  with  odds  and  ends,  which  Vasari  praises  as  so 
fascinating. 


< 
l-l 


o 
z 
w 
p< 
o 
ij 

li. 
IZ 

w 
o 


f^     o 


1-1 
O 

M 
O 


o 

H 
H 
O 

P^ 
O 

o 
o 


si 
2; 


CHAPTER  VI. 

On  the  manner  of  making  Pavements  of  Tesselated  Work. 

§  32.  Mosaic  Pavements. 

There  are  no  possible  devices  in  any  department  that 
the  ancients  did  not  find  out  or  at  any  rate  try  very  hard 
to  discover, — devices  I  mean  that  bring  delight  and 
refreshment  to  the  eyes  of  men.  They  invented  then, 
among  other  beautiful  things,  stone  pavements  diversified 
with  various  blendings  of  porphyry,  serpentine,  and 
granite,  with  round  and  square  or  other  divisions,  whence 
they  went  on  to  conceive  the  fabrication  of  ornamental 
bands,  leafage,  and  other  sorts  of  designs  and  figures. 
Therefore  to  prepare  the  work  the  better  to  receive  such 
treatment,  they  cut  the  marble  into  little  pieces,  so  that 
these  being  small  they  could  be  turned  about  for  the  back- 
ground and  the  field,  in  round  schemes  or  lines  straight 
or  twisted,  as  came  most  conveniently.  From  the  joining 
together  of  these  pieces  they  called  the  work  mosaic,^  and 

'The  ultimate  derivation  of  the  word  'mosaic'  is  a  difficult  problem.  Its 
immediate  parent  is  the  late- Latin  '  musivum '  which  is  generally  connected 
with  the  Greek  liovo-eior,  meaning  a  '  place  of  the  Muses.'  With  this  significance, 
the  Greek  word  in  its  Latinized  form, '  museum '  is  suitably  applied  to  collections 
of  works  of  art  and  similar  objects  of  aesthetic  interest  and  value.  A  '  place 
of  the  Muses'  may  however  be  of  a  different  kind.  The  Muses,  like  other 
nymphs,  were  worshipped  in  grottoes  as  guardian  genii  of  fountains,  and  Pliny, 
ffist.  Nat.,  XXXVI,  21,  writes  of  '  erosa  saxa  in  aedificiis,  quae  musaea  vocant, 
dependentia  ad  imaginem  specus  arte  reddendam,'  where  the  suggestion  is  of 
a  rustic  grotto  like  that  in  the  Boboli  Gardens.  Such  grottoes,  natural  or 
artificial,  might  fittingly  be  decked  with  shells  and  coloured  stones  and  any 
bright  inlay  that  offered  itself.  If  incrustations  of  the  kind  we  call  mosaic 
were  actually  met  with  in  these  haunts  of  the  Muses,  the  work  might  readily 


92  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

used  it  in  the  pavements  of  many  of  their  buildings,  as 
we  still  see  in  the  Baths  of  Caracalla  in  Rome  and  in 
other  places,  where  the  mosaic  is  made  with  little  squares 
of  marble,  that  form  leaves,  masks,  and  other  fancies, 
while  the  background  for  these  is  composed  of  squares 
of  white  marble  and  other  small  squares  of  black.  The 
work  was  set  about  in  the  following  manner.  First  was 
spread  a  layer  of  fresh  stucco  of  lime  and  marble  dust 
thick  enough  to  hold  firmly  in  itself  the  pieces  fitting  into 
each  other,  so  that  when  set  they  could  be  polished  smooth 
on  the  top;  these  in  the  drying  make  an  admirably  com- 
pacted concrete,  which  is  not  hurt  by  the  wear  of  foot- 
steps nor  by  water.  Therefore  this  work  having  come 
into  the  highest  estimation,  clever  people  set  themselves 
to  study  it  further,  as  it  is  always  easy  to  add  something 
valuable  to  an  invention  already  found  out.  So  they  made 
the  marble  mosaics  finer,  and  of  these,  laid  pavements 
both  for  baths  and  for  hot  rooms,  and  with  the  most 
subtle  mastery  and  diligence  they  delicately  fashioned 
various  fishes  in  them,  and  imitated  painting  with  many 

be  called  by  a  name  suggestive  of  these  same  nymphs,  and  this  might  be 
applied  later  on  to  tesselated  work  in  general.  There  is  however  no  proof, 
either  in  Pliny  or  elsewhere,  that  what  we  call  mosaic  was  actually  so  used, 
and  it  has  been  questioned  by  more  than  one  authority  whether  there  is 
really  any  connection  between  the  word  'mosaic,'  in  its  various  forms,  and 
the  Muses.     An  oriental  derivation  has  even  been  suggested  for  the  term. 

Dr.  Albert  Ilg,  in  an  exceedingly  learned  paper  on  the  subject  in  the  Wiener 
Quellenschrifien,  Neue  Folge,  v,  158  f.,  offered  an  entirely  new  explanation 
of  the  word  'mosaic,'  which  he  maintained  had  in  its  original  sense  nothing 
to  do  with  inlaid  work  at  all,  but  rather  with  gilding.  He  connected  it  with  a 
root  'mus'  or  'mos,'  with  a  sense  of  'beating'  or  'grinding,'  and  instanced 
the  mediaeval  Latin  term  '  mosnerium,'  which  Ducange  notices  as  equivalent 
to  'molendinum,'  'mill.'  '  Musivum  opus'  would  refer  on  this  view  to  the 
gilding  process  in  which  the  gold  is  ground  to  powder  or  beaten  out ;  and 
Ilg  affirmed  '  Musaicum  im  alten  Sinne  kann  nur  eigentlich  Vergoldung,  nicht 
das  moderne  Mosaik,  bezeichnen.'  If  the  word  at  first  meant  'gilded  work' 
it  would  later  on  be  extended  to  what  we  know  as  'mosaic,'  because  of  the 
use  in  mediaeval  mosaics  of  the  familiar  gold  background.  The  argument  of 
Dr.  Ilg  is  not  convincing,  and  the  question  must  be  considered  still  open. 
Theophilus,  for  example,  Lib.  II,  c.  12,  uses  'musivum  opus'  for  inlaid  work 
in  which  there  is  no  question  of  gold. 


MOSAIC   FOR  FLOORS   AND  WALLS         93 

colours  suitable  for  that  work,  and  with  many  different 
sorts  of  marbles,  introducing  also  among  these  some  pieces 
cut  into  little  mosaic  squares  of  the  bones  of  fishes  which 
have  a  lustrous  surface.^  And  so  life-like  did  they  make 
the  fishes,  that  water  placed  above  them,  veiling  them  a 
little,  even  though  clear,  made  them  appear  actually  alive 
in  the  pavements;  as  is  seen  in  Parione  in  Rome,  in  the 
house  of  Messer  Egidio  and  Fabio  Sasso.^ 


§  33-  Pictorial  Mosaics  for  Walls,  etc. 

Therefore,  this  mosaic  work  appearing  to  them  a  picture, 
capable  of  resisting  to  all  eternity  water,  wind,  and  sun- 
shine, and  because  they  considered  such  work  much  more 
effective  far  off  than  near,  the  ancients  disposed  it  so  as 
to  decorate  vaults  and  walls,  where  such  things  had  to 
be  seen  at  a  distance,  for  at  a  distance  one  would  not 
perceive  the  pieces  of  mosaic  which  when  near  are  easily 
distinguished.  Then  because  the  mosaics  were  lustrous 
and  withstood  water  and  damp,  it  was  thought  that  such 
work  might  be  made  of  glass,  and  so  it  was  done,  and 
producing  hereby  the  most  beautiful  effect  they  adorned 
their  temples  and  other  places  with  it,  as  we  still  see  in 
our  own  days  at  Rome  in  the  Temple  of  Bacchus*  and 
elsewhere.^  Just  as  from  marble  mosaics  are  derived 
those  which  we  now  call  in  our  time  glass  mosaics,  so 
from  the  mosaic  of  glass  we  have  passed  on  to  egg-shell 

^  Possibly  what  we  call  '  mother  of  pearl.' 

'See  Note  on  'The  Sassi,  della  Valle,  and  other  Collections,'  etc.,  postea, 
p.  102  f.  The  mosaic  here  noticed  is  unfortunately  lost.  Lanciani,  TAe  Golden 
Days  of  the  Renaissance  in  Rome,  igo6,  p.  234,  states  that  he  has  searched  for  it 
in  vain. 

^  See  Note  J,  ante,  p.  27. 

"  Mosaics  made  up  of  'small  'cubes  of  coloured  or  gilded  glass  are  abundant 
in  early  Christian  and  Byzantine  times,  but  were  also  used,  though  sparingly, 
by  the  Romans  from  the  time  of  Augustus  downwards.  See  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat., 
XXXVI,  189,  who  fixes  the  time  of  their  introduction. 


94  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

mosaic,^  and  from  this  to  the  mosaic  in  which  figures  and 
groups  in  light  and  shade  are  formed  entirely  of  tesserae, 
though  the  effect  is  like  painting;  this  we  shall  describe 
in  its  own  place  in  the  chapters  on  that  art.^ 

°  Egg-shell  mosaic.     See  Note,  postea,  p.  136. 

'  See  Chapters  xv  and  xvi  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Painting.  The  pavement 
of  the  cathedral  of  Siena  exhibits  a  large  collection  of  such  mosaics  in  black 
and  white  executed  in  different  technical  processes. 


CHAPTER   VII. 

How  one  is  to  recognize  if  a  Building  have  good  Proportions,  and  of 
what  Members  it  should  generally  be  composed. 

§  34.  The  principles  of  Planning  and  Design. 

But  since  talking  of  particular  things  would  make  me 
turn  aside  too  much  from  my  purpose,  I  leave  this  minute 
consideration  to  the  writers  on  architecture,  and  shall  only 
say  in  general  how  good  buildings  can  be  recognized,  and 
what  is  requisite  to  their  form  to  secure  both  utility  and 
beauty.  Suppose  then  one  comes  to  an  edifice  and  wishes^ 
to  see  whether  it  has  been  planned  by  an  excellent  architect 
and  how  much  ability  he  has  shown,  also  whether  the 
architect  has  known  how  to  accommodate  himself  to  the 
site,  as  well  as  to  the  wishes  of  him  who  ordered  the 
structure  to  be  built,  one  must  consider  the  following^ 
questions.  First,  whether  he  who  has  raised  it  from  the 
foundation  has  thought  if  the  spoti  were  a  suitable  one 
and  capable  of  receiving  buildings  of  that  style  and  extent, 
and  (granted  that  the  site  is  suitable)  how  the  building 
should  be  divided  into  rnnms^  and  how  the  enrichment 
on  the  walls  be  disposed  in  view  of  the  nature  of  the  site 
which  may  be  extensive  or  confined,  elevated  or  low-lying. 
One  must  consider  also  whether  the  edifice  has  been  taste- 
fully arranged  and  in  convenient  proportion,  and  whether 
there  has  Been  furnished  and  distributed  the  proper  kind 
and  number  of  columns,  windows,  doors,  and  junctions 
of  wall-faces,  both  within  and  without,  in  the  given  height 
and  thickness  of  the  walls;  in  short  whether  every  detail 
is  suitable  in  and  for  its  own  place.     It  is  necessary  that 


96  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

there  should  be  distributed  throughout  the  building, 
rooms  which  have  their  proper  arrangement  of  doors, 
windows,  passages,  secret  staircases,  anterooms,  lavatories, 
cabinets,  and  that  no  mistakes  be  apparent  therein.  For 
example  there  should  be  a  large  hall,  a  small  portico  or 
lesser  apartments,  which  being  members  of  the  edifice, 
must  necessarily,  even  as  members  of  the  human  body, 
be  equally  arranged  and  distributed  according  to  the  style 
and  complexity  of  the  buildings.;  just  as  there  are  temples 
round,  or  octagonal,  or  six  sided,  or  square,  or  in  the 
form  of  a  cross,  and  also  various  Orders,  according  to 
the  position  and  rank  of  the  person  who  has  the  buildings 
constructed,  for  when  designed  by  a  skilful  hand  these 
exhibit  very  happily  the  excellence  of  the  workman  and 
the  spirit  of  the  author  of  the  fabric. 

§  35.  An  ideal  Palace. 
To  make  the  matter  clearer,  let  us  here  imagine  a 
palace,^  and  this  will  give  us  light  on  other  buildings, 
so  that  we  may  be  able  to  recognize,  when  we  see  them, 
whether  they  are  well  fashioned  or  no.  First,  then,  if  we 
consider  the  principal  front,  we  shall  see  it  raised  from 
the  ground  either  above  a  range  of  outside  stairs  or  base- 
ment walls,  so  that  standing  thus  freely  the  building 
should  seem  to  rise  with  grandeur  from  the  ground,  while 
the  kitchens  and  cellars  under  ground  are  more  clearly 
lighted  and  of  greater  elevation.  This  also  greatly 
protects  the  edifice  from  earthquakes  and  other  accidents 
of  fortune.  Then  it  must  represent  the  body  of  a  man 
in  the  whole  and  similarly  in  the  parts;  and  as  it  has 
to  fear  wTh37  water,  and  other  natural  forces  it  should  be 
drained  with  sewers,  that  must  be  all  in  connection  with 
a  central  conduit  that  carries  away  all  the  filth  and  smells 
that  might  generate  sickness.  In  its  first  aspect  the  fa9ade 
demands  beauty  and  grandeur,  and  should  be  divided  as 
is  the  face  of  a  man.     The  door  must  be  low  down  and 

1  See  Note  on   '  Ideal  Architecture '  at  the  close  of  the   '  Introduction '  to 
Architecture,  postea,  p.   138. 


AN    IDEAL   PALACE  97 

in  the  middle,  as  in  the  head  the  mouth  of  the  man, 
through  which  passes  every  sort  of  food;  the  windows 
for  the  eyes,  one  on  this  side,  one  on  that,  observing 
always  parity,  that  there  be  as  much  ornament,  and  as 
many  arches,  columns,  pilasters,  niches,  jutting  windows, 
or  aay  other  sort  of  enrichment,  on  this  side  as  on  that; 
regard  being  had  to  the  proportions  and  Orders  already 
explained,  whether  Doric,  Ionic,  Corinthian,  or  Tuscan. 
The  cornice  which  supports  the  roof  must  be  made  pro- 
portionate to  the  fa9ade  according  to  its  size,  that  rain- 
water may  not  drench  the  fafade  and  him  who  is  seated 
at  the  street  front.  The  projection  must  be  in  proportion 
to  the  height  and  breadth  of  the  fa9ade.  Entering  within, 
let  the  first  vestibule  have  a  great  amplitude,  and  let  it 
be  arranged  to  join  fittingly  with  the  entrance  corridor, 
through  which  everything  passes;  let  it  be  free  and  wide, 
so  that  the  press  of  horses  or  of  crowds  on  foot,  that 
often  congregate  there,  shall  not  do  themselves  any  hurt 
in  the  entrance  on  fete  days  or  on  other  brilliant  occasions. 
The  court-yard,  representing  the  trunk,  should  be  square 
and  equal,  or  else  a  square  and  a  half,  like  all  the  parts 
of  the  body,  and  within  there  should  be  doors  and  well- 
arranged  apartments  with  beautiful  decoration.  The 
public  staircase  needs  to  be  convenient  and  easy  to  ascend, 
of  spacious  width  and  ample  height,  but  only  in  accordance 
with  the  proportion  of  the  other  parts.  Besides  all  this, 
the  staircases  should  be  adorned  or  copiously  furnished 
with  lights,  and,  at  least  over  every  landing-place  where 
there  are  turns,  should  have  windows  or  other  apertures. 
In  short,  the  staircases  demand  an  air  of  magnificence 
in  every  part,  seeing  that  many  people  see  the  stairs  and 
not  the  rest  of  the  house.  It  may  be  said  that  they  are 
the  arms  and  legs  of  the  body,  therefore  as  the  arms  are 
at  the  sides  of  a  man  so  ought  the  stairs  to  be  in  the 
wings  of  the  edifice.  Nor  shall  I  omit  to  say  that  the 
height  of  the  risers  ought  to  be  one  fifth  of  a  braccio  at 
least,^  and  every  tread  two  thirds  wide,^  that  is,  as  has 

^  That  is,  about  44  inches.  "  About  15J  inches. 

G 


98  OF  ARCHITECTURE 

been  said,  in  the  stairs  of  public  buildings  and  in  others 
in  proportion;  because  when  they  are  steep  neither 
children  nor  old  people  can  go  up  them,  and  they  make 
the  legs  ache.  This  feature  is  most  difificult  to  place  in 
buildings,  and  notwithstanding  that  it  is  the  most  fre- 
quented and  most  common,  it  often  happens  that  in  order 
to  save  the  rooms  the  stairs  are  spoiled.  It  is  also 
necessary  that  the  reception  rooms  and  other  apartments 
downstairs  should  form  one  common  hall  for  the  summer, 
with  chambers  to  accommodate  many  persons,  while 
upstairs  the  parlours  and  saloons  and  the  various  apart- 
ments should  all  open  into  the  largest  one.  In  the  same 
manner  should  be  arranged  the  kitchens  and  other  places, 
because  if  there  were  not  this  order  and  if  the  whole 
composition  were  broken  up,  one  thing  high,  another  low, 
this  great  and  that  small,  it  would  represent  lame  men, 
halt,  distorted,  and  maimed.  Such  works  would  merit 
only  blame,  and  no  praise  whatever.  When  there  are 
decorated  wall-faces  either  external  or  internal,  the  com- 
positions must  follow  the  rules  of  the  Orders  in  the  matter 
of  the  columns,  so  that  the  shafts  of  the  columns  be  not 
too  long  nor  slender,  not  over  thick  nor  short,  but  that 
the  dignity  of  the  several  Orders  be  always  observed. 
Nor  should  a  heavy  capital  or  base  be  connected  with  a 
slender  column,  but  in  proportion  to  the  body  must  be 
the  members,  that  they  may  have  an  elegant  and  beautiful 
appearance  and  design.  /All  these  things  are  best  appreci- 
ated by  a  correct  eye,  which,  if  it  have  discrimination,  can 
hold  the  true  compasses  and  estimate  exact  measurements, 
because  by  it  alone  shall  be  awarded  praise  or  blame./ 
And  this  is  enough  to  have  said  in  a  general  sense  Oi 
architecture,  because  to  speak  of  it  in  any  other  way  is 
not  matter  for  this  place. 


NOTES   ON   'INTRODUCTION'   TO 
ARCHITECTURE 


NOTES   ON   'INTRODUCTION'   TO 
ARCHITECTURE 

PORPHYRY  AND  PORPHYRY  QUARRIES. 

[See  ^  2,  Of  Porphyry,  ante,  p.  26.] 

Porphyry,  which  is  mineralogically  described  as  consistingf 
of  crystals  of  plagioclase  felspar  in  a  purple  felspathic  paste, 
is  a  very  hard  stone  of  beautiful  colour  susceptible  of  a  high 
polish.  'No  material,'  it  has  been  said,  'can  approach  it, 
either  in  colour,  fineness  of  grain,  hardness  or  toughness. 
When  used  alone  its  colour  is  always  grand ;  and  in  combina- 
tion with  any  other  coloured  material,  although  displaying  its 
nature  conspicuously,  it  is  always  harmonious  '  (Transactions, 
Royal  Institute  of  British  Architects,  1887,  p.  48).  Though 
obtained,  as  Vasari  knew,  from  Egypt,  it  was  not  known  to 
the  dynastic  Egyptians,  but  was  exploited  with  avidity  by  the 
Romans  of  the  later  imperial  period.  The  earliest  mention  of 
it  seems  to  be  in  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xxxvi,  11,  under  the  name 
'  porphyrites  '  and  statues  in  the  material  were  according  to 
this  author  sent  for  the  first  time  to  Rome  from  Egypt  in  the 
reign  of  Claudius.  The  new  material  was  however  not 
approved  of,  and  for  some  time  was  by  no  means  in  fashion. 
It  was  not  indeed  till  the  age  of  the  Antonines  that  as  Helbig 
remarks  '  the  preference  for  costly  and  rare  varieties  of  stone, 
without  reference  to  their  adaptability  for  sculpture,  began  to 
spread. '  After  this  epoch,  the  taste  for  porphyry  and  other 
such  strongly  marked  or  else  intractable  materials  grew  till 
it  became  a  passion,  and  the  Byzantine  emperors  carried  on 
the  tradition  of  its  use  inherited  by  them  from  the  later  days 
of   paganism.     The   material   was    quarried   in   the   mountains 


I02  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

known  as  Djebel  Duchan  near  the  coast  of  the  Red  Sea, 
almost  opposite  the  southern  point  of  the  peninsula  of  Sinai, 
and  the  Romans  carried  the  blocks  a  distance  of  nearly  loo 
miles  to  Koptos  on  the  Nile  whence  they  were  transported 
down  stream  to  Alexandria,  where  Mr  Brindley  thinks  there 
would  be  reserve  dep6ts  where  lapidaries  and  artists  resided, 
a  source  of  supply  for  the  large  quantities  used  by  Constantine. 
The  same  authority  estimates  that  there  must  be  about  300 
monolith  porphyry  pillars  still  extant  in  Europe,  the  finest 
being  the  eight  great  columns  under  the  side  apses  in  S. 
Sophia,  Constantinople.  The  most  important  of  all  porphyry 
monuments  is  the  column,  100  feet  high,  which  Constantine 
erected  at  Constantinople  where  it  still  stands  though  somewhat 
mutilated  and  damaged  by  fire.  It  consisted  in  nine  cylindrical 
drums  each  11  feet  long  and  11  feet  in  diameter. 

The  quarries,  as  Vasari  later  on  remarks,  were  in  his  time 
not  known,  and  seem  never  to  have  been  worked  since  the 
time  of  the  Romans.  The  site  of  them  was  visited  by  Sir 
Gardner  Wilkinson  in  1823,  and  they  were  re-discovered  by 
Mr  Brindley  in  1887.  If  they  are  again  to  be  worked,  the 
material  will  now  be  transferred  to  the  Red  Sea  coast,  distant 
only  about  20  miles.  Mr  Brindley's  account  of  his  expedition, 
with  notes  on  the  material,  is  contained  in  the  Transactions 
of  the  Royal  Institute  of  British  Architects  for  1888. 

THE  SASSI,  DELLA  VALLE,  AND  OTHER  COLLECTIONS 
OF  ANTIQUES  OF  THE  EARLY  PART  OF  THE 
SIXTEENTH   CENTURY. 

[See  §§2,  32,  ante,  pp.  28,  93.] 

In  chapters  i  and  vi  of  the  '  Introduction  '  to  Architecture 
Vasari  refers  to  the  '  casa  di  Egizio  e  di  Fabio  Sasso '  and 
the  '  casa  di  messer  Egidio  e  Fabio  Sasso  '  '  in  Parione. ' 
Parione  is  that  one  of  the  14  wards  or  '  rioni  '  of  Rome  that 
lies  to  the  south  of  the  Piazza  Navona,  and  according  to 
Gregorovius  {Geschichte  der  Stadt  Rom  im  Mittelalter,  Stutt., 
1886,  etc..  Ill,  537)  the  name  is  connected  with  the  Latin 
'parietes,'  'walls,'  and  was  derived  from  the  ruins  of  the 
Theatre  of  Pompeius,  that  bulked  largely  within  its  borders. 


EARLY   COLLECTIONS   OF  ANTIQUES      103 

There  is  now  a  '  Via  Parione '  to  the  west  of  the  Piazza 
Navona,  but  older  plans  of  near  Vasari's  time  show  that  the 
name  was  then  applied  to  the  more  important  thoroughfare 
south  of  the  piazza,  which  is  now  called  '  Via  del  Governo 
Vecchio. '  The  truth  is  that  the  present  Via  Parione  should 
be  called,  as  marked  on  older  maps,  '  Via  di  S.  Tommaso  in 
Parione,'  beside  which  church  it  runs,  and  should  not  have 
been  allowed  to  usurp  the  old  historical  name. 

Among  the  families  noted  by  Gregorovius  as  inhabiting  this 
region  were  the  Sassi,  who,  he  says  (vii,  708),  possessed  there 
'  a  great  palace  with  many  antiques. '  A  notice  of  the  Sassi, 
in  the  Archivio  della  R.  Societa  Romana  di  Storia  Patria, 
Roma,  vol.  xx,  p.  479,  tells  us  that  they  were  among  the  most 
illustrious  families  of  the  '  rione. '  In  1157  one  Giovanni  Sassi 
was  a  senator  of  Rome,  and  the  family  was  especially  flourish- 
ing in  the  fifteenth  century,  but  later  on  declined.  Branches 
of  the  Sassi  stock  still  exist.  When  Vasari  was  in  Rome  in 
the  service  of  the  Cardinal  Ippolito  de'  Medici,  about  1530,  one 
branch  at  any  rate  of  the  family  was  represented  by  a  certain 
Fabio  Sasso  and  his  brother,  whom  Vasari  calls  '  Egidius  ' 
but  who  appears  in  a  document  quoted  by  Lanciani  (Storia 
degli  Scavi  di  Roma,  Roma,  1902,  i,  177)  as  'Decidius,'  who 
possessed  the  family  palace  with  its  antiques,  situated  a  little 
west  of  S.  Tommaso  in  Parione.  When  Michaelis  wrote  the 
paper  presently  to  be  noticed,  the  exact  situation  of  the  palace 
was  not  identified,  but  the  Conte  Gnoli,  the  learned  and 
courteous  director  of  the  Biblioteca  Vittorio  Emanuele,  has 
pointed  out  the  remains  of  the  Sassi  habitation  at  No.  48  in 
the  present  Via  del  Governo  Vecchio,  where  an  early  Renais- 
sance doorway  bears  above  it  the  cognizance  of  the  family, 
and  below  on  one  jamb  the  syllable  '  Dom  '  and  on  the  other 
'  Sax  '  (Domus  Saxorum).  The  house  in  general,  which  is 
claimed  by  legend  as  the  residence  of  Raphael's  Fornarina, 
has  been  reconstructed.  The  plan.  Fig.  8,  is  taken  from 
a  large  map  of  Rome  dating  1748  and  shows  this  particularly 
interesting  portion  of  the  city  as  it  was  before  recent  changes. 
The  line  of  the  present  Corso  Vittorio  Emanuele  is  shown 
by  dotted  strokes. 

By  the  middle  of  the  sixteenth  century  the  family  fortunes 


104  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

had  declined,  and  in  his  will  made  in  1556  Fabio  records  that 
he  had  let  all  his  three  houses  in  Parione.  This  may  account 
for  the  fact  that  no  Palazzo  Sassi  occurs  in  the  lists  of  Roman 
palaces  of  the  seventeenth  century.  Furthermore,  in  1546 
the  two  brothers  effected  a  sale  of  their  antiques  to  the  Duke 
Ottavio  Farnese,  who  transferred  them  to  the  then  newly 
erected  Farnese  palace.  See  text  of  Vasari,  ante  p.  28,  and 
Lanciani,  I.e. 

When  Vasari  first  knew  the  Sassi  collection  it  was  one  of 
the  best  in  Rome,  and  Michaelis  (Jahrbuch  d.  deutschen 
Archeologischen  Instituts,  1891,  p.  170)  quotes  two  writers  of 
the  early  part  of  the  century  who  praise  it.  Moreover  there 
exists  a  contemporary  drawing  of  the  antiques  and  the  court 
in  which  they  were  kept,  that  Michaelis  (I.e.)  has  published. 
The  early  notices  just  referred  to,  and  the  notes  of  Aldovrandi 
(Mauro,  Le  Antichita  della  Citta  di  Roma,  Venet.  1556,  p.  147) 
who  saw  the  works  in  the  Farnese  collection  in  1550,  give 
prominence  to  the  two  pieces  that  are  specially  mentioned  by 
Vasari.  The  '  figura  a  sedere  di  braccia  tre  e  mezzo '  in 
porphyry  (ante,  p.  28)  is  described  by  Aldovrandi  (p.  147)  as 
'  un  bellissimo  simulacro  di  una  Roma  trionfante  assisa,'  partly 
in  porphyry  and  partly  in  bronze,  and  as  having  been  formerly 
in  the  house  of  Messer  Fabio  Sasso.  The  statue  has  passed 
with  the  Farnese  antiques  to  Naples,  where  it  was  numbered 
when  Michaelis  wrote,  212  b.  It  is  now  recognized  as  not 
a  '  Rome  '  but  a  seated  Apollo  fully  draped,  and  is  numbered 
6281. 

The  other  one  of  the  Sassi  antiques  mentioned  by  Vasari  is 
referred  to  in  the  text  §  7,  ante,  p.  42,  as  '  una  figura  in 
Parione  d'  uno  ermafrodito  '  in  the  stone  called  '  paragone  ' 
or  ■  touchstone. '  This  is  also  praised  by  the  earlier  writers, 
and  is  seen  in  the  drawing  which  Michaelis  has  published. 
Aldovrandi  calls  it  (p.  152)  '  uno  Hermafrodito  di  paragone, 
maggiore  del  naturale  '  and  notes  its  provenance.  It  is  the 
'  Apollo  '  at  Naples,  No.  6262,  and  Michaelis  gives  the  material 
as  basalt.      It  is  noticed  by  Winckelmann  as  an  Apollo. 

The  della  Valle  collection  was  more  important  than  that  of 
the  Sassi,  and  was  the  finest  of  all  those  that  were  being 
formed  in  the  early  part  of  the  sixteenth  century.     There  is 


EARLY   COLLECTIONS   OF   ANTIQUES      105 

a  full  notice  of  it  by  Michaelis  in  the  Jahrbuch,  1891,  p.  218  f., 
who  prints  the  inventory  drawn  up  at  the  time  of  the  sale  of 
the  collection  in  1584  to  Cardinal  Ferdinando  de'  Medici,  by 

0  —■ "— --^ 


Fig.  8. — Portion  of  a  Plan  of  Rome,  from  Nolli,  Nuotjo.  Pianta  di  Roma,  1748. 
607,  Palazzo  Pamphili  Doria.  653,  Via  di  Parione. 

6io,  Torre  Millina.  _  783,  Piazza  della  Valle. 

615,  S.  Tommaso  in  Parione.  794,  Palazzo  Capranica. 

620,  Piazza  Pasquino.  795,  Teatio  della  Valle. 

625,  Palazzo  Massiini.  806,  Palazzo  Medici,  or,  Madama. 

80S,  S.  Luigi  del  Francesi. 
The  dotted  portion  marks  the  line  of  the  recent  Corso  Vittorio  Emanuele. 
The  site  of  the  Sassi  Palace,  near  S.  Tommaso,  is  marked  by  a  cross. 

whom  the  antiques  were  removed  to  the  Villa  Medici,  whence 
many  of  them,  including  most  probably  the  '  Medici  Venus,' 
found  their  way  to  Florence. 

The  della  Valle  were  a  family  of  high  importance,  counting 


io6  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

many  branches  and  numerous  houses  in  that  part  of  Rome, 
south-east  of  the  Piazza  Navona,  where  church  and  piazza 
and  palace  and  theatre  still  keep  alive  their  name.  The  most 
important  member  of  the  family  was  Cardinal  Andrea  della 
Valle,  one  of  Leo  X's  creations  of  1517.  Vasari  introduced 
him  into  the  fresco  in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio  at  Florence  repre- 
senting Leo  X  with  his  Cardinals,  that  is  given  as  a  favourable 
specimen  of  Giorgio's  painting  on  Plate  L  His  is  the  upper- 
most figure  on  the  extreme  right  of  the  picture.  Referring  to 
this  fresco,  Vasari  describes  him  in  his  third  '  Ragionamento  ' 
[Opere,  viii,  158)  as  '  quel  cardinale  della  Valle,  che  fece  in 
Roma  quello  antiquario,  e  che  fu  il  primo  che  mettessi  insieme 
le  cose  antiche,  e  le  faceva  restaurare. '  About  the  last  clause 
a  word  will  be  said  later  on. 

Lanciani  (I.e.,  i,  123)  draws  attention  to  the  vast  estates, 
urban  and  suburban,  possessed  by  these  wealthy  proprietors, 
and  the  opportunities  thus  afforded  of  obtaining  antique 
treasures  for  the  mere  trouble  of  digging  for  them.  Nobles 
who  had  official  charge  of  the  streets  and  open  places  could 
turn  the  opportunities  of  their  position  to  account  for  the  same 
purpose,  and  in  the  first  half  of  the  century  lovers  of  ancient 
art  did  not  buy  antiques  but  simply  dug  for  them.  Cardinal 
Aadrea,  Lanciani  says,  '  era  appassionato  scavatore,'  and  he 
made  excavations  in  the  Thermae  of  Agrippa  near  which  his 
palace  lay,  and  in  the  vineyards  of  the  Lateran.  Several 
writers  of  the  early  part  of  the  century  celebrate  this  collection. 
One  (Fichard,  in  Frankfurtisches  Archiv,  Frankfurt,  1815, 
III,  68)  writes,  in  1536,  that  the  Cardinal's  house  was  the  real 
treasury  of  Roman  antiquity,  and  he  singles  out  for  notice 
the  same  porphyry  wolf  about  which  Vasari  writes,  ante,  p. 
28.  There  were  so  many  statues  there,  he  says,  that  you 
would  have  thought  everything  ever  found  in  Rome  had  been 
brought  together  to  that  one  place  !  The  whole  collections  of 
the  family  however  were  divided  among  three  or  four  palaces, 
but  Andrea  had  the  lion's  share.  He  built  a  new  palace  for 
his  treasures  early  in  the  century  and  displayed  the  best  pieces 
in  a  court.  There  were  to  be  seen  a  Venus,  that  was  probably 
the  Medicean,  and  the  Florentine  Ganymede,  both  now  in  the 
Uffizi,  Nos.   548  and  115,  and  close  to  these  above  a  window 


EARLY   COLLECTIONS   OF   ANTIQUES      lo; 

the  porphyry  wolf  of  which  we  hear  from  Vasari.  The  present 
location  of  this  piece  is  not  known,  but  Michaelis  suggests 
it  might  be  looked  for  at  the  Villa  Medici  or  at  Florence. 
Vasari  also  mentions  '  two  prisoners  bound,'  also  of  porphyry, 
as  being  in  the  garden  of  the  palace  (ante,  p.  29).  These 
are  mentioned  in  the  inventory  referred  to  above  (Jahrbuch, 
229)  as  '  two  barbarians,  draped,  of  porphyry,  11  palms  high.' 
They  were  transported  from  the  Villa  Medici  at  Rome  to 
Florence  in  1790,  and  are  now  very  familiar  to  visitors  in 
Florence,  for  they  stand  just  within  the  Boboli  Gardens,  one 
on  each  side  of  the  main  walk  that  leads  up  towards  the  Amphi- 
theatre. They  are  about  eight  feet  high,  of  porphyry,  with 
heads  and  hands  of  white  marble.  Two  similar  figures  are 
to  be  seen  in  the  Louvre,  under  the  staircase  at  the  top  of 
which  is  the  Nike  from  Samothrace. 

Delia  Valle  was  not  content  with  his  fine  house  and  museum, 
but  desired  another  which  he  began  to  build  about  1520.  The 
work  was  directed  by  Lorenzo  Lotti  (Lorenzetto)  a  pupil  and 
assistant  of  Raphael,  and  Vasari  gives  us  an  account  of  it 
in  his  life  of  the  former  artist  (Opere,  iv,  579).  In  connection 
with  this  we  have  from  Vasari  an  interesting  notice  of  the 
beginning  of  the  practice  of  '  restoring  '  antiques,  which  from 
this  period  onwards  was  an  established  custom.  When 
Lorenzetto,  he  tells  us,  was  building  for  the  Cardinal  Andrea 
della  Valle  the  upper  garden  of  his  palace,  situated  where  is 
now  the  Teatro  della  Valle  (see  Fig.  8),  he  arranged  niches 
and  other  places  for  the  Cardinal's  antiques.  '  These  were 
imperfect,  some  wanting  a  head  and  others  arms,  while  others 
again  were  legless,  and  all  were  in  some  way  mutilated. 
Nevertheless  the  artist  managed  everything  excellently  well, 
for  he  got  good  sculptors  to  make  again  everything  that  was 
wanting,  and  this  led  to  other  lords  doing  the  same  thing,  and 
having  many  antique  fragments  restored.  This  was  done  for 
example  by  Cardinals  Cesis,  Ferrara,  and  Farnese,  and  in  a 
word  by  all  Rome.  And  in  truth  these  antiques,  restored  in 
this  fashion,  have  a  much  more  pleasing  effect  than  those 
mutilated  torsos,  and  limbs  without  a  head,  and  such-like 
fragments.'  On  the  restoration  of  the  Papal  antiques  see 
Note,  postea,  p.  116. 


io8  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

THE  PORPHYRY  TAZZA  OF  THE  SALA  ROTONDA  OF  THE 

VATICAN. 

[See  §  2,  Of  Porphyry,  ante,  p.  32.] 

Ascanio  Colonna,  who  was  brother  to  the  famous  Vittoria 
Colonna  the  friend  of  Michelang-elo,  was  one  of  the  chief  repre- 
sentatives of  the  imperial  interests  in  Italy,  in  the  stormy 
times  of  the  first  half  of  the  sixteenth  century.  Charles  V 
made  him  in  1520  Grand  Constable  of  Naples.  With  Pope 
Paul  III  he  had  a  bitter  feud,  and  the  Pope  seized  on  his 
possessions.  On  the  election  in  1550  of  Julius  III,  the  new 
Pope,  in  order  to  please  the  Emperor,  reinstated  Ascanio,  and 
it  was  on  the  occasion  of  this  reconciliation  that  Colonna 
presented  to  the  Pope  the  famous  basin  of  porphyry  of  which 
Vasari  writes.  The  '  vineyard  '  for  which  the  Pope  destined 
it  was  connected  with  the  casino  and  villa  outside  the  Porta 
del  Popolo  which  bear  the  name  of  the  Pope  and  where  is 
now  installed  the  Villa  Papa  Giulio  Museum.  The  tazza  in 
question  is  the  superb  bowl  that  occupies  the  centre  of 
the  Sala  Rotonda  in  the  Vatican  Museum.  It  is  said  to 
have  been  found  temp.  Julius  II,  in  the  Thermae  of  Titus 
(Pistolesi,  II  Vaticano  Descritto,  v,  206),  and  after  remaining 
for  a  time  at  the  papal  villa  it  was  conveyed  by  Clement  XI 
to  the  Vatican  and  placed  in  the  court  of  the  Belvedere,  now 
the  Cortile  Ottagono.  Francesco  de'  Ficorini  (Le  Vestigia  e 
Rarita  di  Roma,  Roma,  1744,  bk.  11,  ch.  2,  p.  15)  says  that 
in  this  court  was  the  '  gran  conca  di  porfido, '  and  another  of 
white  oriental  granite,  both  found  in  the  Thermae  of  Titus. 
When  Clement  XIV  (1769-75)  added  the  octagonal  colonnade 
in  the  interior  of  the  Cortile,  the  tazza  was  apparently  no 
longer  needed  there,  for  soon  afterwards  Pius  VI,  who  with 
Clement  was  the  creator  of  the  Museo  Pio-Clementino,  placed 
it  in  his  newly  constructed  Sala  Rotonda,  where  it  remains. 
Pasquale  Massi  in  his  Indicazione  antiquaria  del  Ponteficio 
Museo  Pio-Clementino,  1792,  p.  118,  speaks  of  '  una  vastissima 
tazza  di  porfido  di  palmi  62  di  circonferenza  tutta  massiccia 
(all  of  one  piece),  la  quale  si  trovava  gik  in  Vaticano  tras- 
portatavi  dalla  Villa  di  Giulio  III,  fuori  di  Porta  del  Popolo, 
ed  ora  squisitamente  risarcita. '     This  restoration  was  completed 


PORPHYRY   TAZZA   IN   VATICAN  109 

in  1792  and  was  no  doubt  carried  out  by  the  same  artists 
whom  Pius  VI  employed  for  the  repair  of  the  porphyry 
sarcophagi  noticed  ante,  p.  27.  In  this  way  the  work,  which 
Vasari  says  in  the  text  had  to  be  left  unfinished,  was  finally 
accomplished.  Cancellieri  {Lettera  .  .  .  intorno  la  maravi- 
gliosa  Tazza  di  Porfido,  etc.,  Roma,  1822)  makes  the  surprising 
statement  that  at  one  time  the  tazza  had  been  mended  with 
pieces  of  white  granite  ! 

The  tazza  is  the  largest  existing  piece  of  the  kind  and 
measures  14  ft.  in  diameter.  It  is  shallow  and  has  in  the 
interior  the  usual  projecting  central  boss.  Independently  of 
this  boss  the  tazza  has  only  one  arris,  or  in  Vasari 's  words 


Fig.  9. — Sketch  of  shape  of  the  large  porphyry  Tazza  in  the  Sala  Rotojada 
of  the  Vatican.  ^-^ 

'  canto  vivo, '  at  A  in  the  rough  sketch.  Fig.  9.  A  smaller 
but  more  artistically  wrought  porphyry  tazza,  beautifully 
restored,  and  measuring  8  ft.  6  in.  in  diameter,  is  in  the  Pitti 
at  Florence  close  to  the  entrance  to  the  passage  to  the  Uffizi. 
It  was  a  gift  from  Clement  VII  to  the  Medici,  and  was  brought 
from  Rome  (Villa  Medici)  to  Florence  in  1790,  where  it  was 
repaired  in  the  Tuscan  manufactory  of  mosaics  (Zobi,  Notizie 
Storiche  suir  Origine  e  Progressi  del  Lavori  di  Commesso 
in  Pietre  Dure,  Firenze,  1853,  p.  118).  Both  these  pieces  are 
superb  works,  and  display  the  magnificent  qualities  of  the  red 
Egyptian  porphyry  to  full  advantage. 

The  original  purpose  of  these  great  basins  is  not  very  clear. 
The  '  conche  '  mentioned  in  the  footnote  to  p.  27,  ante,  though 
now  used  as  sarcophagi,  were  certainly  in  their  origin 
baths,  but  the  shallow  tazza  would  be  unsuitable  for  such  a 
purpose,  and  moreover  the  central  ornament  would  have  almost 


no  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

precluded  such  a  use.  There  seems  no  sign  of  a  central 
opening  through  which  a  water  pipe  could  have  been  intro- 
duced, so  that  the  tazza  might  serve  as  the  basin  of  a  fountain. 
Perhaps  their  employment  was  simply  ornamental. 

FRANCESCO    DEL    TADDA,    AND    THE    REVIVAL    OF 
SCULPTURE   IN    PORPHYRY. 

[See  §  2,  0/  Porphyry,  ante,  p.  29.] 

Vasari  does  not  give  a  biography  of  this  artist  among  his 
Lives,  though  he  more  than  once  refers  to  him  in  connection 
with  other  sculptors.  There  is  on  the  other  hand  a  notice  of 
him  and  of  other  artists  of  his  family  in  Baldinucci's  Notisie 
de'  Professori  del  Disegno,  published  1681-1728.  Baldinucci 
knew  personally  the  son  of  Francesco,  but  was  so  poorly 
informed  about  Francesco's  early  life  that  he  makes  two 
persons  of  him  and  describes  his  early  career  as  if  it  were  that 
of  another  Francesco  del  Tadda.  (It  is  true  that  there  was 
an  earlier  Francesco  Ferrucci  but  he  was  not  called  '  del  Tadda  ' 
and  he  died  before  1500).  The  commentators  on  Vasari 
previous  to  the  Milanesi  edition  seem  to  have  been  misled  by 
Baldinucci,  but  in  this  edition  the  mistake  is  corrected,  and 
a  genealogical  tree  of  the  whole  Ferrucci  family  is  given  in 
voL  IV,  p.  487. 

Francesco  derived  his  name  '  del  Tadda  '  from '  his  grand- 
father Taddeo  Ferrucci,  who  belonged  to  a  family  of  sculptors 
in  Fiesole.  In  early  life  he  worked  with  other  sculptors  under 
the  orders  of  Clement  VII  at  the  completion  of  the  chapel  of 
Our  Lady  of  Loretto,  and  afterwards  assisted  Michelangelo 
in  his  work  in  the  Sacristy  of  S.  Lorenzo  at  Florence.  In 
the  Life  of  Giovanni  Agnolo  Montorsoli  Vasari  praises  him 
as  '  intagliatore  excellente  '  (Opere,  vi,  638).  The  works  in 
porphyry  mentioned  in  Vasari 's  text,  ante,  p.  32  f.,  will  be 
noticed  presently,  but  it  may  be  noted  here  that  del  Tadda's 
chief  work  in  this  material,  executed  after  Vasari  published 
his  Lives,  was  the  figure  of  '  Justice  '  which  stands  on  the 
granite  column  in  the  Piazza  di  S.  Trinitk  at  Florence.  The 
column,  which  is  36  ft.  high,  came  from  the  Baths  of  Caracalla 
at  Rome  and  was  presented  by  Pius  IV  to  Duke  Cosimo  I. 


FRANCESCO   DEL   TADDA  in 

Among  the  letters  of  Vasari  published  in  the  eighth  volume 
of  the  Milanesi  edition  is  one  dated  December  i8,  1561,  to 
Duke  Cosimo,  giving  the  measurements  of  this  column  which 
was  then  lying  at  Rome  awaiting  its  transport  to  Florence. 
The  system  of  measurement  is  instructive  and  has  been  referred 
to  ante,  p.  66  (see  Opere,  viii,  352).  The  column  was  taken 
to  Florence,  occupying  a  year  on  its  journey,  and  was  erected 
in  1565  on  the  Piazza  S.  Triniti  where  it  now  stands.  Cellini 
(Scultura,  ch.  6)  says  that  it  is  of  Elban  granite,  but  it  is  more 
likely  to  be  from  Egypt. 

Francesco  del  Tadda  received  the  commission  for  a  porphyry 
figure  to  surmount  it,  and  the  work  is  said  to  have  taken  him 
and  his  son  eleven  years ;  it  is  in  five  or  six  pieces  and  about 
II  ft.  6  in.  high.  The  statue  was  placed  in  position  on  June 
9,  1581,  and  the  drapery  of  bronze  was  adjusted  to  it  on 
July  21  (Francesco  Settimanni  quoted  by  Zobi,  page  105). 
The  figure  has  been  adversely  criticized  but  is  a  fairly  successful 
piece  of  work,  considering  the  difficulties  of  its  execution. 
Francesco  del  Tadda  died  in  1585  and  was  buried  in  the  church 
of  S.  Girolamo  at  Fiesole,  where  his  epitaph  signalizes  his 
unique  position  as  a  worker  in  porphyry  '  cum  statuariam  in 
Porphyretico  lapide  mult.  ann.  unicus  exerceret,'  and  bears 
his  portrait  by  his  own  hand  in  relief  in  porphyry  on  a  field 
of  green  Prat'o  serpentine. 

On  the  whole  subject  of  work  in  porphyry,  after  the  early 
Byzantine  period  when  the  late  Roman  imperial  tradition  was 
still  in  force,  the  following  may  be  noted. 

Vasari  does  not  say  that  the  art  of  working  the  stone  was 
ever  wholly  lost,  and  mentions,  ante,  p.  29,  the  cutting  of 
the  stone  for  use  in  inlaid  pavements,  Cosmati-work,  and  the 
like,  as  may  be  seen  in  St  Mark's,  Venice ;  at  Ravello,  and 
in  numberless  Roman  churches.  He  also  describes  the 
'  scabbling  '  of  the  stone  by  heavy  hammers  with  steel  points 
to  reduce  it  to  even  surfaces  both  rounded  and  flat  (ante, 
p.  31).  Fine  examples  of  the  use  of  the  material  in  mediaeval 
days,  for  purposes  other  than  statuesque,  can  be  seen  in  the 
Cathedral  of  Palermo.  There  are  there  four  noble  sarcophagi, 
with  canopies  supported  by  monolithic  shafts  all  in  the  same 
stone,  dating  from  the  thirteenth  century.     They  contain  the 


112  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

bodies  of  the  Emperor  Frederick  II,  who  died  in  1250,  and  of 
earlier  members  of  his  house,  and  show  that  at  that  time  the 
artificers  of  southern  Italy  and  Sicily  could  deal  successfully  on 
a  large  scale  with  this  intractable  material.  Anton  Springer, 
die  Mittelalterliche  Kunst  in  Palermo,  Bonn,  1869,  remarks  in 
this  connection,  p.  29,  that  the  Sicilians  are  to  this  day  specially 
expert  in  the  working  of  hard  stones.  Porphyry  was  also 
used  on  the  original  fa9ade  of  S.  Maria  del  Fiore  at  Florence 
that  was  demolished  in  1588.  Vasari  might  too  have  mentioned 
the  porphyry  sarcophagus  completed  in  1472  by  Andrea  del 
Verrocchio  for  the  monument  of  Piero  and  Giovanni  de' 
Medici  in  S.  Lorenzo  at  Florence.  The  Verrocchio  sarco- 
phagus is  however  composed  only  of  flat  slabs  of  porphyry, 
like  those  round  the  pulpit  in  St.  Mark's,  Venice,  whereas 
Vasari  is  drawing  a  distinction  between  this  architectural  use 
of  the  stone  and  its  employment  in  figure  sculpture,  of  which 
he  makes  Francesco  del  Tadda  the  first  restorer. 

In  regard  to  this  use  of  porphyry  it  must  not  be  forgotten 
that  in  the  Cabinet  of  Gems  in  the  Uffizi  there  is  a  beautifully 
executed  porphyry  statuette,  or  rather  group,  of  Venus  with 
Cupid,  about  ten  inches  high,  signed  in  Greek  characters  with 
the  name  of  '  Pietro  Maria. '  This  was  Pier  Maria  da  Pescia, 
noticed  by  Vasari  in  his  life  of  Valerio  Vicentino  and  others, 
as  a  famous  worker  in  hard  stones  of  the  days  of  Leo  X 
(Opere,  v,  370).  This  however  was  executed,  so  Zobi  says 
(P-  97))  with  the  wheel  after  the  manner  of  gem  engraving, 
whereas  the  works  of  Ferrucci,  of  later  date,  were  on  the  scale 
of  statuary  proper. 

In  connection  with  the  latter  we  have  Vasari's  story  of  the 
invention  of  Duke  Cosimo.  This  is  explained  by  Galluzzi, 
(Istoria  del  Granducato  di  Toscana,  Firenze,  1781,  i,  157  f.) 
who  says  that  Cosimo's  efforts  to  exploit  the  mineral  wealth 
of  Tuscany  (see  postea,  p.  120  f.)  gave  him  an  interest  in  metals, 
and  that  he  set  up  a  laboratory  in  his  palace,  where  he  carried 
on  experiments  in  chemistry  and  physics.  Hence  the  discovery 
of  which  Vasari  writes.  Cosimo  certainly  in  his  own  time 
had  some  personal  association  with  this  cutting  of  porphyry, 
for  Galluzzi  says  he  used  to  make  presents  to  his  friends  of 
porphyry    reliefs    executed    with    tools    tempered    by    the    new 


FRANCESCO   DEL   TADDA  113 

process,  and  quotes  (11,  229)  a  letter  of  thanks  from  a  Cardinal 
to  whom  a  gift  of  the  kind  had  been  forwarded.  On  the 
other  hand  Cellini,  (Scultura  ch.  6)  makes  Tadda  the  inventor 
and  ignores  Cosimo  altogether,  while  Baldinucci,  though,  like 
Vasari,  he  was  devoted  to  the  Medici,  scouts  the  idea  of 
Cosimo  having  had  any  personal  share  in  the  invention  of  the 
new  tempering  bath,  which  he  ascribes  to  Tadda  alone,  and 
he  adduces  in  support  of  this  Tadda 's  own  testament,  in  which 
are  the  words  Franciscus  de  Fesulis  sculptor  porfidi,  et  ipse 
inventor,  seu  renovator  talis  sculpturae,  et  artis  porfidorum 
incidendi.  Cosimo's  participation  in  the  discovery,  whatever 
it  was,  can  hardly  have  been  ascribed  to  him  without  some 
small  foundation  in  fact,  and  Aurelio  Gotti,  Le  Gallerie  e  I 
Musei  di  Firenze,  2nd  Ed.,  Firenze,  1875,  p.  45,  gives  credit 
for  it  to  the  Duke. 

However  this  may  be,  Tadda  appears  to  have  used  the  new 
process  for  the  first  time  in  ^he  production  of  the  tazza  for 
the  fountain  in  the  cortile  of  the  Palazzo  Vecchio,  and  to 
have  advanced  from  this  to  the  more  artistic  work  Vasari 
goes  on  to  describe.  Endeavours  to  discover  the  present 
habitat  of  the  oval  portraits  of  the  Medici  and  the  Head  of 
Christ,  referred  to  by  Vasari,  ante,  p.  33,  have  led  to  the 
following  result.  Signor  Supino,  the  Director  of  the  National 
Museum  at  Florence,  courteously  informed  us  that  the  portraits 
of  Cosimo  Pater  Patriae,  of  Leo  X,  and  of  Clement  VH,  with 
one  of  Giovanni  de'  Bicci,  were  preserved  in  the  magazines  of 
the  Bargello,  where  he  has  kindly  allowed  one  of  us  to  photo- 
graph them.  The  head  of  Cosimo  has  on  the  chamfer  of  the 
bust  the  inscription  opa  di  franc"  da  fiesole,  which  identifies 
it  with  certainty  as  the  work  of  Tadda  of  which  Vasari  writes. 
The  others  are  treated  in  the  same  fashion,  and  all  are  mounted 
on  flat  oval  slabs  of  green  serpentine  of  Prato.  They  are  no 
doubt  all  by  the  same  hand.  They  were  formerly  in  the  Uffizi 
but  have  been  for  many  years  in  the  Bargello,  and  their 
historical  and  artistic  interest  would  certainly  vindicate  for 
them  more  honourable  treatment  than  at  present  is  their  lot. 
Plates  III  and  V  give  the  Cosimo  Pater  Patriae  portrait  and 
that  of  Leo  X.     They  measure  about  19  in.  by  14  in. 

With  regard  to  the  other  examples  noticed  by  Vasari,  Zobi, 

H 


114  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

I.C.,  p.  io8,  informed  his  readers  that  the  two  ovals  of  Duke 
Cosimo  I  and  his  wife  the  Duchess  Leonora  were  at  that  time 
(about  1850)  in  the  Pitti  '  on  the  wall  of  the  vestibule  in  the 
part  called  Meridiana,'  but  he  complicates  matters  by  announc- 
ing the  same  about  the  head  of  the  older  Cosimo,  which  we 
have  just  found  at  the  Barg-ello,  and  which  Gotti  says,  I.e., 
p.  46,  was  originally  in  the  Villa  of  Poggio  Imperiale  whence 
it  was  conveyed  in  1862  to  the  Uffizi.  Zobi's  words  are  sub- 
joined in  the  original.  '  Ed  i  ritratti  in  profilo  del  duca 
Cosimo  I,  d'  Eleonora  di  Toledo  sua  moglie,  e  di  Cosimo 
appellato  il  padre  delta  patria,  scolpiti  a  mezzo  rilievo  e 
rapportati  sul  fondo  di  serpentine,  si  trovano  oggidi  situati 
insieme  con  altri  ritratti  parimente  porfiretici,  sulle  pareti  del 
vestibolo  al  quartiere  detto  della  Meridiana  nel  palazzo  regale.' 
The  part  of  the  Pitti  referred  to  is  on  the  second  floor  of 
the  palace  and  receives  its  name  from  a  meridian  line  in  brass 
marked  on  the  floor  on  which,  at  the  psychological  moment, 
the  sun  shines  through  a  hole  in  the  roof.  Here,  through  the 
courtesy  of  Signor  Cornish  the  Conservator  of  the  Royal 
Palace,  we  have  seen  no  fewer  than  seven  oval  portraits  in 
porphyry  mounted  on  serpentine  that  are  built  into  the  wall 
in  situations  which  make  their  study  rather  difficult.  Among 
them  the  marked  features  of  Duke  Cosimo  are  not  apparent, 
but  on  one  of  them  is  the  inscription,  '  Ferdinandus  Magnus 
Dux  Etr.  1609,'  and  on  another  the  name  and  date -of  Christina, 
Duchess  of  Tuscany,  1669.  This  all  bears  out  what  Baldinucci 
tells  us,  that  the  Ferrucci  family  in  general  put  their  hands 
to  this  particular  class  of  work,  which'  was  their  speciality, 
just  as  the  glazed  terra-cottas  were  specialities  of  the  della 
Robbia,  while  they  also  adopted  into  the  circle  pupils  from 
outside.  Zobi,  p.  109,  quotes  an  old  inventory  of  1574,  the 
date  of  the  death  of  Duke  Cosimo  I,  which  mentions  ten  such 
portraits  of  members  of  the  family  as  at  that  time  existing, 
all  mounted  on  serpentine.  Later  on,  Baldinucci  mentions 
three  sons  of  Francesco,  to  one  of  whom,  Romolo,  he  is  sup- 
posed to  have  left  his  '  secret. '  There  was  however  also  an 
Andrea  Ferrucci,  and  a  Mattias  Ferrucci,  who  if  they  lacked 
the  pretended  '  secret  '  at  any  rate  did  the  same  work,  and 
finally  one  Raflfaello  Curradi,  a  pupil  of  Andrea,  who  in   1636 


PORTRAIT  IN  PORPHYRY  OF  LEO  X 
BY  FRANCESCO  DEL  TADDA 


CORTILE   OF  THE   BELVEDERE  115 

abandoned  sculpture  and  took  the  Franciscan  habit.  Accord- 
ing to  Zobi,  p.  116,  he  was  the  last  of  the  porphyry  sculptors, 
and  '  dopo  quest  '  epoca  affatto  s'  ignora  se  furono  prodotte 
altre  opere  porfiree. '  In  view  of  the  date  1669  on  one  of  the 
ovals  in  the  Pitti,  this  should  not  perhaps  be  taken  too 
absolutely.  That  porphyry  has  been  worked  successfully  at 
Florence  at  later  dates,  the  admirable  restoration  of  the 
porphyry  tazza  in  the  Pitti,  mentioned  ante,  p.  109,  and  other 
more  recent  productions  noted  by  Zobi,  sufficiently  show. 

If  we  add  to  the  series  of  ovals  the  various  porphyry  busts 
of  members  of  the  Medici  house,  exhibited  in  the  outer  vestibule 
of  the  Uffizi  and  other  places,  there  would  be  enough  porphyry 
versions  of  the  Medici  to  furnish  material  for  a  monograph. 

With  regard  finally  to  the  '  Head  of  Christ  '  which  Vasari 
says  was  taken  to  Rome  and  much  admired  by  Michelangelo, 
the  original  seems  to  be  lost,  but  Zobi  states,  p.  95,  that  in 
his  time  a  scion  of  the  Ferrucci  family,  living  at  Lugo  in  the 
Province  of  Ravenna,  possessed  a  head  of  Christ  in  porphyry 
signed  Mathias  Ferrucceus  Civis  Florentinus  Fecit,  and 
he  thinks  this  may  have  been  copied  from  the  original  by 
Francesco  del  Tadda,  of  which  there  is  question  in  Vasari 's 
text. 

THE  CORTILE   OF  THE  BELVEDERE    IN   THE    VATICAN, 
IN  THE   SIXTEENTH   CENTURY. 

[See  §  4,  Of  Cipollaccio,  ante,  p.  36.] 

The  history  of  this  famous  Cortile  forms  the  subject  of  an 
elaborate  paper  by  Professor  AjoITMichaelis  in  the  Jahrbuch 
of  the  German  Archaeological  Institute  for  1890.  It  has  been 
described  as  '  the  most  noteworthy  place  of  art  in  all  Italy 
or  rather  in  the  world,'  as  it  was  the  first  home  of  the  nascent 
collection  of  antique  statues  formed  by  successive  Popes  from 
the  beginning  of  the  sixteenth  century,  that  has  grown  into 
the  Vatican  museum  of  sculpture.  It  must  be  remembered 
that  the  octagonal  portico  which  now  surrounds  the  Cortile 
is  a  later  addition  of  the  last  part  of  the  eighteenth  century, 
and  when  Vasari  knew  it,  about  1530,  in  the  pontificate  of 
Clement  VII,  it  was  laid  out  as  a  garden  of  orange  trees,  with 


ii6  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

niches  by  Bramante  in  the  four  corners  and  in  the  middle 
of  the  sides.  In  these  niches  and  on  pedestals  in  the  court 
were  displayed  notable  antiques,  such  as  the  '  Laocoon,'  the 
'  Nile  '  now  in  the  Braccio  Nuovo,  the  '  Tiber  '  now  in  the 
Louvre,  the  '  Torso,'  the  '  Cleopatra,'  two  Venuses,  the  '  Apollo 
Belvedere,'  and  others.  This  was  a  favourite  resort  of  Clement, 
who  used  to  walk  here  in  the  mornings  reading  his  breviary, 
and  listened  in  the  evenings  to  music  made  for  him  by 
Benvenuto  Cellini  and  others  (Cellini,  Autobiography,  transl., 
Lond.,  1878,  p.  42).  Here  too  he  consulted  with  Michelangelo 
in  1532  on  the  question  of  the  restoration  of  the  antiques,  and 
Michelangelo  recommended  to  him  for  the  purpose  the  youthful 
sculptor  Fra  Giovann'  Agnolo  Montorsoli,  whom  the  Pope  in- 
stalled in  the  Belvedere  to  carry  out  the  work  (see  antp,  p.  107). 
Among  the  features  of  the  court  were  fountains  in  some  of  the 
niches,  on  which  were  statues.  The  '  Cleopatra  '  of  the  Vatican 
was  one  of  these,  and  Clement  seems  to  have  desired  to  make 
a  second  fountain  corresponding  to  that  of  the  Cleopatra,  to 
be  adorned  by  the  river  god  Tigris.  The  'Tigris,'  which  is 
now  in  the  Sala  a  Croce  Greca,  is  said  to  have  been  restored 
by  the  august  hands  of  Michelangelo  himself,  and  it  was  for 
the  installation  of  the  '  Tigris  '  that  Buonarotti  designed  the 
fountain  of  which  Vasari  writes.  Vasari's  account,  which  had 
escaped  the  notice  of  Michaelis,  is  our  only  authority  for  this 
work  by  Michelangelo,  which  is  not,  so  far  as  the  present 
writers  can  discover,  mentioned  in  any  of  the  numerous  '  Lives  ' 
of  the  artist.  There  is  a  drawing  of  the  fountain  by  Heems- 
kerck,  reproduced  by  Michaelis,  but  this  only  gives  the  figure, 
and  not  the  decorative  treatment  of  the  niche,  which  is  the 
point  of  interest  as  a  parergon  by  Michelangelo.  The 
situation  of  the  '  Tigris  '  fountain  was  in  the  corner  where 
is  now  the  Cabinet  of  the  Laocoon.  (Michaelis  I.e.,  and  Plans 
and  Drawings  of  the  Vatican  in  the  King's  Library  at  Blooms- 
bury.  Of  older  writers  Bonanni,  Numismata  Summorum 
Pontificum  Templi  Vaticani  Fabricam  Indicantia,  Roma,  1696, 
is  praised  by  Lanciani  as  the  most  useful  and  trustworthy). 


PARAGON   AND   OTHER   STONES  117 

PARAGON   (TOUCHSTONE)  AND   OTHER   STONES 
ASSOCIATED   WITH   IT   BY  VASARI. 

[See  §  7,  Of  Paragon,  ante,  p.  42.] 

There  are  at  least  six  different  kinds  of  stone  referred  to 
in  this  section,  and  for  convenience  they  are  lettered  in  the 
text  (a)  (b)  etc. 

(a)  There  is  a  stone  specially  suited  for  the  process  of 
testing  the  precious  metals  in  the  way  Vasari  describes.  It 
is  called  in  various  tongues  '  touchstone,'  '  pierre  de  touche,' 
'  Probirstein,'  '  pietra  di  paragone,'  '  basanite  '  from  Greek 
jSao-ovos,  a  test,  and  in  Latin  'Lapis  Lydius'  from  the  reason 
that  it  was  found  in  Lydia.  According  to  Theophrastus, 
Ilejoi  Aidtav,  §  35,  and  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xxxiii,  8,  it 
was  only  found  in  small  nodules,  and  this  agrees  with  the 
character  of  the  stone.  It  is  described  by  Professor  Bonney 
as  a  ■  silicified  argillite, '  that  is  to  say  a  clayey  sedimentary 
stone  largely  impregnated  with  silica,  and,  as  used  by  the 
modern  jeweller  and  goldsmith,  it  is  in  appearance  and  texture 
an  extremely  hard  stone  of  very  fine  grain  and  of  a  velvet 
blackness,  the  colour  being  due  to  the  presence  of  carbonaceous 
elements.  Small  lumps  of  fine  texture  are  found  embedded  in 
a  coarser  matrix.  It  has  no  mystic  power  of  testing  metals. 
The  piece  of  metal  to  be  essayed  is  simply  rubbed  on  the 
stone  and  the  mark  scrutinized,  or  compared  as  regards  colour 
with  marks  from  similar  rubbings  of  metal  pins  of  known  com- 
position. A  piece  of  the  stone,  showing  some  marks  of  the 
kind,  is  given  as  I  on  the  Frontispiece.  For  the  above  purpose 
any  hard,  fine-grained,  compact  stone  of  a  dark  colour  will 
serve,  and  black  jasper  Wedgewood-ware  answers  the  demand 
as  well  as  a  natural  stone.  The  small  portion  of  the  metal 
rubbed  off  as  above  may  however  be  tested  more  searchingly  by 
the  application  of  acid,  and  for  this  to  be  practicable  the  stone 
must  not  be  a  limestone,  which  would  be  at  once  attacked 
by  the  acid  and  confuse  the  test. 

(b)  The  '  other  variety  with  a  different  grain  and  colour, ' 
of  which  Egyptian  sphinxes  were  made,  must  be  basalt  (or 
diorite)  in  which  material  the  statue  which  Vasari  calls  the 
'  hermaphrodite   in   Parione  '   is   actually   cut.     A   fine-grained 


ii8  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

basalt  would  serve  well  enough  as  a  touchstone,  though  it  is 
not  the  true  material. 

(c)  There  appears  to  be  a  kind  of  granitic  stone,  which  Mr 
Brindley  calls  '  an  augite  variety  of  green  granite  found  along- 
side the  Prato  serpentine  '  (for  which  see  below)  found  near 
Prato  (Repetti,  art.  'Monte  Ferrato,'  writes  of  a  '  granito 
di  Prato  '  or  '  granitone  di  Fighne  '),  but  the  stone  that  Vasari 
goes  on  to  describe  (d)  as  used  for  sarcophagi,  is  of  another 
composition  altogether.  This  is  a  black  or  grey  limestone  that 
used  to  be  abundantly  employed  as  the  setting  for  Florentine 
mosaics,  and  is  still  used  for  such  purposes  as  inlaid  letters, 
etc.,  in  white  marble.  P,  as  above,  shows  a  piece  cut  for  such 
use.  It  is  however  liable  to  white  or  hght-grey  veins,  and 
is  now  supplanted  at  the  Florentine  mosaic  manufactory  by 
a  black  marble  or  limestone  imported  from  Belgium.  The 
sarcophagus  of  Piero  Soderini,  behind  the  high  altar  in  the 
church  of  the  Carmine  at  Florence  is  in  a  grey  limestone  much 
traversed  by  lighter  veins.  Such  a  stone  could  not  be  suitably 
used  as  a  touchstone,  as  in  the  first  place  it  is  not  hard  enough, 
and,  in  the  second,  would  not  admit  of  the  use  of  the  acid  test. 
The  name  '  paragone  '  is  however  very  commonly  applied  to 
it.  The  '  canopy  of  Prato  touchstone  '  is  mentioned  by  other 
writers  beside  Vasari,  but  is  no  more  to  be  seen  and  may  have 
perished  in  the  Carmine  fire. 

(e)  Here  again  we  have  a  quite  different  stone,  though  one 
very  well  known  and  in  common  use.  The  dark  stone  which 
occurs  in  bands  on  Tuscan  buildings  in  Florence  and  elsewhere 
is  known  as  '  Verde  di  Prato  '  and  is  a  species  of  (true) 
serpentine,  very  dark  in  hue  and  often  seeming  purplish  or 
puce-coloured  rather  than  green.  It  would  be  too  soft  to 
make  a  good  touchstone,  and  is  disposed  to  disintegrate  when 
exposed  to  severe  climatic  conditions.  Thus  on  the  fa9ade 
of  S.  Miniato  a  Monte  on  the  hill  facing  the  north  it  is  far 
more  weathered  than  on  the  Duomo  or  Campanile  below.  For 
the  quarries  of  it  and  its  use  see  the  Note,  postea,  p.  127. 
E,  as  above,  shows  a  characteristic  piece  kindly  lent  from 
his  collection  by  Professor  Bonney. 

(f)  Lastly  there  is  the  red  marble  used  in  bands  on  the 
Campanile  and  Duomo.     For  this  also  see  the  Note  p.   128. 


TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES  119 

TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES. 
[See   §§  5,  9,  97.  99,  etc.] 

The  best  work  on  the  subject  of  Italian  stones  is  that  by 
Jervis,  /  Tesori  Sotterranei  dell'  Italia,  Torino,  1889,  and 
a  considerable  amount  of  information  is  contained  in  the  local 
articles  in  E.  Repetti's  Disionario  geographico,  etc.,  della 
Toscana,  Firenze^  1839,  and  also  in  the  Official  Catalogue  of 
the  Italian  section  in  the  London  International  Exhibition  of 
1862.  In  connection  with  investigations  which  we  have  had 
to  make  on  all  this  subject  of  the  stones,  we  have  to  acknow- 
ledge with  all  gratitude  the  expert  aid  kindly  afforded  by 
Professors  Bonney  of  Cambridge  and  Geikie  of  Edinburgh,  as 
well  as  the  valuable  local  assistance  and  information  kindly 
given  to  us  by  Professor  Enrico  Bonanni  of  Carrara  and  the 
representatives  of  the  firm  Henraux  et  Cie  of  Seravezza,  the 
owners  of  the  Monte  Altissimo  quarries  presently  to  be 
mentioned.  From  both  these  sources  we  have  obtained 
knowledge  which  we  could  not  otherwise  have  compassed,  and 
we  desire  again  to  express  our  obligations  to  Mr  W.  Brindley, 
who  is  as  well  known  in  the  Carrara  district  as  in  London,  and 
who  gave  us  these  introductions  as  well  as  much  technical 
information. 

The  quarries  mentioned  by  Vasari  are  named  in  the 
accompanying  table,  where  there  are  also  indications  of  the 
kinds  of  stone  he  signalizes  as  their  products.  It  must  of 
course  be  understood  that  extensive  quarries  generally  produce 
more  than  one  kind  of  stone,  as  Vasari  notes  in  the  case  of 
the  Carrara  quarries  in  §  9,  and  again  in  '  Painting  '  §  97, 
where  he  speaks  of  variegated  marbles  alternating  with  the 
white. 

The  principal  deposits  of  marble  are  those  in  the  Carrara 
district,  in  the  mountains  called  the  Apuan  Alps  near  the  sea 
coast  between  Pisa  and  Spezia.  The  marbles  of  the  district 
have  been  exploited  since  the  time  of  the  Romans,  under  the 
name  of  marbles  of  Luna  or  Luni.  The  site  of  the  Etrusco- 
Roman  town  of  Luni  is  a  little  south  of  the  railway  line, 
about  half  way  between  Avenza-Carrara  and  Sarzana,  and 
traces  of  the  Roman  workings  are  observable  in  many  of  the 


I20  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

present  quarries.  The  industry  received  a  notable  impulse  at 
the  great  artistic  epoch  of  the  Renaissance.  Duke  Cosimo 
de'  Medici  gave  considerable  attention  to  the  exploitation  of 
this  form  of  mineral  wealth,  as  was  also  the  case  with  the 
metal-producing  mines  (ante,  p.  112).  He  opened  new  quarries 
in  the  Pietrasanta  district  of  the  Apuan  Alps,  and  also  gave 
special  attention  to  the  quarries  in  the  Pisan  Mountains, 
between  Pisa  and  Lucca,  and  to  facilitating  the  transport  of 
the  material  from  the  hills  to  the  former  town. 

The  special  quarries  of  which  the  town  of  Carrara  is  the 
centre  and  d^p6t  are  the  oldest  and  the  most  prolific,  and  a 
useful  local  guide  to  Carrara  gives  a  long  list  of  the  effective 
ones  in  their  different  groups,  with  their  respective  products. 
Of  these,  that  which  has  furnished  the  finest  statuary  marble 
in  the  largest  blocks  is  the  quarry  of  Polvaccio,  in  the  Ravac- 
cione  valley  under  Monte  Sagro,  one  of  the  culminating  points 
of  the  ridge  of  the  Apuan  Alps.  See  the  sketch  map,  Fig. 
10.  Vasari  (ante,  p.  46)  specially  praises  the  Polvaccio 
marbles,  as  being  free  from  the  veins  and  flaws  so  tiresome 
to  the  sculptor.  There  are  now  other  localities  in  the  district 
that  furnish  as  good  pieces  as  Polvaccio. 

There  is  another  important  centre  a  little  to  the  south-east, 
that  is  of  more  interest  in  the  present  connection.  This  is 
Pietrasanta,  which  is  the  emporium  for  the  quarries  of 
Seravezza  several  times  mentioned  by  Vasari,  and  those  of 
Stazzema,  a  little  further  up  among  the  hills. 

The  Seravezza  district  is  quite  apart  from  that  of  Carrara, 
and  the  little  town  in  question  nestles  in  the  folds  of  the  ridges 
that  descend  from  Monte  Altissimo,  the  culminating  point  next 
to  the  south  from  Monte  Sagro,  both  peaks  being  between 
5  and  6,000  feet  high.  Both  districts  are  rich  in  memories 
of  Michelangelo.  About  his  work  at  Carrara  there  is  more 
than  one  published  treatise,  as  for  example  Carlo  Frediani's 
Ragionamento  Storico,  2nd  Ed.,  Siena,  1875,  while  in  con- 
nection with  his  proceedings  at  Seravezza,  and  especially  the 
identification  of  localities  mentioned  in  his  correspondence  and 
memoranda,  MM.  Henraux  have  furnished  us  with  some 
first-hand  information.  Both  at  Carrara  and  at  Pietrasanta 
inscriptions  indicate  houses  where  he  lodged  on.  his  visits  to 


122  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

the  localities.  Carrara  was  his  first  love,  and  when  charged 
by  Leo  X  in  1516  with  the  work  at  S.  Lorenzo  at  Florence 
he  betook  himself  thither  for  marbles.  Vasari,  in  his  Life 
of  Michelangelo,  Ofere,  ed  Milanesi,  vii,  189,  tells  us  how 
while  he  was  there  he  received  a  letter  from  the  Pope  bidding 
him  turn  his  attention  rather  to  the  Seravezza  district,  which 
was  actually  in  Tuscan  territory,  whereas  Carrara  was  in  the 
principality  of  Massa-Carrara,  and  at  the  time  under  the  rule 
of  the  Marchese  Alberigo,  who  was  Michelangelo's  friend. 

Repetti   has   published  documents  of  the  year   1515,   which 
show  that  at  that  date  the  Commune  of   Seravezza  resolved 
to  make  a  donation  to  the  Florentine  people  of  the  right  to 
quarry  in  the  cliffs   of  Monte  Altissimo,   in  which  it  is  said, 
'  there  are  supposed  to  be  mines  and  quarries  of  marble  '  (in 
quibus  dicitur  esse  cava  et  mineria  pro  marmoribus  cavendis), 
and  also  of  the  ground  necessary  for  making  a  road  for  trans- 
port.    This  was  the  cause  of  the  Pope's  orders  to  Michelangelo, 
which  Vasari   says   he  obeyed  with  great  reluctance.     In  the 
invaluable   '  Contratti  '  and  '  Ricordi,'  which  G.   Milanesi  has 
printed  in  his  volume  of  Michelangelo's  Lettere  (Firenze,  1875), 
we  find  Buonarroti  in  1516-7  at  Carrara,  getting  material  from 
the  Polvaccio  quarry,  but  at  the  beginning  of  15 18  he  notes 
(Lettere,    p.    566)    '  Andai    a   cavare    a    Pietra    Santa   e   fecivi 
I'avviamento  (the  start)  che  oggi  si  vede  fatto,'  and  from  this 
time   his    chief   work   was    beneath   the   wild    cliffs    of   Monte 
Altissimo  (ibid.,   p.    573  f.).     A  memorandum  of  a  later  date 
(Lettere,  p.  580)  thus  worded,  '  a  di  circa  venticinque  di  febraio 
nel  mille  cinquecento  diciassette  (our  15 18)  .   .   .  non  mi  pos- 
sendo  servire  a  Carrara  di  detti  marmi,  mi  missi  a  fare  cavare 
nelle    montagnie    di    Seraveza,    villa    di    Pietra    Santa,    dove 
inanzi   non   era   mai   piu   state   cavato,'   shows   that  this   was 
pioneer  work.     The  contract  made  at  Pietrasanta  on  March  15, 
1518,    for  the   work   of   quarrying   (Lettere,   p.    673)   indicates 
that  the  locality  was  the  gorge  of  the  Serra,  which  runs  up 
northward    from    Seravezza    to    the    heart    of    the    mountains. 
Two   localities   are   mentioned,    one,    '  Finochiaia   sive  Trans- 
vaserra,'  and  another  opposite  to  this,  '  dirimpetto  et  riscontro,' 
called  •  alia  Cappella. '     The  first  place  is  now  called  '  Trambi- 
serra,'  and  will  be  seen  on  the  sketch  map  on  the  west  of  the 


TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES  123 

gorge  with  '  la  Cappella  '  over  against  it  on  the  east.  Another 
contract  of  April  14  in  the  same  year  mentions  quarrying 
projected  '  a  1'  Altissimo  '  in  a  locality  called  '  a  la  Piastra 
di  verso  Strettoia  sive  Antognia.'  There  is  a  Strettoia  on 
the  lower  hills  west  of  Seravezza,  but  that  the  operations  in 
question  were  really  higher  up  the  gorge  among  the  very 
cliffs  of  Monte  Altissimo  is  proved  by  a  letter  of  later  date 
from  Vincenzio  Danti  to  Duke  Francesco  de'  Medici  (July  2, 
1568;  Gaye,  Carteggio,  in,  254),  who  reports  that  he  examined 
the  old  workings  and  road  of  Michelangelo  '  al  Altissimo, ' 
and  mentions  various  localities,  'la  Polla,'  'Costa  dei  Cani,' 
etc.,  the  sites  of  which  are  at  the  head  of  the  valley  as  shown 
on  the  map.  '  La  Polla  '  means  the  water-head.  Moreover, 
in  a  letter  from  Seravezza  dated  August,  1518,  Lettere,  p.  394, 
Michelangelo  speaks  of  the  road  for  the  transport  of  the 
marbles  as  being  nearly  finished,  though  in  three  places  rocks 
had  still  to  be  cut  away.  The  places  are  '  a  Rimagno,'  '  poco 
passato  Rimagno  per  andare  a  Seraveza,'  and  '  a  1'  ultime 
case  di  Seravezza,  andando  verso  la  Corvara. '  The  places 
are  marked  on  the  sketch  map.  Marbles  from  any  part  of 
the  upper  gorge  of  the  Serra  would  have  to  be  brought  past 
Rimagno  on  their  way  down,  and  we  therefore  see  that  Michel- 
angelo exploited  to  some  extent  the  actual  marbles  of  the 
Altissimo,  which  for  the  last  half  century  have  furnished  the 
very  finest  and  most  costly  statuary  marble  of  the  whole  Apuan 
Alps,  Mr  Brindley  says,  of  the  whole  world.  The  existing 
quarries  are  under  the  serrated  peaks  of  Monte  Altissimo,  at 
an  elevation  of  some  3  to  4,000  feet,  and  the  marbles  are  now 
brought  down  in  trolleys  sliding  along  a  rope  stretched  across 
the  valley  and  mounting  to  the  highest  levels.  It  is  believed 
locally  that  the  workings  called  '  Vincarella  '  are  some  of  the 
first  opened  by  Michelangelo,  and  from  somewhere  at  any 
rate  among  these  cliffs,  in  the  latter  part  of  15 18,  by  the 
agency  of  some  skilled  workmen  who  had  been  sent  from 
Settignano  as  well  as  local  hands,  and  by  means  of  ropes  and 
windlasses  and  sledges,  Michelangelo  was  letting  down  a 
column,  which  however  fell  and  was  broken. 

A  letter  from  Seravezza  of  April  20,   1519,  Lettere,  p.  403, 
gives  details  of  the  accident,  which  was  due  to  the  fracture 


124  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

of  a  defective  ring  of  iron,  and  he  says,  '  Siano  stati  a  un 
grandissimo  pericolo  della  vita  tutti  che  eravamo  attorno : 
e  issi  guasto  una  mirabil  pietra.'  No  wonder  he  records  in 
a  memorandum  that  he  subsequently  left  Pietrasanta  ill,  and 
that  he  exclaims  in  a  postscript  to  a  letter  of  April  1518, 
Lettere,  p.  138,  '  Oh,  cursed  a  thousand  times  be  the  day  and 
the  hour  when  I  quitted  Carrara  !  ' 

The  Monte  Altissimo  quarries  are  situated  in  a  scene  that 
to  us  to-day  is  sufficiently  wild,  though  the  modern  lover  of 
the  mountains  finds  it  full  of  an  austere  beauty.  To  Michel- 
angelo, who  was  fretting  at  his  enforced  loss  of  ti'me  and 
in  no  mood  to  surrender  himself  to  the  influences  of  nature, 
it  was  a  savage  and  inhospitable  country.  He  writes  from 
Seravezza  to  P'lorence  in  August  1518,  (Lettere,  p.  394),  '  The 
place  where  we  have  to  quarry  here  is  very  rugged  (molto 
aspro),  and  the  men  are  very  unskilled  in  such  work  :  never- 
theless we  must  have  much  patience  for  several  months  till 
the  mountains  are  tamed  and  the  men  are  instructed.  After- 
wards we  shall  go  on  more  quickly  :  it  is  enough  that  what 
I  have  promised,  that  will  I  at  all  costs  perform,  and  I  will 
do  the  finest  work  that  has  ever  yet  been  accomplished  in 
Italy,  if  God  be  my  aid!  '  As  a  fact  it  was  1521  before  the 
first  column  for  the  fafade  of  S.  Lorenzo  arrived  in  Florence, 
the  rest,  as  Vasari  says,  (ante,  p.  47  and  Opere,  vii,  p.  190) 
remained  in  the  quarries  or  by  the  sea-shore,  and  the  '  finest 
work  '  was  never  even  begun.  MM.  Henraux  state  that 
they  know  of  no  traces  of  the  columns  said  to  have  been  left 
thus  '  on  the  sea  shore  '  (by  Forte  dei  Marmi)  but  they  possess 
a  piece  of  a  fractured  column  found  near  the  site  of  Michel- 
angelo's supposed  workings  at  '  la  Polla. ' 

At  the  death  of  Pope  Leo  nothing  had  been  accomplished 
but  the  foundations  of  the  facade,  and  the  transport  of  a  great 
column  from  Seravezza  to  the  Piazza  di  S.  Lorenzo !  For 
nearly  thirty  years  after  this  time  the  quarries  of  this  district 
were  almost  deserted,  and  the  roads  which  Michelangelo  had 
begun  were  not  completed. 

At  a  later  period  however  Duke  Cosimo  I  paid  special 
attention  to  the  quarries  of  the  Seravezza  region,  and  had 
a    casino    or    summer    residence    built    here    for    himself    by 


TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES  125 

Ammanati,  now  termed  '  II  Palazzo,'  and  the  residence  of 
the  Mayor.  A  commissioner  was  established  at  Pietrasanta 
as  the  metropolis  of  the  district,  to  supervise  the  workings. 
In  the  '  Introduction  '  to  Painting  at  Chapter  xvi,  §  99,  postea, 
p.  261,  Vasari  gives  us  an  interesting  notice  of  the  opening 
of  some  new  quarries  in  1563  near  the  village  of  Stazzema, 
which  lies  behind  the  mountains  which  overhang  Pietrasanta, 
and  is  approached  from  Seravezza  up  the  Versiglia,  or  the 
gorge  of  the  river  Vezza.  The  road,  of  which  he  speaks  in 
this  place  (p.  261)  as  in  course  of  making,  he  mentions  in 
some  of  his  letters  of  1564,  and  also  in  the  Life  of  Michel- 
angelo, but  he  gives  no  indication  of  its  course.  It  was 
probably  the  road  from  Seravezza  across  the  marsh-land  to 
the  sea,  a  more  troublesome  affair  than  roads  along  mountain 
valleys. 

As  regards  the  products  of  all  these  quarries  of  the  Apuan 
Alps,  statuary  marble  occurs  as  we  have  seen  in  many  places, 
and  it  is  found,  where  it  occurs,  in  'compact  masses  or  nodules 
embedded  in  and  flanked  by  marbles  impure  in  colour  and 
streaked  and  variegated  in  divers  fashions.  A  vast  amount 
of  the  marble  quarried  in  the  hills  is  what  the  quarrymen  call 
'  Ordinario,'  and  is  of  a  grey  hue  and  often  streaked  with 
veins,  which  when  well  marked  give  it  a  new  value  as  '  fiorito, ' 
or  '  flowered. '  Of  a  more  decided  grey  is  the  prized  marble 
called  '  Bardiglio,'  which  is  the  kind  furnished  by  the  'alia 
Cappella  '  quarries.  Bardiglio  again  may  be  '  fiorito. '  These 
correspond  to  the  '  three  sorts  of  marble  that  come  from  the 
mountains  of  Carrara  '  of  which  Vasari  writes  in  §  97,  postea, 
P-  259,  '  one  of  which  is  of  a  pure  and  dazzling  white,  the 
other  not  white  but  of  a  livid  hue,  while  the  third  is  a  grey 
marble  (marmo  bigio)  of  a  silvery  tint.'  The  white  and  the 
grey  are  shown  in  the  coloured  drawing  at  J  and  K. 

More  decidedly  variegated  are  the  marbles  known  as 
'  Mischi  '  or  '  Breccias, '  and  of  these  the  Stazzema  quarries 
yield  the  chief  supply.  The  '  Mischio  di  Seravezza  '  of  which 
Vasari  writes  in  a  letter,  Gaye,  in,  164,  was  from  this  locality, 
and  so  too  the  '  Mischi  '  mentioned  in  §  §  5,  9,  ante,  pp.  37, 
45,  of  which  some  are  '  Mischiati  di  rosso. '  C  and  D  as 
above  show  characteristic  specimens  of  Breccias  of  Stazzema. 


126  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

Repetti,  art.  '  Stazzema,'  says  that  the  '  Bardigli  fioriti  '  and 
Breccias  of  Stazzema  are  generally  known  as  '  Mischi  da 
Seravezza. ' 

It  should  be  mentioned  that  Massa,  between  Carrara  and 
Pietrasanta,   is  also  a  quarry  centre  of  importance. 

Leaving  the  Apuan  Alps,  the  next  marble-producing  locality 
we  come  to  on  descending  the  coast  is  that  of  the  Monti  Pisani, 
the  range  of  hills  separating  the  territories  of  Pisa  and  Lucca. 
Monte  S.  Giuliano  is  on  the  road  between  the  two  cities,  and 
there  are  quarries  near  Bagni  S.  Giuliano  about  six  kilometres 
from  Pisa.  It  will  be  seen  that  Vasari  (ante,  p.  50)  speaks 
favourably  of  this  marble,  and  Mr  W.  Brindley  thinks  this 
notice  in  Vasari  is  of  special  interest,  as  he  reports  of  this 
marble  that  '  for  durability  and  delicate  honey-tint  it  is  superior 
to  Carrara. '  The  local  term  '  ceroide  '  '  wax-like  '  used  for 
this  stone  conveys  the  same  idea.  It  was  used  at  Lucca  as 
well  as  on  Pisan  buildings.  From  the  same  quarries  come 
red  and  veined  marbles  and  Breccias  and  '  Mischi  '  (Torelli, 
Statistica  della  Provincia  di  Pisa,  Pisa,  1863). 

The  exploitation  of  these  marbles  was  rendered  difficult  at 
Pisa  by  the  marshy  nature  of  the  ground  at  the  foot  of  the 
hills  which  impeded  transport,  and  Duke  Cosimo  set  himself 
to  find  a  remedy.  He  took  up  the  question  of  drainage  and 
regulation  of  watercourses  in  what  is  called  the  '  pianura  di 
Pisa,'  and  among  the  forty  medals  struck  to  celebrate  his 
various  achievements  were  some  for  '  Clima  Pisano  Risanato. ' 
In  1545  an  '  Uffizio  dei  fossi  '  was  constituted,  and  the  modern 
hydraulic  system  which  has  done  so  much  to  benefit  this  region, 
dates  from  these  measures  of  Cosimo.  Vasari,  §  11,  ante, 
p.  50,  speaks  of  a  river  '  Osoli  '  the  course  of  which  was 
straightened  and  confined.  This  is  probably  a  mistake  for 
'  Oseri  '  or  '  Osari,'  names  applying  to  one  of  the  small  streams 
close  to  Pisa  in  the  direction  of  the  quarries.  Targioni  Tozzetti 
in  his  Viaggi  in  Toscana  has  a  long  discussion  on  this  river, 
the  Auser  of  the  ancients,  for  which  he  gives  the  modern 
equivalents  '  Oseri, '  or  '  Osoli  '  (the  latter  probably  derived 
from  this  passage  in  Vasari).  There  is  a  '  Fossa  dell' 
Oseretto  '  to  the  west  of  the  city.  These  straightened  water- 
courses facilitated  the  transport  of  the  stone  in  barges. 


TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES  127 

Continuing  southwards  along  the  coast  we  come  to  some 
marble  quarries  mentioned  by  Vasari  on  the  promontory  of 
Piombino,  opposite  the  island  of  Elba.  The  locality  Vasari 
names  is  Campiglia  (§  10,  ante,  p.  50)  but  the  whole  of 
Monte  Calvi  above  that  town  is  marble-bearing,  and  the  pro- 
ducts were  said  to  be  as  good  in  quality  as  those  of  the  Carrara 
district  (Torelh,  I.e.,  p.  xc).  Vasari  says  that  the  Campiglia 
marbles  are  excellent  for  building  purposes,  and  Repetti  asserts 
that  in  the  fifteenth  century,  for  the  cupola  of  S.  Maria  del 
Fiore,  more  marble  was  used  from  this  region  than  from 
Carrara  itself.  The  ancient  reputation  of  the  district  is  not 
however  now  maintained. 

Hitherto  all  the  marbles  used  for  building  purposes  that 
Vasari  has  mentioned  have  been  white  or  variegated,  but 
everyone  who  has  visited  the  Tuscan  cities  knows  that  the 
decorative  effect  of  the  buildings  depends  on  the  juxtaposition 
of  bands  of  white  and  of  black,  or  at  any  rate,  dark  marble, 
with  occasional  bands  of  red.  The  dark  marbles  come  chiefly 
from  the  neighbourhood  of  Prato,  and  this  introduces  us  to  a 
group  of  inland  quarries  within  a  few  miles  of  Florence  to 
the  north  and  also  to  the  south  and  east.  Vasari  does  not 
say  much  about  this  dark  stone,  which  was  however  of  the 
utmost  importance  in  Tuscan  architecture.  It  is  commonly 
called  Prato  Serpentine,  or  '  Verde  di  Prato,'  and  the  quarries 
at  Monte  Ferrato,  by  Figline,  three  miles  north  of  Prato, 
produce  it  of  the  finest  quality.  The  Figline  quarries  are 
reported  on  by  Professor  Bonney  in  a  paper  on  '  Ligurian 
and  Tuscan  Serpentines  '  in  the  Geological  Magazine  for 
1879.  He  has  kindly  lent  us  the  specimen  from  the  quarry 
figured  as  E  on  the  Frontispiece.  This  stone  is  of  a  deep 
green  colour,  tending  sometimes  towards  a  purple  or  puce 
tint.  Stone  of  much  the  same  character  is  found,  as  Vasari 
states,  near  the  Impruneta,  six  or  seven  miles  east  of 
Florence.  It  is  this  Prato  Serpentine  that  has  been  so  largely 
used  from  the  twelfth  century  to  the  fifteenth  in  Tuscany  for 
alternating  with  the  white  marbles  in  the  incrustation  of 
fa9ades.  There  are  deposits  of  the  same  stone  in  the  Pisan 
mountains.  The  same  stone  was  sometimes  used  for  decorative 
stone  work  in  connection  with  sepulchral  monuments.     Accord- 


128  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

ing  to  Vasari  however,  ante,  p.  42  f . ,  it  was  the  '  paragone  '  or 
dark  limestone  of  Prato  that  was  chiefly  employed  for  this 
purpose. 

If  Vasari 's  information  about  this  important  stone,  and  his 
interest  in  it,  seem  scanty,  it  must  be  borne  in  mind  that  it 
was  a  mediaeval  material  rather  than  a  Renaissance  one.  We 
find  it  on  the  churches  and  bell  towers  and  baptistries  of  the 
twelfth  and  following  centuries,  but  not  on  the  palaces  of  the 
fifteenth  and  sixteenth.  Hence  the  stone  was  not  so  interesting 
in  Vasari 's  eyes  as  it  is  in  ours. 

Finally,  the  red  stone  seen  in  bands  on  the  Duomo  and  the 
Campanile  at  Florence,  that  Vasari  calls  '  marmo  rosso  '  (ante, 
p.  43),  is  not  fully  crystalline  and  is  rather  a  limestone  than 
a  marble.  It  is  deep  red  when  quarried,  but  on  the  buildings 
has  bleached  to  a  pinky  hue  from  exposure  to  the  air.  It  is 
apt  to  scale,  but  this  is  partly  due  to  its  not  being  laid  on 
its  proper  bed.  The  specimens  F  F  on  the  coloured  plate  show 
the  smoothed  external  surface  bleached  light  by  exposure.  We 
are  informed  by  Signor  Cellerini,  the  experienced  capomaestro 
of  the  Opera  del  Duomo  at  Florence,  that  in  old  time  this 
stone  was  quarried  at  Monsummano,  at  the  northern  extremity 
of  the  Monte  Albano  not  far  from  Pistoja.  A  more  modern 
source  of  supply  is  the  Tuscan  Maremma,  where  the  stone, 
called  '  Porta  Santa,'  is  quarried  between  Pisa  and  Grosseto, 
near  Gavorrano.  From  this  place  the  stone  has  been  brought 
for  recent  use  on  the  new  fa9ade  of  the  Duomo  at  Florence. 

Other  Tuscan  marbles,  such  as  those  of  Siena,  that  are  not 
referred  to  by  Vasari,  are  not  noticed  in  this  place. 

THE   ROUND   TEMPLE    ON   THE    PIAZZA   S.    LUIGI    DEI 
FRANCESI,   AND   'MAESTRO    GIAN.' 

[See  §  12,  Of  Travertine,  ante,  p.  51  f.] 

It  is  surprising  that  practically  nothing  appears  to  be  known, 
either  about  the  French  sculptor  mentioned  here,  '  Maestro 
Gian  '  (or  Jean),  or  about  the  French  wood  carver  of  the  same 
name  called  by  Vasari  'Maestro  Janni,'  who  is  referred  to 
at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction  '  to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.  174. 
Equally  strange  is  it  that  their  works,  which  Vasari  describes 


TUSCAN   MARBLE   QUARRIES 


129 


0 
H 

iz; 
0 

M 

H 

Ed 
< 

H 

a 

h 

< 

Pi 
< 

< 


MM 


H 
U 

U 
0 
Oi-J 

w> 

£>' 

heq 
S 


T) 

^° 

« 

c 

•< 

cd 

S  ^ 

0 

H 

OJ    (/) 

cy 

7 

c4  F^ 

vn 

US 

?ffi 

s^ 

"tfi   ri 
ui  ^ 

-t-J  "^^   fll 

CJ     _     N 
O     ™     N 


o 

I 

3 

c/5 


fi,     U     O 

c    . 


O 


U3 

a 

3 
« 
<; 

1-) 
M 
(S! 
<! 
% 

< 
U 
03 
t3 

H 

o 

H 
tn 


5  4; 


a 
o 


;^   I — I  C 

5  1-3  g" 
Is  6 


2  o 

23  .2, 

o  e  s    o 

Ph     OtZi  ti    p-i 


c 
o 


S    &       „ 

C^  I — I 


o 

°  S 


<u       ^ 

OJ  >-,  > 

ES  g^ 

c3  "Ti   ri   (3   g 


w 


I30  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

in  terms  of  high  praise,  and  which  are  in  public  view  in 
Rome  and  in  Florence,  do  not  seem  to  have  attracted  attention 
among  students  either  of  French  art  or  of  Italian.  The 
standard  older  book  on  French  artists  abroad,  Dussieux,  Les 
Artistes  Frangais  a  I'Etranger,  Paris,  1856,  takes  no  note  of 
either  of  them,  nor  are  they  referred  to  in  B6rard's  Dictionnaire 
Biographique  des  Artistes  Frangais  du  XII  au  XVII  Sikcle, 
Paris,  1872.  In  the  more  recent  Italian  work  however  by 
A.  Bertolotti,  Artisti  Francesi  in  Roma  nei  SecoU  XV,  XVI, 
e  XVII,  Mantova,  18S6,  there  is  a  mention  on  p.  220  of  '  un 
Giovanni  Chavenier,  che  forse  disegno  quel  tempio  tondo, 
attribuito  dal  Vasari  all'  architetto  Jean,'  and  on  p.  24  it  is 
said  that  Giovanni  Chiavier,  o  Chavenier,  di  Rouen  lavor6 
pel  Governo  pontificio  e  mori  a  Roma  nel  1527.'  Bertolotti 
unfortunately  gives  no  references  to  his  authorities,  while  the 
work  of  Miintz,  Les  Arts  a  la  Cour  des  Papes  breaks  off  before 
the  sixteenth  century,  and  gives  no  help. 

In  the  course  of  our  inquiries  we  communicated  with  the 
Director  of  the  Biblioteca  Vittorio  Emmanuele  at  Rome,  Com- 
mendatore  Conte  Gnoli,  who  kindly  gave  attention  to  the 
subject,  and  contributed  to  the  Giornale  d'  Italia  of  Dec.  24, 
1906,  an  interesting  article,  in  which,  though  he  could  give  no 
account  of  Maestro  Gian,  he  described  fully  the  extant  works  of 
which  Vasari  writes,  and  made  some  pertinent  suggestions  as 
to  the  '  round  temple. '  He  thinks  it  unlikely  that  the  building 
of  a  circular  church  from  the  foundations  was  contemplated  by 
the  French,  and  suggests  that  they  were  utilizing  the  founda- 
tions of  a  round  chamber  belonging  to  the  Thermae  of  Nero 
which  were  in  that  neighbourhood,  so  that  the  '  round  temple  ' 
would  have  been  like  the  present  S.  Bernardo  in  the  Thermae  of 
Diocletian.  M.  Marcel  Reymond  has  suggested  that  it  was  the 
sack  of  Rome  in  1527  that  led  to  the  abandonment  of  the  project 
— for  the  date  of  the  undertaking  can  be  fixed  in  the  reign  of 
Fran9ois  I  of  France,  who  came  to  the  throne  in  1515,  from 
the  fact  that  his  cognizance,  the  salamander,  occurs  in  the 
sculpture  prepared  for  its  embellishment.  If  the  artist  be  really 
Bertolotti's  'Chavenier,'  as  he  died  in  1527,  this  fact  would 
also  explain  the  abandonment. 

The  sculptures  in  question  are  in  part  incrusted  in  the  fa9ade 


SCULPTURE  AT  S.   LUIGI  131 

of  the  present  church  of  S.  Luigi  (see  ante,  p.  52)  and  the  fact 
that  some  of  them  are  carved  on  curved  surfaces  shows  at  once 
that  they  were  prepared  for  a  building  of  cylindrical  form. 
There  are  two  large  salamanders  in  round  frames  of  which 
one  is  shown  on  Plate  VI,  and  two  panels  higher  up  in  the 
fafade  with  the  curious  device  of  an  eagle  with  the  head  of  a 
woman  and  outspread  wings  from  which  depend  by  ribbons  on 
each  side  small  medallions.  There  are  also  some  lions' 
heads.  The  most  curious  piece  of  all  is  built  into  the  wall  of 
the  Palazzo  Madama  close  beside  the  church,  and  this  contains 
the  various  devices  that  Vasari  calls  '  astrological  globes ' 
'open  books  showing  the  leaves,'  'trophies,'  etc.  The  panel 
is  small  and  placed  too  high  to  be  properly  seen,  but  Sig. 
Gnoli,  by  the  aid  of  the  architect  of  the  palace,  was  able  to 
give  a  description  of  them  in  the  article  above  mentioned. 
The  work  is  very  minute  and  elaborate,  and  there  are  inscrip- 
tions from  which  it  appears  that  the  devices  signify  that  the 
seven  liberal  arts  are  nourished  by  the  lilies  of  France.  The 
sculpture  is  not  only  elaborate  in  design  but  most  artistic  as 
well  as  delicate  in  execution.  The  '  Salamander  '  it  will  be 
seen  is  excellent  work.  M.  Marcel  Reymond  points  out  that 
at  the  early  part  of  the  sixteenth  century  the  Italians  were 
accustomed  to  use  marble  for  decorative  carvings,  and  that  this 
French  artist,  whoever  he  was,  having  been  accustomed  to 
carve  the  limestones  of  his  native  country,  took  naturally  to 
the  manipulation  •  of  travertine,  and  that  his  success  with  the 
material  attracted  the  attention  and  admiration  of  the  Romans 
which  Vasari 's  commendations  reflect.  It  has  been  noticed 
above  that  Michelangelo's  frieze  in  the  cortile  of  the  Palazzo 
Farnese  was  not  carved  but  modelled  in  stucco.  See  ante, 
P-  S3- 

On  the  subject  of  the  mysterious  artist  a  word  will  be  said 
in  connection  with  the  later  passage  indicated  at  the  beginning 
of  this  Note.     See  postea,  p.  175. 


132  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

RUSTICATED    MASONRY. 

[See  §  20,  Rusticated  Masonry  and  the  Tuscan  Order, 
ante,  p.  65.] 

In  masonry  of  this  kind  the  sides  of  the  stones,  where  they 
come  into  contact  with  each  other,  are  dressed  smooth,  but  the 
face  of  each  stone  is  left  to  project  beyond  the  plane  of  the 
wall.  The  projections  may  be  rough  and  irregular,  in  which 
case  the  appearance  is  that  of  natural  stones,  and  a  rugged 
rock-like  aspect  is  given  to  the  wall-face.  The  projections 
may  however  be  wrought  into  bosses  of  regular  form,  or  into 
the  diamonds  and  facets  of  which  Vasari  goes  on  to  speak,  and 
of  which  a  notable  example  is  the  so-called  '  Palazzo  de' 
Diamanti '  at  Ferrara. 

This  method  of  treating  stones,  at  least  when  they  are  left 
rough  and  irregular,  saves  time  and  labour,  and  hence  it  has 
been  in  use  among  many  ancient  peoples,  but  almost  always 
for  substructures  and  parts  not  meant  to  be  seen.  The 
Romans  made  a  more  extensive  employment  of  it,  and  we  find 
it  not  only  on  sustaining  walls,  such  as  those  of  the  Hadrianic 
platform  of  the  Olympeion  at  Athens,  but  on  monumental 
wall-faces,  as  on  the  enclosing  wall  of  the  Forum  of  Augustus 
near  the  Arco  dei  Pantani  at  Rome,  one  of  the  finest  extant 
specimens  of  Roman  masonry  but  still  utilitarian  in  character. 
The  deliberate  use  of  rustication,  as  an  element  of  artistic 
effect,  on  the  fagade  of  a  public  building,  is  another  matter, 
and  it  is  doubtful  if  any  instance  of  this  occurs  before  the 
Italian  Renaissance.  There  is  a  piece  of  Roman  rusticated 
masonry  behind  the  ancient  theatre  at  Fiesole,  the  classical 
Faesolae,  and  Professor  Durm  thought  at  one  time  that  the 
Florentine  builders  might  have  derived  from  this  their  idea  of 
using  the  device  as  a  means  of  expression  in  stonework.  It 
may  be  questioned  however  whether  this  was  visible  at  all  in  the 
fifteenth  century,  and  it  is  much  more  likely  that  Renaissance 
rustication  was  a  natural  development  from  the  treatment  of 
the  wall  in  many  mediaeval  Tuscan  buildings,  in  which  the 
surface  of  the  stones  is  left  to  project  in  an  irregular  undesigned 
fashion.  The  Palazzo  Vecchio  and  the  Gothic  Palazzo  Ales- 
sandri  at  Florence  are  examples.     In  any  case,  in  the  hands 


Plate  VI 


SALAMANDER  CARVED  IN  TRAVERTINE 

On  the  facade  of  S.   Liiigi  dei  Francesi,  Rome,  by  a  French  artist, 

'  Maestro  Gian ' 


RUSTICATED   MASONRY  I33 

of  the  architects  of  the  Renaissance  rustication  became  an 
important  element  in  the  architectural  style  of  the  period,  and 
is  one  of  the  special  contributions  of  this  style  to  architecture 
at  large. 

Rustication  has  two  artistic  advantages.  In  the  first  place, 
it  emphasizes  the  separate  stones  in  an  assemblage,  and  when 
these  are  of  great  size  and  boldly  hewn,  as  at  the  Pitti  Palace 
at  Florence,  the  work  gains  in  dignity  through  this  individual- 
izing of  the  distinct  units  of  the  structure.  The  bossed  surface 
of  some  of  the  blocks  at  the  Pitti  stands  out  as  much  as  three 
feet  from  the  wall,  and  one  of  the  stones  is  twenty  eight  feet 
in  length.  In  the  second  place,  this  rustic  treatment  gives  a 
look  of  rugged  strength  that  is  very  effective,  especially  on  the 
lower  stages  of  monumental  buildings,  where  indeed  the  treat- 
ment is  most  in  place.  The  fa9ade  of  Michelozzo's  Riccardi 
Palace,  which  Vasari  refers  to  under  its  older  name  the  '  Casa 
Medici '  is  epoch-making  in  its  fine  handling  of  rustication  in 
degrees  according  to  the  stages  of  the  elevation. 

It  needs  hardly  to  be  said  that  the  elaborately  cut  facets 
which  Vasari  finds  so  beautiful,  and  of  which  we  have  seen  an 
example  in  Fig.  4,  ante,  p.  69,  are  too  artificial  to  be 
reckoned  in  good  architectural  style.  It  was  a  common 
practice,  when  the  stones  themselves  were  not  all  of  the  same 
size,  to  cut  these  diamonds  and  other  geometrical  forms  in 
independence  of  the  joints  of  the  masonry,  so  that  a  facet 
might  be  half  on  one  stone  and  half  on  another.  As  this 
ignores  the  individuality  of  the  blocks,  which  the  simpler  rusti- 
cation so  effectually  emphasizes,  it  is  by  no  means  to  be 
commended.  Vasari 's  last  sentences  in  §  20,  about  this  treat- 
ment of  stonework  in  general,  are  excellent.  The  rustication 
on  the  Fortezza,  shown  in  Fig.  4  is  sincere,  in  that  the 
jomtmg  corresponds  with  the  design. 

VASARI-S  OPINION  ON   MEDIAEVAL  ARCHITECTURE. 

[See  §  28,  German  Work  (the  Gothic  Style),  ante,  p.  83.] 

Vasari's    tirade    against    the    iniquities    of    the    mediaeval 

mason  is  of  historical  interest  as  reflecting  the  ideas  of  his  age, 

but  need  not  now  be  taken   seriously.     The  reason  why   he 


134  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

vjrrites  of  it  as  '  German  '  work  is  to  be  found  in  the  close 
intercourse  during  the  whole  mediaeval  period  between 
(&ermany  and  Italy,  that  were  nominally  under  the  one  imperial 
dceptre,  and  were  only  separated  by  the  Brenner.  '  Tedesco  ' 
^tood  to  the  mind  of  the  Italian  for  everything  north  of  the 
Alps,  and  though  the  pointed  style  in  architecture  was  of 
French  origin  it  appears  to  have  found  its  way  into  Italy 
through  the  Tyrol.  One  of  the  first  churches  in  this  style  in 
Italy,  S.  Francesco  at  Assisi,  was  designed  by  a  German 
master  from  Meran.  "feut  not  only  does  Vasari  call  the  manner 
he  detests  '  Tedesco, '  me  expressly,  in  this  passage  and  else- 
where, ascribes  it  to  the  Goths,  who,  after  ruining  the  ancient 
buildings  and  killing  off  the  classically  trained  architects,  had 
set  to  work  to  build  with  pointed  archg^j  It  is  clear  from 
this  phrase, 'as^weil  as~TroiinKe~description  he  gives  of  the 
little  niches  and  pinnacles  and  leaves  and  the  extravagant 
height  of  doors,  that  he  had  in  his  mind  the  pointed  style,  that 
dates  from  about  the  middle  of  the  twelfth  century.  The 
Goths  had  then  passed  out  of  existence  for  some  six  hundred 
years  and  Vasari 's  chronology  is  hopelessly  at  fault.  The 
name  '  Gothic  '  however,  which  he  was  the  first  to  apply  in 
this  sense,  has  adhered  to  the  style  ever  since,  and  in  spite  of 
■efforts  which  have  been  made  to  supplant  it,  will  probably 
remain  always  in  use,  though  no  one  will  now  or  in  the  future 
make  the  mistake  of  connecting  it  ethnologically  with  the 
historical  Goths  of  the  fifth  and  sixth  centuries. 

The  question  who  was  actually  the  first  to  apply  the  term 
^  Gothic  '  in  this  sense  has  been  a  subject  of  controversy. 
Some  have  attributed  the  invention  of  the  term  to  Raphael,  or 
the  author  of  the  Report  on  the  condition  of  Roman  monuments 
which  passes  under  his  name ;  while  others  have  claimed  the 
■dubious  honour  for  Cesare  Cesariano,  the  translator  and  com- 
mentator of  Vitruvius.  Neither  of  these  writers  however  uses 
the  word  in  the  sense  referred  to.  Raphael  it  is  true  writes 
of  a  '  Gothic  '  style  in  architecture  which  succeeded  to  the 
■classic  Roman,  but  he  makes  it,  quite  correctly,  belong  to  the 
actual  era  of  the  Gothic  conquest  of  Italy  in  the  fifth  century 
and  to  the  succeeding  hundred  years.  The  later  mediaeval 
architecture  Raphael  terms  '  architectura  Tedesca,'  and  when 


VASARI   ON   GOTHIC   ART  13S 

he  writes  of  this  he  seems  to  have  in  his  view  what  we  should 
rather  call  Lombard  Romanesque,  for  he  blames  in  it  the 
•  strange,  animals  and  figures,  and  foliage  out  of  all  reason.' 
In  other  words  Raphael,  or  the  author  of  the  Report,  distinctly 
does  not  commit  the  historical  enormity  of  dragging  the  word 
'  Gothic  '  six  centuries  out  of  its  proper  location  and  use. 

With  regard  to  Cesare  Cesariano,  this  personage  was  born 
in  1483  and  studied  architecture  under  Bramante.  He  was  of 
good  repute,  Vasari  tell  us,  {Opere,  iv,  149)  as  a  geometrician 
and  architect,  and  at  one  time  he  was  employed  as  director  of 
the  works  on  the  cathedral  of  Milan,  the  interior  of  which  he 
completed  in  its  present  form.  In  152 1  there  was  published  at 
Como,  at  the  charges  of  certain  scholars  and  notables  of  Milan 
and  Como,  an  edition  of  Vitruvius  headed  '  Di  Lucio  Vitruvio 
PoUione  a  Caesare  Augusto  De  Architectura  Incomenza  II 
Primo  Libro.  Translate  In  Vulgare  Sermone  Commentato  Et 
Affigurato  Da  Caesare  Caesariano  Citadino  Mediolanense 
Professore  Di  Architectura  Et  C*. '  Cesariano 's  commentary 
is  a  fearsome  work  of  appalling  verbosity,  but  there  is  nothing 
in  it  about  the  Goths  being  the  originators  of  the  pointed  style. 
He  mentions  the  Goths  on  fol.  cviii,  b,  but  not  in  connection 
with  architecture,  whereas  when  he  does  refer  to  late  mediaeval 
building  he  calls  it  not  Gothic  but  German.  On  fol.  xiii  b 
and  on  the  succeeding  pages  he  gives  some  interesting  plans 
and  drawings  j)f  the  cathedral  of  Milan,  important  in  connec- 
tion with  the  theory  of  the  use  in  Gothic  design  of  the 
equilateral  triangle,  but  distinctly  notes  it  as  constructed  by 
'Germanici  architecti,'  '  Germanico  more,'  and  'secundum 
Germanicam  symmetriam  ' ;  while  on  fol.  ex  b  he  again  says 
that  the  building  was  in  the  hands  of  a  German  architect. 
(See  Mothes,  Baukunst  des  Mittelalters  in  Italien,  Jena,  1884, 
p.  502  ff-)  It  is  clear  therefore  that  Cesare  Cesariano  has 
nothing  to  do  with  the  use  of  '  Gothic  '  as  an  architectural 
term,  and  his  name  need  not  be  mentioned  in  this  connection 

Filarete's  Tmttato  dell'  ArcUtettma,  dating  about  1464    is 
not  the  source  of  the  usage,   and  as  far  as  can  be  seen  at 
present  the  credit,  if  it  be  such,  of  the  invention  of  the  term 
Gothic    rests  with  Vasari. 


136  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

EGG-SHELL  MOSAIC. 

[See  §  33,  Pictorial  Mosaics  for  Walls,  etc.,  ante,  p.  93.] 

This  reference  on  the  part  of  Vasari  to  '  musaico  di  gusci  d' 
novo,'  '  mosaic  of  egg  shells,'  is  puzzling.  In  his  Life  of 
Gaddo  Gaddi  (Opere,  i,  348)  he  is  more  explicit,  and  states 
there  '  Dopo  ci6,  ritorn6  Gaddo  a  Firenze,  con  animo  di 
riposarsi  :  perchfe,  datosi  a  fare  piccole  tavolette  di  musaico,  ne 
condusse  alcune  di  guscia  d'  uova  con  diligenza  e  pacienza 
incredibile;  come  si  pu6,  fra  le  altre,  vedere  in  alcune  che 
ancor  oggi  sono  nel  tempio  di  San  Giovanni  di  Firenze.' 

The  Lemonnier  editors  of  Vasari  added  a  note  to  this 
passage  to  the  effect  that  one  of  these  small  plaques,  repre- 
senting a  Christ  with  an  open  book  in  His  left  hand,  was 
preserved  when  they  wrote  in  the  Uffizi,  and  that  the  mosaic 
was  '  composed  of  very  minute  pieces  of  egg-shell  united 
together  with  a  diligence  and  a  patience  truly  incredible. '  This 
piece  is  now  in  the  Chapel  in  the  Bargello  and  Dr  Giovanni 
Poggi  has  had  the  kindness  to  examine  it  minutely.  He 
reports  that  there  is  no  sign  of  the  use  of  egg-shell  in  it,  but 
that  it  is  a  finely  executed  mosaic  of  small  pieces  of  coloured 
materials  of  a  hard  substance,  in  all  respects  similar  to  the 
portable  Byzantine  mosaics  of  which  there  are  two  notable 
specimens  in  the  Opera  del  Duomo  at  Florence  (Gori,  Thes. 
Vet.  Dipty Chorum,  iii,  320  f.).  Eugfene  Miintz  noticed  various 
examples  of  this  kind  of  work  in  an  article  in  the  Bulletin 
Monumental,  1886,  and  one  of  them,  an  '  Annunciation  '  in  the 
Victoria  and  Albert  Museum,  is  a  typical  piece.  It  is  composed 
of  tesserae  of  minute  size  of  different  coloured  marbles,  lapis 
lazuli,  etc.,  on  a  ground  of  gold  formed  of  little  cubes  of  the 
metal,  all  bedded  in  wax  or  similar  yielding  substance.  There 
is  no  sign  of  the  use  of  egg-shell,  and  indeed  the  idea  of  a 
mosaic  of  pieces  of  egg-shell  seems  absurd,  because  there  is  no 
variety  of  colour,  and  therefore  no  possibility  of  mosaic  effect 
without  painting  each  piece  some  special  hue. 

Were  it  only  Vasari  who  mentioned  this  supposed  egg-shell 
mosaic  the  matter  might  be  passed  over,  but  as  a  fact  one  of 
the  chapters  of  Cennino  Cennini's  Trattato  is  devoted  to  this 
very   subject.     He   there   describes,    c.    172,    what   he   calls   a 


EGG-SHELL   MOSAIC  137 

'  mosaic  '  of  small  cubes  of  the  pith  of  feathers  and  of  egg- 
shells, but  the  technique  as  he  explains  it  is  not  mosaic, 
properly  so-called,  but  rather  an  imitation  of  mosaic  by  means 
of  painting  on  a  roughened  ground  giving  something  of  the 
effect  of  a  ground  laid  with  tesserae.  Egg-shells  are  apparently 
crushed  down  on  the  surface  so  as  to  give  it  a  sort  of  crackled 
appearance,  and  varieties  of  colour  are  added  by  the  paint- 
brush. Vasari  mentions  in  his  life  of  Agnolo  Gaddi,  Opere,  i, 
643  f.,  that  he  had  seen  a  MS.  of  Cennino's  treatise,  and  it  is 
possible  that  he  remembered  the  heading  '  musaico  di  gusci  d' 
uovo  '  and,  with  his  instinct  for  giving  a  personal  interest  to 
everything,  attributed  to  one  of  his  early  Florentines,  Gaddo 
Gaddi,  the  use  of  the  supposed  technique.  We  have  not  been 
able  to  hear  of  any  extant  piece  of  work  corresponding  to 
Cennino's  description,  though  we  have  to  thank  several  expert 
authorities  for  kindly  interesting  themselves  in  the  matter. 
Cennino's  notice  is  appended  in  the  original.  It  does  not  occur 
in  the  Tambroni  text. 

Description  of  the  technique  in   Cennino  Cennini,   II  Libro 
dell'  Arte,  ed.  Milanesi,  Firenze,   1859,  cap.  clxxii. 

'  Come  si  Lavora  in  Opera  Musaica  per  adornamento  di 

Reliquie;    e  del  Musaico  di  Bucciuoli  di  penne,   e  di  Gusci 

d'  Uovo. 

.  .  A  questa  opra  medesima,  e  molto  fine,  buccioli  di  penne 
tagliati  molto  minuti  si  come  panico  e  tinti  si  come  detto  ho. 
Ancora  puoi  lavorare  del  detto  musaico  in  questo  modo. 
Togli  le  tue  guscia  d'  uovo  ben  peste  pur  bianche,  e  in  sulla 
figura  disegnata  campeggia,  riempi  e  lavora  si  come  fussi 
coloriti  :  e  poi  quando  hai  campeggiata  la  tua  figura  coi  colori 
propii  da  cassetta,  e  temperati  con  un  poco  di  chiara  d'  uovo, 
va'  colorendo  la  figura  di  parte  in  parte,  si  come  facessi  in 
su  lo  'ngessato  propio,  pur  d'  acquerelle  di  colori;  e  poi 
quando  k  secco,  vernica  si  come  vernici  I'altre  cose  in  tavola. 
Per  campeggiare  le  dette  figure,  si  come  fai  in  muro,  a  te 
conviene  pigliare  questo  partito,  di  toglier  fc^liette  dorate, 
o  arientate,  o  oro  grosso  battuto  o  ariento  grosso  battuto  : 
taglialo  minutissimo,  e  colle  dette  mollette  va'  campeggiando 
a  modo  Che  campeggi  i  tuoi  gusci  pesti,  dove  il  campo  richiede 


138  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

oro.  Ancora,  campeggiare  di  gusci  bianchi  il  campo ;  bagnare 
di  chiara  d'  uovo  battuta,  di  quella  che  metti  il  tuo  oro  in 
sul  vetro;  bagna  della  medesima;  metti  il  tuo  oro  come 
trae  il  campo;  lascia  asciugare,  e  brunisci  con  bambagia. 
E  questo  basti  alia  detta  opera  musaica,  o  vuoi  greca.' 

IDEAL  ARCHITECTURE;  AN  IDEAL  PALACE. 
[See  §  35,  An  Ideal  Palace,  ante,  p.  96.] 
The  construction — in  words — of  an  imaginary  mansion  of  the 
type  suited  to  the  ideas  of  the  Renaissance  was  a  favourite 
exercise  among  both  professional  and  amateur  writers,  and 
Vasari  might  have  made  a  greater  effort  than  he  has  done  to 
rise  to  the  height  of  his  subject.  The  theme  had  some  signi- 
ficance. The  intent  of  those  who  dealt  with  it  was  to  provide 
the  man  of  the  Renaissance  with  a  fit  setting  for  his  life,  and 
the  spacious  and  lordly  palace  corresponded  to  the  amplitude  of 
the  personality  developed  by  the  humanistic  culture  of  the  age. 
The  representative  man  of  the  Renaissance  may  have  missed 
certain  of  the  higher  ethical  qualities,  but  he  was  many-sided, 
in  mind  and  person  a  finely  developed  creature,  self-reliant, 
instinct  with  vigour  and  set  on  mastery.  Such  a  being 
demanded  space  and  opulence  with  an  air  of  greatness  in  his 
habitation,  and  fitly  to  house  him  was  a  task  calling  forth  all 
the  powers  of  the  architects  of  the  period.  An  imposing  fa9ade 
with  heraldic  achievements  should  proclaim  his  worth,  wide 
gateways  and  roomy  courts  and  loggie  give  an  impression  of 
lordly  ease,  broad  staircases  and  ample  halls  suggest  the 
coming  and  going  of  companies  of  guests.  He  would  need  a 
garden,  where  marble  seats  in  ilex  shades  or  in  grottoes  beside 
cool  fountains  should  await  him  in  hours  when  reflection  or 
reading,  music  or  conversation,  called  him  awhile  from  keen 
conflict  of  wit  or  policy  with  his  peers  in  the  world  outside. 
He  would  exact  moreover  that  over  all  the  place  Art  should 
breathe  a  spell  to  soothe  the  senses  and  to  flatter  pride;  art 
sumptuous  in  materials,  accomplished  in  technique,  pagan  in 
form  and  spirit,  should  people  the  galleries  with  sculptured 
shapes,  cover  walls  and  roof  with  graceful  imagery,  and  set 
here  and  there  on  cabinet  or  console  some  jewel  of  carved  ivory 
or  gilded  wood  or  chiselled  bronze. 


AN   IDEAL  PALACE  I39 

All  the  great  architects  of  the  Renaissance  were  at  work  on 
these  palaces  first  at  Florence  and  then  in  every  rich  Italian 
town,  but  the  actual  achievement  that  circumstances  allowed 
fell  far  short  of  the  ideal  perfection,  the  effort  after  which  was 
the  best  spiritual  product  of  the  Renaissance.  Hence  it  became 
the  fashion  to  draw  out  visionary  schemes  of  princely  dwell- 
ings, and  even  of  whole  city  quarters  for  the  setting  of  these, 
and  ideal  architecture  furnishes  matter  for  a  chapter  in  the  art 
history  of  the  times.  Filarete's  Trattato  dell'  Architettura  is 
full  of  matter  of  the  kind.  In  his  eighth  Book  he  describes 
a  palace  for  a  prince,  in  Book  eleven  an  ideal  mansion  for 
a  nobleman;  and  his  proposed  arrangements  are  all  on 
a  grandiose  scale.  Ammanati,  who  built  the  Ponte  della 
Triniti  at  Florence,  left  a  whole  collection  of  drawings  for  a 
'  Citti  Ideale,'  and  Leonardo  da  Vinci's  codices  are  fertile  in 
similar  suggestions.  In  France,  where  this  phase  of  the 
artistic  activity  of  the  Renaissance  was  as  much  in  evidence 
as  in  Italy,  the  actual  palaces  of  king  or  noble  were  far  outdone 
in  splendour  and  in  symmetry  by  the  schemes  of  Palissy  or 
De  rOrme,  of  which  Baron  de  GeymuUer  has  given  an  interest- 
ing notice  in  his  Baukunst  der  Renaissance  in  Frankreich, 
published  in  the  Handbuch  der  Architectur. 

Nor  was  it  only  the  professed  artists  who  occupied  them- 
selves in  this  fashion.  It  was  a  literary  exercise  to  scheme 
out  in  vague  and  general  outlines  the  ideal  habitation  for 
prince  or  for  community,  and  Rabelais'  Abbey  of  Theleme, 
with  its  nine  thousand  three  hundred  and  thirty  two  rooms, 
its  libraries,  theatres,  and  recreation  halls,  is  the  most  famous 
example  of  its  kind.  In  our  own  literature  too  there  must  not 
be  forgotten  Francis  Bacon's  Essay  on  Building,  in  which  he 
draws  out  the  general  configuration  of  what  he  calls  a  '  perfect 
palace,'  where  the  facade  is  in  two  wings  'uniform  without, 
though  severally  partitioned  within,'  and  these  are  to  be  '  on 
both  sides  of  a  great  and  stately  tower,  in  the  midst  of  the 
front;  that  as  it  were  joineth  them  together  on  either  hand  ' 
Symmetry  is  of  course  the  characteristic  of  all  these  ideal 
structures,  as  it  was  long  ago  of  the  visionary  temple  described 
by  Ezechiel,  and  Vasari's  palace  is  no  exception  to  the  rule 
Vasan  s  description  does  not  convey  a  very  clear  idea  of  what 


140  NOTES   ON   ARCHITECTURE 

he  conceived  the  ideal  palace  would  be,  and  he  might  have 
done  better  for  the  theme  had  he  not  hampered  himself  at  the 
outset  with  the  otiose  comparison  of  the  house  to  a  human 
body.  This  he  may  have  derived  from  Filarete,  who  also 
employs  the  conceit. 


OF   SCULPTURE 


OF   SCULPTURE 


CHAPTER   I.    (VIII.) 

What  Sculpture  is  ;  how  good  works  of  Sculpture  are  made,  and  what 
qualities  they  must  possess  to  be  esteemed  perfect. 

§  36.  The  Nature  of  Sculpture. 

Sculpture  is  an  art  .which  by  removing  all  that  is 
superfluous  from  the  material  under  treatment  reduces  it 
to  that  form  designed  in  the  artist's  mind.^ 

§  37-  Qualities  necessary  for   Work  in  the  Round. 

Now  seeing  that  all  figures  of  whatever  sort,  whether 
carved  in  marble,  cast  in  bronze,  or  wrought  in  plaster 
or  wood,  must  be  in  salient  work  in  the  round,  and  seeing 
too  that  as  we  walk  round  them  they  are  looked  at  from 
every  side,  it  is  clear  that  if  we  want  to  call  them  perfect 
they  must  have  many  qualities.  The  most  obvious  is  / 
that  when  such  a  figure  is  presented  to  our  eyes,  it  should 
show  at  the  first  glance  the  expression  intended,  whether 
pride  or  humility,  caprice,  gaiety  or  melancholy — accord- 
ing to  the  personage  portrayed.  It  must  also  be  balanced 
in  all  its  members :  that  is,  it  must  not  have  long  legs, 
a  thick  head,  and  short  and  deformed  arms;  but  be  well 
proportioned,  and  from  head  to  foot  have  each  part  con- 
forming with  the  others.  In  the  same  way,  if  the  figure 
have  the  face  of  an  old  man,  let  it  have  the  arms,  body, 

'  See  note  on  '  The  Nature  of  Sculpture,'  at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction ' 
to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.   179. 


144  OF   SCULPTURE 

legs,  hands,  and  feet  of  an  old  man,  the  skeleton  sym- 
metrically ordered  throughout,  the  muscles  and  sinews  and 
veins  all  in  their  proper  places.  If  it  have  the  face  of  a 
youth,  it  must  in  like  manner  be  round,  soft  and  sweet 
in  expression,  harmonious  in  every  part.  If  it  is  not  to 
be  nude,  do  not  let  the  drapery/ that  is  to  cover  it  be 
so  meagre  as  to  look  thin,  nor  clumsy  like  lumps  of  stone, 
but  let  the  flow  of  the  folds  be  so  turned  that  they  reveal 
the  nude  beneath — and  with  art  and  grace  now  show  now 
hide  it  without  any  harshness  that  may  detract  from  the 
figure.  Let  the  hair  and  beard  be  worked  with  a  certain 
delicacy,  arranged  and  curled  to  show  they  have  been 
combed,  having  the  greatest  softness  and  grace  given  to 
them  that  the  chisel  can  convey ;  and  because  the  sculptors 
cannot  in  this  part  actually  counterfeit  nature,  they  make 
the  locks  of  hair  solid  and  curled,  working  from  manner  ^ 
rather  than  in  imitation  of  nature.  Even  though  the 
figures  be  draped,  the  feet  and  hands  must  be  modelled 
with  the  care  and  beauty  shown  in  the  other  parts.  And 
as  the  figure  is  in  the  round,  it  is  essential  that  in  front, 
in  profile,  and  at  the  back,  it  be  of  equal  proportions, 
having  at  every  turn  and  view  to  show  itself  happily 
disposed   throughout.     Indeed   the  whole   work   must  be 

^  '  V\forking  from  manner.'  Vasari  refers  here  to  what  artists  call  'treatment,' 
which  is  "  process  of  analysis  and  grouping,  applied  to  appearances  in  nature 
where  the  eye  sees  at  first  little  more  than  a  confused  medley  of  similar  forms 
that  are  perhaps  constantly  changing.  Under  such  an  aspect  the  hair  as  well 
as  the  folds  of  drapery  on  the  human  figure  presented  themselves  to  the  early 
Greek  sculptor,  and  it  was  a  long  time  before  he  learned  to  handle  them 
aright.  In  the  case  of  the  hair  he  had  no  help  in  previous  work,  for  in 
Egyptian  statues  it  is  often  covered,  or  is  replaced  by  a  formal  wig,  and  in 
Assyrian  art  the  hair  is  very  severely  though  finely  conventionalized.  It  was 
not  until  the  age  of  Pheidias  that  the  Greeks  learned  how  to  suggest  the  soft 
and  ample  masses  of  the  hair,  and  at  the  same  time  to  subdivide  these  into 
the  distinct  curls  or  tresses,  each  one  '  solid,'  as  Vasari  requires,  but  individually 
rendered  with  the  minuter  markings  which  suggest  the  structure  and  '  feel '  of 
the  material.  The  Italians  started  of  course  with  this  treatment  or  '  manner ' 
already  an  established  tradition  founded  on  antique  practice.  In  the  mediaeval 
sculpture  of  the  thirteenth  and  fourteenth  centuries  in  France  and  England 
the  hair  is  often  very  artistically  rendered. 


SCULPTURE   TREATED   FOR   POSITION     145 

harmonious,  and  exhibit  pose,  drawing  and  unity,  grace 
and  finish ;  Ahese  qualities  taken  together  show  the  natural/ 
talent  and  capacity  of  the  artist. 


§  38.   Works  of  Sculpture  should  be  treated  with  a  view 
to  their  destined  position. 

Figures  in  relief  as  well  as  in  painting  ought  to  be 
produced  with  judgement  rather  than  in  a  mechanical  way,^ 
especially  when  they  are  to  be  placed  on  a  height,  at.a. 
great  distance.  In  this  position  the  fini.tjh  nf  the,  last 
touches  is  lost,  though  the  beautiful  form  of  the  arms 
and  legs,  and  the  good  taste  displayed  in  the  cast  of 
drapery,  with  folds  not  too  numerous,  may  easily  be 
recognized;  in  this  simplicity  and  reserve  is  shown  the 
refinement  of  the  talent.  Figures  whether  of  marble  or 
of  bronze  that  stand  somewhat  high,  must  be  boldly 
iimlprriit  in  order  that  the  marble  which  is  white  and  the 
bronze  which  tends  towards  black  may  receive  some  shad- 
ing from  the  atmosphere,  and  thus  the  work  at  a  distance 
appear  to  be  finished,  thpugh  from  near  it  is  seen  to  be 
left  only  in  the  rough./ This  was  a  point  to  which  the 
ancients  paid  great  attention,  as  we  see  in  their  figures 
in  the  round  and  in  half  relief,  in  the  arches  and  the 
columns  in  Rome,  which  still  testify  to  the  great  judgement 
they  possessed.  Among  the  moderns,  the  same  quality 
is  notably  exhibited  in  his  works  by  Donatello.  Again, 
it  is  to  be  remembered,  that/when  statues  are  to  be  in  a 
high  position,  and  there  is  n6t  much  space  below  to  enable 
one  to  go  far  enough  off  to  view  them  at  a  distance,  but 
one  is  forced  to  stand  almost  under  them,  they  must  be 
made  one  head  or  two  taller.  This  is  done  because  those 
figures  which  are  placed  high  up  lose  in  the  fore- 
shortening, when  viewed  by  one  standing  beneath  and 
looking  upwards.     Therefore  that  which  is  added  in  height 

*  This  paragraph  opens  up  a  subject  of  much  artistic  interest,  on  which  see 
Note  on  'Sculpture  Treated  for  Position,'  at  the  close  of  the  'Introduction'  to 
Sculpture,  postea,  p.  i8of. 

K 


146  OF   SCULPTURE 

comes  to  be  consumed  in  the  foreshortening,  and  they 
turn  out  when  looked  at  to  be  really  in  proportion,  correct 
and  not  dwarfed,  nay  rather  full  of  grace.  And  if  the 
artist  should  not  desire  to  do  this  he  can  keep  the  members 
of  the  figure  rather  slender  and  refined,  this  gives  almost 
the  same  effect. 

§  39.  The  Proportions  of  the  Human  Figure. 
It  is  the  custom  of  many  artists  to  make  the  figure  nine 
heads  high;  dividing  it  in  the  following  manner;  the 
throat,  the  neck,  and  the  height  of  the  foot  (from  the  instep 
to  the  sole)  are  equal  to  one  head  and  the  rest  of  the  body 
to  eight ;  of  these,  the  shinbone  measures  two  heads,  from 
the  knee  to  the  organs  of  generation  two  more,  while 
the  body  up  to  the  pit  of  the  throat  is  equal  to  three,  with 
another  from  the  chin  to  the  top  of  the  forehead,  so  that 
there  are  nine  in  all.*  As  to  the  measurements  across, 
from  the  pit  of  the  throat  to  the  shoulder  on  each 
side  is  the  length  of  a  head,  and  each  arm  to  the  wrist 
is  three  heads.  Thus  the  man  with  his  arms  stretched 
out  measures  exactly  as  much  as  his  height. 

§  40.  Artists  must  depend  on  their  Judgement  rather  than 
on  the  Measuring  Rule. 
After  all  the  eye  must  give  the  final  judgement,  for, 
even  though  an  object  be  most  carefully  measured,  if 
the  eye  remain  offended  it  will  not  cease  on  that  account 
to  censure  it. 

*  For  Vasari,  a  practical  artist,  to  commit  himself  to  the  statement  that 
figures  are  made  nine  heads  high,  is  somewhat  extraordinary,  for  eight  heads, 
the  proportion  given  by  Vitruvius  (lll,  l)  is  the  extreme  limit  for  a  normal 
adult,  and  very  few  Greek  statues,  let  alone  living  persons,  have  heads  so 
small.  The  recently  discovered  '  Agias '  by  Lysippus,  at  Delphi,  is  very 
nearly  eight  heads  high.  The  '  Doryphorus '  at  Naples  not  much  more  than 
seven.  The  '  Choisseul  Gouffier  Apollo '  about  seven  and  a  half,  etc.  Vasari 
seems  to  have  derived  his  curious  mode  of  reckoning  from  Filarete,  who  in 
Book  I  of  his  Treatise  on  Architecture  measures  a  man  as  follows :  Head  =  i 
head,  neck  =  J,  breast  =1,  body  =  2,  thighs =2,  legs  =  2,  foot  =  J,  total  nine 
heads.  Alberti,  Leonardo,  Albrecht  DUrer,  and  indeed  almost  all  the  older 
writers  on  art,  discourse  on  the  proportions  of  the  human  figure. 


ARTISTS  DEPEND  ON  THEIR  JUDGEMENT     147 

^et  me  repeat  that  although  measurement  exercises 
a  just  control  in  enlarging  the  figure  so  that  the  height 
and  breadth,  kept  according  to  rule,  may  make  the  work 
well  proportioned  and  beautiful,  the  eye  nevertheless  must 
decide  where  to  take  away  and  where  to  add  as  it  sees 
defect  in  the  work,  till  the  due  proportion,  grace,  design 
and  perfection  are  attained,  so  that  the  work  may  be 
praised  in  all  its  parts  by  every  competent  authority.  And 
that  statue  or  figure  which  shall  have  these  qualities  will 
be  perfect  in  beauty,  in  design  and  in  grace.  Such  figures 
we  call  figures  '  in  the  round,'  provided  that  all  the  parts 
appear  finished,  just  as  one  sees  them  in  a  man,  when 
walking  round  him  l/ the  same  holds  good  of  all  the  details 
which  depend  on  the  whole.  But  it  seems  to  me  high 
time  to  come  to  the  particulars  of  the  subject. 


CHAPTER   II.     (IX.) 

Of  the  manner  of  making  Models  in  Wax  and  in  Clay ;  how  they 
are  draped,  and  how  they  are  afterwards  enlarged  in  proportion 
in  the  Marble  ;  how  Marbles  are  worked  with  the  point  and  the 
toothed  tool,  and  are  rubbed  with  pumice  stone  and  polished  till 
they  are  perfect. 

§  41.  The  small  Sketch-Model  in  Wax  or  Clay. 

Sculptors,  when  they  wish  to  work  a  figure  in  marble, 
are  accustomed  to  make  what  is  called  a  model  for  it  in 
clay  or  wax  or  plaster;  that  is,  a  pattern,  about  a  foot 
high,  more  or  less,  according  as  is  found  convenient, 
because  they  can  exhibit  in  it  the  attitude  and  proportion 
of  the  figure  that  they  wish  to  make,  endeavouring  to 
adapt  themselves  to  the  height  and  breadth  of  the  stone 
quarried  for  their  statue. 

§  42.  The  Preparation  of  Wax. 

In  order  to  show  how  wax  is  modelled,  let  us  first  speak 
of  the  working  of  wax  and  not  of  clay.  To  render  it  softer 
a  little  animal  fat  and  turpentine  and  black  pitch  are  put 
into  the  wax,  and  of  these  ingredients  it  is  the  fat  that 
makes  it  more  supple;  the  turpentine  adds  tenacity,  and 
the  pitch  gives  it  the  black  colour  and  a  certain  con- 
sistency, so  that  after  it  has  been  worked  and  left  to  stand 
it  becomes  hard.  And  he  who  would  wish  to  make  wax  of 
another  colour,  may  easily  do  so  by  putting  into  it  red 
earth,  or  vermilion  or  red  lead;  he  will  thus  make  it  of  a 
yellowish  red  or  some  such  shade;  if  he  add  verdigris, 
green,  and  so  on  with  the  other  colours.  But  it  is  well 
to  notice  that  the  colours  should  be  ground  into  powder 


THE   MANIPULATION  OF  WAX  149 

and  sifted,  and  in  this  state  afterwards  mixed  with  the 
wax  made  as  liquid  as  possible.  The  wax  is  also  made 
white  for  small  things,  medals,  portraits,  minute  scenes 
and  other  objects  of  bas-relief.  And  this  is  done  by 
.mixing  powdered  white  lead  with  the  white  wax  as 
explained  above. 

§  43.  Polychrome  Wax  Effigies.^ 

Nor  shall  I  conceal  that  modern  artists  have  discovered 
the  method  of  working  in  wax  of  all  sorts  of  colours,  so 
that  in  taking  portraits  from  the  life  in  half-relief,  they 
make  the  flesh  tints,  the  hair,  the  clothes  and  all  the  other 
details  so  life-like  that  to  these  figures  there  lacks  nothing, 
as  it  were,  but  the  spirit  and  the  power  of  speech. 

§  44.  The  Manipulation  of  Wax  over  an  Armature. 

But  to  return  to  the  manner  of  preparing  the  wax; 
when  the  mixture  has  been  melted  and  allowed  to  go  cold, 
it  is  made  into  sticks  or  rolls.  These  from  the  warmth 
of  the  hands  become,  in  the  working,  like  dough  and  are 
suitable  for  modelling  a  figure  that  is  seated  or  erect  or 
as  you  please.  To  make  the  figure  support  itself,  it  may 
have  underneath  the  wax  an  armature  either  of  wood, 
or  of  iron  wires  according  to  the  pleasure  of  the  artist; 
or  this  can  be  omitted  if  it  suit  him  better.  Little  by 
little,  always  adding  material,  with  judgement  and  manipu- 
lation, the  artist  impresses  the  wax  by  means  of  tools 
made  of  bone,  iron,  or  wood,  and  again  putting  on  more 
he  alters  and  refines  till  with  the  fingers  the  utmost  finish 
is  given  to  the  model. 

§  45.  The  Small  Model  in  Clay. 

Should  he  wish  to  make  his  model  in  clay,  he  works 
exactly  as  with  wax,  but  without  the  armature  of  wood 
or  iron  underneath,  because  that  would  cause  the  clay  to 

'  See  Note  on  '  Waxen  Effigies  and  Medallions,'  at  the  close  of  the  '  Intro- 
duction' to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.  l88. 


ISO  OF  SCULPTURE 

crack  open  or  break  up ;  ^  and  that  it  may  not  crack  while 
it  is  being  worked  he  keeps  it  covered  with  a  wet  cloth 
till  it  is  completed, 

§  46.  The  Full-sized  Model  in  Clay. 

When  these  small  models  or  figures  of  wax  or  clay 
are  finished,  the  artist  sets  himself  to  make  another  model 
as  large  as  the  actual  figure  intended  to  be  executed  in 
marble.  In  fashioning  this  he  must  use  deliberation, 
because  the  clay  which  is  worked  in  a  damp  state  shrinks 
in  drying;  he  therefore,  as  he  works,  adds  more  bit  by 
bit  and  at  the  very  last  mixes  some  baked  flour  with  the 
clay  to  keep  it  soft  and  remove  the  dryness.^  This  trouble 
is  taken  that  the  model  shall  not  shrink  but  remain 
accurate  and  similar  to  the  figure  to  be  carved  in  marble. 
To  ensure  that  the  large  clay  model  shall  support  itself 
and  the  clay  not  crack,  the  artist  must  take  some  soft 
cuttings  of  cloth  or  some  horse  hair,  and  mix  this  with 
the  clay  to  render  it  tenacious  and  not  liable  to  split.  The 
figure  is  supported  by  wood  underneath  with  pressed  tow 
or  hay  fastened  to  it  with  string.*  The  bones  of  the  figure 
are  made  and  placed  in  the  necessary  pose  after  the  pattern 
of  the  small  model,  whether  erect  or  seated ;  and  from 
the  beginning  to  the  end  of  the  process  of  covering  it 
with  clay  the  figure  is  formed  in  the  nude. 

§  47.  Drapery  on  the  Clay  Model. 

This  completed,  if  the  artist  desire  afterwards  to  clothe 
it  with  thin  drapery,  he  takes  fine  cloth,  if  with  heavy, 

^  One  objection  to  an  armature  of  wood  is  that  the  material  may  swell  with 
the  damp  of  the  clay  and  cause  fissures.  Iron  is  objectionable  because  the 
rust  discolours  the  clay.  Modern  sculptors  often  use  gas-piping  in  the  skeletons 
of  their  models,  as  this  is  flexible  and  will  neither  rust  nor  swell. 

'  Baked  flour  used  to  be  employed  by  plasterers  to  keep  the  plaster  they 
were  modelling  from  setting  too  rapidly.  See  the  Introduction  by  G.  F. 
Robinson  to  Millar's  Plastering  Plain  and  Decorative,  London,  1897.  The 
former  used  rye  dough  with  good  effect  for  the  above  purpose. 

''  The  tow  or  hay  tied  round  the  wood  affords  a  good  hold  for  the  clay, 
which  is  apt  to  slip  on  anything  smooth. 


THE   FULL-SIZED   MODEL  151 

he  takes  coarse,  and  wets  it  and  then  covers  it  over  with 
clay,  not  liquid  but  of  the  consistency  of  rather  thick 
mud,  and  arranges  it  around  the  figure  in  such  folds  and 
creases  as  the  mind  suggests;  this  when  dry,  becomes 
hardened  and  continues  to  keep  the  folds.^ 

§  48.  Transference  of  the  Full-sized  Model  to  the  Marble 

Block. 
Models,  whether  of  wax  or  of  clay,  are  formed  in  the 
same  manner.  To  enlarge  the  figure  proportionately  in 
the  marble  ^  it  is  necessary  that  against  this  same  block, 
whence  the  figure  has  to  be  carved,  there  shall  be  placed 
a  carpenter's  square,  one  leg  of  which  shall  be  horizontal 
at  the  foot  of  the  figure  while  the  other  is  vertical  and  is 
always  at  right  angles  with  the  horizontal,  and  so  too 
with  the  straight  piece  above;  and  similarly  let  another 
square  of  wood  or  other  material  be  adjusted  to  the  model, 
by  means  of  which  the  measures  may  be  taken  from  the 
model,  for  instance  how  much  the  legs  project  forward 
and  how  much  the  arms.  Let  the  artist  proceed  to  carve 
out  the  figure  from  these  measurements,  transferring  them 
to  the  marble  from  the  model,  so  that  measuring  the  marble 
and  the  model  in  proportion  he  gradually  chisels  away 
the  stone  till  the  figure  thus  measured  time  after  time, 
issues  forth  from  the  marble,  in  the  same  manner  that 
one  would  lift  a  wax  figure  out  of  a  pail  of  water,  evenly 
and  in  a  horizontal  position.  First  would  appear  the  body, 
the  head,  and  the  knees,  the  figure  gradually  revealing 
itself  as  it  is  raised  upwards,  till  there  would  come  to  view 
the  relief  more  than  half  completed  and  finally  the  round- 
ness of  the  whole. 

§  49.  Danger  of  dispensing  with  the  Full-sized  Model. 

Those  artificers  who  are  in  a  hurry  to  get  on,  and  who 
hew  into  the  stone  at  the  first  and  rashly  cut  away  the 

°  This  method  of  prodncing  drapery  is  not  very  artistic. 
'  See  Note  on   '  Proportionate  Enlargement '   at  close  of  the  '  Introduction ' 
to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.   190. 


152  OF  SCULPTURE 

marble  in  front  and  at  the  back  have  no  means  afterwards 
of  drawing  back  in  case  of  need.''  Many  errors  in  statues 
spring  from  this  impatience  of  the  artist  to  see  the  round 
figure  out  of  the  block  at  once,  so  that  often  an  error  is 
revealed  that  can  only  be  remedied  by  joining  on  pieces, 
as  we  have  seen  to  be  the  habit  of  many  modern  artists. 
This  patching  is  after  the  fashion  of  cobblers  and  not  of 
competent  men  or  rare  masters,  and  is  ugly  and  despicable 
and  worthy  of  the  greatest  blame. 

§  50.   The  Tools  and  Materials  used  in  Marble  Carving. 

Sculptors  are  accustomed,  in  working  their  marble 
statues,  to  begin  by  roughing  out  the  figures  with  a  kind 
of  tool  they  call  '  subbia,'  which  is  pointed  and  heavy; 
it  is  used  to  block  out  their  stone  in  the  large,  and 
then  with  other  tools  called  '  calcagnuoli  '  which  have  a 
notch  in  the  middle  and  are  short,  they  proceed  to  round 
it,  till  they  come  to  use  a  flat  tool  more  slender  than 
the  calcagnuolo,  which  has  two  notches  and  is  called 
'  gradina  '  :  with  this  they  go  all  over  the  figure,  gently 
chiselling  it  to  keep  the  proportion  of  the  muscles  and 
the  folds,  and  treating  it  in  such  a  manner  that  the  notches 
or  teeth  of  the  tool  give  the  stone  a  wonderful  grace. 
This  done,  they  remove  the  tooth  marks  with  a  smooth 
chisel,  and  in  order  to  perfect  the  figure,  wishing  to  add 
sweetness,  softness  and  finish  to  it,  they  work  off  with 
curved  files  all  traces  of  the  gradina.  They  proceed  in 
the  same  way  with  slender  files  and  straight  rasps,  to 
complete  the  smoothing  process,^  and  lastly  with  points 
of  pumice  stone  they  rub  all  over  the  figure  to  give  that 
flesh-like  appearance  that  is  seen  in  marvellous  works  of 

'  See  Note  on  '  The  Use  of  Full-sized  Models '  at  the  close  of  the  '  Intro- 
duction '  to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.  192. 

8  The  carvers'  tools  described  by  Vasari  are  the  same  that  appear  to  have 
been  in  use  in  ancient  Greece  (see  the  article  by  Professor  E.  Gardner  already 
referred  to),  that  are  figured  in  the  Encydopidie  of  the  eighteenth  century, 
and  are  now  in  use.  Fig.  2,  E  to  J,  ante,  p.  48,  shows  a  set  of  them  actually 
employed  in  a  stone  carver's  workshop  at  Settignano  near  Florence. 


MARBLE   CARVING  I53 


r 


sculpture,  Tripoli  earth  is  also  used  to  make  it  lustrous 
and  polished,  and  for  the  same  reason  it  is  rubbed  over 
with  straw  made  into  bunches — till,  finished  and  shining, 
it  appears  before  us  in  its  beauty.^ 

'  Actual  polish  of  the  surface  of  a  marble  figure  is  to  be  avoided,  as  the 
reflections  from  it  where  it  catches  the  light  destroy  the  delicacy  of  the  effect 
of  light  and  shade.  Greek  marbles  were  not  polished,  save  in  some  cases 
where  the  aim  seems  to  have  been  to  imitate  the  appearance  of  shining  bronze, 
but  the  Greeks  finished  their  marbles  more  smoothly  than  the  sculptors  of 
to-day,  most  of  whom  prefer  a  '  sensitive '  surfece  on  which  the  marks  of  the 
last  deUcate  chiselling  can  be  discerned.  Michelangelo's  Dead  Christ  in 
the  '  Pieta '  of  St.  Peter's,  his  most  finished  piece  of  marble  work,  may 
almost  be  said  to  show  polish,  and  Renaissance  marbles  generally  are  quite 
as  smoothly  finished  as  antiques.  In  the  case  of  coloured  marbles,  used  for 
surface  decoration  in  plain  panels,  polish  is  of  course  necessary  in  order  that 
the  colour  and  veining  may  appear,  but  it  does  not  follow  from  this  that  a 
self-coloured  marble,  carved  into  the  similitude  of  a  face  or  figure,  should  be 
polished. 


CHAPTER   III.     (X.) 

Of  Low  and  Half  Reliefs,  the  difficulty  of  making  them  and  how  to 
bring  them  to  perfection. 

§  51.  The  Origin  of  Reliefs. 

Those  works  that  sculptors  call  half  reliefs  ^  were  invented 
by  the  ancients  to  make  figure  compositions  with  which 
to  adorn  flat  walls,  and  they  adopted  this  treatment  in 
theatres  and  triumphal  arches,  because,  even  had  they 
wished  to  sculpture  figures  in  the  round,  they  could  not 
place  them  unless  they  first  constructed  a  standing  ground 
or  an  open  place  that  was  flat.  Desiring  therefore  to  avoid 
this,  they  invented  a  kind  of  sculpture  which  they  named 
half  relief,  and  it  is  called  '  mezzo  rilievo  '  still  among 
ourselves. 

§  52.  Pictorial  or  Perspective  Reliefs. 

In  the  manner  of  a  picture  this  kind  of  relief  sets  forth 
first  the  whole  of  the  principal  figures,  either  in  half  rouiid 
or  still  greater  salience,  as  may  happen,  the  figures  on  the 
second  plane  partly  hidden  by  the  first,  and  those  on  the 
third  by  the  second,  just  as  living  people  are  seen  when 
they  are  assembled  and  crowded  together.  In  this  kind 
of  half  relief,  for  the  sake  of  perspective,  they  make  the 
most  distant  figures  low,  some  of  the  heads  indeed 
extremely  low,  and  no  less  so  the  houses  and  scenery 
which  are  the  objects   most   remote.     By   none  has  this 

^  English  terminology  for  the  different  kinds  of  reliefs,  and  for  sculpture 
generally,  is  very  deficient,  and  many  Italian  terms  are  employed.  It  may 
be  noted  that  Vasari's  'half  relief  (mezzo  rilievo)  is  the  highest  kind  he 
mentions,  and  would  correspond  to  what  is  called  in  English  'high  relief.' 


PICTORIAL   OR   PERSPECTIVE   RELIEFS      155 

species  of  half  relief  ever  been  better  executed,  with  more 
observation,  or  with  its  figures  diminished  and  spaced 
one  from  the  other  more  correctly  than  by  the  ancients ;  ^ 
fpr  they,  who  were  students  of  the  truth  and  gifted  artists, 
liever  made  the  figures  in  such  compositions  with  ground 
that  is  foreshortened  or  seems  to  run  away,  but  placed 
them  with  their  feet  resting  on  the  moulding  beneath  them. 
In  contrast  to  this,  some  of  our  own  moderns,  over  eager, 
have,  in  their  compositions  in  half  relief,  made  their 
principal  figures  stand  on  the  plane  which  is  in  low  relief 
and  recedes,  and  the  middle  figures  on  the  same  plane 
in  such  a  position  that,  as  they  stand,  they  do  not  rest 
the  feet  as  firmly  as  is  natural,  whence  it  not  infrequently 
happens  that  the  points  of  the  feet  of  those  figures  that 
turn  their  backs  actually  touch  the  shins  of  their  own 
legs,  so  violent  is  the  foreshortening.  Such  things  are 
seen  in  many  modern  works,  and  even  in  the  gates  of 
the  Baptistry  and  in  many  examples  of  that  period. 
Therefore  half  reliefs  of  this  character  are  incorrect, 
because,  if  the  foremost  figures  project  half  out  of  the 
stone  while  others  have  to  be  placed  behind  them,  there 
must  be  a  rule  for  the  retiring  and  diminution ;  the  feet 
of  the  figures  have  to  be  on  the  ground,  so  that  the  ground 
may  come  forward  in  front  as  required  by  the  eye  and 
the  rule  in  things  painted.  Accordingly  the  figures  must 
be  gradually  reduced  in  proportion  as  they  recede  till  they 
reach  the  flattened  and  low  relief;  and  because  of  the 
harmony  required  it  is  difficult  to  carry  out  the  work 
perfectly  seeing  that  in  relief  the  feet  and  heads  are  fore- 
shortened. Great  skill  in  design  therefore  is  necessary 
if  the  artist  wish  to  exhibit  his  ability  in  this  art.  The 
same  degree  of  perfection  is  demanded  for  figures  in  clay 
or  wax  as  for  those  worked  in  bronze  and  marble.  There-  \ 
fore  of  all  the  works  which  have  the  qualities  that  I  indicate 
the  half  reliefs  may  be  considered  most  beautiful  and  most 
highly  praised  by  experienced  artists. 

^See  Note  on  'Italian  and  Greek  Reliefs,'  at  the  close  of  the  'Introduction' 
to  Sculpture,  postea,  p,   196. 


156  OF  SCULPTURE 

§  53.  Low  Reliefs  (Bassi  Rilievi). 

The  second  species  called  low  reliefs  projects  much 
less  than  the  half  reliefs;  they  have  not  more  than  half 
the  boldness  of  the  others,  and  one  can  rightly  make  in 
these  low  reliefs  the  ground,  the  buildings,  the  prospects, 
the  stairs  and  the  landscapes  as  we  see  in  the  bronze 
pulpits  in  San  Lorenzo  at  Florence,  and  in  all  the  low 
reliefs  of  Donatello,  who  in  this  art  produced  things  truly 
divine  with  the  greatest  truth  to  nature.  These  reliefs 
present  themselves  easily  to  the  eye  and  without  errors 
or  barbarisms,  seeing  that  they  do  not  project  forward 
so  much  as  to  give  occasion  for  errors  or  censure. 

§  54.  Flat  Reliefs  (Stiacciati  Rilievi). 

The  third  species  called  low  or  flattened  reliefs  only 
shows  up  the  design  of  the  figure  in  the  very  lowest  and 
most  depressed  relief.  These  reliefs  are  very  difficult 
for  they  demand  great  skill  in  design  and  invention, 
and  as  all  depends  on  the  outlines  it  is  a  hard  thing 
[  to  impart  charm  to  them.  Donatello  worked  better  here 
[  than  did  any  other,  with  art,  design  and  invention.^  In 
the  ancient  vases  of  Arezzo,*  many  figures,   masks,  and 

'  Donatello's  flat,  or  '  stiacciati '  reliefs  are  deservedly  famous.  The  difficulty 
here  is  to  convey  the  impression  of  solid  form  of  three  dimensions  with  the 
slightest  possible  actual  salience.  The  treatment  of  the  torso  of  the  Christ 
in  the  marble  'Pieta'  of  the  Victoria  and  Albert  Museum  is  a  good  example. 

*  The  antique  vessels  of  so-called  '  Arezzo '  ware  are  called  Aretine  vases. 
Messer  Giorgio  was  in  duty  bound  to  take  some  note  of  the  ancient  pottery  of 
his  native  city  for  it  was  from  this  that  the  Vasari  derived  their  family  name. 
According  to  the  family  tree  given  in  a  note  to  the  Life  of  an  ancestor  of  the 
historian  (Ofere,  ed.  Milanesi,  II,  561),  the  family  came  from  Cortona,  and 
the  first  who  settled  in  Arezzo  was  the  historian's  great-grandfather,  one 
Lazzaro,  an  artist  in  ornamental  saddlery.  He  had  a  son,  Giorgio,  who 
practised  the  craft  of  the  potter,  and  was  especially  concerned  with  the  old 
Roman  Aretine  vases  the  technique  of  which  he  tried  to  reproduce.  Hence 
he  was  called  '  Vasajo,'  '  the  vase  maker,'  from  which  came  the  family 
appellation  Vasari. 

This  ancient  Aretine  ware  '  must  be  regarded  as  the  Roman  pottery  par 
excellence'    (Waters,   History  of  Ancient   Pottery,   Lond.,    1905,  11,  480).      It 


FLAT  RELIEFS  I57 

other  ancient  compositions  are  to  be  seen  in  this  sort  of 
work :  likewise  in  the  antique  cameos,  in  moulds  for 
striking  bronze  pieces  for  medals,  and  also  in  coins.  This 
style  was  chosen  because,  if  the  relief  had  been  too  high, 
the  coins  could  not  have  been  struck,  for  the  blow 
of  the  hammer  would  not  have  produced  the  impression 
since  the  punches  have  to  be  pressed  on  to  the  cast 
material,  and  when  this  is  in  low  relief  it  costs  little  trouble 
to  fill  the  cavities  of  the  punch.  Now-a-days  we  see  that 
many  modern  artists  have  worked  divinely  in  this  style, 
more  even  than  did  the  ancients,  as  shall  be  fully  described 
in  their  Lives.  Therefore,  he  who  recognizes  in  the  halt 
reliefs  the  perfection  of  the  figures  so  carefully  made  to 
diminish,  and  in  the  lower  reliefs  the  excellence  of  the  | 
design  in  the  perspectives  and  other  inventions,  and  in 
the  flattened  reliefs  the  clearness,  the  refinement  and  the 
beautiful  form  of  the  figures,  will  do  well  to  regard  them 
on  account  of  these  qualities  as  worthy  of  praise  or  blame, 
and  will  teach  others  also  so  to  regard  them, 

is  practically  the  same  ware  that  is  known  by  the  popular  but  unscientific 
term  '  Samian, '  and  consists  in  cups  and  bowls  and  dishes  usually  of  a  small 
size  of  a  fine  red  clay,  ornamented  with  designs  in  low  relief,  produced  by 
the  aid  of  stamps  or  moulds.  It  is  these  relief  ornaments  that  Vasari  had 
in  his  mind  when  he  wrote  the  words  in  the  text.  Arezzo  is  noticed  by 
Pliny  and  other  ancient  writers  as  a  great  centre  for  the  fabrication  of  this 
sort  of  ware,  and  Vasari  tells  us  how  his  grandfather,  Giorgio  the  '  vasajo,' 
discovered  near  the  city  some  kilns  of  the  ancient  potters  and  specimens  of 
their  work.  Very  good  specimens  of  Aretine  ware  are  to  be  seen  in  the 
Museum  at  Arezzo,  and  the  fabrique  is  represented  in  all  important  collections 
of  ancient  pottery. 


CHAPTER   IV.     (XI.) 

How  Models  for  large  and  small  Bronze  Figures  are  made,  with  the 
Moulds  for  casting  them  and  their  Armatures  of  iron  ;  and  how 
they  are  cast  in  metal  and  in  three  sorts  of  Bronze  ;  and  how  after 
they  are  cast  they  are  chased  and  refined  ;  and  how,  if  they  lack 
pieces  that  did  not  come  out  in  the  cast,  these  are  grafted  and 
joined  in  the  same  bronze. 

§  55.  The  Full-sized  Model  for  Bronze. 

It  is  the  custom  of  competent  artists,  when  they  wish  to 
cast  large  figures  in  metal  or  bronze,^  to  make  first  a 
statue  of  clay  as  large  as  that  intended  to  be  cast  in  metal, 
and  to  perfect  the  clay  statue  as  far  as  their  art  and  their 
knowledge  will  allow. 

§  56.  The  Piece-Mould  in  Plaster. 

When  this,  which  they  call  the  model,  is  finished  and 
brought  to  this  point  of  perfection,  they  then  begin,  with 
plaster  that  will  set,  to  build  over  it  piece  by  piece,  making 
the  pieces  correspond  to  the  relief  of  the  model.  On  every 
piece  they  make  a  key,  marking  the  pieces  with  numbers 

^  See  Note  on  '  The  Processes  of  the  Bronze  Founder '  at  the  close  of 
the  'Introduction'  to  Sculpture,  postea,  p.  199,  which  the  reader  who  is 
unacquainted  with  the  subject,  will  find  it  useful  to  read  forthwith.  The 
best  commentary  on  Vasari's  and  Cellini's  account  of  bronze  casting  is  to  be 
found  in  the  French  EncydopSdie,  where  there  is  a  description,  with  numerous 
illustrations,  of  the  casting  in  1699  of  Girardon's  great  equestrian  statue  of 
Louis  XIV,  destined  for  the  Place  Vendome.  It  was  claimed  at  the  time 
to  be  the  largest  known  single  casting  in  the  world,  and  represents  in  their 
utmost  elaboration  the  various  processes  described  by  Vasari.  Some  of  the 
illustrations  are  here  reproduced,  and  will  help  to  render  clearer  the  descriptions 
in  the  text. 


THE   PIECE-MOULD   AND   THE   CORE       159 

or  letters  of  the  alphabet  or  with  other  signs  in  order 
that  the  pieces  can  be  taken  off  and  register  together.  So 
they  mould  it  part  by  part,  oiling  the  pieces  of  the  cast 
where  the  edges  have  to  be  connected;  till  from  piece  to 
piece  the  figure  grows,  the  head,  the  arms,  the  body  and 
the  legs,  to  the  last  detail,  in  such  a  manner  that  the 
concave  of  the  statue,  that  is  the  hollow  mould,  comes 
to  be  imprinted  on  the  inner  surface  with  all  the  parts 
and  with  the  very  minutest  marking  which  is  in  the 
model  .2  This  completed,  the  plaster  casts  are  laid  aside 
to  harden. 

§  57.  The  Construction  of  the  Core. 

The  workers  then  take  a  rod  of  iron  longer  than  the 
whole  figure  that  they  wish  to  make,  and  that  is  to  be 
cast,  and  over  this  they  make  a  core  of  clay  into  which, 
while  kneading  it  to  make  it  soft,  they  mix  horse  dung 
and  hair.  The  core  has  the  same  form  as  the  model  and 
is  baked  in  successive  layers  so  as  to  draw  out  the 
dampness  of  the  clay;  this  is  of  use  afterwards  to  the 
figure,  for  in  casting  the  statue  all  this  core,  which  is  solid, 
leaves  an  empty  space  that  is  not  filled  with  bronze, 
because  if  it  were,  the  figure  could  not  be  moved  on 
account  of  the  weight.  They  make  this  core  large  enough 
and  justly  measured,  so  that  when  the  layers  are  heated  and 
baked,  as  has  been  said,  the  clay  becomes  well  burned 
through  and  so  entirely  freed  from  damp,  that  in  pouring 
the  bronze  upon  it  afterwards  it  does  not  spurt  nor  do 
injury,  as  has  happened  many  times,  involving  the  death 
of  the  masters  and  the  ruin  of  the  work.  Thus  they  go 
on  balancing  the  core  and  adjusting  and  examining  the 
pieces,  till  they  tally  with  it  and  represent  it,  so  that  there 

"  Plate  VII  shows  a  section  or  two  of  a  piece-mould  round  a  portion  of  a 
figure.  It  will  be  noticed  that  the  pieces  are  so  planned  that  they  will  all 
come  away  easily  from  the  model  and  not  be  held  by  any  undercut  projections. 
The  small  pieces  are  then  all  enclosed  in  an  outer  shell  divided  into  two 
halves,  and  called  in  French  '  chape '  answering  to  the  '  cappa '  of  Vasari's 
text.     Plate  VIII,  A,  shows  the  model  of  the  Louis  XIV  statue  as  piece-moulded. 


i6o  OF   SCULPTURE 

comes  to  be  left  exactly  the  thickness,  or,  (if  we  like  to 
say  so,)  the  thinness,  of  the  metal,  according  as  you  wish 
the  statue  to  be. 

Frequently  this  core  has  an  armature  of  rods  of  copper 
across  it,  and  irons  that  can  be  taken  out  and  put  in  to 
hold  it  with  security  and  with  greater  strength.^  The  core, 
after  it  is  finished,  is  yet  again  baked  with  a  gentle  heat, 
and  the  moisture,  should  any  have  remained,  entirely 
removed;   it  is  then  again  laid  aside. 

§  58.  The  Piece-Mould  lined  with  a  Skin  of  Wax. 

Returning  now  to  the  pieces  of  the  hollow  mould,  these 
are  lined  severally  with  yellow  wax  that  has  been  softened 
and  incorporated  with  a  little  turpentine  and  tallow.* 
When  the  wax  is  melted  at  the  fire,  it  is  poured  into  the 
two  halves  of  the  mould  made  up  of  the  hollow  pieces 
in  such  a  manner  as  causes  the  wax  to  come  thin  according 
to  the  worker's  idea  for  the  cast,  and  the  pieces,  which 
have  been  shaped  to  correspond  with  the  relief  of  the  core 
already  made  of  clay,  are  joined  to  it  and  fitted  and  grafted 
together. 

§  59.  This  Skin  of  Wax  applied  over  the  Core. 

With  thin  skewers  of  copper  the  pieces  of  wax  pierced 
with  the  said  skewers  are  now  fixed  to  the  baked  core,  and 

^  In  the  case  of  a  heavy  casting  such  an  armature  is  necessary,  and  must  be 
carefully  constructed  to  give  support  at  all  points.  The  armature  within  the 
core  of  the  horse  of  Louis  XIV  is  shown  in  Plate  VIII,  D. 

*  Vasari  here  describes  a  method  of  constructing  the  indispensable  shell  of 
wax  which  is  to  be  replaced  by  the  bronze.  The  hollow  piece-mould  is  lined 
section  by  section  with  wax  and  a  core  is  then  formed  to  fill  the  rest  of  the 
interior  and  touch  the  inner  surface  of  the  wax  at  every  point.  The  plaster 
mould  is  then  removed  and  the  wax  linings  of  each  of  its  sections  are  applied, 
each  in  its  proper  place,  to  the  core,  and  fixed  thereon  by  skewers.  There 
is  then  a  complete  figure  in  wax,  but,  as  this  is  made  up  of  very  many 
pieces,  it  has  to  be  gone  over  carefully  to  smootlj  over  the  joins  and  secure 
unity  of  surface,  Cellini's  plan  seems  a  better  one.  He  lines  his  hollow 
mould  with  a  sort  of  paste  or  dough,  and  then  fills  up  with  the  core.  The 
dough  is  then  removed  and  wax  is  poured  in  in  its  place,  thus  forming  a 
continuous  skin  and  securing  a  more  perfect  unity  in  the  waxen  shell. 


Plate  VII 


ILLUSTRATION   SHOWING   PROCESS   OF   PIECE-MOULDING 
IN   PLASTER 


SKIN   OF  WAX   OVER   THE   CORE  i6i 

so,  piece  by  piece,  they  are  inserted  and  fitted  to  the  figure 
and  render  it  entirely  finished.  This  completed  they 
proceed  to  remove  all  the  superfluous  wax  that  has  over- 
flowed into  the  interstices  of  the  pieces,  and  bring  it  as 
well  as  possible  to  that  finished  excellence  and  perfection 
which  one  desires  in  the  bronze  cast.  Before  going 
further,  the  craftsman  sets  up  the  figure  and  considers 
diligently  if  the  wax  have  any  deficiency,  and  he  proceeds 
to  repair  it  and  to  fill  up  again,  putting  on  more  or  taking 
away  where  necessary. ^ 

§  60.  The  fire-resisting  Envelope  applied  over  the  Wax 

After  that,  the  wax  being  completed  and  the  figure 
braced  together,  he  puts  it  where  fire  can  be  applied  to 
it  ®  on  two  andirons  of  wood,  stone,  or  iron  like  a  roast, 
arranging  so  that  it  can  be  raised  or  lowered ;  and  with 
moistened  ash,  specially  fitted  for  that  purpose,  by  means 
of  a  paint  brush  he  covers  the  entire  figure  so  that  the 
wax  is  quite  concealed,  and  over  every  hollow  and  chink 
he  clothes  it  well  with  this  material.  Having  applied 
the  ash  to  it  he  replaces  the  transverse  rods,  which  pass 
through  the  wax  and  the  core,  just  as  he  has  left  them 
in  the  figure,  because  these  have  to  support  the  core 
within  and  the  mould  without,  which  is  the  casing  of  the 
hollow  space  between  the  core  and  the  mould,  where  the 
bronze  is  to  be  poured.  When  this  armature  has  been 
fixed,  the  artificer  begins  to  take  some  fine  earth,  beaten 
together  with  horse  dung  and  hair,  as  I  said,  and  carefully 

'  On  Plate  VIII  at  B  we  see  the  core  covered  with  the  skin  of  wax  and  carefully 
gone  over  and  finished  in  every  part.  The  system  of  pipes  with  which  it  is 
covered  are  the  '  vents '  that  Vasari  notices  in  §  62,  and  also  the  channels 
through  which  the  melted  wax  is  to  escape  and  the  molten  bronze  to  enter, 
as  noticed  in  §§  63,  64. 

*  Vasari  actually  says  that  it  must  be  put  'al  fuoco'  'to  the  fire,'  but  it  is 
clear  that  he  does  not  mean  that  heat  is  at  once  to  be  applied  to  it.  If  this 
were  done  the  wax  would  all  be  melted  off  the  core  too  soon,  before  it  was 
covered  by  the  outer  skin.  It  is  only  when  the  wax  has  been  securely 
enclosed  between  the  core  and  the  outer  skin  that  heat  is  needed  to  melt  it 
away  and  leave  its  place  free  for  the  molten  metal. 

L 


i62  OF   SCULPTURE 

lays  a  very  thin  coating  all  over  which  he  allows  to  dry, 
and  so  on  time  after  time  with  other  coatings,  always 
allowing  each  to  dry  until  the  figure  becomes  covered  with 
earth  raised  to  the  thickness  of  half  a  span  at  the  most. 

§  6i.  The  External  Armature, 
This  done,  he  girds  those  irons  that  hold  the  core 
within  with  other  irons  which  hold  the  mould  outside, 
and  fixes  them  together,  so  that  chained  and  bound  the 
one  to  the  other  they  form  a  mutual  support,''  the  core 
within  sustaining  the  mould  without  and  the  mould  without 
holding  firm  the  core  within. 

§  62.  The  Vents. 
It  is  usual  to  make  certain  little  pipes  between  the  core 
and  the  outer  mould  called  vents,  that  have  issue  upwards ; 
they  are  put,  for  instance,  from  a  knee  to  an  arm  that 
is  raised,  because  these  give  passage  to  the  metal  ^  to 
make  up  for  that  which  on  account  of  some  impediment 
may  not  flow  properly,  and  these  little  tubes  are  made 
many  or  few,  according  as  the  casting  is  difficult  or  not. 

§  63.  The  Wax  melted  out. 
This  done,  the  worker  proceeds  to  apply  heat  to  the 
said  mould  equally  all  over,  so  that  it  may  become  united 
and  little  by  little  be  warmed  through,  and  he  increases 
the  heat  till  the  mould  is  thoroughly  hot  throughout,  so 
that  the  wax  which  is  in  the  hollow  space  becomes  melted 
■  and  all  flows  out  at  the  spot  through  which  the  metal 
is  to  be  poured,  without  any  particle  of  the  wax  remaining 
within.^    To  be  sure  of  this,   it  is   needful,   before  the 

'  Plate  VIII,  c,  shows  this  outer  armature,  with  the  ends  of  the  transverse  rods 
holding  core  and  envelope  together. 

8  'Give  passage  to  the  metal.'  Their  essential  purpose  is  to  allow  for  the  escape 
of  air  which  would  be  dangerous  if  driven  by  the  metal  into  a  confined  space. 

'  It  should  be  understood  that,  in  the  process  Vasari  has  in  mind,  the  melted 
metal  is  introduced  at  the  boitom  of  the  mould  so  as  to  rise  in  it  and  expel 
before  it  the  air.  It  is  not  poured  in  at  the  top.  Hence  the  metal  enters  at  the 
same  orifice  at  which  the  wax  flows  out. 


THE  WAX   MELTED   OUT  163 

pieces  of  wax  are  grafted  in  to  their  places  on  tiie  figure, 
to  weigh  them  piece  by  piece;  in  the  same  way  after 
drawing  out  the  wax,  it  must  be  weighed  again,  when 
by  making  the  subtraction  the  artist  sees  if  any  wax  be 
left  between  the  core  and  the  mould,  and  how  much  has 
come  out.  Notice  that  the  skill  and  care  of  the  artist  is 
manifested  in  the  process  of  taking  out  the  wax;  herein 
is  seen  the  difficulty  of  producing  the  casts  so  that  they 
come  out  sharp  and  beautiful,  for  if  any  of  the  wax  be 
left,  it  would  ruin  the  whole  cast,  especially  that  part 
where  the  wax  remains. 

§  64.  The  Mould  in  the  Casting-pit. 

This  finished,  the  craftsman  puts  the  mould  under 
ground  near  to  the  furnace  where  the  bronze  is  melted, 
propping  it  so  that  the  bronze  may  not  strain  it,  and  he 
makes  the  channels  through  which  the  bronze  is  to  flow, 
and  at  the  top  he  leaves  a  certain  thickness,  which  allows 
for  the  surplus  of  the  bronze  to  be  sawn  off  afterwards, 
and  this  he  does  in  order  to  secure  sharpness. ^° 

§  65.  The  Composition  of  the  Bronze. 

The  artist  prepares  the  metal  as  he  thinks  fit,  and  for 
every  pound  of  wax  he  puts  ten  pounds  of  metal. ^^  Statuary 
metal  is  made  of  the  combination  of  two  thirds  of  copper 
and  one  third  of  brass  according  to  the  Italian  rule.  The 
Egyptians,  from  whom  this  art  took  its  origin,  put  into 

'"  Plate  VIII,  D,  gives  a  section  through  the  model  in  the  casting  pit,  when  all  is 
ready  for  the  actual  operation  of  introducing  the  molten  metal.  The  wax  has 
all  been  run  out,  and  the  outline  of  the  figure  and  of  the  horse  is  marked  by 
a  double  line  with  a  narrow  space  between.  It  is  this  space  that  will  be 
filled  by  the  bronze  which  will  be  introduced  through  numerous  channels  so 
that  it  may  be  distributed  rapidly  and  evenly  over  the  whole  surface  it  is  to 
cover.  When  in  the  pit  the  mould  is  packed  all  round  with  broken  bricks 
or  similar  material,  so  that   'the  bronze  may  not  strain  it,'  nor  cause  it  to  shift. 

"  The  wax  has  already  been  carefully  weighed,  and  in  order  to  estimate 
how  much  bronze  will  be  required  for  the  cast  a  rough  calculation  is  made 
based  on  the  amount  of  wax. 


i64  OF   SCULPTURE 

the  bronze  two  thirds  of  brass  and  one  third  of  copper. 
In  electron  metal,  which  is  the  finest  of  all,  two  parts  copper 
are  put  to  one  part  silver.  In  bells,  for  every  hundred 
parts  of  copper  there  are  twenty  of  tin,  in  order  that  the 
sound  of  the  bells  may  carry  far  and  be  more  blended; 
and  for  artillery,  in  every  hundred  parts  of  copper,  ten 
of  tin.i2 

§  66.  Making  up  Imperfections. 

There  only  remains  to  us  now  to  teach  the  method  of 
grafting  a  piece  into  the  figure  should  it  have  a  defect, 
either  because  the  bronze  coagulated,  or  ran  too  thin,  or 
did  not  reach  some  part  of  the  mould.  In  this  case  let 
the  artificer  entirely  remove  the  defective  part  of  the  cast 
and  make  a  square  hole  in  its  place,  cutting  it  out  under 
the  carpenter's  square,  then  let  him  adjust  a  piece  of  metal 

^^  The  subject  of  the  composition  of  bronze  and  of  other  alloys  of  copper 
is  a  complicated  one,  for  the  mixtures  specified  or  .gstabjished  by  analysis  are 
very  varied.  Normally  speaking,  bronze  is  a  mixture  of  copper  with  about 
ten  per  cent,  of  tin,  brass  of  copper  with  twenty  to  forty  per  cent,  of  zinc. 
Vasari's  proportions  for  bells  and  for  cannon  are  pretty  much  what  are  given 
now.  In  the  Manuel  de  Fondeur  (Manuels  Roret)  Paris,  1879,  11,  p.  94, 
eight  to  fifteeij  per  cent,  of  tin  are  prescribed  for  cannon,  fifteen  to  thirty 
per  cent,  for  bell  metal,  the  greater  percentage  of  tin  with  the  copper 
resulting  in  a  less  tough  but  harder  and  so  sharper  sounding  metal.  It  will 
be  noted  however  that  for  statuary  metal  Vasari  specifies  a  mixture  not  of 
coppej:  and  tin  but  of  copper  and  brass,  that  is,  copper  ajid  zinc.  Brass  is 
composed  of,  say,  twenty-five  per  cent,  of  zinc  and  seventy-five  per  ceat.  of 
copper,  so  that  a  mixture  of  two  thirds,  or  sixty-six  per  cent.,  of  copper  with 
one  third,  or  thirty-three  per  cent.,  of  brass  would  work  out  to  about  ten  parts 
of  zinc  to  ninety  of  copper,  and  this  agrees  with  classical  proportions.  The 
Greeks  used  tin  for  their  bronzes,  but  various  mysterious  ingredients  were 
supposed  to  be  mingled  in  to  produce  special  alloys.  The  Romans  used  zinc, 
or  rather  zinciferous  ores  such  as  calamine,  with  or  in  place  of  tin,  and  this 
is  the  tradition  that  Vasari  follows. 

A  recent  analysis  of  the  composition  of  the  bronze  doors  at  Hildesbeim, 
dating  from  1015  A.D.,  gives  about  seventy-six  parts  copper,  ten  lead,  eight 
tin,  four  zinc ;  and  of  the  '  Bernward '  pillar  ascribed  to  about  the  same  date, 
seventy  copper,  twenty-three  tin,  and  five  lead.  These  differences  may  surprise 
us,  but  metal  casting  in  those  days  was  a  matter  of  rule  of  thumb,  and  we 
may  recall  Cellini's  account  of  his  cramming  all  his  household  vessels  of 
pewter  into  the  melting  pot  to  make  the  metal  flow  for  casting  his   '  Perseus.' 


Plate  VIII 


. — J  „ 


ENGRAVINGS  ILLUSTRATING  THE   PROCESS  OF  CASTING  IN   BRONZE 
From  the  French  Encyclopidie 


METHOD   FOR  SMALL  CASTINGS  165 

prepared  for  that  spot,  that  may  project  upward  as  much 
as  he  pleases,  and  when  fitted  exactly  in  the  square  hole 
let  him  strike  it  with  the  hammer  to  send  it  home,  and 
with  files  and  tools  make  it  even  and  thoroughly  finished. 

§  67.  A  simpler  Method  of  Casting  small  Figures  and 

Reliefs. 

Now  should  the  artificer  wish  to  cast  small  figures  in 
metal,  they  are  first  made  of  wax,  or  if  he  happen  to  have 
them  in  clay  or  other  material,  he  makes  the  shell  of 
plaster  over  them  in  the  same  way  as  for  the  large  figures, 
and  fills  it  all  with  wax.  But  the  shell  must  be  moistened 
that  the  wax,  when  poured  into  it,  may  set  (with  a  hard 
skin)  by  reason,  of  the  coldness  of  the  wet  cast.  Then 
by  shaking  about  and  agitating  the  cast,  the  wax  (which 
is  not  hardened)  within  the  cavity  is  thrown  out,  so  that 
the  cast  remains  hollow  in  the  interior :  the  craftsman 
afterwards  fills  up  the  vacant  space  with  clay  and  puts 
in  skewers  of  iron.  This  clay  serves  then  for  core,  but 
it  must  be  allowed  to  dry  well.  Thereafter  he  adjusts 
the  mould  as  for  the  other  large  figures,  giving  it  its 
armature  and  placing  the  tubes  for  the  vents.  Then  he 
bakes  it  and  gets  rid  of  the  (skin  of)  wax  and  thus  the 
vacant  space  remains  clear  so  that  the  bronze  can  easily 
be  poured  in.  The  same  is  done  with  the  low  and  half 
reliefs  and  with  every  other  work  in  metal. 

§  68.  Chasing  the  Cast  and  Colouring  the  Bronze. 

These  casts  being  finished,  the  workman  then,  with 
suitable  tools,  that  is,  with  burins,  burnishers,  chasing 
tools,  punches,  chisels  and  files,  removes  material  where 
needed,  and  where  needed  presses  inward  the  overflow 
of  the  metal  and  smoothes  it  down ;  and  with  other  tools 
that  scrape,  he  shaves  and  cleans  the  whole  of  it  diligently, 
and  finally  with  pumice  stone  gives  the  last  polish.  This 
bronze  which  is  red  when  it  is  worked  assumes  through 
time  by  a  natural  change  a  colour  that  draws  towards 


i66  OF  SCULPTURE 

black.  Some  turn  it  black  with  oil,  others  with  vinegar 
make  it  green,  and  others  with  varnish  give  it  the  colour 
of  black,  so  that  every  one  makes  it  come  as  he  likes 
best. 

§  69.  Modern  Tours  de  Force  in  small  Castings. 

But  that  is  a  truly  marvellous  thing  which  is  come  to 
pass  in  our  times,  this  mode  of  casting  figures,  large  as 
well  as  small,  so  excellently  that  many  masters  make 
them  come  out  in  the  cast  quite  clear  so  that  they  have 
not  to  be  chased  with  tools,  and  as  thin  as  the  back  of  a 
knife.  And  what  is  more,  some  clays  and  ashes  used  for 
this  purpose  are  actually  so  fine,  that  tufts  of  rue  and 
any  other  slender  herb  or  flower  can  be  cast  in  silver  and 
in  gold,  quite  easily  and  with  such  success,  that  they  are 
as  beautiful  as  the  natural ;  from  which  it  is  seen  that 
this  art  is  more  excellent  now  than  it  was  in  the  time  of 
the  ancients. 


CHAPTER  V.   (XII.) 

Concerning  Steel  Dies  for  making  Medals  of  bronze  or  other  metals 
and  how  the  latter  are  formed  from  these  metals  and  from 
Oriental  Stones  and  Cameos. 

§  70.  The  Fabrication  of  Matrices  for  Medals. 

The  craftsman  who  wishes  to  make  medals  of  bronze  or 
silver  or  gold  after  the  manner  of  the  ancients,  must  first 
with  iron  punches  work  in  relief  the  faces  of  steel  dies 
of  which  the  metal  has  been  softened  piece  by  piece  in 
the  fire;  as  for  example,  the  head  alone  in  low  relief,  in 
a  single  steel  die;  and  so  with  the  other  parts  which  are 
joined  to  it.  Fashioned  thus  of  steel,  all  the  dies  needed 
for  the  medal  are  tempered  by  fire;  and  on  the  block  of 
tempered  steel,  that  is  to  serve  for  mould  and  matrix 
of  the  medal,  the  artist  proceeds  to  imprint  by  means 
of  hammer  strokes  the  head  and  the  other  parts  in 
their  proper  places.  And  after  imprinting  the  whole, 
he  diligently  smoothes  it  and  polishes  it  again,  giving 
finish  and  perfection  to  the  said  mould  that  has  afterwards 
to  serve  for  matrix.  Many  artificers  have  been  in  the 
habit  however  of.  carving  the  matrices  with  wheels,  just 
as  intaglio  work  is  done  in  crystals,  jaspers,  calcedonies, 
agates,  amethysts,  sardonyx,  lapis  lazuli,  chrysolites,  cor- 
nelians, cameos  and  other  oriental  stones;  and  the  work 
done  in  this  way  makes  the  matrices  more  sharp,  as  is 
the  case  in  the  aforesaid  stones.  In  the  same  way  they 
make  (the  matrix  for)  the  reverse  of  the  medal,  and  with 
these  two,  the  matrix  of  the  head  and  that  of  the  reverse 
side,  (trial)  medals  of  wax  and  of  lead  are  struck.  These 
are  moulded  afterwards  with  a  very  finely  powdered  earth 
suitable   for   the   purpose;   and   in    these   moulds,    when 


i68  OF   SCULPTURE 

the  wax  or  leaden  (trial)  medal  has  been  taken  out,  and 
they  are  pressed  together  in  the  frame,  you  may  cast  any 
kind  of  metal  which  pleases  you  for  your  medal. 

These  casts  are  then  replaced  in  the  steel  matrices  that 
correspond  to  them  and  by  force  of  screws  or  wedges  and 
with  hammer  blows  they  are  pressed  so  tightly,  that  they 
take  that  finish  of  surface  from  the  stamp  that  they  have 
not  taken  from  the  casting  process.  But  coins  and  other 
medals  in  low  relief  are  stamped  without  screws,  by  blows 
of  the  hammer  struck  by  hand.^ 

§  71.  The  Cutting  of  Intaglios  and  Cameos. 

Those  oriental  stones  that  we  spoke  of  above  are  cut 
in  intaglio  with  wheels  by  means  of  emery,  which  with 

^  Vasari's  account  of  the  making  of  dies  for  medals  and  of  the  process  of 
striking  these  is  clear,  and  agrees  with  the  more  elaborate  directions  contained 
in  the  seventh  and  following  chapters  of  Cellini's  Trattato  delV  Oreficeria. 
Cellini  however,  unlike  Vasari,  was  a  practical  medallist,  and  he  goes  more 
into  detail.  The  process  employed  was  not  the  direct  cutting  of  the  matrices 
or  dies  with  chisels,  nor,  as  gems  are  engraved,  by  the  use  of  the  wheel  and 
emery  (or  diamond)  powder,  but  the  stamping  into  them  of  the  design 
required  by  main  force,  by  means  of  specially  shaped  hard  steel  punches  on 
which  different  parts  of  the  design  had  been  worked  in  relief.  The  steel  of 
the  matrix  or  die  had  of  course  to  be  previously  softened  in  the  fire,  or  these 
punches  would  have  made  no  impression  on  it.  When  finished  it  was  again 
hardened  by  tempering.  It  may  be  noticed  that  the  dies  from  which  Greek 
coins  were  struck  were  to  all  appearance  engraved  as  gems  were  engraved 
by  the  direct  use  of  cutting  tools  or  tools  that,  like  the  wheel,  wore  away  the 
material  with  the  aid  of  sand  or  emery. 

The  two  matrices,  or  dies,  for  the  obverse  and  reverse  of  the  medal,  being 
now  prepared,  the  medal  is  not  immediately  struck.  In  the  case  of  the  Greek 
coin  a  bean-shaped  piece,  or  a  disk,  of  plain  metal,  usually  of  silver,  called 
a  '  blank '  or  '  flan,'  was  placed  between  the  two  dies  and  pressed  into  their 
hollows  by  a.  blow  or  blows  of  the  hammer,  so  that  all  that  was  engraved 
on  them  in  intaglio  came  out  on  the  silver  in  relief.  Vasari's  process  is  more 
elaborate.  A  sort  of  trial  medal  is  first  struck  from  the  matrices  in  a  soft 
material  such  as  lead  or  wax,  and  this  trial  medal  is  reproduced  by  the 
ordinary  process  of  casting  in  the  gold  or  silver  or  bronze  which  is  to  be  the 
matfrial  of  the  final  medal.  This  cast  medal  has  of  course  the  general  form 
required,  but  it  is  not  sharp  nor  has  it  a  fine  surface.  It  is  therefore  placed 
between  the  matrices  and  forcibly  compressed  so  as  to  acquire  all  the  finish 
of  detail  and  texture  desired. 


CUTTING  OF  INTAGLIOS  AND   CAMEOS      169 

the  wheel  cuts  its  way  through  any  sort  of  hardness  of 
any  stone  whatever.  And  as  the  craftsman  proceeds,  he 
is  always  testing  by  wax  impressions  the  intaglio  which 
he  is  fashioning ;  and  in  this  manner  he  goes  on  removing 
material  where  he  deems  it  necessary,  till  the  final  touches 
are  given  to  the  work.  Cameos  however  are  worked  in 
relief;  and  because  this  stone  is  in  layers,  that  is  white 
above  and  dark  underneath,  the  worker  removes  just  so 
much  of  the  white  as  will  leave  the  head  or  figure  white 
on  a  dark  ground.  And  sometimes,  in  order  to  secure 
that  the  whole  head  or  figure  should  appear  white  on  a 
dark  ground,  he  dyes  the  ground  when  it  is  not  so  dark 
as  it  should  be.  In  this  art  we  have  seen  wondrous  and 
divine  works  both  ancient  and  modern. 


CHAPTER   VI.  (XIII.) 

How  works  in  White  Stucco  are  executed,  and  of  the  manner  of 
preparing  the  Wall  underneath  for  them,  and  how  the  work  is 
carried  out. 

§  72.  Modelled  and  stamped  Plaster  Work. 

The  ancients,  when  they  wished  to  make  vaults  or  panels 
or  doors  or  windows  or  other  ornaments  of  white  stucco, 
were  in  the  habit  of  building  a  skeleton  of  walling  either  of 
baked  bricks  or  of  tufa,  that  is,  a  stone  that  is  soft  and 
easy  to  cut.  Making  use  of  these,  they  built  up  the  bones 
underneath,  giving  them  the  form  of  mouldings  or  figures 
or  whatever  they  wished  to  make,  cutting  them  out  of 
the  bricks  or  stones,  which  were  afterwards  put  together 
with  mortar. 

Then  with  stucco,  which  in  our  fourth  chapter  (of 
Architecture)  we  described  as  crushed  marble  mixed  with 
lime  from  travertine,  they  begin  to  cover  the  aforesaid 
skeleton  with  the  first  daub  of  rough  stucco,  that  is  coarse 
and  granulated,  to  be  covered  over  with  finer  when  the 
first  stucco  has  set  and  is  firm,  but  not  thoroughly  dry. 
The  reason  for  this  is  that  to  work  the  mass  of  the  material 
above  a  damp  bed  makes  it  unite  better,  therefore  they 
keep  wetting  the  stucco  at  the  place  where  the  upper 
coating  is  laid  on  so  as  to  render  it  more  easy  to  work. 

To  make  (enriched)  mouldings  or  modelled  leafage  it 
is  necessary  to  have  shapes  of  wood  carved  in  intaglio 
with  those  same  forms  that  you  wish  to  render  in  relief. 
The  worker  takes  stucco  that  is  not  actually  hard  nor 
really  soft,  but  in  a  way  tenacious,  and  puts  it  on  the 


MODELLED  AND  STAMPED  PLASTER  WORK    171 

work  in  the  quantity  needed  for  the  detail  intended  to  be 
formed.  He  then  places  over  it  the  said  hollowed  mould 
which  is  powdered  with  marble  dust,  striking  it  with  a 
hammer  so  that  the  blows  fall  equally,  and  this  leaves  the 
stucco  imprinted;  he  then  proceeds  to  clean  and  finish 
it  so  that  the  work  becomes  true  and  even.  But  if  he 
desire  the  work  to  have  bolder  relief  in  projection,  in 
the  spot  where  this  is  to  come  he  fixes  iron  supports  or 
nails  or  other  armatures  of  a  similar  kind  which  hold  the 
stucco  suspended  in  the  air,  and  by  these  means  the  stucco 
sets  firmly,  as  one  sees  in  the  ancient  edifices  where  the 
stucco  and  the  iron  supports  are  found  still  preserved 
to  the  present  day.^  Moreover,  when  the  artificer  wishes 
to  produce  a  composition  in  bas-relief  on  a  flat  wall,  he 
first  inserts  numerous  nails  in  the  wall,  here  projecting 
less,  there  more,  according  as  the  figures  are  to  be 
arranged,  and  between  these  he  crowds  in  little  bits  of 

^  Plaster,  or  stucco,  is  sometimes  regarded  as  an  inferior  material  only  to  be 
used  when  nothing  better  can  be  obtained.  It  should  not  however  be  judged 
from  the  achievements  of  the  domestic  plasterer  of  to-day,  who  has  to  trust 
sometimes  to  the  wall-paper  to  keep  his  stuff  from  crumbling  away.  Plaster 
as  used  by  the  ancients,  and  through  a  good  part  of  the  mediaeval  and 
Renaissance  periods  up  to  the  eighteenth  century,  is  a  fine  material,  susceptible 
of  very  varied  and  effective  artistic  treatment.  It  was  made  by  the  Greeks  of 
so  exquisite  a  quality  that  it  was  equivalent  to  an  artificial  marble.  It  could 
be  polished,  so  Vitruvius  tells  us,  till  it  would  reflect  the  beholder's  face  as  in 
a  mirror,  and  he  describes  how  the  Roman  connoisseurs  of  his  time  would 
actually  cut  out  plain  panels  of  Greek  stucco  from  old  walls  and  frame  them 
into  the  plaster-work  of  their  own  rooms,  just  as  if  they  were  slabs  of  precious 
marble.  {£>e  Architectura,  vii,  iii,  10.)  Vitruvius  prescribes  no  fewer  than 
six  successive  coats  of  plaster  for  a  wall,  each  laid  on  before  the  last  is  dry, 
the  last  coat  being  of  white  lime  and  finely  powdered  marble. 

By  the  Villa  Farnesina  at  Rome  some  Roman,  or  more  probably  Greek, 
plaster  decoration  was  discovered  a  few  years  ago  that  surpassed  any  work 
of  the  kind  elsewhere  known.  We  find  there  the  moulded  or  stamped 
ornament  Vasari  describes,  as  well  as  figure  compositions  modelled  by  hand, 
while  the  plain  surfaces  are  in  themselves  a  delight  to  the  artistic  eye. 

Among  the  best  and  best  known  stucco  work,  in  figures  and  ornaments,  of 
the  later  Italian  Renaissance,  may  be  ranked  that  at  Fontainebleau  by 
Primaticcio  and  other  artists  from  the  peninsula  who  were  invited  thither  by 
Franyois  I,  for  the  decoration  of  the  '  Galerie  Fran9ois  I '  and  the  '  Escalier 
du  Roi.' 


172  OF  SCULPTURE 

brick  or  tufa,  in  order  that  the  ends  or  heads  of  these 
may  hold  the  coarse  stucco  of  the  first  rough  cast,  which 
he  afterwards  goes  on  refining  delicately  and  patiently 
till  it  consolidates.  While  it  is  hardening  he  works 
diligently,  retouching  it  continually  with  moistened  paint- 
brushes in  such  a  manner  as  may  bring  it  to  perfection, 
just  as  if  it  were  of  wax  or  clay.  By  means  of  this  same 
arrangement  of  nails  and  of  ironwork  made  on  purpose, 
larger  and  smaller  according  to  need,  vaults  and  partition 
walls  and  old  buildings  are  decorated  with  stucco,  as  one 
sees  aH  over  Italy  at  the  present  day  to  be  the  habit  of 
many  masters  who  have  given  themselves  to  this  practice. 
Nor  is  one  to  suspect  work  so  done  of  being  perishable; 
on  the  contrary  it  lasts  for  ever,  and  hardens  so  well  as 
time  goes  on,  that  it  becomes  like  marble. 


CHAPTER  VII.  (XIV.) 

How  Figures  in  Wood  are  executed  and  of  what  sort  of  Wood  is  best 
for  the  purpose. 

§  73-   Wood  Carving. 

He  who  wishes  figures  of  wood  to  be  executed  in  a 
perfect  manner,  must  first  make  for  them  a  model  of  wax 
or  clay,  as  we  have  said.  This  sort  of  figure  is  much 
used  in  the  Christian  religion,  seeing  that  numberless 
masters  have  produced  many  crucifixes  and  other  objects. 
But  in  truth,  one  never  gives  that  flesh-like  appearance 
and  softness  to  wood  that  can  be  given  to  metal  and  to 
marble  and  to  the  sculptured  objects  that  we  see  in  stucco, 
wax,  or  clay.  The  best  however  of  all  the  woods  used 
for  sculpture  is  that  of  the  lime,  because  it  is  equally 
porous  on  every  side,  and  it  more  readily  obeys  the  rasp 
and  chisel.  But  when  the  artificer  wishes  to  make  a  large 
figure,  since  he  cannot  make  it  all  of  one  single  piece, 
he  must  join  other  pieces  to  it  and  add  to  its  height  and 
enlarge  it  according  to  the  form  that  he  wishes  to  make. 
And  to  stick  it  together  in  such  a  way  that  it  may  hold 
he  must  not  take  cheese  mucilage,  because  that  would 
not  hold,  but  parchmant-glue ;  ^   with  this  melted  and  the 

^  The  composition  of  these  two  mucilages  is  given  by  Theophilus,  in  the 
Schedula,  Book  one,  chapter  17,  and  also  by  Cennini,  Trattato,  chapters 
110-112. 

Soft  cheese  from  cows'  milk  must,  according  to  the  earlier  recipe,  be 
shredded  finely  into  hot  water  and  braised  in  a  mortar  to  a  paste.  It  must 
then  be  immersed  in  cold  water  till  it  hardens,  and  then  rubbed  till  it  is 
quite  smooth  on  a  board  and  afterwards  mixed  with  quick  lime  to  the 
consistency  of   a  stiff   paste.      Panels  cemented  with    this,   says    Theophilus, 


174  OF   SCULPTURE 

said  pieces  warmed  at  tiie  fire  let  him  join  and  press  them 
together,  not  with  iron  nails  but  with  pegs  of  the  wood 
itself;  which  done,  let  him  work  it  and  carve  it  according 
to  the  form  of  his  model.  There  are  also  most  praise- 
worthy works  in  boxwood  to  be  seen  done  by  workmen 
in  this  trade,  and  very  beautiful  ornaments  in  walnut, 
which  when  they  are  of  good  black  walnut  almost  appear 
to  be  of  bronze.  We  have  also  seen  carvings  on  fruit 
stones,  such  as  those  of  the  cherry  and  apricot  executed' 
by  the  hand  of  skilful  Germans  ^  with  a  patience  and 
delicacy  which  are  great  indeed.  And  although  foreigners 
do  not  achieve  that  perfect  design  which  the  Italians  exhibit 
in  their  productions,  they  have  nevertheless  wrought,  and 
still  continue  to  work,  in  such  a  manner  that  they  bring 
their  art  to  a  point  of  refinement  that  makes  the  world 
wonder :  as  can  be  seen  in  a  work,  or  to  speak  more 
correctly,  in  a  miracle  of  wood  carving  by  the  hand  of 
the  Frenchman,  Maestro  Janni,  who  living  in  the  city  of 
Florence  which  he  had  chosen  for  his  country,  adopted, 
for  his  designs,  in  which  he  always  delighted,  the  Italian 
style.  This,  with  the  practice  he  had  in  working  in  wood, 
enabled  him  to  make  a  figure  in  lime  wood  of  San  Rocco 
as  large  as  life.  With  exquisite  carving  he  fashioned 
the  soft  and  undercut  draperies  that  clothe  it,  cut  almost 
to  the  thinness  of  paper  and  with  a  beautiful  flow  in 
the  order  of  the  folds,  so  that  one  cannot  see  anything 
more  marvellous.  In  like  manner,  he  has  carried  out  the 
head,  beard,  hands  and  feet  of  that  Saint  with  such  per- 
fection that  it  has  deserved,  and  always  will  deserve  infinite 
praise  from  every  man ;  and  what  is  more,  in  order  that 
the  excellence  of  the  artist  may  be  seen  in  all  its  parts, 

will  be  held  so  fast  when  they  are  dry  that  neither  moisture  nor  heat  will 
bring  them  apart.  Vasari  does  not  seem  to  have  such  faith  in  the  mucilage, 
and  prefers  that  made  from  boiling  down  shreds  of  parchment  and  other 
skins.  The  twelfth  century  writer  knows  how  to  make  this  also.  See  chapter 
eighteen  of  the  first  Book  of  the  Schedula. 

''■  Every  museum  contains   examples  of   these  delicate   German   carvings   in 
hard  materials. 


WOOD   CARVING  i75 

the  figure  has  been  preserved  to  our  days  in  the  church 
of  the  Annunziata  at  Florence  beneath  the  pulpit,  free  from 
any  covering  of  colour  or  painting,  in  its  own  natural 
colour  of  wood  and  with  only  the  finish  and  perfection  that 
Maestro  Janni  gave  it,  beautiful  beyond  all  other  figures 
that  can  be  seen  carved  in  wood.^    And  this  suffices  for 

'  In  a  Note  to  the  'Introduction'  to  Architecture,  ante,  p.  128  f.,  an 
account  was  given  of  some  sculptures  in  travertine  on  the  facade  of  the 
church  of  S.  Luigi  dei  Francesi  at  Rome  by  a  '  Maestro  Gian '  who 
has  been  conjecturally  identified  as  a  certain  Jean  Chavier  or  Chavenier 
of  Rouen  who  worked  at  Rome  in  the  first  quarter  of  the  sixteenth  century. 
Vasari  in  this  place  introduces  an  artist  of  the  name  of  '  Maestro  Janni 
francese,'  and  the  question  at  once  arises  whether  he  is  the  same  person  as  the 
'  Maestro  Gian '  of  Rome. 

The  statue  here  described  is  to  be  seen  in  the  church  of  the  Annunziata  at 
Florence,  but  not  where  Vasari  saw  it.  It  has  been  placed  for  about  the 
last  half  century  in  the  spacious  round  choir,  where  it  occupies  a  niche  in 
the  wall  of  the  second  chapel  to  the  left  as  one  faces  the  high  altar.  It 
has  been  painted  white  in  the  hope  that  it  may  be  mistaken  for  marble,  and 
this  characteristic  performance  dates  from  about  1857.  Certain  fissures  observable 
show  however  that  it  is  of  wood,  and  one  of  the  Frati  remembers  it  when  it 
was  as  Vasari  saw  it  'nello  stesso  colore  del  legname.'  The  work  is  shown 
on  Plate  IX.  We  have  been  unable  to  discover  anything  certain  about  the  artist. 
The  figure,  which  is  in  excellent  preservation,  speaks  for  itself.  The  Saint 
has  a  tight  fitting  cap  over  his  head  and  curling  hair  and  beard.  His  eyes 
are  almost  closed  as  he  looks  down  with  a  somewhat  affected  air  at  his 
wounded  leg  to  which  the  finger  of  his  right  hand  is  pointing.  The  other 
hand  holds  a.  staff,  round  which  the  drapery  curls  and  over  the  top  of  which 
it  is  caught.  This  drapery  bears  out  Vasari's  description  of  it  as  '  traforato ' 
'  cut  into. '  It  is  floridly  treated  with  the  sharp  angles  common  in  the  carving  of 
the  fifteenth  and  sixteenth  centuries  in  Germany,  Flanders,  and  parts  of  France. 
M.  Marcel  Reymond,  who  has  kindly  given  his  opinion  on  the  photographs 
submitted  to  him,  has  written  about  it  as  follows :  '  Le  St  Roch,  par  la 
surcharge  de  vetements,  I'exces  de  reliefs,  I'agitation  des  draperies,  se 
rattache  a  I'art  franyais  tel  qu'il  s'etait  constitu^  au  xiv""  siecle,  et  tel  qu'il 
s'etait  continue  jusqu'au  xvi°'°  siecle,  notamment  dans  le  Bourgogne  et  la 
Champagne.'  He  does  not  consider  the  two  '  Maltres  Jean'  the  same 
person.  '  Ce  sont  sans  doute  deux  artistes  du  xvi™'  siecle,  I'un  travaillant  la 
pierre,  le  travertin,  I'autre  travaillant  le  bois.  C'est  leur  aptitude  a  travailler 
ces  deux  malieres,  que  les  artistes  italiens  travaillaient  moins  bien  que  les 
franjais  qui  a.  retenu  I'attention  de  Vasari  sur  eux  et  qui  leur  a  fait  attribuer 
une  place  si  importante  dans  les  prefaces  de  Vasari.'  Our  study  of  the 
originals  at  Rome  and  Florence  has  led  us  to  the  same  opinion.     The  S. 


176  OF  SCULPTURE 

a  brief  notice  of  all  the  things  relating  to  sculpture.  Let 
us  now  pass  on  to  painting. 

Rocco  is  Gothic  in  feeling,  the  '  Salamander '  and  other  pieces  at  Rome  are 
Renaissance.  The  Roman  'Maestro  Gian'  may  be  credited  with  an  Italian 
style,  but  Vasari  does  not  show  much  critical  acumen  when  he  sees  '  la 
maniera  italiana'  in  the  S.  Rocco  of  the  Florentine  Janni. 


Plate  IX 


STATUE  OF 
S.  ROCCO 
CARVED  IN 
LIMEWOOD, 
by  a  French  Artist 
'  Maestro  Janni,' 
in  the  Church  of 
the  Annunziata, 
Florence 


NOTES   ON  'INTRODUCTION'  TO 
SCULPTURE 


M 


NOTES  ON  'INTRODUCTION'  TO 
SCULPTURE 

THE   NATURE  OF  SCULPTURE. 
[§  36,  The  Nature  of  Sculpture,  ante,  p.   143.] 

■^The  remark  with  which  Vasari  opens  his  '  Introduction  '  to 
Sculpture,  though  it  sounds  rather  trite,  involves  a  point  of 
some  interest.  Vasari  says  that^he  sculptor  removes  all  that 
is  superfluous  from  the  material  under  treatment,  and  reduces 
it  to  the  form  designed  for  it  in  his  mind^*  This  is  true  of  the 
technique  of  sculpture  proper,  that  is  stone  or  marble  carving, 
but  there  are  processes  in  the  art  other  than  that  of  cutting 
away  a  block  of  hard  material.  Michelangelo,  in  a  letter  he 
wroteJn^JLg49J:n  BenedettoJVarchi,_oa-the-e3rer-recurring  theme 
of  the  relative  dignity  of  painting  and  sculpture,  notices  the 
fact  that  the  sculptor  proceeds  in  two  ways,  by  the  progressive 
reduction  of  a  mass,  as  is  the  case  with  the  marble  carver,  or 

_b  his  o_wii  words,  '  per  forza  di  levare  ' ;  and_als£Lhy. successive 
additions,  as  in  modelling  in  clay  or  wax,  which  he  calls  'per 

-K:ia_di  pnrre, '  '  by  the  method  of  putting  on. '  The  distinction 
is  one  of  fundamental  importance  for  a  right  understanding  of 
the  art,  and  upon  it  depends  the  characteristic  difference 
between  Greek  reliefs,  which  are  almost  all  carved  in  marble, 
and  if  not  are  beaten  up  on  metal  plates  by  the  repoussd 
process,  and  Italian  reliefs  that  are  very  often  in  cast  bronze, 
the  models  for  which  have  been  prepared  by  modelling,  '  per 
via  di  porre,'  in  wax.  On  this  point  something  will  be  found 
in  the  Note  on  '  Italian  and  Greek  Reliefs,'  postea,  p.  196  f. 

With  regard  to  sculpture  effected  '  by  taking  away, '   '  per 
forza  di  levare,'  Michelangelo  has  left  a  famous  utterance  in 


i8o  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

one  of  his  sonnets,   No.   xv  in  the  edition  of  Guasti,   which 
opens  as  follows  : — 

'  Non  ha  1'  ottimo  artista  alcun  concetto, 

Ch'  un  marmo  solo  in  si  non  circonscriva 
Col  suo  soverchio;    e  solo  a  quello  arriva 
La  man  che  ubbidisce  all'  intelletto,' 

and  is  thus  translated  by  J.  A.  Symonds  : — 

'  The  best  of  artists  hath  no  thought  to  show 

Which  the  rough  stone  in  its  superfluous  shell 
Doth  not  include.     To  break  the  marble  spell 

Is  all  the  hand  that  serves  the  brain  can  do.' 

The  conceit  is  really  a  classical  one,  and  is  probably  due  to 
some  Greek  writer  used  by  Cicero  in  his  tract  De  Divinatione. 
Some  one  had  testified  to  the  fact  that,  in  a  certain  marble 
quarry  on  Chios,  a  block,  casually  split  open,  had  disclosed  a 
head  of  Pan;  and  Cicero,  or  the  writer  he  had  before  him, 
remarks  that  such  a  chance  might  occur,  though  the  similitude 
would  only  be  a  rude  one.  In  any  case  however,  he  goes  on, 
it  must  be  conceded  that  even  the  very  finest  heads  imaginable 
are  really  in  existence  throughout  all  time  in  every  block  of 
stone  of  sufficient  size.  All  that  even  a  Praxiteles  could  do 
would  be  to  bring  them  into  view  by  taking  off  all  that  was 
superfluous  in  the  marble.  He  would  add  nothing  to  what 
was  there  already.  The  whole  process  would  be  the  removal 
of  what  was  superfluous  and  bringing  to  light  what  was  con- 
cealed within. 

SCULPTURE  TREATED   FOR  POSITION. 

[§  38,   Works  of  Sculpture  should  be  treated  with  a  view  to 
their  destined  Position,  ante,  p.   145.] 

Vasari  is  dealing  with  sculpturesque  treatment  as  conditioned 
by  the  position  and  lighting  for  which  works  of  statuary  are 
destined,  and  a  somewhat  interesting  question  in  the  aesthetics 
of  tjje  plastic  art  is  opened  up. 

/There  are  here  two  matters  to  be  distinguished ;  one  is  the 
general  treatment  of  a  figure  or  relief  in  relation  to  position, 
and  t'Ee"  otJierTs  the  deliberate  alteration  in  the  proportions  of 


SCULPTURE   TREATED   FOR   POSITION     i8i 

it,  with  a  view  to  the  same  consideration.  It  is  almost  a 
matter  of  course  that  an  artist,  in  preparing  his  model,  will 
keep  in  view  the  aspect  under  which  the  finished  work  will  be 
presented  to  the  spectator,  but  the  definite  change  in  propor- 
tions is  another  matter.  Vasari  is  clear  in  his  own  mind  that 
Donatello  and  other  sculptors  did  make  changes  of  proportions 
as  well  as  of  general  treatment  on  the  grounds  indicated,  but 
in  alleging  this  he  is  not  drawing  on  his  own  expert  knowledge 
as  an  artist,  so  much  as  echoing  a  judgement  of  literary  critics 
often  expressed  in  both  ancient  and  modern  times.  There  is 
a  passage  in  Plato's  Sophist  which  shows  that  in  Greek 
aesthetics  this  question  was  discussed,  and  a  distinction  is  there 
drawn,  pp^  235-6,  between  exact  imitation  of  nature,  and  an 
imitation  that  modifies  the  forms  of  nature  for  artistic  effect. 
In  large  works,  Plato  points  out,  if  the  true  proportions  were 
given  '  the  upper  part  which  is  further  off  from  the  eye  would 
appear  to  be  out  of  proportion  in  comparison  with  the  lower, 
which  is  nearer;  and  so  our  artists  give  up  the  truth  in  their 
images  and  make  only  the  proportions  which  appear  to  be 
beautiful  disregarding  the  true  ones.'  The  same  idea  con- 
nected with  a  concrete  instance  is  embodied  in  a  legend 
preserved  in  some  verses  by  the  Byzantine  writer  Tzetzes,  to 
the  effect  that  Pheidias  and  Alcamenes  competed  on  one 
occasion  with  rival  figures  of  the  goddess  Athene.  Alcamenes 
finished  his  with  great  delicacy,  and  on  a  near  view  it  was 
preferred  to  that  by  Pheidias.  The  latter  sculptor,  '  being 
versed  in  optics  and  geometry,'  had  allowed  for  distance  and 
exaggerated  certain  details.  When  both  figures  were  put  into 
position  the  superiority  of  that  by  Pheidias  was  at  once 
apparent.  It  has  been  argued  from  a  passage  in  Eustatius 
that  Pheidias  fashioned  his  Zeus  at  Olympia  with  the  head 
slightly  inclined  forwards,  so  as  to  bring  it  more  directly  into 
view  from  the  floor  of  the  temple  below. 

In  modern  times  Donatello 's  works  have  been  specially 
singled  out  as  illustrating  this  same  principle,  and  not  by 
Vasari  alone.  The  following,  for  instance,  is  an  obiter  dictum 
of  the  Florentine  writer  Davanzati  in  a  letter  aflSxed  to  his 
translation  of  Tacitus  published  first  in  1596,  (see  Opere  di 
Tacito,  Bern.  Davanzati,  Padova,  1755,  p.  656),  where  he  says, 


i82  NOTES  ON   SCULPTURE 

'  You  must  look  at  the  way  an  effect  is  introduced,  as  in  the 
case  of  Donatello  and  his  famous  Zuccone  (Bald  Head)  on  our 
Campanile  of  the  Duomo.  The  eyes  of  this  statue  as  one  looks 
at  it  on  high  seem  as  if  dug  out  with  the  spade,  but  if  he  had 
worked  it  on  the  ground  (for  a  near  view)  the  figure  would 
appear  to  be  blind.  The  reason  is  that  distance  swallows  up 
all  refinement  of  work  (la  lontananza  si  mangia  la  dili- 
genzia)  ...  In  the  same  way  the  rudeness  of  rustic  work  on 
great  palace  walls  does  not  take  away  from  but  rather  adds  to 
the  effect  of  majesty.'  Modern  critics  have  agreed  in  com- 
mending Donatello  for  his  judicious  treatment,  with  a  view  to 
situation,  of  works  like  the  statues  on  the  Campanile,  which 
are  more  than  fifty  feet  above  the  ground.  Hans  Semper 
praises  specially  from  this  stand-point  the  '  Abraham  and 
Isaac  '  on  the  Campanile,  and  remarks  that  if  this  group  were 
taken  down  and  seen  on  the  ground  there  would  be  a  great 
outcry  about  faults  of  proportion  in  the  legs,  (Donatello, 
Wien,  1875,  p.  122.)  In  Lord  Balcarres's  recent  book  on 
Donatello  there  is  a  discussion  of  the  Campanile  statues,  and 
other  works  by  the  master,  in  relation  to  the  same  aesthetic 
principle,  {Donatella,  London,  1903,  p.   17  £f.) 

There  is  no  question  that  the  boldness  and  vigour  which 
were  characteristic  of  Donatello  were  well  suited  to  give  his 
works  a  telling  effect  at  a  distance,  and  this  may  be  noticed  in 
the  case  of  his  '  Cantoria  '  with  the  dancing  children  In  the 
Opera  del  Duomo  at  Florence.  We  are  reminded  here  of  the 
Pheidias  and  Alcamenes  story.  On  a  near  view  Donatello's 
Cantoria  suffers  in  a  comparison  with  the  more  delicate  work 
on  the  same  theme  of  Luca  della  Robbia,  but  when  both 
galleries  were  '  in  position,'  high  up,  and  in  the  semi-darkness 
of  the  Duomo,  the  effect  of  Donatello's  relief  must  have  been 
far  finer.  This  bold  and  sketchy  treatment  was  not  due  to  the 
fact  that  the  master  could  work  in  no  other  way,  for  Donatello 
treated  very  low  relief,  spoken  of  later  on  by  Vasari  as  '  stiac- 
ciato,'  with  remarkable  delicacy  and  finish.  Hence  we  may 
fairly  credit  him  with  intention  in  the  strong  effects  of  some 
of  his  monumental  works. 

This  is  however  quite  a  different  matter  from  deliberate 
alteration  of  the  proportions  of  a  figure  in  view  of  the  position 


SCULPTURE  TREATED  FOR  POSITION     183 

it  is  to  occupy.  In  spite  of  what  Vasari  and  some  modern 
writers  have  said,  it  must  be  doubted  whether  Donatello  or 
any  other  responsible  sculptor  has  done  anything  of  the  kind. 
Vasari  speaks  of  figures  '  made  a  head  or  two  taller  '  when  they 
have  to  be  seen  in  a  near  view  from  below,  but  he  does  not 
refer  to  any  examples.  Decorative  figures  of  elongated  pro- 
portions may  be  instanced,  but  it  does  not  follow  that  these 
proportions  were  intended  to  correct  perspective  foreshortening. 
The  twelfth  century  statues  in  the  western  portals  at  Chartres 
are  curiously  elongated,  and  so  too  are  the  stucco  nymphs  of 
Primaticcio  in  the  Escalier  du  Roi  at  Fontainebleau,  but  in 
both  cases  the  figures  are  but  little  above  the  level  of  the  eye, 
and  their  shape  is  certainly  not  due  to  any  such  consideration 
as  was  in  the  mind  of  Vasari.  The  actual  proportions  of 
Donatello 's  Campanile -statues  seem  perfectly  normal,  though 
the  works  may  have  been  deliberately  treated  with  a  view  to 
position. 

It  is  worth  notice  that,  proportions  apart,  the  principle  of 
'  treatment  for  position  '  has  by  no  means  been  generally 
observed.  In  the  greatest  and  most  prolific  periods  of 
sculpture  indeed,  there  seems  to  have  been  little  consistency 
of  practice  in  this  regard,  while  some  of  the  finest  decorative 
works  in  the  world  appear  to  have  been  very  little  affected  by 
any  considerations  of  the  kind.  As  in  duty  bound,  Vasari 
appeals  to  the  antique,  but  as  a  matter  of  fact,  classical 
decorative  sculpture  exhibits  only  in  a  very  minor  degree  these 
studied  modifications  of  treatment  in  relation  to  position.  In 
the  frieze  of  the  Parthenon  the  background  is  cut  back  a  little 
deeper  above  than  below,  so  as  to  increase  the  apparent  salience 
of  the  parts  farthest  from  the  eye,  and  on  the  column  of 
Marcus  Aurelius  at  Rome,  which  may  have  been  in  Vasari 's 
mind  when  he  mentions  reliefs  on  columns,  the  salience  of  the 
relief  is  much  bolder  above  than  below.  The  well-known  band 
of  ornament  on  the  framing  of  Ghiberti's  '  Old  Testament ' 
gates  shows  similar  variety  in  treatment.  On  the  earlier 
column  of  Trajan,  on  the  other  hand,  the  eye  can  detect  no 
variation  in  treatment  of  the  kind.  The  groups  from  the 
pediments  of  the  Parthenon  give  little  indication  that  they 
were  designed  to  be  looked  at  sixty  feet  above  the  eye,  while 


1 84  NOTES  ON  SCULPTURE 

the  heads  by  Scopas  from  the  pediments  at  Tegea  are  finished 
with  the  utmost  delicacy,  as  if  for  the  closest  inspection. 

In  the  matter  of  the  choice  of  low  or  high  relief  according 
to  the  distance  from  the  eye,  the  frieze  of  the  Parthenon  is 
often  adduced  as  canonical,  because,  being  only  visible  from 
near,  it  is  in  very  low  relief.  It  is  forgotten  however  that  the 
nearly  contemporary  friezes  on  the  Theseum  and  from  the 
interior  of  the  temple  at  Bassae,  though  they  were  correspond- 
ingly placed  and  actually  nearer  to  the  eye,  are  both  in  high 
relief.  On  the  Roman  triumphal  arches,  of  which  Vasari 
writes,  there  are  similar  anomalies.  Thus  the  well-known 
panels  within  the  passage  way  of  the  Arch  of  Titus,  that  must 
have  been  calculated  for  very  near  stand-points,  are  in  boldest 
projection. 

The  magnificent  decorative  sculpture  on  the  French  Gothic 
cathedrals  shows  little  trace  of  the  sort  of  calculation  here 
spoken  of.  It  is  true  that  the  figures  of  Kings  in  the 
'  Galeries  des  Rois  '  across  the  west  fronts  are  as  a  rule  rudely 
carved,  but  this  is  because  they  are  so  purely  formal  and  give 
the  artist  little  opportunity.  At  Reims  some  of  the  finest  and 
most  finished  work  is  to  be  found  in  the  effigies  of  Kings,  the 
Angels,  and  other  figures,  on  the  upper  stages  of  the  building, 
while  the  '  Church  Triumphant '  up  above  on  the  southern 
transept  fa9ade  is  every  whit  as  delicately  beautiful  as  the 
'  Mary  of  the  Visitation, '  in  the  western  porch. 

Enough  has  been  said  to  show  that  on  this  subject  literary 
statements  are  not  to  be  trusted  and  practice  is  very  uncertain. 
It  remains  to  be  seen  what  light  can  be  thrown  upon  it,  first, 
from  the  side  of  aesthetic  principle;  and,  second,  from  that 
of  the  actual  procedure  and  expert  judgement  of  sculptors  of 
to-day. 

The  principle  will  hardly  be  controverted  that  anything 
abnormal,  either  in  the  proportions  of  a  figure  or  even  in  its 
treatment,  will  tend  to  defeat  its  own  object  by  confusing  our 
regular  and  highly  effective  visual  process.  The  organs  which 
co-operate  in  this  are  so  educated  that  we  interpret  by  an 
unconscious  act  of  intelligence  what  we  actually  see,  and  make 
due  allowance  for  distance  and  position.  It  is  often  said  that 
objects   look   larger  through   a  mist.     This   is   not  the   case. 


SCULPTURE  TREATED  FOR  POSITION     185 

They  do  not  look  larger  but  they  look  further  off,  and  the 
equation  between  apparent  size  and  apparent  distance  which 
we  unconsciously  establish  is  vitiated,  so  that  the  impression 
is  produced  that  the  particular  object  is  abnormally  large. 
Now  in  the  same  way  we  allow  for  the  distance  and  the 
perspective  angle  at  which  a  work  of  sculpture  is  seen  and 
interpret  accurately  the  actual  forms  and  effects  of  texture  and 
light  and  shade  the  image  of  which  falls  on  the  retina.  If 
the  sculptor  have  altered  his  proportions  there  is  a  danger 
that  we  shall  derive  the  impression  of  a  distorted  figure, 
because  we  have  made  our  allowances  on  the  supposition  that 
the  proportions  are  normal.  If  he  have  forced  the  effect  by 
emphasizing  the  modelling,  he  will  make  the  parts  where  this 
is  done  appear  too  near  the  eye,  and  this  will  involve  a  false 
impression  of  the  height  and  dimensions  of  the  structure  on 
which  the  sculpture  is  displayed.  There  is  this  forcing  of 
effect  in  the  case  of  the  column  of  Marcus  Aurelius,  but  it 
is  of  no  artistic  advantage,  and  would  tend  to  make  the  column 
itself  look  lower  than  it  really  is.  In  the  column  of  Trajan 
the  spiral  lines  have  a  certain  artistic  wavyness,  so  that  the 
band  of  sculpture  varies  in  width  in  different  parts,  but  the 
treatment  is  the  same  throughout,  and  as  the  reliefs  were  not 
only  to  be  seen  from  below  but  also  from  the  lofty  neighbouring 
structures  of  the  Trajanic  Forum,  this  was  not  only  in  accord- 
ance with  principle  but  with  common  sense.  It  is  obvious 
indeed  that  works  of  monumental  sculpture  are  practically 
always  visible  from  other  points  than  the  one  for  which  their 
effect  is  chiefly  calculated ;  and  hence  if  proportions  be  modified 
so  as  to  suit  one  special  standpoint,  the  work  may  look  right 
in  this  one  aspect,  but  in  all  others  may  appear  painfully 
distorted. 

As  regards  the  second  point,  we  have  asked  Mr.  Pittendrigh 
Macgillivray,  R.S.A. ,  a  question  on  this  subject,  and  he  has 
kindly  given  us  his  opinion  in  the  following  note. 

'  The  question  as  to  whether  or  not  sculptors  deliberately 
'  alter  the  normal  proportions  of  the  human  figure  in  order 
'  to  adapt  their  works  to  special  circumstances  is  one  which 
'  is  frequently  asked,  and  which  I  have  never  found  reason  to 
'  answer   otherwise   than    in    the    negative.     The    rule    in    the 


i86  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

classic  examples  of  all  periods,  as  far  as  I  have  observed,  is 
normal  proportion  and  execution,  irrespective  of  site  and 
circumstances,  and,  to  anyone  familiar  with  the  art  and 
practice  of  sculpture,  the  difficulties  and  uncertainties  con- 
sequent upon  a  lawless  method  of  dealing  with  the  normal 
quantities  of  the  figure,  are  a  sufficient  deterrent  against 
vagaries  in  scale  and  proportion.  To  change  the  proportions 
of  the  figure  in  order  to  meet  the  peculiarities  and  limitations 
of  some  special  site,  seems  on  the  surface  so  reasonable  that 
one  is  not  greatly  surprised  at  the  persistence  of  the  idea  in 
literary  circles,  where  it  has  not  been  possible  to  balance  it 
against  that  technical  knowledge  which  is  the  outcome  of 
actual  practice  and  experience  in  handling  the  mdtier  of  the 
art.  To  adapt  statuary  by  fanciful  proportions  to  unfortunate 
conditions  and  circumstances,  for  which  truer  artistic  taste 
and  understanding,  on  the  part  of  architects,  would  never 
propose  it,  seems  such  a  'cute  notion  that  it  has  occasionally 
attracted  the  clever  ones  of  the  profession  as  a  way  out  of  the 
difficulty,  but  one  which  has  led  only  to  ultimate  discom- 
fiture. 
'  The  fact  is,  I  imagine,  that  the  normal  proportions  of  the 
human  figure  are  so  deeply  printed  on  the  inherited  memory 
of  the  race  that,  except  within  very  narrow  limitations,  they 
cannot  be  modified  and  yet  at  the  same  time  convey  lastingly 
any  high  order  of  serious  emotion  or  effect.  The  great  men 
doing  serious  work  in  sculpture  will  never  find  it  necessary  to 
go  beyond  the  law  of  nature  for  the  architectonic  basis  of 
their  expression.  Faulty  or  arbitrary  proportion  in  handling 
'the  human  figure  is  unnecessary;  it  is  of  no  real  help  to  the 
artist,  and  no  more  desired  by  him  than  is  the  liberty  of 
1 6  lines  and  ballad  measure,  by  the  sonneteer  expert  in  the 
Petrarchan  form  and  rhyme  of  14  pentameter  verses.  The 
real  matter  to  be  dealt  with  in  respect  of  peculiarities  of  site 
and  circumstances  lies  within  the  sphere  of  the  artistic 
capacity,  and  is  at  once  more  easy  and  more  difficult  than  any 
wooden  process  of  mis-handling  the  proportions  of  the  figure. 
It  is  at  issue  in  the  legend  of  the  Byzantine  writer,  Tzetzes, 
to  which  reference  is  made,  wherein  it  is  said  that  Pheidias 
and  Alcamenes  competed  on  one  occasion  with  rival  figures  of 


SCULPTURE  TREATED  FOR  POSITION     187 

Athene,  but  the  explanation  given  of  the  reason  why  the  work 
of  Pheidias  was  admired  and  preferred  at  the  site,  is,  I 
venture  to  say,  the  wrong  one,  in  as  far  as  it  presupposes 
abnormal  proportions  in  the  successful  statue.  To  the 
author's  mind,  no  doubt,  something  profound  and  abstruse 
was  necessary  in  order  to  explain  such  a  triumph,  and  the 
idea  that  Pheidias  was  deeply  versed  in  what  must  then  have 
been  the  occult  mysteries  of  optics  and  geometry,  fitted  the 
need  and  was  pleasant  to  the  love  of  the  marvellous. 

'  In  such  a  case,  Pheidias  would  certainly,  with  the  intuitive 
artistic  sense  and  experience  of  a  master,  handle  the  style, 
composition,  lights  and  shadows,  mass,  line  and  silhouette  of 
his  work  in  relation  to  its  size,  and  the  average  height  and 
distance  from  which  ft  was  to  be  viewed.  It  might  be 
finished  highly  in  respect  of  surface,  or  left  moderately  rough, 
a  condition  of  little  consequence  compared  with  the  factors 
enumerated  above.  It  would  be  made  readable  and  expres- 
sive, but  there  would  be  no  modification  of  the  sacred 
proportions  of  the  figure;  no  trace  of  allowance  in  order 
that  "  the  upper  part  which  is  further  off  from  the  eye  should 
appear  to  be  in  proportion  when  compared  with  the  lower, 
which  is  nearer."  That  artists  should  appear  to  give  up 
natural  truth  in  their  images  for  considerations  of  abstract 
beauty,  was  grateful  to  the  mind  of  Plato,  but  is  only  another 
proof  of  the  soaring  qualities  of  the  White  Horse  in  the 
Human  Chariot ! 

'  Outside  of  a  somewhat  conscious  effort  towards  the 
decorative  in  form  and  towards  the  effective  articulation  of 
parts,  I  find  little  in  the  work  of  Donatello  to  justify  his  being 
specially  singled  out  as  illustrating  those  principles  of  the 
modification  of  true  proportions  for  sculpture  in  relation  to 
the  exigencies  of  site.  The  statues  on  the  Campanile  need 
not,  I  imagine,  be  taken  too  seriously  as  exhibitions  of 
Donatello's  most  careful  judgement.  Compared  with  such 
works  of  his  as  we  may  feel  at  liberty  to  believe  personal, 
they  are  rude  and  ill-considered  in  design  and  execution. 
There  is  in  the  bones,  mass,  and  arrangement  of  the  work 
very  probably  something  of  Donatello,  but  in  the  detail  and 
execution  there  is  little  or  nothing  of  the  hand  that  did  the 


i88  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

'  Christ   of   S.    Antonio   of   Padua,    the  bronze    David   of   the 
'  Bargello,  or  the  bust  of  Niccolo  da  Uzzano. ' 

WAXEN   EFFIGIES   AND    MEDALLIONS. 

[§  43,  Polychrome  Wax  Effigies,  ante,  p.   149.] 

Wax  has  been  used  from  the  time  of  the  ancients  as  a 
modelling  material,  both  in  connection  with  casting  in  bronze, 
and  with  the  making  of  small  studies  for  reproduction  in  more 
permanent  materials.  The  production  of  a  plastic  work  in  wax 
intended  to  remain  as  the  finished  expression  of  the  artist's  idea 
is  of  course  a  different  matter.  Among  the  Greeks,  Lvsistratos, 
the  brother  of  Lysippos,  about  the  time  of  Alexander  the 
Great,  introduced  the  practice  of  taking  plaster  moulds  from 
the  life,  and  then  making-  casts  from  them  in  wax.  These  he 
may  have  coloured,  for  the  use  of  colour,  at  any  rate  on  terra 
cotta,  was  at  the  time  universal,  and  in  this  way  have  produced 
waxen  effigies.  (Hominis  autem  imaginem  gypso  e  facie  ipsa 
primus  omnium  expressit  ceraque  in  earn  formam  gypsi  infusa 
emendare  instituit  Lysistratus  Sicyonius  frater  Lysippi.  Plin. 
Hist.  Nat.,  XXXV,  153).  Rusts  in  nnlnnred  wax  of  departed 
ancestors  were  kept  by  the  Romans  of  position  in  the  atria  of 
their_iiQuses,  and  the  funereal  use  of  thp  ^av  pfflgy  pan  -,hp 
'  followed  from.cJassicaI-.times,-_tQ_thnsp  cnmparativply  p^nfipm, 
for  in  Westminster  Abbey  can  sHIl  he  sppn  the  wavpq  pffigipg 
of  Queen  Elizabeth,  Charles  II,  and  other  sovereigns  and 
nobles  of  the  sixteenth  and  seventeenth  centuries.  These,  like 
the  modern  wax-works  of  popular  exhibitions,  are  hardly  pro- 
ductions of  art.  What  Vasari  writes  of  is  a  highly  refined  and 
artistic  kind  of  work,  that  was  practised  in  Italy  from  the 
early— Bart_  of  the  sixteenth  century,  and  .sBread  to  France, 
Ggrmany,  and  England  in  each  of  which  countries  there  were 
welWcnmrn^executant^  m^  "the  seventeenflir  or  eighteenth 
ceqturies.  TbS— Connoisseur  jof_March,  1904,  contained  an 
articlp.  nn  thp  chief  of  these.  ~  _— __^ 

Though  modelled  effigies  in  wax  of  a  thoroughly  artistic  kind 
were  executed  of  or  near  the  size  of  life  and  in  the  round,  as 
may  be  seen  in  the  Italian  waxen  bust  of  a  girl  in  the  Musde 
Wicar  at  Lille,  that  has  been  ascribed  to  Raphael,  yet  as  a 


WAXEN   EFFIGIES   AND   MEDALLIONS      189 

rule  the  execution  was  in  miniature  and  in  relief.  Specimens 
of  this  form  of  the  work  are  to  be  seen  in  the  British  Museum, 
in  the  Wallace  Collection,  and  at  South  Kensington. 

In  the  Proceedings  of  the  Huguenot  Society  of  London,  m, 
4,  there  is  an  article  on  the  Cossets,  a  Huguenot  family,  some 
members  of  which  practised  the  art  in  England  from  the  early 
part  of  the  eighteenth  century,  and  a  recipe  for  colouring  the 
wax  is  there  quoted  which  it  may  be  interesting  to  compare 
with  "that  given  by  Vasari.  '  To  two  ounces  of  flake  white  (the 
biacca  of  Vasari)  add  three  of  Venice  turpentine,  if  it  be  in 
summer,  and  four  in  winter,  with  sufficient  vermilion 
(cinabrio)  to  give  it  a  pinkish  tint.  Grind  these  together  on  a 
stone  with  a  muller ;  then  put  them  into  a  pound  of  fine  white 
wax,  such  as  is  used  for  making  candies :  this  is  molten  ready 
in  an  earthen  pipkin.  Turn  them  round  over  the  fire  for  some 
time.  When  thoroughly  mixed  the  composition  should  be 
immediately  removed  and  poured  into  dishes  previously  wetted 
to  prevent  the  wax  from  sticking  to  them.' 

This  refers  to  the  preparation  of  a  self-coloured  wax  which 
may  be  prepared  of  a  flesh  tint,  or  of  a  creamy  white,  or  of 
any  other  desired  hue  like  those  Vasari  enumerates.  The 
portraits  in  wax  referred  to  in  our  museums  are  sometimes  in 
self-coloured  material  of  this  kind,  but  at  other  times  are 
coloured  polychromatically  in  all  their  details.  This  is  the 
technique  referred  to  by  Vasari  in  §  43  as  having  been  intro- 
duced by  certain  '  modern  masters. '  In  Opere,  iv,  436  he  refers 
to  one  Pastorino  of  Siena  as  having  acquired  great  celebrity 
for  wax  portraits,  and  as  having  '  invented  a  composition  which 
is  capable  of  reproducing  the  hair,  beard  and  skin,  in  the  most 
natural  manner./  It  would  take  me  too  long  '  he  continues  '  to 
enumerate  all  the  artists  who  model  wax  portraits,  for  now-a- 
days  there  is  scarcely  a  jeweller  who  does  not  occupy  himself 
with  such  work.'  This  last  remark  is  significant,  for  one 
feature  of  these  polychrome  medallions  is  the  introdiiptinn  of 
real  stones,  seed  pearls,  gold  rings,  and  the  I'k^j  '"  f'f>nnpptinp 
with  the  modelled  wax,  so  that  collectors  used  to  style  the  works 
'  Italian—sixteea-th— eeBfairy  jpwp.llpri  wax^a,'  A  portrait  bust 
in  the  Salting  collection,  shown  on  loan  at  South  Kensington, 
representing  Elizabeth  of  France,  wife  of  Philip  II,  is  a  good 


'igo  NOTES  ON   SCULPTURE 

specimen  of  the  technique.  The  lady  wears  a  jewelled  hair  net 
set  with  real  red  and  green  stones,  and  a  necklet  of  seed  pearls. 
In  her  ear  is  a  ring  of  thin  gold  wire.  The  flesh  parts  are 
naturally  coloured,  the  hair  is  auburn,  the  bodice  black,  and 
there  are  two  white  feathers  in  the  headdress.  We  should 
gather  from  Vasari's  words  in  §  43  that  works  of  the  kind 
were  built  up  of  waxes  variously  coloured  in  the  mass,  and  a 
close  examination  of  extant  specimens  clearly  shows  that  this 
was  the  case.  Local  tints  such  as  the  red  of  the  lips,  etc., 
were  added  with  pigment. 

The  best  modern  notice  of  wax  modelling  in  these  forms  is 
that  contained  in  Propert's  History  of  Miniature  Art,  Lond. 
1887,  chapter  xii,  but  little  is  said  there  of  the  technique.  It 
should  be  noticed  that  the  medallion  in  coloured  wax  as  a  form 
of  art  has  been  revived  with  considerable  success  in  our  own 
time  and  country  by  the  Misses  Casella  and  others.  The  artists 
just  named  consider  that  it  would  be  impossible  to  finish  work 
on  the  usual  small  scale  in  coloured  waxes  alone,  without 
touches  of  pigment  added  with  the  brush.  It  would  be  interest- 
ing in  this  connection  to  know  what  were  the  exact  processes 
of  painting  in  wax  used  by  the  ancients.  Paintings,  which 
must  have  been  on  a  small  scale  because  they  were  on  a  ground 
of  ivory,  were  executed  in  coloured  waxes  laid  on  by  the 
'  cestrum  '  (Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xxxv,  147),  which  is  usually 
described  as  a  sort  of  spatula,  something  like  one  of  the  steel 
tools  used  by  artists  for  finishing  figures  in  plaster.  However 
the  substance  was  applied,  the  whole  process  was  apparently 
carried  out  in  the  coloured  waxes.  There  must  have  been 
some  similarity  between  this  technique  and  that  of  the  wax 
medallions  of  Renaissance  and  modern  times. 

PROPORTIONATE   ENLARGEMENT. 

[§  48,  Transference  of  the  full-sized  Model  to  the  Marble  Block, 
ante,  p.   151.] 

'  To  enlarge  the  figure  proportionately  in  the  marble. ' 
Vasari  has  said,  ante,  p.  150,  that  the  model  is  to  be  the  full  size 
of  the  marble  so  that  there  would  be  no  question  of  enlargement 
but  only  of  accurately  copying  the  form  of  the  model  in  the  new 


PROPORTIONATE  ENLARGEMENT  191 

material.  For  this  mechanical  aids  are  invoked,  the  latest  and 
most  elaborate  of  which  is  the  '  pointing  machine  '  now  in 
common  use.  The  appliances  in  Vasari's  time  were  much 
simpler.  Cellini,  in  his  Trattato  sopra  la  Scultura,  describes 
the  mechanical  arrangements  he  made  for  enlarging  a  model 
to  the  size  of  a  proposed  colossal  effigy,  and  the  principle  is  the 
same  whether  there  is  to  be  enlargement  or  exact  reproduction. 

The  model,   and   a  block  rnnghly   trimmpd   hy   mlp   r>f  f^hjinih 

to  the  size  and  shape  requirecl.  but  of  course  somewbgt  larg-pr 
tl^an  will  .ultimately  l^e  neRrieri.  are  placed  side  hy  side  on  tables 
of  exactly  the  same  form  and  dimensions.  About  the  model 
is  set  up  a  sort  of  framework  simple  or  elaborate,-  according  to 
the  character  of  the  piece,  and  a  framework  precisely  similar  in 
all  respects  is  disposed  about  the  block.  A  measurement  is 
then  taken  from  one  or  more  points  on  the  framework  tr>  a 
point  on  the  model,  and  from  a  point  or  points  similarly  situated 
on  the  other  framework,  and  in  the  same  relative  direction,  a 
similar  measurement  is  led  towards  the  block.  As  this  is  ex 
hypothesi  a  little  larger  than  the  model,  the  full  measurement 
cannot  be  taken  until  some  of  the  superfluous  marble  has  been 
removed  by  suitable  tools.  When  this  is  done  a  point  can  be 
established  on  the  block  exactly  corresponding  to  the  point 
already  fixed  on  the  model.  This  process  can  be  repeated  as 
often  as  is  necessary  until  all  the  important  or  salient  points 
on  the  model  have  been  successively  established  on  the  marble 
block,  which  will  ultimately  have  approached  so  nearly  to  the 
exact  similitude  of  the  model,  that  the  artist  can  finish  it  by  the 
eye. 

The  nature  of  what  has  been  termed  the  framework,  from 
which  all  the  measurements  are  taken,  may  vary.  Cellini,  on 
the  occasion  referred  to,  surrounded  his  model  with  a  sort  of 
skeleton  of  a  cubical  box,  from  the  sides  and  corners  of  which 
he  measured.  In  the  Encyclopddie  of  Diderot  and  d'Alembert, 
of  the  middle  of  the  eighteenth  century,  similar  square  frames, 
like  those  used  as  stretchers  for  canvases,  are  suspended  hori- 
zontally over  model  and  block,  and  plumb  lines  are  hung  from 
the  corners,  so  that  skeleton  cubes  are  established,  which  would 
answer  the  same  purpose  as  Cellini's  box.  See  Plate  X,  a.  The 
arrangement  contemplated  by  Vasari  was  somewhat  simpler. 


192  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

He  does  not  establish  a  complete  hollow  cube  about  his  model 
and  his  block,  but  is  apparently  satisfied  with  erecting  perpen- 
diculars beside  each,  from  which  the  measures  would  be  led. 
The  carpenter's  square  (squadra)  he  has  in  mind  consists  of 
two  straight  legs  joined  together  at  right  angles.  If  one  leg 
be  laid  horizontally  along  the  table  the  one  at  right  angles  to  it 
will  be  vertical,  and  from  this  the  measurements  are  taken.  In 
the  treatise  on  Sculpture  by  Leon  Battista  Alberti  there  is  an 
elaborate  description  of  a  device  he  invented  for  the  purpose  in 
view,  and  one  of  his  editors  has  illustrated  this  by  a  drawing 
reproduced  here  in  Plate  X,  b.  The  device  explains  itself,  and 
any  number  of  similar  contrivances  could  be  employed. 

THE  USE  OF   FULL-SIZED   MODELS. 

[§  49,  Danger  of  Dispensing  with  the  Full-sized  Model, 
ante,  p.   151.] 

The  question  here  is  of  the  possibility  of  dispensing 
altogether  with  a  full-sized  clay  model,  and  proceeding  at  once 
to  attack  the  marble  with  the  guidance  only  of  the  small 
original  sketch.  In  modern  times  this  is  practically  never 
done,  but  it  was  the  universal  practice  of  the  Greek  sculptors 
at  any  rate  down  to  the  later  periods  of  Hellenic  art.  These 
remarks  of  Vasari  come  just  at  the  time  of  the  change  from  the 
ancient  to  the  modern  technique,  for  we  shall  see  that  Donatello 
in  the  fifteenth  century  worked  according  to  the  simpler  ancient 
method,  while  Michelangelo  in  the  sixteenth  after  beginning 
in  the  same  fashion  finally  settled  down  to  the  use  of  the  full 
model,  which  has  ever  since  remained  de  rigeur. 

The  technique  of  the  Greeks  furnished  the  subject  for  an 
article  by  Professor  Ernest  Gardner  in  the  14th  volume  of  the 
Journal  of  Hellenic  Studies.  He  shows  there  by  a  comparison 
of  unfinished  works  that  the  Greek  sculptors  attacked  the 
marble  directly,  and  proceeded  apparently  on  the  following 
method.  Having  obtained  a  block  about  the  size  and  shape 
required  they  set  it  up  before  them  as  if  in  a  front  view,  and 
then  hewed  away  at  the  two  sides  till  they  had  brought  the 
contour  of  these  to  the  exact  lines  required  for  the  finished 
work.     They  then  passed  round  through  a  right  angle  to  the 


USE   OF   FULL-SIZED   MODELS 


193 


side,  and  treated  in  a  similar  fashion  the  front  and  back  of  the 
block,  bringing  these  to  the  shape  of  the  front  and  back  of  the 
desired  figure.     The  block  would  then,  when  looked  at  from 


Fig.  II. — Two  views  of  unfinished  Greek  marble  statue  blocked  out  on  the  ancient  system. 
In  quarries  on  Mount  Pentelicus,  Athens. 

the  front  or  back  or  from  the  sides,  present  the  required 
outlines,  but  the  section  of  it  would  still  be  square  in  every 
part — there  would  be  no  rounding  off.  The  sketches.  Fig.  11, 
show  two  views  of  a  figure  blocked  out  in  this  fashion  by  an 
ancient  Attic  sculptor.     It  was  found  in  old  marble  workings 

N 


194  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

on  Mount  Pentelicus,  and  is  preserved  at  the  modern  marble 
quarry  at  the  back  of  that  mountain.  We  owe  the  use  of  the 
photographs  employed  to  the  courtesy  of  M.  Georges  Nicole,  of 
Geneva.  They  were  published  in  the  volume  entitled  Mdlanges 
Nicole,  Geneva,  1905,  in  connection  with  an  article  on  the 
figure  by  the  archaeologist  just  named.  The  next  process  was 
to  cut  away  these  corners  and  with  the  guidance  of  the  already 
established  contours  gradually  bring  the  whole  into  the  required 
shape.  A  small  model  may  in  every  case  be  presupposed  and 
there  must  have  been  some  system  of  measurement.  Indeed  on 
some  antiques,  as  on  a  crouching  Venus  in  the  gallery  leading 
to  the  Venus  of  Milo  in  the  Louvre,  there  are  still  to  be  seen 
the  knobs  (puntelli)  to  which  measurements  were  taken  during 
the  progress  of  the  work.  Of  the  use  of  full-sized  clay  models 
there  is  in  Greece  no  evidence  at  all,  until  the  late  period  of  the 
first  century  B.C.,  when  we  are  told  of  Pasiteles,  a  very  pains- 
taking sculptor  of  a  decadent  epoch,  that  he  never  executed  a 
work  without  first  modelling  it  (nihil  unquam  fecit  antequam 
finxit).  This  no  doubt  implies  a  full-sized  model  in  clay,  for 
a  small  sketch  would  not  be  mentioned  as  it  is  a  matter  of 
course. 

The  practice  of  the  Italians  is  described  by  Cellini  in  words 
which  are  important  enough  to  quote.  They  are  from  the 
fourth  chapter  of  his  treatise  on  Sculpture.  '  Now  although 
many  excellent  masters  of  assured  technique  have  boldly 
attacked  the  marble  with  their  tools,  as  soon  as  they  had 
carved  the  little  model  to  completion,  yet  at  the  end  they  have 
found  themselves  but  little  satisfied  with  their  work.  For,  to 
speak  only  of  the  best  of  the  moderns,  Donatello  adopted  this 
method  in  his  works;  and  another  example  is  Michelangelo, 
who  had  experience  of  both  the  methods,  that  is  to  say,  of 
carving  statues  alike  from  the  small  model  and  the  big,  and  at 
the  end,  convinced  of  their  respective  advantages  and  dis- 
advantages, adopted  the  second  method  (of  the  full-sized 
model).  And  this  I  saw  myself  at  Florence  when  he  was 
working  in  the  sacristy  of  S.  Lorenzo  (on  the  Medici  tombs).' 
As  regards  Michelangelo's  early  practice,  Vasari  records  in  his 
Life  that  he  carved  the  colossal  marble  '  David  '  with  the  sole 
aid  of  a  small  wax  model,  according  to  Vasari  one  of  those 


USE   OF   FULL-SIZED   MODELS  195 

now  preserved  in  the  Casa  Buonarroti  at  Florence.     This  was 
in  1504.     The  Medici  tombs  date  twenty  years  later. 

In  connection  with  the  direct  practice  of  Donatello,  it  is 
worth  while  referring  to  some  words  of  Francesco  Bocchi,  a 
rhetorical  eulogist  of  the  arts  and  artists  of  his  native  Florence, 
who  wrote  in  1571  a  literary  effusion  on  the  sculptor's  St. 
George.  He  notes  in  his  introduction  that  Donatello  was 
accustomed  to  compose  his  marble  figures  compactly  and  to 
avoid  projecting  hands  and  arms,  while  for  his  effigies  in  bronze 
he  used  much  greater  freedom  in  action.  The  difference  is 
really  one  of  material,  and  Donatello's  practice  of  working 
directly  on  the  marble  would  necessarily  involve  this  restraint 
in  composition.  Ajiyone_accustomed  to  deal  with  marble  blocks_ 
asveWcle§_j3f-_artislic__expression,_wouId  avoid  unnecessarx 
projections  as  these  cause  great  waste  of  material  and  expendi- 
ture "ofTime.  WKenTpIastefing  clay  or  wax  on  a  flexible 
armature  tEis  "consideration  is  not  present,  and  modelled  figures 
will  naturally  be  freer  in  action  than  carved  ones.  As  will 
presently  be  seen,  certain  marked  differences  in  the  treatment 
of  relief  sculpture  depend  on  these  same  considerations  of 
material  and  technique. 

In  direct  work  on  the  marble  there  is  of  course  always  the 
danger  of  the  sort  of  miscalculation  that  Vasari  goes  on  to 
notice.  Greek  figures  sometimes  show  variations  from  correct 
proportions,  for  example,  the  left  thigh  of  the  Venus  of  Milo 
is  too  short,  but  the  errors  are  not  such  as  to  destroy  the  effect 
of  the  works.  Greek  work  in  marble  shows  a  marvellously 
intimate  knowledge  on  the  part  of  the  carver  of  his  material 
as  well  as  a  clear  conception  of  what  he  was  aiming  at.  Even 
Michelangelo  yields  in  this  respect  to  the  ancients,  for  though 
no  o:''e  was  ever  more  thoroughly  a  master  of  the  carver's 
technique,  he  made  serious  mistakes  in  calculating  proportions, 
as  in  the  '  Slave  '  of  the  Louvre,  where  he  has  not  left  enough 
marble  for  the  leg  of  the  figure.  Moderns  generally  have  not 
the  ease  which  tradition  and  practice  gave  to  the  Greek 
sculptors,  and  the  full-sized  model  is  now  a  necessary  pre- 
caution. 


196  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

ITALIAN   AND    GREEK   RELIEFS. 
[§  52,  Pictorial  or  Perspective  Reliefs,  ante,  p.    154.] 

Vasari  ascribes  comprehensively  to  the  '  ancients  '  the 
invention  of  the  pictorial  or  gerspectively  treated  relief,  which 
was  not  in  use  in  mediaeval  times,  but  came  into  vogue  in  the 
early  years  of  the  fifteenth  century.  Thp  first  rnnspirnnn-; 
instance  of  its  employment  was  in  the  models  by  Ghiberti  for 
the  second  set  of  gates  for  the  Baptistry  at  Florence  begun  in 
1425,  but  as  these  gates  were  not  finally  completed  till  1452, 
other  artists  had  in  the  meantime  produced  works  in  the  same 
style.  Donatello's  bronze  relief  of  the  beheading  of  John. the 
Baptist,  on  the  font  at  Siennaj_was_cpmpleted  in  1427  and  shows 
the  same  treatment  in  a  modified  form.  It  is  a  treatment  often 
called  pictorial  as  it  aims  at  effects  of  distance,  with  receding 
planes  and  objects  made  smaller  according  to  their  supposed 
distance  from  the  foreground.  The  style  has  been  sufficiently 
criticized,  and  it  is  generally  agreed  that  it  represents  a  defiance 
of  the  barriers  fixed  by  the  nature  of  things  between  painting  and 
sculpture.  It  depended  mainly  however  not  on  the  influence  of 
painting  but  on  the  study  of  perspective,  which  Brunelleschi 
brought  into  vogue  somewhere  about  the  year  1420.  Brunel- 
leschi's  perspectives,  or  those  which  he  inspired,  were  worked 
out  in  inlaid  woods,  or  tarsia  work,  see  postea,  p.  303  f.,  and 
exhibited  elaborate  architectural  compositions  crowded  with 
receding  lines.  These  compositions  wprp.  adnptprl  hy  Donatello 
and  others  for  the  backgrounds  of  their  figure  reliefs,  and 
Ghibertifilled  his  nearer  planes  with  a  crowd  of  figures  repre- 
sented  as  Vasari  describfiS- according  tO-the  laws  of  linear^nd 
so  far  as  the  material  permitted,  of  aerial  perspective. 

The  question  of  the  arnount  of  warrant  for  this  in  antique 
practice  as  a  whole  calls  attention  to  an  interesting  moment 
in  the  general  history  of  relief  sculpture.  This  has  been  dealt 
with  recently  by  Franz  Wickhoff,  in  the  Essay  contributed  by 
him  to  the  publication  of  the  Vienna  '  Genesis,'  and  issued  in  an 
English  translation  by  Mrs  Strong  under  the  title  Roman  Art 
(London,  1900),  and  also  in  Mrs  Strong's  own  Roman  Sculp- 
ture  (London,   Duckworth,    1907).     The  tendency   to  multiply 


ITALIAN   AND   GREEK   RELIEFS  197 

planes  in  relief,  and  to  introduce  the  perspective  effects  and  the 
backgrounds  of  a  picture,  shows  itself  in  some  of  the  late  Greek 
or  '  Hellenistic  '  reliefs,  published  by  Schreiber  under  the  title 
Die  Hellenistischen  Reliefbilder  (Wien,  1889  etc.),  and  more 
especially  in  the  smaller  frieze  from  the  altar  base  at  Pergamon. 
Etruscan  relief  sculpture  is  also  affected  by  it.  It  is  however 
in  Roman  work  of  the  early  imperial  period  that  we  actually 
find  the  antique  prototypes  for  the  kind  of  work  that  Vasari 
has  in  his  mind.  The  reliefs  on  the  tomb  of  the  Julii  at  St 
R^my,  of  the  age  of  Augustus,  those  on  the  ^Ar£J]^j3£JEitus, 
and  most  conspicuously  the  decorative  sculpture  connected 
with  the  name  of  Trajan,  are  instances  in  point.  They  show 
Hifffirences  in  plane,  and  occasionally  a  distinct  effort  after 
perspective  effects,  and  it  is  possible  that  the  study  of  some 
of  these  Roman  examples  by  Brunelleschi  and  Donatello  at 
the  opening  of  the  fifteenth  century  may  have  contributed  to 
the  formation  of  the  picturesque  tradition  in  Florentine  relief 
sculpture  of  the  period.  This  style  was  however  by  no  means 
universal  in  Roman  work^  The  carved  sarcophagi  are  not 
much  influenced  by  it,  and  these  sarcophagi  are  of  special 
importance  in  the  later  history  of  sculpture,  in  that  they  were 
the  models  used  by  Nicola  Pisano  and  the  other  French  and 
Italian  sculptors  of  the  so-called  '  proto-Renaissance  '  of  the 
twelfth  and  thirteenth  centuries.  In  relation  to  antique  sculp- 
ture as  a  whole  the  pictorial  style  is  quite  abnormal.  The 
genius  of  the  classical  Greek  relief  is  indeed  totally  opposed 
to  that  of  the  Italian  reliefs  represented  centrally  by  those  of 

Ghiberti.      The  difference  i~f11nf^ampn^■ally   nnp  nf  matprial  jpH 

technique.  It  is  the  same  distinction  that  was  drawn  bv 
Michelangelo  in  his  letter  to  Benedetto-  Varchi,  and  noticed 
already  in  the  Note  on  '  The  Nature  of  Sculpture,'  ante,  p.  179, 
the  distinction,  that  is,  between  sculpture  that  proceeds  by 
additions,  '  per  via  di  porre,'  and  that  which  advances  by  taking 
material  awavj  '  per  forza  di  levare. '  The  normal  Italian  relief 
was  in  cast  bronze  and  was  necessarily  modelled  work.  "The 
classical  relief  was  in  marble  and  was  essentially  carved  work, 
for  the  diversifying  of  a  flat  surface.  "When  the  "Gl-eek  Irelief 
was  in  baked  clay  it  was  generally  stamped  from  moulds  and 
not  modelled  up  by  hand.     The  cast  bronze  relief  in  classical 


198  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

Greece  may  be  said  only  to  have  existed  in  the  form  of  small 
plaques  for  the  decoration  of  vases  or  other  objects  in  metal. 
The  normal  bronze  relief  in  the  ancient  world  was  beaten  up 
in  sheet  metal  by  the  repouss6  process. 

In  the  case  alike  of  the  relief  carved  on  the  marble  slab,  or 
stamped  in  clay  from  moulds,  or  beaten  up  in  the  sheet  of 
metal,  the  nature  of  the  technique  renders  flatness  of  effect 
almost  obligatory.  '  The  Greek  decorative  relief  cut  '  per  forza 
di  levare  '  in  a  smooth  marble  slab,  that  is  most  often  one  of 
the  constructive  stones  of  an  edifice,  naturally  sacrifices  as  little 
of  the  material  as  is  possible,  and  in  all  Greek  reliefs,  whether 
low  or  high,  as  much  as  possible  of  the  work  is  kept  to  the 
foremost  plane,  the  original  surface  of  the  stone.  Again,  a 
mould  that  is  undercut,  or  at  all  deeply  recessed,  cannot  be 
used  for  stamping  clay,  while  the  difficulty  of  relief  work  in 
sheet  metal  is  greatly  increased  in  proportion  to  the  amount  of 
salience  of  the  forms.  Hence  the  general  flatness  of  the 
antique  relief,  observable  even  on  the  late  Roman  sarcophagi 
which  served  as  models  at  the  first  revival  of  Italian  sculpture. 
Whether  the  field  of  the  relief  is  open  or  crowded,  the  objects 
all  come  together  to  the  front. 

How  different  are  the  conditions  when  the  rehef  is  modelled 
up  by  hand  in  clay  or  wax  !  Herejhe^tarting  point  is  the 
l?ackground,  not_^s^Jn  jhe  carved  relief  the  foreground,  and 
the  forms,  worked  '  per^daTdTporre,'  can  belriaHeto  stand  out 
against  this  with  an  ease  and  effectiveness  which  tempt  the 
modeller  to  try  all  sorts  of  varieties  of  relief  in  the  same 
composition  or  the  same  figure,  and  to  multiply  planes  of 
distance  till  the  objects  on  the  foremost  plane  are  starting  out 
clear  of  the  ground.  There  is  direct  evidence  (see  ante,  p.  194) 
that  in  the  first  century  b.c.  the  use  of  clay  modelling  as  a 
preliminary  process  in  sculpture  was  greatly  extended,  and 
Roman  pictorial  reliefs  may  themselves  have  been  influenced 
from  this  side.  There  is  no  question  at  any  rate  that  the  Italians 
of  the  Renaissance  surrendered  themselves  without  hesitation 
to  the  fascination  of  this  kind  of  work,  and  the  style  of  it 
dommates  their  later  reliefs.  The  contrast  in  this  respect 
between  Ghiberti's  second,  or  Old  Testament,  Gates,  and  his 
earlier   ones   which   adhered   to   the   simpler   style   of   Andrea 


PROCESSES   OF  THE  BRONZE   FOUNDER  199 

Pisano's  reliefs  on  the  first  of  the  three  Baptistry  Gates,  is 
most  instructive.  Andrea's  reliefs  are  in  character  mediaeval, 
and  the  nearest  parallel  to  them  are  the  storied  quatrefoils  on 
the  basement  of  the  westem-portals  at  Amiens.  ItJ,s  worthy 
of  notice  how  classical  these  are  in  style,  and  this  Js_due.  to 
tKF^lact~tiiat  lilce  Greek  relief s,^ _such_as_jth£_frieze_.iif-_the. 
Parthenon,  they  were_cut_in  the  eonstructive^^tones  of  the_ 
edificeJi!Lji%.-ajid .  ayrejn.  A™iL.stQa£jsdiaiaii£i, 

This  contrast  ofGreek^n^JtaHarLOslMs  ii^^ 
con^icuous  object  lesson  on  the  importance  of  matprial  and 
technique  m  conditionmg  artistic  practice.  As  was  pointed  out 
in  the  Introductory  Essay,  these  considerations  have  not  in  the 
past  been  sufficiently  emphasized  in  the  scheme  of  education 
in  design  recognized  in  our  Schools  of  Art,  though  in  several 
quarters  now  there  is  a  promise  of  better  things. 

THE  PROCESSES  OF  THE  BRONZE  FOUNDER. 
[§§  55-69.  ante,  p.  158  ff.] 
Vasari's  account  of  the  processes  attendant  on  casting  in 
bronze  is  intelligible  and  interesting,  though  he  had  himself 
little  practical  acquaintance  with  the  craft.  Benvenuto  Cellini 
on  the  other  hand  was  an  expert  bronze  founder  and  the 
account  he  gives  of  the  necessary  operations  in  the  first  three 
chapters  of  his  treatise  on  Sculpture  is  extremely  graphic  and 
detailed,  and  may  be  usefully  employed  to  amplify  and  explain 
Vasari's  notice.  An  expert  knowledge  of  the  founder's  craft 
was  not  by  any  means  universal  among  the  Italian  sculptors 
of  the  Renaissance.  Donatello  did  not  possess  it,_  nor  did 
Michelangelo.  In  the  case  of  the  former  this  is  somewhat 
remarkable,  for  Donatello  was  such  a  vigorous  craftsman  that 
we  should  have  expected  to  find  him  revelling  in  all  the 
technical  minutiae  of  the  foundry.  We  are  expressly  told 
however  by  Pomponius  Gauricus  that  Donatello  lacked  this 
knowledge,  and  never  cast  his  own  works  but  always  relied 
on  the  help  of  bell  founders  (Hans  Semper,  Donatello, 
Wien,  1875,  P-  317)-  Midhelozzo_on_tiie_other  hand,  wjho^ 
worked^jyith  Dnnaldlo^ould  cast,  and  so  could"^hiberti~  A. 
Pollaiuolo,    and    Verr^cElQ,_wErie    Alessandro"  Leopardi    of 


200  NOTES   ON   SCULPTURE 

Venice,  who  cast  Verrocchio's  CoUeoni  statue,  was  famed  for 
his  practical  skill  in  this  department.  It  was  customary,  when 
expert  help  in  casting  was  required,  to  enlist  the  services  of 
bell  founders  and  makers  of  cannon,  but  Cellini  warns  sculptors 
against  trusting  too  much  to  these  mere  mechanicians  who 
lacked  ingenuity  and  resource. 

The  following  general  sketch  of  the  processes  of  casting  will 
render  Vasari's  account  more  easy  to  follow.  A  successful 
cast  in  bronze  consists  in  a  thin  shell  of  the  metal,  representing 
on  the  exterior  the  exact  form  of  the  model,  or  the  complete 
design  in  the  artisi-'g  mind.  The  best  way  to  procure  this  is  to 
[•^provide  first  a  similar  shell,  perfect  on  its  exterior  surface,  of 
wax,  and  then  to  melt  awpy  ^^^  ^'^""^  ""d  replace  it  bv  molten 
bronze.  For  this  to  be  possible  the  shell  of  wax  must  be 
closely  sealed  between  an  outer  envelope  and  an  inner  packing 
or  core.  It  can  then  be  got  rid  of  by  melting,  but  care  must 
have  been  taken  lest  the  core  when  it  loses  the  support  of  the 
wax  should  shift  its  position  in  relation  to  the  envelope.  To 
prevent  this,  metal  rods  are  run,  skewer-fashion,  through  core 
and  envelope  to  retain  them  firmly  in  their  relative  positions. 
Molten  bronze  may  then  be  introduced  into  the  space  formerly 
occupied  by  the  wax,  and  this,  when  it  is  cold,  and  the 
envelope  and  core  are  both  removed,  will  be  the  cast  required. 

Attention  has  to  be  paid  to  secure  that  there  shall  be  no 
mnistiirp  and  np  remnant  nf  wax  in  the,  parts  where  the  molten 
bronze  is  to  come,  otherwise  steam  may  he  generated  and  a 
dangerous  explosion  follow.  Similarly,  ^r  holes  or  vents  must 
be  provided,  so  that  the  air  may  escape  before  the  flowing 
metal.  The  cast  when  cold  should,  theoretically,  give  a  perfect 
result,  but  as  a  matter  of  fact,  unless  very  accomplished  skill 
or  great  good  fortune  have  presided  over  the  operations,  the 
metal  will  be  blistered  or  seamed  or  flawed  in  parts,  and  these 
imperfections  will  have  to  be  remedied  by  processes  which 
come  under  the  head  of  chasing,  and  are  described  by  Vasari 
at  the  close  of  the  chapter. 

A  direct  and  ingenious  method  of  procuring  the  needful  shell 
of  wax  is  that  described  by  Vasari  in  §  67  as  suitable  for 
small  figures  and  reliefs.  Over  the  model  for  such  a  small 
figure   an  envelope  is  formed,  in  the  shape  of  a  hollow  mould 


PROCESSES   OF  THE   BRONZE   FOUNDER  201 

of  fire-resisting  material,  so  constructed  that  it  can  be  taken  to 
pieces,  the  model  extracted,  and  the  mould  closed  up  again. 
The  mould  must  now  be  cooled  with  cold  water  and  it  is  then 
filled  with  melted  wax.  Contact  with  the  cold  sides  of  the 
mould  chills  the  wax,  which  hardens  all  over  in  a  sort  of  crust 
or  skin.  The  rest  of  the  wax,  still  liquid,  is  then  poured  out 
and  the  skin  or  crust  suffered  to  harden.  The  interior  is  then 
filled  with  clay  of  a  kind  that  will  stand  heat.  Rods  or  skewers 
are  passed  through  this  and  the  envelope,  the  wax  is  melted 
out  and  its  place  taken  by  the  molten  bronze. 

This  process,  one  of  course  only  suitable  for  small  objects, 
presupposes  the  existence  of  a  completely  finished  model  to  be 
exactly  reproduced  in  the  metal.  The  simplest  of  all  processes 
of  bronze  casting  dispenses  with  this  model.  Vasari  does  not 
describe  this  simplest  method  but  Cellini,  who  employed  it  both 
for  his  '  Nymph  of  Fontainebleau  '  and  his  '  Perseus,'  gives  an 
account  of  it  which  is  worth  summarizing  because  the  process 
is  probably  the  one  adopted  in  most  cases  by  the  old  Greek 
masters. 

Cellini  tells  us  that  in  making  his  large  lunette-shaped  relief 
of  the  '  Nymph  of  Fontainebleau, '  now  in  the  Louvre,  he  began 
by  modelling  up  the  piece  in  fire-resisting  clay,  of  course  over 
a  proper  armature  or  skeleton.  He  worked  it  out  to  full  size 
and  then  let  it  dry  till  it  had  shrunk  about  a  finger's  breadth. 
He  then  covered  it  with  a  coating  of  wax  of  rather  less  than 
this  thickness,  which  he  modelled  with  the  utmost  care,  finishing 
it  in  every  detail  so  that  it  expressed  to  the  full  his  own  idea 
for  the  finished  work.  This  was  then  carefully  covered  in 
successive  layers  with  an  envelope  of  fire-resisting  material, 
which  would  be  properly  tied  by  transverse  rods  to  the  core, 
and  braced  on  the  exterior  by  an  armature.  The  wax  was  then 
melted  out,  and  the  core  and  envelope  thoroughly  dried,  when 
the  molten  bronze  was  poured  in  so  as  to  reproduce  the  wax  in 
every  detail. 

It  is  obvious  that  this  is  not  only  the  most  direct  but  the 
most  artistic  method  of  work.  The  wax  forms  a  complete 
unbroken  surface  and  receives  and  retains  the  exact  impression 
in  every  detail  of  the  master's  hand.  If  the  cast  be  thoroughly 
successful,  the  bronze  will  reproduce  the  surface  of  the  wax  so 


202  NOTES   ON    SCULPTURE 

perfectly  that  no  further  work  upon  it  will  be  needed,  and  an 
'  untouched  cast '  will  be  the  result.  This  method  would  suit 
the  genius  of  the  Greeks,  and  was  no  doubt  commonly  employed 
by  them,  but  it  has  the  practical  drawback  that  if  anything 
go  wrong,  and  the  bronze  do  not  flow  properly,  the  whole  work 
is  spoilt,  and  will  have  to  be  built  up  again  de  novo  from  the 
small  study.  Cellini  tells  us  that  his  '  Perseus,'  which  he  was 
casting  in  this  fashion,  nearly  came  to  grief  from  the  cause 
just  indicated,  and  he  accordingly  recommends  what  he  calls 
the  second  method,  a  longer  and  less  direct  process,  which  has 
however  the  advantage  that  a  full-sized  completed  model  is  all 
the  time  preserved. 

This  process  is  the  one  described  by  Vasari.  A  full-sized 
clay  model  is  prepared  and  finished,  and  this  is  then  covered 
with  a  plaster  envelope  made  in  numerous  sections,  so  that  it 
can  be  taken  to  pieces  and  put  together  again  without  the 
model,  which  may  be  preserved  for  further  use.  The  next 
step  is  to  line  the  inside  of  the  empty  envelope,  or  piece-mould, 
as  it  is  called,  with  wax,  and  to  fill  up  all  the  rest  of  the  interior 
with  a  core.  The  piece-mould  is  then  removed,  and  the  surface 
of  the  wax  is  carefully  gone  over  to  secure  that  it  shall  be 
perfect  in  every  part.  Over  it  is  then  laid  in  successive  coats 
a  fire-resisting  envelope  between  which  and  the  core  the  wax 
is  hermetically  sealed.  The  wax  can  then  be  melted  out  and 
replaced  with  bronze.  The  piece-mould,  which  has  been 
detached  section  by  section  from  the  wax,  will  serve  again 
for  other  reproductions.  The  processes  in  which  wax  is 
employed  are  called  cire  perdue  processes,  because  the  wax  is 
got  rid  of  in  order  to  be  replaced  by  the  metal.  The  usual 
process  in  vogue  at  the  present  day  dispenses  with  any  employ- 
ment of  wax.  The  figure  to  be  cast  is  piece-moulded  and 
reproduced  in  a  suitable  material,  a  certain  thickness  of  which 
is  in  every  part  pared  away  according  to  the  thickness  required 
for  the  bronze.  This  core  is  then  replaced  with  proper  adjust- 
ments within  a  fireproof  mould,  and  the  bronze  is  poured  into 
the  space  prepared  for  it. 


OF   PAINTING 


OF   PAINTING 

CHAPTER   I.     (XV,) 

What  Design  is,  and  how,  good  Pictures  are  made  and  known,  and 
concerning  the  invention  of  Compositions. 

§  74.  The  Nature  and  Materials  of  Design  or  Drawing.^ 

Seeing  that  Design,  the  parent  of  our  three  arts,  Archi- 
tecture, Sculpture,  and  Painting,  having  its  origin  in  the 
intellect,  draws  out  from  many  single  things  a  general 
judgement,  it  is  like  a  form  or  idea  of  all  the  objects  in 
nature,  most  marvellous  in  what  it  compasses,  for  not__ 
only  in  the  bodies  of  men  and  of  animals  but  also  in 
plants,  in  buildings,  in  sculpture  and  in  painting,  design 
is  cognizant  of  the  proportion  of  the  whole  to  the  parts  and 
of  ,the  parts  to  each  other  and  to  the  whole.  Seeing  too 
that  from  this  knowledge  there  arises  a  certain  conception 
and  judgement,  so  that  there  is  formed  in  the  mind  that 
something  which  afterwards,  when  expressed  by  the 
hands,  is  called  design,  we  may  conclude  that  design  is  not 
other  than  a  visible  expression  and  declaration  of  our  inner 
conception  and  of  that  which  others  have  imagined  and 
given  form  to  in  their  idea.  And  from  this,  perhaps, 
arose  the  proverb  among  the  ancients  '  ex  ungue  leonem  ' 
when  a  certain  clever  person,  seeing  carved  in  a  stone 
block  the  claw  only  of  a  lion,  apprehended  in  his  mind 

^  The  first  two  sections,  §  §  74,  75,  of  this  chapter  were  added  by  Vasari 
in  the  second  edidon.  They  contain  his  contribution  to  the  philosophy  of 
the  graphic  art.  It  will  be  noted  that  his  word  '  Disegno '  corresponds 
alike  to  our  more  general  word  '  design '  and  the  more  special  term 
'  drawing.' 


2o6  OF   PAINTING 

from  its  size  and  form  all  the  parts  of  the  animal  and 
then  the  whole  together,  just  as  if  he  had  had  it  present 
before  his  eyes.  Some  believe  that  accident  was  the  father 
of  design  and  of  the  arts,  and  that  use  and  experience  as 
foster-mother  and  schoolmaster,  nourished  it  with  the  help 
of  knowledge  and  of  reasoning,  but  I  think  that,  with 
more  truth,  accident  may  be  said  rather  to  have  given 
the  occasion  for  design,  than  to  be  its  father. 

But  let  this  be  as  it  may,  what  design  needs,  when  it 
has  derived  from  the  judgement  the  mental  image  of 
anything,  is  that  the  hand,  through  the  study  and  practice 
of  many  years,  may  be  free  and  apt  to  draw  and  to  express 
correctly,  with  the  pen,  the  silver-point,  the  charcoal,  the 
chalk,  or  other  instrument,  whatever  nature  has  created. 
For  when  the  intellect  puts  forth  refined  and  judicious 
conceptions,  the  hand  which  has  practised  design  for 
many  years,  exhibits  the  perfection  and  excellence  of  the 
arts  as  well  as  the  knowledge  of  the  artist.  And  seeing 
that  there  are  certain  sculptors  who  have  not  much  practice 
in  strokes  and  outlines,  and  consequently  cannot  draw 
on  paper,  these  work  instead  in  clay  or  wax,  fashioning 
men,  animals,  and  other  things  in  relief,  with  beautiful 
proportion  and  balance.  Thus  they  effect  the  same  thing 
as  does  he  who  draws  well  on  paper  or  other  flat  surface. 

The  masters  who  practise  these  arts  have  named  or 
distinguished  the  various  kinds  of  design  according  to 
the  description  of  the  drawing  which  they  make.  Those 
whirh  arp  tniirhpd  lightly  and  just  indicated  with  the  pen 
or  other  instrument  are  called  sketches,  as  shall  be 
explained  in  another  place.  Those,  again,  that  have  the 
first  lines  encircling  an  object  are  called  profiles  or  out- 
Tmesl 

§  75.  Use  of  Design  (or  Drawing)  in  the  Various  Arts. 

All  these,  whether  we  call  them  profiles  or  otherwise, 
are  as  useful  to  architecture  and  sculpture  as  to  painting. 
Their  chief  use  indeed  is  in  Architecture,  becausejts 
designs  are  composed  only  of  lines,  which  so  far  as  the 


USES   OF   DRAWING   IN   THE   ARTS        207 

architect  is  concerned,  are  nothing  else  than  the  beginning 
and  the  end  of  his  art,  for  all  the  rest,  which  is  carried 
out  with  the  aid  of  models  of  wood  formed  from  the  said 
lines,  '".merely  the  work  of  carvers  and  masons.^ 

In  Sculpture,  drawing  is  of  service  in  the  case  of  all  the 
profiles,  because  in  going  round  from  view  to  view  the 
sculptor  uses  it  when  he  wishes  to  delineate  the  forms 
which  please  him  best,  or  which  he  intends  to  bring  out 
in  every  dimension,  whether  in  wax,  or  clay,  or  marble, 
or  wood,  or  other  material. 

In  Painting,  the  lines  are  of  service  in  many  ways,  but 
especially  in  outlining  every  figure,  because  when  they 
are  well  drawn,  and  made  correct  and  in  proportion,  the 
shadows  and  lights  that  are  then  added  give  the  strongest 
relief  to  the  lines  of  the  figure  and  the  result  is  all 
excellence  and  perfection.  Hence  it  happens,  that  whoever 
understands  and  manages  these  lines  well,  will,  with  the 
help  of  practice  and  judgement,  excel  in  each  one  of  these 
arts.  Therefore,  he  who  would  learn  thoroughly  to 
express  in  drawing  the  conceptions  of  the  mind  and  any- 
thing else  that  pleases  him,  must  after  he  has  in  some 
degree  trained  his  hand  to  make  it  more  skilful  in  the  arts, 
exercise  it  in  copying  figures  in  relief  either  in  marble 
or  stone,  or  else  plaster  casts  taken  from  the  life,  yor  from 

*  This  remark  of  Vasari  is  significant  of  the  change  in  architectural  practice 
between  the  mediaeval  and  modern  epochs.  That  the  architect  is  a  man  that 
sits  at  home  and  makes  drawings,  while  practical  craftsmen  carry  them  out, 
is  to  us  a  familiar  idea,  but  the  notion  would  greatly  have  astonished  the 
builders  of  the  French  Gothic  cathedrals  or  the  Florentines  of  the  fourteenth 
century.  In  mediaeval  practice  the  architect  was  the  master  of  the  work, 
carrying  the  "sLlieiiie  Ol  tlie  whole  in  liia  head,  •but  busy  all  the  time"  with  the 
actual  materials  and  tools,  and  directing  progress  rather  from  the  scaffolding 
than  from  the  drawing  oHice!  On  the  tombstone '  of  the  French  architect  of 
the  thirteenth  century,  Hughes  Libergier,  at  Reims,  he  is  shown  with  the 
mason's  square,  rule,  and  compasses  about  him ;  while  in  the  relief  that 
illustrates  'Building'  on  Giotto's  Campanile  at  Florence  we  see  the  master 
mason  directing  the  operations  of  the  journeymen  from  a  position  on  the 
structure  itself.  In  the  present  day  there  is  a  strong  feeling  in  the  profession 
that  this  separation  of  architect  and  craftsman,  which  dates  from  the  later 
Renaissance,  is  a  bad  thing  for  art,  and  that  the  designer  should  be  in  more 
intimate  touch  with  the  materials  and  processes  of  building. 


2o8  OF   PAINTING 

some  beautiful  antique  statue,  or  even  from  models  in 
relief  of  clay,  which  may  either  be  nude  or  clad  in  rags 
covered  with  clay  to  serve  for  clothing  and  drapery.  All 
these  objects  being  mj^innlpss  anH  withQiif  feeling,  greatly 
facilitate  the  work  of  the  artist,  because  they  stand  still, 
which  does  not  happen  in  the  case  of  live  things  that  have 
movement.  When  he  has  trained  his  hand  by  steady 
practice  in  drawing  snrh  objects,  let  him  begin  to  copy 
from  nature  and  make  a  good  and  certain  practice  herein , 
with  all  possible  labour  and  diligence,  for  the  things 
studied  from  nature  are  really/those  which  do  honour  to 
him  who  strives  to  master  them,  since  they  have  in  them- 
selves, besides  a  certain  grace  and  liveliness,  that  simple 
and  easy  sweetness  which  is  nature's  own,  and  which 
can  only  be  learned  perfectly  from  her,  and  never  to  a 
sufficient  degree  from  the  things  of  art.  Hold  it  more- 
over for  certain,  that  the  practice  that  is  acquired  by 
many  years  of  study  in  drawing,  as  has  been  said  above, 
is  the  true  light  of  design  and  that  which  makes  men 
really  proficient.  Now,  having  discoursed  long  enough 
on  this  subject  let  us  go  on  to  see  what  painting  is. 

§  76.  Of  the  Nature  of  Painting. 

A  painting,  then,  is  a  plane  covered  with  patches  of 
colour  on  the  surface- nf  wood,  wall,  or  canvas  filling  up 
the  outlines  spoken  of  above,  which,  by  virtue  of  a  good 
design  of  encompassing  lines,   surround  the  figure.^    If 

^  It  is  characteristically  Florentine  to  regard  painting  as  essentially  the  filling 
up  of  outlines,  and  to  colour  in  staccato  fashion  with  an  assorted  set  of  tints 
arranged  in  gradation.  To  the  eye  of  the  born  painter  outlines  do  not  exist 
and  nature  is  seen  in  tone  and  colour,  while  colours  are  like  the  tones  of  a 
violin  infinite  in  gradation,  not  distinct  like  the  notes  of  a  piano.  With  the 
exception  of  the  Venetians  and  some  other  North  Italians  such  as  Correggio 
and  Lotto,  the  Italians  generally  painted  by  filling  outlines  with  local  tints 
graded  as  light,  middle,  and  dark,  and  the  Florentines  were  pre-eminent  in  the 
emphasis  they  laid  on  the  well-drawn  outline  as  the  foundation  of  the  art. 
Since  the  seventeenth  century  the  general  idea  of  what  constitutes  the  art  of 
painting  has  suffered  a  change  and  Vasari's  account  of  Florentine  practice,  in 
which  he  was  himself  an  expert,  is  all  the  more  interesting.     Vasari's  point 


THE   NATURE   OF   PAINTING  209 

the  painter  treat  his  flat  surface  with  right  judgement, 
keeping  the  centre  light  and  the  edges  and  the  background 
dark  and  medium  colour  between  the  tight  and  dark  in 
thTintermediate  spaces,  the  result  of  the  rnmhTnation  of 
these  three  fields  <7f  colour  will  be  that  everything  between 
the  one  outline  and  the  other  stands  out  "and  appears 
round  and  in  relief^  It  is  indeed  true  that  these  three 
shades  cannot  suffice  for  every  object  treated  in  detail, 
therefore  it  is  necessary  to  divide  every  shade  at  least  into 
two  half  shades,  making  of  the  light  two  half  tints,  and 
of_the  dark  two  lighter,  and  of  the  medium  two  other  half 
tints  which  incline  one  to  the  lighter  and  the  other  to  the 
darker  side.  When  these  tints,  being  of  one  colour  only 
whatever  it  may  be,  are  gradated,  we  see  a  transition 
beginning  with  the  light,  and  then  the  less  light,  and  then 
a  little  darker,  so  that  little  by  little  we  find  the  pure 
blacky/tlaving  then  made  the  mixtures,  that  is,  these 
colours  mixed  together,  and  wishing  to  work  with  oil  or 
tempera  or  in  fresco,  we  proceed  to  fill  in  the  outlmes 
putting  in  their  proper  place  the  lights  and  darks/the 
half  tints  and  the  lowered  tones  of  the  half  tints  and  the 
lights.  I  mean  those  tinfeS  mixed  from  the  three  first, 
light,  medium  and  dark,/which  lights  and  medium  tints 
and  darks  and  lower  tones  are  copied  from  the  cartoon 
or  other  design  which  is  made  for  any  work  before  we 
begin  to  put  it  into  execution.  It  is  necessary  that  the 
design  be  carried  out  with  good  arrangement,  firm 
drawing,  and  judgement  and  invention,  seeing  that  the 
composition  in  a  picture  is  not  other  than  the  parcelling 
out  of  the  places  where  the  figures  come,  so  that  the  spaces 
be  not  unshapely  but  in  accordance  with  the  judgement 
of  the  eye,  while  the  field  is  in  one  place  well  covered 
and  in  another  void.     All  this  is  the  result  of  drawing 

of  view  is  that  of  the  frescoist.  In  that  process,  which,  as  we  shall  see,  had 
to  be  carried  out  swiftly  and  directly  so  as  to  be  finished  at  one  sitting,  it 
was  practically  necessary  to  have  the  various  tints  in  their  gradations  mixed 
and  ready  to  hand.  The  whole  method  and  genius  of  oil-painting,  as  moderns 
understand  it,  is  different,  and  its  processes  much  more  varied  and  subtle. 

O 


2IO  OF   PAINTING 

and  of  having  copied  figures  from  the  life,  or  from  models 
of  figures  made  to  represent  anything  one  wishes  to  malce. 
Design  cannot  have  a  good  origin  if  it  have  not  come 
from  continual  practice  in  copying  natural  objects,  and 
from  the  study  of  pictures  by  excellent  masters  and  of 
ancient  statues  in  relief,/  as  has  been  said  many  times- 
But  above  all,  the  best  thing  is  to  draw  men  and  women 
from  the  nude  and  thus  fix  in  the  memnry  by  rnnstant 
exercise  the  muscles  of  the  torso,  back,  legs,  arms,  and 
knees,  with  the  bones  underneath.  Then  one  may  be 
sure  that  through  much  study  attitudes  in  any  position 
can  be  drawn  by  help  of  the  imagination  without  one's 
having  the  living  forms  in  view.  Again  having  seen 
human  bodies  dissected  one  knows  how  the  bones  lie, 
and  the  muscles  and  sinews,  and  all  the  order  and  con- 
ditions of  anatomy,  so  that  it  is  possible  with  greater 
security  and  more  correctness  to  place  the  limbs  and 
arrange  the  muscles  of  the  body  in  the  figures  we  draw/ 
And  those  who  have  this  knowledge  will  certainly  draw 
the  outlines  of  the  figures  perfectly,  and  these,  when  drawn 
as  they  ought  to  be,  show  a  pleasing  grace  and  beautiful 
style. 

He  who  studies  good  painting  and  sculpture,  and  at 
the  same  time  sees  and  understands  the  life,  must  neces- 
sarily have  acquired  a  good  method  in  art.  Hence  springs 
the  invention  which  groups  figures  in  fours,  sixes,  tens, 
twenties,  in  such  a  manner  as  to  represent  battles  and 
other  great  subjects  of  art.  This  invention  demands  an 
innate  propriety  springing  out  of  harmony  and  obedience; 
thus  if  a  figure  move  to  greet  another,  the  figure  saluted 
having  to  respond  should  not  turn  away.  As  with  this 
example,  so  it  is  with  all  the  rest.  The  subject  may  offer 
many  varied  motives  different  one  from  another,  but  the 
motives  chosen  must  always  bear  relation  to  the  work  in 
hand,  and  to  what  the  artist  is  in  process  of  representing. 
He  ought  to  distinguish  between  different  movements  and 
characteristics,  making  the  women  with  a  sweet  and 
beautiful   air   and   also   the   youths,   but   the   old  always 


THE   NATURE   OF   PAINTING  211 

grave  of  aspect,  and  especially  the  priests  and  persons  in 
authority.  He  must  always  take  care  however,  that  every-; 
thing  is  in  relation  to  the  work  as  a  whole;  so  that  when 
the  picture  is  looked  at,  one  can  recognize  in  it  a  har- 
monious unity,  wherein  the  passions  strike  terror,  and  the 
pleasing  effects  shed  sweetness,  representing  directly  the 
intention  of  the  painter,  and  not  the  things  he  had  no 
thought  of.  It  is  requisite  therefore,  for  this  purpose, 
that  he  form  the  figures  which  have  to  be  spirited  with 
movement  and  vigour,  and  that  he  make  those  which 
are  distant  to  retire  from  the  principal  figures  by  means 
of  shade  and  colour  that  gradually  and  softly  become  lower 
in  tone.  Thus  the  art  will  always  be  associated  with  the 
grace  of  naturalness  and  of  delicate  charm  of  colour,  and 
the  work  be  brought  to  perfection  not  with  the  stress  of 
cruel  suffering,  so  that  men  who  look  at  it  have  to  endure 
pain  on  account  of  the  suffering  which  they  see  has  been 
borne  by  the  artist  in  his  work,  but  rather  with  rejoicing 
at  his  good  fortune  in  that  his  hand  has  received  from 
heaven  the  lightness  of  movement  which  shows  his  paint- 
ing to  be  worked  out  with  study  and  toil  certainly,  but 
not  with  drudgery;  so  will  it  be  that  the  figures,  every 
one  in  its  place,  will  not  appear  dead  to  him  who  observes 
them,  but  alive  and  true.  Let  painters  avoid  crudities, 
let  it  be  their  endeavour  that  the  things  they  are  always 
producing  shall  not  seem  painted,  but  show  themselves 
alive  and  starting  out  of  the  canvas.  This  is  the  secret 
of  sound  design  and  the  true  method  recognized  by  him 
who  has  painted  as  belonging  to  the  pictures  that  are 
known  and  judged  to  be  good. 


CHAPTER   II.    (XVI.) 

Of  Sketches,  Drawings,  Cartoons,  and  Schemes  of  Perspective  ;   how 
they  are  made,  and  to  what  use  they  are  put  by  the  Painters. 

§  77.  Sketches,  Drawings,  and  Cartoons  of  different 
kinds. 

Sketches,  of  which  mention  has  been  made  above,  are 
in  artists'  language  a  sort  of  first  drawing  made  to  find 
out  the  manner  of  the  pose,  and  the  first  composition  of 
the  work.  They  are  made  in  the  form  of  a  blotch, 
and  are  put  down  by  us  only  as  a  rough  draft  of 
the  whole.  Out  of  the  artist's  impetuous  mood  they  are 
hastily  thrown  off,  with  pen  or  other  drawing  instru- 
ment or  with  charcoal,  only  to  test  the  spirit  of  that 
which  occurs  to  him,  and  for  this  reason  we  call  them 
sketches.  From  these  come  afterwards  the  drawings 
executed  in  a  more  finished  manner,  in  the  doing  of  which 
the  artist  tries  with  all  possible  diligence  to  copy  from 
the  life,  if  he  do  not  feel  himself  strong  enough  to  be 
able  to  produce  them  from  his  own  knowledge.  Later 
on,  having  measured  them  with  the  compasses  or  by  the 
eye,  he  enlarges  from  the  small  to  a  larger  size  according 
to  the  work  in  hand.  Drawings  are  made  in  various 
materials,^    that    is,    either    with    red    chalk,    which    is 

^The  innumerable  sketches  and  finished  drawings  that  have  come  down  to 
us  from  the  hands  of  Florentine  artists  testify  to  the  importance  given  in 
the  school  to  preliminary  studies  for  painting,  and  any  collection  will  furnish 
examples  of  the  different  methods  of  execution  here  described.  Drawings  by 
Venetian  masters,  who  felt  in  colour  rather  than  In  form,  are  not  so  numerous 
or  so  elaborate. 


SKETCHES,  DRAWINGS,  AND   CARTOONS      213 

a  stone  coming  from  the  mountains  of  Germany,  soft 
enough  to'  be  easily  sawn  and  reduced  to  a  fine  point 
suitable  for  marking  on  leaves  of  paper  in  any  way  you 
wish;  or  with  black  chalk  that  comes  from  the  hills  of 
France,  which  is  of  the  same  nature  as  the  red.  Other 
drawings  in  light  and  shade  are  executed  on  tinted  paper 
which  gives  a  middle  shade;  the  pen  marks  the  outlines, 
that  is,  the  contour  or  profile,  and  afterwards  half-tone 
or  shadow  is  given  with  ink  mixed  with  a  little  water 
which  produces  a  delicate  tint :  further,  with  a  fine  brush 
dipped  in  white  lead  mixed  with  gum,  the  high  lights 
are  added.  This  method  is  very  pictorial,  and  best  shows 
the  scheme  of  colouring.  Many  work  with  the  pen 
alone,  leaving  the  paper  for  the  lights,  which  is  difficult 
but  in  effect  most  masterly;  and  innumerable  other 
methods  are  practised  in  drawing,  of  which  it  is  not  needful 
to  make  mention,  because  all  represent  the  same  thing, 
that  is  drawing. 

The  designs  having  been  made  in  this  way,  the  artist 
who  wishes  to  work  in  fresco,  that  is,  on  the  wall,  must 
make  cartoons;  many  indeed  prepare  them  even  for 
working  on  panel.  The  cartoons  are  made  thus  :  sheets 
of  paper,  I  mean  square  sheets,  are  fastened  together  with 
paste  made  of  flour  and  water  cooked  on  the  fire.  They 
are  attached  to  the  wall  by  this  paste,  which  is  spread 
two  fingers'  breadth  all  round  on  the  side  next  the  wall, 
and  are  damped  all  over  by  sprinkling  cold  water  on 
them.  In  this  moist  state  they  are  stretched  so  that 
the  creases  are  smoothed  out  in  the  drying.  Then 
when  they  are  dry  the  artist  proceeds,  with  a  long  rod, 
having  a  piece  of  charcoal  at  the  end,  to  transfer  to  the 
cartoon  (in  enlarged  proportions),  to  be  judged  of  at  a 
distance,  all  that  in  the  small  drawing  is  shown  on  the 
small  scale.  In  this  manner  little  by  little  he  finishes, 
now  one  figure  and  now  another.  At  this  point  the 
painters  go  through  all  the  processes  of  their  art  in  repro- 
ducing their  nudes  from  the  life,  and  the  drapery  from 
nature,  and  they  draw  the  perspectives  in  the  same  schemes 


214  OF   PAINTING 

that  have  been  adopted  on  a  small  scale  in  the  first  drawing, 
enlarging  them  in  proportion. 

If  in  these  there  should  be  perspective  views,  or 
buildings,  these  are  enlarged  with  the  net,  which  is  a 
lattice  of  small  squares  that  are  made  large  on  the  cartoon, 
reproducing  everything  correctly,  for  of  course  when  the 
artist  has  drawn  out  the  perspectives  in  the  small  designs, 
taking  them  from  the  plan  and  setting  up  the  elevations 
with  the  right  contours,  and  making  the  lines  diminish 
and  recede  by  means  of  the  intersections  and  the  vanishing 
point,  he  must  reproduce  them  in  proportion  on  the 
cartoon.  But  I  do  not  wish  to  speak  further  of  the  mode 
of  drawing  these  out,  because  it  is  a  wearisome  theme 
and  difficult  to  explain.  It  is  enough  to  say  that  per- 
spectives are  beautiful  in  so  far  as  they  appear  correct 
when  looked  at,  and  diminish  as  they  retire  from  the  eye, 
and  when  they  are  composed  of  a  varied  and  beautiful 
scheme  of  buildings.  The  painter  must  take  care  too, 
to  make  them  diminish  in  proportion  by  means  of  delicate 
gradations  of  colour  that  presuppose  in  the  artist  correct 
discretion  and  good  judgement.^  The  need  of  this  is 
shown  in  the  difficulty  of  the  many  confused  lines  gathered 
from  the  plan,  the  profile,  and  the  intersection ;  but  when 
covered  with  colour  everything  becomes  clear,  and  in 
consequence  the  artist  gains  a  reputation  for  skill  and 
understanding  and  ingenuity  in  his  art. 

Many  masters  also  before  making  the  composition  on 
the  cartoon,  adopt  the  plan  of  fashioning  a  model  in  clay 
on  a  plane  and  of  setting  up  all  the  figures  in  the  round 
to  see  the  projections,^  that  is,  the  shadows  caused  by  a 
light  being  thrown  on  to  the  figures,  which  projections 
correspond  to  the  shadow  cast  by  the  sun,  that  more 
sharply  than  any  artificial  light  defines  the  figures  by  shade 
on  the  ground ;  and  so  portraying  the  whole  of  the  work, 
they  have  marked  the  shadows  that  strike  across  now  one 

'That  is  to  say,  by  observation  of  aerial  as  well  as  linear  perspective. 
'  This  practice  is  noticed  in  the  case  of  more  than  one  artist  of  whom  Vasari 
lias  written  the  biography.     Tintoretto  is  one.     See  also  postea,  p.  216. 


THE   USE   OF   CARTOONS  215 

figure,  now  another,  whence  it  comes  that  on  account  of 
the  pains  taken  the  cartoons  as  well  as  the  work  reach  the 
most  finished  perfection  and  strength,  and  stand  out  from 
the  paper  in  relief.  All  this  shows  the  whole  to  be  most 
beautiful  and  highly  finished. 

§  7^  The  Use  of  Cartoons  in  Mural  and  Panel  Painting. 

/^When  these  cartoons  are  used  for  fresco  or  wall  painting, 
every  day  at  the.  junction  with  yesterday's  work  a  piece 
of  the  cartoon  is  cut  off  and  traced  on  the  wall,  which 
must  be  plastered  afresh  and  perfectly  smoothed.*  This 
piece  of  cartoon  is  put  on  the  spot  where  the  figure  is  to 
be,  and  is  marked;  so  that  next  day,  when  another  piece 
comes  to  be  added,  its  exact  place  may  be  recognized, 
and  no  error  can  arise.  Afterwards,  for  transferring  the 
outlines  on  to  the  said  piece,  the  artist  proceeds  to  impress 
them  with  an  iron  stylus  upon  the  coat  of  plaster,  which, 
being  fresh,  yields  to  the  paper  and  thus  remains  marked. 
He  then  removes  the  cartoon  and  by  means  of  those  marks 
traced  on  the  wall  goes  on  to  work  with  colours;  this 
then  is  how  work  in  fresco  or  on  the  wall  is  carried  out. 
The  same  tracing  is  done  on  panels  and  on  canvas,  bilt 
in  this  case  the  cartoon  is  all  in  one  piece,  the  only 
difference  being  that  it  is  necessary  to  rub  the  back  of 
the  cartoon  with  charcoal  or  black  powder,  so  that  when 
marked  afterwards  with  the  instrument  it  may  transmit 
the  outlines  and  tracings  to  the  canvas  or  panel.  The 
cartoons  are  made  in  order  to  secure  that  the  work  shall 
be  carried  out  exactly  and  in  due  proportion.  There  are 
many  painters  who  for  work  in  oil  will  omit  all  this ;  but 
for  fresco  work  it  must  be  done  and  cannot  be  avoided. 
Certainly  the  man  who  found  out  such  an  invention  had 
a  good  notion,  since  in  the  cartoons  one  sees  the  effect 
of  the  work  as  a  whole  and  these  can  be  adjusted  and 
altered  until  they  are  right,  which  cannot  be  done  on  the 
work  itself. 

■*  See  the  Note  on  '  Fresco  Painting '  at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction '  to 
Painting,  postea,  p.  287. 


CHAPTER   III.     (XVII.) 

Of  the  Foreshortening  of  Figures  looked  at  from  beneath,  and  of 
those  on  the  Level. 

§  79.  Foreshortenings. 

Our  artists  have  had  the  greatest  skill  in  foreshortening 
figures,  that  is,  in  making!^  them  appear  larger  than  they 
really  are;  a  foreshortening  being  to  us  a  thing  drawn 
in  shortened  view,  which  seeming  to  the  eye  to  project 
forward  has  not  the  length  or  height  that  it  appears  to 
have;  however,  the  mass,  outlines,  shadows,  and  lights 
make  it  seem  to  come  forward  and  for  this  reason  it 
is  called  foreshortened.  Never  was  there  painter  or 
draughtsman  that  did  better  work  of  this  sort  than  our 
Michelagnolo  Buonarroti,^  and  even  yet  no  one  has  been 
able  to  surpass  him,  he  has  made  his  figures  stand  out  so 
marvellously.  For  this  work  he  first  made  models  in  clay 
or  wax,  and  from  these,  because  they  remain  stationary, 
he  took  the  outlines,  the  lights,  and  the  shadows,  rather 
than  from  the  living  model.  These  foreshortenings 
give  the  greatest  trouble  to  him  who  does  not  understand 
them  because  his  intelligence  does  not  help  him  to  reach 
the  depth  of  such  a  difficulty,  to  overcome  which  is  a 
more  formidable  task  than  any  other  in  painting. 
Certainly  our  old  painters,  as  lovers  of  the  art,  found  the 
solution  of  the  difficulty  by  usinpf  1ine.s   in    perspprtuiR, 

1  Michelangelo's  greatest  (our  de  force  in  foreshortening,  much  lauded  by 
Vasari  in  his  Life  of  the  master,  is  the  figure  of  the  prophet  Jonah  on  the 
end  wall  of  the  Sistine  chapel.  It  is  painted  at  the  springing  of  the  vault,  on 
a  surface  that  is  inclined  sharply  towards  the  spectator,  but  the  figure  is  so 
drawn  as  to  appear  to  be  leaning  back  in  the  opposite  direction. 


FORESHORTENINGS  217 

a  thing  never  done  before,  and  made  therein  so  much 
progress  that  to-day  there  is  true  mastery  in  the  execu- 
tion of  forpshortenings.  Those  who  censure  the  method 
of  foreshortening,  I  speak  of  our  artists,  are  those  who 
do  not  know  how  to  employ  it;  and  for  the  sake  of 
exalting  themselves  go  on  lowering  others.  We  have 
however  a  considerable  number  of  master  painters  who, 
although  skilful,  do  not  take  pleasure  in  making  fore- 
shortened figures,  and  yet  when  they  see  how  beautiful 
they  are  and  how  difficult,  they  not  only  do  not  censure 
but  praise  them  highly.  Of  these  foreshortenings  the 
moderns  have  given  us  some  examples  which  are  to  the 
point  and  difficult  enough,  as  for  instance  in  a  vault  the 
figures  which  look  upwards,  are  foreshortened  and  retire. 
We  call  these  foreshortenings  '  al  di  sotto  in  su  '  (in  the 
'  up  from  below  '  style),  and  they  have  such  force  that 
they  pierce  the  vaults.  These  cannot  be  executed  without 
study  from  the  life,  or  from  models  at  suitable  heights, 
else  the  attitudes  and  movements  of  such  things  cannot  be 
caught.  And  certainly  the  difficulty  in  this  kind  of  work 
calls  forth  the  highest  grace  as  well  as  great  beauty,  and 
results  in  something  stupendous  in  art.  You  will  find, 
in  the  Lives  of  our  Artists,  that  they  have  given  very  great 
salience  to  works  of  this  kind,  and  laboured  to  complete 
them  perfectly,  whence  they  have  obtained  great  praise. 
The  foreshortenings  from  beneath  upwards  (di  sotto  in  su) 
are  so  named  because  the  object  represented  is  pIpvatpH 
and  looked  at  by  the  eye  raised  upwards,  and  is  not  on 
the  level  line  of  the  horizon  :  wherefore  because  one  must 
raise  the  head  in  the  wish  to  see  them,  and  perceives  first 
the  soles  of  the  feet  and  the  other  lower  parts  we  find  the 
said  name  justly  chosen^^ 

^Correggio  is  responsible  for  many  of  the  forced  effects  of  drawing  in  the 
decorative  painting  of  vaults  and  ceilings  in  later  times,  but  the  Umbrian 
Melozzo  da  Fori!  in  his  painting  of  the  Ascension  of  Christ,  now  destroyed 
save  for  the  fragments  in  the  Quirinal  and  in  the  sacristy  of  St.  Peter's  at 
Rome,  may  have  the  doubtful  honour  of  beginning  the  practice  of  foreshortening 
a  whole  composition,  so  that  the  scene  is  painted  as  it  would  appear  were 
we  looking  up  at  it  from  underneath. 


CHAPTER   IV.     (XVIII.) 

How  Colours  in  oil  painting,  in  fresco,  or  in  tempera  should  be  blended  : 
and  how  the  Flesh,  the  Draperies  and  all  that  is  depicted  come  to 
be  harmonized  in  the  work  in  such  a  manner  that  the  figures  do 
not  appear  cut  up,  and  stand  out  well  and  forcibly  and  show  the 
work  to  be  clear  and  comprehensible. 

§  80.  On  Colouring. 

TTnttv  \r\   paintings  is  prnHnrpH  whpn   a  varipty  of  different 

colours  pre-  harmnniypH  tngpthprj  these  colours  in  all  the 
diversity  of  many  designs  show  the  parts  of  the  figures 
distinct  the  one  from  the  other^  as  the  flesh  from  the  hair, 
and  one  garment  different  in  colour  from  another.  When 
Ahese  colours  are  laid  on  flashing  and  vivid  in  a  disagree- 
able discordance  so  that  they  are  like  stains  and  loaded 
Vith  body,  as  was  formerly  tlie  wont  with  some  painters, 
the  design  becomes  marred/in  such  a  manner  that  the 
figures  are  left  painted  by  the  patches  of  colour  rather 
than  by  the  brush,  which  distributes  the  light  and  shade 
over  the.figures  and  makes  them  appear  natural  and  in 
.relief.  ^^11  pictures  then  whether  in  oil,  in  fresco,  or  in 
tempem  ought  to  be  so  blended  in  their  colours  that  the 
principal  figures  in  the  groups  are  brought  out  with  the 
utmost  clearness,  jthe.  draperies  of  those  in  front  being 
kept  so  light  that  the  figures  which  stand  behind  are 
darker  than  the  first,  and  so  little  by  little  as  the  figures 
retire  inwards7  they  become  also  in  equal  measure  gradu- 
ally lower  in  tone  in  the  colour  both  of  the  flesh  tints 
and  of  the  vestments.  And  especially  let  there  be  great 
care  always  in  putting  the  most  attractive,  the  most 
charming,  and  the  most  beautiful  colours  on  the  principal 
figures,  and  above  all  on  those  that  are  complete  and  not 


COLOURING  219 

cut  off  bv  others,  because  these  are  always  the  most  con- 
^jTirnnus  and  are  more  looked  at  than  others  which  serve 
ac  f^p  harlfgrniinri   tn  the  colouring  of  the  former.     A 
§aliaw. -Golour^ makes,  another  whirh   is--placfi.d-bgsjde   it 
agpear-the-more -Lively,  and  melancholy  and  pallid  colours 
make  those  near  then/very  cheerful  and  almost  of  a  certain 
flaming  beauty.^  ^^or  ought  one  to  clothe  the  nude  with 
heavy   colours   tnat   would    make   too   sharp    a    division 
between  the  flesh  and  the  draperies  when  the  said  draperies 
pass  across  the  nude  figures,  but  let  the  colours  of  the 
lights  of  the  drapery  be  delicate  and  similar  to  the  tints 
of  the  flesh,  either  yellowish  or  reddish,  violet  or  purple, 
making  the   depths   either   green   or  blue   or   purple   or 
yellow,  provided  that  they  tend  to  a  dark  shade  and  make 
a  harmonious  sequence   in   the   rounding  of  the  figures 
with  their  shadows;   just  as  we  see  in  the  life,  that  those 
parts  that  appear  nearest  to  our  eyes,   have  most  light 
and  the  others,  retiring  from  view,  lose  light  and  colourv/' 
In  the  same  manner  the  colours  should  be  employed 
with  so  much  harmony  that  a  dark  and  a  light  are  not 
left  unpleasantly  contrasted  in  light  and  shade,  so  as  to 
create  a  discordance   and  a  disagreeable   lack  of   unity, 
save  only  in  the  case  of  the  projections,  which  are  those 
shadows  that  the  figures  throw  one  on  to  the  other,  when 
a  ray  of  light  strikes  on  a  principal  figure,  and  makes  it 
darken  the  second  with  its  projected  shadow.     And  these 
again  when  they  occur  must  be  painted  with  sweetness 
and  harmony,  because  he  who  throws  them  into  disorder 
makes  that  picture  look  like  a  coloured  carpet  or  a  handful 
of  playing  cards,  rather  than  blended  flesh  or  soft  clothing 
or  other  things  that  are  light,  delicate,  and  sweet.     For  as 
the  ear  remains  offended  by  a  strain  of  music  that  is  noisy, 
jarring  or  hard — save  however  in  certain  places  and  times, 

'This  truth,  about  the  mutual  influence  of  colours  in  juxtaposition,  was 
well  put  by  Sir  Charles  Eastlake  when  he  wrote,  in  his  Materials  for  a 
History  of  Oil  Painting,  '  flesh  is  never  more  glowing  than  when  opposed 
to  blue,  never  more  pearly  than  when  compared  with  red,  never  ruddier  than 
in  the  neighbourhood  of  green,  never  fairer  than  when  contrasted  with  black, 
nor  richer  or  deeper  than  when  opposed  to  white.' 


220  OF   PAINTING 

as  I  said  of  the  strong  shadows — so  the  eye  is  offended 
by  colours  that  are  overcharged  or  crude.  As  the  too 
fiery  mars  the  design ;  so  the  dim,  sallow,  flat,  and  over- 
delicate  makes  a  thing  appear  quenched,  old,  and  smoke- 
dried;  but  the  concord  that  is  established  between  the 
fiery  and  the  flat  tone  is  perfect  and  delights  the  eye  just 
as  harmonious  and  subtle  music  delights  the  ear.  Certain 
parts  of  the  figures  must  be  lost  in  the  obscure  tints  and 
in  the  background  of  the  group;  for,  if  these  parts  were 
to  appear  too  vivid  and  fiery,  they  would  confound  the 
distinction  between  the  figures,  but  by  remaining  dark 
and  hazy  almost  as  background  they  give  even  greater 
force  to  the  others  which  are  in  front.  Nor  can  one  believe 
how  much  grace  and  beauty  is  given  to  the  work  by 
varying  the  colours  of  the  flesh,  making  the  complexion 
of  the  young  fresher  than  that  of  the  old,  giving  to  the 
middle-aged  a  tint  between  a  brick-colour  and  a  greenish 
yellow ;  and  almost  in  the  same  way  as  in  drawing  one 
contrasts  the  mien  of  the  old  with  that  of  youths  and  young 
girls  and  children,  so  the  sight  of  one  face  soft  and  plump, 
and  another  fresh  and  blooming,  makes  in  the  painting 
a  most  harmonious  dissonance. 

In  this  way  one  ought,  in  working,  to  jTijt  the  Hajjf 
tints  where  thev  are  least  ronspjcuous  and  make  least 
division,  in  order  to  bring  nut  the  fignrpg,  ag  |<5  seen  in 
the  pictures  of  Raffaello  da  UrMao  and  of  other  excellent 
painters  who  have  followed  this  manner.  One  ought  not 
however  to  hold  to  this  rule  in  the  groups  where  the  lights 
imitate  those  of  the  sun  and  moon  or  of  fires  or  bright 
things  at  night,  because  these  effects  are  produced  by 
means  of  hard  and  sharp  contrasts  as  happens  in  life. 
And  in  the  upper  part,  wherever  such  a  light  may  strike 
there  will  always  be  sweetness  and  harmony.  One  can 
recognize  in  those  pictures  which  possess  these  qualities 
that  the  intelligence  of  the  painter  has  by  the  harmony 
of  his  colours  assured  the  excellence  of  the  design,  given 
charm  to  the  picture,  and  prominence  and  stupendous 
force  to  the  figures. 


Plaie  X 


DIAGRAM 
to  illustrate 
Alberti's 
method  of 
measurement 


INTERIOR  OF  A  SCULPTOR'S  STUDIO  IN  THE  EIGHTEENTH  CENTURY 
With  illustrations  of  methods  of  measurement 


CHAPTER   V.     (XIX.) 

Of  Painting  on  the  Wall,  how  it  is  done,  and  why  it  is  called 
Working  in  Fresco. 

§  8i.  The  Fresco  process. 

Of  all  the  methods  that  painters  employ,  painting  on  the 
wall  is  the  most  masterly  and  beautiful,  because  it  consists 
in  doing  in  a  single  day  that  which,  in  the  other  methods, 
may  be  retouched  day  after  day,  over  the  work  already 
done.  Fresco  was  much  used  among  the  ancients,^  and 
the  older  masters  among  the  moderns  have  continued  to 
employ  it.  It  is  worked  on  the  plaster  while  it  is  fresh 
and  must  not  be  left  till  the  day's  portion  is  finished.  The 
reason  is  that  if  there  be  any  delay  in  painting,  tjie  plaster 
forms  a  certain  slight  r.rii.st  whether  from  heat  nr  cold 
nr  riirrprntt!  nf  air  nr  ffost  whereby  the  whole  work  is 
Stained  and  grows  mouldx.  To  prevent  this  the  wall  that 
is  to  be  painted .  must  be  kept  continually  moist ;  and 
the  colours  employed  thereon  must  all  be  of  earths  and 
not  metallic  and  the  white  of  calcined  travertine.^  There 
is  needed  also  a  hand  that  is  dexterous,  resolute  and  rapid, 
but  most  of  all  a  sound  and  perfect  judgement ;  because 
while  the  wall  is  wet  the  colours  show  up  in  one  fashion, 
and  afterwards  when  dry  they  are  no  longer  the  same. 

'Vitruvius  describes  the  fresco  process  in  his  seventh  Book.  See  Note  on 
'  Fresco  Painting '  at  the  end  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Painting,  postea,  p.  287. 
This  chapter  is  one  of  the  most  interesting  in  the  three  '  Introductions.' 

^Travertine,  next  to  marble,  makes  when  burnt  the  whitest  lime  (see  §  30, 
ante,  p.  86).  From  this  lime  the  fresco  white,  called  bianco  Sangiovanni,  is 
made,  and  Cennini  gives  the  recipe  for  its  preparation  in  his  s8th  chapter. 
The  ordinary  lead  white  (biacca)  cannot  be  used  in  fresco. 


222  OF   PAINTING 

Therefore  in  these  works  done  in  fresco  it  is  necessary 
that  the  judgement  of  the  painter  should  play  a  more 
important  part  than  his  drawing,  and  that  he  should  have 
for  his  guide  the  very  greatest  experience,  it  being 
supremely  difficult  to  bring  fresco  work  to  perfection. 
Many  of  our  artists  excel  in  the  other  kinds  of  work,  that 
is,  in  oil  or  in  tempera,  but  in  this  do  not  succeed,  fresco 
being  truly  the  most  manly,  most  certain,  most  resolute 
and  durable  of  all  the  other  methods,  and  as  time  goes 
on  it  continually  acquires  infinitely  more  beauty  and 
harmony  than  do  the  others.  Exposed  to  the  air  fresco 
throws  off  all  impurities,  water  does  not  penetrate  it,  and 
it  resists  anything  that  would  injure  it.  But  beware  of 
having  to  retouch  it  with  colours  that  contain  size  pre- 
pared from  parchment,  or  the  yolk  of  egg,  or  gum  or 
tragacanth,  as  many  painters  do,  for  besides  preventing 
the  wall  from  showing  up  the  work  in  all  clearness,  the 
colours  become  clouded  by  that  retouching  and  in  a  short 
time  turn  black.  Therefore  let  those  who  desire  to  work 
on  the  wall  work  boldly  in  fresco  and  not  retouch  in  the 
dry,  because,  besides  being  a  very  poor  thing  in  itself,  it 
renders  the  life  of  the  pictures  short,  as  has  been  said 
in  another  place. 


CHAPTER  VI.    (XX.) 

Of  Painting  in  Tempera,'  or  with  egg,  on  Panel  or  Canvas,  and  how 
it  is  employed  on  the  wall  which  is  dry. 

§  82.  Painting  in  Tempera. 

Before  the  time  of  Cimabue  and  from  that  time  onwards, 
worlis  done  by  the  Greeks  in  tempera  on  panel  and 
occasionally  on  the  wall  have  always  been  seen.  And 
these  old  masters  when  they  laid  the  gesso  ground  on 

'  The  word  '  tempera '  is  used  by  Vasari  and  other  writers  as  a  noun 
meaning  (i)  a  substance  mixed  with  another,  as  a  medium  with  pigments  (2) 
a  liquid  in  which  hot  steel  is  plunged  to  give  it  a  particular  molecular  quality 
(ante,  p.  30)  (3)  the  quality  thus  given  to  the  steel  (ante,  p.  32),  while  (4) 
it  has  come  to  mean  in  modern  times,  as  in  the  heading  of  this  Note,  a 
particular  kind  of  painting.  It  is  really  to  be  regarded  as  the  imperative  of 
the  verb  'temperare,'  which  alike  in  Latin  and  in  Italian  means  'to  divide 
or  proportion  duly,'  'to  qualify  by  mixing,'  and  generally  'to  regulate'  or  'to 
discipline.'  'Tempera'  thus  means  strictly  'mix'  or  'regulate.'  It  is  used 
in  the  latter  sense  in  metallurgy,  as  the  liquid  which  Vasari  calls  (ante,  p.  30) 
a  'tempera'  (translated  ' tempering-bath ')  regulates  the  amount  of  hardness  or 
elasticity  required  in  the  metal,  and  the  quaUty  the  steel  thus  receives  is 
called  (ante,  p.  32)  its  'temper.'  In  the  case  of  painting  the  ' tempera '  is  the 
binding  material  mixed  with  the  pigment  to  secure  its  adhesion  to  the  ground 
when  it  is  Hrv.  The  painting  process  is,  in  Italian,  painting  'a  tempera'  'with 
a  mixture, '  and  our  expression  '  tempera  painting '  is  a  loose  one.  For  the 
form  of  the  word  we  may  compare  'recipe,'  also  employed  as  a  substantive 
but  really  an  imperative  meaning  'take.' 

Strictly  speaking  any  medium  mixed  with  pigments  makes  the  process  one 
'a  tempera.'  Many  substances  may  be  thus  used,  some  soluble  in  water,  as 
size,  gum,  honey,  and  the  like ;  others  insoluble  in  water,  such  as  drying  oils, 
varnishes,  resins,  etc.,  while  the  inside  of  an  egg  which  is  in  great  part 
oleaginous  may  have  a  place  between.  It  is  not  the  usage  however  to  apply 
the  term  '  tempera '  to  drying  oils  or  varnishes,  and  a  distinction  is  always  made 
between  'tempera  painting'  and  "oil  painting.'  See  Note  on  'Tempera 
Fainting,'  postea,  p.  291. 


224  OF   PAINTING 

their  panels,  fearing  lest  they  should  open  at  the  joints, 
were  accustomed  to  cover  them  all  over  with  linen  cloth 
attached  with  glue  of  parchment  shreds,  and  then  above 
that  they  put  on  the  gesso  to  make  their  working  ground.^ 
They  then  mixed  the  colours  thev  were  going  to  use  with 
the  yolk  of  an  egg  or  tempera.^  of  the  following  kind. 
They  whisked  up  an  egg  and  shredded  into  it  a  tender 
branch  of  a  fig  tree,  in  order  that  the  milk  of  this  with 
the  egg  should  make  the  tempera  of  the  colours,  which 
after  being  mixed  with  this  medium  were  ready  for  use. 
They  chose  for  these  panels  mineral  colours  of  which  some 
are  made  by  the  chemists  and  some  found  in  the  mines. 
And  for  this  kind  of  work  all  pigments  are  good,  except 
the  white  used  for  work  on  walls  made  with  lime,  for 
that  is  too  strong.  In  this  manner  their  works  and  their 
pictures  are  executed,  and  this  they  call  colouring  in 
tempera.  But  the  blues  are  mixed  with  parchment  size, 
because  the  yellow  of  the  egg  would  turn  them  green 
whereas  size  does  not  affect  them,  nor  does  gum.  The 
same  method  is  followed  on  panels  whether  with  or  without 
a  gesso  ground;  and  thus  on  walls  when  they  are  dry 
the  artist  gives  one  or  two  coats  of  hot  size,  and  afterwards 
with  colours  mixed  with  that  size  he  carries  out  the  whole 
work.  The  process  of  mixing  colours  with  size  is  easy 
if  what  has  been  related  of  tempera  be  observed.  Nor 
will  the  colours  suffer  for  this  since  there  are  yet  seen 
things  in  tempera  by  our  old  masters  which  have  been 

I  ^This  practice  of  covering  wooden  panels  with  linen  and  laying  over  this 
the  gesso  painting  ground  was  in  use  in  ancient  Egypt.  In  fact  the  methods 
described  by  Cennini  of  preparing  and  grounding  panels  are  almost  exactly 
the  same  as  those  used  in  ancient  Egypt  for  painting  wooden  mummy-cases. 
Even  the  practice,  so  much  used  in  early  Italian  art,  of  modelling  details  and 
ornaments  in  relief  in  gesso  and  gilding  them,  is  common  on  the  mummy- 
cases.     On  the  subject  of  gesso  see  Note  5  on  p.  249. 

'Vasari's  expression  'rosso  dell'  uovo  o  tempera,  la  quale  e  questa'  calls 
attention  to  the  fact,  to  which  his  language  generally  bears  testimony,  that  he 
looked  upon  the  yolk  of  egg  medium  as  the  tempera  par  excellence.  When  he 
uses  the  term  'tempera'  alone  he  has  the  egg  medium  in  his  mind,  and  the 
size  medium  is  something  apart.     See  this  chapter  throughout. 


PAINTING   IN   TEMPERA  225 

preserved  in  great  beauty  and  freshness  for  hundreds  of 
years.*  And  certainly  one  still  sees  things  of  Giotto's, 
some  even  on  panel,  that  have  already  lasted  two  hundred 
years  and  are  preserved  in  very  good  condition.  Working 
in  oil  has  come  later,  and  this  has  made  many  put  aside 
the  method  of  tempera  :  in  so  much  that  to-day  we  see 
that  the  oil  medium  has  been,  and  still  is,  continually 
used  for  panel  pictures  and  other  works  of  importance. 

^Tempera  painting  has  had  a  far  longer  history  and  more  extensive  use 
than  any  other  kind.  The  technique  predominated  for  all  kinds  of  painting 
among  the  older  Oriental  peoples  and  in  classical  lands,  and  was  in  use  both 
on  walls  and  on  panels  in  Western  Europe  north  of  the  Alps  during  the  whole 
mediaeval  period,  while  south  of  the  Alps  and  at  Byzantium  it  was  to  a  great 
extent  superseded  for  mural  painting  by  firesco,  but  remained  in  fashion  for  panels 
till  the  end  of  the  fifteenth  century.  After  the  fifteenth  century  the  oil  medium, 
as  Vasari  remarks,  superseded  it  entirely  for  portable  pictures,  and  partly  for  work 
on  walls  and  ceilings,  but  in  our  own  time  there  has  been  a  partial  revival  of 
the  old  technique.     See  Note  on  'Tempera  Painting,'  postea,  p.  291. 

The  whole  question  of  the  diflferent  vehicles  and  methods  used  in  painting 
at  various  periods  is  a  difficult  and  complicated  one,  and  too  often  chemical 
analysis  fails  to  give  satisfactory  results  owing  to  the  small  amount  of  material 
available  for  experiment.  Berger,  in  his  Beitrage  zur  Entvdcklungs-Geschichte 
der  Maltecknik,  an  unfinished  work  that  has  already  run  to  a  thousand  pages, 
goes  elaborately  into  the  subject,  but  has  to  admit  that  many  points  are  still 
doubtful.  It  makes  comparatively  little  difference  what  particular  medium  is 
used  in  tempera  painting,  but  it  is  of  great  importance  to  decide  whether  a 
particular  class  of  work  is  in  tempera  or  in  fresco.  In  connection  with  this 
Berger  has  reopened  the  old  controversy  as  to  the  technique  of  Pompeian  wall 
paintings,  which  have  been  accepted  as  frescoes,  on  the  authority  of  Otto 
Donner,  for  a  generation  past.  There  are  difficulties  about  Pompeian  work 
and  it  is  well  that  the  question  has  again  been  raised,  but  Berger  goes  much 
too  far  when  he  attempts  to  deny  to  the  ancients  the  knowledge  and  use  of 
the  fresco  process.  The  evidence  on  this  point  of  Vitruvius  is  quite  decisive, 
as  he,  and  Pliny  after  him,  refer  to  the  process  of  painting  on  wet  plaster  in 
the  most  unmistakeable  terms.  See  Note  on  '  Fresco  Painting,  postea, 
p.  287. 


CHAPTER   VII.     (XXI.) 
Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  Panel  or  on  Canvas. 

§  83.  Oil  Painting,  its  Discovery  and  Early  History. 

A  MOST  beautiful  invention  and  a  great  convenience 
to  the  art  of  Painting,  was  tiie  discovery  of  colouring 
in  oil.  The  first  inventor  of  it  was  John  of  Bruges  in 
Flanders,^  who  sent  the  panel  to  Naples  to  King  Alfonso,^ 

1  This  passage  about  the  early  painters  of  Flanders  occurs  just  as  it  stands, 
with  some  trifling  verbal  differences,  in  Vasari's  first  edition  of  1550.  The 
best  commentary  on  it  is,  first,  the  account  of  the  same  artists  in  Guicciardini's 
Descrittione  di  Tutti  i  Paesi  Bassi,  first  published  at  Antwerp  in  1567,  and 
next,  Vasari's  own  notes  on  divers  Flemish  artists  which  he  added  at  the  end 
of  the  Lives  in  the  second  edition  of  1568  (Of ere,  ed.  Milanesi,  vil,  579 f.). 
He  there  made  certain  additions  and  corrections  from  Guicciardini,  the  most 
noteworthy  of  which  is  the  mention  of  Hubert  van  Eyck,  whom  Vasari 
ignores  in  this  passage  of  the  Introduction,  but  who  is  just  referred  to  by 
Guicciardini  at  the  end  of  his  sentences  on  the  younger  brother — 'A  pari 
a  pari  di  Giovanni  andava  Huberto  suo  fratello,  il  quale  viveva,  e  dipingeva 
continuamente  sopra  le  medesime  opere,  insieme  con  esso  fratello.'  Vasari 
however  in  the  notes  of  1568  goes  much  farther  than  this,  and,  though  he 
does  not  call  Hubert  the  elder  brother,  he  seems  to  ascribe  to  him  personally 
the  supposed  'invention' — 'Huberto  suo  fratello,  che  nel  1510  (sic)  mise  in 
luce  r  invenzione  e  modo  di  colorire  a  olio'  (Opere,  I.e.).  'John  of  Bruges' 
is  of  course  Jan  van  Eyck.  Vasari  writes  of  him  at  the  end  of  the  Lives  as 
'John  Eyck  of  Bruges.'  Vasari's  statement  in  this  sentence  is  of  great 
historical  importance,  for  it  is  the  first  affirmation  of  a  definite  '  invention '  of 
oil  painting,  and  the  first  ascription  of  this  invention  to  van  Eyck.  As  van 
Eyck's  own  epitaph  makes  no  mention  of  this,  and  as  oil  painting  was  practised 
long  before  his  time,  Vasari's  statement  has  naturally  been  questioned,  and 
on  the  subject  the  reader  will  find  a  Note  at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction ' 
to  Painting,  postea,  p.  294. 

^  It  was  long  supposed  that  this  picture  was  the  '  Epiphany '  preserved 
behind  the  High  Altar  of  the  Church  of  S.  Barbara,  Naples,  but  Crowe  and 
Cavalcaselle,  History  of  Painting  in  North  Italy,  n,  103,  pronounce  this  'a 
feeble  and  injured  picture  of  the  eighteenth  century.' 


DISCOVERY  OF  OIL  PAINTING  227 

and  to  the  Duke  of  Urbino,  Federico  II, ^  the  paintings 
for  his  bathroom.  He  made  also  a  San  Gironimo,*  that 
Lorenzo  de'  Medici  possessed,  and  many  other  estimable 
things.  Then  Roger  of  Bruges  ^  his  disciple  followed 
him ;   and  Ausse  (Hans)  ®  disciple  of  Roger,  who  painted 

'  Frederick  of  Urbino  (there  were  not  two  of  the  name  as  Vasari  supposes) 
seems  to  have  had  a  bathroom  decorated  with  secular  compositions  by  the 
Flemish  master.  Facio,  whose  tract  De  Viris  lllustribus,  written  in  the  middle 
of  the  fifteenth  century,  was  printed  at  Florence  in  1745,  writes,  p.  46,  of 
'  Joannes  Gallicus '  (who  can  be  identified  as  Jan  van  Eyck)  who  had  painted 
certain  '  picturae  nobiles '  then  in  the  possession  of  Cardinal  Octavianus,  with 
'representations  of  fair  women  only  slightly  veiled  at  the  bath.'  Such  pictures 
were  considered  suitable  decorations  for  bath  chambers.  There  is  a  curious 
early  example  of  mediaeval  date  in  the  Schloss  Runkelstein  near  Botzen  in  the 
Tyrol,  in  the  form  of  wall  paintings  round  a  bathroom  on  one  side  of  which 
nude  figures  are  seen  preparing  to  enter  the  water,  while  on  two  other  walls 
spectators  of  both  sexes  are  seen  looking  in  through  an  open  arcade.  The 
pictures  here  referred  to  by  van  Eyck  are  now  lost,  but  by  a  curious 
coincidence  attention  has  just  been  directed  to  an  existing  copy  of  one  of  them, 
of  which  Facio  gives  a  special  notice.  The  copy  occurs  in  a  painting  by  Verhaecht 
of  Antwerp,  1593-1637,  that  represents  the  picture  gallery  of  an  Antwerp  con- 
noisseur at  about  the  date  1615.  There  on  the  wall  is  seen  hanging  the  van 
Eyck,  that  corresponds  closely  to  the  full  description  given  by  Facio.  The 
painting  by  Verhaecht  was  shown  at  Burlington  House  in  the  Winter  Exhibition, 
1906-7,  and  in  the  'Toison  d'Or'  Exhibition  at  Bruges  in  1907.  See  also 
the  Burlington  Magazine,  February,  1907,  p.  325.  It  may  be  added  that 
the  Cardinal  Octavianus  mentioned  above  was  a  somewhat  obscure  prelate, 
who  received  the  purple  from  Gregory  XII  in  1408. 

*The  latest  editors  of  Vasari  (Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  I,  184)  think  this  may 
be  a  picture  in  the  Museum  at  Naples,  ascribed  there  to  an  apocryphal 
artist  '  Colantonio  del  Fiore.'  Von  Wurzbach  says  it  is  by  a  Neapolitan 
painter  influenced  by  the  Flemings. 

^  Roger  van  der  Weyden,  more  properly  called,  as  by  Guicciardini  and  by 
Vasari  in  1568,  'Roger  of  Brussels.'  In  1449  he  made  a.  journey  to  Italy, 
and  stayed  for  a  time  at  Ferrara,  which  under  the  rule  of  the  art-loving  Este 
was  very  hospitable  to  foreign  craftsmen.  He  was  in  Rome  in  1450  and  may 
have  visited  Florence  and  other  centres.  His  own  style  in  works  subsequent 
to  this  journey  shows  little  of  Italian  influence. 

'  Hans  Memling.  <  No  Flemish  painter  of  note,'  remark  Crowe  and 
Cavalcaselle,  Early  Flemish  Painters,  p.  256,  '  produced  pictures  more  attractive 
to  the  Italians  than  Memling.'  The  Portinari,  for  whom  Memling  worked,  were 
Florentine  merchants  who  had  a  house  at  Bruges,  the  commercial  connection 
of  which  with  Tuscany  was  very  close.     In  his  Notes  on  Flemish  Painters  at 


228  OF   PAINTING 

for  the  Portinari  at  Santa  Maria  Nuova  in  Florence  a 
small  picture  which  is  to-day  in  Duke  Cosimo's  possession. 
From  his  hand  also  comes  the  picture  at  Careggi,  a  villa 
outside  of  Florence  belonging  to  the  most  illustrious  house 
of  the  Medici.  There  were  likewise  among  the  first 
painters  in  oil  Lodovico  da  Luano  "^  and  Pietro  Crista,^  and 

the  end  of  the  Lives,  Vasari  says  that  the  subject  of  '  a  small  picture  in  the 
possession  of  the  Duke '  which  is  probably  the  one  here  mentioned,  was  '  The 
Passion  of  Christ.'  If  this  be  the  case,  it  cannot  be  the  beautiful  little 
Memling  now  in  the  Uffizi,  No.  703,  for  the  subject  of  this  is  'The  Virgin 
and  Child.'  It  might  possibly  however  be  the  panel  of  'The  Seven  Griefs,' 
a.  Passion  picture  in  the  Museum  at  Turin.  On  the  other  hand,  Passavant 
thought  the  Turin  panel  was  the  '  Careggi '  picture  that  Vasari  goes  on  to 
mention.     See  Note  on  p.  268  of  Crowe  and  Cavalcaselle's  work. 

'  The  German  editors  of  Vasari  identified  Lodovico  da  Luano  with  the  well- 
known  painter  Dierich  Bouts  of  Louvain,  but  the  name  Ludovico  (Chlodwig, 
'  Warrior  of  Renown ')  is  not  the  same  etymologically  as  Dierich  (Theodoric, 
'  Prince  of  the  People ').  It  is  to  be  noted  that  in  Guicciardini  we  find  a 
mention  of  'Dirich  da  Louano,'  who  is  undoubtedly  Dierich  Bouts  (the 
surname  is  derived  from  St  Rombout  the  patron  of  Haarlem,  where  the 
painter,  who  is  also  called  '  Dirick  van  Haarlem '  [see  below],  was  born) 
and  also  a  mention  of  Vasari's  '  Ludovico  da  Luvano. '  A  scrutiny  however 
of  the  sentence  in  Guicciardini,  where  the  last-mentioned  name  occurs,  shows 
that  it  is  copied  almost  verbatim  from  our  text  of  Vasari.  (Vasari  [155°]  • — 
'  Similmente  Lodovico  da  Luano  &  Pietro  Christa,  &  maestro  Martino,  & 
ancora  Giusto  da  Guanto,  che  fece  la  tavola  della  comunione  de'l  Duca  d' 
Vrbino,  &  altre  pitture;  &  Vgo  d'  Anuersa,  che  fe  la  tauola  di  Sancta  Maria 
Nuoua  di  Fiorenza';  Guicciardini: — '  Seguirono  o.  mano  a  mano  Lodouico  da 
Louano,  Pietro  Crista,  Martino  d'  Holanda,  &  Giusto  da  Guanto,  che  fece 
quella  nobil'  pittura  della  comunione  al  Duca  d'  Vrbino,  &  dietro  a  lui  venne 
Vgo  d'  Anuersa,  che  fece  la  bellissima  tauola,  che  si  vede  a  Hrenze  in  santa 
Maria  nuoua ').  Vasari  is  accordingly  responsible  for  this  '  Ludovico  da  Luano,' 
whose  name  is  duly  chronicled  in  von  Wurzbach's  '  Niederlandisches  Kiinstkr- 
Lexicon,  Leipzig,  1906,  II,  p.  69,  on  the  authority  of  Guicciardini  alone, 
and  who  is  called  in  M.  Ruelens's  annotations  to  the  French  edition  of  Crowe 
and  Cavalcaselle  'Louys  de  Louvain  (peintre  encore  inconnu).'  Subsequently 
Guicciardini  mentions  also  a  '  Dirich  d'  Harlem,'  who  can  be  none  other 
than  the  same  Dierick  Bouts,  and  Vasari,  as  a  return  favour,  copies  back 
all  three  Diericks  into  his  Notes  at  the  end  of  the  edition  of  156S.  The 
first  '  Ludovico '  may  be  merely  due  to  a  mistake  in  the  text  of  Vasari 
carelessly  adopted  by  Guicciardini.  Vasari's  copyist  may  have  written 
'  Ludovico '  in  place  of  the  somewhat  similar  '  Teodorico.'  There  was 
however  a  certain  Ludovicus   Dalmau  or  Dalman   (D'Alamagna  ? ),  a   Flemish 


DISCOVERY   OF   OIL   PAINTING  229 

master  Martin  ^  and  Justus  of  Ghent  ^°  who  painted  the 
panel  of  the  communion  of.  the  Duke  of  Urbino  and  other 
pictures;  and  Hugo  of  Antwerp  who  was  the  author  of 
the  picture  at  Santa  Maria  Nuova  in  Florence. ^^  This 
art  was  afterwards  brought  into  Italy  by  Antonello  da 
Messina,  who  spent  many  years  in  Flanders,  and  when 
he  returned  to  this  side  of  the  mountains,  he  took  up 
his  abode  in  Venice,  and  there  taught  the  art  to  some 
friends.  One  of  these  was  Domenico  Veniziano,  who 
brought  it  afterwards  to  Florence,  where  he  painted  in 
oil  the  chapel  of  the  Portinari  in  Santa  Maria  Nuova. 
Here  Andrea  dal  Castagno  learned  the  art  and  taught  it 
to  other   masters, ^^  among  whom   it  was  amplified  and 

painter  who  worked  at  Barcelona  in  Spain  about  1445  (von  Wurzbach,  sub 
voce)  who  may  be  meant,  though  there  is  no  indication  of  a  connection 
between  him  and  Louvain. 

*  Pietro  Crista  is  of  course  Petrus  Christus  or  Christi  of  Bruges,  an  imitator, 
though  as  Mr  Weale  has  shown  not  an  actual  pupil,  of  the  van  Eycks. 
Von  Wurzbach  says  that  Guicciardini  was  the  first  to  mention  his  name,  but 
Vasari  in  1550  already  knows  him.  As  an  explanation  of  the  surname  it  has 
been  suggested  that  the  artist's  father  may  have  had  a  reputation  as  a  painter 
or  carver  of  Christ-figures,  so  that  Petrus  would  be  called  '  son  of  the 
Christ-man.' 

°  The  name  Martin  belongs  to  painters  of  two  generations  in  Ghent,  and 
von  Wurzbach  thinks  it  is  the  earlier  of  these,  Jan  Martins,  apparently  a 
scholar  of  the  van  Eycks,  who  is  referred  to  here,  and  called  by  Guicciardini 
(see  above),  and  by  Vasari  in  1568,  '  Martino  d'  Holanda.'  There  was  a 
later  and  better  known  Martin  of  Ghent  called  '  Nabor  Martin.'  The  more 
famous  '  Martins,'  '  of  Heemskerk,'  and  '  Schongauer,'  when  referred  to  by 
Vasari,  have  more  distinct  indications  of  their  identity.  See,  e.g.,  Opere, 
V.  396- 

"■Justus  of  Ghent  worked  at  Urbino,  where  he  finished  the  altar  piece 
referred  to  by  Vasari  in  1474.  The  '  other  pictures '  may  be  a  series  of 
panels  painted  for  the  library  at  Urbino,  on  which  Crowe  and  Cavalcaselle 
have  an  interesting  paragraph,  op.  cit.  p.  180. 

"  Hugo  of  Antwerp  is  Hugo  van  der  Goes,  whose  altar  piece  painted  for 
S.  Maria  Nuova  at  Florence  has  now  been  placed  in  the  Uffizi. 

"  Vasari's  stories  about  the  connection  with  oil  painting  of  Antonello  da 
Messina,  Domenico  Veneziano,  and  Andrea  dal  Castagno  have  of  course  been 
subjected  to  a  good  deal  of  hostile  criticism.  Those  about  the  two  latter 
artists  are  in  the  meantime  relegated  to  the  limbo  of  fable,  but  the  case  of 


230  OF   PAINTING 

went  on  gaining  in  importance  till  the  time  of  Pietro 
Perugino,  of  Leonardo  da  Vinci  and  of  Raffaello  da 
Urbino,  so  much  so  that  it  has  now  attained  to  that  beauty 
which  thanks  to  these  masters  our  artists  have  achieved. 
This  manner  of  painting  kindles  the  pigments  and  nothing 
else  is  needed  save  diligence  and  devotion,  because  the 
oil  in  itself  softens  and  sweetens  the  colours  and  renders 
them  more  delicate  and  more  easily  blended  than  do  the 
other  mediums.  While  the  work  is  wet  the  colours  readily 
mix  and  unite  one  with  the  other;  in  short,  by  this  method 
the  artists  impart  wonderful  grace  and  vivacity  and  vigour 
to  their  figures,  so  much  so  that  these  often  seem  to  us 
in  relief  and  ready  to  issue  forth  from  the  panel,  especially 
when  they  are  carried  out  in  good  drawing  with  invention 
and  a  beautiful  style. 

§  84.  How  to  Prime  the  Panel  or  Canvas. 

I  must  now  explain  how  to  set  about  the  work.  When 
the  artist  wishes  to  begin,  that  is,  after  he  has  laid  the 
gesso  on  the  panels  or  framed  canvases  and  smoothed 
it,  he  spreads  over  this  with  a  sponge  four  or  five  coats  of 
the  smoothest  size,  and  proceeds  to  grind  the  colours 
with  walnut  or  linseed  oil,  though  walnut  oil  is  better 
because  it  yellows  less  with  time.  When  they  are  ground 
with  these  oils,  which  is  their  tempera  (medium),  nothing 
else  is  needed  so  far  as  the  colours  are  concerned,  but  to 
lay  them  on  with  a  brush.  But  first  there  must  be  made 
a  composition  of  2igments  which  possess  seccative  qualities 
as  white  lead,  dryers,  and  earth  such  as  is  used  for  bells. ^^ 

Antonello  da  Messina  is  somewhat  diflferent,  and  we  are  not  dependent  in 
his  case  on  Vasari  alone.  He  certainly  did  not  visit  Flanders  in  the  lifetime 
of  Jan  van  Eyck,  for  this  artist  died  before  Antonello  was  born,  but  von 
Wurzbach  accepts  as  authentic  a  visit  on  his  part  to  Flanders  between  1465 
and  1475,  and  sees  evidence  of  what  he  learned  there  in  his  extant  works 
(Niederliindischts  Kunstler- Lexicon,  sub  voce,   '  Antonello'). 

"'Terre  da  campane,'  'bell  earths.'  There  seem  to  be  two  possible 
meanings  for  the  phrase.  It  may  refer  to  the  material  used  for  the  moulds 
in    bell    casting,   or  to  the  clay  from  which  are  made   the    little  terra-cotta 


PRIMING  AND   LAYING-IN  231 

all  thoroughly  well  mixed  together  and  of  one  tint,  and 
when  the  size  is  dry  this  must  beplastefed  over  the  panel 
and  then  beaten  with  the  palm  of  the  hand,  so  that  it 
becomes  evenly  }\T\\tpr\  anH  cprgaH  all  mrprj  and  this  man;^ 
call  the  '  imprimatiira  '  (primLng-) . 

§  85.  Drawing,  by  transfer  or  directly. 

After  spreading  the  said  composition  or  pigment  all 
over  the  panel,  the  cartoon  that  you  have  made  with  figures 
and  inventions  all  your  own  may  be  put  on  it,  and  under 
this  cartoon  another  sheet  of  paper  covered  with  black 
on  one  side,  that  is,  on  that  part  that  lies  on  the  priming. 
Having  fixed  both  the  one  and  the  other  with  little  nails, 
take  an  iron  point  or  else  one  of  ivory  or  hard  wood  and 
go  over  the  outlines  of  the  cartoons,  marking  them  firmly. 
In  so  doing  the  cartoon  is  not  spoiled  and  all  the  figures 
and  other  details  on  the  cartoon  become  very  well  outlined 
on  the  panel  or  framed  canvas. 

He  who  does  not  wish  to  make  cartoons  should  draw 
with  tailors'  white  chalk  over  the  priming  or  else  with 
charcoal  made  from  the  willow  tree,  because  both  are 
easily  erased.  Thus  it  is  seen  that  the  artist,  after  the 
priming  is  dry,  either  tracing  the  cartoon  or  drawing 
with  white  chalk,  makes  the  first  sketch  1*  which  some  call 
'  imporre  '  (getting  it  in).  And  having  finished  covering 
the  whole  the  artist  returns  to  it  again  to  complete  it 
with  the  greatest  care  :  and  here  he  employs  all  his  art 
and  diligence  to  bring  it  to  perfection.  In  this  manner 
do  the  masters  in  oil  proceed  with  their  pictures. 

bells  by  which  children  in  Italy  set  great  store  on  the  occasion  of  the  mid- 
summer festival.     This  last  is  improbable. 

Baldinucci,  Vocabolario  del  Disegno,  sub  voce  '  Nero  di  Terra  di  Campana,' 
says  that  this  is  a  colour  made  out  of  a  certain  scale  that  forms  on  moulds 
for  casting  bells  or  cannon,  and  that  it  is  good  with  oil,  but  does  not  stand 
in  fresco.     Lomazzo  also  mentions  the  pigment. 

"  '  L'  abbozza  *  evidently  refers  to  the  first  or  under-painting,  not  to  the 
sketch  in  chalk,  for  in  the  first  edition  the  passage  has  some  additional 
words  which  make  this  clear.  They  run  as  follows :  '  desegnando  quella :  e 
cosi  ne  primi  colori  1'  abozza,  il  che  alcuni  chiamono  imporre.' 


CHAPTER  VIII.    (XXII.) 
Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  a  Wall  which  is  dry. 

§  86.  Mural  Painting  in  Oil. 

When  artists  wish  to  work  in  oil  nn   the  dry  wall  two 
methods  may  be  followed  :    first,   if  the  wall  have  been 
whitened,    either    '  a   fresco '    or    otherwise,    it    must   be 
srrapeH  ;  or  if  it  be  left  grpnoth  withrMit  whitpning  but  only 
plastered  there  must  be  given  to  it  two  or  three  coats  of 
boiled  oil,  the  process  being  repeated  till  the  wall  cannot 
drink  in  more,  and  when  dry  it  is  covered  over  with  the 
composition  or   priming   spoken   of   in   the   last  chapter. 
When  this  is  finished  and  dry,  the  artist  can  trace  or  draw 
on  it  and  can  finish  such  work  in  the  same  manner  as  he 
treats  the  panel,  always  having  a.  Jittle  varnish  mixed  with 
the  colours,  because  if  he  does  this  he  need  not  varnish 
it  afterwards.     The  other  method  is  for  the  artist  to  make, 
either  with  sturro  nf  marhip  riiicit  or  finely  pftiinderi  hrirk. 
a  rough  cast  that  mi)c;f-  he  cmnni-liprl^  and  to  score  it  with 
th'^  pd;j°  "f  p  <^'-^¥^<;l.  in  order  that  th^  ^^H  may  b^  left 
seamed.     Afterwards  he  puts  on  a  coat  of  linseed  oil,  and 
then  mixes  in  a  bowl  some  Greek  pitch  and  resin  (mastice) 
and  thick  varnish,  and  when  this  is  boiled  it  is  thrown  on 
to  the  wall  with  a  big  brush,  and  then  spread  all  over 
with  a  builder's  trowel  that  has  been  heated  in  the  fire. 
This  mixture  fills  up  the  scores  in  the  rough  cast  and 
makes  a  very  smooth  skin  over  the  wall,  when  dry  it  is 
covered  with  priming,   or  a  composition  worked  in   the 
manner    usually   adopted    for    oil,    as    we    have    already 
explained.^ 

'With  the  above  may  be  compared  ch.   9  of  Book  vii  of  L.  B.   Alberti's 
De  Re  Aedificatoria. 


VASARI'S  OWN   METHOD  FOR  WALLS     233 

§  87.   Vasari's  own  Method. 

Since  the  experience  of  many  years  has  taught  me  how 
to  work  in  oil  on  a  wall,  I  have  recently,  in  painting  the 
halls,  chambers,  and  other  rooms  of  Duke  Cosimo's 
palace,^  followed  the  method  frequently  used  by  me  in  the 

2  The  matter  in  our  §  87  was  added  in  the  edition  of  1568.  Though  Vasari 
declared  so  unhesitatingly  for  fresco  as  the  finest  of  all  processes  of  painting, 
he  tells  us  that  he  used  oil  for  a  portion  of  his  mural  work  in  the  Palazzo 
Vecchio  at  Florence,  when  he  prepared  it  for  the  residence  of  Duke  Cosimo, 
and  we  shall  notice  later  his  praise  of  tempera  (postea,  p.  291).  Vasari 
describes  how  he  painted  in  oil  on  the  walls  of  a  refectory  at  Naples  (Of ere, 
VII,  674),  and  gives  us  an  interesting  notice  of  his  experiments  in  the 
technique  about  the  year  1540  at  the  monastery  of  the  Camaldoli,  near 
Arezzo,  where  he  says  '  feci  esperimento  di  unire  il  colorito  a  olio  con  quelle 
(fresco)  e  riuscimmi  assai  acconciamente '  (Opere,  vii,  667).  The  technique 
required  proper  working  out,  .for  it  was  not  a  traditional  one. 

The  most  notable  instance  of  its  employment  before  the  end  of  the  fifteenth 
century  is  in  the  case  of  the  'Last  Supper'  by  Leonardo  da  Vinci  at  Milan. 
A  commission  of  experts  has  recently  been  examining  the  remains  of  this, 
the  most  famous  mural  painting  in  the  world,  and  has  ascertained  that  the 
original  process  employed  by  Leonardo  was  not  pure  oil  painting  but  a  mixed 
process  in  which  oil  played  only  a  part.  The  result  at  any  rate,  as  all  the 
world  is  aware,  was  the  speedy  ruin  of  the  work,  which  now  only  tells  as  a 
design,  there  being  but  little  of  its  creator's  actual  handiwork  now  visible. 

Some  words  of  the  Report  are  of  sufficient  interest  to  be  quoted.  '  Pur 
troppo,  dunque,  la  stessa  tecnica  del  maestro  aveva  in  se  il  germe  della  rovina, 
ben  presto,  infatti,  avvertita  nelle  sue  opere  murali.  Spirito  indagitore, 
innovatore,  voglioso  sempre  di  "provare  e  riprovare"  egli  voile  abbandonare 
i  vecchi,  sicuri  e  sperimentati  sistemi,  per  tentare  1'  esito  di  sostanze  oleose 
in  miscela  coi  colori.  Perche  nemmeno  pu6  dirsi  ch'  ei  dipingesse,  in  questo 
caso,  semplicemente,  ad  olio  come  avrebbe  fatto  ogni  altro  mortale  entrato 
nell'  errore  di  seguire  quel  metodo  anche  pei  muri.  Egli  tentb  invece  cosa 
affato  nuova ;  poiche,  se  da  un  lato  appaiono  tracce  di  parziali  e  circoscritte 
arricciature  in  uso  pel  fresco,  dall'  altro,  la  presenza  delle  sostanze  oleose  e 
accertata  dalla  mancanza  di  adhesione  dei  colori  con  la  superficie  del  muro  e 
dalle  speciali  screpolature  della  crosta  o  pelle  formata  dai  colori  stessi,  non 
che  dal  modo  con  quale  il  dipinto  si  e  andato  e  si  va  lentamente  disgregando 
e  sfaldando.'  BoUettino  d'  Arte  del  Ministero  della  Pubblica  Istruzione,  Roma, 
1907,  I,  p.  17- 

Another  famous  instance  of  the  use  of  oil  paint  in  mural  work  about  a 
generation  later  is  to  be  found  in  the  Sala  di  Costantino  in  the  Vatican,  where 
Raphael's  pupils  have  left  two  of  the  decorative  figures  by  the  side  of  the 
Popes  executed  in  that  medium.     One  (Urbanity)  is  close  to  the  door  leading 


234  OF   PAINTING 

past  for  this  sort  of  work;  which  method  is  briefly  this. 
Make  the  rough  cast,  over  which  put  the  plaster  made 
of  lime,  pounded  brick,  and  sand,  and  leave  it  to  dry- 
thoroughly;  that  done,  make  a  second  coating  of  lime, 
very  finely  pounded  brick,  and  the  scum  from  iron  works  ; 
these  three  ingredients  in  equal  proportions,  bound  with 
white  of  egg  sufficiently  beaten  and  linseed  oil,  make  a 
very  stiff  stucco,  such  as  cannot  be  excelled.  But  take 
great  care  not  to  neglect  the  plaster  while  it  is  fresh,  lest 
it  should  crack  in  many  places;  indeed  it  is  necessary, 
if  one  wish  to  keep  it  good,  to  be  ever  about  it  with  the 
trowel  or  spatula  or  spoon,  whichever  we  choose  to  call 
it,  until  it  be  all  evenly  spread  over  the  surface  in  the 

to  the  Chapel  of  Nicholas  V,  the  other  is  on  the  wall  containing  the  battle, 
and  is  in  better  preservation  than  the  first  which  is  covered  with  wrinkles. 
The  oil  paint  gives  a  certain  depth  and  richness  of  effect,  but  there  is  the 
fatal  disadvantage  that  the  painting  does  not  look  a  part  of  the  wall  as  is  the 
case  with  work  done  in  fresco.  The  fresco  is  really  executed  in  the  material 
of  the  ground,  whereas  oils  and  varnishes  have  nothing  in  common  with  lime 
and  earths,  and  the  connection  of  structure  and  decoration  is  broken.  One 
of  the  most  successful  pieces  of  work  of  the  kind  is  the  painting  of  '  Christ  at 
the  Pillar'  by  Sebastian  del  Piombo  in  S.  Pietro  in  Montorio  at  Rome.  The 
work,  which  is  executed  on  a  cylindrical  surface,  is  rather  shiny,  an  appearance 
which  in  mural  painting  is  to  be  avoided,  and  it  has  darkened  somewhat, 
though  this  defect  is  not  very  apparent  and  the  experiment  has  on  the 
whole  succeeded  well.  Vasari's  Life  of  Fra  Sebastiano  contains  a  good  deal 
of  information  about  this  particular  technique,  which  was  essayed  in  the  later 
age  of  Italian  painting  more  often  than  is  sometimes  imagined.  It  needs 
hardly  to  be  said  that  this  oil  painting  on  the  actual  plaster  of  the  wall  is  a 
different  thing  from  the  modern  process  of  painting  on  canvas  in  the  studio 
and  then  cementing  the  completed  picture  on  to  the  wall.  Mural  painting 
on  canvas  was  introduced  by  the  Venetians  in  the  fifteenth  century,  for  at 
Venice  atmospheric  conditions  seem  to  have  been  unfavourable  to  the  pre- 
servation of  frescoes,  and  the  Venetians  preferred  canvas  to  plaster  for  their 
work  in  oils.  It  would  be  interesting  to  know  whether  the  canvas  was  ever 
fixed  in  situ  before  the  painter  commenced  operations,  as  from  the  point  of 
view  of  the  preservation  of  decorative  effect  this  would  be  of  importance. 
Vasari's  story  about  Tintoretto's  proceedings  at  the  Scuola  di  S.  Rocco 
(Opere,  VI,  594)  is  evidence  that  canvases  were  painted  at  home  and  put  up 
on  walls  or  ceilings  when  finished.  Of  course  if  a  wall  be  covered  with 
canvas  before  the  painting  begins  the  canvas  is  to  all  intents  and  purposes  the 
wall  itself,  grounded  in  a  certain  way. 


VASARI'S   OWN   METHOD   FOR  WALLS     235 

way  it  has  to  remain.  Then  when  this  plaster  is  dry  and 
some  priming  or  composition  laid  over  it,  the  figures  and 
scenes  can  be  perfectly  carried  out,  as  the  works  in  the 
said  palace  and  many  others  will  clearly  demonstrate  to 
everyone. 


CHAPTER   IX.     (XXIII.) 
Of  Painting  in  Oil  on  Canvas. 

§  88.  Painting  on  Canvas.^ 

In  order  to  be  able  to  convey  pictures  from  one  place  to 
another  men  have  invented  the  convenient  method  of 
painting  on  canvas,  which  is  of  little  weight,  and  when 
rolled  up  is  easy  to  transport.  Unless  these  canvases 
intended  for  oil  painting  are  to  remain  stationary,  they 
are  not  covered  with  gesso,  which  would  interfere  with 
their  flexibility,  seeing  that  the  gesso  would  crack  if  they 
were  rolled  up.  A  paste  however  is  made  of  flour  and 
walnut  oil  with  two  or  three  measures  ^  of  white  lead  put 

^The  use  of  canvas  for  the  purpose  in  view  was,  as  Vasari  mentions 
below,  very  common  at  Venice,  where  as  early  as  about  1476,  if  we  believe 
Vasari  {Opere,  III,  156),  Gentile  Bellini  executed  in  this  technique  the  large 
scenic  pictures  with  which  he  adorned  the  Hall  of  Grand  Council  in  the  Ducal 
Palace.  Such  a  process  would  come  naturally  enough  to  Italian  painters  as 
well  as  to  the  Flemings,  for  they  had  been  accustomed  from  time  immemorial 
to  paint  for  temporary  purposes  on  banners  and  draperies,  after  a  fashion  of 
which  Mantegna's  decorative  frieze  on  fine  canvas  at  Hampton  Court  is  a 
classic  example.  Canvas  had  however  been  actually  used  for  pictures  even 
in  ancient  Egypt.  Not  only  was  the  practice  of  stretchii^  linen  over  wooden 
panels  to  receive  the  painting  ground  in  use  there  in  the  time  of  the  New 
Empire,  but  some  of  the  recently  discovered  mummy-case  portraits  from 
Egypt,  of  the  earliest  Christian  centuries,  are  actually  on  canvas.  There  is 
an  example  in  the  National  Gallery.  At  Rome  painting  on  canvas  is  men- 
tioned by  Pliny  {Hisi.  Nat.,  xxxv,  51)  and  Boethius  {de  Arithmetical  Praef ,  I) 
says  that  '  picturae  .  .  .  lintea  operosis  elaborata  textrinis  .  .  .  materiam 
praestant.'  The  Netherland  painters  of  the  fifteenth  century  nearly  always 
painted  on  panel,  but  canvas  was  sometimes  used,  as  by  Roger  van  der 
Weyden  in  his  paintings  for  the  Town  Hall  at  Brussels. 

^Vasari  prescribes  'due  o  tre  macinate'  of  white  lead  for  mixture  with  the 
flour  and  nut  oil  for  the  priming  of  canvas.      A  'macinata'  was  the  amount 


PAINTING   ON   CANVAS  237 

into  it,  and  after  the  canvas  has  been  covered  from  one 
side  to  the  other  with  three  or  four  coats  of  smooth  size, 
this  paste  is  spread  on  by  means  of  a  knife,  and  all  the 
holes  come  to  be  filled  up  by  the  hand  of  the  artist.  That 
done,  he  gives  it  one  or  two  more  coats  of  soft  size  and 
then  the  composition  or  priming.  In  order  to  paint  on 
it  afterwards  he  follows  the  same  method  as  has  been 
described  above  for  the  other  processes.  Because  painting 
on  canvas  has  seemed  easy  and  convenient  it  has  been 
adopted  not  only  for  small  pictures  that  can  be  carried 
about,  but  also  for  altar  pieces  and  other  important  com- 
positions, such  as  are  seen  in  the  halls  of  the  palace  of 
San  Marco  at  Venice,^  and  elsewhere.  Consequently, 
where  the  panels  are  not  sufficiently  large  they  are  replaced 
by  canvases  on  account  of  the  size  and  convenience  of  the 
latter.* 

placed  at  one  time  on  the  '  macina '  or  stone  for  grinding  colours.  Berger 
suggests  'handfuls'  as  a  translation,  but  the  amount  would  be  small,  as  for 
careful  grinding  only  one  or  two  lumps  of  the  pigment  would  be  dealt  with 
at  one  time. 

'The  Ducal  Palace,  that  adjoins  S.  Marco,  is  probably  the  building  in 
Vasari's  mind.  The  Library  of  S.  Marco,  Sansovino's  masterpiece,  might  also 
be  meant,  as  this  was  called  sometimes  the  Palace  of  S.  Marco.  We  must 
remember  B&wev^f  that,  as  noticed  before,  ante,  p.  56,  this  building,  at  the 
time  of  Vasari's  visit  to  Venice,  was  still  unfinished. 

''  On  panels  and  canvases  as  used  at  Venice  Vasari  has  an  interesting  note 
at  the  beginning  of  his  Life  of  Jacopo  Bellini  (Opere,  III,  152).  This  was  a 
subject  that  would  at  once  appeal  to  his  practical  mind  when  he  visited  the 
city.  He  notices  incidentally  that  the  usual  woods  for  panels  were  '  oppio ' 
acer  campestris,  maple ;  or  '  gattice,'  the  populus  alba  of  Horace,  but  that  the 
Venetians  used  only  fir  from  the  Alps.  (Cennini,  c.  113,  recommends  poplar 
or  lime  or  willow.  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  xvi,  187,  speaks  of  larch  and  box,  and 
Ilg  says  that  northern  painters  generally  used  oak.)  The  Venetian  preference 
for  canvas,  Vasari  says,  was  due  to  the  facts  that  it  did  not  split  nor  harbour 
worms,  was  portable,  and  could  be  obtained  of  the  size  desired ;  this  last  he 
notes  too  in  our  text.  Berger  {Beitrage,  iv,  29),  gives  the  meaning  of  '  Gross- 
artigkeit'  to  the  word  'grandezza'  used  above  by  Vasari,  but  of  course  it 
only  means  material  size,  not  '  grandeur '  in  an  aesthetic  sense. 


CHAPTER   X.     (XXIV.) 

Of  painting  in  Oil  on  Stone,  and  what  stones  are  good  for  the 

purpose. 

§  89.  Oil  painting  on  Stone. 

The  courage  of  our  pictorial  artists  has  gone  on  increasing, 
so  that  colouring  in  oil,  besides  the  use  made  of  it  on  the 
wall,  can  when  they  desire  be  employed  also  for  painting 
on  stones.  Of  these  last  they  have  found  a  suitable  kind 
on  the  sea-coast  of  Genoa,  in  those  flagstones  we  have 
spoken  of  in  connection  with  Architecture,^  which  are  very 
well  fitted  for  this  purpose,  for  the  reason  that  they  are 
compact  and  of  fine  grain,  and  take  an  even  polish.  In 
modern  times  an  almost  unlimited  number  of  artists  have 
painted  on  these  slabs  and  have  found  the  true  method 
of  working  upon  them.  Later  they  have  tried  the  finer 
stones,  such  as  marble  breccias,  serpentines,  porphyries 
and  the  like,  which  being  smooth  and  polished  admit  of 
the  colour  attaching  itself  to  them.  But  in  truth  when 
the  stone  is  rough  and  dry  it  imbibes  and  takes  the  boiled 
oil  and  the  colour  much  better;  as  is  the  case  with  some 
kinds  of  soft  peperino,  which,  when  they  are  worked  over 
the  surface  with  an  iron  tool  and  are  not  rubbed  down  with 
sand  or  a  piece  of  hearth  stone,  can  be  brought  to  a 
smooth  surface  with  the  same  mixture  that  I  spoke  of  in 
connection  with  the  rough  cast  and  that  heated  trowel. 
Therefore  it  is  not  necessary  to  begin  by  spreading  size 
on  all  these  stones,   but  only  a  coat  of  priming  of  oil 

>  See  'Introduction'  to  Architecture,  §  13,  ante,  p.  54.  The  stone  is  a 
species  of  slate.  Slate  is  suitable  for  painting  on.  See  Church's  Chemistry 
of  Paints  and  Painting,  1890,  p.  21. 


OIL   PAINTING   ON   STONE  239 

colour,  that  is,  the  composition  already  referred  to,  and 
when  this  is  dry  the  work  may  be  begun  at  will. 

He  who  desires  to  paint  a  picture  in  oil  on  stone  can 
take  some  of  those  Genoese  flagstones  and  have  them  cut 
square  and  fixed  in  the  wall  with  clamps  over  a  layer  of 
stucco,  spreading  the  composition  well  over  the  joinings 
so  as  to  make  a  flat  surface  of  the  size  the  artist  needs. 
This  is  the  true  way  of  bringing  such  works  to  a  finished 
state,  and  when  completed,  ornaments  can  be  added  of 
fine  stones,  breccias,  and  other  marbles.  These,  provided 
they  are  worked  with  diligence  and  care,  endure  for  ever. 
They  may  or  may  not  be  varnished,  just  as  you  like, 
because  the  stone  does  not  suck  up,  that  is,  absorb  as 
much  as  does  the  panel  or  canvas,  and  it  is  impervious 
to  worms,  which  cannot  be  said  for  wooden  panels.^ 

"  Greek  paintings  on  marble  panels  have  come  down  to  us  from  various 
periods  of  ancient  art.  Some  early  Attic  specimens  on  tombstones  are  in  the 
museums  of  Athens,  and  at  Herculaneum  there  was  found  an  interesting 
painting  on  marble  of  a  group  of  Greek  heroines  playing  at  knuckle  bones. 
A  much  earlier  slab  with  a  figure  of  a  warrior  is  in  the  Acropolis  Museum 
at  Athens. 


CHAPTER  XL     (XXV.) 

Of  Painting  on  the  wall  in  Monochrome  with  various  earths  :  how 
objects  in  bronze  are  imitated  :  and  of  groups  for  Triumphal  Arches 
or  festal  structures,  done  with  powdered  earths  mixed  with  size, 
which  process  is  called  Gouache  and  Tempera. 

§  90,  Imitative  Paintings  for  Decorations. 
Monochromes  according  to  the  painters  are  a  kind  of 

picture  that  has  a  Hngpr  rplatinn   tn  Hrawing  than   tO  WOrlj 

in  colour  because  it  has  been  derived  from  copying  marble 
statiipq  and  fissures  in  bronze  and  various  sorts  of  stone; 
and  artists  have  been  accustomed  to  decorate  in  mono- 
chrome the  facades  of  palaces  and  houses,  giving  these 
a  semblance  other  than  the  realitv.  ^r\r\  making  thpm 
appear  to  be  built  of  marble  or  stone,  with  the  decorative 
groups  actually  carved  in  relief ;  or  indeed  they  may 
imitate  particular  sorts  of  marble,  and  porphyry,  serpen- 
tine, and  red  and  grey  granite  or  other  stones,  or  bronze, 
according  to  their  taste,  arranging  them  in  many  divisions; 
and  this  style  is  much  in  use  now-a-days  for  the  fronts 
of  houses  and  palaces  in  Rome  and  throughout  Italy. 

These  paintings  are  executed  in  two  ways,  first,  in  fresco 
which  is  the  true  way ;  secondly,  on  canvas  to  adorn 
arches  erected  on  the  occasion  of  the  entrance  of  princes 
into  the  city,  and  of  processions,  or  in  the  apparatus  for 
f^tes  and  plays,  since  on  such  structures  they  produce  a 
very  beautiful  effect.  We  shall  first  treat  of  the  manner 
of  working  these  in  fresco,  and  then  speak  of  the  other 
method.  In  the  first  kind  the  backgrounds  are  laid  in  with 
potters'  clay,  and  with  this  is  mixed  powdered  charcoal  or 
other  black  for  the  darker  shadows,  and  white  of  travertine. 


IMITATIVE  PAINTINGS  FOR  DECORATIONS    241 

There  are  many  gradations  from  light  to  dark;  the  high 
lights  are  put  in  with  pure  white,  and  the  strongest 
shadows  are  finished  with  the  deepest  hla^k.  Such  works 
must  have  boldness,  intention,  power,  vivacity,  and  grace, 
and  must  be  expressed  with  an  artistic  freedom  and  spirit 
and  with  nothing  cramped  about  them,  because  they  have 
to  be  seen  and  recognized  from  a  distance.^  In  this 
style  too  must  bronze  figures  be  imitated;  they  are 
sketched  in  on  a  background  of  yellow  and  red  earth,  the 
darker  shades  put  in  with  blended  tints  of  black,  red, 
and  yellow,  the  middle  tints  with  pure  yellow,  and  the 
high  lights  with  yellow  and  white.^  And  with  these 
painters  have  composed  decorations  on  the  fa9ades,  inter- 
mingling statues,  which  in  this  kind  of  work  give  a  most 
graceful  effect. 

Those  pictures  however  intended  for  arches,  plays,  or 
festivals,  are  worked  after  the  canvas  has  been  prepared 
with  clay,  that  is,  with  that  pure  earth  (terretta)  before 
mentioned  which  potters  use,  mixed  with  size,^  and  the 

^  These  chiaroscuri  or  monochromes  are  characteristic  of  the  later  Renais- 
sance. They  may  either  be  frankly  decorative,  and  in  this  form  obey  the 
rules  of  all  other  pictorial  enrichment ;  or  they  may  have  an  illusive  intention, 
and  be  designed  to  produce  the  appearance  on  a  flat  wall  of  architectural 
members  or  sculptured  or  cast-bronze  reliefs.  In  this  case,  when  on  monumental 
buildings  and  permanent,  they  are  insincere  and  opposed  to  sound  decorative 
principles,  though  on  temporary  structures  they  are  quite  in  place.  Vasari 
was  a  famous  adept  at  the  construction  and  adornment  of  such  fabrics,  which 
were  in  great  demand  for  the  numerous  Florentine  pageants  and  processions. 
See  his  letters,  passim. 

^  There  are  examples  of  painted  imitations  of  bronze  in  Michelangelo's 
frescoes  on  the  vault  of  the  Sistine.  The  medallions  held  by  the  pairs  of 
decorative  figures  of  youths  on  the  cornice  are  painted  to  represent  reliefs  in 
this  metal.  Raphael's  Stanze  and  Loggie  also  furnish  instances,  and  there 
are  good  examples  on  the  external  fa9ade  of  the  Palazzo  Ricci  at  Rome. 

^  The  clay  or  earth  that  Vasari  speaks  of  forms  the  body  of  the  '  distemper ' 
or  'gouache,'  as  it  would  be  called  respectively  in  Britain  and  in  France,  and 
takes  the  place  of  the  '  whitening '  used  in  modern  times.  Baldinucci  in  his 
Vocabolario  explains  '  Terra  di  cava  o  Terretta '  as  '  the  earth  (clay)  with  which 
vessels  for  the  table  are  made,  that  mixed  with  pounded  charcoal  is  used 
by  painters  for  backgrounds  and  monochromes,  and  also  for  primings,  and  with 

Q 


.242  OF   PAINTING 

back  of  the  canvas  must  be  moistened  while  the  artist  is 
painting  on  it,  that  the  darks  and  lights  of  his  work  may 
unite  better  with  the  ground  of  clay.*  It  is  customary  to 
mix  the  blacks  with  a  little  tempera  ;^  white  leads  are  used 
for  the  white,  and  red  lead  to  simulate  relief  in  things 
that  appear  to  be  of  bronze,  and  Naples  yellow  (giallino) 
to  put  in  the  high  lights  over  the  red  lead,  and  for  the 
backgrounds  and  the  darks  the  same  red  and  yellow  earths 
and  the  same  blacks  that  I  spoke  of  in  connection  with 
fresco  work;  these  make  the  half  tints  and  shadows.  The 
painter  uses  also  other  different  pigments  to  shade  other 
kinds  of  monochromes,  such  as  umber  to  which  is  added 
terra  verte  and  yellow  ochre  and  white;  in  the  same  way 
is  used  black  earth,  which  is  another  sort  of  terra  verte 
and  the  dark  colour  that  is  called  '  verdaccio.^ 

a  tempera  of  size  for  the  canvases  with  which  are  painted  triumphal  arches, 
perspectives,  and  the  like.'  It  is  of  very  fine  and  even  texture,  and  Baldinucci 
says  it  was  found  near  St  Peter's  at  Rome,  and  also  in  great  quantity  at 
Monte  Spertoli,  thirteen  miles  from  Florence. 

*  This  process  of  wetting  the  back  of  the  canvas  is  to  be  noted.  The  chief 
inconvenience  of  the  kind  of  work  here  spoken  of  is  that  it  dries  very  quickly, 
and  dries  moreover  very  much  lighter  than  when  the  work  is  wet.  Hence  it 
is  an  advantage  to  keep  the  ground  wet  as  long  as  possible  till  the  tints  are 
properly  fused,  so  that  all  may  dry  together.  Wetting  the  back  of  the  canvas 
secures  this  end.  The  technique  that  Vasari  is  describing  is  the  same  as  that 
of  the  modern  theatrical  scene-painter,  and  would  be  called  'distemper 
painting.'  The  colours  are  mixed  with  whitening,  or  finely-ground  chalk, 
and  tempered  with  size.  The  whitening  makes  them  opaque  and  gives  them 
'  body,'  but  is  also  the  cause  of  their  drying  light.  F.  Lloyds,  in  his  Practical 
Guide  to  Scene  Painting  and  Painting  in  Distemper,  Lond.  1879,  says  (p.  42) 
'  In  the  study  of  the  art  of  distemper  painting,  a  source  of  considerable 
embarrassment  to  the  inexperienced  eye  is  that  the  colours  when  wet  present 
such  a  different  appearance  from  what  they  do  when  dry.' 

'  Does  Vasari  mean  by  '  tempera '  yolk  of  egg  ?  It  has  this  sense  with 
him  sometimes,  as  in  the  heading  of  chapter  vi. 

'  Cennini  in  his  67th  chapter  gives  directions  for  preparing  the  mixed  colour 
he  calls  verdacdo.     It  was  a  compound  of  white,  dark  ochre,  black  and  red. 


CHAPTER   XII.     (XXVI.) 

Of  the  Sgraffiti  for  house  decoration  which  withstand  water  ;  that  which 
is  used  in  their  production ;  and  how  Grotesques  are  worked  on 
the  wall. 

§  91.  Sgraffito-work. 

Painters  have  another  sort  of  picture  which  is  drawing 
and  painting  both  together.  This  is  called  sgraffito;  it 
serves  only  for  ornament  on  the  fa9ades  of  houses  and 
palaces,  and  is  very  quickly  executed,  while  it  perfectly 
resists  the  action  of  water,  because  all  the  outlines,  instead 
of  being  drawn  with  charcoal  or  other  similar  material, 
are  etched  by  the  hand  of  the  painter  with  an  iron  tool. 
The  work  is  done  in  this  manner.  They  take  lime 
mixed  with  sand  in  the  usual  fashion  and  tinge  it  by 
means  of  burnt  straw  to  a  tint  of  a  medium  colour  inclining 
to  pearl  grey,  a  little  more  towards  the  dark  than  the 
middle  tint,  and  with  this  they  plaster  the  fagade.  That 
done  and  the  fafade  smoothed,  they  give  it  a  coat  of  white 
all  over  with  the  white  lime  of  travertine,  and  then  dust 
over  the  (perforated)  cartoons,  or  else  draw  directly  that 
which  they  wish  to  execute.  Afterwards  pressing  upon 
it  with  an  iron  stylus  they  trace  the  contours  and  draw 
lines  on  the  cement,  which,  because  there  is  a  black 
substance  underneath,  shows  all  the  scratches  of  the  tool 
as  marks  of  drawing.^ 

'The  principle  of  sgraffito  work,  that  is  the  scratching  through  a  thin 
superimposed  coat  to  hring  to  view  an  under  layer  of  a  different  colour,  seems 
to  have  been  established  first  in  pottery  making,  and  in  this  connection  the 
Italians  called  it  'Sgraffiato.'  The  adoption  of  the  process  for  the  decoration 
of  surfaces  of  plaster  or  cement  was  an  innovation  of  the   Renaissance,  and 


244  OF  PAINTING 

It  is  customary  too  to  scrape  away  the  white  in  the 
backgrounds,  and  then  to  prepare  a  water  colour  tint, 
darkish  and  very  watery,  and  with  that  reinforce  the  darks, 
as  one  would  do  on  paper ;  this  seen  at  a  distance  is  most 
effective.  But  if  there  be  grotesques  or  leafage  in  the 
design,  cast  shadows  are  painted  on  the  background  by 
means  of  that  water  colour.  This  is  the  work  that  the 
painters  have  called  sgraffito,  on  account  of  its  being 
scratched  by  the  iron  instrument. 


§  92.  Grotesques,  or  Fanciful  Devices,  painted  or  modelled 

on  Walls.^ 

There  remains  to  us  now  to  speak  of  the  grotesques 
done  on  the  wall.  For  those,  then,  that  go  on  a  white 
ground,  when  the  background  is  not  of  stucco  (white 
plaster),  because  the  ordinary  lime  plastering  is  not  white, 
therefore  a  thin  coat  of  white  is  laid  over ;  and  that  done  the 
cartoons  are  powdered  and  the  work  executed  in  fresco 

Vasari  appears  to  have  been  the  first  writer  who  gives  a  recipe  for  it. 
According  to  his  account  in  the  Lives,  it  was  a  friend  of  Morto  da  Feltro, 
the  Florentine  Andrea  di  Cosimo,  who  first  started  the  work,  and  Vasari 
describes  the  process  he  employed  in  phrases  that  correspond  with  the  wording 
of  the  present  chapter  {Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  V,  207).  A  modern  expert  describes 
the  process  as  follows :  '  A  wall  is  covered  with  a  layer  of  tinted  plaster, 
and  on  this  is  superimposed  a  thin  coating  of  white  plaster.  The  outer  coat 
is  scratched  through,  and  the  colour  behind  it  is  revealed.  Then  all  the  white 
surface  outside  the  design  is  cut  away,  and  a  cameo-like  effect  given  to  the 
design.  This  is  the  art  of  Sgraffito  as  known  to  the  Italian  Renaissance' 
(Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  1889,  p.  125).  The  process  dropped  out  of  use 
after  a  while,  but  was  revived  in  Germany  in  the  middle  of  the  nineteenth 
century,  mainly  through  the  agency  of  the  architect  Gottfried  Semper,  the 
author  of  Der  Stil.  It  is  sometimes  used  in  our  own  country  both  on 
monumental  and  on  domestic  buildings,  and  as  it  is  simple  and  cheap  and 
permanent  it  is  well  fitted  for  modern  use  in  our  climate.  The  back  of  the 
Science  School  in  Exhibition  Road,  S.  Kensington,  was  covered  with  sgraffiti 
by  the  pupils  of  the  late  F.  W.  Moody  about  1872.  They  would  be  the 
better  now  for  a  cleansing  with  the  modern  steam-blast. 

2 See  the  Notes  on  'Enriched  Fa9ades,'  and  'Stucco  "Grotesques,"'  at  the 
close  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Painting,  postea,  pp.  298,  299. 


< 
1-1 


o 

1-H 

H 

<: 

Pii 

u 

o 

a 

u 

%. 

H 

S 

O 

(n 

« 

o 

o 

>, 

H 

S 

HH 

a 

Ei< 

o 

< 

S 

l4 

o 

O 

c^ 

w 

li 

P-i 

Q 

<u 

W 

■£ 

kJ 

,, 

iJ 

o 

<; 

k< 

o 

,g 

6 

a) 

tn 

"S 

u 

ta 

OJ 

O 

,5 

a 

c 

w 

0 

s 

o 

w 

GROTESQUES  245 

with  opaque  colours,^  but  these  will  never  have  the  charm 
of  those  worked  directly  upon  the  stucco.  In  this  style 
there  may  be  grotesques  both  coarse  and  fine,  and  these 
are  done  in  the  same  way  as  the  figures  in  fresco  or  on 
the  dry  wall. 

'  This  passage  presents  some  difficulty.  It  runs  '  Dunque,  quelle  che  vanno 
in  campo  bianco,  non  ci  essendo  il  campo  di  stucco  per  non  essere  bianca  la 
calce,  si  dk  per  tutto  sottiltnente  il  campo  di  bianco.'  Vasari  seems  to  have 
in  his  mind  the  difference  between  ordinary  plaster  made,  as  he  has  just 
described,  of  Mime  mixed  with  sand  in  the  ordinary  fashion,'  which  would 
not  be  white,  and  what  he  calls  'stucco,'  by  which  term  is  probably  meant 
the  finer  plasten  made  of  white  lime  from  travertine  and  marble  dust. 
Ordinary  plaster  has  accordingly  to  be  coated  with  white  before  the  work 
begins. 


CHAPTER   XIII.     (XXVII.) 

How  Grotesques  are  worked  on  the  Stucco. 

The  grotesque  is  a  kind  of  free  and  humorous  picture 
produced  by  the  ancients  for  the  decoration  of  vacant 
spaces  in  some  position  where  only  things  placed  high 
up  are  suitable.  For  this  purpose  they  fashioned  monsters 
deformed  by  a  freak  of  nature  or  by  the  whim  and  fancy 
of  the  workers,  who  in  these  grotesque  pictures  make 
things  outside  of  any  rule,  attaching  to  the  finest  thread 
a  weight  that  it  cannot  support,  to  a  horse  legs  of  leaves, 
to  a  man  the  legs  of  a  crane,  and  similar  follies  and 
nonsense  without  end.^  He  whose  imagination  ran  the 
most  oddly,  was  held  to  be  the  most  able.  Afterwards 
the  grotesques  were  reduced  to  rule  and  for  friezes  and 
compartments  had  a  most  admirable  effect.  Similar  works 
in  stucco  were  mingled  with  the  painting.  So  generally 
was  this  usage  adopted  that  in  Rome  and  in  every  place 
where  the  Romans  settled  there  is  some  vestige  of  it  still 
preserved.  And  truly,  when  touched  with  gold  and 
modelled  in  stucco  such  works  are  gay  and  delightful  to 
behold. 

They  are  executed  in  four  different  ways.^  One  is  to 
work  in  stucco  alone  :   another  to  make  only  the  ornaments 

'Examples  of  this  whimsical  style  of  decoration  are  abundant  in  the 
Pompeian  wall  paintings,  and  the  mind  of  Vitruvius  was  much  exercised 
about  their  frivolity  and  want  of  meaning  (De  Architectura,  VII,  v). 

"Vasari  is  not  very  clear  in  his  account  of  these  methods  of  work,  but  it  is 
enough  to  know  that  both  by  the  ancients,  and  at  the  time  of  the 
Renaissance,  colour  was  used  largely  in  connection  with  these  reliefs,  and  the 
combination  could  of  course  take  several  forms.     In  the  loggia  of  the  Villa 


GROTESQUES  WORKED   ON   STUCCO       247 

of  stucco  and  paint  groups  in  the  spaces  thus  formed 
and  grotesques  on  the  friezes  :  the  third  to  make  the  figures 
partly  in  stucco,  and  partly  painted  in  black  and  white  so 
as  to  imitate  cameos  and  other  stones.  Many  examples 
of  this  kind  of  grotesque  and  stucco  work  have  been,  and 
still  are  seen,  done  by  the  moderns,  who  with  consummate 
grace  and  beauty  have  ornamented  the  most  notable  build- 
ings of  all  Italy,  so  that  the  ancients  are  left  far  behind. 
Finally  the  last  method  is  to  work  upon  stucco  with  water 
colour,  leaving  the  stucco  itself  for  the  lights,  and  shading 
the  rest  with  various  colours.  Of  all  these  kinds  of  work, 
all  of  which  offer  a  good  resistance  to  time,  antique 
examples  are  seen  in  numberless  places  in  Rome,  and  at 
Pozzuoli  near  to  Naples.  This  last  sort  can  also  be 
excellently  worked  in  fresco  with  opaque  colours,  leaving 
the  stucco  white  for  the  background.^  And  truly  all  these 
works  possess  wonderful  beauty  and  grace.  Among  them 
are  introduced  landscape  views,  which  much  enliven  them, 
as  do  also  little  coloured  compositions  of  figures  on  a 
small  scale.  There  are  to-day  many  masters  in  Italy  who 
make  this  sort  of  work  their  profession,  and  really  excel 
in  it. 

Farnesina,  where  Raphael  worked  with  his  assistants,  there  are  painted  panels 
in  fresco  framed  in  mouldings  of  stucco,  modelled  plaster  figures  in  white  against 
a  coloured  ground,  coloured  stuccos  against  coloured  fields,  and  tinted  bands 
separating  the  framed  plaster  medallions.  The  same  kind  of  work  is  found  in 
the  Loggie  of  the  Vatican,  the  Doria  Palace  at  Genoa,  and  other  localities 
innumerable.  Plate  XII  shows  a  characteristic  section  of  the  decoration  of  the 
Vatican  Loggie. 

'As  in  the  work  described  at  the  close  of  ch.   xil   (the  beginning  of  the 
present  section). 


CHAPTER   XIV.    (XXVIII.) 

Of  the  manner  of  applying  Gold  on  a  Bolus,*  or  with  a  Mordant,^ 
and  other  methods. 

§  93,  Methods  of  Gilding. 

It  was  truly  a  most  beautiful  secret  and  an  ingenious 
investigation — that  discovery  of  the  method  of  beating  gold 
into  such  thin  leaves,  that  for  every  thousand  pieces  beaten 
to  the  size  of  the  eighth  of  a  braccio  in  every  direction, 
the  cost,  counting  the  labour  and  the  gold,  was  not  more 
than  the  value  of  six  scudi.^  Nor  was  it  in  any  way  less 
ingenious  to  discover  the  method  of  spreading  the  gold 
over  the  gesso  in  such  a  manner  that  the  wood  and  other 
material  hidden  beneath  it  should  appear  a  mass  of  gold. 

*The  word  'bolus'  is  derived  from  the  Greek  pSSos,  a  lump  or  clod,  and 
means,  according  to  Murray's  Dictionary,  a  pill,  or  a  small  rounded  mass  of 
any  substance,  and  also  a  kind  of  reddish  clay  or  earth,  used  medically  for  its 
astringent  properties,  that  was  brought  from .  Armenia,  and  called  by  the 
pharmacologist  'bole  armeniac'  Its  use  in  the  arts  is  due  to  its  unctuous 
character,  which  made  gold  adhere  to  it.  See  below.  In  mediaeval  illumina- 
tions a  'bolus'  or  small  lump  of  a  properly  prepared  gesso  is  generally  laid 
on  the  parchment  where  gold  is  to  come,  so  that  the  raised  surface  may  give 
the  polished  metal  more  effect.  The  gold  over  the  bolus  was  always  burnished. 
It  may  be  noticed  that  our  word  'size'  is  really  'assise,'  the  bed  or  layer 
under  gilding,  for  which  a  gluey  substance  was  suitable. 

■•"A  'mordant'  as  the  word  implies  is  some  corrosive  liquid,  such  as  is  used 
by  dyers  to  bite  into  the  fabric  and  carry  in  with  it  the  colouring  matter.  The 
word  is  also  employed,  as  in  this  passage,  for  a  glutinous  size  used  as  ground 
for  gilding,  such  as  the  modern  decorator's  'gold-size.'  Gold  laid  in  this  way 
has  a  '  mat '  surface. 

*The  scudo  was  worth  in  Tuscany  about  four-and-sixpence  of  our  money. 
In  Florence  its  value  was  a  little  greater. 


< 
o 

< 
> 

u 

X 
E- 


u 

5 
o 
o 


< 
<; 

o 

Di 
11. 

o 
o 

W 


METHODS  OF  GILDING  349 

This  is  how  it  is  done.  The  wood  is  covered  with  the 
thinnest  gesso  lineaded  with  size  weak  rather  than  strong, 
and  coarser  gesso  is  laid  on  in  several  coats  according 
as  the  wood  has  been  well  or  badly  prepared.  When  the 
gesso  is  scraped  and  smoothed,  white  of  egg  beaten  care- 
fully in  water  is  mixed  with  Armenian  bole,  which  has 
been  reduced  with  water  to  the  finest  paste.  The  first 
coat  of  this  is  made  watery,  I  mean  to  say  liquid  and 
clear,  and  the  next  thicker.  This  is  laid  on  to  the  panel 
at  least  three  times,  until  it  takes  it  well  all  over,  then 
with  a  brush  the  worker  gradually  wets  with  pure  water 
the  parts  where  the  Armenian  bole  has  been  applied  and 
there  he  puts  on  the  gold  leaf,  which  quickly  sticks  to 
that  soft  substance ;  *  and  when  partially  but  not  entirely 
dry  he  burnishes  it  with  a  dog's  tooth  or  the  tooth  of  a 
wolf  in  order  to  make  it  become  lustrous  and  beautiful.^ 

Gilding  is  effected  in  another  fashion  also,  '  with  a 
mordant,'  as  it  is  said.^  This  is  used  for  every  sort  of 
material — stone,  wood,  canvas,  metals  of  all  kinds,  cloth, 
and  leather;  and  is  not  burnished  as  is  the  former.  The 
mordant,  which  is  the  lye  that  holds  the  gold,  is  made 
of  various  sorts  of  drying  oil  pigments  and  of  oil  boiled 
with  the  varnish  in  it.     It  is  laid  upon  the  wood  which 

*See  Note  I,  ante,  p.  248. 

'For  the  various  processes  of  preparing  a  panel  for  painting  and  for  gilding 
reference  must  be  made  to  Cennini's  Trattato,  where  many  technical  matters 
are  elucidated  that  Vasari  passes  over  almost  without  notice.  It  must  be 
remembered  that  Cennini  writes  as  a  tempera  painter,  while  in  Vasari's  time 
these  elaborate  processes  were  falling  out  of  use.  In  his  chapters  115-119, 
Cennini  gives  recipes  for  what  he  calls  'gesso  grosso'  and  'gesso  sottile.' 
They  are  made  of  the  same  materials,  '  volterrano,'  or  plaster  from  Volterra, 
which  is  a  sulphate  of  lime  corresponding  to  our  'plaster  of  Paris,'  and  size 
made  from  parchment  shreds ;  but  the  plaster  for  '  gesso  sottile '  is  more 
finely  prepared.  The  plaster,  produced  by  calcining  gypsum,  is  first  thoroughly 
slaked  by  being  drenched  with  water  till  it  loses  all  tendency  to  '  set,'  and 
is  then  as  a  powder  or  paste  mixed  with  the  heated  size.  The  size  makes 
the  composition  dry  quite  hard,  and  Cennini  speaks  of  its  having  a  surface 
like  ivory. 

'See  Note  2,  ante,  p.  248. 


250  OF   PAINTING 

has  first  received  two  coats  of  size.  And  after  the  mordant 
is  so  applied,  not  when  it  is  fresh,  but  half  dry,  the  gold 
leaf  is  laid  upon  it.  The  same  can  be  done  also  with 
gum-ammoniac,  when  there  is  hurry,  provided  that  the 
stuff  is  good.  This  is  used  more  to  adorn  saddles  and 
make  arabesques  and  other  ornaments  than  for  anything 
else.  Sometimes  also  gold  leaves  are  ground  in  a  glass 
cup  with  a  little  honey  and  gum  ^  and  made  use  of  by 
miniature-painters  and  many  others  who,  with  the  brush, 
delight  to  draw  outlines  and  put  very  delicate  lights  into 
pictures.  And  all  these  are  most  valuable  secrets;  but 
because  they  are  very  numerous  one  does  not  take  much 
account  of  them. 

^This  we  should  call  'shell  gold.'  It  is  in  common  use.  The  employment 
of  the  shell  represents  a  very  ancient  tradition,  for  shells  were  the  usual  receptacles 
for  pigments  in  late  classical  and  Early  Christian  times. 


CHAPTER   XV.    (XXIX.) 
Of  Glass  Mosaic  and  how  it  is  recognized  as  good  and  praiseworthy. 

§  94.  Glass  Mosaics. 

We  have  spoken  sufficiently  above,  in  the  sixth  chapter 
on  Architecture,  of  the  nature  of  mosaic  and  how  it  is 
made,  and,  adding  here  just  so  much  as  really  refers  to 
pictures,  let  us  say  that  very  great  mastery  is  needed  to 
arrange  the  pieces  so  harmoniously  that  the  mosaic  appears 
at  a  distance  a  genuine  and  beautiful  picture,  seeing  that 
this  kind  of  work  demands  great  experience  and  judgement 
and  a  profound  knowledge  of  the  art  of  design.  For  if 
any  one  in  his  designs  obscure  the  mosaic  with  too  great 
wealth  and  abundance  of  figures  in  the  groups,  and  with 
multiplying  over-much  the  pieces,  he  will  bring  it  all  into 
confusion.  Therefore  the  design  of  the  cartoons  made 
for  mosaic  must  be  open,  broad,  easy,  clear,  and  carried 
out  with  excellence  and  in  admirable  style. ^  The  artist 
who  understands  the  force  of  shadows  in  the  design  and  of 
giving  few  lights  and  many  darks,  leaving  in  these  certain 
vacant  spaces  or  fields,  he  above  all  others  will  make  his 
mosaic  beautiful  and  well  arranged.  Mosaic  to  be  praised 
must  have  clearness  in  itself,  with  a  certain  harmonious 
obscurity  towards  the  shadows,  and  must  be  executed  far 
from  the  eye  with  the  greatest  discretion  that  it  may  be 

'This  is  excellent  advice.  The  architectural  character  of  mosaic  decoration, 
the  distance  of  the  work  from  the  eye,  the  nature  of  the  technique  and 
material,  all  invite  to  a  broad  and  simple  treatment,  such  as  we  find  in  the 
best  mosaics  at  Ravenna  and  Rome.  Modern  work  is  often  too  elaborate  and 
too  minute  in  detail. 


252  OF   PAINTING 

esteemed  painting  and  not  inlaid  work.^  Therefore  the 
mosaics  that  have  these  qualities,  are  good  and  will  be 
praised  by  everyone;  and  it  is  certain  that  mosaic  is  the 
most  durable  picture  that  exists.  Other  painting  fades 
through  time,  but  mosaic  continually  brightens  with  age; 
other  painting  fails  and  wastes  away,  while  mosaic  on 
account  of  its  long  life  may  almost  be  called  eternal.^ 
For  this  reason  we  perceive  in  it  not  only  the  perfection 
of  the  old  masters,  but  also  of  the  ancients  * — by  means 
of  those  examples  from  their  epoch  that  we  recognize  as 
such  to-day,  as  in  the  Temple  of  Bacchus  at  Sant'  Agnese 
outside  of  Rome,  where  all  that  is  there  executed  is 
exceedingly  well  done.^  At  Ravenna  also  there  is  some 
very  beautiful  old  mosaic  in  many  places,  and  at  Venice 
in  San  Marco,  at  Pisa  in  the  Duomo,  and  at  Florence  in 
the  tribune  of  San  Giovanni,^  but  the  most  beautiful  of 

"A  modern  would  say  that  if  the  work  be  really  inlaid,  it  should  look  like 
inlaid  work,  and  not  like  something  else.  In  the  Italy  of  Vasari's  day 
however,  as  we  have  seen,  painting  had  so  thoroughly  got  the  upper  hand, 
that  to  ape  the  nobler  art  would  seem  a  legitimate  ambition  for  the  mosaicist. 

'The  durability  of  mosaic  depends  on  the  cement  in  which  the  cubes  are 
embedded  and  on  the  care  taken  in  their  setting.  The  pieces  themselves  are 
indestructible  but  they  will  sometimes  drop  out  from  the  wall.  Hence 
extensive  restorations  have  been  carried  out  on  the  Early  Christian  mosaics 
at  Ravenna  and  other  places. 

*In  his  Proemio  delle  Vite  (Opere,  I,  242)  Vasari  explains  what  he  means 
by  the  words  'antique'  and  'old.'  The  former  refers  to  the  so-called 
'classical'  epoch  before  Constantine ;  the  latter  to  the  Early  Christian  and 
early  mediaeval  period,  prior  to  the  Italian  revival  of  the  thirteenth  century. 

"  At  S.  Costanza  (see  Note  5,  ante,  p.  27)  on  the  vault  of  the  aisle  there  are 
decorative  mosaics  of  the  time  of  Constantine  showing  vine  scrolls  issuing  out 
of  vases,  and  classical  genii  gathering  the  grapes.  Birds  are  introduced  among 
the  tendrils. 

'The  mosaics  at  Ravenna  and  S.  Marco,  Venice,  are  well  known.  In  the 
Duomo  at  Pisa,  in  the  apse,  there  still  remains  the  Saviour  in  Glory  between 
the  Madonna  and  John  the  Baptist,  designed  by  a  certain  Cimabue,  and  the 
only  existing  work  which  modern  criticism  would  accept  as  from  the  hand  of 
the  traditional  father  of  Florentine  painting.  It  may  however  have  been 
another  painter  nicknamed  'Cimabue,'  who  worked  at  Pisa  early  in  the 
fourteenth  century.  The  mosaics  of  the  Tribune  of  the  Baptistry  at  Florence 
were  executed  in  1225  by  Jacobus,  a  monk  of  the  Franciscan  Order,  and  this 
fact  is  attested  by  an  inscription  in  mosaic  which  forms  part  of  the  work. 


GLASS  MOSAICS  253 

all  is  that  of  Giotto  in  the  main  aisle  of  the  porch  at 
St.  Peter's  at  Rome ' — truly  a  miraculous  thing  in  that 
kind  of  work — and  among  the  moderns  there  is  that  of 
Domenico  Ghirlandaio  above  the  door  outside  Santa  Maria 
del  Fiore  that  leads  to  the  Annunziata.^ 


§  95.  The  Preparation  of  the  Mosaic  Cubes, 

The  pieces  for  mosaic  are  prepared  in  the  following 
manner.  When  the  glass  furnaces  are  ready  and  the  pans 
full  of  glass,  the  workers  go  round  giving  to  every  pan 
its  own  colour,  starting  from  a  true  white  which  contains 
body  and  is  not  transparent,  and  carefully  proceeding  to 
the  darker  tints  by  gradual  transitions,  in  the  same  manner 
as  they  make  the  mixtures  of  colours  for  ordinary  paint- 
ing. Afterwards  when  the  glass  is  fused  and  in  a  fit  state, 
and  the  mixtures  both  light  and  dark  and  of  every  tint 
are  prepared,  they  ladle  out  the  hot  glass  with  certain  long 
iron  spoons  and  spread  it  on  a  flat  piece  of  marble,  then 
with  another  piece  of  marble  press  it  evenly,  making 
round  discs  that  come  equally  flat  and  remain  the  third 
part  of  the  breadth  of  a  finger  in  thickness.  Then  some 
cut  little  square  pieces  with  an  iron  tool  called  dog's 
mouth,  and  others  break  it  with  a  hot  iron  tool,  cracking 
it  as  they  wish.^    The  same  pieces  if  too  long  are  cut 

'This  mosaic,  called  the  'Navicella,'  represents  the  Gospel  ship  manned  by 
Christ  and  the  disciples,  with  Peter  struggling  in  the  waves.  It  has  been  so 
much  restored  that  little  if  any  of  Giotto's  work  remains  in  it.  It  was  replaced 
in  the  seventeenth  century,  after  some  wanderings,  in  the  porch  of  the 
present  Basilica,  but  Vasari  saw  it  of  course  in  the  porch  of  the  old,  or 
Constantinian,  church,  the  entrance  end  of  which  was  still  standing  in  his  day. 

"This  mosaic  was  executed  at  the  end  of  the  fifteenth  century  by  Domenico 
Ghirlandajo  and  his  brother  over  the  northern  door  of  the  nave  of  the 
cathedral  of  Florence.  It  is  still  in  situ  but  has  been  greatly  restored.  The 
date  1490  is  introduced  in  the  composition. 

°  This  corresponds  with  modern  practice.  The  following  is  from  a  paper  by 
Mr.  James  C.  Powell,  who,  as  practical  worker  in  glass,  has  been  engaged 
with   Sir  W.  B.   Richmond  in  the  decoration  in  mosaic  of  the  vaults  of  St 


254  OF  PAINTING 

with  emery  and  so  are  all  the  pieces  of  glass  that  have 
need  of  it.  They  are  then  put  into  boxes  and  kept 
arranged  as  is  done  with  the  pigments  for  fresco  work, 
which  are  kept  separately  in  various  little  pots  so  that 
the  mixtures  of  the  lighter  and  the  darker  tints  may  be 
ready  at  hand  for  working. 

There  is  another  sort  of  glass  covered  with  gold  that 
is  used  for  the  background  and  for  the  lights  of  the 
draperies.^"  When  the  glass  is  to  be  gilded,  the  workers 
take  the  glass  disc  which  they  have  made,  and  damp  it 
over  with  gum-water,  and  then  apply  the  gold-leaf;  this 
done  they  put  this  gold-covered  disc  on  an  iron  shovel 

Paul's.  '  The  glass  which  is  rendered  opaque  by  the  addition  of  oxide  of  tin, 
is  coloured  as  required  by  one  of  the  metallic  oxides ;  this  is  melted  in  crucibles 
placed  in  the  furnace,  and  when  sufficiently  fused  is  ladled  out  in  small  quantities 
on  to  a  metal  table,  and  pressed  into  circular  cakes  about  eight  inches  in 
diameter  and  from  three-eighths  to  half  an  inch  in  thickness ;  these  are  then 
cooled  gradually  in  a  kiln,  and  when  cold  are  ready  for  cracking  up  into 
tesserae,  which  can  be  further  subdivided  as  the  mosaicist  requires.  It  is 
the  fractured  surface  that  is  used  in  mosaic  generally,  as  that  has  a  pleasanter 
surface  and  a.  greater  richness  of  colour ;  the  thickness  of  the  cake,  therefore, 
regulates  the  limit  of  the  size  of  the  tesserae,  and  the  fractured  surface  gives 
that  roughness  of  texture  which  is  so  valuable  from  an  artistic  point  of  view.' 
[^Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,   1893-4,  P-  249). 

'"  This  is  a  point  attended  to  by  the  best  modern  workers  in  mosaic. 
Where  gold  backgrounds  are  used  it  is  advisable  to  carry  the  gold  into  the 
figures  by  using  it  as  Vasari  suggests  for  the  lights  on  the  draperies.  If  this 
were  not  done  the  figures  would  be  liable  to  tell  as  dull  masses  against  the 
more  brilliant  ground.  The  use  of  gold  backgrounds  is  specially  Byzantine. 
The  earlier  mosaics  at  Rome  and  at  Ravenna  have  backgrounds  of  blue 
generally  of  a  dark  shade,  which  is  particularly  fine  at  Ss.  Cosma  e  Damiano 
at  Rome  and  in  the  tomb  of  Galla  Placidia  at  Ravenna.  The  mosaics  at  S. 
Sophia  at  Constantinople  of  the  sixth  century  had  gold  backgrounds,  and  this 
is  the  case  also  with  all  the  later  examples  in  Italy  from  the  ninth  and  tenth 
centuries  onwards.  The  finest  displays  of  these  varied  fields  of  gold,  now 
deep  now  lustrous  of  hue,  are  to  be  seen  in  S.  Sophia,  S.  Marco  at  Venice, 
and  the  Cappella  Palatina  at  Palermo. 

Vasari's  account  of  the  fabrication  of  the  gilded  tesserae  required  for  this 
part  of  the  work  is  quite  clear  and  agrees  with  modern  practice.  The  gold 
leaf  is  hermetically  sealed  between  two  sheets  of  glass  by  the  fusion  of  a  thin 
film  over  it.  The  technique  of  the  '  fondi  d'  oro,'  or  glass  vessels  adorned 
with  designs  in  gold,  found  in  the  Roman  catacombs,  was  of  the  same  nature. 


PREPARATION   OF  MOSAIC  CUBES         255 

and  that  in  the  mouth  of  the  furnace,  first  covering  with 
a  thin  piece  of  glass  all  the  glass  disc  that  they  had  coated 
with  gold.  These  coverings  are  made  either  of  glass 
bubbles  or  of  broken  bottles  so  that  one  piece  covers  the 
whole  disc,  and  it  is  then  held  in  the  furnace  till  it  becomes 
almost  red,  and  quickly  drawn  out,  when  the  gold  at  once 
becomes  admirably  set  so  as  to  be  imprinted  in  the  glass 
and  remain  there.  This  is  impervious  to  water  and  resists 
every  attack,  and  afterwards  the  disc  is  cut  and  disposed 
as  the  other  coloured  pieces  described  above. 

§  96.  The  Fixing  of  the  Mosaic  Cubes. 

In  order  to  fix  the  mosaic  in  the  wall,  the  custom  is  to 
make  a  coloured  cartoon,  though  some  make  it  without 
colour,  and  to  trace  or  mark  the  cartoon  bit  by  bit  on 
the  stucco. ^^  and  then  to  proceed  to  arrange  the  pieces 

^^  It  has  been  noticed  at  some  places,  as  at  Torcello,  that  before  the  cubes 
were  laid  in  the  soft  cement  the  whole  design  was  washed  in  in  colour  on  the 
surface  of  the  cement.  This  facilitated  correct  setting  and  avoided  any 
appearance  of  white  cement  squeezed  up  in  the  interstices  between  the  cubes. 
On  this  particular  feature  of  the  mosaic  technique  Berger  has  founded  an 
ingenious  theory  of  the  origin  of  painting  in  fresco.  It  is  his  thesis,  in  his 
Beitr'dge  zur  Entwickhtngs-Geschichte  der  Maltechnik,  I,  MUnchen,  1904,  that 
the  ancients  did  not  employ  the  fresco  process,  but  that  this  was  evolved 
in  early  mediaeval  days  out  of  the  mosaic  technique  as  seen,  e.g.,  at  Torcello. 
''xhe  stucco,  that  Vasari  describes,  must  be  put  on  portion  by  portion,  for  it 
only  keeps  soft  two  or  three  days,  and  can  only  be  used  for  setting  the  cubes 
while  in  a  moist  state.  Now,  Berger  contends,  if  the  design  for  the  mosaic 
be  painted  in  colours  on  the  wet  stucco,  and  the  whole  allowed  to  dry,  without 
any  use  of  the  mosaic  cubes,  we  should  have  a  painting  in  fresco,  and  he 
imagines  that  fresco  painting  began  in  this  way.  Unfortunately  for  the  theory, 
(i),  the  testimony  of  Vitruvius  and  Pliny  is  absolutely  decisive  in  favour  of 
the  knowledge  in  antiquity  of  the  fresco  technique,  and,  (2),  the  use  of  the 
coloured  painting  on  the  stucco  as  a  guide  for  the  setting  of  the  cubes  was 
not  normal,  and  can  never  have  been  used  so  freely  as  to  give  rise  to  a  new 
technique  of  painting.  As  a  fact,  this  colouring  of  the  stucco  is  objected  to  by 
the  best  modern  workers  on  aesthetic  grounds,  for  they  point  out  that  the  lines 
of  grey  cement  between  the  coloured  cubes  answer  to  the  lead  lines  in  the 
stained  glass  window,  and  should  be  reckoned  with  by  the  designer  as  part  of 
his  artistic  effect.  No  doubt  the  older  mosaicists,  like  the  workers  in  stained 
glass,  instinctively  apprehended  this,  and  had  no  desire  for  the  coloured  cement. 


256  OF   PAINTING 

as  many  as  are  needed  to  fill  in  the  mosaic  work.  The 
stucco,  when  put  on  in  a  thick  coat  over  the  wall,  remains 
available  two  days  and  sometimes  four,  according  to.  the 
kind  of  weather.  It  is  made  of  travertine,  lime,^^  pounded 
brick,  gum-tragacanth  and  white  of  egg,  and  once  made 
it  is  kept  moist  with  damp  cloths.  Thus  then,  bit  by  bit, 
they  cut  the  cartoons  for  the  wall,  and  trace  the  design 
on  the  stucco;  afterwards  with  certain  little  tongs,  they 
pick  up  the  bits  of  vitreous  paste  and  fit  them  together 
in  the  stucco,  and  give  lights  to  the  lights,  middle  tints 
to  the  middle  tints  and  darks  to  the  darks,  imitating 
minutely  the  shadows,  the  lights,  and  the  half  tints  as 
they  are  in  the  cartoons. ^^  Thus,  working  with  diligence 
they  gradually  bring  it  all  to  perfection,  and  he  who  best 

'^  One  would  expect  here  '  lime  of  travertine,'  for  what  Vasari  must  mean 
is  lime  prepared  by  burning  this  stone,  which  he  recommends  elsewhere,  e.g. 
'  Architettura, '  cap.  iv,  and  'Scultura,'  cap.  vi  (calce  di  trevertino).  The 
cement  here  given  is  a  lime  cement  mixed  with  water.  A  sort  of  putty 
mixed  with  boiled  oil  is  also  employed,  and  is  said  to  have  been  introduced 
by  Girolamo  Muziano  of  Brescia,  a  contemporary  of  Vasari.  Each  mosaic 
worker  seems  to  have  his  own  special  recipe  for  this  compound. 

'^  The  process  described  by  Vasari  of  building  up  the  mosaic  in  situ,  tessera 
by  tessera,  according  to  the  design  pounced  portion  by  portion  on  the  soft 
cement,  is  the  most  direct  and  by  far  the  most  artistic,  and  was  employed 
for  all  the  fine  mosaics  of  olden  time.  In  modern  days  labour-saving  appli- 
ances have  been  tried,  though  it  is  satisfactory  to  know  that  they  are  all  again 
discarded  in  the,best  work  of  to-day,  such  as  that  of  Sir  W.  B.  Richmond 
in  St.  Paul's^''^ne  of  the  methods  referred  to,  which  can  be  carried  out  in 
the  studio,  is  to  take  a  reversed  tracing  of  the  design,  covered  with  gum,  and 
place  the  cubes  face  downwards  upon  it  according  to  the  colour  scheme. 
When  they  are  all  in  position,  as  far  as  can  be  judged  when  working  from 
the  back,  a  coating  of  cement  is  laid  over  them  and  they  are  thus  fixed  in 
their  places.  The  whole  sheet  is  then  lifted  up  and  cemented  in  its  proper 
place  on  the  wall,  the  drawing  to  which  the  faces  of  the  cubes  are  gummed 
being  afterwards  removed  by  wetting.  A  better  plan  than  this  is  called  by 
the  Italians  '  Mosaico  a  rivoltatura.'  For  this  process  the  tesserae  are  laid, 
face  upwards,  in  a  bed  of  pozzolana,  slightly  damp,  which  forms  a  temporary 
joint  between  the  adjacent  cubes.  Coarse  canvas  is  pasted  over  the  face  of  the 
work  ;  it  is  lifted  up,  and  the  pozzolana  brushed  out  of  the  interstices.  The 
whole  is  then  applied  to  the  wall  surface  and  pressed  into  the  cement  with 
which  this  has  been  coated.  When  the  cement  has  set  the  canvas  is  removed 
from  the  face. 


-  FIXING   QF   T§E   MOSAIC    CUBES  257 

succeeds  in  joining  it  so  that  it  comes  out  even  and  smooth, 
is  most  worthy  of  praise  and  is  more  esteemed  than  the 
others.  Some  are  so  clever  in  working  mosaic  that  they 
make  it  appear  as  if  painted  in  fresco.  So  firmly  does 
the  glass  harden  into  the  stucco,  after  the  latter  has  set, 
that  this  mosaic  lasts  for  ever — as  is  testified  by  the  antique 
mosaics,  which  are  in  Rome,  and  those  also  which  are 
of  the  older  (modern)  times.  In  both  methods  of  working 
the  moderns  of  our  days  have  done  marvellous  things. 


CHAPTER   XVI.     (XXX.) 

Concerning  the  Compositions  and  Figures  made   in    Inlaid   Work   on 
Pavements  in  imitation  of  objects  in  monochrome. 

§  97.  Pavements  in  Marble  Mosaic  and  Monochrome. 

To  the  mosaic  in  small  pieces  our  modern  masters  have 
added  another  kind  of  mosaic,  that  of  marbles  fitted 
tog^ether  to  counterfeit  paiated  groiip.s  in  monochrome. 
This  art  takes  its  origin  from  the  very  ardent  desire  that 
there  should  remain  in  the  world  to  those  who  come  after, 
even  if  other  kinds  of  painting  were  to  be  destroyed,  a 
light  that  may  keep  alive  the  jnemory:^of  modern  painters. 
Hence  they  have  produced  with  wondrous  skill  very  large 
compositions  that  can  be  placed  not  only  on  the  pavements, 
where  one  walks,  but  also  on  the  face  of  walls  and  palaces, 
with  such  beautiful  and  marvellous  art  that  there  can  be 
no  danger  lest  time  should  waste  away  the  design  of  those 
who  excel  in  this  profession.  Examples  of  these  works 
can  be  seen  in  the  Duomo  at  Siena  begun  first  by  Duccio 
oL-Siena,  then  added  to  by  Domenico  Beccafumi,  and 
continued  by  others  even  to  our  own  day.^ 

'The  Duomo  of  Siena  is  a  veritable  museum  of  floor  decorations  in  incised 
outlines  and  in  black  and  white,  in  the  various  processes  described  by  Vasari. 
There  is  a  good  notice  of  them  in  Labarte,  Histoire  des  Arts  Industriek. 
None  of  the  work  is  as  early  as  the  time  of  Duccio,  but  Beccafiimi  executed 
a  large  amount  of  it.  See  the  Life  of  that  artist  by  Vasari. 
f  It  is  worthy  of  notice  that  Dante  had  something  of  this  kind  in  his  thoughts, 
when  in  the  12th  Canto  of  the  Purgatorio  he  describes  the  figure  designs  on  the 
ground  of  the  first  circle  of  Purgatory. 
'  So  saw  I  there  .  .  . 

.  .  .  with  figures  covered 
Whate'er  of  pathway  from  the  mount  projects. 


PAVEMENTS   IN   MARBLE   MOSAIC         259 

This  art  possesses  so  much  that  is  good,  new,  and 
durable,  that  for  pictorial  work  made  up  of  black  and 
white  greater  excellence  and  beauty  can  hardly  be  desired. 
It  is  composed  of  three  sorts  nf  marhlft,  which  come  from 
the  Carrara  mountains;'^  one  of  these  is  the  finest_piire 
white  marble;  another  is  not  white  but  inclines  to  a  livid 
tint,  which  furnishes  a  middle  shade ;  and  the  third  is  grey 
marble  that  inclines  towards  a  silvery  hue,  and  this  serves 
for  dark.  When  the  artist  wishes  to  compose  a  figure 
from  these  marbles  he  first  prepares  a  cartoon  in  light  and 
shade  with  the  same  tints,  and  that  done,  following  the 
outlines  of  those  medium  and  dark  and  pale  tints,  he 
fUs-logether  with  great  care  in  their  proper  places  first 
of  all  in  the  middle,  the  light  of  that  pure  white  marble, 
and  then  the  half  tones  and  the  darks  beside  them,  accord- 
ing  to  the  actual  outlines  that  the  artist  has  drawn  in  the 
cartoon.  When  all  thepieces  of  marble,  the  light  pieces 
as  well  as  the  darks  and  half  tints,  are  joined  together 
and  are  laid  quite  fiat,  the  artist  who  has  prepared  the 
cartoon  takes  a  fine  brush  dipped  in  moist  black,  and,  with 
all  the  work  fitted  together  before  him  on  the  ground, 
traces  in  lines  the  contours  and  where  the  shadows  come, 
in  the  same  manner  in  which  one  would  prepare  an  out- 
lined drawing  for  monochrome.  That  done  the  carver 
proceeds  to  cut  in  with  chisels  all  those  lines  and  contours 

O  Niobe  !  with  what  afflicted  eyes 

Thee  I  beheld  upon  the  pathway  traced, 

Between  thy  seven  and  seven  children  slain ! 
O  Saul !  how  fallen  upon  thy  proper  sword 

Didst  thou  appear  there  lifeless  in  Gilboa 

That  felt  thereafter  neither  rain  nor  dew  ! 


Whoe'er  of  pencil  master  was  or  stile, 

That  could  portray  the  shades  and  traits  which  there 
Would  cause  each  subtle  genius  to  admire? 
Dead  seemed  the  dead,  the  living  seemed  alive ; 
Better  than  I  saw  not  who  saw  the  truth, 
All  that  I  trod  upon  while  bowed  I  went.' 

Longfellow's  Translation. 
^See  Note  on  'Tuscan  Marble  Quarries,'  ante,  p.  119. 


26o  OF   PAINTING 

that  the  painter  has  made,  and  he  ^Qs^jlims-CMi  all  that 
part  which  the  brush  has  marked  with  black.  Having 
finished  this,  the  pieces  are  bjnlElD-XUi-rhelUrbit  by  bit, 
and  then  with  a  mixture  of  boiled  WadL.Silcli,--QJ^-asptiak, 
or  hlark  eartJT^aUjheJiollows  which  the  chiseLhas_made 
are  filledTup;  WheiTthe"  material  is  cold__and  has  set, 
the'worker  proceeds  to  remove  and  rub  away  the  projectijig 
parts  with  pieces  of  soft  stone,  and  to  smooth  and  polish 
witih  sand,  bricks,  and  water,  till  all  that  remains  is 
brought  to  a  true  surface,  that  is,  the  marble  itself  and  the 
substance  put  in  to  fill  up  the  hollows.  When  that  is  done 
the  work  remains  in  aspect  exacdy  like  a  flat^pjcturgju  and 
possesses  great  force  combined  with  art  and  masterly 
skill.  This  kind  of  work  has  come  much  into  use  on 
account  of  its  beauty. 

§  98.  Pavements  in  Variegated  Tiles. 

Hence  it  is  that  the  pavements  of  many  apartments  in 
our  day  are  made  of  variegated  bricks,  one  portion  of  wjiitg 
clay,  that  is  of  clay  that  draws  towards  a  bluish^sbaide  when 
it  is  fresh  and  when  baked  becomes  whit£.  and  the  other 
portion  ot  the  ordinary  earth  torrnaking  bricks_which 
becomes  red  when  baked.  Of  these  two  sorts  are  made 
pavements,  inlaid  in  various  designs  and  compartments, 
as  the  papal  halls  at  Romfi-in  the  time  of  Raffaello  da 
Urbino  bear  testimony;  ^  and  now  recently  many  apart- 
ments in  the  castle  of  Sant'  Angelo  where  emblems  of  lilies 
of  fitted  pieces  showing  the  arms  of  Pope  Paolo,  and  many 
other  devices,   have  been  rnade  witti  tftese  same  bricks. 

°  The  Appartamento  Borgia  still  contains  a  good  display  of  these  variegated 
tiles  ;  the  original  ones  are  however  rather  the  worse  for  wear.  In  the  Life  of 
Raphael.  Vasari  says  they  wprp  siippHprl  hy  tht-  Hplla  Rr.V.l-.iti  nf  •Rl^rfnrf.^  in  the 
Castle  of  S.  Angelo  there  is  a  collection  of  interesting  specimens  of  the  tiles 
Vasari  goes  on  to  mention.  They  are  in  cases  in  the  Sala  della  Giustizia,  and 
exhibit  the  devices  of  Alexander  VI,  Julius  II,  Leo  X,  Paul  III,  and  other 
Popes.  The  pavement  of  the  Laurentian  Lihrarv  at  Florence  is  laid  with 
tilesshowing  a  very  effective  desipjn  of  yellow  upon  red.  Tliey  are  ascribed 
taJIubali?. 


PAVEMENTS   IN   TILES   AND   BRE££IA      261 

In  Florence  also  there  is  the  pavement  of  the  library  of 
San  Lorenzo  ordered  to  be  made  by  Duke  Cosimo.  All 
have  been  executed  with  such  great  care  that  anything 
more  beautiful  in  that  sort  of  workmanship  cannot  be 
desired,  and  the  point  of  departure  for  all  these  inlaid 
things  was  the  first  mosaic. 

§  99.  Pavements  in  Breccia  Marble. 

To  explain  why  no  mention  was  made  of  some  breccias 
recently  discovered  by  Uiike—Coaimo  while  stones  and 
marbles  of  all  sorts  were  being  spoken  of — I  may  say 
that  in  the  year  1563  His  Excellency  found  in  the  moun- 
tains  of  Pielrptjantp,  near  to  the  village  of  Stazzema,  a 
hill  which  extends  for  two  miles,  whose  outeji_cnist_is 
of  white  marble  excellent  for  statues.  The  under  layer 
is  a  red  and  yellowish  breccia,  and  those  farther  down 
are  greenish,  black,  red,  and  yellow  with  various  other 
mixtures  of  colour;  _ajl  these  marbles  arp  hard,  and  their 
nature  is  such  that  thp  farther  one  penetrates  inwards 
the  greater  is  their  solidity.  Up  to  the  present  time  there 
can  be  seen  quarried  from  thence  columns  of  fifteen  to 
twenty  braccia;  but  these  marbles  are  not  yet  put  into  use, 
because  a  road  three  miles  in  length  is  only  now  being 
constructed  by  order  of  his  Excellency  to  make  it  possible 
to  transport  the  marbles  from  the  said  quarries  to  the  sea 
shore.*  These  breccias  will,  so  far  as  one  can  see,  be 
most  suitable  for  pavements. 

*  Was  this  the  road  from  Seravezza  seawards  which  Michelangelo  had  begun  ? 
See  Note  on  'Tuscan  Marble  Quarries,'  ante,  p.  iig.  Specimens  of  these 
Stazzema  breccias  are  shown  as  C,  D,  on  the  Frontispiece. 


CHAPTER   XVII.     (XXXI.) 

Of  Mosaic  in  wood,  that  is,  of  Tarsia ;  and  of  the  Compositions  that 
are  made  in  Tinted  Woods,  fitted  together  after  the  manner  of 
a  picture. 

§  loo.  Inlays  in  Wood. 

How  easy  a  thing  it  is  to  add  some  new  discovery  to  the 
inventions  of  the  past,  is  clearly  shown  to  us,  not  only  by 
the  aforesaid  fitted  pavement,  which  without  doubt  comes 
from  mosaic  work,  but  also  by  these  same  tarsias  and  the 
figures  of  many  different  things,  that  closely  resembling 
mosaic  and  painting  have  been  made  by  our  elder  artists 
out  of' little  pieces  of  wood,  variously  coloured,  fitted  and 
joined  together  in  panels  of  walnut.  This  is  called  by 
the  moderns  '  lavoiOjiLcaonnesso  '  (inlaid  work)  although 
to  the  elder  artists  it  was  tarsia.  The  best  specimens  of 
this  work  were  to  be  found  in  Florence  in  the  time  of 
Filippo  di  Ser  Brunellesco  and  afterwards  in  that  of 
Benedetto  _da-MaLajiQx-.  who,  however,  strangely  enough 
judged  tarsia  a  useless  thing  and  completely  abandoned 
it  as  will  be  told  in  his  Life.  He,  like  the  others  of  past 
times,  executed  tarsia  in  black  and  white  only,  but  Fra 
Giovanni  of  Verona  who  was  very  proficient  in  the  art 
improved  it  greatly,  giving  various  colours  to  the  woods 
by  means  of  dyes  in  ■boiling  water  and  of  penetrating 
oiis*— in_oide.r  to  produce  the  lights  and  shadows  with 
these  variously  tinted  woods,  as  in  the  art  of  painting, 
and  skilfully  putting  in  the  high  lights  by  means  of  the 


INLAYS   IN   WOOD  263 

very  white  wood  of  the  silio.^  This  work  began  in  the 
first  instance  with  designs  in  perspective,  because  the 
forms  in  these  end  with  plane  angles,  and  the  pieces 
joined  together  showed  the  contours,  and  the  work 
appeared  all  of  one  flat  piece,  though  it  was  made  up  of 
more  than  a  thousand.  The  ancients  worked  however  in 
the  same  manner  with  incrustations  of  fj""  gfnni»g ;  as  is 
plainly  seen  in  the  portico  of  St  Peter's,  where  there  is  a 
cage  with  a  bird  and  all  the  details  of  the  wooden  bars 
etc.,  on  a  ground  of  porphyry  inlaid  with  other  different 
stones.^  But,  because  w_ood  is  more  pliant  and  much 
more  amenable  for  this  work,  our  masters  have  b^en  able 

to    make    more    ahimrlant    iigp    r»f    it.  anH    in    thp    way    that 

best  pleased  them.  Formerly  for  making  the  shadows 
thev  used  to  scorch  the  wood  with  fire  on  one  side,  this 
imitated  shade  well ;  hut  nthpr";  aftprwardg  havp  used  nil 
of  sulphur  and  corrosive  sublimate  and  preparations  of 
artjpnjrj  with  whirh  siihstanrps  they  have  obtained  the 
hues  that  they  desired,  as  is  seen  in  the  work  of  Fra 
Damiano  in  San  Domenico  in  Bologna.^  And  because 
such  a  line  of  work  consists  only  in  the  choice  of  designs 
that  may  be  adapted  to  it — those  containing  blocks  of 
buildings  and  objects  with  rectangular  outlines  to  which 
force  and  projection  can  be  lent  by  means  of  light  and 
shade — it  has  always  been  exercised  by  persons  possessing 
more  patience  than  skill  in  design.  And  thus  it  is  that 
though  many  things  have  been  produced  in  this  line,  such 
as  representations  of  figures,  fruit,  and  animals,  some 
of  which  are  in  truth  most  life-like,  yet  since  it  is  a  work 
that  ""OE  hprnmpg  hlarV  pnH  docs  uot  do  more  than 
counterfeit  painting,  being  less  than  painting,  and  is  also 
of  short  duration  because  of  worms  and  fire,  it  is  con- 

^  Lat.  Evonymus  Europaeus.  The.  only  English  example  of  the  family  is  the 
spindle  tree. 

^The  Lemonnier  editors  say  that  this  work  is  lost.  Of  course  Vasari  is 
speaking  of  the  Old  St.  Peter's,  not  the  present  structure. 

'Fra  Damiano  of  Bergamo  is  mentioned  by  Vasari  in  his  Life  of  Francesco 
Salviati  (Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  vii). 


264  OF  PAINTING 

sidered  time  thrown  away  in  vain  to  practise  it,  altiiough 
it  may  indeed  be  both  praiseworthy  and  masterly.* 

*  Inlays    nf    diffprpnt    coloured    woods,     fffTpiing    what is known    as    farsia 

wnrlf,  and  fjnmgtjmes  as  marqueterje,  compose  an  easily  understood  kind  of 
decoration  that  has  been  practised  especia^ly  jti  the  East  from  timp  irpmpnmrigl 
There  is  however  a  special  interest  attaching  to  this  work  in  the  Italy  of  the 
fifteenth  century,  in  that  it  was  connected  with  the  studies  in  perspective  that 
had  so  potent  an  influence  on  the  general  artistic  progress  of  the  time.  For 
some  reason  that  is  not  clearly  apparent  the  designs  for  this  work  often  took 
the  form  of  buildinp^s  and  dttt.  views  in  perspectivg.  and  artists  amused  them- 
selves in  working  out  in  this  form  problems  in  that  indispensable  science. 
The  history  of  the  craft  is  so  instructive  that  it  is  worth  a  special  Note, 
which  the  reader  will  find  at  the  end  of  this  'Introduction,'  postea,  p.  303. 


CHAPTER   XVIII.     (XXXII.) 

On  Painting  Glass  Windows  and  how  they  are  put  together  with 
Leads  and  supported  with  Irons  so  as  not  to  interfere  with  the 
view  of  the  figures. 

§  loi.  Stained  Glass  Windows;  their  Origin  and  History. 

Formerly  the  ancients  were  in  the  habit  of  filling  in 
their  windows,  but  only  in  the  houses  of  great  men,  or 
of  those  at  least  of  some  importance,  in  such  a  manner 
as  to  prevent  the  wind  or  cold  from  entering,  while  not 
excluding  the  light.  This  plan  was  adopted  only  in  their 
baths  and  sweating  rooms,  vapour  baths  and  other  retiring 
rooms,  and  the  apertures  and  vacant  places  of  these  were 
closed  with  transparent  stones,  such  as  onyx  marbles, ^ 
alabasters,  and  other  delicate  marbles  that  are  variegated 
or  that  incline  towards  a  yellowish  tint.  But  the  moderns, 
who  have  had  glass  furnaces  in  much  greater  abundance, 
have  made  the  windows  of  glass,   either  of  bull's-eyes  ^ 

' '  The  onyx  marbles  of  Algeria,  Mexico,  and  California  (which  are  of  the 
same  nature  as  the  Oriental  alabasters)  can  be  cut  and  ground  sufficiently  thin 
for  window  purposes'  (Mr.  W.  Brindley  in  Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  1887, 
p.  53).     See  also  ante,  p.  43. 

^  The  '  occhi '  of  Vasari  correspond  to  the  old-fashioned  '  bull's  eyes '  which 
are  still  to  be  seen  surviving  in  cottage  windows.  The  'bull's  eve'  pane  w;^ 
the  middle  part  of  a  sheet  of  so-called  '  crown '  glass  where  was  attached  the 
irnn  rnri  nr  tiiVic  with  wViirh  thp  mass  of  molten  jrlass  was  extracted  from  the 

fiii-n<jfa,     hcfnro^     Ky    rr|^-^fjr>n     nf     tVlP     rcA       1>    i.rac    cpvoo^      fM.^     ^^tr,     fl^p     fnm,     nf   g 

slissf.  When  the  rod  was  ultimately  detached  a  knob  remained,  and  this  part 
of  the  sheet  was  used  for  glazing  as  a  cheap  'waste  product.'  In  connection 
with  the  modern  revival  in  domestic  architecture,  for  which  iVTr.  Norman 
Shaw  deserves  a  good  deal  of  the  credit,  these  rough  panes  have  come  again 
into  fashion,  and  manufacturers  make  them  specially  and  supply  them  at  the 
price  of  an  artistic  luxury  !     In  Vasari's  time  they  were  evidently  quite  common. 


266  OF   PAINTING 

or  of  panes,  similar  to  or  in  imitation  of  those  that  the 
ancients  made  of  stone;  and  they  have  fastened  them 
together  and  bound  them  with  strips  of  lead,  grooved  on 
both  sides,  and  furnished  them  and  secured  them  with 
irons  let  into  the  walls  for  this  purpose,  or  indeed  into 
wooden  frames,^  as  we  shall  relate.  Whereas  at  first 
the  windows  used  to  be  made  simply  of  clear  bull's-eyes 
with  white  or  coloured  corners,  afterwards  the  artists 
thought  of  making  a  mosaic  of  the  shapes  of  these  glasses 
differently  coloured  and  joined  after  the  manner  of  a 
picture.*  And  so  refined  has  the  skill  in  this  art  become, 
that  in  our  days  glass  windows  are  seen  carried  to  the 
same  perfection  that  is  arrived  at  in  fine  pictures  upon 
panel,  with  all  their  harmony  of  colour  and  finish  of 
execution,  and  this  we  shall  amply  show  in  the  Life  of 
the  Frenchman  Guglielmo  da  Marcilla.^ 

and  we  find  numerous  specimens  represented  in  the  pictures  of  the  fifteenth 
and  sixteenth  centuries.  Tht.  KcHi-rn^pi  nf  g — IXiaiLlajn_£aj3ja£ciBls-^etw*.at 
Venice ;  the  cell  of  S.  Terome  '"  Purer's  engraving ;  the  room  in  which  van 
Eyck  paints  Arnolfini  and  his  wife,  those  "in  which  Jost  Amman's  'jHand- 
workers'  are  busy,  etc.,  etc.,  have  casements  glazed  in  this  fashion,  [the  knob, 
called  in  English  'bullion,'  in  French  'boudine,'  in  German  'Butzen,'  being 
distinctly  represented  as  in  relief. 

'The  'telajo  di  legno'  is  a  window  frame  of  wood  such  as  we  are  familiar 
with  in  modern  days,  only  in  olden  times  these  were  often  made  detachable 
and  taken  about  from  place  to  place  when  lords  and  ladies  changed  their 
domicile.  When  Julius  II  wanted  Bramante  to  fill  some  windows  of  the 
Vatican  with  coloured  glass,  it  was  found  that  the  French  ambassador  to  the 
Papal  court  had  brought  a,  painted  window  in  such  a  frame  from  his  own 
country,  and  the  sight  of  this  led  to  the  invitation  to  Rome  of  French  artists 
in  this  material.     See  infra.  Note  5. 

*  See  Note  on  '  The  Stained  Glass  Window '  at  the  close  of  this  '  Introduction,' 
postea,  p.  308. 

'  Vasari  wrote  the  life  of  this  artist,  who  had  been  his  own  teacher  in  early 
years  at  Arezzo  {Opere,  iv,  417).  Gaye,  Carteggio,  11,  449,  gives  documentary 
evidence  that  he  was  the  son  of  a  certain  Pierre  de  Marcillat,  and  was  born 
at  S.  Michel  in  the  diocese  of  Verdun  in  France.  His  name  therefore  has 
nothing  to  do  with  Marseilles,  which  moreover  is  not  in  a  glass-painting 
locality,  whereas  Verdun,  between  France  and  Germany,  is  just  in  the 
region  where  the  art  was  developed  and  flourished.  Guglielmo  and  another 
Frenchman    named    Claude  came  to   Rome  about   1508  in  the  circumstances 


STAINED   GLASS   WINDOWS  267 

In  this  art  the  Flemings  and  the  French  have  succeeded 
better  than  the  other  nations,  seeing  that  they,  with  their 
cunning  researches  into  pigments  and  the  action  on  them 
of  fire,  have  managed  to  burn  in  the  colours  that  are  put 
on  the  glass,  so  that  wind,  air,  and  rain  may  do  them  no 
injury,  whereas  formerly  it  was  customary  to  paint 
windows  in  colours  coated  with  gum  and  other  temperas 
that  wasted  away  through  time  and  were  carried  off  by 
the  winds,  mists,  and  rains,  till  nothing  was  left  but  the 
mere  colour  of  the  glass.  In  the  present  age,  we  see  this 
art  brought  to  that  high  grade  beyond  which  one  can 
hardly  desire  further  perfection  of  fineness  and  beauty 
and  of  every  quality  which  contributes  thereto.  It  supplies 
a  delicate  loveliness  not  less  beneficial  to  health,  through 
securing  the  rooms  from  wind  and  foul  airs,  than  useful 
and  convenient  on  account  of  the  clear  and  unimpeded 
light  that  by  its  means  is  offered  to  us. 

In  order  to  produce  such  windows,  three  things  are 
necessary,  namely,  luminous  transparency  in  the  glasses 
chosen,^  beautiful  arrangement  in  that  which  is  worked 
out  with  them,  and  clear  colour  without  any  confusion. 
Transparency  is  secured  by  knowing  how  to  choose  glasses 

described  in  the  foregoing  Note,  and  made  some  windows  for  the  Sala  Regia 
of  the  Vatican  and  other  parts  of  the  Palace.  These  have  all  perished,  but 
there  still  survive  two  windows  from  their  hands  in  the  choir  of  S.  Maria 
del  Popolo,  on  which  are  the  name  and  arms  of  Pope  Julius  II.  They  are 
placed  north  and  south  behind  and  above  the  high  altar,  and  have  each  three 
lights.  They  contain  scenes  from  the  lives  of  Christ  and  the  Madonna,  in 
which  the  figures  are  carefully  drawn  but  the  colour  is  patchy.  Though  the 
reds  are  clear  and  strong,  there  is  a  good  deal  of  grey  and  the  architectural 
backgrounds  are  rather  muddy  in  hue.  The  artist  was  invited  from  Rome  to 
Cortona  and  from  thence  to  Arezzo,  which  as  Vasari  notices  in  the  beginning  of 
his  Life  remained  his  home  to  the  end.  He  executed  many  windows  there,  in 
the  cathedral  and  in  S.  Francesco,  some  of  which  still  remain  ;  and  also  works  in 
fresco.     Vasari  declares  that  he  owed  to  his  teaching  the  first  principles  of  art. 

On  the  whole  subject  of  the  glass-painting  craft  see  the  Note  on  '  The  Stained 
Glass  Wfindow,'  postea,  p.  308,  where  the  curious  confiision  of  two  different 
processes,  between  which  Vasari's  treatment  oscillates,  is  elucidated. 

'The  significance  of  Vasari's  demand  for  transparency  in  glass  is  explained  in 
the  Note,  postea,  p.  308. 


268  OF   PAINTING 

that  are  clear  in  themselves,  and  in  this  respect  French, 
Flemish,  and  English  glasses  are  better  than  the  Venetian,'' 
because  the  Flemish  are  very  clear  and  the  Venetian  much 
charged  with  colour.  In  clear  glasses  when  shaded  with 
darker  tints  the  light  is  not  totally  lost,  they  are  trans- 
parent even  in  their  shadows,  but  the  Venetian,  being 
obscure  in  their  nature  and  darker  still  in  their  shadow, 
lose  all  transparency.  Again  many  delight  in  having  the 
glasses  loaded  with  colours  artificially  laid  on  so  that  when 
the  air  and  sun  strike  upon  them,  they  exhibit  I  cannot 
tell  how  much  more  beauty  than  do  the  natural  colours; 
nevertheless,  it  is  better  to  have  the  glasses  clear  in  their 
own  substance,  rather  than  obscure,  so  that  when  heavily 
coloured  they  may  not  be  left  too  dim. 

§   102.  The  Technique  of  the  Stained  Glass  Window.^ 

For  painting  on  glass,  we  must  first  have  a  cartoon 
on  which  are  drawn  the  outlines  of  the  figures  and  of  the 
folds  of  the  drapery.  These  show  where  the  pieces  of 
glass  have  to  be  joined;  then  the  bits  of  red,  yellow,  blue, 
and  white  glass  must  be  picked  out  and  divided  according 
to  the  design  for  the  flesh  parts  and  for  the  draperies,  as 
occasion  demands.  To  bring  each  piece  of  glass  to  the 
dimensions  traced  on  the  cartoon,  the  said  pieces  are  laid 
on  the  cartoon  and  the  outline  marked  with  a  brush  dipped 

'  It  is  somewhat  remarkable  that  the  Venetians,  who  pranHspH  thp  arf  r.f  [rlagg 
mosaic  from  about  the  ninth  centarv.  and  in  the  thirteenth  bepan  their  famonf; 
glass  works,  never  achieved  anything  in  the  technique  of  tht;  -jtajpeH  plass 
window.  Vene'tian  glass  vessels,  like  the  glorious  lamps  from  the  Cairo  Mosques. 
jiwe  much  of  their  beauty  to  the  fact  that  the  material  is  not  clarified  but 
possesses  a  beautiful  warm  tone.     It  is  indeed  more  difficult  to  get  dear  plass 

than  tinted- 

'  For  the  most  part  this  description,  with  the  exception  of  the  part  about  scaling- 
ofif  glass  in  order  to  introduce  a  variety  in  colour,  corresponds  closely  with  the 
technical  directions  which  Theophilus  gives  so  fully  and  clearly  in  his  Schedula 
Diversarum  Artium  of  about  lioo  A.D.  It  is  pretty  clear  that  Vasari  is 
telling  us  here  what  he  learned  from  William  of  Marcillat  who  would  have 
inherited  the  traditions  of  the  great  French  glass-painters  of  the  thirteenth 
century. 


STAINED   GLASS   WINDOWS  269 

in  white  lead,  and  to  each  piece  is  assigned  its  number 
in  order  to  find  it  easily  when  joining  them  together; 
when  the  work  is  finished  the  numbers  are  rubbed  oflf. 
When  this  is  done,  in  order  to  cut  the  pieces  to  measure, 
the  workman,  having  first  drawn  an  emery  point  over  the 
upper  surface  of  the  glass  along  the  outline,  which  he 
damps  with  saliva,  takes  a  red-hot  pointed  tool  and  pro- 
ceeds to  pass  the  point  along  the  outlines,  keeping  a  little 
within  them ;  as  he  gradually  moves  the  tool,  the  glass 
cracks  and  snaps  off  from  the  sheet.  Then  with  the  emery 
point  he  trims  the  said  pieces,  removing  the  superfluous 
part,  and  with  a  tool  called  '  grisatoio  '  or  '  topo  '  (grozing 
iron)  which  nibbles  the  traced  edges,  he  makes  them  exact 
and  ready  to  be  joined  all  round. 

In  this  manner  then  the  bits  of  glass  fitted  together 
are  spread  on  a  flat  table  above  the  cartoon,  and  the  artist 
begins  to  paint  in  the  shadows  over  the  draperies,  using 
for  this  the  ground  scales  of  iron  and  of  another  rust  ^ 
found  in  iron  pits,  which  is  red,  or  else  hard  red  haematite 
finely  ground,  and  with  these  pigments  he  shades  the 
flesh,  using  alternately  black  and  red,  according  to  need. 
To  produce  the  flesh  tints  it  is  necessary  to  glaze  all  the 
glasses  with  this  red,  and  the  draperies  with  the  black, 
the  colours  being  tempered  with  gum,i°  and  so  gradually 
to  paint  and  shade  the  glasses  to  correspond  with  the 
tints  on  the  cartoon.  When  this  process  is  finished,  the 
worker,  desiring  to  put  in  the  brightest  lights,  takes  a 
short  thin  brush  of  hog's  bristles  and  with  it  scratches 
the  glass  over  the  light,  and  removes  some  of  that  coat 
of  the  first  colour  that  had  been  given  all  over,  and  with 

"The  'scaglia'  is  the  thin  scale  that  comes  oflf  heated  iron  when  cooling  under 
the  hammer,  and  is  collected  from  the  floors  of  smithies.  Vasari  thinks  of  it  as  a 
'  rust'  'ruggine,'  because  rusty  iron  scales  off  in  much  the  same  way,  the  cause  in 
both  cases  probably  being  oxidization.     Hence  the  expression  'another  rust.' 

'The  pigments  or  pastes  that  are  to  be  fused  on  to  the  coloured  glass,  to 
modify  its  hue  or  to  indicate  details,  are  powdered  and  mixed  with  gum  for 
convenience  in  application.  The  gum  is  not  to  serve  as  permanent  binding 
material  as  the  pastes  are  subsequently  fused  and  burnt  in  on  the  glass. 


270  OF   PAINTING 

the  handle  of  the  brush  picks  out  the  lights  on  the  hair, 
the  beard,  the  drapery,  the  buildings,  and  the  landscapes 
as  he  sees  fit.  There  are  great  difficulties  however  in  this 
work ;  and  he  who  delights  in  it  may  put  various  colours 
on  the  glass,  for  example,  if  he  trace  a  leaf  or  other  minute 
object  over  a  red  colour,  intending  it  to  come  out  in  the 
fire  a  different  tint,  he  removes  from  the  glass  a  scale 
the  size  of  the  leaf,  with  the  point  of  a  tool  that  pares 
away  the  upper  surface  of  the  glass.  This  must  be  the 
first  layer  and  not  more;  by  so  doing,  the  glass  remains 
white  ^^  and  can  be  tinged  afterwards  with  that  red  ^^  made 
of  many  mixtures,  which  when  fused  by  heat  becomes 
yellow.  This  can  be  done  with  all  the  colours,  but  the 
yellow  succeeds  better  on  white  than  on  other  colours; 
when  blue  is  used  to  paint  in  the  ground,  it  becomes 
green  in  the  firing,  because  yellow  and  blue  mixed  make 
a  green  colour.  This  yellow  is  never  used  unless  at  the 
back  of  the  glass  where  it  is  not  painted,^^  because  if  it 
were  on  the  face  it  would  mingle  and  run,  so  as  to  spoil 
and  mix  itself  with  the  painting;  when  fired  however  the 
whole  of  the  red  remains  on  the  surface,  this,  when 
scraped  away  by  a  tool  leaves  the  yellow  visible.^* 

^'  It  will  be  understood  that  the  glass  subjected  to  this  treatment  is  not 
coloured  in  the  mass,  or  what  is  called  '  pot-metal,'  but  has  a  film  of  colour 
'  flashed '  or  spread  thinly  on  a  clear  sheet.  This  is  done  with  certain  colours, 
such  as  the  admired  ruby  red,  because  a  piece  coloured  in  the  mass  would 
be  too  opaque  for  effect.  Economy  may  also  be  a  consideration,  as  the  ruby 
stain  is  a  product  of  gold. 

'''The  composition,  which  when  fused  stains  the  glass  yellow,  may  before 
fusion  be  of  a  red  hue.  As  a  rule  the  yellow  stain  on  glass  is  produced  by 
silver.     Vasari  does  not  say  what  his  composition  is. 

''The  red  film  is  what  Vasari  understands  by  the  'painting.'  This  might 
fuse  and  run  with  the  heat  required  to  fuse  the  yellow. 

"That  is,  the  space  where  the  yellow  leaf  is  to  come  may  be  cleared  of 
the  red  film  after  the  yellow  leaf  has  been  painted  on  the  back,  as  well  as 
before  that  process.  The  process  Vasari  describes  of  introducing  small  details 
of  a  particular  colour  into  a  field  of  another  hue  is  a  good  deal  employed  by 
modern  workers  in  glass,  but  it  was  not  known  to  Theophilus,  or  much  used 
in  the  palmy  days  of  the  art,  the  twelfth  and  thirteenth  centuries. 


STAINED   GLASS  WINDOWS  271 

After  the  glasses  are  painted  they  must  be  put  into  an 
iron  muffle  with  a  layer  of  sifted  cinders  mixed  with  burnt 
lime,  and  arranged  evenly,  layer  by  layer,  each  layer 
covered  with  these  ashes;  they  are  then  put  into  the 
furnace,  in  which  at  a  slow  fire  they  are  gradually  heated 
through  till  both  cinders  and  glasses  begin  to  glow,  when 
the  colours  thereon  become  red  hot  and  run  and  are  incor- 
porated with  the  glass.  In  this  firing  the  greatest  care 
must  be  taken,  because  a  too  violent  heat  would  make 
the  glasses  crack  and  too  little  would  not  fix  the  colours. 
Nor  must  they  be  taken  out  till  the  pan,  or  muffle,  in 
which  they  are  placed  is  seen  to  be  red  hot,  as  well  as 
the  ashes,  with  some  samples  laid  on  the  top  to  show 
when  the  pigment  is  liquefied. 

After  this  the  leads  are  cast  in  certain  moulds  of 
stone  or  iron.  The  leads  have  two  grooves;  that  is 
one  on  either  side,  within  which  the  glass  is  fitted  and 
pressed  tight.^^  The  leads  are  then  flattened  and  made 
straight  and  fastened  together  on  a  table.  Bit  by  bit  all 
the  work  is  leaded  in  many  squares  and  all  the  joinings 
of  the  lead  soldered  by  means  of  tin  soldering  irons. 
Across  it  in  parts  are  iron  rods  bearing  copper  wires 
leaded  in  to  support  and  bind  the  work,  whicl>  has  an 
armature  of  irons  that  do  not  run  straight  across  the 
figures,  but  are  twisted  according  to  the  lines  of  the  join- 
ings, so  as  not  to  interrupt  the  view  of  the  figures.  These 
are  rivetted  into  the  irons  that  support  the  whole,  and 
they  are  made  not  square  but  round  that  they  may  interfere 
less  with  the  view.  They  are  put  on  to  the  outside-  of 
the  windows  and  leaded  into  holes  in  the  walls,  and  are 
strongly  bound  together  with  copper  wires,  that  are 
soldered  by  means  of  fire  into  the  leads  of  the  windows. 
And  in  order  that  boys  and  other  nuisances  should  not 
spoil  the  windows,  a  fine  network  of  copper-wire  is  placed 

"In  Theophilus's  time  these  convenient  leads  grooved  on  both  sides,  which 
are  still  in  use,  were  not  invented.  He  directs  the  worker  to  bind  strips 
of  lead  round  each  piece  of  glass  and  then  solder  together  the  leads  when  the 
pieces  so  bound  are  brought  into  juxtaposition. 


272  OF  PAINTING 

behind  them.  These  works,  if  it  were  not  for  the  too 
fragile  material,  would  last  in  the  world  an  infinite  time. 
But  for  all  this  it  cannot  be  said  that  the  art  is  not  difficult, 
artistic,  and  most  beautiful. 


CHAPTER   XIX.    (XXXIII.) 

Of  Niello,'  and  how  by  means  of  this  process  we  have  Copper  Prints  ; 
and  how  Silver  is  engraved  to  make  Enamels  over  bas-relief,  and 
in  like  manner  how  Gold  and  Silver  Plate  is  chased.^ 

§  103.  Niello  Work. 

Niello,  which  may  be  described  as  a  design  traced  and 
painted  pn  silver,  as  one  paints  and  traces  delicately  with 
the  pen,  was  discovered  by  the  goldsmiths  as  far  back 
as  the  time  of  the  ancients,  there  having  been  seen  in 
their  gold  and  silver  plates  incisions  made  by  tools 
and  filled  up  with  some  mixture.^  In  niello  the  design 
is  traced  with  the  stylus  on  silver  which  has  a  smooth 
surface,  and  is  engraved  with  the  burin,  a  square  tool  cut 
on  the  slant  like  a  spur  from  one  of  its  angles  to  the  other ; 
for  sloping  thus  towards  one  of  the  corners  makes  it  very 

'' Niello'  is  from  the  mediaeval  Latin  'nigellum,'  'black,'  and  refers  to  the 
black  composition  with  which  engraved  lines  in  metal  plates  were  filled,  according 
to  the  process  detailed  by  Vasari. 

^  It  is  curious  that  the  chapter  ends  without  any  discussion  of  the  chasing  of 
gold  and  silver  plate. 

'To  some  small  extent  the  ancients  do  seem  to  have  filled  the  engraved  lines  in 
their  bronze  or  silver  plates  with  colouring  matter,  and  the  known  examples  are 
described  in  Daremberg  et  Saglio,  Dictionnaire  des  Antiqiiitis,  art.  '  Chryso- 
graphia,'  p.  1138.  Pliny,  Hist.  Nat.,  XXXIII,  46,  gives  a  recipe,  as  used  bv-the 
Egyptians,  for  a  material  for  colouring  silver  that  corresponds  with  the  com- 
position used  I'or  nieuo  work,  though  the  use  he  indicates  seems  rather  that  of  an 
artificial  patina  than  a  hlhng  for  incisions.  In  any  case  the  use  of  such  a  filling  in 
antiquity  was  quite  uncommon,  for  the  innumerable  incised  designs  on  the  backs 
of  Greek  and  Etruscan  mirrors  and  on  caskets  like  the  Ficeronian  Cista  show  no 
indication  of  the  process,  though  of  course  in  the  lapse  of  time  the  incisions  have 
acquired  a  darker  tinge  than  the  smooth  surfaces  of  the  metal,  and  Vasari  may 
have  seen  them  filled  with  accidental  impurities. 

S 


274  OF   PAINTING 

sharp  and  cutting  on  the  two  edges,  and  its  point 
glides  over  the  metal  and  graves  extremely  finely.*  With 
this  tool  is  executed  all  graving  on  metal,  whether  the 
lines  are  to  be  filled  or  are  to  be  left  open,  according  to 
the  pleasure  of  the  artificer.  When  therefore  they  have 
finished  their  graving  with  the  burin,  they  take  silver  and 
lead  and  fuse  them  into  one  substance  over  the  fire;  and 
this  when  completely  amalgamated  is  black  in  colour, 
very  friable,  and  extremely  fusible.^ 

The  next  process  is  to  pound  this  substance  and  put 
it  over  the  engraved  silver  plaque  which  must  be  thor- 
oughly clean,  then  to  bring  it  near  to  a  fire  of  green  wood, 
blowing  with  the  bellows  that  the  rays  of  the  fire  may 
strike  upon  the  niello,  which  by  virtue  of  the  heat  melts 
and  flows  filling  up  all  incisions  that  the  graver  has 
made.  Afterwards  when  'the  silver  has  cooled,  the  worker 
proceeds  to  remove  carefully  the  overplus  with  scrapers, 
and  with  pumice  stone  to  grind  it  away  little  by  little, 
rubbing  it  with  the  hands  and  with  a  leather  till  it  is 
reduced  to  the  true  flat  and  the  whole  is  left  polished. 
The  Florentine  Maso  Finiguerra  worked  most  admirably 
in  this  craft  in  which  he  was  really  extraordinary,  as  is 
testified  to  by  some  paxes  ®  of  niello  in  San  Giovanni  of 
Florence  that  are  esteemed  wonderful. 

§  104.  The  Origin  oj  Engraving. 

From  this  graving  by  the  burin  are  derived  the  copper 
plates   from   which   we   see  to-day   so  many   impressions 

^  A  burin  is  shown  in  Fig.  2,  D,  ante,  p.  48. 

^Vasari  makes  no  mention  here  of  sulphur,  which  in  the  recipes  given  by 
Pliny,  Theophilus,  and  Cellini,  is  a  constant  constituent  of  the  black  amalgam. 
Silver  and  lead  alone  would  not  give  the  black  required. 

'The  'Pax,'  Italian  'pace,'  was  a  little  tablet  of  metal  or  some  other  material 
used  in  churches  to  transmit  the  kiss  of  peace  from  the  priest  to  the  people. 
Certain  paxes  once  in  the  Baptistry  of  Florence  have  now  found  their  way 
through  the  Uffizi  to  the  Museum  in  the  Bargello,  but  experts  are  not  agreed 
as  to  the  ascription  of  particular  examples  to  Finiguerra.  See  Milanesi's  note  on 
this  artist  at  the  close  of  Vasari's  Life  of  Marc  Antonio  Raimondi  (0/iere, 
V,  443)- 


Plate  XIII 

^t^viSf '**^1». 

So^BH^IVr^! 

^^, 

El 

'viVP^^^^H^  ^^^V^l^l 

^mM 

m 

1 

^^^ 

^P 

Wi^^tA 

W^  — > 

1^^ 

!Lg'^> 

'-^^ 

SPECIMEN   OF  NIELLO  WORK 
A  'Pax'  formerly  in  the  Baptistry,  and  now  in  the  National  Museum,  Florence 


ORIGIN   OF   ENGRAVING  275 

throughout  all  Italy  of  both  Italian  and  German  origin. 
Just  as  impressions  in  clay  were  taken  from  silver  plaques 
before  they  were  filled  with  niello,  and  casts  pulled  from 
these  in  sulphur,^  in  the  same  manner  the  printers  found 
out  the  method  of  striking  off  the  sheets  from  the  copper 
plates  with  the  press,  as  we  have  seen  printing  done  in 
our  own  days. 

'In  Vasari's  firsL  edition,  of  1550,  there  is  a  notice  of  Finiguerra  in  the  Life 
of  Antonio  Pollaiuolo  (p.  498)  and  he  there  celebrates  only  the  skill  of  Maso  as  a 
niellist,  but  in  the  edition  of  1 568  there  is  another  notice  of  him  in  connection 
with  Marc  Antonio  (Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  v,  395),  and  here  Vasari  claims  for 
him  the  credit  of  being  the  first  to  make  the  advance  from  niello  work  to 
copper-plate  engraving.  This  second  passage  is  a  famous  one,  and  describes 
how  Finiyuerra  moulded  his  silver  plate.  i"r|figprl  with  a  riesipn,  in  clay,  and  then 
c^t  it  in  sulphur,  and  subsequently  filled  the  hollow  lines  in  the  sulphur  cast 
(which  reproduced  the  incisions  on  the  silver  plate)  with  lamp-black,  so  that 
they  showed  up  more  clearly.  He  then  seems,  according  to  Vasari,  to  have 
pressed  damp  paper  e^ainst  the  sulphur  plaque  so  treated,  and  obtained  a  print  by 
extracting  the  black  from  the  lines.  Benvenuto  Cellini  however,  a  better  autho- 
rity than  Vasari  on  Finiguerra,  praises  him  as  the  best  niello  worker  of  his  time, 
but  says  nothing  about-  this  further  development  of  his  craft,  and  on  the  contrary 
ascribes  the  invention  of  copper-plate  engraving  to  the  Germans.  Cellini  tells  us 
at  the  end  of  his  'Introduzione,'  that  in  1515,  when  fifteen  years  old,  he  began 
to  learn  the  goldsmith's  trade,  and  that  then,  though  the  art  of  niello-work  had 
greatly  declined,  the  older  goldsmiths  sang  in  his  ears  the  praise  of  Maso 
Finiguerra,  who  had  died  in  1464.  Hence,  Cellini  says,  he  gave  special 
attention  to  niello  work,  and  he  describes  the  process,  at  rather  greater  length 
than  Vasari,  in  the  first  chapter  of  his  Treatise  on  Gold-work  (/  Trattati,  etc. 
di  Benvenuto  Cellini,  ed.  Milanesi,  Firenze,  1893). 

The  question  of  the  origin  of  copper-plate  engraving  need  not  be  here 
discussed.  Any  of  the  incised  silver  or  bronze  plaques  of  the  ancients  might 
have  been  printed  from  ;  and  as  a  fact  some  incised  bronze  discs  that  are  placed 
at  the  bottoms  of  the  towers  in  the  great  crown-light  of  the  twelfth  century 
in  the  Minster  at  Aachen  have  actually  been  put  through  the  printing  press  and 
the  impressions  published,  though  no  one  at  the  time  they  were  made  can  have 
thought  of  printing  from  them.  In  the  same  way  wooden  stamps  in  relief 
were  used  by  Egyptians  and  Romans  for  impressing  the  damp  clay  of  their 
bricks,  though  no  one  seems  to  have  thought  of  multiplying  impressions  on 
papyrus  or  parchment.  So  trial  impressions  of  niello  plates,  before  the  lines 
were  filled  in  permanently,  may  often  have  been  made,  and  not  by  Finiguerra 
alone.  The  idea  of  multiplying  such  impressions  on  their  own  account  is  now 
universally  credited  to  the  Germans,  and  this  seems  also  to  have  been  the 
opinion  of  Cellini.     See  his  'Introduzione.' 


2/6  OF   PAINTING 

§  105;  Enamels  over  Reliefs. 
See  now  another  sort  of  work  in  silver  and  in  gold, 
commonly  called  enamel,  a  kind  of  painting  intermingled 
with  sculpture,  suitable  for  lining  the  bottom  of  pieces 
intended  to  hold  water.^  This  when  worked  on  gold, 
needs  the  very  finest  gold ;  and  when  on  silver,  the  silver 
at  least  of  the  quality  of  the  giulio.^  The  following 
method  is  necessary  in  order  that  the  enamel  may  remain 
in  its  place  and  not  run  beyond  its  proper  limits.  The 
edges  of  the  silver  ^^  must  be  left  so  fine  that  when  looked 
at  from  above  they  escape  the  eye.  In  this  way  is  made  a 
flat  relief  contrary  to  the  other  kind,^^  in  order  that  when 
the  enamels  are  put  over  it,  it  may  take  its  darks  and  lights 
from  the  height  and  depth  of  the  intaglio.  Then  glass 
enamels  of  various  colours  are  picked  out  and  carefully 
fixed  with  the  hammer ;  ^^  they  are  kept  in  little  bowls 
filled  with  clear  water,   separated  and  distinct  one  from 

*That  is  to  say,  the  bottoms  of  cups  or  chalices.  There  are  notices  of 
armorial  insignia,  enamelled  at  the  bottom  of  cups  of  gold  used  by  some  of 
the  French  kings,  in  Labarte,  Histoire  des  Arts  Industrieh. 

'Giulio:  a  piece  coined  under  Pope  Julius  II,  of  the  same  value  as  the 
'  paolo,'  and  equivalent  to  56  centesimi,  or  about  5jd.  of  our  money. 

^"That  is,  the  outlines  of  the  different  figures,  ornaments,  or  other  objects 
executed  in  low  relief  on  the  metal.  See  the  Note  on  '  Vasari's  Description 
of  Enamel  Work '  at  the  close  of  the  '  Introduction '  to  Painting,  postea, 
p.  311. 

^' '  The  other  kind '  probably  refers  to  the  incisions  on  the  niello  plates 
of  which  he  has  been  speaking.  These  are  hollow,  or  in  intaglio,  whereas 
the  work  he  is  here  describing  is  in  relief. 

^^'Si  fermino  col  ihartello.'  The  only  practicable  use  of  the  hammer  in 
connection  with  enamels  is  to  pound  the  lumps  of  vitreous  paste  to  a  more  or 
less  fine  powder,  in  which  form  they  are  placed  over  the  metal.  Theophilus, 
in  chapter  53  of  his  third  Book,  '  de  Electro,'  '  on  Enamel,'  introduces  the 
hammer  in  a  similar  connection :  '  Accipiensque  singulas  probati  vitri  .  .  . 
quod  mox  confringas  cum  rotundo  malleo  donee  subtile  fiat ; '  '  take  portions 
of  the  glass  you  have  tested  .  .  .  and  break  up  each  lump  with  a  round- 
headed  hammer  till  it  be  finely  powdered.'  Cellini  also  says  the  pastes  are 
to  be  pounded  in  a  mortar  'con  martello.'  Trattati,  p.  30.  It  is  not  easy 
however  to  see  how  any  sense  of  '  pounding '  can  be  extracted  from  the  verb 
'fermare'  which  Vasari  uses. 


ENAMELS   OVER   RELIEFS  277 

the  other.  Those  which  are  used  with  gold  are  different 
from  those  that  serve  for  silver  ^^  and  they  are  worked 
in  the  following  manner.  The  enamels  are  lifted  out 
separately  with  the  most  delicate  little  silver  shovel  and 
spread  in  their  places  with  scrupulous  cleanliness,  and 
this  is  done  over  and  over  again,  according  as  the  enamel 
adheres  properly,  and  so  with  all  the  quantity  that  is 
needed  at  the  time.  This  done,  an  earthenware  receptacle, 
made  on  purpose,  is  prepared;  it  must  be  perforated  all 
over  and  have  a  mouthpiece  in  front,  then  the  muffle, 
which  is  a  little  perforated  earthenware  cover  that  will 
prevent  the  charcoal  falling  from  above,  is  introduced  into 
this  receptacle,  and  above  the  muffle  the  space  is  filled 

^  The  difference  in  colour  between  gold  and  silver  will  naturally  affect 
the  choice  of  the  transparent  vitreous  pastes  that  are  to  cover  them,  and  there 
are  also  considerations  of  a  chemical  kind  which  prevent  the  use  of  certain 
pastes  on  certain  metal  grounds.  For  example  tin  has  the  property  of  rendering 
transparent  enamels  opaque,  and  transparent  pastes  cannot  be  used  over  metal 
grounds  wherein  tin  enters  into  the  composition.  Cellini,  who  gives  the  same 
caution  as  Vasari,  takes  as  an  illustration  transparent  ruby  coloured  enamel, 
which  he  says  cannot  be  used  over  silver,  for  a  reason  which  has  about  it 
a  reminiscence  of  the  ancient  alchemy,  namely,  that  it  is  a  product  of  gold 
and  must  be  employed  only  over  its  kindred  metal !  On  the  other  hand 
he  forbids  for  use  with  gold  yellow,  white,  and  turquoise  blue.  We  are 
indebted  for  some  special  information  on  this  highly  technical  subject  to  the 
kindness  of  Mr.  H.  H.  Cunyngharae,  C.B.,  who  writes:  'There  are  two 
distinct  reasons  why  different  enamels  are  used  on  silver  and  gold  respectively. 
The  first  is  an  artistic  reason.  Transparent  reds  do  not  show  well  over  silver, 
the  rays  reflected  from  a  silver  surface  not  being  well  calculated  to  show  off  the 
colours  of  the  gold.  In  fact  silver  absorbs  those  rays  on  the  transmission  of 
which  the  beauty  of  gold-red  largely  depends,  whence  then  it  follows  that 
transparent  blues  and  greens  should  be  used  on  silver,  and  reds,  browns,  and 
tbf  hrisjiter  yellows  on  gold.  In  addition  to  this,  silver  has  fts-sUrJace  disturbed 
by^the  silicic  acid  in  the  enamel.  The  consequence  is  that  ordinary  enamels 
put  on  a  silver  surface  are  stained.  To  prevent  this  it  is  desirable  to  add 
some  ingredient  that  dissolves  and  renders  colourless  the  stain.  For  this  purpose 
therefore  special  fluxes  or  clear  enamels  are  made  for  silver.  They  usually 
contain  manganese  and  arsenic.  The  first  of  these  has  such  a  property  of 
"clarifying"  enamels  and  glazes  that  it  used  to  be  called  the  potter's  "soap," 
for  it  cleaned  the  glazes  on  china.  The  other  is  also  used  for  the  same  purpose. 
...  As  silver  alloy  is  more  easy  to  melt  than  gold  alloy,  fluxes,  i.e.  clear 
enamels  for  silver,  are  much  more  fusible  than  those  for  gold.' 


278  OF   PAINTING 

up  to  the  top  with  oak  charcoal  kindled  in  the  ordinary 
way.  In  the  empty  space  which  is  left  under  the  afore- 
named cover  the  enamelled  object  is  placed  on  a  very  thin 
iron  tray  to  feel  the  heat  gradually  and  is  kept  there  long 
enough  to  admit  of  the  enamels  melting,  when  they  flow 
all  over  almost  like  water.  Which  done,  it  is  allowed  to 
cool,  and  then  with  a  '  frassinella,'  that  is,  a  stone  for 
sharpening  iron  tools,  and  with  sand  such  as  is  used  for 
drinking  glasses  moistened  with  clear  water,  it  is  rubbed 
till  it  becomes  perfectly  level.  When  the  process  of 
removing  all  superfluity  is  finished,  the  object  is  placed 
in  the  actual  fire,  to  be  melted  a  second  time  in  order  that 
the  whole  surface  may  become  lustrous. ^^  Another  sort 
is  made  by  hand,  and  polished  with  Tripoli  plaster 
(powder)  and  a  piece  of  leather,  but  of  this  there  is  no 
need  to  make  mention. ^^  I  have  however  described  the 
above  because  being,  like  the  other  processes,  of  the  nature 
of  painting  it  seemed  to  come  into  our  subject. 

'*This  is  a  practice  of  modern  enamellers.  Cellini  however  is  against  it, 
as  if  the  enamels  begin  again  to  run  there  is  a  danger  of  losing  the  truth 
of  the  surface.  He  recommends  polishing  by  hand  alone  (Tratlati,  ed. 
Milanesi,  35). 

'^This  may  have  been  the  so-called  Venetian  enamel  used  in  Vasari's  time. 
This  was  a  form  of  opaque  painted  enamel  over  copper,  extremely  decorative, 
but  coarse  as  compared  with  the  translucent  enamel  over  reliefs.  We  owe 
this  suggestion  to  Sir  T.  Gibson  Carmichael. 


CHAPTER   XX.     (XXXIV.) 
Of  Tausia,'  that  is,  work  called  Damascening. 

§    io6.  Metal  Inlays. 

In  imitation  of  the  ancients,  tiie  moderns  have  revived 
a  gjTPrjf'f^  qi  inlaying  in  mpta1«;,  with  sunk  designs  in 
gj'old  or  silver,  making  surfaces  either  flat  or  in  half  or  low 
rfilief ;  and  in  that  they  have  made  great  progress.  Thus 
we  have  seen  works  in  steel  sunk  in  the  manner  of  tausia, 
otherwise  called  damascening,  because  of  its  being  excel- 
lently well  done  in  Damascus  and  in  all  the  Levant. 
Wherefore  we  have  before  us  to-day  many  bronzes  and 
brasses  and  coppers  inlaid  in  silver  and  gold  with 
arabesques,  which  have  come  from  those  countries ;  and 
among  the  works  of  the  ancients  we  have  observed 
rings  of  steel,  with  half  figures  and  leafage  very  beautiful. 
In  our  days,  there  is  made  in  this  kind  of  work  armour 
for  fighting  all  worked  with  arabesques  inlaid  with 
gold,  also  stirrups  and  saddle-bows  and  iron  maces : 
and  now  much  in  vogue  are  such  furnishings  of  swords, 

^  The  word  'Tausia,'  and  its  connection  with  'Tpi-cia  '  thf  tcmn  ngpH  fr^r 
wood  inlaySf  has  given  rise  to  some  discussion.  The  explanation  in  Bucher's 
Geschichte  der  Technischen  Kiinste,  in,  14,  is  probably  correct,  and  according 
to  this  the  Italian  '  Tausia '  comes  from  the  Spanish  '  Tauscia '  or  '  Atauscia,' 

wVl;r^^^    I'c    ,^pr;v<.r^     frnm     p,n     Arghjf    xnc^ -nM^rv^ni^      '  fr»    deCOrate.'        Thp    art    nf 

inlaying  one  metal  in  another  is  one  of  great  antiquity  in  the  East,  and  was 
no  doubt  brought  to  Spain  bv  the  Moors,  from  which  country,  perhaps  by 
way  of  Sicily,  it  spread  to  Italy.  The  word  'Tarsia,'  appuea  as  we  have 
already  seen  to  inlays  in  wood,  may  have  been  derived  by  corruption  from 
'  Tausia,'  though,  as  the  form  '  Intarsia '  is  also  common,  a  derivation 
(unlikely)  has  been  suggested  from  the  Latin  '  Interserere.'  The  'in'  is  probably 
only  the  preposition,  that  has  become  incorporated  with  the  word  it  preceded; 


28o  OF   PAINTING 

of  daggers,  of  knives  and  of  every  weapon  that  men 
desire  to  have  richly  ornamented.  Damascening  is 
done  in  this  way.  The  worker  makes  undercut  sinkings 
in  the  iron  ^  and  beats  in  the  gold  by  the  force  of  a 
hammer,  having  first  made  cuttings  or  little  teeth  like 
those  of  a  slender  file  underneath,  so  that  the  gold  is 
driven  into  these  hollows  and  is  fixed  there.^  Then  by 
means  of  tools,  he  enriches  it  with  a  pleasing  design 
of  leaves  or  of  whatever  he  fancies.  All  these  designs 
executed  with  threads  of  gold  passed  through  the  wire- 
drawing plate  *  are  twined  over  the  surface  of  the  iron 
and  beaten  in  with  the  hammer,  so  as  to  be  fixed  in  the 
method  mentioned  above.  Let  care  however  be  taken 
that  the  threads  are  thicker  than  the  incised  outlines  so 
as  to  fill  these  up  and  remain  fixed  into  them.  In  this 
craft  numberless  ingenious  men  have  executed  praise- 
worthy things  which  have  been  esteemed  marvellous ;  and 
for  this  reason  I  have  not  wished  to  omit  mention  of  it, 
for  it  depends  on  inlaid  work  and  so,  partaking  of  the 
nature  of  both  sculpture  and  painting,  is  part  of  the 
operations  of  the  art  of  design. 

2  '  Cavasi  il  ferro  in  sotto  squadra.' 

=*  If  the  sinkings  be  undercut  the  further  process  of  roughening  the  sunk 
surfaces  is  hardly  necessary,  but  the  roughening  or  puncturing  may  suffice  to 
hold  the  inlaid  metal  when  there  is  no  actual  undercutting  of  the  sides 
of  the  sinkings. 

*  The  '  filiera,'  or  iron  plate  pierced  with  holes  of  various  sizes  for  drawing 
wires  through,  was  known  to  Theophilus.  See  chapter  8  of  Book  in  of  the 
Schedula,    '  De  ferris  per  quae  fila  trahuntur. ' 


CHAPTER  XXI.     (XXXV.) 

Of  Wood  Engraving  and  the  method  of  executing  it  and  concerning 
its  first  Inventor:  how  Sheets  which  appear  to  be  drawn  by 
hand  and  exhibit  Lights  and  Half-tones  and  Shades  are  produced 
with  three  Blocks  of  Wood. 

§  107.  Chiaroscuro  Wood  Engravings. 
The  first  inventor  of  engraving  on  wood  in  three  pieces 
for  showing  not  only  the  design  but  the  shadows, 
half -tints,  and  lights  also  was  Ugo  da  Carpi. ^  He 
invented  the  method  of  wood  engraving  in  imitation  of 
the  engravings  on  copper,  cutting  them  on  the  wood  of 
the  pear  tree  or  the  box  which  are  excellent  above  all 
other  kinds  of  wood  for  this  work.     He  made  his  blocks 

'  Vasari  does  not  attempt  to  deal  with  the  art  of  wood  leagraving  in  general 
nor  need  this  Note  traverse  the  whole  subject.  In  all  these  later  chapters  of 
the  '  Introduction '  to  Painting  he  is  dealing  with  forms  of  the  decorative  art 
in  which  various  materials  are  put  together  so  as  to  produce  something  of  the 
effect  of  a  picture.  Hence  all  that  he  envisages  in  the  department  of  wood 
engraving  are  what  are  called  chiaroscuri,  or  engravings  meant  to  produce 
the  effect  of  shaded  drawings  by  tints  rather  than  by  the  lines  which  constitute 
engravings  proper.  It  has  been  noticed  that  some  writers  on  engraving,  (ante, 
p.  20)  have  denied  to  these  imitated  light-and-shade  drawings  the  character 
of  true  engravings. 

As  we  have  seen  to  be  the  case  with  copper-plate  engraving  (ante,  p.  275) 
priority  is  now  claimed  in  these  chiaroscuri  for  Germany  over  Italy,  and  Ugo 
da  Carpi,  who  was  born  about  1450,  near  Bologna,  becomes  rather  the 
improver  of  a  German  process  than  the  inventor  of  a  new  one.  On  July  24, 
1516,  when  resident  in  Venice  he  petitions  the  Signoria  of  that  city  for 
privilege  for  his  '  new  method  of  printing  in  light  and  shade,  a  novel  thing 
and  not  done  before.'  Lippmann  {TTte  Art  of  Wood  Engraving  in  Italy  in 
the  Fifteenth  Century,  trans.,  London,  1888)  thinks  that  this  claim  may  be 
true  'in  so  far  as  he  may  have  introduced  further  developments  in  the 
practice  of  colour  printing  with  several  blocks,  which  still  survived  in  Venice, 


282  OF   PAINTING 

then  in  three  pieces,^  placing  on  the  first  all  that  is  contour 
and  line;  on  the  second  all  that  is  tinted  near  to  the 
outline,  putting  in  the  shadow  with  water-colour;  and 
on  the  third  the  lights  and  the  ground  leaving  the  white 
of  the  paper  to  give  the  light,  and  tingeing  the  rest  for 
the  ground.  This  third  block  containing  the  light  and  the 
ground,  is  executed  in  the  following  manner.  A  sheet 
printed  by  the  first  block,  on  which  are  all  the  contours 

especially  after  the  production  of  coloured  wood-cuts  by  Burgkmair  and 
Cranach  in  Germany  had  given  fresh  stimulus  to  a  more  artistic  cultivation 
of  that  method '  (p.  69),  and  that  '  he  gave  the  art  an  entirely  new 
development  based  upon  the  principles  which  guided  the  profession  of  painting ' 
(p.  136).  This  last  phrase  explains  the  interest  that  Vasari  here  manifests  in 
his  work.  In  the  older  wood  engraving  only  lines  had  been  left  on  the  block 
to  take  the  imt,  the  rest  oTThe  surfane  heinfr  rut  away,  and  whatever  waS-to 
be  shown  in  the  print  was  displayed  in  the  lines  alone.  In  the  new  method 
broad  surfaces  of  the  wood  were  left,  on  which  was  spread  a  film  of  ink  or 
pigment,  and  these  printed  a  corresponding  tint  upon  the  paper  which  took 
off  the  film  thus  laid.  The  pigment  might  be  of  any  colour  desired,  or 
might  only  represent  a  lighter  tint  of  the  ink  that  had  been  used  all  along 
for  the  lines.  Hence  either  an  effect  of  colour  or  one  merely  of  gradations 
of  light-and-shade  could  equally  well  be  produced  by  the  process  Vasari 
describes.  The  work  he  contemplates  is  of  the  latter  kind,  and  his 
explanation  of  the  process  by  which  it  was  produced  is  fairly  clear.  Plate  XIV, 
from  a  print  by  Ugo  da  Carpi  in  the  British  Museum,  gives  a  specimen  of 
the  result. 

Critics  of  Ugo  da  Carpi's  work,  which  is  sufficiently  abundant,  notice  that 
he  begins  by  merely  adding   tints  of   shading    to  outlines,   which  as  in   the 

remained  substantially  responsible  for  the  effect^:  but  that  he  gives  more  and 
more  importance  to  the  tints,  the  pictorial  element  in  the  design,  till  the 
outlines  end  by  merely  reinforcing  the  chiaroscuro,  like  the  tnnrbes  'a  tempera' 
that  give  effect  and  decision  to  painting  ir|  fresrn  (TfrUtpllpi-,  Kitpferstich  und 
Hohschnitt  in  vier  Jahrhunderten,  Berlin,   1905,  p.  300). 

^That  is,  he  made  three  blocks  A,  B,  C,  each  the  full  size  of  the  design, 
but  each  containing  only  a  part  of  the  work.  A  has  engraved  on  it 
all  the  lines  of  the  design,  and  a  print  from  it  would  be  an  old-fashioned 
engraving  proper.  Such  a  print  with  the  ink  on  it  still  wet  is  pressed  down 
on  a  clean  block  of  wood,  on  which  it  leaves  indications  of  all  these  lines. 
The  broad  tints  of  shading,  in  which  gradations  may  be  introduced,  are  then 
laid  on  the  block  by  hand,  the  outlines  being  a.  guide,  and  so  is  constituted 
block  B,  an  impression  from  which  printed  on  a  sheet  already  printed  from 
block  A,  and  made   to  register   accurately  with   this,   would  add  shading  to 


1-1     fi 


Q  I 

o  a 

o 

o  "l 

>  <u 

O 

w  i 

Q  Si 

o  S 


o  -S 

«  pq 
D 

"  S 

tn  o 

(^  ^ 

^  .S 


CHIAROSCURO  WOOD  ENGRAVINGS       283 

and  lines,  is  taken  wet  and  placed  on  the  plank  of  the 
pear  tree  and  weighted  down  with  other  sheets  which  are 
not  damp  and  so  pressed  upon  that  the  wet  sheet  leaves 
on  the  board  the  impression  of  all  the  outlines  of  the 
figures.  Then  the  painter  takes  white  lead  mixed  with 
gum  and  puts  in  the  lights  on  the  pear-wood.  After  this 
is  done  the  engraver  cuts  them  all  out  with  tools, 
according  as  they  are  marked.  This  block  is  that  which, 
duly  primed  with  oil  colour,^  is  used  for  the  first  process, 
namely,  to  produce  the  lights  and  the  ground,  the  whole 
surface,  therefore,  is  left  tinted  except  just  where  it  is 
hollowed  out,  because  there  the  paper  remains  white.  The 
second  block  is  that  which  gives  shadows.  It  is  quite 
flat  and  tinted  with  water-colour,  except  where  the  shadows 
are  not  to  come,  because  there  the  wood  is  hollowed  out. 
And  the  third,  which  is  the  first  to  be  shaped,  is  that  in 
which  the  whole  outlined  part  is  hollowed  out  all  over, 
except  where  there  are  no  profiles  touched  in  with  black 
by  the  pen.* 

These  are  printed  at  the  press  and  are  put  under  it  three 
times,  i.e.  once  for  each  impression,  so  that  they  shall 

the  outlines.  C  would  add  by  the  same  process  a  third  tint,  quite  flat, 
for  the  background,  and  this  might  of  course  be  of  another  colour.  The 
high  lights  would  be  cut  away  in  this  block,  C,  and  these  parts  come  out 
white  in  the  print,  as  is  seen  on  Plate  XIV.  The  uniform  grey  shade  on  the 
Plate  is  the  background  tint.  In  the  actual  process  of  printing  this  block, 
C,  is  first  put  into  the  press  and  produces  an  impression  showing  the  tinted 
background  but  white  spaces  where  the  high  lights  are  to  come.  B,  with  the 
shadows  tinted  but  all  the  rest  of  the  wood  cut  away,  is  printed  over  the 
impression  from  C,  and  lastly  A  comes  to  give  the  decided  lines  and  sharpen 
up  the  whole  effect. 

^  The  '  oil  colour '  is  the  pigment  which  is  transferred  from  the  block  to 
the  paper.  The  '  water  colour'  and  the  '  white  lead  mixed  with  gum '  mentioned 
above  are  only  put  on  by  the  artist  to  guide  the  wood-cutter  in  his  work  of 
cutting  the  block. 

*The  text,  in  both  the  original  editions,  runs  as  follows:  'E  la  terza  che  e 
la  prima  a  formarsi,  h  quella  dove  il  profilato  del  tutto  e  incavato  per  tutto, 
salvo  che  dove  e'  non  ha  i  profili  tocchi  dal  nero  della  penna,'  and  the 
negative  is  puzzling,  for  obviously  the  wood  must  be  cut  away  everywhere 
but  in  those  places  where  the  outlines  do  come. 


284  OF  PAINTING 

severally  have  the  same  pressure.     And  certainly  this  was 
a  most  beautiful  invention. 


§    1 08.  Dependence  on  Design  of  the  Decorative  Arts. 

All  these  lines  of  work  and  ingenious  arts,  as  one  sees, 
are  derived  from  design,  which  is  the  necessary  fount  of 
all,  for  if  they  are  lacking  in  design  they  have  nothing.^ 
Therefore  although  all  processes  and  styles  are  good,  that 
is  best  by  which  every  lost  thing  is  recovered  and  every 
difficult  thing  becomes  easy  :  as  we  shall  see  in  reading 
the  Lives  of  the  artists,  who,  aided  by  nature  and  by  study 
have  done  superhuman  things  solely  by  means  of  design. 
And  thus,  making  an  end  of  the  Introduction  to  the  three 
Arts,  treated  perhaps  at  too  great  length,  which  in  the 
beginning  I  did  not  intend,  I  pass  on  to  write  the  Lives. 

°  But  Theophilus  says  practically  nothing  about  design,  and  yet  the  mediaeval 
epoch  was  for  the  decorative  arts  one  of  the  most  glorious  the  world  has 
ever  seen.  See  on  this  subject  the  last  part  of  the  Introductory  Essay, 
ante,  p.  20  f. 


NOTES   ON   'INTRODUCTION' 
TO   PAINTING 


NOTES   ON   'INTRODUCTION' 
TO   PAINTING 

FRESCO   PAINTING. 
[§  8i,  The  Fresco  Process,  ante,  p.  221.] 

The  fresco  process  is  generally  regarded  as  one  of  several 
methods  for  the  production  of  pictures.  It  is  better  to  consider 
it  in  the  first  place  as  a  colour  finish  to  plaster  work.  What  it 
produces  is  a  coloured  surface  of  a  certain  quality  of  texture 
and  a  high  degree  of  permanence,  and  it  is  a  secondary  matter 
that  this  coloured  surface  may  be  so  diversified  as  to  become  a 
picture. 

The  history  of  the  process  is  involved  in  obscurity,  and  it  is 
not  known  who  first  observed  the  fact  that  colours  mixed  only 
with  water  when  laid  on  a  wet  surface  of  lime  plaster  dried 
with  the  plaster  and  remained  permanently  attached  to  it.  The 
technique  was  however  known  to  the  Romans,  and  we  obtain 
the  best  idea  of  its  essential  character  from  the  notice  of  it 
by  Vitruvius  in  the  third  chapter  of  his  seventh  book.  It  is 
there  treated  in  intimate  connection  with  plaster  work,  as  only 
the  last  stage  in  the  technical  treatment  of  a  wall.  The  wall 
is  constructed  of  stone  or  brick ;  it  is  then  plastered ;  and  the 
plaster  is,  or  can  be,  finally  finished  with  a  wash  of  colour.  Of 
the  character  of  this  antique  plaster  work  something  has 
already  been  said  in  a  note  to  §  72,  in  connection  with  Sculpture 
(ante,  p.  171).  It  could  be  finished  either  in  a  plain  face  of 
exquisite  surface  that  might  even  be  polished,  or  with  stamped 
ornaments  in  relief  or  figures  modelled  by  hand;  but  it  could 
also  be  completed  with  colour  in  the  form  either  of  a  plain  tint 


288  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

or  a  picture,  and  this  colour  would  be  applied  by  the  fresco 
process. 

PairvHny   'a    frpsrr.  '   mpans   painting   nn    the   frpshlv  laid. and 

stni  wet  final  coat  of  plaster.  The  pigments  are  mixed  with 
nothing  but  pure  water,  and  the  palette  of  the  artist  is  limited 
by  the  fact  that  practically  speaking  only  the  earth  colours, 
such  as  the  ochres,  can  be  used  with  safety ;  even  the  white  has 
to  be  made  from  lime-rthe  Italians  called  it  '  bianco  San 
Giovanni  ' — as  lead  white,  called  '  biacca, '  is  inadmissible. 
Vegetable  and  metallic  pigments  are  as  a  rule  excluded  from 
use.  The  reason  why  pigments  mixed  with  water  only,  without 
any  gum  or  similar  binding  material,  adhere  when  dry  to  the 
plaster  is  a  chemical  one.  The  explanation  of  it  was  given  by 
Otto  Donner  in  an  Appendix  to  Helbig's  Campanische  Wand- 
gemdlde,  Leipzig,  1868,  and  is  to  be  found  also  in  Professor 
Church's  Chemistry  of  Paints  and  Painting.  When  limestone 
is  burnt  into  lime  all  the  carbonic  acid  is  driven  out  of  it.  The 
result  of  the  slaking  of  the  lime  by  water,  which  is  preliminary 
to  its  use  in  plastering,  is  that  the  material  becomes  saturated 
with  an  aqueous  solution  of  hydrate  of  lime.  This  hydrate  of 
lime  rises  to  the  surface  of  the  plaster,  and  when  the  pigment 
is  laid  on,  to  use  Professor  Church's  phrasing,  it  '  diffuses  into 
the  paint,  soaks  it  through  and  through,  and  gradually  takes 
up  carbonic  acid  from  the  air,  thus  producing  carbonate  of 
lime,  which  acts  as  the  binding  material.'  To  put  the  matter 
in  simpler  language,  lime  when  burnt  loses  its  carbonic  acid, 
but  gradually  recovers  it  from  the  air,  and  incidentally  this 
carbonic  acid,  as  it  is  re-absorbed,  serves  to  fix  the  colours 
used  in  the  fresco  process.  It  jg  a  mistake  to  speak  of  the 
pigment  '  sinking  into  the  wet  olastfr  '  T*-  '-""'a;^.^  ^r.  j-ho 
surface,  but  it  is  fixed  there  in  a  sort  of  crvstallinp  gb-in  nf 
carbonate  of  lime  which  has  formed  on  the  surface  of  the 
plaster.  This  crystalline  skin  ^ives  a  certain  metallic  lustoe 
to  the  surface  r>t  a  tresrn  paintinfr,  anH  ic  ei.fflr-jf>r.j-  tn  prntecj 
the     colours     irom     the     artmn     nf     pytprnal  '  nini'itliri^i      though 

on  the  other  hand  there  are  many  causes  chemical  and  physical 
that  may  contribute  to  their  decay.  If  however  proper  care 
have  been  taken  throughout,  and  atmospheric  conditions 
remain  favourable,  the  fresco  painting  is  quite  permanent. 


FRESCO   PAINTING  289 

The  process  of  painting,  it  will  be  easily  seen,  must  be  a 
rapid  one,  for  it  must  be  completed  before  the  plaster  has  time 
to  dry,  which  it  would  do  if  left  for  a  night.  Hence  only  a 
certain  portion  of  the  work  in  hand  is  undertaken  on  each  day 
and  only  so  much  of  the  final  coat  of  plaster,  called  by  the 
Italians  '  intonaco,'  is  laid  by  the  plasterer  as  will  correspond 
to  the  amount  the  artist  expects  to  cover  before  nightfall.  At 
the  end  of  the  day's  work,  the  plaster  not  painted  on  is  cut 
away  round  the  outline  of  the  work  actually  finished,  and  the 
next  morning  a  fresh  patch  is  laid  on  and  joined  up  as  neatly 
as  possible  to  that  of  yesterday.  In  the  making  of  these  joints 
the  ancient  plasterer  seems  to  have  been  more  expert  than  the 
Italians  of  the  Renaissance,  and  the  seams  are  often  pretty 
apparent  in  frescoes  of  the  fifteenth  and  sixteenth  centuries, 
so  that  thiey  can  be  discerned  in  a  good  photograph.  When 
they  can  be  followed,  they  furnish  information,  which  it  is 
often  interesting  to  possess,  as  to  the  amount  that  has  been 
executed  in  a  single  day. 

To  prevent  loss  of  time  it  is  necessary  to  have  a  full-sized 
cartoon  in  readiness-so  that  the  drawing  can  be  at  once  trans- 
ferred  to  the  coat  of  wet  plaster  as  soon  as  it  has  been  laid. 
Vasari  speaks  of  these  cartoons  in  §  'j'j,  in  the  second  chapter 
on  Painting,  ante,  p.  213.  The  use  of  the  iron  stvlus  for 
impressing  the  lines  of  the  drawing  on  the  wet  plaster  is  to  be 
traced  in  some  of  the  later  Italian  frescoes.  Another  process 
for  carrying  out  the  transfer  was  called  '  gouQcingJ  For  this 
the  lines  of  the  cartoon  were  pricked  and  dabbed  with  a  muslin 
bag  filled  with  powdered  black,  so  as  to  show  in  dotted 
contours  upon  the  wall. 

Vasari  is  eloquent,  both  here  and  in  a  passage  in  his 
'  Proemio  '  to  his  whole  work,  on  the  judgement,  skill,  and 
decision  necessary  to  paint  successfully  in  fresco  under  these 
conditions  and  within  these  limits  of  time.  The  ideal  of  the 
process  was  to  complete  each  portion  absolutely  at  the  one 
sitting.  When  the  wall  is  once  dry,  any  retouching,  re- 
inforcement of  shadows,  and  the  like,  must  be  done  '  a  secco,' 
'  on  the  dry, '  that  is  with  pigments  mixed  with  size,  egg,  or 
some  other  tempera,  which  will  bind  them  to  the  surface. 
These  after-touches  lack  the  quality  of  texture  and  permanence 

T 


290  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

of  the  true  fresco  (buon  fresco).  If  size  or  gum  have  been  used, 
they  can  be  washed  off  the  wall,  and  having  been  laid  on  a 
dry  surface  by  a  kind  of  hatching  process  they  are  harsh  and 
'  liney. '  It  is  often  possible  in  good  large-scale  photographs 
to  distinguish  between  the  broad  soft  touches  of  the  frescoist 
laid  on  while  the  ground  was  wet,  and  the  hard  dry  hatchings 
of  the  subsequent  retouching. 

The  illustration,  Plate  XV,  has  been  chosen  as  a  good 
example  of  the  fresco  technique.  It  shows  the  head  of  Mary 
from  Luini's  fresco  of  the  '  Marriage  of  the  Virgin  '  at  Saronno. 
The  painting  is  executed  in  a  broad  and  facile  manner,  the 
tints  and  tones  which  give  the  colour  and  the  modelling  being 
deftly  fused  while  the  whole  is  wet,  and  the  darker  details,  such 
as  the  locks  of  the  hair,  are  struck  over  the  moist  ground  so 
that  the  touches  seem  soft  and  have  no  appearance  of  hatching. 
The  light-coloured  leaves  of  the  garland  round  the  head  show 
the  same  softness,  and  they  are  laid  in  with  a  full  brush  in 
thick  pigment.  On  the  other  hand  there  are  marks  of  retouch- 
ing where  the  shadows  round  the  eyes,  the  corner  of  the 
mouth,  etc.,  have  been  reinforced  '  a  secco,'  perhaps  by  a 
restorer.  These  show  as  thin,  hard,  wiry  lines,  and  have  quite 
a  different  appearance  from  the  work  on  the  wet  plaster. 

It  was  only  in  the  palmy  days  of  Italian  painting,  from  the 
latter  part  of  the  fifteenth  century  onwards,  that  artists  were 
able  to  dispense  almost  entirely  with  retouching.  In  thf  f^prlipr 
period  of  Giotto  and  his  successors  much  more  was  left  to  be 
done  '  a  secco, '  but  the  Giottesques  fully  understood  the  import- 
ance of  doing  all  they  could  on  the  wet  plaster,  and  Cennini  in 
the  67th  chapter  of  his  Trattato  insists  that'  to  paint  on  the 
fresh,  that  is  a  fixed  portion  on  each  day,  is  the  best  and  most 
permanent  way  of  laying  on  the  colour,  and  the  pleasantest 
method  of  painting. '  The  truth  is  that  the  technique  of  '  buon 
fresco,'  while  apparently  understood  by  the  Romans,  was  lost 
in  the  west  during  the  early  middle  ages,  though  it  may  have 
been  maintained  in  the  Byzantine  cloisters.  In  the  course  of 
the  progressive  improvements  in  the  art  of  painting  in  the 
fourteenth  and  fifteenth  centuries  the  old  technique  was  gradu- 
ally recovered.  Recently  Ernst  Berger,  in  his  Beitrage  zur 
Entwicklungs-Geschichte  der  Maltechnik,   i   and   11,   Munchen, 


Plate  XV 


HEAD   OF   MARY,   FROM   LUINFS   FRESCO   OF  THE 
OF  THE  Vn^GlN'  AT   SARONNO 

(From  a  photograph  by  Giacomo  Brogi) 


MARRIAGE 


FRESCO   AND   TEMPERA  291 

2nd  ed.,  1904,  has  denied  that  the  Romans  used  the  fresco 
technique,  and  has  evolved  an  ingenious  theory  of  a  derivation 
of  fresco  painting  from  the  mural  work  in  mosaic  which 
flourished  in  the  Early  Christian  centuries.  See  note,  ante, 
p.  255.  Into  the  question  thus  raised  it  is  not  necessary  to  enter, 
because  no  reader  of  Vitruvius  or  Pliny  can  have  the  shadow  of 
a  doubt  that  they  knew  and  were  referring  to  the  fresco  process. 
The  words  of  Vitruvius  (vii,  iii)  '  Colores  autem,  udo  tectorio 
cum  diligenter  sunt  inducti,  ideo  non  remittunt  sed  sunt  per- 
petiio  permanentes,  quod  calx,'  etc.,  and  those  of  Pliny  (xxxv, 
49)  '  udo  inlini  recusant  '  employed  of  certain  colours  which 
are  known  not  to  be  admissible  in  fresco  are  quite  conclusive 
on  this  point,  and  it  does  not  advance  science  to  build  up 
elaborate  theories  on  a  denial  of  obvious  facts. 

TEMPERA  PAINTING. 

[§  82,  Painting  in  Tempera,  ante,  p.  223.] 

In  his  appreciation  of  technical  processes  Vasari,  it  will  be 
seen,  reserves  his  enthusiasm  for  fresco  painting,  but  gives  oil 
the  advantage  over  tempera  (ante,  p.  230)  in  that  it  (i)  '  kindles 
the  colours,'  i.e.,  gives  them  greater  brilliancy;  (2)  enables  the 
artist  to  blend  his  pigments  on  the  panel  or  canvas  so  as  to 
secure  a  melting,  or  as  the  Italians  say  a  '  sfumato  '  or  '  misty  ' 
effect;  (3)  admits  of  a  force  and  liveliness  in  execution  which 
makes  the  figures  seem  in  relief  upon  the  surface,  and  finally  (4), 
as  he  says  at  the  beginning  of  chapter  vii,  is  a  great  con- 
venience, '  una  gran  comoditi  all'  arte  della  pittura. '  The  only 
corresponding-  advantages  on  the  side  of  tempera,  as  detailed 
in  §  82,  ante,  p.  223  f.,  are  the  facts  that  all  pigments  canlE'e 
used  in  it^  and  that  the  same  media  serve  for  work  on  grounded 
or  ungrounded  panels  or  on  the  dry  plaster  of  walls ;  and  that 
paintings  in  tempera  are  very  lasting.  When  Vasari  came  to 
write  of  his  own  works  at  tne  end  of  the  Lives  in  the  second 
edition,  his  conscience  seems  a  little  to  have  smitten  him,  and 
he  gives  the  process  a  word  of  special  commendation.  He 
speaks  of  using  it  for  some  mural  paintings  in  his  private  house 
which  he  had  just  built  at  Arezzo,  and  says,  '  I  have  always 
reverenced  the  memory  and  the  works  of   the  ancients,   and 


292  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

seeirtg  that  this  method  of  colouring  "  a  tempera  "  has  fallen 
out  of  use,  I  conceived  the  desire  of  rpsruinfr  it  from  oblivion. 
Hence  I  did  all  this  work  in  tempera,  a  process  that  certainly 

does   not   mprit   to   b^   flpcpicprl    nr   nfg-lprtpH  '    (OperB,    VII,    686). 

If  antiquity  and  wide  diffusion  be  criteria  of  rank  among 
painting  processes,  then  tempera  may  claim  the  first  place  of 
all.  The  Spaniard  Pacheco,  the  father-in-law  and  teacher  of 
Velasquez,  remarks  on  the  veneration  due  to  it  herpnsp  it 
had  its  hirthdav  with  art  itself.  As  a  fact  all  the  wall  paint- 
ings in  ancient  Eg;j;j2t_a.nd  Babylonia  and  Myrpngpan  (^i-pppp, 

all    the    mummy    f^g^sps     gnH    pgpymg    rnlls     in     thp    firs^-nampH 

cnpntry,  nrp  pvp''"tpf)  in  tpmpprg  and  the  same  is  probably  true 
of  all  the  wall  paintings  in  Italian  tombs,  as  well  as  of  the  lost 
mural  work  of  Polygnotus  and  his  school,  and  the  panel  paint- 
ings of  all  the  Greek  artists  save  those  who,  in  the  later  period 
after  Alexander,  adopted  encaustic.  Though  fresco  was  known 
as  a  mural  process  to  the  Romans  it  was  not  used  in  the  Early 
Christian  catacomb  paintings,  nor  in  the  mediaeval  wall 
paintings  north  of  the  Alps,  for  all  these  were  in  tempera.  For 
panel  painting,  both  in  the  East  and  the  West,  save  for  a 
doubtful  and  in  any  case  limited  use  of  oil,  tempera  was  in 
constant  employment  till  in  the  fifteenth  century  it  began  to  be 
superseded  by  the  new  oil  media  popularized  by  the  van  Eycks. 
Even  then  tempera  maintained  its  ground,  and  it  is  not  always 
realized  that  artists  like  Mantegna,  Botticelli  and  Diirpr  wprp 
as  a  rule  in  their  panel  work  tempera  painters.  In  the  case 
of  mural  work  at  any  period  fresco  can  really  never  have  wholly 
superseded  tempera,  for  fresco  can  only  be  worked  on  fresh 
plaster,  while  the  artist  must  often  have  to  decorate  walls 
already  plastered  and  long  ago  dry.  In  this  case  there  would 
be  a  choice  between  replastering  for  fresco  and  the  more 
fiCCQoniical  alternative  of  employing  some  form  of  tempera. 

It  is  however  with  tempera  painting  on  panels  rather  than 
with  mural  work  that  we  are  here  concerned.  Vasari's  sum- 
mary treatment  of  the  process  in  §  82  ante,  p.  223,  contrasts 
with  Cennini's  far  more  elaborate  directions,  and  is  a  measure 
of  the  destructive  effect  of  the  inroad  of  oil  painting  on  the 
more  venerable  system.  At  the  outset  of  his  Trattato  Cennini 
gives    a   list   of   the    processes    the   panel    painter   has    to   go 


PAINTING   IN   TEMPERA  293 

through.  The  preliminary  ones,  before  painting  actually 
begins,  will  take  him  six  years  to  learn  and  Cennini  needs 
about  a  hundred  chapters  to  describe  them.  The  artificer  must 
know  how  to  grind  colours,  to  use  ^lue,  to  fasten  the 
linea  on  the  panel,  to  prime  with  gesso,  to  scrape  and  smooth 
the  gesso,  to  make  reliefs  in  ^esso.  to  put  on  bole,  to  gild,  to 

burmsil,    to    mix    temperas,    to    Ifiy    ""    gmnnHinfr    rnlnnrc;,    to 

transfer  bv  pouncing  through  pricked  lines,  to  sharpen  lines 
with  the  stylus,  to  indent  with  little  patterns,  to  carve,  to 
colour,  to  ornament  the  panel,  and  finally  to  varnish  it !  All  ■ 
this  suggests,  what  was  actually  the  case,  that  the  prnress  p£ 
tempera  painting  was  a  very  precise  and  methodical  one,  pro- 
ceeding  by  regular  stages  according  to  traditional  methods  and 
recipes.  The  result  was  from  the  point  of  view  of  modern 
painting  something  very  limited,  but  within  its  range,  and  in  the 
hands  of  artists  of  the  fifteenth  century,  it  was  a  very  finished 
and  exquisite  artistic  product,  one  indeed  to  which  we  return 
with  ever-renewed  delight  after  our  yearly  visits  to  the  Salon 
or  to  Burlington  House.  A  certain  natural  reaction,  that  some 
artists  of  to-day  have  felt  against  the  slashing  impressionistic 
style,  has  led  to  a  revival  of  the  old  precise  technique,  which 
is  now  cultivated  in  London  in  a  Society  of  Painters  in  Tempera. 
It  should  be  remembered  that  it  is_  perfectly  possible  to  paint 
'  a  tempera  '  in  a  free  and  loose  fashion  with  a  full  impasto  and 
individualistic  handling.  If  dry  powdered  colours  be  mixed 
with  the  yolk  or  whole  inside  of  an  egg  without  dilution,  the 
resulting  pigment  is  as  full  of  body  as  oil  paint  and  can  be 
manipulated  in  the  same  fashion.  What  is  generally  under- 
stood however  by  the  tempera  style  is  the  painting  of  the 
fifteenth  century  on  panel,  in  which,  as  Cennini  indicates,  the 
egg  would  be  diluted  with  about  its  own  bulk  of  water.  This 
rendered  the  pigment  comparatively  thin  and  as  a  result  trans- 
parent, and  allowed  coat  to  be  laid  over  coat,  so  that  Cennini 
contemplates  seven  or  eight  or  even  ten  coats  of  colour 
tempered  with  egg  yolk  diluted  with  water.  These  are  laid 
over  an  underpainting  in  a  monochrome  of  terra  verte,  and  are 
so  transparent  that  even  at  the  end  the  ground  will  remain 
slightly  visible  (c.  147)  and  so  help  the  modelling.  It  is  how- 
ever a  difficulty  in  tempera  that  it  dries  very  quickly,  too  quickly 


294  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

to  admit  of  that  fusing  of  the  tints  while  the  impasto  is  wet, 
which  Vasari  mentions  as  an  advantage  in  the  oil  process, 
§  83,  ante,  p.  230.  Hence  the  usual  ways  to  model  in  tempera 
are  (i)  to  superimpose  coats  varying  in  tone,  and  (2),  to  use 
hatching,  a  process  very  observable  in  early  Italian  temperas, 
such  as  some  ascribed  to  Botticelli  in  the  National  Gallery. 
Another  drawback,  not  so  marked  however  in  egg  tempera  as 
in  the  size  tempera  with  a  basis  of  whitening  used  by  scenic 
artists,  is  that  the  colours  dry  lighter  than  they  appear  when 
wet.  Those  who  in  the  present  day  are  enamoured  of  the 
tempera  process  say  that  these  inconveniences  do  not  trouble 
them,  while  they  delight  in  the  purity  of  the  tints,  the  precision 
of  the  forms,  which  it  enables  them  to  preserve,  and  in  a 
certainty  and  reposefulness  which  seem  to  belong  to  it.  One 
of  these  writes  as  the  result  of  her  experience  '  In  tempera  you 
work  with  solid  paints,  and  blending  must  be  extremely  rapid, 
or  a  substitute  for  this  must  be  found  in  thin  washes  or  in 
hatching.  Crisp  work  is  again  a  great  beauty,  but  from  the 
rapid  drying  of  the  paint  in  the  brush,  and  its  un-tenacious 
quality,  it  is  a  difficulty.  Vasari  is  right  in  saying  oil  is  a  great 
convenience,  but  its  introduction  does  not  seem  to  have  been  in 
all  respects  a  gain. ' 

OIL  PAINTING. 

[§   83,   Oil  Painting,   its  Discovery  and  Early  History, 
ante,  p.   226.] 

The  bare  fact  of  the  invention  of  oil  painting  by  John  of 
Bruges,  recorded  by  Vasari  in  1550  in  chapter  vii  of  his 
'  Introduction  '  to  Painting,  is  in  the  Life  of  Antonello  da 
Messina,  in  the  same  edition,  retold  in  the  personal  anecdotic 
vein  that  accords  with  Vasari 's  literary  methods.  Here  the 
'  invention  '  followed  on  the  splittio^i  of  a  particular  temppra 
panel,  varnished  in  oil,  that  according  to  traditional  i^rartW 
vaju-F^yk  hflH  put  nut  in  thp_amL_to  dr"y.  The  said  artuTtheJi 
turned  his  attention  to  devising  some  means  for  avoiding  such 
mischances  for  the  future,  and,  in  Vasari's  words,  '  being  not 
less  dissatisfied  with  the  varnish  than  with  the  process  of 
tempera  painting,  he  began  to  devise  means  for  preparing  a 


OIL   PAINTING  295 

kind  of  varnisVi  which  should  dry  in  the  shade,  so  as  to  avoid 
having  to  place  the  pictures  in  the  sun.  Having  made  experi- 
ments with  many  things  both  pure  and  in  compounds,  he  at 
last  found  that  linseed  and  nut  oil,  among  the  many  which  he 
had  tested,  were  more  drv'ng-  tVian  all  tVip  rp-^t  These  there- 
fore. Soiled  with  other  mixtures  of  his,  made  him  the  varnish 
wtTirVi  Vip  had  1nng  He.sireri.'  This  varnisVi,  Vasari  frnp.s  on  to 
say,  he  mixed  with  the  colTirfi  and  found  that  it  '  lit  up  the 
t-nWrg  so  powprfiilly  that  it  gave  a.  c^loss  ^f  ifgplf,'  without 
any   aftpr-poat   of   varnish. 

If  we  ask  What  is  the  truth  about  this  '  invention  '  of  van 
Eyck,  or  of  the  brothers  van  Eyck  (see  ante,  p.  226,  note  i),  the 
first  answer  of  any  one  knowing  alike  the  earlier  history  of  the 
oil  medium  and  Vasari's  anecdotal  predilections  would  be  '  there 
was  no  invention  at  all. '  The  drying  properties  of  linseed  and 
nut  oil,  and  the  way  to  increase  these,  had  been  known  for 
hundreds  of  years,  as  had  also  the  preparation  of  an  oil  varnish 
with^sandarac  resin.  There  is  question  too  of  a  colourless  spirit 
varnish,  and  of  the  process  of  mixing  varnish  with  oil  for  a 
painting  medium,  in  documents  prior  to  the  fifteenth  century. 
The  technique  of  oil  painting  is  described  by  Theophilus,  about 
1 100  A.D.  ;  in  the  Hermeneia  or  Mount  Athos  Handbook;  and 
in  the  Trattato  of  Cennini,  while  numerous  accounts  and  records 
of  the  thirteenth  and  fourteenth  centuries  establish  incontestably, 
at  any  rate  for  the  lands  north  of  the  Alps,  the  employment  of 
oils  and  varnishes  for  artistic  wall  and  panel  painting.  The 
epitaphs  for  the  tombs  of  the  two  van  Eycks  make  no  mention 
of  such  a  feat  as  Vasari  ascribes  to  them,  and  it  is  quite  open 
to  any  one  to  argue,  as  is  the  case  with  M.  Dalbon  in  his 
recent  Origines  de  la  Peinture  a  I'Huile,  Paris,  1904,  that  it 
was  no  special  improvement  in  technique  that  brought  the  van 
Eycks  their  fame  in  connection  with  oil  painting,  but  rather 
an  artistic  improvement  that  consisted  in  using  a  traditional 
process  to  execute  pictures  which  in  design,  finish,  beauty,  and 
glow  of  colour,  far  surpassed  anything  previously  produced  in 
the  northern  schools.  There  is  a  good  deal  of  force  in  this 
view,  but  at  the  same  time  it_is  impossible  to  deny  to  the  van 
Eycks  the  credit  of  technical  improvements.  They  Kacl  a 
reputation  for  this  long  before  the  time  of  Vasari.     In   1456, 


296  NOTES    ON    PAINTING 

fifteen  years  after  the  death  of  the  younger  brother  Jan,  Bar- 
tolomeo  Facie  of  Spezia  wrote  a  tract  De  Viris  Illustribus  in 
which  he  spoke  of  John  van  Eyck  as  specially  '  learned  in  those 
arts  which  contributed  to  the  making-  of  a  picture,  and  on  that 
account  credited  with  the  discovery  of  many  things  in  the  pro- 
perties of  colours,  which  he  had  learned  from  ancient  traditions 
recorded  by  Pliny  and  other  writers. '     The  Florentine  Filarete, 
c.    1464,   knew  of  the  repute  of  Jan  van   Eyck  in  connection 
with  the  oil  technique.     Hence  we  may  credit  the  van  Eycks 
with   certain   technical   improvements   on   traditional  practices 
and  preparations  in  the  oil  technique,  though  these  can  hardly 
be  termed  the  '  invention  of  oil  painting, '  while  their  artistic 
achievement  was  great  enough  to  force  into  prominence  what- 
ever in  the  technical  department  they  had  actually  accomplished. 
The  question  of  the  exact  technique  of  the  van  Eycks,  in  its 
relation  to  the  oil  practice  before  their  time,  is  one  that  has 
occupied   many   minds,    and   is    not   yet   satisfactorily   settled. 
Most  of  those  who  have  enunciated  theories  on  the  subject  have 
proceeded  by  guess-work,  and  have  suggested  media  and  pro- 
cesses that  may  possibly  have  been  used,  but  for  the  employ- 
ment of  which  there  is  no  direct  evidence.     The  most  recent 
suggestion  is  that  of  Principal  Laurie  of  Edinburgh,  and  this 
is   founded  on  scientific  analysis.     The  experiments  with  oils 
and   varnishes   and   other  media,    which   this   investigator  has 
been  carrying  on  for  many  years,   have  taught  him  that  the 
most  secure  substance  for  '  locking-up  '  pigments  as  the  phrase 
goes,  that  is  for  shielding  them  from  the  access  of  moisture  or 
deleterious   gases,    is   a   resin,    like   our   Canada   balsam,    that 
may  be  used  as  a  varnish  or  painting  medium  when  dissolved 
in  an  essential  oil.     As  he  believes  he  can  detect  in  the  van 
Eycks'  extant  pictures  pigments  that  would  only  have  lasted 
had    they    been    shielded    by    a    preparation    of    the    kind,    he 
conjectures  that  the  use  of  a  natural  pine  balsam,  with  probably 
a  small  proportion  of  drying  oil  and  rendered  more  workable 
by  emulsifying  with  egg,  may  be  the  real  secret  of  which  so 
many   investigators   have  been   in    search.     For   example,    the 
green  used  for  the  robe  of  John  Baptist  and  other  figures  in 
the   '  Adoration  of  the  Lamb  '   at  Ghent  can  be  matched,   as 
we   lately   found   by   experiment,    with   verdigris    (dissolved   in 


OIL  PAINTING  297 

pine  balsam  which  is  a  much  finer  green  than  verdigris  ground 
in  oil)  and  yellow  ochre  or  orpiment,  and  the  only  known  way 
of  rendering  verdigris  stable  is  to  dissolve  it  in  these  pine 
balsams,  according  to  a  recipe  that  is  actually  preserved  in 
the  de  Mayerne  MS.,  which  Berger  has  lately  printed  in  full 
in  the  fourth  Part  of  his  Beitrdge. 

Be  this  as  it  may,  one  thing  is  certain,  that  the  oil  painting 
of  the  van  Eycks  and  other  painters  of  the  early  Flemish  school 
did  not  differ  greatly  if  at  all  in  its  artistic  effect  from  the 
tempera  that  had  preceded  it,  and  that  is  described  in  the  last 
note.  Oil  painting,  in  the  sense  that  we  attach  to  the  term, 
is  really  the  creation  not  of  the  Flemings,  nor  of  the  Florentines 
and  other  Italians  who  were  the  first  to  try  experiments  with 
the  new  Flemish  process,  but  of  Giovanni  Bellini  and  the  other 
Venetians  who  adopted  the  oil  medium  in  the  last  quarter  of  the 
fifteenth  century.  According  to  Vasari,  ante,  p.  229,  and  Life 
of  Antonello  da  Messina,  Opere,  11,  563  f . ,  it  was  the  last  named 
artist  who  acquired  the  secret  of  the  invention  of  van  Eyck 
through  a  visit  to  Flanders,  and  brought  it  to  Venice.  Vasari 
has  been  proved  to  be  wrong  in  the  chronology  he  gives  of  the 
life  of  Antonello,  who  was  born  about  1444  and  was  therefore 
much  younger  than  Vasari  makes  him,  and  many  critics  have 
been  disposed  to  relegate  his  whole  account  of  the  Sicilian 
painter  to  the  realm  of  myth.  The  most  recent  authority  on 
the  subject  however,  Dr  von  Wurtzbach,  in  his  Niederldndisches 
Kiinstler-Lexicon,  vindicates  Vasari 's  accuracy  in  the  main 
points  of  the  visit  to  Flanders  and  the  introduction  of  the  new 
process  at  Venice,  which  event  may  be  fixed  about  1475.  It 
was  taken  up  with  avidity  by  the  Bellini  and  by  other  Venetians 
of  the  time,  and  it  is  to  the  younger  Bellini  more  than  to  any 
other  painter  that  is  due  the  apprehension  of  the  possibilities 
latent  in  the  oil  medium.  Giovanni  Bellini  began  to  manipulate 
the  oil  pigments  with  a  freedom  and  a  feeling  for  their  varied 
qualities  of  which  earlier  oil  painters  had  possessed  little  idea, 
and  the  way  was  prepared  for  the  splendid  unfolding  of  the 
technique  in  the  hands  of  Giorgione,  Palma,  and  Titian. 


298  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

ENRICHED    FACADES. 
[§§  90-92,   ante,  p.   240  f.] 

The  external  decorations,  of  which  Vasari  writes  in  chapters 
XI,  XII,  and  xiii  of  his  '  Introduction  '  to  Painting,  have  come 
down  to  us  in  a  very  dilapidated  condition,  but  there  are  still 
to  be  seen  specimens  of  all  the  work  he  there  describes,  as  well 
as  of  the  decorative  carvings  in  stone  noticed  in  the  '  Introduc- 
tion '  to  Architecture,  under  the  head  of  Travertine  (at  Rome) 
§  12,  Istrian  stone  (at  Venice)  §  15,  and  Pietra  forte  (at  Flor- 
ence) §  17;  ante,  pp.  51,  56,  60.  The  most  common  technique 
is  monochrome  painting  '  a  fresco  '  on  the  plaster,  and  a  good 
deal  that  passes  as  sgraffito  is  really  only  painted  work  in  which 
there  is  no  relief.  One  of  the  best  existing  displays  is  that  on 
the  fa9ade  of  the  Palazzo  Ricci,  at  Rome,  a  little  to  the  west  of 
the  Palazzo  Farnese.  Here  on  the  top  floor  are  painted  trophies 
of  armour  in  bronze  colour  (ante,  p.  241)  with  grotesques 
(ante,  p.  244)  in  yellow  and  brown  on  the  story  below.  On  the 
piano  nobile  there  is  a  frieze  of  figures  in  grisaille  monochrome, 
with  some  single  figures  on  a  larger  scale  between  the  windows. 
Above  the  door  is  another  frieze  of  figures  on  a  black  ground. 
More  extensive,  but  less  varied  and  not  so  well  preserved,  are 
the  figure  compositions  on  the  back  of  the  Palazzo  Massimi, 
in  the  Piazza  dei  Massimi,  at  Rome,  where  the  whole  wall  is 
covered  with  figure  monochromes  on  a  large  scale  on  dark 
grounds.  There  are  many  more  fragmentary  specimens,  as 
in  the  Via  Maschera  d'  Oro,  No.  7;  the  Via  Pellegrino,  No.  66, 
etc.  The  work  of  Maccari,  Roma,  Graffiti  e  Chiaroscuri,  Secolo 
XV,  XVI,  gives  a  large  collection  of  reproductions  of  work 
that  has  now  to  a  great  extent  perished. 

Sgraffito  work,  in  which  the  effect  is  produced  by  differences 
of  plane  in  the  plaster  itself  (see  ante,  p.  243),  resists  the 
weather  much  better  than  mere  painting,  but  it  takes  longer  to 
execute  and  was  not  so  much  used  as  the  more  rapidly  wrought 
fresco.  The  Palazzo  Montalvo,  in  the  Borgo  degli  Albizzi  at 
Florence,  offers  a  good  example  of  a  compromise.  The  work, 
at  any  rate  in  the  lower  part,  is  not  true  sgraffito  as  the  plaster 
in  the  backgrounds  is  not  scraped  away,  but  the  outlines  of  the 


DECORATION   ON  FACADES  299 

figures  and  ornaments  are  marked  by  lines  incised  in  the  plaster, 
the  brush,  with  light  and  dark  tints,  accomplishing  the  rest. 
On  the  other  hand  the  house  of  Bianca  Capello,  26  in  the  Via 
Maggio,  is  decorated  in  the  true  sgraffito  technique  as  described 
by  Vasari,  ante,  p.  243.  The  same  may  be  said  of  a  house  in 
Rome,  Via  Maschera  d'  Oro,  No.  9,  where  the  difference  of  the 
two  planes  of  plaster  is  about  an  eighth  of  an  inch.  This  work 
is  clogged  up  with  buff  lime-wash  and  would  be  worth  cleaning, 
as  it  seems  in  fair  preservation. 

Of  modelled  stucco  figure-designs  and  grotesques  the  Cortile 
of  the  Palazzo  Spada,  near  the  Campo  di  Fiore  at  Rome, 
presents  the  most  extensive  display.  A  more  interesting  piece 
of  work  will  however  be  found  not  far  away  in  the  Via  de' 
Banchi  Vecchi,  Nos.  22-24,  the  house  of  the  goldsmith  Pietro 
Crivelli  of  Milan,  of  the  first  half  of  the  sixteenth  century. 
Here  between  the  windows  of  the  first  floor  are  boldly  designed 
trophies  of  arms  carved  in  travertine,  while  between  and  above 
the  windows  of  the  second  floor  there  are  figures  and 
grotesques  effectively  modelled  in  stucco.  These  are  outlined 
with  an  incised  line  in  the  stucco  and  there  is  no  colour.  For 
free  but  not  over-florid  Renaissance  enrichment  the  fa9ade  is 
noteworthy.  The  abundant  stone  carving  at  Florence  in  the 
form  of  the  '  stemmi  '  has  been  already  referred  to,  ante,  p.  61. 

STUCCO   'GROTESQUES.' 

[§  92,   Grotesques  or  fanciful  devices  painted  or  modelled  on 
walls,  ante,  p.   244.] 

Vasari  touches  on  the  subject  of  plaster  work  in  all  three 
'  Introductions,'  to  Architecture  (§  29),  to  Sculpture  (§  73)  and 
to  Painting  (§  92).  In  the  former  passages  he  deals  with  the 
material  itself  and  with  what  may  be  called  its  utilitarian 
employment;  in  the  last  he  has  in  view  the  artistic  forms  into 
which  the  material  can  be  moulded,  and  which  he  calls  by  the 
curious  name  '  grotesques. '  What  these  '  grotesques  '  are  will 
presently  be  seen,  but  it  is  worth  while  first  casting  a  glance 
back  on  the  artistic  use  of  plaster  in  its  historical  aspects. 

It  is  not  a  little  remarkable  that  although  all  the  great 
ancient  nations  were  familiar  with  this  material,  it  was  not  till 


300  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

the  late  Greek  and  Greco-Roman  periods  that  any  general  use 
was  made  of  it  as  an  independent  vehicle  of  artistic  effect. 
The  Egyptians  coated  their  walls  with  plaster  of  exquisite 
quality,  which  they  brought  to  a  fine,  almost  a  polished,  surface 
for  their  tempera  paintings.  The  inhabitants  of  Mesopotamia 
protected  their  mud-brick  walls  with  thin  coats  of  lime  plaster, 
sometimes  only  about  a  quarter  of  an  inch  in  thickness  but 
perfect  in  durability  and  weather-resisting  properties.  The 
Phoenicians  at  Carthage  plastered  the  interior  walls  of  their 
tombs,  and  the  expression  '  whited  sepulchres  '  shows  that 
Jewish  tombs  were  coated  in  the  same  fashion.  All  through  the 
historical  period  of  Greek  art  plaster  was  at  the  command  of 
the  architect,  to  cover,  and  fill  up  inequalities  in,  the  rough 
stone  of  which  so  many  of  the  Hellenic  temples  were  built,  and 
fragments  of  the  pre-Persian  buildings  of  the  Athenian 
Acropolis,  still  preserved  on  the  rock,  show  how  finely  finished 
and  how  adhesive  was  this  stucco  film.  So  far  as  we  know 
however  none  of  the  peoples  just  named  seem  to  have  modelled 
in  the  material,  or  used  it  for  any  of  the  decorative  purposes 
for  which  the  Greeks  at  any  rate  employed  so  largely  the 
material  of  burnt  clay.  The  exception  is  in  the  case  of  the 
older  Aegean  peoples,  for  the  Cretans  of  Knossos  made,  as  all 
the  world  now  knows,  a  most  effective  artistic  use  of  modelled 
stucco.  This  Aegean  work  may  be  connected  technically  with 
Egypt,  for  in  the  latest  Egyptian  period  a  considerable  use 
was  made  of  modelled  plaster  for  sepulchral  purposes,  in  the 
form  of  mummy-cases  in  which  the  features  of  the  deceased, 
with  headdress,  jewels,  etc.,  were  represented  in  this  material. 
The  technique  may  go  back  in  Egypt  to  the  remoter  times  and 
may  have  been  carried  thence  to  the  Aegean  lands.  The  process 
however  was  apparently  not  inherited  by  the  historical  Greeks, 
who  did  not  begin  to  use  plaster  freely  and  artistically  till  the 
later  Hellenistic  or  Greco-Roman  period. 

Some  late  Greek  private  houses  of  the  second  or  first  century 
B.C.,  on  Delos,  show  a  beginning  of  modelled  plaster  work  in 
the  form  of  drafted  ashlar  stones  imitated  in  the  material,  and 
it  may  be  conjectured  that  the  technique  was  developed  at 
Alexandria,  for  the  earliest  existing  mature  works  in  the 
style,  the  famous  stucco  reliefs  and  mouldings  found  near  the 


MODELLED   PLASTER   WORK  301 

Villa  Farnesina  at  Rome,  resemble  in  many  respects  the 
so-called  '  Hellenistic '  reliefs,  with  landscape  motives,  that 
are  ascribed  to  the  school  of  Alexandria.  In  these  stuccoes, 
now  preserved  in  the  Terme  Museum  at  Rome,  there  are  bands 
of  enrichment  stamped  with  wooden  moulds,  after  the  fashion 
described  by  Vasari  in  the  '  Introduction  '  to  Sculpture,  §  73, 
that  enclose  fields  wherein  figure  compositions  with  landscape 
adjuncts,  or  single  figures,  have  been  modelled  by  hand.  Many 
of  these  last  are  of  great  beauty  of  form,  and  the  whole  have 
been  executed  with  the  lightest  but  firmest  touch  and  the  most 
delightful  freedom.  Some  ceiling  decorations  in  two  tombs  on 
the  Via  Latina,  of  the  second  century  a.d.,  are  almost  as  good 
in  execution,  and  are  interesting  as  giving  in  typical  form 
ancient  models  that  have  been  much  copied  at  the  Renaissance 
and  in  more  modern  times. 

Early  Christian  artists,  both  in  the  West  and  in  the  East  kept 
up  the  artistic  use  of  stamped  or  modelled  stucco.  The  Arabs 
inherited  the  technique,  and  at  Cairo,  and  in  the  East  and  in 
Spain,  they  made  a  very  extensive  and  tasteful  use  of  the 
tractable  material  in  their  own  style  of  artistic  decoration. 
This  style,  like  that  of  Byzantium,  from  which  in  great  part  it 
was  derived ;  and  that  of  the  familiar  Indian  work  in  the 
exquisite  marble-dust  plaster  or  chunam,  is  chiefly  surface 
decoration,  without  much  plastic  feeling,  and  relying  mainly  on 
geometrical,  or  at  any  rate  inorganic,  motives  and  forms.  Bold 
modelling  of  forms  accentuated  by  light  and  shade,  as  we  are 
kindly  informed  by  Dr  James  Burgess,  does  occur  in  old 
Buddhist  work  in  northern  India,  and  some  excellent  examples 
have  recently  been  published  in  Ancient  Khotan  (Chinese 
Turkistan)  Oxford,  1907,  vol.  i,  p.  587  and  pi.  liii  ff.  The  work 
however  belongs  essentially  to  the  West  rather  than  to  the 
East,  and  the  middle-ages  in  Western  Europe  produced  some 
remarkable  works  in  this  style.  There  is  some  modelled  stucco- 
work  of  early  date  in  the  Baptistry  at  Ravenna,  but  the  most 
interesting  examples  of  the  period  in  Italy  are  the  large  figures 
of  saints  and  the  archivolt  enriched  with  very  bold  and  effective 
vine  scrolls,  that  are  to  be  seen  in  the  interior  of  the  little 
oratory  of  S.  Maria  in  Valle  (or  Peltrude's  chapel)  at  Cividale 
in  Friuli.     These  very  remarkable  works,  with  which  may  be 


302  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

connected  the  stuccoes  of  the  altar  ciborium  at  S.  Ambrogio, 
Milan,  date  about  iioo,  and  may  be  paralleled  by  similar 
figures,  equally  plastic  in  treatment,  and  of  about  the  same 
period,  north  of  the  Alps,  in  St  Michael's  at  Hildesheim. 
Signer  Cattaneo  calls  the  Cividale  work  '  Byzantine,'  but  life- 
sized  plastically-treated  figures  in  high  relief  represent  a  form 
of  decorative  art  that  was  not  practised  at  Byzantium,  and  the 
work,  like  a  good  deal  else  that  is  too  lightly  dubbed  '  Byzan- 
tine,' is  no  doubt  of  western  origin,  and  is  a  proof  that  the 
tradition  of  modelling  in  plaster  was  handed  down  without  a 
break  through  the  mediaeval  period. 

At  the  Renaissance  the  tradition  was  revived,  and  this  style 
of  decoration  was  developed  in  Tuscany  and  North  Italy,  while 
one  of  its  most  conspicuous  triumphs  was  the  adornment  by 
Italian  artists  in  the  first  half  of  the  sixteenth  century  of  the 
Galerie  Frangois  Premier  and  Escalier  du  Roi  at  Fontainebleau 
in  France.  It  spread  also  to  our  own  country,  where  artists 
of  the  Italian  school  carried  out  work  in  the  same  thoroughly 
plastic  style  in  the  now  destroyed  palace  of  Nonsuch,  under 
the  patronage  of  Henry  VIII. 

This  is  not  however  the  style  that  Vasari  has  in  view  when 
he  speaks  of  '  stucco  grotesques. '  What  he  means  is  an 
imitation  of  ancient  stamped  and  modelled  plaster  decoration, 
of  the  type  of  that  represented  in  the  tombs  on  the  Via  Latina 
just  referred  to.  Here  the  scale  is  small,  though  the  work  may 
cover  large  'spaces,  and  the  design  is  on  the  whole  of  a  light 
and  fanciful  kind.  The  impulse  to  it  dates  from  the  early  years 
of  the  sixteenth  century  when  considerable  discoveries  were 
made  at  Rome,  in  the  Baths  of  Titus  and  elsewhere,  of  antique 
apartments  or  sepulchral  chambers  decorated  in  this  fashion. 
As  these  interiors,  when  discovered,  were  all  underground  they 
were  called  '  caves  '  or  '  grottoes,'  and  for  this  reason,  as 
Benvenuto  Cellini  informs  us  in  the  6th  chapter  of  his  Auto- 
biography, the  decoration  characteristic  of  them  was  called 
'  grottesque. '  The  fact  that  the  designs  were  so  commonly  of 
the  fantastic  or  so-called  '  Pompeian  '  order  has  given  to  the 
word  '  grotesque '  its  modern  meaning  of  bizarre  or  semi- 
ludicrous. 

According  to  Vasari,  the  painter  Morto  da  Feltro  (c.   1474- 


TARSIA   WORK  303 

c.  1519)  was  the  first  to  study  these  antique  decorations.  '  Our 
first  thanks  and  commendations  '  he  says  {Opere,  ed.  Milanesi, 
V,  205  f.)  '  are  due  to  Morto,  who  was  the  first  to  discover  and 
restore  the  kind  of  painting  called  "  arabesques  "  and  "  grot- 
tesques,"  seeing  that  they  were  for  the  most  part  hidden  among 
the  subterraneous  portions  of  the  ruins  of  Rome,  whence  he 
brought  them,  devoting  all  his  study  to  this  branch  of  art. '  He 
spent  many  months  also,  Vasari  tells  us,  at  Tivoli  among  the 
ruins  of  Hadrian's  Villa,  and  made  a  journey  to  Pozzuoli  near 
Naples,  all  on  the  same  quest.  Stucco  reliefs  in  this  revived 
antique  style  were  used  at  the  beginning  of  the  sixteenth 
century  by  Pinturicchio  in  the  Appartamenti  Borgia  in  the 
Vatican,  and  from  that  time  onwards  they  become  exceedingly 
common. 


TARSIA  WORK,  OR  WOOD    INLAYS. 
[§    100,  Inlays  in  Wood,  ante,   p.   262.] 

The  covering  of  one  kind  of  material  by  another,  for  reasons 
of  a  constructive  or  an  aesthetic  kind,  is  so  primitive  and  so 
universal  that  Gottfried  Semper  made  it  the  fundamental  prin- 
ciple of  decoration  in  general,  and  developed  this  view  in 
his  famous  '  Bekleidungstheorie, '  which  dominates  der  Stil. 
Semper's  philosophy  of  art  was  sufficiently  profound  for  him  to 
see  that  this  process  is  not  to  be  accused  of  insincerity  because 
the  more  costly  or  beautiful  material  appears  only  on  the  out- 
side, while  the  mass  of  the  structure  may  be  of  commoner 
fabric.  The  materials  in  question  are  as  a  rule  limited  in 
quantity  and  it  would  be  bad  economy  to  employ  them  in 
positions  where  their  beauty  would  not  be  seen.  To  build  a 
thick  wall  of  rare  finely-veined  and  coloured  marble  in  solid 
blocks  would  be  to  behave  like  degenerate  Roman  Emperors. 
Such  material  is  far  more  suitably  treated  when  it  is  exposed  in 
thin  layers  over  as  large  a  superficial  area  as  possible.  Hence 
though  there  is  nothing  in  the  world  to  equal  the  fine 
'  isodomon  '  masonry  of  the  earlier  Greeks,  which  is  the  same 
throughout,  there  is  much  to  be  said  in  justification  of  the 
late  Greek  and  Roman  technique,  so  lai'gely  used  in  mediaeval 


304  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

Italy,  of  incrusting  a  common  material  with  one  of  finer  grain 
and  colour. 

In  the  case  of  wood  inlays,  it  may  be  claimed  for  the  craft  that 
it  originates  in  material  need  and  not  in  any  aesthetic  considera- 
tions. Wood,  of  which  the  grain  always  runs  one  way,  needs 
sometimes  to  be  overlaid,  braced,  and  prevented  from  warping 
by  a  slip  of  the  same  material  placed  with  the  grain  at  right 
angles  to  the  first,  after  the  fashion  seen  in  our  common 
drawing-boards.  The  great  variety  in  colours  and  markings 
shown  by  different  woods  must  however  at  a  very  early  date 
have  led  to  the  employment  of  inlays  and  veneers  for  reasons  of 
artistic  effect,  and  in  this  craft  the  old  Oriental  peoples  were 
proficient.  It  is  worthy  of  notice  that  some  Greek  wood  inlays 
have  survived,  and  may  be  seen  in  the  Kertch  room  at  the 
Hermitage  in  St  Petersburg.  The  motives  of  all  early  inlays 
are  either  geometrical  patterns  or  simple  conventional  orna- 
ment, like  the  olive  sprays  which  are  represented  in  the  Greek 
work  just  mentioned.  In  these  forms  the  craft  was  preserved 
through  the  mediaeval  period,  and  though  in  the  West,  at  any 
rate  north  of  the  Alps,  the  mediaeval  epoch  was  one  in  which 
ornamentation  was  plastic  rather  than  graphic,  that  is  to  say, 
in  carving  more  often  than  in  inlay,  yet  in  Moorish  lands,  and 
in  parts  of  Italy,  inlays,  both  in  stone  and  wood,  were  freely 
developed. 

The  history  of  Italian  tarsia  work  takes  a  new  start  with  the 
beginning  of  the  Renaissance,  and  it  became  as  Bode  has  termed 
it  '  a  true  child  of  the  art  of  the  Quattrocento  '  or  fifteenth 
century.  The  earliest  examples  seem  to  be  in  geometrical 
schemes,  influenced  by  the  so-called  '  Cosmati  '  work,  or  inlays 
of  small  pieces  of  coloured  stones  and  gilded  pastes,  so  common 
in  Italy  from  the  twelfth  to  the  fourteenth  century.  The  painted 
borders  to  the  frescoes  of  Giotto  and  other  pre-Renaissance 
masters  imitate  this  kind  of  work  and  show  how  familiar  it  must 
have  been.  Next  come  conventional  ornaments  in  the  so-called 
'  Italian  '  manner,  consisting  in  acanthus  scrolls,  swags  of  fruit 
and  flowers,  with  classical  motives  such  as  horns  of  plenty  and 
candelabra,  among  which  are  soon  introduced  '  putti  '  or 
Cupids,  terminal  figures,  etc.  As  the  fifteenth  century  advanced 
there  was  developed  the  curious  penchant,  noticed  ante,  p.  264, 


TARSIA   WORK  305 

for  introducing  perspective  delineations  of  buildings  and  articles 
of  furniture  into  the  tarsia  designs.  Vasari  in  his  Life  of 
Filippo  Brunelleschi  Opere,  ed.  Milanesi,  11,  333  (see  also  the 
text  ante,  p.  262),  distinctly  intimates  that  this  was  due  to  the 
influence  of  this  artist,  whose  enthusiasm  for  perspective  studies 
is  well  known.  The  only  existing  works  in  wood  inlay  which 
might  claim  to  be  designed  or  inspired  by  Brunelleschi  are  those 
in  the  old  sacristy  of  S.  Lorenzo  at  Florence,  but  these  do  not 
display  perspectives,  and  the  subjects  comprise  only  '  putti  ' 
with  candelabra,  rosettes,  and  other  simple  ornaments.  The 
influence  of  Brunelleschi  on  the  advancement  of  the  study  of 
perspective  was  however  so  great,  that  Vasari 's  view  of  his 
general  responsibility  for  the  perspectives  is  credible. 

With  the  perspective  designs  of  the  latter  part  of  the  fifteenth 
and  beginning  of  the  sixteenth  century,  was  developed  the 
elaborate  delineation  of  objects  of  still  life,  as  well  as  more 
ambitious  work  in  the  representation  of  the  human  figure,  alone 
or  in  groups.  These  inlays  were  abundantly  displayed  in  wall 
panelling  and  on  the  doors  of  presses,  and  more  especially  on 
the  backs  and  frames  of  choir  stalls  in  the  churches.  It  is  char- 
acteristic of  Italian  decoration  as  opposed  to  that  prevailing  at 
an  earlier  date  north  of  the  Alps,  to  find  choir  stalls,  which  in 
northern  churches  are  made  the  occasion  of  the  most  splendid 
display  of  wood  carving  in  the  boldest  architectural  and  plastic 
styles  which  the  world  has  to  show,  decorated  in  Italy  for  the 
most  part  in  a  pictorial  style  with  flat  inlays. 

The  number  of  extant  examples,  both  in  the  case  of  presses 
and  of  choir  stalls,  is  so  great  that  no  enumeration  is  possible, 
and  the  reader  is  referred  for  a  critical  account  of  the  chief 
monuments  of  the  art  to  the  small  book  by  Dr  Scherer,  Technik 
und  Geschichte  der  Intarsia,  Leipzig,  1891.  The  artists  who 
fostered  the  work  were  also  very  numerous,  and  represent  many 
centres  in  the  northern  parts  of  Italy.  We  learn  for  instance 
that  in  Florence  alone  in  the  year  1478  there  were  no  fewer 
than  84  botteghe  where  tarsia  work  was  in  full  practice.  The 
names  actually  mentioned  by  Vasari  will  suffice  to  represent 
the  chief  phases  of  the  craft.  If  Brunelleschi  may  have  started 
the  idea  of  perspective  designs,  these  were  carried  out  to  great 
perfection  by  Fra  Giovanni  da  Verona,  whose  master-works,  the 

u 


3o6  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

stalls  and  presses  in  S.  Maria  in  Organo  at  Verona,  dating  from 
about  1500  onwards,  are  among  the  most  famous  examples  of 
the  kind.  Here  are  perspectives  of  buildings  and  furniture, 
objects  of  still-life,  and  the  like,  with  geometrical  patterns  in 
the  framings  and  on  the  dado.  In  figure  work  Benedetto  da 
Majano,  whom  Vasari  mentions,  and  more  especially  his 
brother  Giuliano  da  Majano,  were  masters  of  the  very  first  rank, 
and  the  examples  left  by  the  latter  on  the  presses  of  the  sacristy 
of  the  Duomo  at  Florence,  and  on  the  door  leading  to  the  Sala 
d'  Udienza  in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio,  are  masterpieces  of 
technique  and  style.  At  a  later  date  near  the  middle  of  the 
century,  the  artist  mentioned  by  Vasari  towards  the  end  of  his 
chapter  xvii,  Fra  Damiano  of  Bergamo,  a  pupil  of  the  same 
Venetian  school  from  which  proceeded  Fra  Giovanni  of  Verona, 
executed  at  S.  Domenico  in  Bologna  a  series  of  works  in  tarsia 
that  represent  the  furthest  development  in  a  pictorial  direction 
that  the  craft  ever  attained. 

Of  this  display  however  Dr  Scherer  aptly  writes  (p.  80)  that, 
'  whoever  demands  from  wood  an  effect  similar  to  that  of  a 
picture,  sets  it  in  ignorance  of  its  nature  to  tasks  that  are 
beyond  its  capabilities,  and  constrains  material  and  technique 
to  exaggerated  efforts  which  are  contradictory  to  their  char- 
acter. This  is  the  fundamental  error  that  clings  to  all  the 
works  of  the  much-belauded  Fra  Damiano  and  is  calculated 
seriously  to  obscure  his  greatness.'  The  development  of  tarsia 
work  was  in  the  direction  of  pictorial  effects.  Though  purely 
decorative  patterns  of  a  geometrical  or  conventional  kind  were 
always  used,  they  tended  as  the  art  advanced  to  be  confined 
to  borders  and  subsidiary  parts  of  a  design,  while  the  principal 
fields  were  pictorially  treated.  The  introduction  of  perspectives 
naturally  led  to  the  accentuation  of  the  third  dimension  of 
objects,  and  in  still-life  compositions  modelling  and  shading 
were  deemed  essential.  The  human  figure,  the  use  of  which 
increased  greatly  as  the  fifteenth  century  advanced,  was  given 
its  plastic  roundness  which  it  was  assuming  in  the  contempor- 
ary frescoes.  Conventional  leafage,  etc.,  was  no  longer  treated 
for  the  effect  of  a  mere  flat  pattern.  In  the  latter  part  of  the 
century  the  figure  work  of  Giuliano  da  Majano  shows  how  far 
in  this  direction  the  art  could  be  carried  while  still  preserving 


> 


TARSIA   WORK  3°/ 

its  sincerity  as  a  mosaic  of  natural  woods.  In  this  work  the 
utmost  advantage  is  taken  of  the  varieties  shown  by  woods  in 
colour  and  texture,  without  dependence  on  artificial  colouring 
matters,  and  those  pictorial  refinements  over  which  Vasari  sings 
his  usual  paean,  but  which  really  prefigure  the  decline  of  the  art. 
A  close  examination  of  a  specimen  of  Giuliano's  inlays  of  about 
1470-80,  such  as  the  S.  Zenobi  now  in  the  Opera  del  Duomo  at 
Florence  (see  Plate  XVI),  shows  extraordinary  skill  and  patience 
in  the  laborious  work.  The  outlines  are  marked  by  thin  strips 
of  black  wood;  the  staff  which  the  Saint  holds  in  his  hand, 
though  it  is  not  half-an-inch  broad,  is  modelled  in  light  and 
shade  with  no  fewer  than  six  parallel  strips  of  wood  varying 
in  light  and  dark.  The  hands  are  carefully  modelled  in  inlays. 
The  mouth  of  the  figure  on  the  right  of  the  Saint  has  one  piece 
for  the  upper  lip  and  a  lighter  piece  for  the  lower  in  which  the 
two  lights  on  the  lobes  are  let  in  with  separate  pieces.  The 
shadow  between  the  Ups  and  the  light  on  the  lower  edge  of  the 
lower  lip  are  inserted  with  strips  of  dark  and  light  tinted  wood. 
In  one  of  the  most  interesting  works  of  the  da  Majano  brothers, 
the  two  portrait  figures  of  Dante  and  Petrarch,  on  the  door 
leading  into  the  Sala  d'  Udienza  in  the  Palazzo  Vecchio  at 
Florence,  the  face  of  the  older  poet  is  deeply  furrowed,  and  in 
order  to  prevent  the  inlaid  streaks  appearing  too  hard  and 
'  liney  '  they  are  made  up  of  an  infinite  number  of  little  morsels 
of  wood  the  size  and  shape  of  millet  grains,  each  one  glued 
down  into  its  place.  Such  work  impresses  the  spectator  by 
its  sincerity  and  earnestness  as  well  as  by  its  technical  mastery. 
The  use  of  artificial  colouring  matters,  over  and  above  the 
burning  which  was  the  first  device  employed  to  give  an  effect  of 
shading  in  special  places,  destroys  for  us  this  aspect  of  sincerity. 
The  material  is  no  longer  allowed  to  express  itself  in  its  own 
character,  and  taste  revolts  from  the  work  as  it  does  from 
tapestry  in  which  pigments  have  been  used  to  give  details  for 
which  stitches  should  in  the  theory  of  the  work  suffice.  The 
case  is  different  from  that  of  the  coloured  wax  medallions 
noticed  ante,  p.  188  f.,  where  the  scale  is  so  small,  and  the 
detailed  representation  of  nature  so  essential  a  part  of  the  work, 
that  waxes  coloured  in  the  piece  could  hardly  be  made  to  avail. 


308  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

THE   STAINED    GLASS   WINDOW. 

[§   loi,  Stained  Glass   Windows,  their  Origin  and  History, 
ante,  p.   265.] 

This  is  not  a  specially  Italian  form  of  the  decorative  art,  but 
belongs  rather  to  France  and  north-western  Europe.  A  proof 
of  this  may  be  found  in  the  fact  that  in  1436  the  Florentines 
have  to  send  for  a  worker  in  glass  from  Liibeck  in  Germany  to 
make  windows  for  their  Duomo  (Gaye,  Carteggio,  11,  441  f.), 
while  at  the  beginning  of  the  next  century  Pope  Julius  II 
summons  French  verriers  to  supply  coloured  windows  for  the 
Vatican  (see  ante,  p.  266,  note).  The  art  was  differently 
regarded  north  and  south  of  the  Alps,  and  Vasari  in  his  account 
of  it  gives,  in  §  102,  the  tradition  of  the  northern  schools,  but 
lets  us  see  at  the  same  time,  in  §  loi,  how  the  Italians  were 
accustomed  to  envisage  the  craft. 

There  is  accordingly  in  his  treatment  a  confusion  between  two 
distinct  ideals  of  the  art,  one  traditional  and  northern,  the  other 
congenial  to  an  Italian  painter  of  the  sixteenth  century.  Accord- 
ing to  the  first  ideal  of  the  art,  that  on  which  it  was  founded 
and  nurtured  north  of  the  Alps,  it  depended  for  its  effect  upon 
coloured  glass,  that  is  upon  the  varied  tints  of  pieces  of  glass 
stained  in  the  mass  with  metallic  oxides,  and  called  by  the 
moderns  '  pot  metal. '  These  different  coloured  pieces  were  so 
arranged  and  so  treated  as  to  give  the  appearance  of  figures  or 
ornaments,  and  to  this  extent  the  effect  was  pictorial,  but  such 
a  window  would  depend  for  its  beauty  far  more  on  the 
sumptuous  display  of  coloured  light  than  on  any  delineation  of 
figures  or  objects. 

The  sort  of  window  which  would  present  itself  to  the  Italian 
of  the  Renaissance,  as  representing  his  ideal  of  the  art,  is  rather 
a  transparent  picture  painted  on  glass,  in  which  delineation  is 
the  chief  part  of  the  effect.  This  is  the  view  that  Vasari  has 
in  mind,  when,  in  §  loi,  he  insists  on  transparency  in  the  glass 
employed.  The  old  glass  worker  of  Chartres  or  the  Sainte 
Chapelle  would  hardly  have  known  what  to  do  with  transparent 
uncoloured  glass,  for  this,  save  in  pearl  borders,  was  not  an 
element  with  which  he  worked.     Vasari  however  starts  with  the 


STAINED   GLASS   WINDOWS  309 

idea  of  clear  glass  and  imagines  it  coloured  in  sucli  a  way  as 
to  produce  a  transparent  picture.  There  were  two  methods  for 
this  colouring.  The  only  satisfactory  one  was  to  paint  in 
transparent  enamel  colours  which  were  afterwards  burnt  in  on 
to  the  glass.  This  was  a  process  specially  developed  in  the 
fifteenth  and  sixteenth  centuries  in  Flanders,  whence  it  was 
probably  introduced  into  Italy. 

The  other  method  was  to  employ  transparent  pigments,  such 
as  were  used  for  ordinary  painting,  and  to  fix  them  on  the  glass 
by  means  of  gum  or  varnish.  This  method  is  of  course  a  mere 
pis  alter  to  which  no  self-respecting  worker  in  glass  would  like 
to  have  recourse,  and  must  be  regarded  as  merely  a  cheap 
imitation  of  true  glass  painting  in  enamel  colours.  That  is  to 
say,  it  did  not  precede,  as  Vasari  suggests  in  §  loi,  but 
followed  as  an  imitation,  the  development  of  true  enamel  paint- 
ing. That  the  two  processes  were  in  use  in  Italy  in  Vasari 's 
time  is  shown  by  a  contract  printed  by  Gaye,  Carteggio,  11,  446, 
in  which  certain  windows  to  be  executed  at  Arezzo  in  1478  are 
to  be  '  cotte  al  fuoco, '  '  burned  in  the  fire, '  and  not  merely  to 
have  the  colours  '  messi  a  olio, '  '  laid  on  in  oil-paint. ' 

The  earlier  glass  workers  of  the  palmy  days  of  the  craft,  from 
the  twelfth  to  the  fourteenth  century,  in  France,  England, 
Flanders,  or  Germany,  aimed  at  different  effects  altogether,  and 
their  technique  is  explained  by  Vasari  in  §  102,  (ante,  p.  268), 
where  the  whole  character  of  the  work  envisaged  differs  from 
the  painted  work  previously  in  contemplation.  As  is  indicated 
in  a  foot-note  to  the  text,  the  description  of  the  work,  which 
starts  it  will  be  noticed  with  '  bits  of  red,  yellow,  blue,  and 
white  glass,'  not  with  a  clear  pane,  is  almost  exactly  what  we 
find  in  Theophilus,  though  a  little  less  simple,  and  represents 
the  early  tradition  of  the  mediaeval  masters.  Their  work  was 
the  development  of  an  Early  Christian  technique.  Coloured 
glass,  which  it  must  be  remembered  is  really  easier  to  procure 
than  glass  perfectly  clear,  was  first  used  in  little  rounds  or 
squares  for  insertion  in  the  holes  pierced  in  marble  or  plaster 
slabs  that  filled  window  openings.  Such  window  fillings  are  to 
be  seen  in  mosques  and  Byzantine  churches.  The  next  stage 
was  a  mosaic  of  pieces  of  coloured  glass  arranged  on  a  certain 
scheme  and  perhaps  displaying  geometrical  patterns.     No  speci- 


3IO  NOTES   ON    PAINTING 

mens  of  early  windows  of  this  kind  seem  to  have  survived,  but 
they  are  referred  to  in  contemporary  documents,  as  in  the  Liber 
Pontijicalis,  where  it  is  said  that  Leo  III,  795-816,  in  Old  St. 
Peter's,   '  fenestras  de  apsida  ex  vitro  diversis  coloribus  con- 
clusit.'     It  is  not  clear  whether  such  mosaics,   or  something 
more  pictorial,  is  referred  to  by  Abbot  Gozbert  of  Tegernsee 
about  the  year  looo  a.d.  as  '  discoloria  picturarum  vitra,'  but 
about  this  same  epoch  we  find  it  stated  of.  Archbishop  Adalberon 
of  Reims,  who  died  in  989  a.d.,  that  he  supplied  his  church 
with  '  fenestris  diversas  continentibus  historias/  which  certainly 
implies  something  more  than  the  kaleidoscope  effect  of  a  mere 
conjunction  of  coloured  pieces.     Theophilus,  whose  treatment 
of  the  process  shows  that  it  was  fully  established  at  the  time  of 
his  writing,  say  about  iioo  a.d.,  makes  it  clear  wherein  the 
innovation  consisted.     The  new  invention  was  that  of  a  oiy- 
mentp  of  a  brown  colour  when  fused,  with  which  could  he  painted 
any  details  or  shading-  required  for  representing  the  forms  of 
objects.     A  mere  patch  of  pale  flesh-coloured  glass  the  shape  of 
a  face  would  tell  nothing,  but  when  the  features,  the  locks  of. 
the  hair,  and  the  like,  were  painted  in  with  this  piyment  then  the 
patch  became  a.  human  countenance.      In  the  same  way  a  piece 
of  red  or  blue  glass  with  some  lines  and  shading  on  it  became 
a  garment,  and  so  on  with  the  representation  in  a  simple  and 
summary  fashion  of  the  objects  necessary  to  constitute  the  sort 
of    pictorial    representation    suitable    to    the    technique.     The 
coloured  glass   remained  throughout  the   essential   element  in 
the  effect.     All  the  finest  glass  windows   of  tlie  twelfth  and 
thirteenth   centuries   were   executed   with   these   simple  media. 
The  later   history   of   the   art   shows   as   usual   a   progressive 
advance  in  the  importance  of  the  pictorial  element,  till  by  the 
sixteenth  century  coloured  glass  is  scarcely  needed,   and  the 
pictorial  effect  desired  may  be  gained  by  fusing  pigments  on 
to  clear  glass,  in  the  way  Vasari  contemplates  in  §  loi  (ante, 
p.  267). 

Of  this  Italian  stained  glass  of  the  Renaissance  period  very 
good  examples  are  to  be  seen  in  the  Laurentian  Library  at 
Florence,  and  a  specimen  is  shown  on  Plate  XVII. 

Chapter  xiii  of  Charles  Heath  Wilson's  Life  and  Works  of 
Michelangelo  contains  a  good  critical  notice  of  the  decorative 


Plate  XVII 


PAINTED 

GLASS 

WINDOW 

IN  THE 

LAURENTIAN 

LIBRARY, 

FLORENCE 


STAINED   GLASS   AND   ENAMELS  311 

work  at  the  Laurentian  Library.  The  windows,  which  were 
not  executed  till  long  after  the  death  of  Clement  VII  whose 
name  appears  on  the  glass,  he  thinks  may  be  mainly  from  the 
designs  of  Vasari's  friend  Francesco  Salviati,  a  pupil  of  the 
glass  painter  Guglielmo  da  Marcillat.  He  writes  of  them  : — 
'  These  windows  both  in  design  and  colour  are  admirably  suited 
to  Italian  architecture,  and  offer  useful  lessons  at  the  present 
time.  Introduced  into  a  Library  where  plenty  of  light  was 
indispensable,  white  glass  prevails.  There  is  much  yellow 
(silver)  stain,  and  where  colour  is  wanted  in  some  parts,  pot 
metal  is  introduced,  but  there  is  not  much  of  it.  The  shadows 
are  vigorously  painted  in  enamel  brown  of  a  rich  tone.  Unlike 
modern  painted  glass,  the  figures  and  ornaments  are  drawn 
with  all  the  skill  of  an  educated  artist,  and  it  is  a  pleasure  to 
look  at  them.' 

The  Victoria  and  Albert  Museum  in  London  affords  the  oppor- 
tunity for  a  comparison  of  all  these  different  styles.  There  is 
some  original  glass  of  the  thirteenth  century  from  the  Sainte 
Chapelle  at  Paris,  made  of  small  pieces  of  very  richly  tinted 
glass,  coloured  in  the  mass,  the  effect  being  more  that  of  a  very 
rich  and  beautiful  diaper  pattern  than  a  picture ;  while  close  by 
may  be  seen  a  Flemish  window  of  1542,  in  which  the  pieces  of 
glass  are  of  large  size  and  in  many  cases  are  white,  the  neces- 
sary colouring  being  added  in  different  enamel  pigments.  The 
subject  is  the  Last  Supper,  and  a  purely  pictorial  result  is 
aimed  at,  the  effect  of  colour  being  as  a  fact  extremely  poor. 

VASARI'S   DESCRIPTION   OF  ENAMEL  WORK. 

[§   105,  Enamels  over  Reliefs,  ante,  p.  276.] 

Coloured  vitreous  pastes  are  among  the  most  valuable 
materials  at  the  command  of  thp  Hernrativp  arti<^t,  and  are 
erpployed  in  numerous  crafts,  as  for  example  for  the  glazes  of 
keramic  products  including  floor  or  wall  tiles,  for  painted  glass 
wjjidows,  for  glass  mosaic,  and  for  enamel  work.  The  glass  is 
jinged  in  the  mass  with  various  metallic  oxides,  one  of  the 
finest  colours  being  a  rubv  red  gained  from  gold.  Silver  gives 
yellow,  copper  a  blue-green,  cobalt  blue,  manganese  violet,  aijid 
so  on.     Tin  in  any  form  has  the  property  of  making  the  vitreous 


312  NOTES   ON   PAINTING 

paste  opaque.     The  material  is  generally  lustrpus,  and  it  admits 
of  a  great  variety  in  colours  some  of  which  are  highly  saturated 
and  beautiful.     It  is  on  the  lustre  and  colour  of  the  substance, . 
more  than  on  the  pictorial  designs  that  can  be  produced  by  its 
aid,  that  its  artistic  value  depends. 

The  difference  between  opaque  and  transparent  coloured  glass 
is  the  basis  of  a  division  that  can  be  made  among  the  crafts 
which  employ  the  material.  If  the  glass  be  kept  transparent 
the  finest  possible  effect  is  obtained  from  it  in  the  stained  gla^s 
windosy  where  the  colours  are  seen  by  transmitted  light.  A 
similar  effect  is  secured  on  a  minute  scale  in  that  form  of  enamel 
work  called  by  Labarte  '  pmgiiv  jt  plignp  a  jn^j^j '  or  '  trans- 
parent cloisonnt^  enamel/   in   wfiirh   tran<;parpnt  rnlnnrpH   pactpg 

are  fused  into  small  apertures  in  metal  plates.  Old  examples  in 
this  kind  are  very  rare,  but  modern  workers  seem  to  reproduce 
it  without  difficulty.  On  the  other  hand  transparent  or  more 
usually  opaque  vitreous  pastpg  in  thin  films  form  many  of  the 
so-called  '  glazes  '  which  give  the  charm  of  lustre  and  colour., 
to  so  many  products  of  the  potter's  art.  The  most  effective 
use  of  opaque  coloured  glass  is  in  wall  mosaic,  where  it  is  seen 
by  reflected  light,  and  owes  its  beauty  to  its  lustrousness  as  well 
as  to  the  richness  and  variety  of  its  hues.  Between  these  two 
crafts  of  the  stained-glass  window  and  mosaic  comes  that  of 
the  enameller,  who  makes  use  of  vitreous  pastes  both  in  an 
opaque  and  a  transparent  condition.  The  identity  of  the 
materials  in  these  different  uses  is  shown  by  the  fact  that 
Theophilus,  Bk.  ii,  ch.  12,  directs  the  enameller  to  pound  up  and 
mek  for  his  incrustations  the  very  cubes  used  in  old  mosaics, 
or  as  he  puts  it '  in  antiquis  aedificiis  paganorum  in  musivo  opere 
diversa  genera  vitri.'  Enamel  work  consists  in  fusing  these 
coloured  pastes  oyer  surfaces  that  are  generally  of  metal,  the 
different  tints  heinff  pithpr  Histinrtly  separated  by  Hiyisipnc^  nr 
else^  running  beside.-£ach  other,  or  again  interpenetrating  like 
the  colours  in  a  picture.  Hence  there  are  two  main  HivUinng  nf 
the  enameller 's  craft,  the  painted  enamel  where  the  colours  are 
fus£d-on  to  the  metal  but  produce  an  effect  simiiadp_that  of  a 
painting  executed  wiUiJhe  brush,  the  special  advantage  of  the 
enamel  being  its  lustre;  and  the  encrusted  enamel,  where  the 
effe£t_Ja    mnr.£_J|ike    that    of    mosaic.      Vasari    would    have 


ENAMELS  313 

thoroughly  appreciated  the  painted  enamels,  known  generally 
as  enamels  of  Limogfs.  which  are  complete  pictures,  but, 
though  Cellini  mentions  them,  they  originated  north  of  the  Alps 
and  only  came  into  general  vogue  after  Vasari's  time.  The 
incrusted  pnamel';  arp  parlipr^  and  of  these  he  only  describes  one 
particular  kind  that  had  its  home  gpprially  In  Italy 

The  earliest  known  enamels,  whether  Western  or  Byzantine 
or  Oriental  in  origin,  have  the  different  colours  separated^  in 
compartments  HivirlpH  frnm  each  nfher  hy  riHgpg  r»f  rp^tal  whiqh 

give  the  lines  of  the  design.  These  so-called  '  champlev6  '  and 
'  qloisonnd  '  enamels  there  is  no  need  to  discuss,  but  it  may  be 
noted  that  the  pastes  used  in  them,  though  highly  lustrous, 
arejipaque^  and  cover  completely  the  metal  over  which  they  are 
laid.  The  enamel  described  by  Vasari  dififers  from  these  earlier 
enamels  in  compartments  in  that  the  pastes  are  transparent, 
so  that  the  ground  shows  through.  The  divisions  between  the 
colours  also  are  not  so  marked.  In  this  kind  of  work  trans- 
-  parent  vitrpniKi  paiitpi  are  fused  over  a  metal  ground  that  has 
been  chased  in  low  relief,  so  that  the  light  and  shade  of  the 
relief  shows  through  the  transparent  coloured  film.  The  work 
is  very  delicate  and  on  a  small  scale,  and  thg  ground  is  nearly 
always  g"lf1  Or  ^ilvpr  A  slight  sinking  is  made  in  a  plate  of 
one  of  these  metals  where  the  enamel  is  to  come,  and  at  the 
bottom  of  this  sinking  the  subject  is  carved  or  chased  in  very 
low  relief,  so  low  indeed  that  Cellini  compares  the  height  of  it 
to  the  thickness  of  two  sheets  of  paper  (DeW  Oreficeria,  c.  iii). 
The  transparent  enamels  are  then  fused  over  the  different  parts 
of  the  design,  the  contours  of  the  figures  or  objects  being  just 
allowed  to  show  as  fine  lines  of  metal  between  the  different 
colours. 

Examples  of  this  work  are  rare,  but  the  Victoria  and  Albert 
Museum  and  the  British  Museum  have  some  good  specimens. 
Transparent  enamels  are  used  also  in  other  ways,  and  are  some- 
times arranged  in  apertures  (see  above)  so  as  to  show  by 
transmitted  light.  Labarte's  Histoire  des  Arts  Industriels  is 
still  indispensable  as  an  authority  on  various  kinds  of  enamel 
work,  though  there  is  a  whole  literature  on  the  theme. 


INDEX 


for  buildings  and  permanent  monuments  at  Florence,  Rome,  etc.,  see  under  the 
names  of  the  respective  cities. 

The  references  are  to  pages.  The  upright  numerals  refer  to  the  text,  the  sloping 
ones  to  the  commentary. 


Aachen,  minster  at,  crown  light  in, 

^75- 
Abbozza,  1',  ^j/. 
'  Abundance,'       see       '  Donatello, 

Dovizia.' 
'Adoration  of  the  Lamb,'  by  van 

Eyck,  2g6. 
'  Agias,'  the,  by  Lysippus,  146. 
'  Alberese,'  57. 
Alberti,  Leon  Battista  :  i,  7,  8,  10, 

II,  12,  ij,  25,  30, 66 :  his  writings ; 

De  Re  Aedificatoria,  6, 13, 26, 34, 

6j,  2J2 ;  Delia  Pittura,  6,  11,  12, 

13;  Delia  Scultura,  6,  ig2;  Tract 

on  the  Orders,  66. 
Alcamenes,   his    competition   with 

Pheidias,  iSi,  186. 
Aldovrandi,  104. 
Alexander  VI,  260. 
Alexandria,  102, 300. 
Alfonso  of  Naples,  226. 
Amalgam,  for  niello  work,  274. 
Amiens,  portals  at,  igg. 
Ammanati,  46, 123,  i3g. 
Anastatius  IV,  2^. 
Ancona,  arch  at,  79. 
Andrea  dal  Castagno,  229. 
Anio,  the,  31. 

Antiques,  collections  of,  102 1. 
Antonello  da  Messina,  229,  2gy. 
'Apollo';  'Belvedere,'  116;  'Chois- 

seul  Gouffier,'  146;  at  Naples,  42, 

104. 
'  Applied  ornament,'  22. 
Arabesques,  303. 
Arch  of  Discharge,  70. 


Arches  :  ancient ;  at  Ancona,  79  ; 
at  Pola,  79  ;  at  Rome,  76,  82, 132, 
184,  igy :  temporary,  240. 

Architectural  forms,  significance  of, 
68. 

Architectural  practice,  mediaeval 
and  modern,  207. 

Architecture;  Gothic,  83, 132, 133  {. ; 
ideal,  18,  96,  138 ;  mediaeval, 
Vasarion,83,7'jjf.;  Renaissance, 
^SS,  U^U  books  on,  /2,  74; 
Roman,  see  '  Rome,'  and  passim. 

'  Architettura  Tedesca,'  134. 

Archivio  delta  R.  Societa  Romana 
di  Sloria  Patria,  103. 

Armatures  ;  in  models  of  clay  or 
wax,  149,  150,  igs ;  in  moulds 
for  bronze  casting,  160  f ,  201 ;  in 
modelled  plaster  work,  171. 

Aretine  vases,  136. 

Arezzo ;  267,  3og  ;  Cathedral,  267  ; 
Museum,  137 ;  S.  Francesco, 
267  ;  Vasari's  house,  2gi. 

Armenini,  7. 

Armour,  arms,  inlaid,  279  f. 

'  Ascension '  by  Melozzo  da  Forli, 
217. 

Ashlar  work,  50,  63. 

Assisi ;  S.  Francesco,  134;  Roman 
Temple,  75. 

Athens  ;  Acropolis,  300  ;  Museums, 
23g\  Olympeion,  132 ;  Pentelicus 
quarries,  44,  ig4. 

Bacchus,  Temple  of,  at  Rome,  27, 
93- 


3i6 


INDEX 


Bacon,     Francis,     his     Essay    on 

Building,  ijg. 
Baldinucci ;  his  Notizie,  no,  113, 

114  ;  his  Vocabolario,  57,  231. 
Bandinello,  46. 

Bardiglio,  grey  marble,  4S1  49i  ^^5- 
Basalt,  104,  J17. 
Bassae,  sculpture  from,  184. 
Bathroom  pictures,  227. 
Beccafumi,  Domenico,  258. 
Bekleidungstheorie,  Samper's,  joy. 
Bell  earths,  230. 
Bellini ;  Gentile,  2j6;  Giovanni,  597; 

Jacopo,  Vasari's  Life  of,  2jy. 
Bells,  casting  of,  164,  igg. 
Belvedere,  Cortile  di,  see  '  Rome, 

Vatican.' 
Bdrard,  Dictionnaire  des  Artistes 

Franqais,  130. 
'  Bernward '  pillar,  the,  164. 
Bertolotti,     Artisti     Francesi     in 

Roma,  etc.,  130. 
Biacca(whitelead),.s^7,230,236,^(S'(?. 
'  Bianco  Sangiovanni,'  221,  288. 
Birmingham,  its  School  of  Art,  22. 
Boccaccio,    his     Commentary    on 

Dante,  J5. 
Bocchi,Francesco,onDonatello,/pj. 
Boetheus,  de  Ariihmetica,  236. 
Bollettino  d'   Arte   del  Minister o 

delta  Pubblica  Istruzione,  quoted, 

233- 
Bole  Armeniac,  Bolus,  248. 
Bologna ;  John  of,  38;  S.  Domenico, 

306. 
Bonanni,  Numismata,  etc.,  116. 
Borghini,  7. 
Botticelli,  as  tempera  painter,  2g2, 

2g4. 
Box  wood;   for  carving,   174;   for 

wood-cuts,  281. 
Braccio,  as  measure  of  length,  viii. 
Bramante,  116, 133,  266. 
Breccia,  37, 38,  45,  49,  57,  123,  261. 
Brenner,  the,  134. 
Brick;   pounded,  232,  234;   varie- 
gated, for  pavements,  260. 
British  Museum,  313. 
Bronze  ;  casting  in,  see  '  Sculpture, 

in  Bronze';  composition  of,  163  f; 

incised  designs  in,  273. 
Brunelleschi,  23,  46,  58,  ig6,  igy, 

262, 303. 


Brussels,  Town  Hall  at,  236. 

Buddhist  stucco  work,  301. 

'  Building,'  relief  on  Giotto's  Cam- 
panile, .307. 

Bulletin  Monumental,  136. 

Bulls'  eyes,  265. 

Buonarroti,  the  Casa,  46,  igj. 

Buonarroti,  Michelangelo,  personal 
references  to,  3,  13,  25,  33,  io8. 

Buonarroti,  his  work  ;  at  Florence, 
46, 80,  no;  at  the  marble quarriei: 
120  f.;  at  Rome,  14,  36,  53,  81 
J 16, 153  ;  as  architect,  53  f ,  80  f 
as  decorative  designer,  33,  81 
116;  as  draughtsman,  216;  as 
restorer  of  antiques,  32, 116  ;  as 
sculptor,  go,  153,  ig2,  ig4,  igs, 
igg ;  as  writer,  lyg,  180,  ig?. 

Buontalenti,  go. 

Burgkmair,  282. 

'Burin,'  or  graver,  165,  273. 

Burlington  ;  House,  see  '  Exhibi- 
tions ' ;  Magazine,  227. 

Burnishing  of  gold,  249. 

Busts,  Roman,  in  coloured  -wax,  188. 

Byzantine  ;  mosaics,  136  ;  mural 
paintings,  223  ;  temperas,  223  ; 
misuse  of  the  word,  302. 

'  Calcagnuolo '  (toothed  chisel),  48, 
152. 

Camaldoli,  monastery  of,  233. 

Cameos,  157,  169. 

'Campanini,'  marbles,  45,  50. 

Campiglia,  50,  J27. 

Cancellieri,  Lettera  .  .  .  intomo  la 
.  .  .   Tazza,  log. 

Cannon,  casting  of,  164,  200. 

Canopy,  in  the  Carmine,  Florence, 
43.  118. 

Cantini,  Legislazione  Toscana,  38. 

Canvas  ;  as  painting  ground,  236  f.; 
mural  painting  on,  234 ;  as  used 
in  Egypt,  236  ;  at  Rome,  236  ;  at 
Venice,  236  f.  ;  by  Mantegna, 
236 ;  by  Netherland  painters, 
236. 

Carborundum,  2g. 

Careggi,  33. 

Carfagnana,  or  Garfagnana,  a 
district  of  Italy,  43. 

Carpi,  Ugo  da,  281. 

Carrara,  42,  iigi.,  259. 


INDEX 


317 


Carteggio,  the,  of  Gaye,  16, 32, 266, 

308  i. 
Cartoons ;  how  made,  2 1 3 ;  how  used, 

215  f.,  259,  28g  ;  for  glass,  268. 
Castagno,  Andrea  dal,  229. 
Casting-pit,  the,  163. 
Cellini,  Benvenuto  ;  7,  43, 116,  160, 

164,  igg  f. ;  his  Autobiography, 

116, 302  ;  his   Trattati,  7,  18,  41, 

57,  III,  113,  168,  igi,  275,  276, 

277,  278;  on  the  use  of  full-sized 

models,    ig4 ;    his    process    of 

bronze-casting,  201. 
Cennini,  Cennino,  g,  10, 11,  88 ;  his 

Trattato,  6,  8, 11, 136  I.,  173, 224, 

237,  2go,  2g2,  2gj. 
Cesare  Cesariano,  134  f. 
Chalk  ;  black,  213 ;  red, 212 ;. tailors' 

white,  231  ;  as  '  whitening,'  242. 
Chambers,  Sir  William,  68. 
Charcoal ;  for  darkening  mixtures, 

240;  for  drawing,  213,  231  ;  for 

transferring,  215. 
Charles  V,  108. 
Chartres,  sculpture  at,  183. 
Chasing ;  200,  273  ;  tools  for,  165. 
Chavenier     (Chiavier),     Jean,     of 

Rouen,  130, 175. 
Chemical  analysis  of  paintingmedia, 

223. 
Chiaroscuri  ;  decorative  paintings, 

240  f,  2g8\  wood  engravings,  20, 

281  f. 
Choir-stalls,  303. 
Christ ;  by  Donatello  at  Padua,  188; 

'  At  the  pillar'  by  del  Piombo,5j^ ; 

Head  of,  by  Tadda,  33, 113, 113. 
Christa,  Christus  (the  painter),  see 

'  Crista.' 
'  Chunam,'  301. 
'  Church  Triumphant,'  the,  at  Reims, 

184. 
Cicero,  de  Divinatione,  180. 
Cimabue,  223,  232. 
'  CipoUaccio,'  36. 
CipoUino,  36,  45,  49. 
'  Cire  Perdue,'  202. 
Cista,  Ficeronian,  the,  273. 
Cividale,  S.  Maria  in  Valle,  301. 
Claude  (worker  in  glass),  266. 
Clement;  VII,  36,  46,  58,  89,  log, 

110,116,  311  ;  XI,  108;  XII,  28; 

XIV,  108. 


'  Cleopatra,'  the,  116. 

Coats  of  Arms,  see  'Stemmi.' 

Coins,  technique  of,  157,  168. 

'  Colantonio  del  Fiore '  (apocryphal 
artist),  227. 

Colonna;  Ascanio,32,zoi?;  Vittoria, 
108. 

Colouring ;  218  f. ;  Florentine, North 
Italian,  208 ;  in  three  shades,  209 ; 
printing  in,  281 ;  of  woods  for 
tarsia,  262  ;  of  wax,  148, 188  {. 

Columns :  see  'Orders  of  Archi- 
tecture ' :  ^t  Constantinople,  102  : 
at  Florence  ;  Baptistry,  34 ;  Mer- 
cato  Vecchio,  59  ;  S.  Trinitk,  41, 
66,  no  :  at  Pisa,  Baptistry,^/  :  at 
Rome  ;  Aurelian,  183  f. ;  Basilica 
of  Constantine,  7g ;  Pantheon,  41 ; 
St.  Peter's,  39  ;  Trajanic,  183  f  : 
rustication  of,  63. 

'  Commesso,  lavoro  di,'  262. 

Composition,  in  a  picture,  its  mean- 
ing, 209. 

Conche  (antique  bathing  urns 
used  for  sepulchral  purposes  or 
fountains),  27, 38, 3g,  108  i. 

Conglomerate,  see  '  Breccia.' 

Coningsburgh  Castle,  72. 

Constantine,  27, 102. 

Constantinople  ;  porphyry  at,  JOi ; 
S.  Sophia,  102,  234. 

Correggio,  208,  217. 

Corsi,  delte  Pietre  antiche,  ^7,  41, 

49- 

Cortona,  136,  267. 

Corundum  (emery),  2g. 

Cosimo,  see  '  Medici,  dei.' 

Cosmati  work,  304. 

Cranach,  282. 

Crista,  Pietro,  228. 

Crowe  and  Cavalcaselle ;  Early 
Flemish  Painters,  227 ;  History 
of  Painting  in  North  Italy,  226. 

Dalman,  Dalmau,  Ludovicus,  228. 
Damascening,  279. 
Damiano,Fra,  of  Bergamo,  263,  jo(5. 
Dante ;  307 ;  quoted,  238i. :  referred 

to,i5. 
Danti,  Vincenzio,  123. 
Daremberg  et  Saglio,  Dictionnaire 

des  Antiquites,  273. 
Davanzati,  on  Donatello,  181. 


3i8 


INDEX 


'  David,'  the,  by  Michelangelo,  44, 

45, 194- 

De  I'Orrae,  i^g. 

De  Mayerne  MS.,  sgy. 

Design  ;  how  it  should  be  studied, 
210  ;  as  basis  of  the  decorative 
arts,  284. 

Dienecker,  282. 

Dierich,  Dirick ;  Bouts,  228 ;  of 
Haarlem,  228. 

'  Di  segno,'  Vasari's  use  of  the  term, 
20J. 

Dissection,  value  of,  210. 

Djebel  Duchan,  porphyry  quarries, 
102. 

Dome  of  St.  Peter's,  81. 

Donatello  :  personal  references,  12, 
igy,  igg  :  his  treatment  of  relief, 
18,  145,  156:  his  treatment  of 
the  proportions  of  the  figure, 
181  i.  :  his  works  ;  'Abraham  and 
Isaac,'  1S2,  '  Beheading  of  John 
Baptist,'  ig6,  '  Cantoria,'  182, 
'  Christ '  of  S.  Antonio,  Padua, 
188,  '  David,'  t88,  '  Dovizia,'  J7, 
59,  '  St.  George,'  4s,  ^95, '  Niccolo 
da  Uzzano,'  188,  '  Pietk,'  zjd, 
'  Zuccone,'  182. 

'  Doryphorus,'  the,  at  Naples,  146. 

'  Dovizia,'  by  Donatello,  J7,  59. 

Drapery,  its  treatment  in  sculpture, 
144,  150,775. 

Drawing  ;  its  use  in  the  various  arts, 
206  f.  ;  materials  of,  212. 

Drawings,  Florentine  and  Venetian, 

212. 

Drills,  49. 

Duccio  of  Siena,  258. 

Diirer,   Albrecht ;   / ;    as   tempera 

painter,  2g2. 
Dussieux,     Artistes     Franqais     a 

PEtranger,  ijo. 

Egg,  as  a  tempera,  222,  22J,  224, 

234,  249,  293. 
Egg-shell  mosaic,  93,  ij6  f. 
Egypt,   as    source    of   supply    for 

stones,  26,  36,  38,  39,  40,  41,  42, 

lOI,  II J. 

Egyptians ;  their  bronze-casting, 
163  ;  their  painting  methods,  224; 
their  silver  work,  273  ;  their  use 
of  wooden  stamps  for  bricks,  ^75. 


Elba,  granite  from,  40,  lii. 
'Electron'  metal,  164. 
Elsa,  river  of  Tuscany,  88. 
Emery;  27  f.;  point  for  cutting  glass, 

269  ;  veins  (smerigli),  47. 
Enamels  ;  different  kinds  of,  3l2i.; 

vitreous  pastes  for,  311 ;  effect  of 

tin  in,  277, 311;  Cellini  on,  2y6i.\ 

Labarte  on,  313  ;  Theophilus  on, 

276, 312  ;  over  reliefs,  276  f. ;  over 

different  metals,  277;  firing  of,  278; 

fluxes  for,  277;  polishing  of,  278  ; 

ruby  colourin,^77 ;  Venetian,  278. 
Encaustic  painting,  igo,  292. 
EncyclopMie,  the  French,  18,  '1^2, 

15S,  igi. 
Engraving,   on    metal,    273  f ;    on 

wood,  281  f. 
Etruscan  ;    incised    designs,   273  : 

reliefs,  197 ;    see    also    '  Orders 

of    Architecture,    Tuscan '    and 

'Tuscan  style.' 
Eugenius  IV,  28. 
Eustatius,  181. 

Evonimus  Europaeus,  see  '  Silio.' 
Exhibitions  ;  at  Burlington  House, 

227.,  293 ;    at    the    Salon,  293 ; 

International,   of    1851,    21 ;    of 

1862,  41,  S5i  60,  119;   'Toison 

d'Or,'  at  Bruges,  227. 
Eyck,  van  ;  10,  ig,  2g4  f.  ;  Hubert, 

226  ;  Jan,  226  f.,  230,  bath  room 

pictures  by,  227. 
Ezechiel,  his  visionary  temple,  I3g. 

Facio,   De    Viris  Jllustribus,  227, 

2g6. 
Falda,  G.  F.,  Vedute  delle  Fabbriche, 

28. 
Farnese  Collection  of  Antiques,  28, 

104. 
Federico  of  Urbino,  227. 
Ferrara  ;  as  an  artistic  centre,  227; 

Palazzo  dei  Diamanti,  132. 
Fichard,   Frankfurtisches   Archiv, 

106. 
Ficorini,  Francesco  dei,  Le  Vestigia, 

etc.,  108. 
Fiesole  ;  37,  58,  60,  132 ;  S.  Giro- 

lamo,  tomb  in,  iii. 
Fig  tree,  milk  of,  as  a  tempera,  224. 
Filarete,   Trattato,  13^,  i3g  {.,  146, 

296. 


INDEX 


319 


'Filiera'  (wire-drawing  plate),  280. 
Fineschi,  on  S.  Maria  Novella,  jo. 
Finiguerra,  Maso,  274,  275. 
Fireplaces,  mediaeval,  75. 
Firing ;  of  enamels,  278 ;  of  glass, 
271  ;  ai cire perdue vaov!A%,  \(i2i. 
'  Flashing,'  in  glass  staining,  2yo. 
Flemings,  as   glass  workers,   267, 

309- 
Flemish;  correspondents  of  Vasari, 

I ;  painting,  226  f.,  236. 
Florence.:  Baptistry;  34,25^,274; 
gatesof^?^,i55,7.?j,/p(5:  Bargello, 
see  '  Museum,  National'  :  Boboli 
Gardens,  ^p,  38, 3g,  41,  go,  107  : 
Borgo  degli  Albizzi,  2p8:  Cam- 
panile ;  materials  of,  118,  128 ; 
relief  on,  207  ;  statues  on,  182, 
iSf :  '  Centro,'  the,  60  : 

Churches ;  Annunziata,  18, 
i75j  253;  Carmine,  42,  118; 
Cathedral,  see'Duomo';  Duomo, 
43,  61,7/5, 118, 128, 233,306,308; 
S.  Giovanni,  see  '  Baptistry ' ; 
S.  Lorenzo,  58,  112,  122,  156, 
(CappelladeiPrincipi,59,  Fagade, 
46,  124,  Library,  58,  80,  81,  261, 
310,  Sacristy,  58,  80,  no,  194, 
303) ;  S.  Maria  del  Fiore,  see 
' Duomo';  S.  Maria  Novella,  30 ; 
S.  Maria  Nuova,  228,  229  ;  Or 
"  San  Michele,  60,  61  ;  S.  Miniato 
a  Monte,  28,  43, 118 ;  S.  Spirito, 
58: 

Citadel,  fortress,  see  'Fortezza' : 
Fortezza ;  Belvedere,  66 ;  da 
Basso,  61,  66,  133:  Fountains, 
32,  38,  46,  88,  go,  113  :  Loggia 
dei  Lanzi,  61  :  Manufactory  of 
Mosaics,  log,  118 :  Mercato ; 
Nuovo,59;  Vecchio,59:  Museum; 
of  S.  Marco,  60 ;  National,  113, 
136,  2^4 1  Opera  del  Duomo, 
136, 182, 307 : 

Palazzo ;  Alessandri,  132 ; 
Medici,  68,  133 ;  Montalvo, 
2g8;  Pitti,  42,  60,  61,  66,  68, 
log,  1/4,  133;  Riccardi,  133; 
Strozzi,  61,  68 ;  Vecchio  (dei 
Signori,  Ducal,  Duke  Cosimo's, 
etc.),  i,  15,  ig,  33^  45.  61,  113, 
■y^.  233, 306, 307  : 

Piazza ;    S.    Trinitk,   66,   no ; 


Vittorio  Emanuele,  sg :  Ponte 
S.  Trinitk,  46,  i3g  :  Strada  dei 
Magistrati,  see  '  Uffizi ' :  UfKzi, 
S,  sg,  70  f.,  106,  112,  113,  136 : 
Via  dei  Magistrati,  see  '  Uffizi.' 

Flour  ;  baked,  mixed  with  clay  to 
keep  it  moist,  150;  in  paste  for 
priming  canvas,  236  ;  for  muci- 
lage, 213. 

Fluxes,  for  enamels,  277. 

Foggini,  Giov.  Batt.,  60. 

Fontainebleau,  stucco  work  at,  171, 
1S3, 302. 

Foreshortening  ;  in  painting,  iiisi.; 
in  sculpture,  145. 

Fornarina,  Raphael's,  her  reputed 
house,  103. 

Fountains,  32,  36,  38,  40,  46,  87  f., 
no,  113, 116. 

Frangois  I  of  France,  130, 171. 

'  Frassinella '  (sharpening  stone), 
278. 

Frederick  II,  Emperor,  1/2. 

French  School  at  Rome,  33. 

French,  the,  as  glass  workers,  267. 

Fresco  painting,  see  '  Painting, 
fresco.' 

Gaddi ;    Agnolo,  10,  137  ;   Gaddo, 

136  ;  Taddeo,  10. 
Galluzzi,    History    of   the    Grand 

Dukes,  13,  112. 
'  Ganymede,'  the  Florentine,  106. 
Garfagnana  or  Carfagnaha  ;  a  dis- 
trict of  Italy,  43. 
Gamier,  M.,  on  Michelangelo,  81. 
Gaye,  Carteggio,  16, 32,  266, 308  f. 
Gazette  des  Beaux  Arts,  referred  to, 

81. 
Genoa  ;     Doria   Palace,  247  ;     its 

flagstones  or  slates,  55,  238. 
German  carving  in  hard  materials, 

174. 
'  German  work,'  63,  83, 133  f. 
Germans,  the,  in  connection  with 

engraving,  273,  282. 
Gesso  ;  as  painting  ground,  223  {., 

230,  236, 24g,  2g3  ;  reliefs  in,  224. 
Ghiberti,  18, 183,  igg. 
Gian,  Maestro,  52,  I28i.,  173. 
Giornale  d'  Italia,  130. 
Giotto,  10,  225,  2go,  304. 
Giovanni,  Fra,  of  Verona,  262, 303. 


320 


INDEX 


Girardon,  his  statue  of  Louis  XIV, 

/<?,  IS8. 
Giulio,  a  silver  coin,  276. 
Giusto,  S.,  near  Florence,  37. 
Glass ;  '  crown,'  26^ ;  stained,  265  f., 

308  f. ;  Venetian,  268  ;  see  also 

'  Mosaic' 
Glue  ;    from    cheese,    173 ;     from 

parchment  shreds,  173  ;  see  also 

'  Size.' 
Gori,  Thesaurus  Vet.  Diptychorum, 

Z36. 
Gossets,  the,  workers  in  wax,  i8g. 
Gothic  Art,  7(5,  //,  60,  83,  133  {., 

184. 
Goths,  the,  60,  63,  83, 134. 
Gotti,  Aurelio  ;    on  the  length   of 

the  'braccio,'  viii  ;    Le   Gallerie 

.  .  .  di  Firenze,  113. 
Gozbert  of  Tegernsee,  310. 
'Gradina'  (toothed  chisel),  48,  152. 
Granite,  39  f 
Granito  ;    del  foro,  41 ;    di  Prato, 

118 
Greece,   as    source    of  supply  for 

stones,  35,  36,  38,  42,  43. 
Greek  ;   bronzes,  164 ;   incised  de- 
signs, 2^3  ;  reliefs,  lyg,  ig6  i. ; 

statues,  146 ;  technique  of  marble 

sculpture,     ig2 ;     technique    of 

bronze    casting,    202 ;    tempera 

paintings,  see  '  Byzantine ' ;  w^ood 

inlays,  304. 
Gregorovius,  Geschichte  der  Stadt 

Rom.,  102,  {. 
Gregory  XII,  22^. 
'  Grisatoio '  (a  tool),  269. 
Grotesques  ;  244  f ,  2gg  i. ;  meaning 

of  term,  302. 
Grottoes,  87, 302. 
'  Grozing-iron '  (a  tool),  269. 
Guasti,  edition   of    Michelangelo's 

poems,  180. 
Guglielmo   da   Marcilla,  266,  268, 

311- 
Guicciardini,     on     early    Flemish 

painters,  226. 
Gum,  as  a  tempera,  222,  223,  itfi, 

267,  283. 

Haematite,  269. 

Hair,  the,  its  treatment  in  sculp- 
ture, 144. 


Hampton  Court,  236. 

Hare,  Days  near  Rome,  88. 

'  Heads,'  as  measures  of  columns, 
65. 

Heemskerck,  drawing  of  Michel- 
angelo's fountain,  iz6. 

Helena,  mother  of  Constantine,  2y. 

Hermeneia  (Mount  Athos  Hand- 
book), 2gs. 

'  Hermes,'  the,  of  Praxiteles,  44. 

Herrmann,  Steinbruchindusirie,  4g. 

Hildesheim  ;  bronze  doors  at,  164 ; 
St.  Michael's,  jo^. 

'  Historic  Ornament,'  22. 

Honey,  as  a  tempera,  223,  250. 

Hugo  of  Antwerp  (van  der  Goes), 
229. 

Humanism,  7/,  2^,  138  i. 

Ideal  Architecture,  18,  96, 138. 

Ilg,  Dr.  Albert,  6,  g2. 

Impruneta,  Hill  of  the,  37,  i2y. 

Industrial  Arts,  the ;  ^7 ;  in  Britain, 
22  \  in  France,  21 ;  in  Italy, 
passim. 

Inlays  :  breccia,  38  :  marble,  92  f , 
258  f. :  metal ;  damascening, 
279  f  ;  niello,  273  f  :  rustic,  for 
fountains  and  grottoes,  87  i. :  of 
coloured  stones  for  pavements, 
etc.,  57,  91  :  wood,  262f.,  jqjf 

Intaglios,  technique  of,  168  i. 

Intarsia,  2yg  ;  see  also  'Tarsia.' 

Iron  ;  armatures,  ties,  etc.,  25,  74, 
161  f ,  271 ;  see  also  'Armatures'; 
damascening  in,  279  f. ;  scale  or 
scum  of,  234,  269. 

Istrian  Stone,  56. 

Jahrbuch  d.  k.  deutschen  Archeo- 
logischen  Iristituts,  104,  loj,  107, 

IIS- 
Janni,  Maestro,  128,  174. 
Jervis,   /   Tesori  Sotterranei  deW 

Italia,  41,  iig  f. 
Joggled  lintels,  'j2. 
John  of  Bruges,  see  'Eyck,  van,  Jan.' 
'  Jonah,'  by  Michelangelo,  216. 
Julius  ;    II,  108,  260,  266,  267,  276, 

308;    III,  32,70.?. 

'Justice,'  statue  by  Francesco  del 

Tadda,  770. 
Justus  of  Ghent,  229. 


INDEX 


321 


Labarte,  Histbire  des  Arts  Indus- 

triels,  2j8,  2'/6,  jij. 
'  Lacedaemonium  viride,'  jj. 
'  Laocoon,'  the,  116. 
'  Last  Supper ' ;    Leonardo's,  ^yj  ; 

in  Flemish  glass,  jii. 
Lavagna,  slates  of,  55. 
Laws,    against    use    of   particular 

materials,  etc.,  58. 
Leads,  for  glass  windows,  271. 
Leo  ;  III,  310  ;  X,  75,  44,  46,  106, 

122,  260. 
Leonardo  da  Vinci,  I2, 14,  ij,  ijg, 

230,  ^33- 
Leopardi,  Alessandro,  /Qg. 
Liber  Pontificalis,  jio. 
Libergier,  Hughes,  of  Reims,  207. 
Light    and    shade,    treatment    of, 

220. 
Lime  ;  from  marble  chips,  86  ;  from 

travertine,  86,  221;  its  behaviour 

in  connection  with  fresco,  288. 
Lime-white,  see    '  Bianco   Sangio- 

vanni.' 
Lime  wood,  for  carving,  173. 
Linen  cloth,  over  panels,  224. 
Linlithgow  Palace,  '72. 
Lippmann,     The    Art    of    Wood 

Engraving,  281. 
Lomazzo,  231. 

Lorenzetto,  the  sculptor,  loy. 
Lotto,  208. 
Louis  :  XIV,  age  of,  21  ;  statue  of, 

iS8:  XV,  style  of,  8g. 
Louvre,  the,  44,  loy,  116,  ig4,  201. 
'  Luano,  Ludovico  da '  (apocryphal 

painter),  228. 
Liibeck,  ^08. 
Luini,  2go. 
Luni,  iig. 
Lysistratus,  188. 

Maccari,  Graffiti  e  Chiaroscuri,  2g8. 

'  Macigno,'  57. 

Majano  ;  Benedetto  da,  262,  jo6  ; 

Giuliano  da,  jo6. 
Manganese,  its  use  in  fluxes,  277. 
'  Manner,'  its  meaning  in  sculpture, 

144. 
Mantegna,      2j6 ;      as      tempera 

painter,  2g3. 
Manufactory  of  Mosaics,  Tuscan, 

log,  118. 


Manufacture    des    Meubles    de   la 

Couronne,  21. 
Marangoni,  Delle  Cose  Gentilesche, 

38 

Marble  ;  coloured,  /jj ;  Italian,  ch. 
I  passim,  117 1.,  152,  259;  for 
mosaic,  91  f.,  258  ;  Parian,  Pen- 
telic,  44  ;  polish  of,  49,  152,  zjj  ; 
transparent,  43,  265. 

Marcilla,  Guglielmo  da,  266,  267, 
268,  jii. 

Marenima,  the  Tuscan,  its  quarries, 
128. 

Mariotti,  Legislazione  delle  Belle 
Arti,  jg,  61. 

Marqueterie,  264. 

Martin,  painters  named,  22g. 

'  Mary  of  the  Visitation,'  keims,  184. 

Massa,  its  quarries,  126. 

Massi,  Museo  Pio-Clewientino,  27, 
108. 

Medals,  technique  of,  167  f. 

Mediaeval ;  sculpture,  144  ;  decora- 
tive art,  284  ;    see  also  '  Gothic' 

Medici ;  arms  of  the,  61,  67  ;  por- 
phyry portraits  of  the,  33,  113  f. ; 
tombs  of  the,  ig4. 

Medici,  dei  :  Alessandro,  66  : 
Cosimo  {Pater  Patriae),  33, 
113  f. : 

Cosimo  I,  Duke ;  personal 
references,  14,  ij,  32,  33,  47,  70, 
no,  112,  228  ;  portrait  in  por- 
phyry, 33,  113  ;  connection  with 
the  marble  quarries,  120,  124, 
261  ;  his  interest  in  Pisa,  50, 
126  \  works  connected  with  his 
name  at  Florence,  (Palazzo 
Vecchio),  32,  33,  37  ;  (Pitti),  38, 
41  ;  (Ufifizi),  59,  70 ;  (elsewhere), 
59,  88  : 

Ferdinando,  los :  Francesco, 
jj,  123:  Giovanni,  77^ :  Giuliano, 
7j:  Giulio  (Clement  VII),  75: 
Ippolito,  103  :  Leonora,  Duchess, 
33  :  Lorenzo  ;  the  Magnificent, 
227  ;  Duca  d'  Urbino,  75 :  Piero, 

112. 

Mdlanges  Nicole,  ig4. 
Melozzo  da  Forli,  217. 
Memling,  Hans,  227. 
'  Meridiana,'  in  the  Pitti,  77^. 
Merrifield,  Mrs,  3,  6. 


322 


INDEX 


Michelagnolo,    Michelangelo,    see 

'  Buonarroti.' 
Michelozzo,  igg. 
Milan;  S.  Ambrogio,  j05;  Cathedral, 

135- 

Millar,  Plastering,  150. 

Mischiato,  Mischio,  see  '  Breccia.' 

Mitteilungen  d.  k.  deutschen  Archeo- 
logischen  Insiituts,  yS. 

Modelling  in  clay,  149  f.,  ig8. 

Models  :  for  sculpture  ;  full- sized, 
150 f.,  158,  igo,  igsi.,  ig4,  202; 
small,  148,  ig4  :  for  wood  carving, 
173  :  of  wood  for  architecture, 
207:  for  studying  shadows,  214, 
216. 

Monochromes,  see  '  Chiaroscuri.' 

Monsummano,  quarries  of,  128. 

Monte,  monti  ;  Albano,  128 ;  Altis- 
simo,  z.s'of  ;  Ceceri,j7;  Ferrato, 
I2y  ;  S.  Giuliano,  50,  126  \ 
Martiri,  J7  ;  Morello,  88  ;  Pisani, 
50,  126 ;  Rantoli,  37  ;  Ripaldi, 
60  ;  Sagro,  120  ;  Spertoli,  242. 

Monumenti  del  Istituto,  76. 

Morris,  William,  j,  22. 

Morto  da  Feltro,  J02. 

Mosaic  ;  antique,  91  f.,  gj,  2'57,  263 ; 
derivation  of  word,  gi  ;  Early 
Christian,  27,  2J2  f. ;  egg  shell, 
93,  ij6  ;  Tuscan  manufactory  of, 
iog,ii8\  glass,  93,  251  ;  marble, 
37,92  f.,  258  f. ;  pictorial,  for  walls, 
93,  25 1  f  ;  rustic,  for  fountains 
and  grottoes,  89,  90 ;  technique 
of,  253  i.  ;  for  variegated  pave- 
ments (Cosmati  work),  91,  304  ; 
vitreous  pastes  for,  _j//  f. ;  of 
window  glass,  266,  ^og ;  wood, 
262  f.,  303  f. 

Mosque  ;  lamps  from,  268;  windows 
in,  3og. 

Mother  of  Pearl,  pj. 

Mothes,  Baukunst  .  .  .  in  Italien, 

135- 
Moulds,    plaster,    from    the    life, 

188. 
Mucilage,  see  '  Glue.' 
'  Muffle'  furnace,  271,  277. 
Miintz,  Eugene  ;  Les  Artsd.  la  Cour 

des  Popes,  J30 ;     on   Byzantine 

mosaics,  136. 
Mural  decoration  :  decorative  pro- 


cesses, ig,  240  f ,  28J  f  :  fresco, 
10,  213  f,  221  f,  287  {.:  mosaic, 
93,  251  f.  :  oil,  232  f,  236,  237, 
2g4i.  ;  on  stone,  239  :  stucco,  53, 
170  f ,  244  f.,  2gg  i.  :  sgraffito,  243, 
2g8{.  :  tempera,  224,  ^p/f. 

Naples  ;  Museum,  antiques  at,  43, 
104 ;  pictures  at,  22y  :  S.  Barbara, 
226  :  S.  Giacomo,  tomb  in,  47 : 
Vasari's  paintings  at,  233. 

Nature,  study  of,  at  the  Renaissance, 
12, 14. 

Net,  the,  for  enlarging,  214. 

Niello,  273  f. 

Nikd,  from  Samothrace,  loj. 

'  Nile,'  Statue  of  the,  36,  44, 116. 

Nola,  Giovanni  da,  47. 

'  Nonsuch,'  Palace  of,  stuccoes  at, 
302. 

Nose,  the,  in  Greek  and  Florentine 
sculpture,  4^. 

'  Nymph  of  Fontainebleau,' Cellini's, 
201. 

Octavianus,  Cardinal,  227. 

Oil  ;  linseed,  230,  234  ;  walnut, 
230,  236. 

Oil  colour,  for  printing  from  wood 
blocks,  283. 

Oil  painting,  225,  226  f.;  its  first 
discovery,  226 ;  its  artistic  ad- 
vantages, 230  ;  on  stone,  55,  239. 

Olmo,  by  Castello,  88. 

Orders  of  Architecture  ;  63  ;  Com- 
posite, 80  f. ;  Corinthian,  79  f.  ; 
Doric,  68  f.  ;  Ionic,  78  i.  ;  Italic, 
82  ;  Latin,  82  ;  Rustic,  65  i. ; 
Tuscan,  65  f.,  132. 

Oseri,  Osoh,  the  river,  50, 126. 

Pacheco  ;  7  ;  on  tempera,  2g2. 

Painting  :  definition  of,  208  :  com- 
parison of  with  sculpture,  779: 
history  of,  225,  226  f ,  287,  2^0, 
2g2, 2g4  f. :  Florentine  and  Italian 
compared  with  modern,  208 : 
Greek,  23g : 

painting  grounds  ;  canvas,  236 
f.  ;  glass,  267  f.,  308  f. ;  ivory, 
igo ;  panels,  223  f.,  230,  237  ; 
plaster,  221  f ,  223,  287  ff. ; 
stone,    55,   239 :    materials,  225, 


INDEX 


323 


and  '  Introduction  '  to  Painting, 

passim  •  pigments,  22 1,  224,  242  : 
processes  ;  encaustic,  /po,  3p3  ; 

fresco,  4,  10,  ig,  221  f.,  28y  f.  ; 

oil,  70,  ig,  226  ff.,  3g4  f. ;  tempera, 

ig,  223  f,,  240  f.,  2gi  {. 
Palazzo ;  dei  Diamanti,  Ferrara,  ij2 ; 

see  also  '  Florence,'  '  Rome,'  etc. 
Palermo,  Cathedral,  i/i. 
Palissy,  ijg. 
Palladio,  66. 

Palmo,  as  measure  of  length,  viii. 
Palomino,  7. 
Panels  ;  as  painting  grounds,  223  f., 

230,  237;  disadvantages  of,  2j^, 

239  ;  woods  used  for,  3j^. 
Paragon   (touchstone),   42   f.,    104, 

117  {. 
Parione,  see  '  Rome.' 
Paris  ;  as  an  art  centre,  21  ;  Sainte 

Chapelle,  J77. 
Parthenon,  sculpture  of,  iSj,  igg. 
Pasiteles,  ig4. 
Pastes  ;   coloured  for  rustic  work, 

89  ;  for  first  priming  of  canvas, 
236. 

Pastorino  of  Siena,  iSg. 

Patina,  artificial ;  for  bronze,  166  ; 

for  silver,  s^j. 
Paul ;  II,  40;  III,  40,  108,  260  ;  V, 

39- 
Pavements  ;  breccia,  261  ;  mosaic, 

90  f ,  258  ;  tiled,  90,  260. 
Paxes,  274  f. 

Pear-tree  wood,  for  wood-cuts,  281. 
Pedestals,  to  columns  ;  65,  75,  78, 

79,  82  ;  architectural  use  of  them, 

75- 
Pentelicus,  Mount,  quarries  at,  44, 

„  ^94; 

Peperigno,  Peperino,  57,  55,  238. 

'Per  forza  di  levare,'   'per  via  di 

porre '    (methods   of   sculpture), 

irg  f.,  797  f. 
Pergamon,  smaller  frieze  from  altar 

base,  igy. 
Perino  del  Vaga,  14,  jj. 
'  Perseus,'  by  Cellini,  164,  201  f. 
Perspective,  its  study,  12,  264. 
Perspectives,  214,  264,30^. 
Perugino,  Pietro,  230. 
Peruzzi,  y8. 
Petersburg,  St.,  jo^. 


Petrarch,  figure  of  in  tarsia,  jo/. 

Pheidias,  11,  j8t,  186. 

V\h  di  Lupo  (Lugo),  87  f. 

Piece-mould,  158  f ,  202. 

Pier  Maria  da  Pescia,  77^". 

Pietk ;     by     Donatello,    156 ;      by 

Michelangelo,  1^3. 
Pietra  forte,  57,  60  f. 
Pietra  del  fossato  (fossataccio),  58. 
Pietra  morta,  j/. 
Pietra  serena,  57  f. 
Pietrasanta,  46,  50,  120  {.,  261. 
Pigments  ;  221,  224,  230,  242  ;  for 

glass  painting,  269,  jio. 
Pinturicchio,  joj. 
Piombino,  127. 
Piperno,  see  '  Peperigno.' 
Pisa :  Duke  Cosimo's  care  for,  50  f , 

126  :     Baptistry,     4/ :     Campo- 

santo,    50  :     Duomo  ;    50,   252  ; 

'  Cimabue '  at,  2J2. 
Pisan  mountains,  jo,  126. 
Pisano,  Nicola,  797. 
Pistolesi,  //  Vaticano  Descriito,  jj, 

108. 
Pius  ;  IV,  770  ;  VI,  2'/,  108,  log. 
Plaster  work,  see  '  Stucco.' 
Plato,  Sophist,  181. 
Pliny,  Historia  Naturalis,  34,  jj, 

44,  J^.  QJ^,  93,  loi,  ir?-,  s^S-,  236, 

237,  273,  291- 
Podium,  of  Roman  temples,  75,  7c?. 
Pointing  machine,  7p7. 
Pola,  arch  at,  79. 
PoHshing  ;    breccias,   38  ;    bronze, 

165  ;     enamels,     278  ;     marble 

mosaics,  260  ;    marble,  statuary, 

4Sj  47.  49.  152,  153  ■■,  niellos,  274; 

pietra  serena,  58  ;  porphyry,  31, 

34  ;   stucco,    777;   '  touchstones,' 

42  f. 
Pollaiuolo,  A.,  igg,  273. 
Polvaccio  quan-y,  46,  Z20. 
Pompeian  ;  style  in  ornament,  302 ; 

wall  paintings,  22^. 
Pomponius  Gauricus,  igg. 
Popes,   see  the   individual   names, 

'  Clement,'  etc. 
Porphyry  ;  26  ff.,  loi  ff.  ;  green,  at 

S.  Nicola  in  Carcere,  Rome,  28. 
Porta,  Giacomo  della,  ji". 
Portinari,  the,  227  f  ' 

'  Pot-metal,'  270,  jii. 


324 


INDEX 


Potters' ;  clay,  240  ;  '  soap,'  277. 
Pouncing,  as   method   of  transfer, 

28g. 
Pozzuoli,  Pozzuolo,  66,  _joj. 
Prato,  42, 12'/. 
Praxiteles;     180;     his    'Hermes,' 

44- 
Presses,  decorated,  jqj. 
Primaticcio,  lyi,  i8j. 
Priming,  directions  for,  230  ff. 
'  Prisoners,'     porphyry    figures     in 

Boboli  Gardens,  29. 
Probert,  History  of  Miniature  Art, 

jgo. 
Proceedings  of  Huguenot  Society, 

i8g. 
Proportions   of  the  human  figure, 

146, 180  f. 
Pulvinated  frieze,  79. 
Pumice  stone,  for  polishing  ;  bronze, 

165  ;    marble,   49,    152  ;    niellos, 

274. 
'  Puntelli,'   for    measuring    statues, 

194. 

Quellenschriften,  the  Vienna,  2,  6, 
92. 

Rabelais,  his   Abbey  of  Theleme, 

^39- 
Raffaello  da  Urbino,  see  '  Raphael.' 
Ragionamenti,    see    '  Vasari,     his 

writings.' 
Rags  covered  with  clay,  for  drapery, 

150,  208. 
Raimondi,  Marc  Antonio,  2/4,  sys- 
Raphael ;  14,  75, 134, 188,  220,  230, 
260 ;     the     Report    on    Roman 
Monuments,  134. 
Ravello,  iii. 
Ravenna  ;  mosaics,  252  ;   stuccoes 

in  Baptistry,  joz. 
Recipes  :  6,  20: 

black  ;  filling  for  marble  mono- 
chromes, 260  ;  for  niellos,  274  ; 
for  transferring,  215  : 

bronzes  and  metal  alloys,  163  : 
keeping  clay  soft,  1 50  : 
core  for  a  bronze  casting,  1 59  : 
'  egg-shell '  mosaic,  ij'y  : 
enamels,  fluxes  for,  ^77  : 
envelope  for  a  bronze  casting, 
161,  166 : 


gesso,  'grosso'  and  'sottile,' 
249: 

gildmg,  248  f.  : 

glass  ;  gilding,  254  ;  painting 
on  (burnt  in),  269, 310,  (unburnt), 
267  ;  yellow  stain  for,  270,  jii ; 

ink,  drawing,  213  : 

preparing  mosaic  cubes,  2^4 : 

mucilages,  173,  213  : 

oil  paint,  mixing,  230,  ^pjf. : 

patina,  artificial ;  for  bronze, 
166  ;  for  silver,  273  : 

priming,  230  ff.  : 

polishing,  see  '  Polishing ' : 

sgraffito,  243  f. : 

retouching  media  for  fresco, 
222,  289 : 

stone,  painting  on,  238  : 

stucco ;  for  enriched  vaults  and 
'grotesques,'  86,  170;  for  setting 
glass  mosaic,  255  f,  2^6;  for 
setting  mosaic  pavements,  92 ; 
for  preparing  a  wall  for  oil 
painting,  232  f.  ;  retarding  its 
setting,  Jjo : 

temperas,  for  painting,  224, 
2gj  f.  ;  for  decorative  painting, 
etc.,  240  f.  : 

tempering  baths  for  steel,  30, 
32,  112 : 

tiles,  variegated,  260 : 

'  verdaccio,'  242 : 

vitreous  pastes,  coloured,  j/i : 

preparing  walls  for  oil  painting, 
232  f.  : 

wax  ;  for  bronze-casting,  160 ; 
for  coloured  effigies,  iSg ;  for 
modelling,  148  : 

white,  lime,  (bianco  Sangio- 
vanni)  221 : 

colouring     woods    for    tarsia 
work,  262  f. 
Reliefs  ;    origin  of,  1 54  ;    influence 
of  painting  and  perspective  on, 
rgdf.  ;  terminology  of,  iS4 ; 

antique,  1 54,  ig6  ;  flat  (stiac- 
ciati),  i56f.  ;  low  (bassi),  156; 
pictorial  or  perspective,  154  f., 
196  {.  ; 

in  cast  bronze,  /p/f-  ;  in  baked 
clay,  197  f.  ;  in  marble,  J^g/f- ;  in 
metal  repoussd,  198 ; 

Andrea  Pisano's,  799 ;   Dona- 


INDEX 


325 


tello's,  1 56,  ig6  ;  Etruscan,  zp/  ; 
Ghiberti's,  ig6  ;  Greek,  igj  I.  ; 
Hellenistic,  ipy,  jot  ;  mediaeval, 
ig6,  igg  :  Roman,  igj. 

St.  Rdmy,  tomb  of  Julii  at,  ig'/. 

Renaissance  ;  the,  7,  11,  si ;  the 
man  of  the,  138 ;  marbles,  tjj  ; 
the  '  proto-,'  igy. 

Repetti,  Dizioiiario,  118,  iig  f. 

Repousse  process,  lyg,  ig8. 

Restoration  of  antiques,  106,  107, 
116. 

Retouching,  on  frescoes,  222,  28g. 

Ring,  the,  at  Vienna,  j6. 

Robbia,  della ;  the,  114,  260 ; 
Luca,  182. 

Robinson,  G.  T.,  _j,  150. 

Rocaille,  Rococo,  style,  18,  87,  8g. 

Rocco,  S.,  statue  of,  /<?,  1 74. 

Roger,  'of  Bruges,'  'of  Brussels,' 
'  van  der  Weyden,'  227,  236. 

Romans,  the  ;  their  bronzes,  164 ; 
their  reliefs,  igj ;  their  use  of 
rustication,  132 ;  their  wooden 
stamps  for  bricks,  ^75. 

Rome :  Arch ;  of  Septimius  Severus, 
yd  ;  of  Titus,  82, 184,  igy  ;  Arco 
dei  Pantani,  /J2 :  S.  Angelo, 
Castle  of,  260 :  Basilica ;  Aemilia, 
76  ;  of  Constantine,  79  :  Bocca 
della  Veritk,7(5 :  Campo ;  di  Fiore, 
78,  2gg ;  Vaccino,  76  :  Capitol, 
81 :  Career  Mamertinus,  76  : 

Churches  ;  S.  Bernardo,  ijo  ; 
Ss.  Cosma  e  Damiano,  52  ;  S. 
Costanza,  ^7,  2^2  ;  S.  Giovanni 
in  Laterano,  27 ;  S.  Luigi  dei 
Francesi,  41,  52,  j^,  775;  S. 
Marco,  39  ;  S.  Maria,  (in  Araceli) 
76,  (Maggiore)  79,  (del  Popolo) 
267,  (Sopra  Minerva)  44 ;  S. 
Nicola  in  Carcere,  28,  7<?;  S. 
Pietro  in  Montorio,  2J4  ;  S.  Pietro 
in  Vaticano,  (the  Constantinian 
basihca)  39,263,^70,  (the  present 
church)  28,  jg,  54,  81,  86,  217; 
S.  Pietro  in  Vincola,  39,  40 ; 
S.  Salvadore  del  Lauro,  39  ;  S. 
Stefano,  40;  S.  Tommaso  in 
Parione,  loj  : 

Colosseum,  51,  5J,  74,  82  : 
Column  ;  of  Marcus  Aurelius, 
18 J  f. ;  of  Trajan,  i8j  f.  :    Corso 


Vittorio  Emanuele,  loj,  los : 
Forum ;  of  Augustus,  ij2 ; 
Boarium,  76  ;  Olitorium,  yS ; 
Romanum,  4g,  yd  ;  Trajanic,  41, 
i8j  :  Monte  Cavallo,  Colossi  of, 
44  :    Museum,  Terme,  joi : 

Palazzo  ;  dei  Conservatori,  8/  ; 
Farnese,  28,  53,  78,  81,  104,  131 ; 
la  Valle,  28  ;  Madama,  32,  iji ; 
Massimi,.?^!?;  Ricci,^^!?;  Spada, 
2gg  :  Pantheon,  28,  41,  79,  80  : 
Parione,  42,  93, 102  : 

Piazza ;  Carapo  di  Fiore,  78, 
2gg  ;  Farnese,  40 ;  S.  Luigi  dei 
Francesi,  I28i. ;  di  S.  Marco,  ^o  ; 
dei  Massimi,  2g8 ;  Navona,  5.?, 
102  ;  della  Rotonda,  27, 28:  Plan" 
of  Rome,  /qy : 

Ritonda,  Rotonda,  see  '  Pan- 
theon ' :  Temple  ;  of  Bacchus,  27, 
93 ;  of  Peace,  79 :  Templum 
Sacrae  Urbis,  J2 :  Theatre  ;  of 
Marcellus,  76,  79  ;  of  Pompeius, 
102  :  Thermae ;  of  Agrippa,  106  ; 
of  Caracalla,  i/o  ;  of  Constan- 
tine, 44  ;  of  Diocletian,  ijo  ;  of 
Nero,  41,  ijo  ;  of  Titus,  108,  J02 : 
Tombs  on  Via  Latina,507:  Torre 
Pignattara,  27  :  '  Treasury,'  the, 
52  :  Tullianum,  76  : 

Vatican  ;  Appartamento  Bor- 
gia, S3j  ^60,  303 ;  Belvedere, 
Cortile  di,  36,  44,  108,  113  f  ; 
Braccio  Nuovo,  116  ;  Chapel  of 
Nicholas  V,  234 ;  coloured 
windows,  266  ;  Museo  Pio- 
Clementino,  108;  Museum  of 
Sculpture,  115  ;  Sala  di  Costan- 
tino,  233  ;  Sala  a  Croce  Greca, 
27,  116;  Sala  Regia,  33,  267; 
Sala  Rotonda,  32,  108  \  Sistine 
Chapel,  S3,  2i6 : 

Via  ;  de'  Banchi  Vecchi,  2gg  ; 
del  Governo  Vecchio,  103 ; 
Latina,  301 ;  Maschera  d'  Oro, 
2g8,  2gg  ;  Parione,  103  ;  Pelle- 
grino,  2g8 :  Villa ;  Farnesina, 
171, 301 ;  Madama,  8g  ;  Medici, 
40,  103,  J07,  log;  Papa  Giulio, 
108 :  Wall  of  Servius  Tullius,  33. 
Royal  Institute  of  British  Architects, 
Transactions  of,  3g,  33,  38,  loi, 
102,  263. 


326 


INDEX 


Ruby  red,  in  glass,  270. 
Ruccellai,  the  family,  _jo. 
Runkelstein,  Schloss,  22^. 
Rustication,  rustic  work,  52,5(5,  (55, 

67,  87,  T32. 
Rye-dough,  mixed  with  plaster  to 

retard  its  setting,  150. 

Salamander,  carved,  at  S.  Luigi, 
Rome,  130  i. 

'Sahgni'  marbles,  45,  50. 

Salting  collection,  i8g. 

Salviati,  Francesco,  311. 

San  Gallo ;  Antonio  da,  53,  76 ; 
Giuliano  da,  76. 

Sansovino,  Jacopo,  56. 

Sarcophagi,  Sarcophagus  ;  of  Ha- 
drian, 28 ;  the  Marsuppini,  16  ;  of 
the  Medici, 77^;  of  Nectanebes  I, 
38 ;  at  Palermo,  /// ;  Roman, 
igT,  of  L.  C.  Scipio  Barbatus,jj'; 
of  Piero  Soderini,  42,  118 ;  in 
Sala  a  Cioce  Greca,  Vatican,  27, 
log. 

Sassi,  the  family,  102  i. 

Sasso,  Egidio  e  Fabio,  28, 93,  102  i. 

Scaling,  of  glass,  270. 

Schedula  Diversarum  Artium,  see 
'  Theophilus.' 

Schools  of  Art,  22,  igg. 

Science  and  Art  Department,  22. 

Scopas,  his  sculpture  at  Tegea,  184. 

Sculpture :  its  nature  and  condi- 
tions, 143  f.,  iyg-188:  compared 
with  painting,  lyg  :  processes  of, 
148-153,790-/95:  use  of  drawing 
in,  207  :  imitated  in  painting, 
240  f.  :  relief  sculpture,  see 
'Reliefs'; 

in  bronze;  beaten, 779, 198;  cast, 
4,  7, 18, 158 f.,  iggi.;  chased,  276, 
313 ;  stamped,  167  f. :  in  free  stone, 
52,  59,  61,  131,  2gg:  in  marble; 
43  f. ;  technique  of,  48,  1 5 1  f. :  in 
porphyry  and  hard  materials,  33, 
42,  iioi.,  117 {.,   174;    in  wood, 

173  f- 
Seccatives,  230. 
Semper,  Gottfried,  244, 303. 
Seravezza,  46,  50,  7^0  f. 
Serpentine,  35,  77j,  118, 127. 
SgrafRato,  243. 
Sgraffito,  ig,  243  f.,  2g8l. 


'  Sicilian '  marble,  4g, 

Siena ;  Duomo,  pavement  in,  g4, 
258  ;  Baptistry,  Donatello's  relief 
in,  ig6. 

Silio,  a  white  wood,  263. 

Silver ;  as  ground  for  enamels, 
276  f.  ;  for  glass  staining,  ^70, 
J77  ;  for  niello  work,  273  ;  work, 
antique,  273. 

Sixtus  IV,  53. 

Size  ;  meaning  of  the  word,  248 ; 
in  grounds  for  gilding,  248,  249  ; 
as  priming,  224,  230,  237,  238  ; 
as  a  tempera,  222,  223,  12.^,  241, 
242,  28g,  2g4. 

Sketches,  212. 

Slate,  54,  238. 

'  Slave,'  the,  of  the  Louvre,  795. 

'  Smerigli '  (emery  veins),  47. 

Soderini,  Piero,  his  tomb,  42,  77^. 

Springer,  Anton,  112. 

Stalactites,  87  f. 

Stamps,  wooden,  for  bricks,  273. 

Stazzema,  123,  261. 

Steel,  damascened,  279. 

Stemmi,  61,  2gg. 

'  Stiacciato'  rehef,  156, 182. 

Stockholm  ;  Museum  at,  30  ;  Par- 
liament buildings  at,  72. 

Stone  ;  its  hardening  by  exposure, 
26,  41  ;  as  painting  ground,  55, 
238  ;  and  passim. 

Stucco; 777;  antique, 5<?7;  as  fresco 
ground,  288 ;  over  travertine,  53  ; 
enriched  vaults  in,  85 ;  (recipes) 
86;  modelled  and  stamped  enrich- 
ments and  grotesques  (recipes), 
170  f.,  244  f,  2ggff.;  for  fixing 
panels  of  slate,  239 ;  for  preparing 
a  wall  for  oil  paint  (recipes),  232, 
234;  for  piece-moulding,  158; 
for  rustic  grottoes,  etc.,  89  f. ;  for 
setting  marble  mosaic  pavements 
(recipe),  92 ;  for  setting  glass 
mosaics,  255  ;  for  sgraffito  work 
(recipe),  243. 

Stylus,  use  of  the  ;  in  niello  work, 
273  ;  for  sharpening  lines  in 
tempera,  2g3  ;  in  sgraffito  work, 
243  ;  for  transferring,  215,  231, 
28g. 

'Subbia'  (tool  for  stone-working), 
48,  152. 


INDEX 


327 


Sulphur  ;  in  amalgam  for  niellos, 
274  ;  for  casting  niellos,  275. 

Symonds,  J.  A.,  his  translation  of 
Michelangelo,  180. 

Tadda,  Francesco  del,  32  f ,  66, 
I/off. 

Targioni  Tozzetti,  Viaggi  in 
Toscana,  126. 

Tarsia  work,  ig6,  262  f.,  _joj  f 

Tausia  work,  279. 

'  Tedesco,'    its     meaning     to     the  • 
Italians,  134. 

Tempera  ;  meanings  of  the  term, 
22J ;  advantages  of  tempera  pro- 
cess, 224,  2gi  {. ;  its  disadvan- 
tages, 2gj  f. ;  see  also  '  Painting, 
tempera.' 

Terminal  figures,  82. 

Terni,  SS. 

'  Terre  da  Campane,'  2jo. 

Teverone,  the,  51,  79,  87. 

Text,  Vasari's  printed,  possible 
mistakes  in,  viii,  79,  SS,  228,  276, 
2S3. 

Theophilus,  his  Schedula,  6,  S,  20, 
92,  173,  26S,  270,  271,  276,  2S0, 
284,  29J. 

Theophrastus,  Ilepi  KWav,  34^  117. 

Theseum,  sculpture  of,  184. 

'Three  block'  wood  engraving, 
281  f. 

'  Tiber,'  statue  of  the,  36,  44, 116. 

'  Tigris,'  statue  of  the,  36, 116. 

Tiles,  glazed,  90,  260. 

'  Times,  The,'  referred  to,  2g. 

Tin  ;  effect  of  on  enamels,  277,311 ; 
as  ingredient  in  bronze,  164. 

Tintoretto,  214,  234. 

Tivoli,  51,66,  79.  87,J<y. 

Toledo,  don  Pietro  di,  47. 

Tools  ;  for  working  bronze,  165  ; 
for  glass  cutting,  269  ;  for 
granite,  etc.,  41  ;  for  marble,  48, 
152  ;  for  porphyry,  32  ;  for  wax, 
149. 

'  Tppo,'  a  tool,  269. 

Torcello,  mosaics  at,  2jj. 

'  Torso,'  the,  116. 

Touchstone,  see  '  Paragon ' ;  of 
Prato,  43. 

Trajan,  sculpture  connected  with 
him,  ig7. 


Transactions,  R.I.B.A.,  see  'Royal 
Institute  of  British  Architects.' 

Transparency  in  glass,  267, 308. 

Travertine;  51;  carving  in,  52 f, 
131,  2gg, 

Triangle,  equilateral,  in  Gothic 
architecture,  13J. 

Tribolo,  42,  88,  260. 

Tripoli  earth,  for  polishing,  1 53, 278. 

Tuscan  style,  j6,  87. 

Tzetzes,  181, 186. 

Udine,  Giovanni  da,  89. 
Urns,  bathing   or  sepulchral,   see 
'  Conche.' 

Valle,  della ;  family,  collection, 
palace,  etc.,  28, 104  f.  ;  Cardinal 
Andrea,  106  i. 

Varchi,  Benedetto,  I7g,  ig7. 

Varnish,  232,  239,  249,  293,  2g4i., 

jog- 

'Vasajo,'  origin  of  Vasari  family 
name,  136. 

Vasari,  the  family,  136. 

Vasari,  Giorgio,  the  elder  ('Vasajo'), 
136  i. 

Vasari,  Giorgio  :  his  character  and 
gifts,  4,  13  f.  :  his  life  and  art,  3, 
7i  33.  59. 106,  2gi :  his  visits,  36, 
103,  237 :  his  method  of  mural 
painting  in  oil,  233  f  ;  his  writings ; 
Letters,  3,  6,  iii ;  Lives  of  the 
Artists,  I,  2,  3,  7,  and  passim  ; 
Ragionamenti,  3  ;  Editions  of,  i, 
2,7;  Translations  of,  2i.;  Text, 
printed,  possible  mistakes  in,  see 
'Text.' 

Vaults  ;  brick,  86  ;  stucco,  85,  170  ; 
in  St.  Peter's,  54. 

Vellino,  river,  88. 

Venetians,  the,  14,  212. 

Venice  :  colour  printing,  281 :  en- 
amels of,  278 :  frescoes  at,  234 : 
glass  work  at,  268  :  mosaics  at, 
232,  234,  268 : 

Ducal  Palace,  236,  237  : 
Church  of  S.  Marco,  iii,  112  ; 
mosaics  at,  232 :    Library  of  S. 
Marco,  36,  237 :     Palace  of  S. 
Marco,  see  '  Ducal  Palace' : 
Panattiera,  56  : 
Piazza  di  S.  Marco,  56  : 


328 


INDEX 


Piazzetta,  ^6 : 
Scuola  di  S.  Rocco,  234. : 
Zecca  (Mint),  56,  (5y. 
Veniziano,  Domenico,  229. 
'  Venus' ;  crouching,  in  Louvre, ig4  ; 
Medici,  103 ;  of  Milo,  /pj  ;  and 
Cupid,  IJ2. 
'  Verdaccio,'  242. 
'Verde';  ' Antico,' j^ ;  'di  Prato,' 

35,  iiS,  127- 
Verdun,  266. 

Verhaecht,  227.  * 

Verona  ;  marble,  39  ;   S.  Maria  in 

Organo,  306. 
Verrocchio,  igg  ;  his  '  Boy  with  a 

Dolphin,'  33  ;  his  sarcophagus  in 

S.    Lorenzo,   112 ;    his   CoUeoni 

statue,  200. 
Versiglia,  the,  I2§. 
'  Via  dei  Magistral!,'  see  'Florence,' 

'  Uffizi.' 
Victoria  and  Albert  Museum,  136, 

/S6,  i8g,  311, 313. 
Vignola,  81. 
Villa ;  Careggi,  33,  228 ;  Farnesina, 

301,  171 ;  of  Hadrian,  303  ;  Ma- 

dama,  8g  ;   Medici,  40,  los,  107, 

log  ;   Papa  Giulio,  108 ;  Poggio 

Imperiale,  114. 
Villani,  Chronicle,  34,^5. 
Vitreous     pastes,     coloured,     277, 

311  f. 
Vitruvius,  25,  5/,  65,  66,  68,  75,  79, 

80,  13s,  146,  171-,  220,  22s,  287, 

2gi. 
Volterra,  Daniele  da,  S3- 


'  Volterrano '  (Volterra  gypsum 
plaster),  24g. 

Walnut  oil,  see  '  Oil,  nut.' 

Walnut  wood  ;  for  carving,  174  ;  as 
ground  for  inlays,  262. 

Wax ;  its  use  by  the  modeller,  148, 
i88i.  ;  by  the  bronze  founder, 
i6of.  ;  coloured,  its  preparation 
and  use,  148  f.,  i88i. ;  as  setting 
for  portable  mosaics,  136. 

Westminster  Abbey,  waxen  effigies 
at,  188. 

Wheel,  the,  for  working  hard  stones, 
112,  167,  168. 

White  ;  of  egg,  234,  249  ;  for  fresco 
(bianco  Sangiovanni),  221 ;  lead 
white  (biacca),  221,  230,  236  ;  for 
tempera,  224. 

Whitening,  241,  242,  2g4. 

Wilkinson,  Sir  Gardner,  102. 

Wilson,  Charles  Heath,  Life  of 
Michelangelo,  310. 

Winckelmann,  104. 

Wire-drawing  plate,  280. 

Wolf,  porphyry,  28,  107. 

Wood;  carving,  173 f.;  engraving, 
281  f.  ;  inlaying,  see  'Tarsia.' 

Yellow  stain  for  glass,  270, 311. 

'  Zeus,'  of  Pheidias,  i8z. 
Zinc,  ingredient  in  bronze,  164. 
Zirkel,  Petrographie,  4g. 
Zobi,  Notizie  .  .  .  dei  Lavori  .  . 
in  Pietre  Dure,  log,  114  i. 


GLASGOW  :    PRINTED  AT  THE  UNIVERSITY  PRESS  BY  ROBERT  MACLEHOSE  AND  CO.   LTD.